SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 10
Download to read offline
International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), 
Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME 
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT (IJM) 
ISSN 0976-6502 (Print) 
ISSN 0976-6510 (Online) 
Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 
© IAEME: http://www.iaeme.com/IJM.asp 
Journal Impact Factor (2014): 7.2230 (Calculated by GISI) 
www.jifactor.com 
57 
 
IJM 
© I A E M E 
EMPLOYEE MENTORING: A TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT 
TECHNIQUE IN ENHANCING ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS AND 
EFFICIENCY 
Dr. Stephen I. Dugguh 
Centre for Entrepreneurship  Service Learning, Federal University, Kashere-Gombe, Nigeria 
Abubakar Muhammad Galadanchi 
Registry Department, Federal University, Kashere-Gombe, Nigeria 
ABSTRACT 
Many organizations do not understand, encourage and apply cost effective techniques like 
mentoring in training and developing employees. That is where the problem of this paper lies. To 
find solutions to this problem therefore, the paper seeks to give an overview of mentoring and 
examine its effectiveness and efficiency as alternative technique in training and developing 
employees as oppose to other training techniques that are directed only towards improving employee 
skills. The paper is descriptive in nature and draws largely from many research works in mentoring. 
Literature findings indicate that mentoring is not only beneficial to the mentee but also to the mentor 
and the organization at large. It also tends to improve both individual and organizational 
effectiveness and efficiency as illustrated in a case study of Nottingham University. The 
recommendation of the paper is that employees should be mentored so that the personal development 
of the mentee and mentor and organizational effectiveness and efficiency would be enhanced. It is 
suggested that further research be conducted in similar training techniques like coaching and 
counselling. 
Keywords: Mentoring, Training, Development, Organizational, Effectiveness and Efficiency. 
1. INTRODUCTION 
There is no gain in saying that over the years there has been considerable interest in 
organizational programmes aimed at training and developing employees. Literature and researches 
abound to suggest that effective training techniques may improve employee skills, knowledge and 
abilities thereby enhancing their performance in organizations. Some of the training techniques relate
International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), 
Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME 
to both in company on-the-job and off-the-job and include: demonstration, coaching, enlarged 
assignment, job rotation, seminars, workshops, apprenticeship, assistant to, committee membership, 
job instruction, case studies, lecture, group exercise and so on (Armstrong, 2003, Butler  Rose, 
2013). These programmes or techniques have been used in various organizations with varying 
degrees of success. 
58 
 
However, one of such programmes that seek to improve employee skills, knowledge and 
abilities has not been given the desired attention and is rarely practised in organizations. This training 
and development technique is employee mentoring: the process of using specially selected and 
trained individuals to provide guidance and advice which will help to develop the careers of the 
‘protégés’ allocated to them (Armstrong, 2003). Mentors may be required to provide assistance 
regarding the improvement of employee performance, informal clarification of roles, job 
expectations and so on. Debates also exist as to roles and effectiveness of mentoring as a programme 
of training employees. The focus and major thrust of mentoring is to develop the whole person and 
not just his skills (Daloz, 1990). Despite the usefulness of this technique, it appears it is not fully 
explored in training employees for career development. 
This paper therefore aims at providing an overview of mentoring and to examine its 
effectiveness as an alternative technique in training and developing employees believing it would 
enhance both the employee and organizational performance. 
2. THEORETICAL UNDERPINNING 
In consideration of its effectiveness, efficiency and worth, it is pertinent to examine certain 
theories of mentoring (Rhodes, 2005, Rhodes  DuBois, 2008). Some of the theories to be examined 
in relation to mentoring include: the GROW theory, the Self-Organized Learning theory and the 
Development Alliance theory. 
The GROW (Goal, Reality, Options and Wrap-up) theory revolves around structured, in-person 
conversations. It is said to be structured in the sense that it begins by defining the topic in 
order to understand what specifically the mentor and mentee want to talk about, what environment 
they are in and the scale of the problem they face, the importance of the topic to be discussed and so 
on. This model is fashioned in a four-step structure. Step one starts by both parties identifying and 
agreeing on a number of clear and achievable goals or outcomes bearing in mind that the goals are 
not long-term in nature. Step two is the reality. In this step, both players brainstorm together, make 
self-assessment and offer specific examples to illustrate their points and achieve the most accurate 
picture of goal in question or to come up with specific ideas. Step three is the specification of 
options. The mentor draws out a list of all possibilities and expects the mentee to offer suggestions or 
ask effective questions. The mentee is not evaluated or judged. He is then guided towards making the 
right choices. The last step in the theory is the wrap-up where the mentor’s intention is to gain 
commitment to action by the trainee. Both select the most appropriate options, commit resources to 
action, define action plan, and other actions necessary to overcome obstacles to achieve their 
objectives. This theory is popular where the official system of mentoring is employed but does not 
work effectively and efficiently in an informal approach to mentoring. 
(http//www.1000ventures.com/business guide/cross cuttings/coaching grow.htm/). 
The Self-Organized Learning (SOL) Theory developed by Brunel University’s Centre for the 
Study of Human Learning focuses on the process of learning itself rather than specific academic 
knowledge. SOL borrows some elements of the Humanistic, Cognitive and Behavioural Schools of 
Psychology. Mentors in SOL expect their mentees to take active role in their own growth process, 
and assume that each mentee knows him/her self and understand how he learns best. Mentees define 
their own goals, develop and execute strategies for success and evaluate their own performance.
International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), 
Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME 
However, many employees find goal setting as a difficult task since they may not have the required 
skills and experience. 
59 
 
The Development Alliance Theory (DAT) frames mentoring as a process that involves three 
parties: the mentor, the mentee and the larger organization that sponsors (or is expected to sponsor) 
mentoring. This is because since the sponsoring organization stands to benefit from the mentee’s 
success, all the three parties have the same goal and emotional distance between them is equal. What 
is common to the three parties is the desire to succeed. However, the downside of the theory is that if 
the mentee fails in his responsibilities and duties to the sponsoring organization, the organization will 
no longer have the same interest in the mentee’s success. Moreover, should the mentor becomes too 
close to the mentee, he may act in the best interest of the mentee and not in the best interest of all the 
three parties. All the three theories are relevant to employee mentoring and for this paper. 
3. CONCEPTUAL CLARIFICATIONS 
Mentoring as a training technique is very complex. It varies from one situation to another and 
is interpreted in different ways by different people (Head, Reiman  Theis, 1992). However, it is 
important that the intent and purpose of mentoring in a particular context be explicit to all 
stakeholders: the mentor, the mentee and the organization. Defining mentoring is multidimensional. 
But there are some common elements in the definitions. Megginson  Clutterbuck (1995.13) defined 
mentoring as ‘off the line help by one person to another in making significant transitions in 
knowledge, work or thinking’. On his part, Armstrong opined that mentoring is the process of 
specially selecting and training individuals to provide guidance and advice which will help to 
develop the careers of mentees allocated to them with the aim of complementing learning (training) 
on the job in order to acquire particular skills and knowledge the job holder needs. It is the individual 
guidance from experienced employees who are ‘wise in the ways of the organization’. This paper 
gives credence to Bozeman  Feehey (2007) conceptual clarifications that mentoring is a process for 
the informal transmission of knowledge, social capital and the psychosocial support perceived by the 
recipient as relevant to work, career or professional development and entails informal 
communication, usually face-to-face and during a sustained period of time, between a person who is 
perceived to have greater relevant knowledge, wisdom, or experience (the mentor) and a person who 
is perceived to have less (the mentee or protégé). The common element in these definitions is that 
mentoring is a process of transferring knowledge on a face-to-face basis from a senior, experience 
person to another who does not possess the necessary knowledge and experience. 
Historically, mentoring is a very old concept but now in a new guise. It can be traced back to 
Greek mythology when Odysseus entrusted his son Telemachus to the Goddess Athena, who 
disguised herself in human form as Mentor, an old friend of Oddysseus. Her function, according to 
Hormer, was to act as a wise counsellor and helper to the youth. Mentoring then became common 
practice in the time of the guilds and trade apprenticeships when young people, having acquired 
technical skills, often benefited from the patronage of more experienced and established 
professionals (Roberts, 1999). 
Today, it on record that established ‘stars’ encourage and nature younger ones and most 
successful people, in any walk of life, probably have had one or more people who have exerted a 
particular strong influence over their lives and careers. A study conducted by Aubrey  Cohen 
(1995) found the commonly used mentoring techniques to include: accompanying, sowing, 
catalyzing, showing and harvesting. Though different techniques may be used according to the 
situation and the mindset of the mentee, personal credibility is essential to quality mentoring. 
Mentoring is experience-based way of developing leadership capabilities. It is typically an informal 
relationship based on compatibility between two personalities. The standard approach to mentoring 
relationships is to make oneself visible through outstanding job performance and volunteering for
International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), 
Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME 
assignments (Dubrin, 1995). From this beginning, a long-lasting relationship that aims to enhance the 
mentees’ capabilities, understanding and advancement within their professional career is established. 
60 
3.1 The importance of mentoring 
 
Entering into practice in any profession offers a major challenge to young, newly qualified 
practitioners. The entry period is a formative one where the knowledge, skills and attitudes acquired 
during a programme of education are applied in practice. It is a transition period which can be 
stressful as well as challenging as new demands are made upon individuals who are seeking to 
consolidate their skills and experience. It is therefore a period when a practitioner is in need of 
guidance and support in order to develop both competence and confidence. Mentoring is therefore 
well established in many professions like lecturing (teaching), social work and other organizations. It 
is considered to be a programme or scheme. Anyanwu (2014), and Jones  Jowett (1997) studies 
indicate that mentoring programmes may be implemented for reasons that are highlighted below: 
a. to identify potentials more effectively 
b. to induct new staff more quickly 
c. to improve the retention of staff 
d. to encourage and support high flyers 
e. to encourage and support minorities and disadvantaged groups 
f. to encourage and support women to get a breakthrough 
g. to support self-development and work-based learning 
h. to help individuals cope with transitions (moving into a new job) 
i. to support organizational change and so on. 
3.2 Values and Principles of Mentoring 
Hay, (1995), Jowett, Shaw  Tarbitt (1997) in their separate studies, emphasized that the 
mentoring process is underpinned by a number of values and principles some of which are outlined 
below: 
a. Recognising that people are good 
b. Realising that people can change and want to grow 
c. Understanding how people learn 
d. Recognising individual differences 
e. Empowering through personal and professional development 
f. Encouraging capability 
g. Developing competence 
h. Encouraging collaboration and not competition 
i. Encouraging scholarship and a sense of enquiry 
j. Searching for new ideas, theories and knowledge 
k. Equal opportunities in the organization 
l. Reflection on past experiences as a way of understanding 
m. Looking forward and developing the ability to transfer learning and apply it in new 
situations. 
n. Realising that a new meaning of mentoring can be created 
3.3 Mentoring Skills and Roles 
From the foregoing, it may be clear that effective mentoring requires certain skills. From the 
research report conducted by Schein (1978), David  Garrison (1979), McKimm, Jolie  Hatter 
(2007), mentoring skills can be grouped into two: organizational and interpersonal. Organizational
International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), 
Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME 
skills revolve around planning, contracting, recording, structuring sessions, time management, 
scheduling, evaluating, assessing, report writing, action planning, prioritising, facilitating and so on. 
Interpersonal skills focus on the following: negotiating and influencing, listening, giving constructive 
feedback, intervention, questioning, motivation and encouraging, self-awareness, coaching/teaching, 
reflection, non-judgemental, non-prejudicial and so on. 
61 
 
