SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 15
Download to read offline
376 Int. J. Management in Education, Vol. 4, No. 4, 2010
Copyright © 2010 Inderscience Enterprises Ltd.
Administration and management of
undergraduate capstone projects in
joint degree technology programmes
M.K.S. Sastry*
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering,
University of the West Indies,
St. Augustine Campus,
Trinidad and Tobago
Email: mks_sastry@ieee.org
*Corresponding author
Clement K. Sankat
University of the West Indies,
St. Augustine Campus,
Trinidad and Tobago
Email: clement.sankat@sta.uwi.edu
Kamel Singh
Applied Engineering Programs,
University of Trinidad and Tobago,
Trinidad and Tobago
Email: kamel.singh@utt.edu.tt
Abstract: Managing undergraduate capstone projects is a specialised task which
depends on the nature of programmes, availability of resources, inputs and
the expected outcomes. Technology programmes are different from conventional
engineering programmes and hence the training in technology capstone
projects should be aligned with the programme objectives and expectations.
This paper describes an effective policy framework and administrative process
for managing the capstone projects in typical joint technology degree
programmes in Trinidad and Tobago. Uniqueness of technology capstone
projects and their distinct inputs and expected outcomes are illustrated.
Detailed management process, assessment criteria and the experiences gained
so far are presented. Few technology projects of these programmes under this
framework are briefly described.
Keywords: capstone projects; technology programmes; technologists; joint
degrees; engineering programmes.
Reference to this paper should be made as follows: Sastry, M.K.S., Sankat, C.K.
and Singh, K. (2010) ‘Administration and management of undergraduate
capstone projects in joint degree technology programmes’, Int. J. Management
in Education, Vol. 4, No. 4, pp.376–390.
Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 377
Biographical notes: M.K.S. Sastry is currently with the Department of
Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of the West Indies (UWI) and
also the Programme Coordinator, BTech Degree Programmes jointly offered
by UWI and University of Trinidad and Tobago (UTT). He received his
Doctoral degree in Electrical Engineering from National Institute of Technology,
India. He is a senior member of Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers
(IEEE), USA, and a member of Institution of Engineering and Technology
(IET), UK. His research interests include Engineering Education, Information
Systems, Computer Applications in Power Engineering, and Asset and Facility
Management.
Clement K. Sankat is presently Pro-Vice Chancellor and Campus Principal for
the University of West Indies, St. Augustine Campus. Prior to this, he served
UWI in different capacities including Dean, Faculty of Engineering; Head and
Professor of Department of Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering;
Chairman, Executive Management Committee for UWI–UTT Joint Degree
Programmes. His teaching and research activities have covered an extended
area of Mechanical Engineering and related domains.
Kamel Singh is a Senior Instructor and Programme Leader for the Bachelor of
Applied Technology and Bachelor of Engineering in Applied Process and
Utilities Technology Programmes at the University of Trinidad and Tobago. He
has 18 years of industrial experience in the design and construction of process
plant, pressure vessel, storage tank, pipeline, offshore production facilities,
welding engineering, quality control and maintenance management. His research
interests include modern energy systems, engineering curricula development
and machine design.
1 Introduction
Capstone project is a significant component in engineering or technology curricula
and provides an opportunity to the student in developing professional skills like
problem solving, analysis, synthesis and evaluation. Most often, the words ‘Engineer’,
‘Technologist’, ‘Engineering Programmes’, ‘Technology Programmes’ are used
synonymously. However, these words are completely different and the Institution of
Engineering and Technology (IET), UK, clearly defines these terms with respective
meaning, inputs, outputs and expectations. The underlying spirit of technology programmes
is to produce more industry-ready graduates with hands-on skills in using innovative
tools, processes and technologies, as opposed to engineers who design and simulate the
systems or processes (Sastry et al., 2007). Hence, technology training is reinforced by
‘hands-on’ laboratory training and real world exposure to the utility engineering/industry
environment, through internships. Technology programmes have different structures,
standards and outcomes than the conventional engineering degree programmes and
produce ‘Incorporated Engineers’. Currently, there are several technology programmes
around the world which produce ‘Technologists’. The discussion in this paper focuses on
the administrative aspects of capstone projects in technology programmes offered jointly
by the University of the West Indies (UWI) and the University of Trinidad and Tobago
(UTT). These programmes are unique with distinct features to serve the needs of local
378 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh
industries and utilities (Sastry et al., 2008) and essentially offered on part-time basis in
the evening. Further, about 95% of the students are full-time employees of local
industries and utilities. Capstone projects in these programmes are differently administrated
and managed to meet the programme expectations and global quality standards.
