SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 28
Download to read offline
*X8377611*
©
National
Qualications
H
Total marks — 44
SECTION 1 — BRITISH — 22 marks
Attempt ONE question from the part you have chosen.
SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD — 22 marks
Attempt ONE question from the part you have chosen.
Write your answers clearly in the answer booklet provided. In the answer booklet you must
clearly identify the question number you are attempting.
Use blue or black ink.
Before leaving the examination room you must give your answer booklet to the Invigilator; if you
do not, you may lose all the marks for this paper.
X837/76/11 History
British, European and World History
Duration — 1 hour 30 minutes
page 02
[BLANK PAGE]
DO NOT WRITE ON THIS PAGE
page 03
SECTION 1 — BRITISH
Attempt ONE question from the part you have chosen.
PARTS
A. Church, state and feudal society, 1066–1406 page 04
B. The century of revolutions, 1603–1702 page 04
C. The Atlantic slave trade page 05
D. Britain, 1851–1951 page 05
E. Britain and Ireland, 1900–1985 page 06
SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD
Attempt ONE question from the part you have chosen.
PARTS
A. The crusades, 1071–1204 page 07
B. The American Revolution, 1763–1787 page 07
C. The French Revolution, to 1799 page 08
D. Germany, 1815–1939 page 08
E. Italy, 1815–1939 page 09
F. Russia, 1881–1921 page 09
G. USA, 1918–1968 page 10
H. Appeasement and the road to war, to 1939 page 10
I. The Cold War, 1945–1989 page 11
[Turn over
page 04
MARKS
SECTION 1 — BRITISH — 22 marks
Attempt ONE question from the part you have chosen
PART A — Church, state and feudal society, 1066−1406
1. The main role of the church in medieval society was economic.
How valid is this view?
2. How important was law and order as a reason for the increase of central royal power
in the reign of Henry II in England?
3. To what extent was King John successful in his attempts to increase royal authority in
England?
4. How important were changing social attitudes as a reason for the decline of feudal
society?
PART B — The century of revolutions, 1603−1702
5. Charles I’s policies in Scotland were successful.
How valid is this view?
6. How important was the role of Parliament as a reason for the failure to find an
alternative form of government, 1649−58?
7. How important were religious issues as a reason for the Revolution Settlement of
1688−1689?
8. To what extent did the Revolution Settlement bring about significant change,
1688−1702?
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
page 05
MARKS
SECTION 1 — BRITISH (continued)
PART C — The Atlantic slave trade
9. How important was the slave trade to the British economy?
10. To what extent did the slave trade have negative implications for African societies?
11. To what extent were the attitudes of British governments the main obstacle to the
abolition of the slave trade?
12. The effects of slave resistance were the main reason for the success of the abolitionist
campaign in 1807.
How valid is this view?
PART D — Britain, 1851−1951
13. Britain was still far from being a democratic country by 1914.
How valid is this view?
14. How important were the social surveys of Booth and Rowntree as a reason why the
Liberals introduced social welfare reforms, 1906-1914?
15. To what extent were the Liberal social welfare reforms effective in meeting the
needs of the British people?
16. The Labour reforms, 1945−1951, dealt effectively with the social problems of Britain.
How valid is this view?
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
page 06
MARKS
SECTION 1 — BRITISH (continued)
PART E — Britain and Ireland, 1900−1985
17. World War I changed the political situation in Ireland.
How valid is this view?
18. To what extent was the role of Collins the main reason for the outbreak of the Irish
Civil War?
19. To what extent were economic issues the main reason for the developing crisis in
Northern Ireland by 1968?
20. How important were British government policies as an obstacle to peace in Ireland,
1968−1985?
[Now go to SECTION 2 starting on page 07]
22
22
22
22
page 07
MARKS
SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD — 22 marks
Attempt ONE question from the part you have chosen
PART A — The crusades, 1071−1204
21. To what extent were overpopulation and famine the main motive for Christians of
different classes taking the cross?
22. To what extent was the Christian defeat at Hattin the main reason for the fall of
Jerusalem in 1187?
23. How important was Saladin’s use of diplomacy as a reason for the resolution of the
Third Crusade?
24. The crusading ideal had declined by the time of the Fourth Crusade.
How valid is this view?
PART B — The American Revolution, 1763−1787
25. How important was the rejection of the Olive Branch Petition as a reason for the
colonists’ moves towards independence?
26. To what extent was the American War of Independence a conflict which was global in
nature?
27. To what extent was the role of George Washington the most important reason for the
colonists’ victory?
28. The American Revolution had an important political impact.
How valid is this view?
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
page 08
MARKS
SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD (continued)
PART C — The French Revolution, to 1799
29. How important were the effects of the American Revolution as a reason for the
French Revolution in 1789?
30. How important was the role of Robespierre as a reason for the Terror, 1792−95?
31. Political instability was the main reason for the establishment of the Consulate.
How valid is this view?
32. To what extent did the nobility gain the most from the French Revolution?
PART D — Germany, 1815−1939
33. To what extent was there a growth of nationalism in Germany, up to 1850?
34. How important was Prussian military strength as a reason why unification was
achieved in Germany, by 1871?
35. How important were economic difficulties as a reason why the Nazis achieved power
in 1933?
36. Fear and state terrorism was the main reason why the Nazis were able to stay in
power, 1933−1939.
How valid is this view?
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
page 09
MARKS
SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD (continued)
PART E — Italy, 1815−1939
37. To what extent was there a growth of nationalism in Italy, up to 1850?
38. To what extent was the rise of Piedmont the main reason why unification was
achieved in Italy, by 1870?
39.		 How important were the weaknesses of Italian governments as a reason why the
Fascists achieved power in Italy, 1919−1925?
40. Fear and intimidation was the main reason why the Fascists were able to stay in
power, 1922−1939.
How valid is this view?
PART F — Russia, 1881−1921
41. How important was military defeat in the war against Japan as a cause of the 1905
Revolution?
42. How important was discontent among the working class as a reason for the February
Revolution, 1917?
43. The decision to continue the war was the main reason for the success of the October
Revolution, 1917.
How valid is this view?
44. To what extent were the effects of foreign intervention the main reason for the
victory of the Reds in the Civil War?
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
page 10
MARKS
SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD (continued)
PART G — USA, 1918−1968
45. To what extent were legal impediments the most important obstacle to the
achievement of civil rights for black people, up to 1941?
46.		 The New Deal was effective in solving America’s problems in the 1930s.
		 How valid is this view?
47. How important was the experience of black servicemen in the Second World War as a
reason for the development of the Civil Rights campaign, after 1945?
48. The Civil Rights movement was effective in meeting the needs of black Americans, up
to 1968.
How valid is this view?
PART H — Appeasement and the road to war, to 1939
49. How important was diplomacy as a method used by Germany and Italy to pursue
their foreign policies from 1933?
50. British foreign policy was unsuccessful in containing Fascist aggression, 1935 to March
1938.
		 How valid is this view?
51. To what extent was the Munich Agreement a successful settlement?
52. The Nazi-Soviet Pact was the main reason for the outbreak of war in 1939.
How valid is this view?
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
page 11
MARKS
SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD (continued)
PART I — The Cold War, 1945−1989
53. To what extent were Soviet policies effective in controlling Eastern Europe, up to
1961?
54. The Americans lost the war in Vietnam due to the difficulties faced by the US military.
How valid is this view?
55. The economic cost of the arms race was the main reason why the superpowers
attempted to manage the Cold War, 1962−1979.
How valid is this view?
56. How important was the role of Mikhail Gorbachev as a reason for the end of the Cold
War?
[END OF QUESTION PAPER]
22
22
22
22
22
page 12
[BLANK PAGE]
DO NOT WRITE ON THIS PAGE
*X8377612*
©
National
Qualications
H
SCOTTISH HISTORY — 36 marks
Attempt ONE part.
Write your answers clearly in the answer booklet provided. In the answer booklet you must
clearly identify the question number you are attempting.
Use blue or black ink.
Before leaving the examination room you must give your answer booklet to the Invigilator; if you
do not, you may lose all the marks for this paper.
X837/76/12 History
Scottish History
Duration — 1 hour 30 minutes
page 02
[BLANK PAGE]
DO NOT WRITE ON THIS PAGE
page 03
SCOTTISH HISTORY
Attempt ONE part
PARTS
A. The Wars of Independence, 1249–1328 page 04
B. The age of the Reformation, 1542–1603 page 06
C. The Treaty of Union, 1689–1740 page 08
D. Migration and empire, 1830–1939 page 10
E. The impact of the Great War, 1914–1928 page 12
[Turn over
page 04
SCOTTISH HISTORY — 36 marks
PART A — The Wars of Independence, 1249−1328
Study the sources below and attempt the following four questions.
Source A from a letter by King John resigning his kingdom to Edward I, at Kincardine,
2 July 1296.
John, by the grace of God king of Scotland, gives greeting to all those who shall see or
hear this letter. We have by evil and false counsel, offended and angered our lord
Edward, by the grace of God king of England. We made an alliance against lord
Edward, with the king of France, who then was, and still is, his enemy, to harass our
lord Edward, and hold the king of France, with all our power, in war and by other
means but now we have been made to renounce this alliance. We defied our lord the
king of England, and withdrew ourselves from his homage and fealty but now we must
apologise for renouncing that homage. We have fortified against Edward the land of
Scotland, by putting and maintaining armed men in the towns and castles to defend
the lands against him. For all these reasons we accept that due to our rebellion, our
lord the king of England entered the realm of Scotland by force.
