Topic of presentation in Medical education Training

1. Introduction to Assessment
Dr. Saurabh Jain
Associate Professor
Dept. of Microbiology
Govt medical College, Khandwa

2. Specific Learning Objective
a) Elaborate the Principle of assessment
b) Elaborate the type of assessment
c) Attributes of appropriate assessment
d) Explain the utility of assessment
8/2/2019 2Dr Saurabh jain

3. • Assessment, derived from a Latin word that
means
“to sit beside and judge”
8/2/2019 3Dr Saurabh jain

4. Principle of assessment
1) Assessment should be aligned with students,
objective, competencies & educational
standard.
2) Assessment should not to used to threaten &
intimidate students. It should become more
like instruction.
3) Assessment result need to be used by
teacher to help student learn better.
8/2/2019 4Dr Saurabh jain

5. Miller’s pyramid
Actually performs
Competence to performs
Concept building
& understanding
8/2/2019 5Dr Saurabh jain

6. Functions of Assessment
a) Diagnosis –
b) Prediction –
c) Selection –
d) Grading –
e) Program evaluation-
diagnose area that are not properly learnt
Assumption that a candidate scoring high on
these test will do well in real life tooEntrance test like NEET
We assess to rank order the student of
any given class for prizes, scholarships
8/2/2019 6Dr Saurabh jain

7. Type of Assessment
1. Summative Assessment –
To know the sum of student learning
after end of lecture/system or end of year.
 Summative assessment doesn't mean only
university examination.
 Still it is generally used for making pass/fail
decisions in most set-ups.
8/2/2019 7Dr Saurabh jain

8. Type of Assessment
2. Formative Assessment-
to provide feedback to the learner as
well as the teachers to make learning even
better
 it is generally not useful for making pass/fail.
8/2/2019 8Dr Saurabh jain

9. Type of Assessment
3. Internal assessment –
conducted by the teachers themselves
without any external
 Can serve formative as well as summative
assessment
8/2/2019 9Dr Saurabh jain

10. Question: What is the best method to
assessed students?
1. Paper consist of MCQ
2. Paper consist of Essay type/Short/Very short
questions
3. Practical aspects
4. All of the above
8/2/2019 10Dr Saurabh jain

11. Attributes of appropriate assessment
1. Validity
2. Reliability
3. Feasibility & acceptability
4. Educational impact of assessment
8/2/2019 11Dr Saurabh jain

12. Attributes of appropriate assessment
1. Validity
–The validity of an assessment is the extent
to which a test really measures what it is
supposed to measure.
8/2/2019 12Dr Saurabh jain

13.  A Question asked to student “Write short
notes on eliciting knee jerk” & Student
write it correctly. Now which one is your
valid interpretation:-
1. Student can elicit knee jerk.
2. Student only know but may or may not
able to elicit knee jerk.
8/2/2019 13Dr Saurabh jain

14. Attributes of appropriate assessment
1. Validity
a) Content validity
b) Criterion related validity
c) Construct validity – example, an essay being
marked on the basis of handwriting or good
presentation, the assessment become low on
construct validity
8/2/2019 14Dr Saurabh jain

15. Threats to valid assessment
 Too few test items
 Too easy or too difficult items
 Items not aligned with learning objectives
 Improper/ biased sampling of items
 Improperly worded items
 Item testing individual skills & not constructs
 Leakage of question paper/checklist
8/2/2019 15Dr Saurabh jain

16. Attributes of appropriate assessment
1. Validity
2. Reliability
• Reliability is the extent to which a test of
assessment is repeatable, reproducible and
yields consistent scores.
8/2/2019 16Dr Saurabh jain

17. Threats to reliable assessment
 Too few test items
 Too easy or too difficult test items
 Items not representative of learning objectives
 Poorly written items
 Inappropriate length or timing of the test
 Leakage of question paper/checklist
 Inappropriate examination conditions (hot &
humid hall, tired students)
8/2/2019 17Dr Saurabh jain

18. Attributes of appropriate assessment
1. Validity
2. Reliability
3. Feasibility & acceptability –
E.g. Practical exam on lumber puncture or
putting an IV drip
Is this feasible & acceptable ??
8/2/2019 18Dr Saurabh jain

19. Attributes of appropriate assessment
1. Validity
2. Reliability
3. Feasibility & acceptability
4. Educational impact of assessment
Any assessment should stimulate the students
to adopt good study habits & engage in deep
learning
if we promotes students to adopt short
cuts, then it indicates a poor quality assessment.
8/2/2019 19Dr Saurabh jain

20. • Utility of assessment = validity x
x reliability
x feasibility & acceptability
x educational impact
8/2/2019 20Dr Saurabh jain

21. Summary
Assessment means to sit beside the learner and
judge him.
Type of assessment include Summative (means
sum of student learning after end of
lecture/system or end of year), Formative (means
to provide feedback to the learner) & Internal
assessment.
8/2/2019 21Dr Saurabh jain

22. Utility of assessment become perfect when it
included all tools (validity, reliability,
acceptability, feasibility, educational impact).
For good quality assessment all 4 parameter
of Miller’s pyramid should be completed
(Knows, Knows how, Shows how, Does)
8/2/2019 22Dr Saurabh jain

23. Thanks
8/2/2019 23Dr Saurabh jain