#FIRMday Manchester - 15th Oct 2015 - Helping line managers to recruit more objectively at Skanska UK
Driving diversity through objective assessment
Talent Q
10. 2015Only 57% of those surveyed in The
FIRM’s 4th Annual Membership Survey
are using psychometric ability tests in
Assessment and Selection
11. What is Personality?
“Personality is a pattern of relatively permanent traits and
unique characteristics that give both consistency and
individuality to a person's behavior.“ (Feist and Feist, 2009)
“The characteristics or blend of characteristics that make a
person unique” (Weinberg & Gould, 1999).
12. What is General Ability or Intelligence?
“““Intelligence represents an individuals ability to adapt to
their environment”
“The ability to acquire knowledge and skills”
“The ability to learn or understand or to deal with new or
trying situations”
“The ability to apply knowledge to manipulate one's
environment or to think abstractly as measured by
objective criteria”
13. 0
0.1
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
1Certain prediction
Assessment centers
Skilful and structured interviews
Ability tests
Work sampling
Graphology, astrology
Personality assessment
Assessment centers for job performance
Unstructured interviews
References
Predictive validity of different selection methods
Predictive validity is the link between
results or scores on a selection method
and a subsequent outcome – most
commonly job performance at a future
point
Different selection methods can be
combined in order to get a higher
validity
Source: Pilbeam and Colbridge (2006) summary of the predictive validity
of selection methods based on the findings of various research studies
Why are personality and intellect important?
15. Accelerated growth with tighter budgets
15
The challenge: How to achieve the business objectives
with limited assessment resources?
16. The cost of getting recruitment wrong
• One conservative estimate is that “bad” recruitment will cost
Skanska circa £10,000,000 in two years – including direct cost
only, excluding lost opportunities, management time etc.
• Psychometrics that identify those candidates most likely to
perform well in the workplace dramatically reduce the chance of
making a selection error.
17. The challenge in recruiting STEM candidates
• We are all fighting over the same, small candidate pool
• Need to look beyond academic qualification alone
• Widen the diversity of candidates
• More innovative in how we source and assess candidates
• Extend the assessment criteria to include potential
19. The requirements…….
Limited
assessment
resource
Transient and busy
resourcing team
Limited line
manager knowledge
Different businesses
with their own cultures
and challenges
Restrictions from Skanska AB
Low margin
Works and provides
consistency across all
business units
Is affordable
Is easy to administer
with limited training
Empowered
line managers
to make better
decisions
Provide user
friendly, jargon- free
reports for line
managers
Psychometric data aligned to our
Leadership competencies
20. The requirements…….
Limited
assessment
resource
Transient and busy
resourcing team
Limited line
manager knowledge
Different businesses
with their own cultures
and challenges
Restrictions from Skanska AB
Low margin
Works and provides
consistency across all
business units
Is affordable
Is easy to administer
with limited training
Empowered
line managers
to make better
decisions
Provide user
friendly, jargon- free
reports for line
managers
Psychometric data aligned to our
Leadership competencies
Pragmatic
22. Pragmatic Approach Required
• A solution that utilises sifting stages to minimise resource, save time.
• A solution that minimises our likelihood of getting decisions “wrong”
• A solution we can also use for development
• A solution we can use for on boarding and induction
• A solution which will aid our drive to being a leader in diversity
23. Talent Q assessments that were selected
Elements
Measures: verbal, numerical
and logical reasoning
Why?
Sifting tool
Adaptive
Quick to complete
Dimensions
Assesses key behaviours at
work
Why?
Mapped with Skanska
Leadership framework
Easy to understand reports
Additional report options
Available in 44 languages
24. Adherence to Skanska AB
• Leadership Profile mapped
against Dimensions
• The language is familiar
• One report supports four
leader role types
• One assessment for all
Operating Units
• Identifying competencies
critical to Skanska Sweden
28. For line managers
Workshops and encouragement
• Introduction to
psychometrics
• Rationale of using the
assessments
• Getting the best out of the
customised report
For the Resourcing Team
• Psychometric training
where required
• Completion of the
assessments
• System customised for
ease of use
30. Feedback so far…….
“This is the best that Skanska is doing globally”
“Assessment has started conversations”
“I now know what I am looking for when
recruiting
“I am now seen as a real strategic partner”
31. This is just the first step
• This solution will continue to be improved and developed
• Integration with Taleo to provide seamless candidate experience
and reduce resource effort further
• Desire to develop further reports aligned to the Graduate and
line manager frameworks
• Plans to develop on-boarding report from Dimensions
• Feedback to date from line managers is extremely positive and
uptake is rising.