Source B from Michael Brown, The Wars of Scotland, 1214−1371 (2004).
William Wallace ended talks with the English by saying ‘we are not here for the good
of peace, but are ready to fight to defend ourselves and free our kingdom’. Seeing
their enemies divided by the river, Wallace and Andrew Murray led the attack on the
English at Stirling Bridge, killing the English treasurer, Cressingham, in a savage fight,
while Warenne and the rest of his army fled. The Scottish magnates, Steward and his
neighbour, the earl of Lennox, who had been in the English force, changed sides late
in the battle and led the pursuit. If the military results of Stirling Bridge were clear, its
political consequences were less certain. The kingdom had been recovered from the
English by an army of lesser men acting without the leadership of the great Scottish
magnates. Wallace certainly had the support of some nobles, from the Steward,
Lennox and Strathearn amongst others, but it was not universal, clearly there was
some reluctance to accept his leadership.
Source C from James Mackay, William Wallace: Brave Heart (1995).
The Scots victory at Stirling Bridge was decisive and the Scottish losses were negligible
except in one important respect: Andrew Murray received a severe wound from which
he died several weeks later. But Stirling Bridge was by no stretch of the imagination a
decisive victory in the same sense as Bannockburn, fought seventeen years later a mile
or two downstream. Wallace’s defeat of Earl Warenne did not put an end to English
designs on Scotland — far from it — the humiliation of the English was something that
King Edward now addressed himself towards avenging. For the time being, however,
Wallace’s star was in the ascendant. If his role in securing the Scottish victory has been
debated, there is no doubt that the leader who had so dramatically been catapulted
into the role of Guardian was very much the man of the hour. Now Wallace’s
considerable intellect, charisma, personal magnetism, call it what you will, were
pressed into service.
page 05
MARKS
SCOTTISH HISTORY — PART A (continued)
Source D from Michael Penman, Robert the Bruce: King of the Scots (2014).
Robert Bruce started his campaign in the summer of 1307. Over the next 12 months,
Robert’s success against his Scottish opponents testified to his inspiring physical
courage. Bruce marched north through the Great Glen, a remarkable succession of
royal and pro-Comyn castles would be taken and razed by spring 1308 — Inverlochy,
Urquhart, Inverness and Nairn. In a letter sent to Edward II’s administration by his
Scots sheriff in Banff, Duncan de Freandraught reported this run of military victories
had surely caused the Bruce ranks to swell. A sustained guerrilla campaign of rapid
movement in all weathers, living off northern lands while harrying nonetheless
numerous foes, reaped its rewards as well as its costs in what was another severe
Scottish winter. A number of Scottish sources reported that King Robert’s
outnumbered forces were starving and that the king was gravely ill.
Attempt ALL of the following questions.
1. Explain the reasons why there was a succession problem 1286−1292.
2. Evaluate the usefulness of Source A as evidence of the subjugation of Scotland in
1296.
In reaching a conclusion you should refer to
• the origin and possible purpose of the source
• the content of the source
• recalled knowledge.
3. How much do Sources B and C reveal about differing interpretations of victory at
Stirling Bridge in 1297 and its effects on Scotland?
Use the sources and recalled knowledge.
4. How fully does Source D explain the rise and triumph of Robert Bruce?
Use the source and recalled knowledge.
8
8
10
10
page 06
SCOTTISH HISTORY — 36 marks
PART B — The age of the Reformation, 1542–1603
Study the sources below and attempt the following four questions.
Source A from a Royal Proclamation Against Any Changes to the State of Religion in
Scotland, 25 August 1561.
Her Majesty understands the great trouble and division at present in this her realm,
caused by differences in matters of religion. She is most keen to see peace and good
order in her realm on this matter. Her Majesty therefore orders, by open proclamation
in Edinburgh and other places, that neither Lords nor anyone else, either privately or
publicly, should, for the moment, attempt to bring in any new or sudden changes to
the religious settlement [of 1560] publicly and universally standing at Her Majesty’s
arrival in Scotland. Her Majesty further wishes it to be known that anyone who seeks
to upset the existing religious settlement shall be viewed as a rebellious subject and a
troublemaker, and shall be punished accordingly. Her Majesty, following the advice of
her Privy Council, also commands that all of her Lords refrain from troubling any
members of her domestic household brought from France, on religious or any other
matters whatsoever.
Source B from Gordon Donaldson, Scottish Kings (1967).
The peace-loving king who now sat on the throne was just as determined as his
ancestors had been to establish the rule of law and he came nearer to success than
any of them had done. James’s practical measures to consolidate his kingdom and
subject everyone in it to his own rule were supported by his belief in the Divine Right
of Kings. James believed in ‘one kingdom’ that included both the Church and the State
with Christ as its Head but with Christ’s rule carried out through the king and bishops
chosen by the king. In practical terms this meant a contest between the General
Assembly on one side and the King on the other. James’s view of his direct
responsibility to God, because he had been appointed by God, meant that as far as he
was concerned he was answerable to God alone not to any of his subjects.
Source C from Finlay Macdonald, From Reform to Renewal (2017).
Andrew Melville was not prepared to take a moderate approach to the issue of bishops
in the Kirk. His opposition rested on the grounds that a system of bishops effectively
meant that the Kirk was ruled by the King because bishops were appointed by the
Crown. Melville was not interested in whether bishops might be ‘good’ or ‘bad’. His
objection was to the idea of bishops. For him all ministers were equal and answerable
to the Church through the church courts, with the General Assembly as the highest
and supreme governing body of the Kirk, not the king. Melville was equally clear about
the distinction between the Church and the State, the Kingdom of God and the
kingdom ruled over by an earthly king. Famously, Melville informed James VI that
there were two kingdoms in Scotland. In one of which, the Kirk, Christ Jesus was King.
In that kingdom, James VI was a member not a lord and not its head either.
page 07
MARKS
SCOTTISH HISTORY — PART B (continued)
Source D from Ian B Cowan, The Scottish Reformation (1982).
The Protestants had argued that if the distance between people and church of
pre-Reformation times was to be met and overturned then it was only by drawing the
people into church attendance, and into a sympathetic and supportive attachment to
their ministers that this could be achieved. The reformers had complained about the
Church’s failure to instruct the people in the fundamentals of the faith so the new Kirk
made strenuous efforts to ensure that the fundamentals were taught to all children in
Sunday afternoon classes. Moreover, the Kirk’s emphasis was on positive teaching of
the Bible in Scots so everyone could understand. Before 1560 devotion was often
encouraged by means of plays, but the new Kirk put a stop to that. And the insides of
churches were cleared of statues of saints and images of Mary and other decoration
that was deemed to be a distraction from the teaching of the Bible.
Attempt ALL of the following questions.
5. Explain the reasons why there was a Reformation in Scotland, 1560.
6. Evaluate the usefulness of Source A as evidence of Mary’s religious policy as a reason
for her difficulties in ruling Scotland, 1561–1567.
In reaching a conclusion you should refer to
• the origin and possible purpose of the source
• the content of the source
• recalled knowledge.
7. How much do Sources B and C reveal about differing interpretations of the struggle
for control of the Kirk?
Use the sources and recalled knowledge.
8. How fully does Source D explain the impact of the Reformation on Scotland, to 1603?
Use the source and recalled knowledge.
8
8
10
10
page 08
SCOTTISH HISTORY — 36 marks
PART C — The Treaty of Union, 1689−1740
Study the sources below and attempt the following four questions.
Source A from a speech by Lord Belhaven in parliament, November 1706.
I wish to contribute my thoughts on the two kingdoms of Scotland and England being
forever united into one Kingdom by the name of Great Britain. Shall we, in just a
single half hour of debate, surrender and give up what our ancestors won and
defended with their lives for centuries? In this case, I can see Scotland — our own
ancient mother Caledonia — watching us inflict a fatal wound upon her, causing her to
take her last breath. Does this not bring to mind the murder of Julius Caesar by his
own Senate? It seems to me that this treaty will mean that we are forced to pay long-
standing English debts, through increased taxes and customs duties. All this, while the
English constitution remains firm and suffers no annihilation.
Source B from Paul Henderson Scott, The Union of 1707: Why and How (2006).
The Scottish Parliament which met on 3 October 1706 to discuss the Treaty drawn up
in London had the same membership as the one elected in 1703, except for those who
had died in the meantime. The Treaty contained last minute guarantees to several
groups. Scottish lawyers were promised that the Scottish legal system would continue,
with Scots Law to remain intact. There was also the guarantee of free trade with the
colony plantations in America and the Caribbean, which English parliaments had
always refused in the past. These changes did not have as much influence over as
many ordinary people in the country as they did over MPs. Members from the burghs,
however, were persuaded by the fact that royal burgh rights would not be affected by
union. The English government was determined to secure the Treaty.
Source C from Gordon Menzies, The Scottish Nation (1972).
The English government was convinced that a runaway Scotland would make common
cause with France. Union now became England’s first priority. The Duke of Argyll was
bribed to vote for union by the promise of military promotion and a position in the
House of Lords. He was not the only noble to benefit from such corruption. The earl of
Glasgow was given £20,000 from English funds to be divided amongst those who would
support union. It was also necessary for England to recognise the future needs of those
who were opposed to the Treaty. MPs in this group were ‘bought off’ by the guarantee
of an Equivalent fund which remarkably matched the amount of money lost in the