Armed with appropriate skills and at a point in time over the duration of the relationship, a 
mentor will probably fulfil the following roles: teacher/educator, counsellor, motivator, facilitator, 
coach, adviser, guide, sounding board, devil’s advocate, learning consultant, process consultant, 
translator/decoder, interpreter, time manager, planner, problem-solver, catalyst, energiser, expert, 
guru, sponsor, role model, target/pace setter, friend, talent developer, guardian, confidant, master, 
door opener, patron, pioneer, successful leader, helper, monitor, commentator and so on. 
These skills and roles can be seen and used by all organizations: small, medium and large to 
further the training, development and retention of employees. Be it formal or informal, mentoring 
programmes serve a variety of specific objectives - acclimation of new employees, skills 
development, employee retention, diversity and in some cases, cultural enhancement. 
Based on the preceding, it becomes clear that mentors bring experience, perspective, objectivity and 
distance into the mentoring relationship. They offer a long term view for the organization and the 
individual. They are also influential in terms of helping the mentee/learner reach their goals and 
aspirations: caring about the mentee, they focus on the needs of the individual; they provide 
empathy, openness and honesty, willingness to share their expertise and so on. 
To accomplish these roles, a mentor should have the following characteristics: good 
interpersonal skills, advocacy, sincerity, warmth, commitment, objectivity, role model, flexibility, 
peer respect, demonstrable competence, reflective practitioner, non-threatening attitude, learning 
facilitator, open mindedness, approachability, self confidence, understanding etc. The mentee on the 
other hand must exhibit the following characteristics: willingness to learn and develop, willingness to 
participate, intelligent, ambitious, keen to succeed, loyal, committed, conscientious, able to develop 
alliances, flexible, self-awareness, well organized, able to accept challenge and able to receive 
constructive feedback. 
3.4 Mentor-Mentee Relationship 
Research findings from the work of McKimm, Jollie  Hatter indicate that a mentor-mentee 
relationship is a special one where two people make real connection with each other. In other words, 
they form a bond: building on mutual trust and respect, openness, and honesty. It is a powerful and 
emotional relationship. In this case, the mentoring relationship enables the mentee to learn and grow 
in a safe and protected environment. Further, the quality of the relationship is crucial to a successful 
outcome. Successful bond is contingent upon the comfort of both the mentor and the mentee within 
the relationship. Otherwise mentoring cannot be sustained. Therefore, a good mentor-mentee 
relationship recognises the need for personal development and the partners have some idea of where 
they want to go (Clutterbuck, 1991). 
It is important to understand that as a process, the mentee will be relatively dependent and the 
mentor will need to be supportive, helpful, friendly, and encouraging to nurture the mentee to learn 
and grow. The relationship will change with time and subsequently the mentor’s role will have to 
change. When the mentee becomes more confident and independent, the mentor will need to 
challenge, stimulate and encourage reflection. Mentoring should not remain a dependent relationship. 
Neither should it become an excuse for a chat session. Hay (1995) opined that since mentoring is a 
two-way process with the mentor having as much to gain as the mentee, the crux therefore should be 
to encourage both partners to contribute freely and operate as equals. Factors like age, wisdom and 
experience are not relevant in a mentor-mentee relationship. The mentor may take the initial 
initiative to ensure that the relationship gets going. In this stage the mentor will be concerned with
International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), 
Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME 
motivation, supporting, enabling and empowering activities. As time progresses, the mentee will 
develop independence and autonomy and in the end may even surpass the mentor. 
4. ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS AND EFFICIENCY 
62 
 
Mentoring influences organizational effectiveness which in itself is multi dimensional as 
there are multiple definitions. It may refer to the concept of how an organization is in achieving the 
organization intends to produce. It also captures organizational performance plus the myriad internal 
performance outcomes normally associated with more efficient or effective operations and other 
external measures that relate to considerations that are broader than those simply associated with 
economic valuation (Etzioni, 1964, Herman  Renz, 2008, Richard et al, 2009). In organizational 
effectiveness, activities such as administration, funding, and volunteer training are important inputs 
into specific, measurable impacts. In summary therefore, organizational effectiveness is how well the 
job gets done and how good the end result is. Closely associated with organizational effectiveness is 
efficiency – how frugally a job gets done using as little time and as few resources as possible. 
Resources for this purpose refer to money, materials, people, energy, time, information and so on. 
Both effectiveness and efficiency are ways an organization can measure the success of a task 
outcome (Mitchell, 2012). 
Going by this conceptual clarification, mentoring is considered beneficial to the organization, 
the mentor and the mentee. These benefits can be assessed in the following dimensions: 
At the organizational level, mentoring widens the skill bases and competencies in line with the 
organization’s strategic goals. That is, mentoring increases staff morale and job satisfaction, reduces 
the gap in service and education, serves as an alternative to external training, more cost effective 
personal development programme and develops habits of trust and confidentiality. Further, 
mentoring gives senior management a more informed view of the organization’ talent and assists in 
succession planning. It also helps the organization to achieve it mission and vision thereby 
developing a mature management population and improved quality of service through increased 
competence of supported practitioners and experts. In addition, mentoring also improves teamwork 
and co-operation in the organization. 
To the mentor, mentoring improves awareness of own learning gaps and develops ability to 
give and take criticisms; it develops up-to-date organizational and professional knowledge and offers 
networking opportunities. Further, mentoring is beneficial to a mentor in the sense that it develops 
ability to challenge, stimulate and reflect thereby raising organizational profile. Again mentoring 
increases job satisfaction and offers opportunity to pass on knowledge and experience. Lastly, it 
provides stimulation and may offer advancement opportunities. 
On the part of the mentee, mentoring basically develops learning, analytical and reflective 
skills as well as developing both organizational and professional knowledge. Again, mentoring 
develops the following in a mentee: political awareness, own practice, self-confidence and 
willingness to take risks, ability to accept criticism, autonomy and independence. In most cases 
mentoring supports the mentee through transition and accelerates professional development just as it 
broadens horizons and increases job satisfaction. It reduces reality shock and offers opportunities for 
effective role modelling. It is also on record that mentoring encourages the mentee’s ongoing 
learning and developing/identifying learning opportunities in the working situation while offering 
individualized one-on-one teaching and opportunities for experiential learning and so on (McKimm, 
Jollie  Hatter, 2007). 
From the literature review above it becomes clear that mentoring impacts the organization, 
the mentor and the mentee. As stated earlier, mentoring is more likely to be effective if the parties 
are willing volunteers. It is also helpful if the mentee is able to select his mentor. This may however 
require a matching and pairing process within a facilitated mentoring scheme. Despite the numerous
International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), 
Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME 
benefits of mentoring as a training technique, it is regrettable that very few organizations and 
employers understand and encourage the technique. The case study below further demonstrates the 
importance some organizations attach to mentoring. The case study is that of Nottingham University, 
United Kingdom. 
Mentoring in Higher Education: Nottingham University 
63 
5. A CASE STUDY OF MENTORING 
 
This mentoring scheme covers all grades of staff within Nottingham University. Guidance 
about the scheme includes guidance notes for mentors and mentees and guidance on mentors for 
probationary Academic Staff, Staff in the Registry Department, Clerical, Secretaries, Junior 
Administrative Staff and Technical Staff. 
The scheme is designed for all new staff that from the beginning of the 1997/8 Session are 
entitled to a mentor if they wish to have one. Different mentor arrangements have been organised 
depending on individual departmental/ school circumstances. The formal scheme is therefore 
intended to be relatively flexible, presenting options and indicating “the norm” rather than 
prescribing universal rules. 
The scheme sees mentoring as ‘a process in which a person (mentor) is responsible for 
overseeing the initial career and development of another person’. The emphasis therefore is on the 
relationship (rather than, the activity). In some circumstance mentoring is used as a way of preparing 
established colleagues for new roles or posts. 
The Mentor is seen as a trusted friend, counsellor, guide, advocate, role model, information 
provider and door opener. As a minimum, mentors are expected to assist with induction and 
introducing the new person to the University and Departmental processes and procedures. In addition 
the mentor may have a role in providing guidance and support in relation to job requirements and 
performance. The precise role varies according to the experience and needs of the people involved. 
The importance of discussing and agreeing on the nature of relationship at an early stage is 
emphasised. 
The Nottingham University scheme identifies two models of mentoring although it 
emphasises the fact that mentor relationships change over time, that some combination of the models 
is possible and that participants need to be conscious of the different models and the approaches that 
they imply. Misunderstanding and confusion may arise if the mentor partners have different models 
of the relationship in mind or fail to appreciate how it is changing. One model is based on peer 
development, in which the partners are of relatively equal status and in which learning and 
development is collaborative and a two way. This model supports the view that a peer who has 
recently gone through the same period of induction as the new person is the most appropriate person 
to take on the mentor role. This suggests that normally the mentor should be a member of staff who 
has a minimum of two years experience within the current Department/School but not more than 
five. In this approach, age, seniority and subject area are secondary considerations. On the other, 
more traditional approach, is based on a developmental model in which the more senior person is 
largely passing on his/her wisdom and experience to the new person. This approach argues that 
more experienced members of staff are better able to advice and guide the new person. In this 
approach length of service and seniority may be decisive factors. Whichever approach is adopted, it 
is regarded as vitally important that the mentor is committed to the role. It is also a prerequisite of the 
scheme that new members of staff should have the option of changing their mentor where it becomes 
clear that the relationship is not working. Rules for confidentiality are also agreed at the outset in 
order that the new members of staff feel professionally “safe” with the mentor. The mentor is not 
normally the mentee’s appraiser or head of department or equivalent (in order to separate the mentor 
role from ‘line management’ and judgements required about probation, promotion etc.). Where for
International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), 
Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME 
practical reasons this is impossible to achieve, it is emphasised that great care should be taken to 
ensure that the two roles are kept separate. 
64 
 