From the literature it is clear that engineering faculties across the globe have
experimented with capstone projects in several ways to achieve better throughput, to
maintain the quality standards and to improve the existing knowledge base. These
experiments included changing the duration of projects, group and individual projects,
assessment strategies and colloboration with industry. Few authors reported that couple
of cycles of expereinces were required to perfect the administrative framework governing
the capstone (Armstrong et al., 2006; Bachnak, 2006; Morales, 2006). During the early
1990s, few universities offered this course as a combination of classroom teaching and a
hands-on design labotorary training (Fabiano, 1992) over one, final semester. However,
administration and management of capstone projects in engineering programmes has
changed considerably since then. New strategies in the assessment process to normalise
the capstone grades and to minimise the differences among the examiners and the
experiences have been presented by Teo and Ho (1998). Incorportation of necessary
courses and training programmes to prepare students to take up challenging capstone
projects is preferred by some univeristies (Bhurtum et al., 1999). Universities have set
up industry-based projects to provide real-world exposure and training to the students
(Gol et al., 2001; Ray, 2003; Wang and Pai, 2006). However, Morales (2006) reported on
attempts to minimise the role of industry inputs on the basis of student feedback expressing
the lesser availability of industry personnel to interact with the students. Difficulties of
administering the capstone projects to meet the accreditation standards are also presented
by Hudson and Harding (2002) and Campbell and Sobel (2003). In summary, administration
and management of capstone projects is a specialised task which depends on nature
of programme, availability of resources and expected outcomes. However, not much
information is available on the capstone technology projects in case of degrees offered
jointly by two different univerisites. In this paper, an attempt is made to explain the
administrative and management framework goverining these unique capstone technology
projects. This paper is organised as follows. Section 2 explains a brief background of the
programmes. Section 3 provides the methodology in defining the policy framework for
the capstone projects. Section 4 explains the administrative framework, inputs, expected
outcomes and assessment criteria. The unique aspects of capstone projects are presented
in Section 5. Overall management process is presented in Section 6. Section 7 illustrates
our experiences so far, throughput analysis of student performance, student reaction and
industry perspective.
2 Background of UWI–UTT joint degrees
The UWI is a regional university which serves the 15 English-speaking countries of the
Caribbean region and which was established nearly 60 years ago. The UTT has been
established in the year 2004 and partnered with the UWI through a Memorandum of
Understanding (MOU) to offer two undergraduate degrees, viz. the Bachelor of Applied
Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 379
Technology Degrees (BTech) in Mechanical and Electrical Engineering. The primary
outputs of these two degrees are technologists (also known as Incorporated Engineers)
for the local industrial and service sectors. These programmes are being governed by a
Joint Management Executive Committee (JMEC) in which senior fauclty members of
both institutions are members (Sastry et al., 2007). The Institution of Engineering and
Technology (the IET), UK, has accredited these programmes after a succesful visit in the
year 2007. According to standards of the IET,
The Incorporated Engineers are characterized by their ability to act as
exponents of today’s technology through creativity and innovation (EC-UK,
2003). To this end, they maintain and manage applications of current and
developing technology, and may undertake engineering design, development,
manufacture, construction and operation. Incorporated Engineers are variously
engaged in technical and commercial management and also possess effective
interpersonal skills.
3 Methodology for creation of policy framework
Unfortunately, not much information is available in the literature about the policies and
processes governing technology projects to help JMEC in the initial planning. This task
is challenging in a sense that mostly technologies are imported, but managed locally in
Trinidad and Tobago, which has a vibrant energy industry sector. The senior members
of JMEC engaged themselves in series of brain storming sessions on different occassions,
discussed on the needs of the local industries, international accreditation statndards
and overall expectations of the technology programmes. As a result of their efforts,
a well-defined administrative policy framework for producing high-quality projects is
devised. This policy framework ensures that the technology projects in these programmes
provide much required hands-on and high skills training to the students. This policy is
then translated administrative process.