Darien Scheme. This was to boost Scottish development after union and ensure that
the new burden of taxation would not bear down too heavily on the country.
page 09
MARKS
SCOTTISH HISTORY — PART C (continued)
Source D from Allan MacInnes, Union and Empire (2007).
Initially many people in Scotland were not favourable towards the effects of union
across the country. In the years after 1707, Scottish MPs objected to increased duties,
particularly the attempt to impose new taxes which caused attacks on customs agents
and an upsurge in smuggling. This led to some Scots in parliament proposing a reversal
of union in 1713, although their efforts were in vain. Partnership did not necessarily
mean an equal division of wealth and resources. However, colonies in the West Indies
became a new market for Scottish merchants in the early 1700s. Therefore, union led
to a change in the Scottish balance of trade, with an increase in profits entering into
the country via ships arriving in Glasgow from the Caribbean. The creation of a United
Kingdom was significant for the whole of the British Empire.
Attempt ALL of the following questions.
9. Explain the reasons why Scottish relations with England worsened, from 1689.
10. Evaluate the usefulness of Source A as evidence of contrasting attitudes in Scotland
towards Union.
In reaching a conclusion you should refer to
• the origin and possible purpose of the source
• the content of the source
• recalled knowledge.
11. How much do Sources B and C reveal about differing interpretations of the passing of
the Union by the Scottish Parliament?
Use the sources and recalled knowledge.
12. How fully does Source D explain the effects of the Union, to 1740?
Use the source and recalled knowledge.
8
8
10
10
page 10
SCOTTISH HISTORY — 36 marks
PART D — Migration and empire, 1830–1939
Study the sources below and attempt the following four questions.
Source A from Joe Smith (Cesaikas), a memoir of a first-generation Scot born to an
immigrant family, written in 1933.
I was born in 1903 in Glengarnock to Lithuanian parents, but of course, we were all
called Poles back then. I think my worst time was at the school, before my father
changed our name when I was bullied and asked, time after time, ‘What’s your name?
Tell us your name. Go home to your own country.’ If I had a sandwich made with rye
bread and Lithuanian sausage they would say, ‘What is that you are eating? Your bread
is dirty. Did you drop it in the mud?’ We lived in the Long Row where housing
conditions were poor. I was lucky as there were lots of Lithuanian children in the Row
that I could play with without being called a Pole. It was also good for my parents as
they had a close-knit Lithuanian community who kept to their own traditions in food,
religion and music away from any discrimination.
Source B from Alexander MacArthur, a memoir written in 1886.
In 1861 I left Nairn and my job in the local law office to emigrate to Canada which was
a most daunting task. I first of all took employment with the Bank of Toronto as Scots
were very prominent in this field of business and I had family connections who had
vouched for my suitability. Soon my sense of adventure took over and in 1864, I moved
to join fellow Scots at the Hudson Bay Company in Montreal as a second officer and
accountant. By 1869, I felt the need to move again. This time I moved to the Red River
settlement where my brother Peter was living. We set up a successful and profitable
lumber business and had a much greater quality of life than had we stayed in Nairn.
Source C from Marjory Harper, Crossing borders: Scottish emigration to Canada (2006).
Hebridean Scots struggled in areas of Canada where their forefathers were not
present. The Gaelic language isolated Hebridean emigrants from their more
experienced Scots neighbours who did not speak the language resulting in them being
offered less employment in a foreign land than English-speaking Scots. Distinctiveness
was certainly interpreted negatively by earlier Scots immigrants. In a stinging verbal
attack against the Hebridean Scots of Nova Scotia, fellow Scots immigrants depicted
them as an ‘oat-eating, money-griping tribe of second-hand Scots, not even fit for
domestic servants.’ Further west, in Killarney, the observation of Sunday as a day of
worship and rest by the Hebridean emigrants irritated their less religious Scottish
neighbours who believed in ‘working, when work needed done’ leading to further
tensions and less opportunities than Scots from other parts of Scotland.
page 11
MARKS
SCOTTISH HISTORY — PART D (continued)
Source D from John Burrowes, Irish (2003).
The continued development of the canal system was one of the major projects which
required the tenacity and muscle power of the Glasgow Irish. Yet, the greatest and
most hazardous project on which the Glasgow Irish navvies worked was the Forth Rail
Bridge, one of the biggest construction projects ever carried out in Britain. There were
57 recorded navvies’ deaths, but because of poor record keeping, the eventual fate of
the 461 seriously injured was never recorded. Some projects were closer to home such
as the building of the quayside of Broomielaw on the Clyde, which improved access for
shipping right into the heart of Glasgow. The tunnelling skills were also essential in the
building of the new Glasgow subway system where there was an oozing flow of mud
above the navvies 60 feet thick, as like moles they shovelled their way under the river
Clyde.
Attempt ALL of the following questions.
13. Explain the reasons for the migration of Scots.
14. Evaluate the usefulness of Source A as evidence of the experience of Lithuanian
immigrants in Scotland.
In reaching a conclusion you should refer to
• the origin and possible purpose of the source
• the content of the source
• recalled knowledge.
15. How much do Sources B and C reveal about differing interpretations of the impact of
Scots emigrants on Canada?
Use the sources and recalled knowledge.
16. How fully does Source D explain the effects of migration and empire on Scotland, to
1939?
Use the source and recalled knowledge.
8
8
10
10
page 12
SCOTTISH HISTORY — 36 marks
PART E — The impact of The Great War, 1914–1928
Study the sources below and attempt the following four questions.
Source A from an article in The Glasgow Herald newspaper, 29 October 1915.
The first attempt to put into force the eviction warrants which have been issued
against Glasgow tenants who are participating in the ‘Rent Strike’ was made yesterday
afternoon in Merryland Street, Govan. The householder is a widow. As has been the
custom since the beginning of the movement against increased rents, a demonstration
of the ‘strikers’ was held at the time when the warrant became operative. While Mrs
Barbour, of the Glasgow Women’s Housing Association, was addressing those who had
assembled, two sheriff officers arrived and endeavoured to gain admission to the
house. As soon as it was known that it was proposed to eject the tenant the
demonstrators determined to resist. Most of them were women and they attacked the
officers and their assistants with flour and fish. A woman was arrested on a charge of
assaulting one of the officers, but later released from Govan police station with no
charge.
Source B from Ewen A Cameron, Impaled Upon a Thistle: Scotland since 1880 (2010).
The 1920s were the first decade since the availability of proper data to show a decline
in Scotland’s population. This was a national experience, felt in rural and urban areas,
in the highlands and the lowlands. A number of factors lie behind emigration in the
1920s: economic depression had a huge impact on struggling heavy industry leading to
rising levels of unemployment. This was compounded by low wages and an uncertain
farming sector, all of which made Scotland a less than attractive place to stay. These
points cannot, however, bear the entire burden of explanation because of the
different pattern in the depression of 1920–1922, when emigration was high and after
1929, when it was not. One other factor was Government assistance to help
ex‑soldiers migrate, in the form of the Empire Settlement Act of 1922, which
redirected the flow of emigrants from the United States to the dominions, especially
Canada.
Source C from an article in The Glasgow Herald newspaper, 14 April 1923.
This weekend is witnessing emigration from the Hebrides on a scale comparable only
to that experienced in the early 1880s. Thirty families, numbering some 400 souls, are
leaving Benbecula, South Uist and Barra for the distant land of Alberta, Canada. This
scheme was initiated by the Reverend Father McDonnell and is being carried out by
arrangement with the Canadian Pacific Railway Company. Their ship, the Marloch, will
sail early this afternoon from Greenock with about 700 Scottish emigrants, many of
them of the skilled tradesmen class who are in demand in Canada. Others who are
going out are to take up the opportunity offered to work on the land. Next weekend a
second party will sail from Stornoway with between 400 and 500 persons. They are
going out to Canada soon to be welcomed by the local people of Alberta.
page 13
MARKS
SCOTTISH HISTORY — PART E (continued)
Source D from I C G Hutchison, The Impact of the First World War on Scottish Politics
(1999).
Before 1914 the Liberals were the most popular political party in Scotland and the
Conservatives found it difficult to challenge them. For most of the Great War, opinion
in Scotland was strongly committed to victory which naturally boosted the Tories who
were wholeheartedly in favour of the war unlike the Liberals, or Labour. Many of the
Conservative party workers were known for encouraging recruitment — a factor which
strengthened their credibility after the war. In the 1918 election, a very large
difference between the Tories and the other two parties was that the Conservatives
put up many candidates with military titles, 46% had a military rank compared to none
for the Labour Party. In Fife East, the heroism of the Tory candidate in the war,
Colonel Sir Alexander Sprot, was one factor in unseating the ex-Liberal Prime Minister,
Henry Herbert Asquith.
Attempt ALL of the following questions.
17. Explain the reasons why the Scots played an important role on the Western Front.
18. Evaluate the usefulness of Source A as evidence of the changing role of women in
Scotland during the war.
In reaching a conclusion you should refer to
• the origin and possible purpose of the source
• the content of the source
• recalled knowledge.
19. How much do Sources B and C reveal about differing interpretations of the reasons
for post-war emigration from Scotland?
Use the sources and recalled knowledge.
20. How fully does Source D explain the impact of the Great War on Scottish politics?
Use the source and recalled knowledge.
[END OF QUESTION PAPER]
8
8
10
10
page 14
[BLANK PAGE]
DO NOT WRITE ON THIS PAGE
page 15
[BLANK PAGE]
DO NOT WRITE ON THIS PAGE
page 16
[BLANK PAGE]
DO NOT WRITE ON THIS PAGE