In most mentoring scheme, it is anticipated that there will come a point when the mentoring 
relationship will and should end. It can be suggested that the mentor partners review the agreed focus 
and ground rules at least annually. 
Preparing and training of mentors is organised by University Training  Staff Development 
Unit and detailed briefing notes and courses are provided on the scheme and its operation. Mentors 
are encouraged to agree with their mentees the frequency and length of meetings, venues, rules about 
contact (only at work?), agendas for meetings and whether or not to hold an annual meeting and to 
emphasise the importance of both giving and receiving feedback. 
The above case study is culled from an article by Richard Blackwell, Head of Staff 
Training and Development, Nottingham University, United Kingdom and illustrates how 
Department and Schools at the University consider mentoring as a very important learning and 
training scheme. A mentor is looked upon as a trusted friend, counsellor, guide and so on. The 
emphasis on mentoring is on establishing relationships rather than activities. Two mentoring 
approaches: the peer development and the traditional approaches are used in mentoring employees at 
the university. It is interesting to note that mentors are trained by the Staff and Development Unit of 
the University and encouraged to meet with mentees on regular basis. The University has a 
mentoring scheme. The application of this technique results in effective and efficient training of 
employees for a higher position in the organization. 
6. CONCLUSION 
There are many and varying literature and concepts of mentoring. The basic ingredient being 
a situation whereby an experienced, highly regarded, knowledgeable, abler and senior colleague 
called a mentor, by talking, listening in confidence, guides another individual called a mentee, 
working in the same organization or field, in the development and re-examination of the mentee’s 
own ideas, learning, personal and professional development. Mentoring is seen as voluntary activity 
and not imposed and that confidentiality is essential. It is equally important that both the mentor and 
mentee fully understand the purpose and limits of the mentoring relationship. The benefits of 
mentoring are legion and impacts in various ways on the organization, the mentor and the mentee. 
Therefore, mentoring is a valuable technique to support and develop the mentee personally, 
professionally and educationally. 
Regrettably, in many organizations, be it manufacturing, educational, service-based, non-governmental, 
military and para-military, health care providers or the public sector have not 
understood and encouraged the application of mentoring as a training and development technique to 
enhance employee effectiveness and efficiency. Further research could be conducted in coaching or 
counselling as an alternative technique in developing employee skills on the job. 
7. RECOMMENDATION 
Based on the literature findings above, it is hereby recommended that organizational leaders 
should imbibe the practice of mentoring for its effectiveness and efficiency as an alternative 
technique in training and developing employees in the organization. If this technique is understood 
and applied, it is very likely that the mentor, the mentee and the organization would benefit from 
mentoring thereby increasing the level of performance and productivity in the organization.
International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), 
Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME 
65 
8. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 
 
We wish to acknowledge the Vice Chancellor, Federal University, Kashere, Gombe State, 
Nigeria Professor Mohammed Kabiru Farouk for creating a very conducive learning environment 
and encouraging publications and scholarship. We appreciate the authors of the materials we have 
lavishly consulted ant to all who contributed immensely in one way or the other in supporting us in 
writing this article. The Staff of the Centre for Entrepreneurship  Service Learning and the Registry 
Department of the University are also acknowledged for their support and professional suggestions 
that added value to the production of this article. Finally, we appreciate the students of Accounting 
and Business Administration, Federal University, Kashere for their encouragement in making this 
paper a reality. 
REFERENCES 
[1] Anyanwu, S. O. (2014). Mentorship and Networking between the Professional and students 
for enhancing Entrepreneurship culture. Paper presented at the Entrepreneurship Stakeholders 
Forum organized by the National Universities Commission, Abuja- Nigeria. 
[2] Armstrong, M. (2003). A handbook of Human Resource Management Practice, 9th edition, 
London: Kogan Page 
[3] Bozeman, B and Feehey, M. K. (2007) Toward a useful theory of mentoring: A conceptual 
analysis and critique. Administration and Society 39(6): 710-739 
[4] Buell, C. (2004) ‘Models of Mentoring in Communication’. Communication Review53 (1): 
56-73 
[5] Bullis C, and Bach, W. B. (1989). Are mentor relationships helping organization? An 
exploration of developing mentee-mentor-organizational identification using turning point 
analysis’ Communication Quarterly 37 (3): 199-213. 
[6] Buttler, M.  Rose , E (2011). Introduction to Organizational Behaviour, London: CIPD 
[7] Clutterbuck, D. (1995) Counselling Adults - making the most of mentoring. 
[8] Davis, J.R.L,  Garrison, P.A (1979). Mentoring in search of a topology. (MIT Sloan) Master 
Thesis) 
[9] Daloz, L.A (1990). Effective Teaching and Mentoring. San Francisco, Jossey Bass. 
[10] DuBrin, A. J (1995). Leadership: Research Findings, Practice, and Skills. Boston: Houghton 
Mifflin Company. 
[11] Etzioni, A. (1964). Modern Organizations. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall 
[12] Cornway, C. (1994). Mentoring Manager in organization – A study of mentoring and its 
application to organizations with case studies, Ashridge Research Group. 
[13] Jowett, J.V., Shaw, E. D.  Tarbitt, V. (1977). A guide to mentoring, Leeds Metropolitan 
University 
[14] Hay, J. (1995). Transformational Mentoring. McGraw Hill Book Company, New York. 
[15] Head, F.A., Reiman, A. J., Theis, S. (1992). The reality of mentoring: Complexity in its 
process and Function. In Bey, T. M.  Holmes, C. T. (Eds). Mentoring: Contemporary 
Principles and Issues. Reston VA. Association of Teachers Educators: 5-24. 
[16] Herman, R. D.  Renz, D. O. (2008). Advancing nonprofit organizational effectiveness 
Research and Theory: Nine Thesis. Nonprofit Management  Leadership, 18(4) 399-415. 
[17] Huag, C.  Jerry, L. (195). Mentoring- The TAO of Giving and Receiving Wisdom. 
Harper,San Francisco. 
[18] Kolb, D.A (1994). Experiential Learning: Experience as a source of learning and 
development, Prentice Hall, New York.
International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), 
Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME 
66 
 
[19] McKimm, J., Jollie, C,  Hatter, M. (2007) Mentoring: Theory and Practice. London NHSE. 
[20] Megginson, D and Clutterbuek, D (1995). Mentoring in Action: A practical guide for leaders 
of international nonprofits in the United States. Nonprofit and Voluntary leaders of 
international nonprofits in the United States. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector leaders of 
international nonprofits in the United States. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector. 
[21] Metchell, G. E. (2012). The construct of organizational effectiveness: Perspectives from 
Quarterly. 
[22] Odiorne, G.S (1985) ‘Mentoring’ An American Management Innovation. Personnel 
Administrator (30): 63-65. 
[23] Parsloe, E  Wray, M. J. (2000). Governing and Mentoring: Practical methods to 
improveLearning. Kogan page, New York. 
[24] Robert, A. (1999). ‘The origin of the term mentor’. History of Education Society Bullettin 
No46: 313-329. 
[25] Rhodes, J. E. (2005). ‘A theoretical model of youth mentoring’. In DuBois, D. L.  Karcher 
M. J. (Eds) Handbook of youth mentoring. Thousand Oakes, CA: Sage Press. 
[26] Rhodes, J. E.  DuBois, D. L. (2008). Mentoring relationships and programmes for youth. 
Current Directions in Psychological Science, 17: 254-259. 
[27] Richard et al (2009). Measuring Organizational Performance: Towards Methodological Best 
Practice. Journal of Management. 
[28] Schein, E.H. (1978) Career Dynamics: Matching Individual and organization needs. 
Addison- Wesley. 
[29] Schlee, R. (2000). ‘Mentoring and the professional development of students’ Journal of 
Management Education 24(30: 322-337. 
[30] (http//www.1000ventures.com/business guide/cross cuttings/coaching grow.htm/) Retrieved 
20.8.2014. 
[31] M.Sudarsan and Ponramalingam, “Significance of the Training on Enhancing Effectiveness of 
Communication Skills in the IT Industry”, International Journal of Management (IJM), 
Volume 4, Issue 4, 2013, pp. 1 - 8, ISSN Print: 0976-6502, ISSN Online: 0976-6510. 
[32] Mohd.Irfan Khan, Anil Kumar Mishra and Prof.(Dr.) Y.P.Singh, “A Review: Technology 
Innovation and Role of Training and Education in Small and Medium Size Enterprise and it 
Sector”, International Journal of Management (IJM), Volume 4, Issue 3, 2013, pp. 75 - 81, 
ISSN Print: 0976-6502, ISSN Online: 0976-6510.

More Related Content

What's hot

Personnel Training and Development and Employee Productivity in a Financial I...
Personnel Training and Development and Employee Productivity in a Financial I...Personnel Training and Development and Employee Productivity in a Financial I...
Personnel Training and Development and Employee Productivity in a Financial I...
Ameh Elizabeth (GNIM)
 
Learning organisation and employee development
Learning organisation and employee developmentLearning organisation and employee development
Learning organisation and employee development
Yathish Kumar
 
Final workshop executive summary
Final workshop executive summaryFinal workshop executive summary
Final workshop executive summary
Wael Aziz
 
Leadership development in the us
Leadership development in the usLeadership development in the us
Leadership development in the us
Wael Aziz
 
ILJ_Fall2015_FatienOtter
ILJ_Fall2015_FatienOtterILJ_Fall2015_FatienOtter
ILJ_Fall2015_FatienOtter
Ken Otter
 
Building leaders
Building leadersBuilding leaders
Building leaders
Wael Aziz
 

What's hot (20)

Developing leaders and managers via Coaching
Developing leaders and managers via CoachingDeveloping leaders and managers via Coaching
Developing leaders and managers via Coaching
 
Hrd 8
Hrd 8Hrd 8
Hrd 8
 
Bagali MM, Case Study
Bagali MM, Case Study Bagali MM, Case Study
Bagali MM, Case Study
 
Defining and measuring employability 2001
Defining and measuring employability 2001Defining and measuring employability 2001
Defining and measuring employability 2001
 
Hrd 1
Hrd 1Hrd 1
Hrd 1
 
Cultures of Engagement Insights Paper
Cultures of Engagement Insights PaperCultures of Engagement Insights Paper
Cultures of Engagement Insights Paper
 
Hrd 10
Hrd 10Hrd 10
Hrd 10
 
Hrd 16
Hrd 16Hrd 16
Hrd 16
 
Hrd 18
Hrd 18Hrd 18
Hrd 18
 
Personnel Training and Development and Employee Productivity in a Financial I...
Personnel Training and Development and Employee Productivity in a Financial I...Personnel Training and Development and Employee Productivity in a Financial I...
Personnel Training and Development and Employee Productivity in a Financial I...
 