4 Administrative process
The JMEC has laid out a well-defined adminstrative process in terms of types of projects
that can be taken up, availability of resources, expected outcomes, assessment criteria
and the related rules and regulations. Each student of these programmes has to register
for the course titled ‘Integrated Project in Industry’ after having completed all the courses
in the programme successfully. The duration of the capstone project is two semesters,
13 weeks each with a total weighting of six credits. Capstone project is completely
different from the rest of courses in the programme and does not follow the usual
protocol of regular instruction, course work and examinations, etc. Further, technology
projects are closely coupled to local industry processes and practices to provide a complete
work-related experience in the real world. Student is responsible for project selection,
supervisor selection, and conduct and progress of the work. Obviously, this requires a
considerable shift in the attitude of the student, and management skills in realising the set
objectives of the chosen project within the specified time frame. The various aspects of
administrative framework are discussed briefly in the following sections.
380 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh
4.1 Types of projects
Capstone projects can be of different types based on the area of engineering specialisation,
student’s background and interests of the industries and local utilities. Keeping the
overall outcomes of the technology programmes and the standards, the technology
projects are broadly classified into four categories which are summarised hereafter.
• Problem identification and solving: The projects under this category can be an
existing major problem in an industry or a utility, or a time consuming task in a
complex process. This type of projects require modelling of the plant/system and
rigorous analysis of the problem and the student’s own approach or strategy to solve
the same using a feasible and cost effective solution.
• Design and build: Design of complex engineering systems based on standard
specifications and benchmarks. A fully functional working prototype must be
designed and built based on custom specifications. Design validation and extensive
analysis must be undertaken. The same must be tested and demonstrated during the
examinations.
• Implementation (or re-engineering): Development of a working prototype based on
an existing methodology/standard technique, such as new electronic circuits, working
tools or machines. Under this category, a working prototype must be built based
on available designs and standard specifications. The same must be tested and
demonstrated during the examinations.
• Software simulation: Development of software for engineering applications through
standard software process and using any approved technologies must be developed
to solve specific problem. The developed software must be tested thoroughly and
demonstrated during the examinations.
Students enjoy freedom to choose any type of project. An interactive orientation session
will be held by the programme coordinator to help students to understand the overall
governing process for this course. During this orientation, students are advised to identify
problems in their own work places, local industries or even from the literature. Each
student is expected to define the problem and formulate the objectives, scope and
expected deliverables.
4.2 Inputs and expected outcomes
Though there is no formal teaching or training to the students, during the two semester
period, they are provided with wide range of inputs throughout the programme and even
during to meet the standard expectations. These inputs and resources are provided to the
students to inculcate the notion of design, analysis and awareness of interdisciplinary
nature of engineering practice. The various inputs and outcomes are outlined below as
well as in Figure 1.
Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 381
4.2.1 Academic inputs
Students of these joint degree programmes receive training in wide ranging courses
in ‘Core Engineering’, ‘Technology Management’, ‘Basic Sciences and Mathematics’,
‘Languages and Humanities’ (Sastry et al., 2008). These courses impart a variety of
skills, knowledge and hands-on experience to the students, thus making them ready to
face the likely challenges during the capstone project. The UTT has developed good
relations with several senior industry personnel and engaged them in as part-time
instructors to teach technology courses in the same programmes.
Figure 1 Inputs and expected outcomes of technology capstone projects
Final Year Individual,
Capstone Project
Conceive
Design
Develop
Test
Analyse
Employer/Ind
ustry Support
Academic
Inputs
through
Courses:
Core
Engineering,
Technology
Management,
Maths and
Science,
Languages
and
Humanities
Technical
guidance from
Supervisor
Overall Progress
monitoring by
panel of examiners
Guidance on technical report writing, Laboratory
and Library Facilities
Expected Outcomes
Fully working system
Functional prototype
A new Strategy/
Methodology
This strategy provided students an opportunity to develop close relations with the senior
engineers directly in the classroom who can help them in problem identification and
formulation of the projects. This nature of classroom interactions can pave the way
forward for effective cross-industry partnership, technology and knowledge transfer to
identify the solutions to the existing or known technological problems.