More Related Content

What's hot

Main section - Advanced Higher History essay
Main section - Advanced Higher History essayMain section - Advanced Higher History essay
Main section - Advanced Higher History essaymrmarr
 
2017 National 5 History exam
2017 National 5 History exam2017 National 5 History exam
2017 National 5 History exammrmarr
 
REVISION IGCSE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY: APPEASEMENT
REVISION IGCSE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY: APPEASEMENTREVISION IGCSE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY: APPEASEMENT
REVISION IGCSE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY: APPEASEMENTGeorge Dumitrache
 
Example National 5 History questions - Explain
Example National 5 History questions - ExplainExample National 5 History questions - Explain
Example National 5 History questions - Explainmrmarr
 
Higher History Past paper questions - Britain 1851-1951
Higher History Past paper questions - Britain 1851-1951Higher History Past paper questions - Britain 1851-1951
Higher History Past paper questions - Britain 1851-1951mrmarr
 
Higher history revision notes - cold war (vietnam and cuba)
Higher history revision notes - cold war (vietnam and cuba)Higher history revision notes - cold war (vietnam and cuba)
Higher history revision notes - cold war (vietnam and cuba)mrmarr
 
2019 National 5 History exam
2019 National 5 History exam2019 National 5 History exam
2019 National 5 History exammrmarr
 
Example National 5 History questions - Short essay
Example National 5 History questions - Short essayExample National 5 History questions - Short essay
Example National 5 History questions - Short essaymrmarr
 
HISTORY IGCSE REVISION - PAPER 4 - DETAILED GUIDE ABOUT HOW TO ANSWER
HISTORY IGCSE REVISION - PAPER 4 - DETAILED GUIDE ABOUT HOW TO ANSWERHISTORY IGCSE REVISION - PAPER 4 - DETAILED GUIDE ABOUT HOW TO ANSWER
HISTORY IGCSE REVISION - PAPER 4 - DETAILED GUIDE ABOUT HOW TO ANSWERGeorge Dumitrache
 
Obstacles to german unification austria strength
Obstacles to german unification   austria strengthObstacles to german unification   austria strength
Obstacles to german unification austria strengthmrmarr
 
Weimar Germany - Foreign policy (‘erfullungspolitik’)
Weimar Germany - Foreign policy (‘erfullungspolitik’)Weimar Germany - Foreign policy (‘erfullungspolitik’)
Weimar Germany - Foreign policy (‘erfullungspolitik’)mrmarr
 
How effectively did the USA contain the spread of communism
How effectively did the USA contain the spread of communismHow effectively did the USA contain the spread of communism
How effectively did the USA contain the spread of communismWan Farida Hamimi
 
Hitler and Nazi Germany - discontent towards weimar
Hitler and Nazi Germany - discontent towards weimarHitler and Nazi Germany - discontent towards weimar
Hitler and Nazi Germany - discontent towards weimarmrmarr
 
Revolutions of 1848 final version
Revolutions of 1848 final versionRevolutions of 1848 final version
Revolutions of 1848 final versionflodeste
 
Higher History exam - 2018 (marking instructions)
Higher History exam - 2018 (marking instructions)Higher History exam - 2018 (marking instructions)
Higher History exam - 2018 (marking instructions)mrmarr
 
Example National 5 History questions - How fully?
Example National 5 History questions - How fully?Example National 5 History questions - How fully?
Example National 5 History questions - How fully?mrmarr
 
2013 higher history exam
2013 higher history exam2013 higher history exam
2013 higher history exammrmarr
 
Weimar Constitution
Weimar ConstitutionWeimar Constitution
Weimar ConstitutionRCB78
 
National 5 History exam - 2019 (marking instructions)
National 5 History exam - 2019 (marking instructions)National 5 History exam - 2019 (marking instructions)
National 5 History exam - 2019 (marking instructions)mrmarr
 

What's hot (20)

Main section - Advanced Higher History essay
Main section - Advanced Higher History essayMain section - Advanced Higher History essay
Main section - Advanced Higher History essay
 
2017 National 5 History exam
2017 National 5 History exam2017 National 5 History exam
2017 National 5 History exam
 
REVISION IGCSE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY: APPEASEMENT
REVISION IGCSE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY: APPEASEMENTREVISION IGCSE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY: APPEASEMENT
REVISION IGCSE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY: APPEASEMENT
 
Example National 5 History questions - Explain
Example National 5 History questions - ExplainExample National 5 History questions - Explain
Example National 5 History questions - Explain
 
WWII in Europe: The Policy of Appeasement
WWII in Europe: The Policy of AppeasementWWII in Europe: The Policy of Appeasement
WWII in Europe: The Policy of Appeasement
 
Higher History Past paper questions - Britain 1851-1951
Higher History Past paper questions - Britain 1851-1951Higher History Past paper questions - Britain 1851-1951
Higher History Past paper questions - Britain 1851-1951
 
Higher history revision notes - cold war (vietnam and cuba)
Higher history revision notes - cold war (vietnam and cuba)Higher history revision notes - cold war (vietnam and cuba)
Higher history revision notes - cold war (vietnam and cuba)
 
2019 National 5 History exam
2019 National 5 History exam2019 National 5 History exam
2019 National 5 History exam
 
Example National 5 History questions - Short essay
Example National 5 History questions - Short essayExample National 5 History questions - Short essay
Example National 5 History questions - Short essay
 
HISTORY IGCSE REVISION - PAPER 4 - DETAILED GUIDE ABOUT HOW TO ANSWER
HISTORY IGCSE REVISION - PAPER 4 - DETAILED GUIDE ABOUT HOW TO ANSWERHISTORY IGCSE REVISION - PAPER 4 - DETAILED GUIDE ABOUT HOW TO ANSWER
HISTORY IGCSE REVISION - PAPER 4 - DETAILED GUIDE ABOUT HOW TO ANSWER
 
Obstacles to german unification austria strength
Obstacles to german unification   austria strengthObstacles to german unification   austria strength
Obstacles to german unification austria strength
 
Weimar Germany - Foreign policy (‘erfullungspolitik’)
Weimar Germany - Foreign policy (‘erfullungspolitik’)Weimar Germany - Foreign policy (‘erfullungspolitik’)
Weimar Germany - Foreign policy (‘erfullungspolitik’)
 
How effectively did the USA contain the spread of communism
How effectively did the USA contain the spread of communismHow effectively did the USA contain the spread of communism
How effectively did the USA contain the spread of communism
 
Hitler and Nazi Germany - discontent towards weimar
Hitler and Nazi Germany - discontent towards weimarHitler and Nazi Germany - discontent towards weimar
Hitler and Nazi Germany - discontent towards weimar
 
Revolutions of 1848 final version
Revolutions of 1848 final versionRevolutions of 1848 final version
Revolutions of 1848 final version
 
Higher History exam - 2018 (marking instructions)
Higher History exam - 2018 (marking instructions)Higher History exam - 2018 (marking instructions)
Higher History exam - 2018 (marking instructions)
 
Example National 5 History questions - How fully?
Example National 5 History questions - How fully?Example National 5 History questions - How fully?
Example National 5 History questions - How fully?
 
2013 higher history exam
2013 higher history exam2013 higher history exam
2013 higher history exam
 
Weimar Constitution
Weimar ConstitutionWeimar Constitution
Weimar Constitution
 
National 5 History exam - 2019 (marking instructions)
National 5 History exam - 2019 (marking instructions)National 5 History exam - 2019 (marking instructions)
National 5 History exam - 2019 (marking instructions)
 

Similar to Higher History exam - 2021

SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023
SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023
SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023mrmarr
 
Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2022
Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2022Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2022
Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2022mrmarr
 
2019 Higher History exam (papers 1 & 2)
2019 Higher History exam (papers 1 & 2)2019 Higher History exam (papers 1 & 2)
2019 Higher History exam (papers 1 & 2)mrmarr
 
2013 advanced higher history exam
2013 advanced higher history exam2013 advanced higher history exam
2013 advanced higher history exammrmarr
 
Advanced Higher History exam – 2009
Advanced Higher History exam – 2009Advanced Higher History exam – 2009
Advanced Higher History exam – 2009mrmarr
 
2015 advanced higher history exam
2015 advanced higher history exam2015 advanced higher history exam
2015 advanced higher history exammrmarr
 
2012 advanced higher history exam
2012 advanced higher history exam2012 advanced higher history exam
2012 advanced higher history exammrmarr
 
2011 advanced higher history exam
2011 advanced higher history exam2011 advanced higher history exam
2011 advanced higher history exammrmarr
 
2014 advanced higher history exam
2014 advanced higher history exam2014 advanced higher history exam
2014 advanced higher history exammrmarr
 
Advanced Higher History exam – 2010
Advanced Higher History exam – 2010Advanced Higher History exam – 2010
Advanced Higher History exam – 2010mrmarr
 
Advanced Higher History exam – 2007
Advanced Higher History exam – 2007Advanced Higher History exam – 2007
Advanced Higher History exam – 2007mrmarr
 
Higher History exam – 2010 (paper 1 + paper 2)
Higher History exam – 2010 (paper 1 + paper 2)Higher History exam – 2010 (paper 1 + paper 2)
Higher History exam – 2010 (paper 1 + paper 2)mrmarr
 
2012 higher history exam
2012 higher history exam2012 higher history exam
2012 higher history exammrmarr
 
Higher History exam – 2009 (paper 1 + paper 2)
Higher History exam – 2009 (paper 1 + paper 2)Higher History exam – 2009 (paper 1 + paper 2)
Higher History exam – 2009 (paper 1 + paper 2)mrmarr
 