Learning organisation and employee development
Learning organisation and employee developmentLearning organisation and employee development
Learning organisation and employee development
 
Hrd 14
Hrd 14Hrd 14
Hrd 14
 
Hrd 11
Hrd 11Hrd 11
Hrd 11
 
Mowgli Foundation: Mentoring Entrepreneurs for Learning
Mowgli Foundation: Mentoring Entrepreneurs for LearningMowgli Foundation: Mentoring Entrepreneurs for Learning
Mowgli Foundation: Mentoring Entrepreneurs for Learning
 
Challenges to Organizations and to HRD Professionals
Challenges to Organizations and to HRD ProfessionalsChallenges to Organizations and to HRD Professionals
Challenges to Organizations and to HRD Professionals
 
Final workshop executive summary
Final workshop executive summaryFinal workshop executive summary
Final workshop executive summary
 
Hrd 3
Hrd 3Hrd 3
Hrd 3
 
Leadership development in the us
Leadership development in the usLeadership development in the us
Leadership development in the us
 
ILJ_Fall2015_FatienOtter
ILJ_Fall2015_FatienOtterILJ_Fall2015_FatienOtter
ILJ_Fall2015_FatienOtter
 
Building leaders
Building leadersBuilding leaders
Building leaders
 

Similar to Employee mentoring a training and development technique in enhancing organizational

Paper id 23201429
Paper id 23201429Paper id 23201429
Paper id 23201429
IJRAT
 
FinalReportMentorshipinFPLS
FinalReportMentorshipinFPLSFinalReportMentorshipinFPLS
FinalReportMentorshipinFPLS
Warren Wessling
 
Personal And Professional Accountability And Opportunities...
Personal And Professional Accountability And Opportunities...Personal And Professional Accountability And Opportunities...
Personal And Professional Accountability And Opportunities...
Dani Cox
 
Final paper and powerpoint presentation
Final paper and powerpoint presentationFinal paper and powerpoint presentation
Final paper and powerpoint presentation
Connie Butts
 
Overview of the Effect of Employee Training on Organizational Perf.docx
Overview of the Effect of Employee Training on Organizational Perf.docxOverview of the Effect of Employee Training on Organizational Perf.docx
Overview of the Effect of Employee Training on Organizational Perf.docx
gerardkortney
 
22 ProfessionalSafety DECEMBER 2017 www.asse.org.docx
22   ProfessionalSafety      DECEMBER 2017      www.asse.org.docx22   ProfessionalSafety      DECEMBER 2017      www.asse.org.docx
22 ProfessionalSafety DECEMBER 2017 www.asse.org.docx
novabroom
 
Effects Of Hr Practices On Organizational Performance
Effects Of Hr Practices On Organizational PerformanceEffects Of Hr Practices On Organizational Performance
Effects Of Hr Practices On Organizational Performance
Patricia Johnson
 
22 ProfessionalSafety DECEMBER 2017 www.asse.org.docx
22   ProfessionalSafety      DECEMBER 2017      www.asse.org.docx22   ProfessionalSafety      DECEMBER 2017      www.asse.org.docx
22 ProfessionalSafety DECEMBER 2017 www.asse.org.docx
standfordabbot
 
17342257 training-and-development
17342257 training-and-development17342257 training-and-development
17342257 training-and-development
vignesssh
 
Study on effectiveness of training and development
Study on effectiveness of training and developmentStudy on effectiveness of training and development
Study on effectiveness of training and development
Anoop Voyager
 

Similar to Employee mentoring a training and development technique in enhancing organizational (20)

ImpactofTrainingonEmployeeRetention.pdf
ImpactofTrainingonEmployeeRetention.pdfImpactofTrainingonEmployeeRetention.pdf
ImpactofTrainingonEmployeeRetention.pdf
 
Employee Mentoring and Organizational Effectiveness
Employee Mentoring and Organizational EffectivenessEmployee Mentoring and Organizational Effectiveness
Employee Mentoring and Organizational Effectiveness
 
Coaching Sponsoring And Mentoring.pptx
Coaching Sponsoring And Mentoring.pptxCoaching Sponsoring And Mentoring.pptx
Coaching Sponsoring And Mentoring.pptx
 
Human Resoruce - Training and development (GSK Glaxosmithkline India)
Human Resoruce - Training and development (GSK Glaxosmithkline India)Human Resoruce - Training and development (GSK Glaxosmithkline India)
Human Resoruce - Training and development (GSK Glaxosmithkline India)
 
Paper id 23201429
Paper id 23201429Paper id 23201429
Paper id 23201429
 
basic career information
basic career informationbasic career information
basic career information
 
Impact of Training and Development, training design and on the job training ...
	Impact of Training and Development, training design and on the job training ...	Impact of Training and Development, training design and on the job training ...
Impact of Training and Development, training design and on the job training ...
 
Impact of professional
Impact of professionalImpact of professional
Impact of professional
 
FinalReportMentorshipinFPLS
FinalReportMentorshipinFPLSFinalReportMentorshipinFPLS
FinalReportMentorshipinFPLS
 
Personal And Professional Accountability And Opportunities...
Personal And Professional Accountability And Opportunities...Personal And Professional Accountability And Opportunities...
Personal And Professional Accountability And Opportunities...
 
Final paper and powerpoint presentation
Final paper and powerpoint presentationFinal paper and powerpoint presentation
Final paper and powerpoint presentation
 
A
AA
A
 
SYSTEMS ANALYSIS: LEARNING ORGANIZATIONS
SYSTEMS ANALYSIS: LEARNING ORGANIZATIONSSYSTEMS ANALYSIS: LEARNING ORGANIZATIONS
SYSTEMS ANALYSIS: LEARNING ORGANIZATIONS
 
Overview of the Effect of Employee Training on Organizational Perf.docx
Overview of the Effect of Employee Training on Organizational Perf.docxOverview of the Effect of Employee Training on Organizational Perf.docx
Overview of the Effect of Employee Training on Organizational Perf.docx
 
22 ProfessionalSafety DECEMBER 2017 www.asse.org.docx
22   ProfessionalSafety      DECEMBER 2017      www.asse.org.docx22   ProfessionalSafety      DECEMBER 2017      www.asse.org.docx
22 ProfessionalSafety DECEMBER 2017 www.asse.org.docx
 
Effects Of Hr Practices On Organizational Performance
Effects Of Hr Practices On Organizational PerformanceEffects Of Hr Practices On Organizational Performance
Effects Of Hr Practices On Organizational Performance
 
22 ProfessionalSafety DECEMBER 2017 www.asse.org.docx
22   ProfessionalSafety      DECEMBER 2017      www.asse.org.docx22   ProfessionalSafety      DECEMBER 2017      www.asse.org.docx
22 ProfessionalSafety DECEMBER 2017 www.asse.org.docx
 
17342257 training-and-development
17342257 training-and-development17342257 training-and-development
17342257 training-and-development
 
Study on effectiveness of training and development
Study on effectiveness of training and developmentStudy on effectiveness of training and development
Study on effectiveness of training and development
 
EMPLOYEENGAGMENT AS AN OUTCOME OF TRAINING
EMPLOYEENGAGMENT AS AN OUTCOME OF TRAININGEMPLOYEENGAGMENT AS AN OUTCOME OF TRAINING
EMPLOYEENGAGMENT AS AN OUTCOME OF TRAINING
 

More from IAEME Publication

A STUDY ON THE REASONS FOR TRANSGENDER TO BECOME ENTREPRENEURS
A STUDY ON THE REASONS FOR TRANSGENDER TO BECOME ENTREPRENEURSA STUDY ON THE REASONS FOR TRANSGENDER TO BECOME ENTREPRENEURS
A STUDY ON THE REASONS FOR TRANSGENDER TO BECOME ENTREPRENEURS
IAEME Publication
 
BROAD UNEXPOSED SKILLS OF TRANSGENDER ENTREPRENEURS
BROAD UNEXPOSED SKILLS OF TRANSGENDER ENTREPRENEURSBROAD UNEXPOSED SKILLS OF TRANSGENDER ENTREPRENEURS
BROAD UNEXPOSED SKILLS OF TRANSGENDER ENTREPRENEURS
IAEME Publication
 
GANDHI ON NON-VIOLENT POLICE
GANDHI ON NON-VIOLENT POLICEGANDHI ON NON-VIOLENT POLICE
GANDHI ON NON-VIOLENT POLICE
IAEME Publication
 
A STUDY ON TALENT MANAGEMENT AND ITS IMPACT ON EMPLOYEE RETENTION IN SELECTED...
A STUDY ON TALENT MANAGEMENT AND ITS IMPACT ON EMPLOYEE RETENTION IN SELECTED...A STUDY ON TALENT MANAGEMENT AND ITS IMPACT ON EMPLOYEE RETENTION IN SELECTED...
A STUDY ON TALENT MANAGEMENT AND ITS IMPACT ON EMPLOYEE RETENTION IN SELECTED...
IAEME Publication
 
ATTRITION IN THE IT INDUSTRY DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC: LINKING EMOTIONAL INTE...
ATTRITION IN THE IT INDUSTRY DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC: LINKING EMOTIONAL INTE...ATTRITION IN THE IT INDUSTRY DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC: LINKING EMOTIONAL INTE...
ATTRITION IN THE IT INDUSTRY DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC: LINKING EMOTIONAL INTE...
IAEME Publication
 
INFLUENCE OF TALENT MANAGEMENT PRACTICES ON ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE A STUD...
INFLUENCE OF TALENT MANAGEMENT PRACTICES ON ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE A STUD...INFLUENCE OF TALENT MANAGEMENT PRACTICES ON ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE A STUD...
INFLUENCE OF TALENT MANAGEMENT PRACTICES ON ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE A STUD...
IAEME Publication
 
A STUDY OF VARIOUS TYPES OF LOANS OF SELECTED PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS...
A STUDY OF VARIOUS TYPES OF LOANS OF SELECTED PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS...A STUDY OF VARIOUS TYPES OF LOANS OF SELECTED PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS...
A STUDY OF VARIOUS TYPES OF LOANS OF SELECTED PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS...
IAEME Publication
 
ROLE OF SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN RURAL DEVELOPMENT OF INDIA - PROBLEMS AND ...
ROLE OF SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN RURAL DEVELOPMENT OF INDIA - PROBLEMS AND ...ROLE OF SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN RURAL DEVELOPMENT OF INDIA - PROBLEMS AND ...
ROLE OF SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN RURAL DEVELOPMENT OF INDIA - PROBLEMS AND ...
IAEME Publication
 
