3. Christianity in the 8th century was
much affected by the rise of Islam in
the Middle East. By the late 8th
century, the Muslim empire had
conquered all of Persia and parts of
the Eastern Roman (Byzantine)
territory including Egypt, Palestine,
and Syria. Suddenly parts of the
Christian world were under Muslim
rule.
7. 7
2) Successful military and political career
a) Led the Franks in victory against Muslims in
732 at the Battle of Tours (in northwest
France). Although it would take more than
700 years to drive the Muslims out of Europe,
many historians see this as a decisive battle
because it permanently halted the western
progress of the Islamic Empire. The Franks
forced the Muslims back into Spain where
they remained for 700 years.
b) Early in his life he initiated friendly contacts
with the Roman popes.
8. 8
c) Directly assisted Boniface and
other Anglo-Saxon missionaries
who were busy among the
Germanic tribes of the north. Since
Boniface was working under the
direction of the pope, harles’
support was taken as support of
the pope himself.
11. 1) Crowned king of the Franks by the great missionary
Boniface (He did this in the name of the pope).
2) This was the first time a pope had claimed that his
apostolic authority involved the right to sanction the
dethroning of one king and his replacement by
another.
3) It meant that the new royal family in France owed
its legal authority to the papacy (Pope Zachary [741-
52]).
4) Frankish monarchy was now the central diplomatic
and spiritual center of the world, sealing the bond
between the Franks and the papacy.
12. 1) 2. Charlemagne, a.k.a. Charles
the Great (742-814) became
emperor in 768.
13. a. From the beginning of his rule, he
acted in concert to expand his own
power and to strengthen his
connections with the pope.
1) Saved the pope from Lombard
invaders.
2) Delivered the pope again in 799 from
the anger of Rome, which had accused
the pope of many faults.
14. b. Imposed his rule on the whole of the
civilized West: “no sovereign since
Constantine had assembled so many
territories beneath his scepter; like
Constantine he appeared to mankind as the
witness, as the herald, of Christ.”
c. Military campaigns
1) Forced Islam back beyond the Alps.
2) Only suffered one loss in his long and
illustrious career (he spent most of his 43-
year reign fighting wars).
15. d. Devoutly and fiercely Christian
1) Called the “Moses of the
Middle Ages” because he led the
Germans out of their barbarism
and gave them a new code of
civil and ecclesiastical laws.
16. 2) Typically required conquered peoples to
become Christians or be killed. But in
response to his chief theological adviser’s
repeated protestations (Alcuin of York),
Charlemagne eventually repealed the
death penalty for paganism in 797: “Faith is
a free act of the
will, not a forced act. We must appeal to
the conscience, not compel it by violence.
You can force people to be baptized, but
you cannot force them to believe.”
17. 3) Extremely motivated by the Christian
religion in his reign and brought about a
variety of reforms and initiatives in the
church.
a) Appointed bishops to significant roles in
government.
b) Made Sunday a mandatory rest day.
c) Made tithe to parish church mandatory
and punishable by excommunication.
d) Regularized the worship and liturgy of the
West.
18. 4) Believed his authority came to him from God: “It is
my duty, with the help of the divine Mercy, to defend
the Holy Church of God with my arms, everywhere.”
“The king’s task is the effective strengthening,
consolidating, propagating and preserving of the
faith; the pope’s task is to support the king in this
duty, by praying for him like Moses with outstretched
arms.”
a) Political authority ought to go hand in hand with
ecclesiastical power.
b) Clergy as a means by which he could train and
reform society for the service of God.
c) More on this below under “Sacred Kingship”
19. 3. The “Carolingian Renaissance”:
Charlemagne sought to use his power
to regulate the lives of the priests and
to set up schools throughout the land,
leading to what is commonly called the
“Carolingian Renaissance,” a period
during which learning flourished, and
during which the foundation was laid
for the great humanistic scholarship of
the Middle Ages.
20. a. Gathered together in his court the
most distinguished scholars in Western
Europe. The greatest of which was
Alcuin of York, who entered
Charlemagne’s service in 782. He was “a
Bible commentator, textual scholar,
liturgical reviser, defender of orthodoxy
against the Adoptionists, reformer of
monasteries, builder of libraries, and
learned astronomer.”75 He was
responsible for the following advances:
21. 1) Language: Created “Carolingian miniscule,” which marked a reform in
handwriting on which our modern printed letters are based; revised Latin
and taught it to all educated people and it became the international
language of Western civilization.
2) Literature: Most of our surviving texts from ancient Greece and
Rome have come down to us from Carolingian copies. Alcuin used
an army of monk-scholars to accomplish this great work. He also
oversaw the establishment of monastic libraries throughout the
empire where the books were copied and stored.