Advanced Higher History exam – 2008
Advanced Higher History exam – 2008Advanced Higher History exam – 2008
Advanced Higher History exam – 2008mrmarr
 
Higher History exam – 2008 (paper 1 only)
Higher History exam – 2008 (paper 1 only)Higher History exam – 2008 (paper 1 only)
Higher History exam – 2008 (paper 1 only)mrmarr
 
2011 higher history exam
2011 higher history exam2011 higher history exam
2011 higher history exammrmarr
 
H12 Chapter 10 questions
H12 Chapter 10 questionsH12 Chapter 10 questions
H12 Chapter 10 questionsjkoryan
 
Britain 1918-51 Essay Plans
Britain 1918-51 Essay PlansBritain 1918-51 Essay Plans
Britain 1918-51 Essay PlansKatie B
 
Higher History exam – 2007 (paper 1 only)
Higher History exam – 2007 (paper 1 only)Higher History exam – 2007 (paper 1 only)
Higher History exam – 2007 (paper 1 only)mrmarr
 

Similar to Higher History exam - 2021 (20)

SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023
SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023
SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023
 
Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2022
Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2022Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2022
Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2022
 
2019 Higher History exam (papers 1 & 2)
2019 Higher History exam (papers 1 & 2)2019 Higher History exam (papers 1 & 2)
2019 Higher History exam (papers 1 & 2)
 
2013 advanced higher history exam
2013 advanced higher history exam2013 advanced higher history exam
2013 advanced higher history exam
 
Advanced Higher History exam – 2009
Advanced Higher History exam – 2009Advanced Higher History exam – 2009
Advanced Higher History exam – 2009
 
2015 advanced higher history exam
2015 advanced higher history exam2015 advanced higher history exam
2015 advanced higher history exam
 
2012 advanced higher history exam
2012 advanced higher history exam2012 advanced higher history exam
2012 advanced higher history exam
 
2011 advanced higher history exam
2011 advanced higher history exam2011 advanced higher history exam
2011 advanced higher history exam
 
2014 advanced higher history exam
2014 advanced higher history exam2014 advanced higher history exam
2014 advanced higher history exam
 
Advanced Higher History exam – 2010
Advanced Higher History exam – 2010Advanced Higher History exam – 2010
Advanced Higher History exam – 2010
 
Advanced Higher History exam – 2007
Advanced Higher History exam – 2007Advanced Higher History exam – 2007
Advanced Higher History exam – 2007
 
Higher History exam – 2010 (paper 1 + paper 2)
Higher History exam – 2010 (paper 1 + paper 2)Higher History exam – 2010 (paper 1 + paper 2)
Higher History exam – 2010 (paper 1 + paper 2)
 
2012 higher history exam
2012 higher history exam2012 higher history exam
2012 higher history exam
 
Higher History exam – 2009 (paper 1 + paper 2)
Higher History exam – 2009 (paper 1 + paper 2)Higher History exam – 2009 (paper 1 + paper 2)
Higher History exam – 2009 (paper 1 + paper 2)
 
Advanced Higher History exam – 2008
Advanced Higher History exam – 2008Advanced Higher History exam – 2008
Advanced Higher History exam – 2008
 
Higher History exam – 2008 (paper 1 only)
Higher History exam – 2008 (paper 1 only)Higher History exam – 2008 (paper 1 only)
Higher History exam – 2008 (paper 1 only)
 
2011 higher history exam
2011 higher history exam2011 higher history exam
2011 higher history exam
 
H12 Chapter 10 questions
H12 Chapter 10 questionsH12 Chapter 10 questions
H12 Chapter 10 questions
 
Britain 1918-51 Essay Plans
Britain 1918-51 Essay PlansBritain 1918-51 Essay Plans
Britain 1918-51 Essay Plans
 
Higher History exam – 2007 (paper 1 only)
Higher History exam – 2007 (paper 1 only)Higher History exam – 2007 (paper 1 only)
Higher History exam – 2007 (paper 1 only)
 

More from mrmarr

National 5 History assignment - writing the main section
National 5 History assignment - writing the main sectionNational 5 History assignment - writing the main section
National 5 History assignment - writing the main sectionmrmarr
 
National 5 History assignment - writing the conclusion
National 5 History assignment - writing the conclusionNational 5 History assignment - writing the conclusion
National 5 History assignment - writing the conclusionmrmarr
 
SQA Advanced Higher History exam paper - 2023
SQA Advanced Higher History exam paper - 2023SQA Advanced Higher History exam paper - 2023
SQA Advanced Higher History exam paper - 2023mrmarr
 
Advanced Higher History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)
Advanced Higher History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)Advanced Higher History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)
Advanced Higher History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)mrmarr
 
SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023 (marking instructions)
SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023 (marking instructions)SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023 (marking instructions)
SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023 (marking instructions)mrmarr
 
Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023 (marking instructions)
Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023 (marking instructions)Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023 (marking instructions)
Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023 (marking instructions)mrmarr
 
SQA Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023
SQA Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023SQA Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023
SQA Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023mrmarr
 
Higher Migration and Empire - reasons for emigrant scots' success
Higher Migration and Empire - reasons for emigrant scots' successHigher Migration and Empire - reasons for emigrant scots' success
Higher Migration and Empire - reasons for emigrant scots' successmrmarr
 
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Education
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - EducationLabour social reforms 1945-51 - Education
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Educationmrmarr
 
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Health
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - HealthLabour social reforms 1945-51 - Health
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Healthmrmarr
 
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Housing
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - HousingLabour social reforms 1945-51 - Housing
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Housingmrmarr
 
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Poverty
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - PovertyLabour social reforms 1945-51 - Poverty
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Povertymrmarr
 
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Unemployment
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - UnemploymentLabour social reforms 1945-51 - Unemployment
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Unemploymentmrmarr
 
National 5 History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)
 National 5 History exam - 2023 (marking instructions) National 5 History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)
National 5 History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)mrmarr
 
National 5 History exam - 2023
 National 5 History exam - 2023 National 5 History exam - 2023
National 5 History exam - 2023mrmarr
 
Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Lowlands)
Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Lowlands)Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Lowlands)
Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Lowlands)mrmarr
 
Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Emigration)
Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Emigration)Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Emigration)
Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Emigration)mrmarr
 
Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Internal migration)
Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Internal migration)Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Internal migration)
Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Internal migration)mrmarr
 
Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Highlands)
Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Highlands)Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Highlands)
Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Highlands)mrmarr
 
Women and the vote - Changing social attitudes
Women and the vote - Changing social attitudesWomen and the vote - Changing social attitudes
Women and the vote - Changing social attitudesmrmarr
 

More from mrmarr (20)

National 5 History assignment - writing the main section
National 5 History assignment - writing the main sectionNational 5 History assignment - writing the main section
National 5 History assignment - writing the main section
 
National 5 History assignment - writing the conclusion
National 5 History assignment - writing the conclusionNational 5 History assignment - writing the conclusion
National 5 History assignment - writing the conclusion
 
SQA Advanced Higher History exam paper - 2023
SQA Advanced Higher History exam paper - 2023SQA Advanced Higher History exam paper - 2023
SQA Advanced Higher History exam paper - 2023
 
Advanced Higher History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)
Advanced Higher History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)Advanced Higher History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)
Advanced Higher History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)
 
SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023 (marking instructions)
SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023 (marking instructions)SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023 (marking instructions)
SQA Higher History exam (paper 1) - 2023 (marking instructions)
 
Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023 (marking instructions)
Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023 (marking instructions)Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023 (marking instructions)
Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023 (marking instructions)
 
SQA Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023
SQA Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023SQA Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023
SQA Higher History exam (paper 2) - 2023
 
Higher Migration and Empire - reasons for emigrant scots' success
Higher Migration and Empire - reasons for emigrant scots' successHigher Migration and Empire - reasons for emigrant scots' success
Higher Migration and Empire - reasons for emigrant scots' success
 
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Education
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - EducationLabour social reforms 1945-51 - Education
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Education
 
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Health
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - HealthLabour social reforms 1945-51 - Health
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Health
 
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Housing
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - HousingLabour social reforms 1945-51 - Housing
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Housing
 
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Poverty
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - PovertyLabour social reforms 1945-51 - Poverty
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Poverty
 
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Unemployment
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - UnemploymentLabour social reforms 1945-51 - Unemployment
Labour social reforms 1945-51 - Unemployment
 
National 5 History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)
 National 5 History exam - 2023 (marking instructions) National 5 History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)
National 5 History exam - 2023 (marking instructions)
 
National 5 History exam - 2023
 National 5 History exam - 2023 National 5 History exam - 2023
National 5 History exam - 2023
 
Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Lowlands)
Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Lowlands)Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Lowlands)
Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Lowlands)
 
Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Emigration)
Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Emigration)Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Emigration)
Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Emigration)
 
Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Internal migration)
Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Internal migration)Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Internal migration)
Higher Migration and Empire - Pull factors (Internal migration)
 
Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Highlands)
Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Highlands)Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Highlands)
Higher Migration and Empire - Push factors (Highlands)
 
Women and the vote - Changing social attitudes
Women and the vote - Changing social attitudesWomen and the vote - Changing social attitudes
Women and the vote - Changing social attitudes
 

Recently uploaded

SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxiammrhaywood
 
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptxContemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptxRoyAbrique
 
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsPresiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsanshu789521
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfSanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfsanyamsingh5019
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Celine George
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactdawncurless
 
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfEnzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfSumit Tiwari
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxNirmalaLoungPoorunde1
 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Educationpboyjonauth
 