OPTIMAL RECONFIGURATION OF POWER DISTRIBUTION RADIAL NETWORK USING HYBRID MET...
OPTIMAL RECONFIGURATION OF POWER DISTRIBUTION RADIAL NETWORK USING HYBRID MET...OPTIMAL RECONFIGURATION OF POWER DISTRIBUTION RADIAL NETWORK USING HYBRID MET...
OPTIMAL RECONFIGURATION OF POWER DISTRIBUTION RADIAL NETWORK USING HYBRID MET...
IAEME Publication
 
APPLICATION OF FRUGAL APPROACH FOR PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT - A CASE STUDY OF...
APPLICATION OF FRUGAL APPROACH FOR PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT - A CASE STUDY OF...APPLICATION OF FRUGAL APPROACH FOR PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT - A CASE STUDY OF...
APPLICATION OF FRUGAL APPROACH FOR PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT - A CASE STUDY OF...
IAEME Publication
 

More from IAEME Publication (20)

IAEME_Publication_Call_for_Paper_September_2022.pdf
IAEME_Publication_Call_for_Paper_September_2022.pdfIAEME_Publication_Call_for_Paper_September_2022.pdf
IAEME_Publication_Call_for_Paper_September_2022.pdf
 
MODELING AND ANALYSIS OF SURFACE ROUGHNESS AND WHITE LATER THICKNESS IN WIRE-...
MODELING AND ANALYSIS OF SURFACE ROUGHNESS AND WHITE LATER THICKNESS IN WIRE-...MODELING AND ANALYSIS OF SURFACE ROUGHNESS AND WHITE LATER THICKNESS IN WIRE-...
MODELING AND ANALYSIS OF SURFACE ROUGHNESS AND WHITE LATER THICKNESS IN WIRE-...
 
A STUDY ON THE REASONS FOR TRANSGENDER TO BECOME ENTREPRENEURS
A STUDY ON THE REASONS FOR TRANSGENDER TO BECOME ENTREPRENEURSA STUDY ON THE REASONS FOR TRANSGENDER TO BECOME ENTREPRENEURS
A STUDY ON THE REASONS FOR TRANSGENDER TO BECOME ENTREPRENEURS
 
BROAD UNEXPOSED SKILLS OF TRANSGENDER ENTREPRENEURS
BROAD UNEXPOSED SKILLS OF TRANSGENDER ENTREPRENEURSBROAD UNEXPOSED SKILLS OF TRANSGENDER ENTREPRENEURS
BROAD UNEXPOSED SKILLS OF TRANSGENDER ENTREPRENEURS
 
DETERMINANTS AFFECTING THE USER'S INTENTION TO USE MOBILE BANKING APPLICATIONS
DETERMINANTS AFFECTING THE USER'S INTENTION TO USE MOBILE BANKING APPLICATIONSDETERMINANTS AFFECTING THE USER'S INTENTION TO USE MOBILE BANKING APPLICATIONS
DETERMINANTS AFFECTING THE USER'S INTENTION TO USE MOBILE BANKING APPLICATIONS
 
ANALYSE THE USER PREDILECTION ON GPAY AND PHONEPE FOR DIGITAL TRANSACTIONS
ANALYSE THE USER PREDILECTION ON GPAY AND PHONEPE FOR DIGITAL TRANSACTIONSANALYSE THE USER PREDILECTION ON GPAY AND PHONEPE FOR DIGITAL TRANSACTIONS
ANALYSE THE USER PREDILECTION ON GPAY AND PHONEPE FOR DIGITAL TRANSACTIONS
 
VOICE BASED ATM FOR VISUALLY IMPAIRED USING ARDUINO
VOICE BASED ATM FOR VISUALLY IMPAIRED USING ARDUINOVOICE BASED ATM FOR VISUALLY IMPAIRED USING ARDUINO
VOICE BASED ATM FOR VISUALLY IMPAIRED USING ARDUINO
 
IMPACT OF EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE ON HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT PRACTICES AMONG...
IMPACT OF EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE ON HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT PRACTICES AMONG...IMPACT OF EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE ON HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT PRACTICES AMONG...
IMPACT OF EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE ON HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT PRACTICES AMONG...
 
VISUALISING AGING PARENTS & THEIR CLOSE CARERS LIFE JOURNEY IN AGING ECONOMY
VISUALISING AGING PARENTS & THEIR CLOSE CARERS LIFE JOURNEY IN AGING ECONOMYVISUALISING AGING PARENTS & THEIR CLOSE CARERS LIFE JOURNEY IN AGING ECONOMY
VISUALISING AGING PARENTS & THEIR CLOSE CARERS LIFE JOURNEY IN AGING ECONOMY
 
A STUDY ON THE IMPACT OF ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF PERFO...
A STUDY ON THE IMPACT OF ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF PERFO...A STUDY ON THE IMPACT OF ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF PERFO...
A STUDY ON THE IMPACT OF ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF PERFO...
 
GANDHI ON NON-VIOLENT POLICE
GANDHI ON NON-VIOLENT POLICEGANDHI ON NON-VIOLENT POLICE
GANDHI ON NON-VIOLENT POLICE
 
A STUDY ON TALENT MANAGEMENT AND ITS IMPACT ON EMPLOYEE RETENTION IN SELECTED...
A STUDY ON TALENT MANAGEMENT AND ITS IMPACT ON EMPLOYEE RETENTION IN SELECTED...A STUDY ON TALENT MANAGEMENT AND ITS IMPACT ON EMPLOYEE RETENTION IN SELECTED...
A STUDY ON TALENT MANAGEMENT AND ITS IMPACT ON EMPLOYEE RETENTION IN SELECTED...
 
ATTRITION IN THE IT INDUSTRY DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC: LINKING EMOTIONAL INTE...
ATTRITION IN THE IT INDUSTRY DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC: LINKING EMOTIONAL INTE...ATTRITION IN THE IT INDUSTRY DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC: LINKING EMOTIONAL INTE...
ATTRITION IN THE IT INDUSTRY DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC: LINKING EMOTIONAL INTE...
 
INFLUENCE OF TALENT MANAGEMENT PRACTICES ON ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE A STUD...
INFLUENCE OF TALENT MANAGEMENT PRACTICES ON ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE A STUD...INFLUENCE OF TALENT MANAGEMENT PRACTICES ON ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE A STUD...
INFLUENCE OF TALENT MANAGEMENT PRACTICES ON ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE A STUD...
 
A STUDY OF VARIOUS TYPES OF LOANS OF SELECTED PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS...
A STUDY OF VARIOUS TYPES OF LOANS OF SELECTED PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS...A STUDY OF VARIOUS TYPES OF LOANS OF SELECTED PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS...
A STUDY OF VARIOUS TYPES OF LOANS OF SELECTED PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS...
 
EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF MECHANICAL AND TRIBOLOGICAL RELATION OF NYLON/BaSO4 POL...
EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF MECHANICAL AND TRIBOLOGICAL RELATION OF NYLON/BaSO4 POL...EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF MECHANICAL AND TRIBOLOGICAL RELATION OF NYLON/BaSO4 POL...
EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF MECHANICAL AND TRIBOLOGICAL RELATION OF NYLON/BaSO4 POL...
 
ROLE OF SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN RURAL DEVELOPMENT OF INDIA - PROBLEMS AND ...
ROLE OF SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN RURAL DEVELOPMENT OF INDIA - PROBLEMS AND ...ROLE OF SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN RURAL DEVELOPMENT OF INDIA - PROBLEMS AND ...
ROLE OF SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN RURAL DEVELOPMENT OF INDIA - PROBLEMS AND ...
 
OPTIMAL RECONFIGURATION OF POWER DISTRIBUTION RADIAL NETWORK USING HYBRID MET...
OPTIMAL RECONFIGURATION OF POWER DISTRIBUTION RADIAL NETWORK USING HYBRID MET...OPTIMAL RECONFIGURATION OF POWER DISTRIBUTION RADIAL NETWORK USING HYBRID MET...
OPTIMAL RECONFIGURATION OF POWER DISTRIBUTION RADIAL NETWORK USING HYBRID MET...
 
APPLICATION OF FRUGAL APPROACH FOR PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT - A CASE STUDY OF...
APPLICATION OF FRUGAL APPROACH FOR PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT - A CASE STUDY OF...APPLICATION OF FRUGAL APPROACH FOR PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT - A CASE STUDY OF...
APPLICATION OF FRUGAL APPROACH FOR PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT - A CASE STUDY OF...
 
A MULTIPLE – CHANNEL QUEUING MODELS ON FUZZY ENVIRONMENT
A MULTIPLE – CHANNEL QUEUING MODELS ON FUZZY ENVIRONMENTA MULTIPLE – CHANNEL QUEUING MODELS ON FUZZY ENVIRONMENT
A MULTIPLE – CHANNEL QUEUING MODELS ON FUZZY ENVIRONMENT
 

Recently uploaded

TrustArc Webinar - Unified Trust Center for Privacy, Security, Compliance, an...
TrustArc Webinar - Unified Trust Center for Privacy, Security, Compliance, an...TrustArc Webinar - Unified Trust Center for Privacy, Security, Compliance, an...
TrustArc Webinar - Unified Trust Center for Privacy, Security, Compliance, an...
TrustArc
 
Cloud Frontiers: A Deep Dive into Serverless Spatial Data and FME
Cloud Frontiers:  A Deep Dive into Serverless Spatial Data and FMECloud Frontiers:  A Deep Dive into Serverless Spatial Data and FME
Cloud Frontiers: A Deep Dive into Serverless Spatial Data and FME
Safe Software
 
Architecting Cloud Native Applications
Architecting Cloud Native ApplicationsArchitecting Cloud Native Applications
Architecting Cloud Native Applications
WSO2
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Web Form Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apri...
Web Form Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apri...Web Form Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apri...
Web Form Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apri...
 
Vector Search -An Introduction in Oracle Database 23ai.pptx
Vector Search -An Introduction in Oracle Database 23ai.pptxVector Search -An Introduction in Oracle Database 23ai.pptx
Vector Search -An Introduction in Oracle Database 23ai.pptx
 
Stronger Together: Developing an Organizational Strategy for Accessible Desig...
Stronger Together: Developing an Organizational Strategy for Accessible Desig...Stronger Together: Developing an Organizational Strategy for Accessible Desig...
Stronger Together: Developing an Organizational Strategy for Accessible Desig...
 
TrustArc Webinar - Unified Trust Center for Privacy, Security, Compliance, an...
TrustArc Webinar - Unified Trust Center for Privacy, Security, Compliance, an...TrustArc Webinar - Unified Trust Center for Privacy, Security, Compliance, an...
TrustArc Webinar - Unified Trust Center for Privacy, Security, Compliance, an...
 