4.2.2 Technical guidance from supervisor
Most of the students are employed in local industries and utilities. About 95% of the
students formulate their capstone projects based on the problems or the topics which are
of interest to their respective employers. Students can identify the project supervisors
382 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh
from their work place or from the university faculty. If a student is not able to identify an
appropriate supervisor, then the UTT will circulate the proposal and then identify one for
that project. Students consult their project supervisor for necessary guidance periodically.
Supervisors work with the student very closely, make necessary visits to the project sites
to understand, analyse and then help the student. In most cases, it will be a learning
experience for the supervisors too. This approach provided the much needed interaction
between university teaching staff and the industry.
4.2.3 Employer/industry support
The support from the employer is vital to the student in carrying out the project
successfully. Usually employers provide necessary permissions and approvals to use their
equipment and resources due to the fact that some of their long pending problems are
likely to be solved through their own employees. It is also interesting to note that
employers are very happy to see that their staff, who are students of the technology
programmes, engaged in technologically challenging projects (Ugas and Sastry, 2009)
and progressing well in terms of professional development. Some industries funded and
closely monitored the progress of the projects to ensure the expected results and derive
benefits (Dial et al., 2008; Roberts et al., 2009).
4.2.4 Infrastructural facilities of the universities
As the BTech degrees are jointly offered by the UWI and the UTT, the students have
access to the libraries, simulators, laboratories and workshops of both the universities and
this has helped the students in understanding the concepts, experimentation process and
analysing information related to their projects. In addition, the UTT has devised a student
friendly purchase procedures for equipment procurement, which is a great challenge,
given the fact that Trinidad and Tobago is an island country and most of the equipment
need to be procured from the USA or UK. Despite such challenges, a wide range of
instruments, equipment and other apparatus have been purchased without losing the time.
Two faculty members from the languages department of the UTT trained the students in
technical report writing and also assisted them in proof reading their reports.
4.2.5 Overall monitoring and assessment
Students meet the project supervisors regularly to seek consultation. The respective
engineering departments at the UWI appoint a panel of examiners to assess the student
performance. The panel makes the necessary field visits, before commencement of the
project and after completion of the project. Through these field visits, the panel can
examine the student closely from project commencement to the completion. Normally,
the panel suggests the suitable solutions to the likely and potential challenges in the
project as well as their expectations during the site visits. In addition to this, at the end of
first semester, students have to present their progress reports to the same panel of
examiners and this examination has a weighting of 20% of final grade. During this
examination, students present the progress made thus far and what needs to be done in
the coming semester. Panel carefully analyses the progress of the student and provides a
Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 383
cursory feedback and its views on the student performance. In summary, site visits,
support from supervisor and progress report presentation, help students to check their
own progress as well as making necessary changes in time, if necessary.
4.2.6 Expected outcomes
At the end of the two semesters, every capstone project should ideally result in any one
of the three outcomes (a) fully working system, (b) functional prototype and (c) a new
strategy/methodology to improve an existing process. In addition to this, students are
expected to submit a thesis on their work. The students will gain the unique experience of
solving technical problems, within demanding work-time schedules, using available
resources. With this experience, they will be able to address real-world problems and
new technological challenges in an effective manner.
4.2.7 Assessment mechanism
Assessment is done by a panel consisting of project supervisor and two additional
examiners drawn from both universities. Each student is examined in three major areas
(a) technical report writing skills (b) oral presentation and communication skills and
(c) professional conduct and progression during the project execution. Table 1 illustrates
various assessment components that are used to examine the student skills and the quality
of work done in completing the project.
Table 1 Assessment components with weightings for evaluation of capstone projects
Assessment component Percentage weighting
1 Technical report writing skills
Presentation quality 10
Technical content 30
Research 20
2 Oral presentation and communication skills
Presentation quality 10
Delivery 10
Defence 10
3 Professional conduct and progression 10
Total 100
5 Distinction of technology capstone projects in joint degree programmes
As can be seen from Section 4, the technology capstones projects are distinctly different
from the conventional engineering capstone projects at the UWI with typical sets of
inputs and outcomes. Table 2 summarises the similarities and differences between the
technology and engineering capstone projects.