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdfssuser54595a
 
mini mental status format.docx
mini    mental       status     format.docxmini    mental       status     format.docx
mini mental status format.docxPoojaSen20
 
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communicationInteractive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communicationnomboosow
 
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...Krashi Coaching
 
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxSolving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxOH TEIK BIN
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionMaksud Ahmed
 
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionMastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionSafetyChain Software
 

Recently uploaded (20)

SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
 
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptxContemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
 
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsPresiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
 
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSDStaff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
 
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfSanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
 
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri  Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri  Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfEnzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
 
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
 
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdfTataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
 
mini mental status format.docx
mini    mental       status     format.docxmini    mental       status     format.docx
mini mental status format.docx
 
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communicationInteractive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
 
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
 
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxSolving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
 
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionMastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
 

Higher History exam - 2021

  • 1. *X8377611* © National Qualications H Total marks — 44 SECTION 1 — BRITISH — 22 marks Attempt ONE question from the part you have chosen. SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD — 22 marks Attempt ONE question from the part you have chosen. Write your answers clearly in the answer booklet provided. In the answer booklet you must clearly identify the question number you are attempting. Use blue or black ink. Before leaving the examination room you must give your answer booklet to the Invigilator; if you do not, you may lose all the marks for this paper. X837/76/11 History British, European and World History Duration — 1 hour 30 minutes
  • 2. page 02 [BLANK PAGE] DO NOT WRITE ON THIS PAGE
  • 3. page 03 SECTION 1 — BRITISH Attempt ONE question from the part you have chosen. PARTS A. Church, state and feudal society, 1066–1406 page 04 B. The century of revolutions, 1603–1702 page 04 C. The Atlantic slave trade page 05 D. Britain, 1851–1951 page 05 E. Britain and Ireland, 1900–1985 page 06 SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD Attempt ONE question from the part you have chosen. PARTS A. The crusades, 1071–1204 page 07 B. The American Revolution, 1763–1787 page 07 C. The French Revolution, to 1799 page 08 D. Germany, 1815–1939 page 08 E. Italy, 1815–1939 page 09 F. Russia, 1881–1921 page 09 G. USA, 1918–1968 page 10 H. Appeasement and the road to war, to 1939 page 10 I. The Cold War, 1945–1989 page 11 [Turn over
  • 4. page 04 MARKS SECTION 1 — BRITISH — 22 marks Attempt ONE question from the part you have chosen PART A — Church, state and feudal society, 1066−1406 1. The main role of the church in medieval society was economic. How valid is this view? 2. How important was law and order as a reason for the increase of central royal power in the reign of Henry II in England? 3. To what extent was King John successful in his attempts to increase royal authority in England? 4. How important were changing social attitudes as a reason for the decline of feudal society? PART B — The century of revolutions, 1603−1702 5. Charles I’s policies in Scotland were successful. How valid is this view? 6. How important was the role of Parliament as a reason for the failure to find an alternative form of government, 1649−58? 7. How important were religious issues as a reason for the Revolution Settlement of 1688−1689? 8. To what extent did the Revolution Settlement bring about significant change, 1688−1702? 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22
  • 5. page 05 MARKS SECTION 1 — BRITISH (continued) PART C — The Atlantic slave trade 9. How important was the slave trade to the British economy? 10. To what extent did the slave trade have negative implications for African societies? 11. To what extent were the attitudes of British governments the main obstacle to the abolition of the slave trade? 12. The effects of slave resistance were the main reason for the success of the abolitionist campaign in 1807. How valid is this view? PART D — Britain, 1851−1951 13. Britain was still far from being a democratic country by 1914. How valid is this view? 14. How important were the social surveys of Booth and Rowntree as a reason why the Liberals introduced social welfare reforms, 1906-1914? 15. To what extent were the Liberal social welfare reforms effective in meeting the needs of the British people? 16. The Labour reforms, 1945−1951, dealt effectively with the social problems of Britain. How valid is this view? 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22
  • 6. page 06 MARKS SECTION 1 — BRITISH (continued) PART E — Britain and Ireland, 1900−1985 17. World War I changed the political situation in Ireland. How valid is this view? 18. To what extent was the role of Collins the main reason for the outbreak of the Irish Civil War? 19. To what extent were economic issues the main reason for the developing crisis in Northern Ireland by 1968? 20. How important were British government policies as an obstacle to peace in Ireland, 1968−1985? [Now go to SECTION 2 starting on page 07] 22 22 22 22
  • 7. page 07 MARKS SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD — 22 marks Attempt ONE question from the part you have chosen PART A — The crusades, 1071−1204 21. To what extent were overpopulation and famine the main motive for Christians of different classes taking the cross? 22. To what extent was the Christian defeat at Hattin the main reason for the fall of Jerusalem in 1187? 23. How important was Saladin’s use of diplomacy as a reason for the resolution of the Third Crusade? 24. The crusading ideal had declined by the time of the Fourth Crusade. How valid is this view? PART B — The American Revolution, 1763−1787 25. How important was the rejection of the Olive Branch Petition as a reason for the colonists’ moves towards independence? 26. To what extent was the American War of Independence a conflict which was global in nature? 27. To what extent was the role of George Washington the most important reason for the colonists’ victory? 28. The American Revolution had an important political impact. How valid is this view? 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22
  • 8. page 08 MARKS SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD (continued) PART C — The French Revolution, to 1799 29. How important were the effects of the American Revolution as a reason for the French Revolution in 1789? 30. How important was the role of Robespierre as a reason for the Terror, 1792−95? 31. Political instability was the main reason for the establishment of the Consulate. How valid is this view? 32. To what extent did the nobility gain the most from the French Revolution? PART D — Germany, 1815−1939 33. To what extent was there a growth of nationalism in Germany, up to 1850? 34. How important was Prussian military strength as a reason why unification was achieved in Germany, by 1871? 35. How important were economic difficulties as a reason why the Nazis achieved power in 1933? 36. Fear and state terrorism was the main reason why the Nazis were able to stay in power, 1933−1939. How valid is this view? 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22
  • 9. page 09 MARKS SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD (continued) PART E — Italy, 1815−1939 37. To what extent was there a growth of nationalism in Italy, up to 1850? 38. To what extent was the rise of Piedmont the main reason why unification was achieved in Italy, by 1870? 39. How important were the weaknesses of Italian governments as a reason why the Fascists achieved power in Italy, 1919−1925? 40. Fear and intimidation was the main reason why the Fascists were able to stay in power, 1922−1939. How valid is this view? PART F — Russia, 1881−1921 41. How important was military defeat in the war against Japan as a cause of the 1905 Revolution? 42. How important was discontent among the working class as a reason for the February Revolution, 1917? 43. The decision to continue the war was the main reason for the success of the October Revolution, 1917. How valid is this view? 44. To what extent were the effects of foreign intervention the main reason for the victory of the Reds in the Civil War? 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22
  • 10. page 10 MARKS SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD (continued) PART G — USA, 1918−1968 45. To what extent were legal impediments the most important obstacle to the achievement of civil rights for black people, up to 1941? 46. The New Deal was effective in solving America’s problems in the 1930s. How valid is this view? 47. How important was the experience of black servicemen in the Second World War as a reason for the development of the Civil Rights campaign, after 1945? 48. The Civil Rights movement was effective in meeting the needs of black Americans, up to 1968. How valid is this view? PART H — Appeasement and the road to war, to 1939 49. How important was diplomacy as a method used by Germany and Italy to pursue their foreign policies from 1933? 50. British foreign policy was unsuccessful in containing Fascist aggression, 1935 to March 1938. How valid is this view? 51. To what extent was the Munich Agreement a successful settlement? 52. The Nazi-Soviet Pact was the main reason for the outbreak of war in 1939. How valid is this view? 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22
  • 11. page 11 MARKS SECTION 2 — EUROPEAN AND WORLD (continued) PART I — The Cold War, 1945−1989 53. To what extent were Soviet policies effective in controlling Eastern Europe, up to 1961? 54. The Americans lost the war in Vietnam due to the difficulties faced by the US military. How valid is this view? 55. The economic cost of the arms race was the main reason why the superpowers attempted to manage the Cold War, 1962−1979. How valid is this view? 56. How important was the role of Mikhail Gorbachev as a reason for the end of the Cold War? [END OF QUESTION PAPER] 22 22 22 22 22
  • 12. page 12 [BLANK PAGE] DO NOT WRITE ON THIS PAGE
  • 13. *X8377612* © National Qualications H SCOTTISH HISTORY — 36 marks Attempt ONE part. Write your answers clearly in the answer booklet provided. In the answer booklet you must clearly identify the question number you are attempting. Use blue or black ink. Before leaving the examination room you must give your answer booklet to the Invigilator; if you do not, you may lose all the marks for this paper. X837/76/12 History Scottish History Duration — 1 hour 30 minutes