Connector Corner: Accelerate revenue generation using UiPath API-centric busi...
Connector Corner: Accelerate revenue generation using UiPath API-centric busi...Connector Corner: Accelerate revenue generation using UiPath API-centric busi...
Connector Corner: Accelerate revenue generation using UiPath API-centric busi...
 
Understanding the FAA Part 107 License ..
Understanding the FAA Part 107 License ..Understanding the FAA Part 107 License ..
Understanding the FAA Part 107 License ..
 
JohnPollard-hybrid-app-RailsConf2024.pptx
JohnPollard-hybrid-app-RailsConf2024.pptxJohnPollard-hybrid-app-RailsConf2024.pptx
JohnPollard-hybrid-app-RailsConf2024.pptx
 
TEST BANK For Principles of Anatomy and Physiology, 16th Edition by Gerard J....
TEST BANK For Principles of Anatomy and Physiology, 16th Edition by Gerard J....TEST BANK For Principles of Anatomy and Physiology, 16th Edition by Gerard J....
TEST BANK For Principles of Anatomy and Physiology, 16th Edition by Gerard J....
 
Cloud Frontiers: A Deep Dive into Serverless Spatial Data and FME
Cloud Frontiers:  A Deep Dive into Serverless Spatial Data and FMECloud Frontiers:  A Deep Dive into Serverless Spatial Data and FME
Cloud Frontiers: A Deep Dive into Serverless Spatial Data and FME
 
DEV meet-up UiPath Document Understanding May 7 2024 Amsterdam
DEV meet-up UiPath Document Understanding May 7 2024 AmsterdamDEV meet-up UiPath Document Understanding May 7 2024 Amsterdam
DEV meet-up UiPath Document Understanding May 7 2024 Amsterdam
 
AI+A11Y 11MAY2024 HYDERBAD GAAD 2024 - HelloA11Y (11 May 2024)
AI+A11Y 11MAY2024 HYDERBAD GAAD 2024 - HelloA11Y (11 May 2024)AI+A11Y 11MAY2024 HYDERBAD GAAD 2024 - HelloA11Y (11 May 2024)
AI+A11Y 11MAY2024 HYDERBAD GAAD 2024 - HelloA11Y (11 May 2024)
 
WSO2's API Vision: Unifying Control, Empowering Developers
WSO2's API Vision: Unifying Control, Empowering DevelopersWSO2's API Vision: Unifying Control, Empowering Developers
WSO2's API Vision: Unifying Control, Empowering Developers
 
Introduction to Multilingual Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
Introduction to Multilingual Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)Introduction to Multilingual Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
Introduction to Multilingual Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
 
Corporate and higher education May webinar.pptx
Corporate and higher education May webinar.pptxCorporate and higher education May webinar.pptx
Corporate and higher education May webinar.pptx
 
Design and Development of a Provenance Capture Platform for Data Science
Design and Development of a Provenance Capture Platform for Data ScienceDesign and Development of a Provenance Capture Platform for Data Science
Design and Development of a Provenance Capture Platform for Data Science
 
MINDCTI Revenue Release Quarter One 2024
MINDCTI Revenue Release Quarter One 2024MINDCTI Revenue Release Quarter One 2024
MINDCTI Revenue Release Quarter One 2024
 
[BuildWithAI] Introduction to Gemini.pdf
[BuildWithAI] Introduction to Gemini.pdf[BuildWithAI] Introduction to Gemini.pdf
[BuildWithAI] Introduction to Gemini.pdf
 
Architecting Cloud Native Applications
Architecting Cloud Native ApplicationsArchitecting Cloud Native Applications
Architecting Cloud Native Applications
 
Elevate Developer Efficiency & build GenAI Application with Amazon Q​
Elevate Developer Efficiency & build GenAI Application with Amazon Q​Elevate Developer Efficiency & build GenAI Application with Amazon Q​
Elevate Developer Efficiency & build GenAI Application with Amazon Q​
 
Decarbonising Commercial Real Estate: The Role of Operational Performance
Decarbonising Commercial Real Estate: The Role of Operational PerformanceDecarbonising Commercial Real Estate: The Role of Operational Performance
Decarbonising Commercial Real Estate: The Role of Operational Performance
 

Employee mentoring a training and development technique in enhancing organizational

