2. Interest in ultimate values, since 1800:
truth, justice, beauty, virtue, wisdom,
happiness
‘Happiness’ and other values in books 1800-2000 (Google Ngram)
1800
Source: Google Ngram Viewer (relative frequency of occurrence in books in English)
3.
4.
5.
6. Global goals – remedial, instrumental, and
aspirational
Prevent,
remove, or
mitigate
harms
Produce
useful
goods and
services
Facilitate
wonderful
lives
Frombadtogood
From usefulness
to happiness
The OK line
8. The OK line
Maslow’s hierarchy, positivity, and progress
Self-
transcendence
Self-
actualization
Mental wellbeing
Social wellbeing
Resources and
conditions
preventing,
remedying,
coping
Personal and
societal
aspirations
9. …but there is understandable resistance to appreciative
learning and aspirational planning
The OK line
‘negative utilitarianism’
Fix if
broken
Otherwise provide
OK conditions
10. Millennium Development Goals 1990-2015
Badtogood
Means… …ends
The OK line
Halve
poverty
and
hunger
Reduce
child
mortality
Halt
spread of
HIV/AIDS
& malaria
Universal
primary
schooling
End gender
disparity in
schooling
Reduce
maternal
mortality
Environmental
sustainability
Global
partnership
11. Positive social qualities (4,5,7, 8,10,16,17): lifelong
learning, peace, social inclusion, justice, co-
operation, and decent work and sustainable
production and consumption
Resources (6,7,9,11): clean and safe infrastructure
and resource flows
Minimising human suffering (1,2,3,5,8,11): end
poverty, hunger, avoidable illness
Minimising planetary harms (12,13,14,15): stable
climate, oceans, terrestrial ecosystems,
biodiversity
UN Sustainable Development Goals
12. UN SDG ‘Health and wellbeing’ indicators 2016-2030
The OK line
NCD
premature
mortality
Maternal
mortality
Well-being???
Health
services
Traffic
accidents
tobacco
vaccines
AIDS,
TB etc
Substance
abuse
Hazardous
chemicals
Infant
mortality
13. UN SDG ‘Peace, justice & strong institutions’ indicators
2016-2030
The OK line
Organised
crime and
illegal
arms flows
violence
Social
well-being???
Rule of
law
Participatory
decision
making
Transparent
institutions
corruption
Non-
discriminatory
laws
Global
governance
Trafficking
& torture of
children
14. How could we evaluate the
comparative importance of “greatest
happiness” versus “greatest
number?”
The OK line
10 billion fairly
happy people?
5 billion
very happy
people?
www.gapminder.org ourworldindata.orghumanprogress.org
Editor's Notes
Key sources:
United Nations (2018) The Sustainable Development Goals Report 2018. New York: United Nations
Lomborg, Bjørn [ed] (2018) Prioritizing Development: a Cost Benefit Analysis of the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press
Maslow’s hierarchy depicts two very different kinds of contrast
From a bad life to a good life
From basic provisioning and material conditions to more sophisticated aspirations and ultimate values
Note that social goods sit around the middle, whereas the two top layers are mainly about individual mental wellbeing
Notice also that as you shift your attention ‘up’ the hierarchy you are also moving your gaze from ‘external’ conditions to ‘internal’ experiences
Note, further, the absence of ‘self-transcendence’ from this model. This misses the fact that some of our most important senses of meaning or purpose in life are about escaping the confines of individualistic or even communalistic or even humanistic self-interest, and realising connection with self-transcendent goods.
Refs: Koltko-Rivera, Mark E. (2006) ‘Rediscovering the later version of Maslow's hierarchy of needs: Self-transcendence and opportunities for theory, research, and unification.’ Review of General Psychology 10,4:302-317
Normal social science and normal social planning are dominated by ‘negative utilitarianism’
n.b several goals appear under more than one goal because their targets are diverse – e.g.promoting provision of resources and minimising pathologies.
Two main meanings of ‘positive’:
preferable, better – as in ‘positive emotions’
More emphatic, more important, more sustainable, more substantial, more active, or more ultimately valuable – as in ‘positive justice’ or ‘positive peace’
Two main meanings of ‘positive’:
preferable, better – as in ‘positive emotions’
More emphatic, more important, more sustainable, more substantial, more active, or more ultimately valuable – as in ‘positive justice’ or ‘positive peace’
Normal social science and normal social planning are dominated by ‘negative utilitarianism’