  • 14. page 02 [BLANK PAGE] DO NOT WRITE ON THIS PAGE
  • 15. page 03 SCOTTISH HISTORY Attempt ONE part PARTS A. The Wars of Independence, 1249–1328 page 04 B. The age of the Reformation, 1542–1603 page 06 C. The Treaty of Union, 1689–1740 page 08 D. Migration and empire, 1830–1939 page 10 E. The impact of the Great War, 1914–1928 page 12 [Turn over
  • 16. page 04 SCOTTISH HISTORY — 36 marks PART A — The Wars of Independence, 1249−1328 Study the sources below and attempt the following four questions. Source A from a letter by King John resigning his kingdom to Edward I, at Kincardine, 2 July 1296. John, by the grace of God king of Scotland, gives greeting to all those who shall see or hear this letter. We have by evil and false counsel, offended and angered our lord Edward, by the grace of God king of England. We made an alliance against lord Edward, with the king of France, who then was, and still is, his enemy, to harass our lord Edward, and hold the king of France, with all our power, in war and by other means but now we have been made to renounce this alliance. We defied our lord the king of England, and withdrew ourselves from his homage and fealty but now we must apologise for renouncing that homage. We have fortified against Edward the land of Scotland, by putting and maintaining armed men in the towns and castles to defend the lands against him. For all these reasons we accept that due to our rebellion, our lord the king of England entered the realm of Scotland by force. Source B from Michael Brown, The Wars of Scotland, 1214−1371 (2004). William Wallace ended talks with the English by saying ‘we are not here for the good of peace, but are ready to fight to defend ourselves and free our kingdom’. Seeing their enemies divided by the river, Wallace and Andrew Murray led the attack on the English at Stirling Bridge, killing the English treasurer, Cressingham, in a savage fight, while Warenne and the rest of his army fled. The Scottish magnates, Steward and his neighbour, the earl of Lennox, who had been in the English force, changed sides late in the battle and led the pursuit. If the military results of Stirling Bridge were clear, its political consequences were less certain. The kingdom had been recovered from the English by an army of lesser men acting without the leadership of the great Scottish magnates. Wallace certainly had the support of some nobles, from the Steward, Lennox and Strathearn amongst others, but it was not universal, clearly there was some reluctance to accept his leadership. Source C from James Mackay, William Wallace: Brave Heart (1995). The Scots victory at Stirling Bridge was decisive and the Scottish losses were negligible except in one important respect: Andrew Murray received a severe wound from which he died several weeks later. But Stirling Bridge was by no stretch of the imagination a decisive victory in the same sense as Bannockburn, fought seventeen years later a mile or two downstream. Wallace’s defeat of Earl Warenne did not put an end to English designs on Scotland — far from it — the humiliation of the English was something that King Edward now addressed himself towards avenging. For the time being, however, Wallace’s star was in the ascendant. If his role in securing the Scottish victory has been debated, there is no doubt that the leader who had so dramatically been catapulted into the role of Guardian was very much the man of the hour. Now Wallace’s considerable intellect, charisma, personal magnetism, call it what you will, were pressed into service.
  • 17. page 05 MARKS SCOTTISH HISTORY — PART A (continued) Source D from Michael Penman, Robert the Bruce: King of the Scots (2014). Robert Bruce started his campaign in the summer of 1307. Over the next 12 months, Robert’s success against his Scottish opponents testified to his inspiring physical courage. Bruce marched north through the Great Glen, a remarkable succession of royal and pro-Comyn castles would be taken and razed by spring 1308 — Inverlochy, Urquhart, Inverness and Nairn. In a letter sent to Edward II’s administration by his Scots sheriff in Banff, Duncan de Freandraught reported this run of military victories had surely caused the Bruce ranks to swell. A sustained guerrilla campaign of rapid movement in all weathers, living off northern lands while harrying nonetheless numerous foes, reaped its rewards as well as its costs in what was another severe Scottish winter. A number of Scottish sources reported that King Robert’s outnumbered forces were starving and that the king was gravely ill. Attempt ALL of the following questions. 1. Explain the reasons why there was a succession problem 1286−1292. 2. Evaluate the usefulness of Source A as evidence of the subjugation of Scotland in 1296. In reaching a conclusion you should refer to • the origin and possible purpose of the source • the content of the source • recalled knowledge. 3. How much do Sources B and C reveal about differing interpretations of victory at Stirling Bridge in 1297 and its effects on Scotland? Use the sources and recalled knowledge. 4. How fully does Source D explain the rise and triumph of Robert Bruce? Use the source and recalled knowledge. 8 8 10 10
  • 18. page 06 SCOTTISH HISTORY — 36 marks PART B — The age of the Reformation, 1542–1603 Study the sources below and attempt the following four questions. Source A from a Royal Proclamation Against Any Changes to the State of Religion in Scotland, 25 August 1561. Her Majesty understands the great trouble and division at present in this her realm, caused by differences in matters of religion. She is most keen to see peace and good order in her realm on this matter. Her Majesty therefore orders, by open proclamation in Edinburgh and other places, that neither Lords nor anyone else, either privately or publicly, should, for the moment, attempt to bring in any new or sudden changes to the religious settlement [of 1560] publicly and universally standing at Her Majesty’s arrival in Scotland. Her Majesty further wishes it to be known that anyone who seeks to upset the existing religious settlement shall be viewed as a rebellious subject and a troublemaker, and shall be punished accordingly. Her Majesty, following the advice of her Privy Council, also commands that all of her Lords refrain from troubling any members of her domestic household brought from France, on religious or any other matters whatsoever. Source B from Gordon Donaldson, Scottish Kings (1967). The peace-loving king who now sat on the throne was just as determined as his ancestors had been to establish the rule of law and he came nearer to success than any of them had done. James’s practical measures to consolidate his kingdom and subject everyone in it to his own rule were supported by his belief in the Divine Right of Kings. James believed in ‘one kingdom’ that included both the Church and the State with Christ as its Head but with Christ’s rule carried out through the king and bishops chosen by the king. In practical terms this meant a contest between the General Assembly on one side and the King on the other. James’s view of his direct responsibility to God, because he had been appointed by God, meant that as far as he was concerned he was answerable to God alone not to any of his subjects. Source C from Finlay Macdonald, From Reform to Renewal (2017). Andrew Melville was not prepared to take a moderate approach to the issue of bishops in the Kirk. His opposition rested on the grounds that a system of bishops effectively meant that the Kirk was ruled by the King because bishops were appointed by the Crown. Melville was not interested in whether bishops might be ‘good’ or ‘bad’. His objection was to the idea of bishops. For him all ministers were equal and answerable to the Church through the church courts, with the General Assembly as the highest and supreme governing body of the Kirk, not the king. Melville was equally clear about the distinction between the Church and the State, the Kingdom of God and the kingdom ruled over by an earthly king. Famously, Melville informed James VI that there were two kingdoms in Scotland. In one of which, the Kirk, Christ Jesus was King. In that kingdom, James VI was a member not a lord and not its head either.
  • 19. page 07 MARKS SCOTTISH HISTORY — PART B (continued) Source D from Ian B Cowan, The Scottish Reformation (1982). The Protestants had argued that if the distance between people and church of pre-Reformation times was to be met and overturned then it was only by drawing the people into church attendance, and into a sympathetic and supportive attachment to their ministers that this could be achieved. The reformers had complained about the Church’s failure to instruct the people in the fundamentals of the faith so the new Kirk made strenuous efforts to ensure that the fundamentals were taught to all children in Sunday afternoon classes. Moreover, the Kirk’s emphasis was on positive teaching of the Bible in Scots so everyone could understand. Before 1560 devotion was often encouraged by means of plays, but the new Kirk put a stop to that. And the insides of churches were cleared of statues of saints and images of Mary and other decoration that was deemed to be a distraction from the teaching of the Bible. Attempt ALL of the following questions. 5. Explain the reasons why there was a Reformation in Scotland, 1560. 6. Evaluate the usefulness of Source A as evidence of Mary’s religious policy as a reason for her difficulties in ruling Scotland, 1561–1567. In reaching a conclusion you should refer to • the origin and possible purpose of the source • the content of the source • recalled knowledge. 7. How much do Sources B and C reveal about differing interpretations of the struggle for control of the Kirk? Use the sources and recalled knowledge. 8. How fully does Source D explain the impact of the Reformation on Scotland, to 1603? Use the source and recalled knowledge. 8 8 10 10
  • 20. page 08 SCOTTISH HISTORY — 36 marks PART C — The Treaty of Union, 1689−1740 Study the sources below and attempt the following four questions. Source A from a speech by Lord Belhaven in parliament, November 1706. I wish to contribute my thoughts on the two kingdoms of Scotland and England being forever united into one Kingdom by the name of Great Britain. Shall we, in just a single half hour of debate, surrender and give up what our ancestors won and defended with their lives for centuries? In this case, I can see Scotland — our own ancient mother Caledonia — watching us inflict a fatal wound upon her, causing her to take her last breath. Does this not bring to mind the murder of Julius Caesar by his own Senate? It seems to me that this treaty will mean that we are forced to pay long- standing English debts, through increased taxes and customs duties. All this, while the English constitution remains firm and suffers no annihilation. Source B from Paul Henderson Scott, The Union of 1707: Why and How (2006). The Scottish Parliament which met on 3 October 1706 to discuss the Treaty drawn up in London had the same membership as the one elected in 1703, except for those who had died in the meantime. The Treaty contained last minute guarantees to several groups. Scottish lawyers were promised that the Scottish legal system would continue, with Scots Law to remain intact. There was also the guarantee of free trade with the colony plantations in America and the Caribbean, which English parliaments had always refused in the past. These changes did not have as much influence over as many ordinary people in the country as they did over MPs. Members from the burghs, however, were persuaded by the fact that royal burgh rights would not be affected by union. The English government was determined to secure the Treaty. Source C from Gordon Menzies, The Scottish Nation (1972). The English government was convinced that a runaway Scotland would make common cause with France. Union now became England’s first priority. The Duke of Argyll was bribed to vote for union by the promise of military promotion and a position in the House of Lords. He was not the only noble to benefit from such corruption. The earl of Glasgow was given £20,000 from English funds to be divided amongst those who would support union. It was also necessary for England to recognise the future needs of those who were opposed to the Treaty. MPs in this group were ‘bought off’ by the guarantee of an Equivalent fund which remarkably matched the amount of money lost in the Darien Scheme. This was to boost Scottish development after union and ensure that the new burden of taxation would not bear down too heavily on the country.