  • 1. International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT (IJM) ISSN 0976-6502 (Print) ISSN 0976-6510 (Online) Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME: http://www.iaeme.com/IJM.asp Journal Impact Factor (2014): 7.2230 (Calculated by GISI) www.jifactor.com 57 IJM © I A E M E EMPLOYEE MENTORING: A TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT TECHNIQUE IN ENHANCING ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS AND EFFICIENCY Dr. Stephen I. Dugguh Centre for Entrepreneurship Service Learning, Federal University, Kashere-Gombe, Nigeria Abubakar Muhammad Galadanchi Registry Department, Federal University, Kashere-Gombe, Nigeria ABSTRACT Many organizations do not understand, encourage and apply cost effective techniques like mentoring in training and developing employees. That is where the problem of this paper lies. To find solutions to this problem therefore, the paper seeks to give an overview of mentoring and examine its effectiveness and efficiency as alternative technique in training and developing employees as oppose to other training techniques that are directed only towards improving employee skills. The paper is descriptive in nature and draws largely from many research works in mentoring. Literature findings indicate that mentoring is not only beneficial to the mentee but also to the mentor and the organization at large. It also tends to improve both individual and organizational effectiveness and efficiency as illustrated in a case study of Nottingham University. The recommendation of the paper is that employees should be mentored so that the personal development of the mentee and mentor and organizational effectiveness and efficiency would be enhanced. It is suggested that further research be conducted in similar training techniques like coaching and counselling. Keywords: Mentoring, Training, Development, Organizational, Effectiveness and Efficiency. 1. INTRODUCTION There is no gain in saying that over the years there has been considerable interest in organizational programmes aimed at training and developing employees. Literature and researches abound to suggest that effective training techniques may improve employee skills, knowledge and abilities thereby enhancing their performance in organizations. Some of the training techniques relate
  • 2. International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME to both in company on-the-job and off-the-job and include: demonstration, coaching, enlarged assignment, job rotation, seminars, workshops, apprenticeship, assistant to, committee membership, job instruction, case studies, lecture, group exercise and so on (Armstrong, 2003, Butler Rose, 2013). These programmes or techniques have been used in various organizations with varying degrees of success. 58 However, one of such programmes that seek to improve employee skills, knowledge and abilities has not been given the desired attention and is rarely practised in organizations. This training and development technique is employee mentoring: the process of using specially selected and trained individuals to provide guidance and advice which will help to develop the careers of the ‘protégés’ allocated to them (Armstrong, 2003). Mentors may be required to provide assistance regarding the improvement of employee performance, informal clarification of roles, job expectations and so on. Debates also exist as to roles and effectiveness of mentoring as a programme of training employees. The focus and major thrust of mentoring is to develop the whole person and not just his skills (Daloz, 1990). Despite the usefulness of this technique, it appears it is not fully explored in training employees for career development. This paper therefore aims at providing an overview of mentoring and to examine its effectiveness as an alternative technique in training and developing employees believing it would enhance both the employee and organizational performance. 2. THEORETICAL UNDERPINNING In consideration of its effectiveness, efficiency and worth, it is pertinent to examine certain theories of mentoring (Rhodes, 2005, Rhodes DuBois, 2008). Some of the theories to be examined in relation to mentoring include: the GROW theory, the Self-Organized Learning theory and the Development Alliance theory. The GROW (Goal, Reality, Options and Wrap-up) theory revolves around structured, in-person conversations. It is said to be structured in the sense that it begins by defining the topic in order to understand what specifically the mentor and mentee want to talk about, what environment they are in and the scale of the problem they face, the importance of the topic to be discussed and so on. This model is fashioned in a four-step structure. Step one starts by both parties identifying and agreeing on a number of clear and achievable goals or outcomes bearing in mind that the goals are not long-term in nature. Step two is the reality. In this step, both players brainstorm together, make self-assessment and offer specific examples to illustrate their points and achieve the most accurate picture of goal in question or to come up with specific ideas. Step three is the specification of options. The mentor draws out a list of all possibilities and expects the mentee to offer suggestions or ask effective questions. The mentee is not evaluated or judged. He is then guided towards making the right choices. The last step in the theory is the wrap-up where the mentor’s intention is to gain commitment to action by the trainee. Both select the most appropriate options, commit resources to action, define action plan, and other actions necessary to overcome obstacles to achieve their objectives. This theory is popular where the official system of mentoring is employed but does not work effectively and efficiently in an informal approach to mentoring. (http//www.1000ventures.com/business guide/cross cuttings/coaching grow.htm/). The Self-Organized Learning (SOL) Theory developed by Brunel University’s Centre for the Study of Human Learning focuses on the process of learning itself rather than specific academic knowledge. SOL borrows some elements of the Humanistic, Cognitive and Behavioural Schools of Psychology. Mentors in SOL expect their mentees to take active role in their own growth process, and assume that each mentee knows him/her self and understand how he learns best. Mentees define their own goals, develop and execute strategies for success and evaluate their own performance.
  • 3. International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME However, many employees find goal setting as a difficult task since they may not have the required skills and experience. 59 The Development Alliance Theory (DAT) frames mentoring as a process that involves three parties: the mentor, the mentee and the larger organization that sponsors (or is expected to sponsor) mentoring. This is because since the sponsoring organization stands to benefit from the mentee’s success, all the three parties have the same goal and emotional distance between them is equal. What is common to the three parties is the desire to succeed. However, the downside of the theory is that if the mentee fails in his responsibilities and duties to the sponsoring organization, the organization will no longer have the same interest in the mentee’s success. Moreover, should the mentor becomes too close to the mentee, he may act in the best interest of the mentee and not in the best interest of all the three parties. All the three theories are relevant to employee mentoring and for this paper. 3. CONCEPTUAL CLARIFICATIONS Mentoring as a training technique is very complex. It varies from one situation to another and is interpreted in different ways by different people (Head, Reiman Theis, 1992). However, it is important that the intent and purpose of mentoring in a particular context be explicit to all stakeholders: the mentor, the mentee and the organization. Defining mentoring is multidimensional. But there are some common elements in the definitions. Megginson Clutterbuck (1995.13) defined mentoring as ‘off the line help by one person to another in making significant transitions in knowledge, work or thinking’. On his part, Armstrong opined that mentoring is the process of specially selecting and training individuals to provide guidance and advice which will help to develop the careers of mentees allocated to them with the aim of complementing learning (training) on the job in order to acquire particular skills and knowledge the job holder needs. It is the individual guidance from experienced employees who are ‘wise in the ways of the organization’. This paper gives credence to Bozeman Feehey (2007) conceptual clarifications that mentoring is a process for the informal transmission of knowledge, social capital and the psychosocial support perceived by the recipient as relevant to work, career or professional development and entails informal communication, usually face-to-face and during a sustained period of time, between a person who is perceived to have greater relevant knowledge, wisdom, or experience (the mentor) and a person who is perceived to have less (the mentee or protégé). The common element in these definitions is that mentoring is a process of transferring knowledge on a face-to-face basis from a senior, experience person to another who does not possess the necessary knowledge and experience. Historically, mentoring is a very old concept but now in a new guise. It can be traced back to Greek mythology when Odysseus entrusted his son Telemachus to the Goddess Athena, who disguised herself in human form as Mentor, an old friend of Oddysseus. Her function, according to Hormer, was to act as a wise counsellor and helper to the youth. Mentoring then became common practice in the time of the guilds and trade apprenticeships when young people, having acquired technical skills, often benefited from the patronage of more experienced and established professionals (Roberts, 1999). Today, it on record that established ‘stars’ encourage and nature younger ones and most successful people, in any walk of life, probably have had one or more people who have exerted a particular strong influence over their lives and careers. A study conducted by Aubrey Cohen (1995) found the commonly used mentoring techniques to include: accompanying, sowing, catalyzing, showing and harvesting. Though different techniques may be used according to the situation and the mindset of the mentee, personal credibility is essential to quality mentoring. Mentoring is experience-based way of developing leadership capabilities. It is typically an informal relationship based on compatibility between two personalities. The standard approach to mentoring relationships is to make oneself visible through outstanding job performance and volunteering for
  • 4. International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME assignments (Dubrin, 1995). From this beginning, a long-lasting relationship that aims to enhance the mentees’ capabilities, understanding and advancement within their professional career is established. 60 3.1 The importance of mentoring Entering into practice in any profession offers a major challenge to young, newly qualified practitioners. The entry period is a formative one where the knowledge, skills and attitudes acquired during a programme of education are applied in practice. It is a transition period which can be stressful as well as challenging as new demands are made upon individuals who are seeking to consolidate their skills and experience. It is therefore a period when a practitioner is in need of guidance and support in order to develop both competence and confidence. Mentoring is therefore well established in many professions like lecturing (teaching), social work and other organizations. It is considered to be a programme or scheme. Anyanwu (2014), and Jones Jowett (1997) studies indicate that mentoring programmes may be implemented for reasons that are highlighted below: a. to identify potentials more effectively b. to induct new staff more quickly c. to improve the retention of staff d. to encourage and support high flyers e. to encourage and support minorities and disadvantaged groups f. to encourage and support women to get a breakthrough g. to support self-development and work-based learning h. to help individuals cope with transitions (moving into a new job) i. to support organizational change and so on. 3.2 Values and Principles of Mentoring Hay, (1995), Jowett, Shaw Tarbitt (1997) in their separate studies, emphasized that the mentoring process is underpinned by a number of values and principles some of which are outlined below: a. Recognising that people are good b. Realising that people can change and want to grow c. Understanding how people learn d. Recognising individual differences e. Empowering through personal and professional development f. Encouraging capability g. Developing competence h. Encouraging collaboration and not competition i. Encouraging scholarship and a sense of enquiry j. Searching for new ideas, theories and knowledge k. Equal opportunities in the organization l. Reflection on past experiences as a way of understanding m. Looking forward and developing the ability to transfer learning and apply it in new situations. n. Realising that a new meaning of mentoring can be created 3.3 Mentoring Skills and Roles From the foregoing, it may be clear that effective mentoring requires certain skills. From the research report conducted by Schein (1978), David Garrison (1979), McKimm, Jolie Hatter (2007), mentoring skills can be grouped into two: organizational and interpersonal. Organizational
  • 5. International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME skills revolve around planning, contracting, recording, structuring sessions, time management, scheduling, evaluating, assessing, report writing, action planning, prioritising, facilitating and so on. Interpersonal skills focus on the following: negotiating and influencing, listening, giving constructive feedback, intervention, questioning, motivation and encouraging, self-awareness, coaching/teaching, reflection, non-judgemental, non-prejudicial and so on. 61 Armed with appropriate skills and at a point in time over the duration of the relationship, a mentor will probably fulfil the following roles: teacher/educator, counsellor, motivator, facilitator, coach, adviser, guide, sounding board, devil’s advocate, learning consultant, process consultant, translator/decoder, interpreter, time manager, planner, problem-solver, catalyst, energiser, expert, guru, sponsor, role model, target/pace setter, friend, talent developer, guardian, confidant, master, door opener, patron, pioneer, successful leader, helper, monitor, commentator and so on. These skills and roles can be seen and used by all organizations: small, medium and large to further the training, development and retention of employees. Be it formal or informal, mentoring programmes serve a variety of specific objectives - acclimation of new employees, skills development, employee retention, diversity and in some cases, cultural enhancement. Based on the preceding, it becomes clear that mentors bring experience, perspective, objectivity and distance into the mentoring relationship. They offer a long term view for the organization and the individual. They are also influential in terms of helping the mentee/learner reach their goals and aspirations: caring about the mentee, they focus on the needs of the individual; they provide empathy, openness and honesty, willingness to share their expertise and so on. To accomplish these roles, a mentor should have the following characteristics: good interpersonal skills, advocacy, sincerity, warmth, commitment, objectivity, role model, flexibility, peer respect, demonstrable competence, reflective practitioner, non-threatening attitude, learning facilitator, open mindedness, approachability, self confidence, understanding etc. The mentee on the other hand must exhibit the following characteristics: willingness to learn and develop, willingness to participate, intelligent, ambitious, keen to succeed, loyal, committed, conscientious, able to develop alliances, flexible, self-awareness, well organized, able to accept challenge and able to receive constructive feedback. 3.4 Mentor-Mentee Relationship Research findings from the work of McKimm, Jollie Hatter indicate that a mentor-mentee relationship is a special one where two people make real connection with each other. In other words, they form a bond: building on mutual trust and respect, openness, and honesty. It is a powerful and emotional relationship. In this case, the mentoring relationship enables the mentee to learn and grow in a safe and protected environment. Further, the quality of the relationship is crucial to a successful outcome. Successful bond is contingent upon the comfort of both the mentor and the mentee within the relationship. Otherwise mentoring cannot be sustained. Therefore, a good mentor-mentee relationship recognises the need for personal development and the partners have some idea of where they want to go (Clutterbuck, 1991). It is important to understand that as a process, the mentee will be relatively dependent and the mentor will need to be supportive, helpful, friendly, and encouraging to nurture the mentee to learn and grow. The relationship will change with time and subsequently the mentor’s role will have to change. When the mentee becomes more confident and independent, the mentor will need to challenge, stimulate and encourage reflection. Mentoring should not remain a dependent relationship. Neither should it become an excuse for a chat session. Hay (1995) opined that since mentoring is a two-way process with the mentor having as much to gain as the mentee, the crux therefore should be to encourage both partners to contribute freely and operate as equals. Factors like age, wisdom and experience are not relevant in a mentor-mentee relationship. The mentor may take the initial initiative to ensure that the relationship gets going. In this stage the mentor will be concerned with