3) Bible: Alcuin revised the text of the Latin Bible and established a
standard edition of the Vulgate.
4) Education: Ordered bishops and abbots to establish schools for
training monks and priests, decreed that every parish should have
school to educate all the male children of the neighborhood, and
founded a royal academy for the study of logic, philosophy, and
literature.
22. 4. “Sacred Kingship”: This refers to the
notion that the king is the vicar of God
while the bishop is only the Vicar of
Christ (the mediator); therefore, the
monarchy has authority over the church.
The king, in this sense, is et rex et
sacerdos (“both king and priest”).76
Charlemagne held to this ideal,
seeing himself in the place of God in the
world.
23. a. In 790, without consulting Pope Adrian I, he
issued the Western Church’s response to the
iconoclastic controversy (see below). His
response came in what are called the “Caroline
books.” The Caroline books took a middle ground
between the opposing parties in the conflict in
the East by rejecting bowing down or kneeling
before icons, kissing them, or burning incense or
candles in front of them, by rejecting the stories
of miracles worked by the icons, by accepting
that religious honor should be paid to the sign of
the cross and the relics ofthe saints.
24. b. Despite the veto of Pope Leo III, Charlemagne
supported the inclusion of the filioque clause into the
Niceno-Constantinopolitan Creed (381). From the sixth
century onwards, Western Christians hadadded “and
from the Son” to the line which says that the Holy Spirit
proceeds from the Father. The Council of Toledo (Spain,
589) added the filioque clause to the creed. The East
protested that the West had no right to alter an
ecumenical creed, as ecumenism by definition involves
the entire church. Pope Leo III agreed with the notion
that the Spirit proceeds from both Father and Son, but
objected to the phrase being added to the creed.
25. 5. The coronation of a new Roman
king: Christmas Day, 800 a. “By the
time he came to Rome in 800,
Charlemagne’s success against the
Saxons to his north and east, the
Spanish in the west, and the
Lombards to his south had made him
lord over more of Europe than
anyone since Theodosius at the end
of the fourth century.”
26. b. The pope crowned Charlemagne as emperor of
the Holy Roman Empire of the West. Obviously,
this was a massively significant and symbolic event
– conjoining church and state, the emperor and
the Western Pope working together. This is what
gives us the concept of Christendom – the idea of a
world that is a church – of political and religious
power governing the lives and the worship of
people. This act solidified a connection that had
been developed for more than fiftyyears between
the Frankish government and the Roman papacy.
27. [B]y 800 an elaborate mixing of elements had created a situation
in which the Roman bishop was regarded unquestionably as the
prime ecclesiastical figure in the West and as the personal
representative of Western Christianity to the East….What made
the coronation of 800 so important was not that it represented
the height of papal power. Rather, it represented a strategic
alliance between the papacy’s gradually expanding influence and
a political power that, like the pope, was also expanding in
influence.For the next 800 years and more, the politics, learning,
social organization, art, music, economics, and law of Europe
would be ‘Christian’ – not necessarily in the sense of fully
incorporating norms of the gospel, but because the fate of the
Western church centered in Rome had been so decisively linked
with the new ‘Roman’ emperor over the Alps
28. B. The Strengthening of the Papacy
1. Papacy advanced its claim of temporal
sovereignty.
2. Important developments in France: It
was in Rome’s interests to secure such an
alliance, as the threats against Rome at
this time were coming from different
places. Kings of France interested in
having the moral support of Rome in
their various endeavors.
30. 4. Pepin the Short’s papal coronation
a. In exchange, Pepin extracted Rome from its last lingering tie to
Constantinople and in 756 gave the pope a “donation” that gave the
pope control of Italian territories won by Pepin from the Lombards
and also committed his successors to act as protectors of the papacy.
b. Pepin’s gift to pope Stephen furthered the rift between Eastern and
Western churches by giving Ravenna (northern Italy) to him, which
until that point had been under Byzantine control, but even though
Constantine V protested, Pepin argued that he was under no obligation
to Byzantium since he was serving the glory of God, the apostle Peter,
and the pope.
c. Gave the papacy a huge independent state (the “papal states” across
west-central and northeastern Italy). From now on popes would be
heads of state as much as they would be leaders in the church.
31. 5. The Donation of Constantine: This was a
document that surfaced in the eighth century
which claimed to be a letter from Constantine the
Great to pope Sylvester I in which Constantine
said that the pope was superior to the emperor
and granted the papacy the right to govern the
city of Rome and all imperial territory in Italy and
the West. The document was a forgery (exposed
as such in 1440 by the Italian scholar Lorenzo
Valla), but for 700 years the popes used it to back
up their claims.