• Skanska UK are leading the company in this advancement –
potential to extend to other countries
32. How could psychometrics help me?
• Looks beyond candidates’ academic achievements
• Provides objectivity around decision-making
• Reduces the cost of hiring
• Sifting out at earlier stages
• Hiring the wrong people
• Establishes a consistency around the interview
• Provides supports to the line manager
• Customised reports
• Off the shelf role profile reports
• Help resourcing partner’s become strategic partners
rather than operational
Skanska on a global stage
In 2012 we celebrated our first 125 years globally.
Skanska was founded in Sweden by Rudolf Fredrik Berg in 1887.
Our founder had strong beliefs about what’s right and wrong and our values remain fundamental to our culture.
We believe in responsible business.
Final image in large circle is off the Oresund Bridge linking Sweden to Denmark, which Skanska built in the late 1990s.
5
Our Journey – Culture and values
Our culture is unique. It’s not perfect, but it’s a differentiator
This book describes the way we want our culture to look and feel
Defines the way we are
Honest
Transparent
Straight forward → Easy to do business with
It very much starts with big heart and that is about being a caring company
But there are many other attributes, working collaboratively, ethically and transparently. This helps us win work
Our community journey – some highlights
2007 Mencap partnership with IFE launched
2012 UKCG Open Doors event
2012 Global Corporate Community Involvement policy launched
2013 Skanska joins Business in the Community
2014 Considerate Constructors Scheme 111th award for Skanska
2014 Lend a hand volunteering programme launched
2014 Groundwork partnership launched (for community and volunteering days)
Charlotte
Short overview of TQ and Hay Group (and Try Talent Q to help people prepare).
Show of hands – who currently uses psychometric ability tests when selecting?
Charlotte
Timely to include topics from The FIRM’s 4th Annual Membership survey – shared with FIRM members on Insight Day, 14th July - where they discussed general view of HR challenges including that only 57% of those who completed survey use psychological ability tests during the assessment and selection process. Please note that the annual survey will be distributed on 15th October.
Charlotte
When we talk about personality assessments, what are we looking to measure? There are many varied views on this, but these statements seem to capture the typical view.
Dimensions, our personality assessment, assesses for individual’s typical preferences across 15 core competencies, important in many roles.
Charlotte
involves the ability to:
1. Learn. The acquisition, retention, and use of knowledge is an important component of intelligence.
2. Recognize problems. To put knowledge to use, people must first be able to identify possible problems in the environment that need to be addressed.
3. Solve problems. People must then be able to take what they have learned to come up with a useful solution to a problem they have noticed in the world around them.
Charlotte AND ALISTAIR TO FINISH
Alistair
Alistair
Alistair
Alistair
Alistair
Alistair
Charlotte
Charlotte
Outline mapping of the report at item level
Removal of number scores and introduction of colour banding – removes any interpretation required by the line manager
Clear descriptions at either end of the competency to bring the competency to life
Charlotte
Removal of scores – managers don’t need to determine what’s an acceptable score
Interview guides – drives consistency, and ensures that a good level of interviews take place across the Business units.
Alistair
Lunch and learn sessions
Resourcing team
Training – conversion and full BPS traiing
Completion of assessment to understand outputs – appreciate the value of the assessment
Customised – split by division so only access to what they needed, formatted email templates, fixed assessments set up etc.
Alistair
Alistair
Skanska AB diversity film
As mentioned in the deck, we are picking from a greatly limited pool and we are picking from a pool which is still largely white, middle class and male. Construction still has a “muddy boots” image and the shortage and competition for these people will only increase. This is a challenge if we want to be more diverse, innovative and look like our clients (SEE THE VIDEO). Therefore, I think that whilst we have started, the future will be very much in challenging providers such as Talent Q to not only help drive us to make better recruitment decisions, but also more diverse, in a world where we look beyond track record, degree, A levels etc. This bridge the potential benefit of increasing social mobility.