  • 6. International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME motivation, supporting, enabling and empowering activities. As time progresses, the mentee will develop independence and autonomy and in the end may even surpass the mentor. 4. ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS AND EFFICIENCY 62 Mentoring influences organizational effectiveness which in itself is multi dimensional as there are multiple definitions. It may refer to the concept of how an organization is in achieving the organization intends to produce. It also captures organizational performance plus the myriad internal performance outcomes normally associated with more efficient or effective operations and other external measures that relate to considerations that are broader than those simply associated with economic valuation (Etzioni, 1964, Herman Renz, 2008, Richard et al, 2009). In organizational effectiveness, activities such as administration, funding, and volunteer training are important inputs into specific, measurable impacts. In summary therefore, organizational effectiveness is how well the job gets done and how good the end result is. Closely associated with organizational effectiveness is efficiency – how frugally a job gets done using as little time and as few resources as possible. Resources for this purpose refer to money, materials, people, energy, time, information and so on. Both effectiveness and efficiency are ways an organization can measure the success of a task outcome (Mitchell, 2012). Going by this conceptual clarification, mentoring is considered beneficial to the organization, the mentor and the mentee. These benefits can be assessed in the following dimensions: At the organizational level, mentoring widens the skill bases and competencies in line with the organization’s strategic goals. That is, mentoring increases staff morale and job satisfaction, reduces the gap in service and education, serves as an alternative to external training, more cost effective personal development programme and develops habits of trust and confidentiality. Further, mentoring gives senior management a more informed view of the organization’ talent and assists in succession planning. It also helps the organization to achieve it mission and vision thereby developing a mature management population and improved quality of service through increased competence of supported practitioners and experts. In addition, mentoring also improves teamwork and co-operation in the organization. To the mentor, mentoring improves awareness of own learning gaps and develops ability to give and take criticisms; it develops up-to-date organizational and professional knowledge and offers networking opportunities. Further, mentoring is beneficial to a mentor in the sense that it develops ability to challenge, stimulate and reflect thereby raising organizational profile. Again mentoring increases job satisfaction and offers opportunity to pass on knowledge and experience. Lastly, it provides stimulation and may offer advancement opportunities. On the part of the mentee, mentoring basically develops learning, analytical and reflective skills as well as developing both organizational and professional knowledge. Again, mentoring develops the following in a mentee: political awareness, own practice, self-confidence and willingness to take risks, ability to accept criticism, autonomy and independence. In most cases mentoring supports the mentee through transition and accelerates professional development just as it broadens horizons and increases job satisfaction. It reduces reality shock and offers opportunities for effective role modelling. It is also on record that mentoring encourages the mentee’s ongoing learning and developing/identifying learning opportunities in the working situation while offering individualized one-on-one teaching and opportunities for experiential learning and so on (McKimm, Jollie Hatter, 2007). From the literature review above it becomes clear that mentoring impacts the organization, the mentor and the mentee. As stated earlier, mentoring is more likely to be effective if the parties are willing volunteers. It is also helpful if the mentee is able to select his mentor. This may however require a matching and pairing process within a facilitated mentoring scheme. Despite the numerous
  • 7. International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME benefits of mentoring as a training technique, it is regrettable that very few organizations and employers understand and encourage the technique. The case study below further demonstrates the importance some organizations attach to mentoring. The case study is that of Nottingham University, United Kingdom. Mentoring in Higher Education: Nottingham University 63 5. A CASE STUDY OF MENTORING This mentoring scheme covers all grades of staff within Nottingham University. Guidance about the scheme includes guidance notes for mentors and mentees and guidance on mentors for probationary Academic Staff, Staff in the Registry Department, Clerical, Secretaries, Junior Administrative Staff and Technical Staff. The scheme is designed for all new staff that from the beginning of the 1997/8 Session are entitled to a mentor if they wish to have one. Different mentor arrangements have been organised depending on individual departmental/ school circumstances. The formal scheme is therefore intended to be relatively flexible, presenting options and indicating “the norm” rather than prescribing universal rules. The scheme sees mentoring as ‘a process in which a person (mentor) is responsible for overseeing the initial career and development of another person’. The emphasis therefore is on the relationship (rather than, the activity). In some circumstance mentoring is used as a way of preparing established colleagues for new roles or posts. The Mentor is seen as a trusted friend, counsellor, guide, advocate, role model, information provider and door opener. As a minimum, mentors are expected to assist with induction and introducing the new person to the University and Departmental processes and procedures. In addition the mentor may have a role in providing guidance and support in relation to job requirements and performance. The precise role varies according to the experience and needs of the people involved. The importance of discussing and agreeing on the nature of relationship at an early stage is emphasised. The Nottingham University scheme identifies two models of mentoring although it emphasises the fact that mentor relationships change over time, that some combination of the models is possible and that participants need to be conscious of the different models and the approaches that they imply. Misunderstanding and confusion may arise if the mentor partners have different models of the relationship in mind or fail to appreciate how it is changing. One model is based on peer development, in which the partners are of relatively equal status and in which learning and development is collaborative and a two way. This model supports the view that a peer who has recently gone through the same period of induction as the new person is the most appropriate person to take on the mentor role. This suggests that normally the mentor should be a member of staff who has a minimum of two years experience within the current Department/School but not more than five. In this approach, age, seniority and subject area are secondary considerations. On the other, more traditional approach, is based on a developmental model in which the more senior person is largely passing on his/her wisdom and experience to the new person. This approach argues that more experienced members of staff are better able to advice and guide the new person. In this approach length of service and seniority may be decisive factors. Whichever approach is adopted, it is regarded as vitally important that the mentor is committed to the role. It is also a prerequisite of the scheme that new members of staff should have the option of changing their mentor where it becomes clear that the relationship is not working. Rules for confidentiality are also agreed at the outset in order that the new members of staff feel professionally “safe” with the mentor. The mentor is not normally the mentee’s appraiser or head of department or equivalent (in order to separate the mentor role from ‘line management’ and judgements required about probation, promotion etc.). Where for
  • 8. International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME practical reasons this is impossible to achieve, it is emphasised that great care should be taken to ensure that the two roles are kept separate. 64 In most mentoring scheme, it is anticipated that there will come a point when the mentoring relationship will and should end. It can be suggested that the mentor partners review the agreed focus and ground rules at least annually. Preparing and training of mentors is organised by University Training Staff Development Unit and detailed briefing notes and courses are provided on the scheme and its operation. Mentors are encouraged to agree with their mentees the frequency and length of meetings, venues, rules about contact (only at work?), agendas for meetings and whether or not to hold an annual meeting and to emphasise the importance of both giving and receiving feedback. The above case study is culled from an article by Richard Blackwell, Head of Staff Training and Development, Nottingham University, United Kingdom and illustrates how Department and Schools at the University consider mentoring as a very important learning and training scheme. A mentor is looked upon as a trusted friend, counsellor, guide and so on. The emphasis on mentoring is on establishing relationships rather than activities. Two mentoring approaches: the peer development and the traditional approaches are used in mentoring employees at the university. It is interesting to note that mentors are trained by the Staff and Development Unit of the University and encouraged to meet with mentees on regular basis. The University has a mentoring scheme. The application of this technique results in effective and efficient training of employees for a higher position in the organization. 6. CONCLUSION There are many and varying literature and concepts of mentoring. The basic ingredient being a situation whereby an experienced, highly regarded, knowledgeable, abler and senior colleague called a mentor, by talking, listening in confidence, guides another individual called a mentee, working in the same organization or field, in the development and re-examination of the mentee’s own ideas, learning, personal and professional development. Mentoring is seen as voluntary activity and not imposed and that confidentiality is essential. It is equally important that both the mentor and mentee fully understand the purpose and limits of the mentoring relationship. The benefits of mentoring are legion and impacts in various ways on the organization, the mentor and the mentee. Therefore, mentoring is a valuable technique to support and develop the mentee personally, professionally and educationally. Regrettably, in many organizations, be it manufacturing, educational, service-based, non-governmental, military and para-military, health care providers or the public sector have not understood and encouraged the application of mentoring as a training and development technique to enhance employee effectiveness and efficiency. Further research could be conducted in coaching or counselling as an alternative technique in developing employee skills on the job. 7. RECOMMENDATION Based on the literature findings above, it is hereby recommended that organizational leaders should imbibe the practice of mentoring for its effectiveness and efficiency as an alternative technique in training and developing employees in the organization. If this technique is understood and applied, it is very likely that the mentor, the mentee and the organization would benefit from mentoring thereby increasing the level of performance and productivity in the organization.
  • 9. International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME 65 8. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT We wish to acknowledge the Vice Chancellor, Federal University, Kashere, Gombe State, Nigeria Professor Mohammed Kabiru Farouk for creating a very conducive learning environment and encouraging publications and scholarship. We appreciate the authors of the materials we have lavishly consulted ant to all who contributed immensely in one way or the other in supporting us in writing this article. The Staff of the Centre for Entrepreneurship Service Learning and the Registry Department of the University are also acknowledged for their support and professional suggestions that added value to the production of this article. Finally, we appreciate the students of Accounting and Business Administration, Federal University, Kashere for their encouragement in making this paper a reality. REFERENCES [1] Anyanwu, S. O. (2014). Mentorship and Networking between the Professional and students for enhancing Entrepreneurship culture. Paper presented at the Entrepreneurship Stakeholders Forum organized by the National Universities Commission, Abuja- Nigeria. [2] Armstrong, M. (2003). A handbook of Human Resource Management Practice, 9th edition, London: Kogan Page [3] Bozeman, B and Feehey, M. K. (2007) Toward a useful theory of mentoring: A conceptual analysis and critique. Administration and Society 39(6): 710-739 [4] Buell, C. (2004) ‘Models of Mentoring in Communication’. Communication Review53 (1): 56-73 [5] Bullis C, and Bach, W. B. (1989). Are mentor relationships helping organization? An exploration of developing mentee-mentor-organizational identification using turning point analysis’ Communication Quarterly 37 (3): 199-213. [6] Buttler, M. Rose , E (2011). Introduction to Organizational Behaviour, London: CIPD [7] Clutterbuck, D. (1995) Counselling Adults - making the most of mentoring. [8] Davis, J.R.L, Garrison, P.A (1979). Mentoring in search of a topology. (MIT Sloan) Master Thesis) [9] Daloz, L.A (1990). Effective Teaching and Mentoring. San Francisco, Jossey Bass. [10] DuBrin, A. J (1995). Leadership: Research Findings, Practice, and Skills. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company. [11] Etzioni, A. (1964). Modern Organizations. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall [12] Cornway, C. (1994). Mentoring Manager in organization – A study of mentoring and its application to organizations with case studies, Ashridge Research Group. [13] Jowett, J.V., Shaw, E. D. Tarbitt, V. (1977). A guide to mentoring, Leeds Metropolitan University [14] Hay, J. (1995). Transformational Mentoring. McGraw Hill Book Company, New York. [15] Head, F.A., Reiman, A. J., Theis, S. (1992). The reality of mentoring: Complexity in its process and Function. In Bey, T. M. Holmes, C. T. (Eds). Mentoring: Contemporary Principles and Issues. Reston VA. Association of Teachers Educators: 5-24. [16] Herman, R. D. Renz, D. O. (2008). Advancing nonprofit organizational effectiveness Research and Theory: Nine Thesis. Nonprofit Management Leadership, 18(4) 399-415. [17] Huag, C. Jerry, L. (195). Mentoring- The TAO of Giving and Receiving Wisdom. Harper,San Francisco. [18] Kolb, D.A (1994). Experiential Learning: Experience as a source of learning and development, Prentice Hall, New York.
  • 10. International Journal of Management (IJM), ISSN 0976 – 6502(Print), ISSN 0976 - 6510(Online), Volume 5, Issue 8, August (2014), pp. 57-66 © IAEME 66 [19] McKimm, J., Jollie, C, Hatter, M. (2007) Mentoring: Theory and Practice. London NHSE. [20] Megginson, D and Clutterbuek, D (1995). Mentoring in Action: A practical guide for leaders of international nonprofits in the United States. Nonprofit and Voluntary leaders of international nonprofits in the United States. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector leaders of international nonprofits in the United States. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector. [21] Metchell, G. E. (2012). The construct of organizational effectiveness: Perspectives from Quarterly. [22] Odiorne, G.S (1985) ‘Mentoring’ An American Management Innovation. Personnel Administrator (30): 63-65. [23] Parsloe, E Wray, M. J. (2000). Governing and Mentoring: Practical methods to improveLearning. Kogan page, New York. [24] Robert, A. (1999). ‘The origin of the term mentor’. History of Education Society Bullettin No46: 313-329. [25] Rhodes, J. E. (2005). ‘A theoretical model of youth mentoring’. In DuBois, D. L. Karcher M. J. (Eds) Handbook of youth mentoring. Thousand Oakes, CA: Sage Press. [26] Rhodes, J. E. DuBois, D. L. (2008). Mentoring relationships and programmes for youth. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 17: 254-259. [27] Richard et al (2009). Measuring Organizational Performance: Towards Methodological Best Practice. Journal of Management. [28] Schein, E.H. (1978) Career Dynamics: Matching Individual and organization needs. Addison- Wesley. [29] Schlee, R. (2000). ‘Mentoring and the professional development of students’ Journal of Management Education 24(30: 322-337. [30] (http//www.1000ventures.com/business guide/cross cuttings/coaching grow.htm/) Retrieved 20.8.2014. [31] M.Sudarsan and Ponramalingam, “Significance of the Training on Enhancing Effectiveness of Communication Skills in the IT Industry”, International Journal of Management (IJM), Volume 4, Issue 4, 2013, pp. 1 - 8, ISSN Print: 0976-6502, ISSN Online: 0976-6510. [32] Mohd.Irfan Khan, Anil Kumar Mishra and Prof.(Dr.) Y.P.Singh, “A Review: Technology Innovation and Role of Training and Education in Small and Medium Size Enterprise and it Sector”, International Journal of Management (IJM), Volume 4, Issue 3, 2013, pp. 75 - 81, ISSN Print: 0976-6502, ISSN Online: 0976-6510.