  • 21. page 09 MARKS SCOTTISH HISTORY — PART C (continued) Source D from Allan MacInnes, Union and Empire (2007). Initially many people in Scotland were not favourable towards the effects of union across the country. In the years after 1707, Scottish MPs objected to increased duties, particularly the attempt to impose new taxes which caused attacks on customs agents and an upsurge in smuggling. This led to some Scots in parliament proposing a reversal of union in 1713, although their efforts were in vain. Partnership did not necessarily mean an equal division of wealth and resources. However, colonies in the West Indies became a new market for Scottish merchants in the early 1700s. Therefore, union led to a change in the Scottish balance of trade, with an increase in profits entering into the country via ships arriving in Glasgow from the Caribbean. The creation of a United Kingdom was significant for the whole of the British Empire. Attempt ALL of the following questions. 9. Explain the reasons why Scottish relations with England worsened, from 1689. 10. Evaluate the usefulness of Source A as evidence of contrasting attitudes in Scotland towards Union. In reaching a conclusion you should refer to • the origin and possible purpose of the source • the content of the source • recalled knowledge. 11. How much do Sources B and C reveal about differing interpretations of the passing of the Union by the Scottish Parliament? Use the sources and recalled knowledge. 12. How fully does Source D explain the effects of the Union, to 1740? Use the source and recalled knowledge. 8 8 10 10
  • 22. page 10 SCOTTISH HISTORY — 36 marks PART D — Migration and empire, 1830–1939 Study the sources below and attempt the following four questions. Source A from Joe Smith (Cesaikas), a memoir of a first-generation Scot born to an immigrant family, written in 1933. I was born in 1903 in Glengarnock to Lithuanian parents, but of course, we were all called Poles back then. I think my worst time was at the school, before my father changed our name when I was bullied and asked, time after time, ‘What’s your name? Tell us your name. Go home to your own country.’ If I had a sandwich made with rye bread and Lithuanian sausage they would say, ‘What is that you are eating? Your bread is dirty. Did you drop it in the mud?’ We lived in the Long Row where housing conditions were poor. I was lucky as there were lots of Lithuanian children in the Row that I could play with without being called a Pole. It was also good for my parents as they had a close-knit Lithuanian community who kept to their own traditions in food, religion and music away from any discrimination. Source B from Alexander MacArthur, a memoir written in 1886. In 1861 I left Nairn and my job in the local law office to emigrate to Canada which was a most daunting task. I first of all took employment with the Bank of Toronto as Scots were very prominent in this field of business and I had family connections who had vouched for my suitability. Soon my sense of adventure took over and in 1864, I moved to join fellow Scots at the Hudson Bay Company in Montreal as a second officer and accountant. By 1869, I felt the need to move again. This time I moved to the Red River settlement where my brother Peter was living. We set up a successful and profitable lumber business and had a much greater quality of life than had we stayed in Nairn. Source C from Marjory Harper, Crossing borders: Scottish emigration to Canada (2006). Hebridean Scots struggled in areas of Canada where their forefathers were not present. The Gaelic language isolated Hebridean emigrants from their more experienced Scots neighbours who did not speak the language resulting in them being offered less employment in a foreign land than English-speaking Scots. Distinctiveness was certainly interpreted negatively by earlier Scots immigrants. In a stinging verbal attack against the Hebridean Scots of Nova Scotia, fellow Scots immigrants depicted them as an ‘oat-eating, money-griping tribe of second-hand Scots, not even fit for domestic servants.’ Further west, in Killarney, the observation of Sunday as a day of worship and rest by the Hebridean emigrants irritated their less religious Scottish neighbours who believed in ‘working, when work needed done’ leading to further tensions and less opportunities than Scots from other parts of Scotland.
  • 23. page 11 MARKS SCOTTISH HISTORY — PART D (continued) Source D from John Burrowes, Irish (2003). The continued development of the canal system was one of the major projects which required the tenacity and muscle power of the Glasgow Irish. Yet, the greatest and most hazardous project on which the Glasgow Irish navvies worked was the Forth Rail Bridge, one of the biggest construction projects ever carried out in Britain. There were 57 recorded navvies’ deaths, but because of poor record keeping, the eventual fate of the 461 seriously injured was never recorded. Some projects were closer to home such as the building of the quayside of Broomielaw on the Clyde, which improved access for shipping right into the heart of Glasgow. The tunnelling skills were also essential in the building of the new Glasgow subway system where there was an oozing flow of mud above the navvies 60 feet thick, as like moles they shovelled their way under the river Clyde. Attempt ALL of the following questions. 13. Explain the reasons for the migration of Scots. 14. Evaluate the usefulness of Source A as evidence of the experience of Lithuanian immigrants in Scotland. In reaching a conclusion you should refer to • the origin and possible purpose of the source • the content of the source • recalled knowledge. 15. How much do Sources B and C reveal about differing interpretations of the impact of Scots emigrants on Canada? Use the sources and recalled knowledge. 16. How fully does Source D explain the effects of migration and empire on Scotland, to 1939? Use the source and recalled knowledge. 8 8 10 10
  • 24. page 12 SCOTTISH HISTORY — 36 marks PART E — The impact of The Great War, 1914–1928 Study the sources below and attempt the following four questions. Source A from an article in The Glasgow Herald newspaper, 29 October 1915. The first attempt to put into force the eviction warrants which have been issued against Glasgow tenants who are participating in the ‘Rent Strike’ was made yesterday afternoon in Merryland Street, Govan. The householder is a widow. As has been the custom since the beginning of the movement against increased rents, a demonstration of the ‘strikers’ was held at the time when the warrant became operative. While Mrs Barbour, of the Glasgow Women’s Housing Association, was addressing those who had assembled, two sheriff officers arrived and endeavoured to gain admission to the house. As soon as it was known that it was proposed to eject the tenant the demonstrators determined to resist. Most of them were women and they attacked the officers and their assistants with flour and fish. A woman was arrested on a charge of assaulting one of the officers, but later released from Govan police station with no charge. Source B from Ewen A Cameron, Impaled Upon a Thistle: Scotland since 1880 (2010). The 1920s were the first decade since the availability of proper data to show a decline in Scotland’s population. This was a national experience, felt in rural and urban areas, in the highlands and the lowlands. A number of factors lie behind emigration in the 1920s: economic depression had a huge impact on struggling heavy industry leading to rising levels of unemployment. This was compounded by low wages and an uncertain farming sector, all of which made Scotland a less than attractive place to stay. These points cannot, however, bear the entire burden of explanation because of the different pattern in the depression of 1920–1922, when emigration was high and after 1929, when it was not. One other factor was Government assistance to help ex‑soldiers migrate, in the form of the Empire Settlement Act of 1922, which redirected the flow of emigrants from the United States to the dominions, especially Canada. Source C from an article in The Glasgow Herald newspaper, 14 April 1923. This weekend is witnessing emigration from the Hebrides on a scale comparable only to that experienced in the early 1880s. Thirty families, numbering some 400 souls, are leaving Benbecula, South Uist and Barra for the distant land of Alberta, Canada. This scheme was initiated by the Reverend Father McDonnell and is being carried out by arrangement with the Canadian Pacific Railway Company. Their ship, the Marloch, will sail early this afternoon from Greenock with about 700 Scottish emigrants, many of them of the skilled tradesmen class who are in demand in Canada. Others who are going out are to take up the opportunity offered to work on the land. Next weekend a second party will sail from Stornoway with between 400 and 500 persons. They are going out to Canada soon to be welcomed by the local people of Alberta.
  • 25. page 13 MARKS SCOTTISH HISTORY — PART E (continued) Source D from I C G Hutchison, The Impact of the First World War on Scottish Politics (1999). Before 1914 the Liberals were the most popular political party in Scotland and the Conservatives found it difficult to challenge them. For most of the Great War, opinion in Scotland was strongly committed to victory which naturally boosted the Tories who were wholeheartedly in favour of the war unlike the Liberals, or Labour. Many of the Conservative party workers were known for encouraging recruitment — a factor which strengthened their credibility after the war. In the 1918 election, a very large difference between the Tories and the other two parties was that the Conservatives put up many candidates with military titles, 46% had a military rank compared to none for the Labour Party. In Fife East, the heroism of the Tory candidate in the war, Colonel Sir Alexander Sprot, was one factor in unseating the ex-Liberal Prime Minister, Henry Herbert Asquith. Attempt ALL of the following questions. 17. Explain the reasons why the Scots played an important role on the Western Front. 18. Evaluate the usefulness of Source A as evidence of the changing role of women in Scotland during the war. In reaching a conclusion you should refer to • the origin and possible purpose of the source • the content of the source • recalled knowledge. 19. How much do Sources B and C reveal about differing interpretations of the reasons for post-war emigration from Scotland? Use the sources and recalled knowledge. 20. How fully does Source D explain the impact of the Great War on Scottish politics? Use the source and recalled knowledge. [END OF QUESTION PAPER] 8 8 10 10
  • 26. page 14 [BLANK PAGE] DO NOT WRITE ON THIS PAGE
  • 27. page 15 [BLANK PAGE] DO NOT WRITE ON THIS PAGE
  • 28. page 16 [BLANK PAGE] DO NOT WRITE ON THIS PAGE