Playing together in a worship band. For groups of all sizes and abilities. Understand the common factors which make bands sound bad and learn the key points to play well together.
Get over 40 free lessons from Musicademy
http://bit.ly/1pQDyUF
Before the throne - 2 notches up and it rushes
Your love is amazing - 1 notch down too slow, 1 up rushes
Better is one day [E] - wrong strumming pattern (Folk galloping with Backing Band) - from V2
Great is thy faithfulness [C] - keys too busy (with backing track right then wrong) - from Link 1
Lord, reign in me [A] - Tim - straight, Andy - pushes - from Link 1
Heart of worship (C2) - get people to clap what they think the groove is
Orchestral = keys 2
The lead vocal is the main thing - everything else is built around this.
The rhythm (groove) is based on the melody and everything else supports it.
Drums (if present) pick up on the rhythm of the melody and provide a solid foundation.
e.g. Here I am to worship - main rhythm from verse
Just melody and rhythm aren’t quite enough to support the whole song
Bass and drums work together - bass aids rhythm and provides the foundation for harmony.
It’s important that the bass provides this foundation locking with the drums and playing the correct bass notes.
Adding acoustic guitar further emphasises the rhythm and fills in chord notes.
This is a good basic combination of instruments.
Acoustic guitar picks up on the groove from bass and drums.
Electric guitar and keys add both harmony and texture.
They can cross over with each other and with other instruments so need to be careful - more on that later.
Both will thicken the sound as well as adding interest.
Orchestral instruments don’t always have much space to operate in modern worship songs. However, they can add a lot of interest. The key is to add the most by fitting into the gaps.
Backing vocals have a very small space to fill.
Typically harmony with the main melody - definitely not distracting from the melody or words.
This is a complete picture of things working well.
Most of us go wrong when instruments do too much… first keyboards…
Piano players are used to playing everything.
Big chords, lots of melody and rhythm take the space of most instrument.
Particularly difficult for electric guitar and orchestral instruments if you do too much.
Also let the bass handle the low end - particularly rhythm.
It’s ok to do more if there are fewer people in the band.
Now let’s swap things round and see what happens if the electric guitar does too much…
Crosses over keys and orchestral instruments.
Typically adding texture and harmony - not lead guitar and blues riffs.
Again, you can do more if there are fewer other players in the same space.
Back to normal.
Now let’s see what can happen when the bass does too much…
Playing too many notes (too funky?) and too much rhythm takes space from drums, keys, guitars and orchestral instruments.
Don’t play too many notes.
Or…
Frustrated lead guitarists tend to play too high (and too much) - this can leave a hole at the bottom of the sound. It also cuts across the roll of other guitars.
Now let’s see what happens if orchestral instruments do too much…
Probably getting the idea.
There’s a real risk of cutting across the melody (even obliterating it) together with electric guitars and keys.
What about BVs?
If you sing too much of the melody or a harmony but are too loud in the mix it will undermine the lead vocal - need to be careful of this.
Trilling and frilling also cuts across the melody.
It will also have an impact on orchestral instruments, guitars and keys.
Don’t do it!
What about acoustic guitar?
The main problems are playing too much (rhythm) - this cuts across bass but can also clash with drums and leave little space in the sound.
There are also problems when the acoustic is mixed too high. This doesn’t leave space for much else.
A frequent problem is that most or all of the band do too much…
It’s not pretty!
What about smaller setups?
You won’t have everything all of the time.
Many of us have to work with what we’ve got.
Not a common combination but one which can work really well.
If there’s a gap in the sound at the lower end things tend not to work well.
Be especially careful about drums without bass.
In this situation it would work better not to use drums.
Acoustic guitar covers the rhythmic role and there’s no gap in the sound.
It’s possible to fill the gap with keyboard.
Better if the player can use a bass sound well (i.e. no octaves in the bass)
The sound of an electric bass is much fuller than a piano and supports the sound better.
Here we can see that it’s ok not to have acoustic guitar.
Because the electric guitar and/or keys cover this part of the sonic spectrum the ‘gap’ isn’t serious.
This combination could also work without bass.
Again, if the left hand of the keyboard can use a bass sound it’s generally better than piano.
A lot of bands struggle for both bass and drums.
That’s not a problem - there are a number of solutions which work.
This is often because there’s no gap.
Here the keyboard would need to be more rhythmic than with bass and drums.
The important points are:
Don’t do too much
Cover rhythm, harmony and texture in supporting the melody
Don’t leave gaps low down