384 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh
Table 2 Comparison between technology and engineering projects
Technology capstone projects
Traditional engineering capstone
projects at the UWI
Students identify their own problem and
develop the project proposal with objectives
and expected deliverables
Teaching staff conceive the projects and
make the ready-made proposals available
to students
About 95% of the technology capstone projects
are based on the real-world problems in
industries or utilities where the student is
working
Less than 5% of engineering projects are
carried out in local industries and utilities,
as the students are with the university on
full-time basis
Students use propriety technologies, tools and
software systems to analyse, design and
develop the systems during their project work
More than 95% of engineering projects
involve developing new tools, algorithms,
software applications, simulation and
in-depth analysis of complex systems, etc.
Research is not a significant component of
technology projects. As the problems are
unique and specific to the local industries and
utilities, it is very difficult to find the
previously published articles. Students are
expected to carry out in-depth analysis and
develop a feasible solution
Research is a significant component of
engineering projects and students are
expected to undertake an in-depth literature
survey on the chosen problem and compare
their results with international benchmarks
which may be available in the refereed
journals
Final outcomes of the technology projects
include a fully working system or a prototype
system or an effective strategy to improve or
maintain an existing process
Final outcomes of engineering projects
include new processes, systems or algorithms
to solve complex problems or software
applications
Project duration is two semesters Project duration is two semesters
6 Overall management process
The administrative framework is translated into a systematic management process, which
is used by the teaching faculty and administrative staff for the management of student
projects. Eligible students register for their capstone projects at the start of the semester,
just as they register for other courses. During the registration week, the UTT organises
orientation classes to explain about the procedures, expectations, deadlines, resources and
previous experiences of students as well as those of supervisors. Students are required to
identify a topic or a work-related problem on their own and then submit a project
proposal in the prescribed format within the first week. The proposal consists of title,
problem statement, objectives and scope, a brief introduction of the problem, background
expected end deliverables, tools and technologies that will be used, resources needed
from universities, etc. The senior faculty from respective engineering departments at the
UWI will review the proposals according to the expected standards and approve them
based on their merit, subjected to modifications.
After securing the approval for the project, student arranges a site visit to explain the
problem to the UWI examiners and programme coordinators. During this site visit, the
panel will identify the technical challenges involved and give suggestions that can help
student to solve the same. A supervisor will be identified either from industry or from the
UTT to monitor the progress of the student. The first semester is called Phase 1 and the
second semester as Phase 2. Student will be coordinating activities like problem analysis,
Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 385
resource identification, equipment procurement, solution formulation and design, etc. in
the Phase 1. At the end of the first semester a progress report is required to be submitted
and all the Phase 1 students will be examined for the progress made thus far and for their
action plan for the Phase 2. Examination panel provides necessary inputs, suggestions
and recommendations to the students to encourage them towards successful completion
of their projects. Students who could not make enough progress can opt to withdraw from
the project and restart. However, they need to identify a new problem and a new
supervisor different from the past project, in order to keep the uniform challenges to all
the students.
During the Phase 2, students undertake building the prototypes, cost benefit analysis,
testing and comparison, final report writing, etc. Students meet their respective supervisors
periodically and note the proceedings of the meetings in a project log book, issued by the
BTech department. Upon completion of the project, student arranges another site visit to
demonstrate the outcome of the project to the examiners. The overall process and the
intermediate activities are illustrated in Figure 2.
Figure 2 Overall process of capstone projects with intermediate activities
Project Registration/
Preliminary Orientation
Review of the Project Proposal by UWI Senior
Faculty and appointment of UWI Examiners
Site visit and inspection by UWI Examiners
Identify suitable project supervisors from UTT
and from Industry . Student starts working on
the approved project
Progress Report Presentation - Phase 1
Examination at the end of First Semester
Final Project Presentation - Phase 2
Examination at the end of Second Semester
Final Project Submission and Demonstration of
Working Prototype
Site visit and inspection by UWI Examiners to
check the completed project in working
condition
Identify the Overall features and requirements ,
Formulate solution Strategy , Design the
solution/ Prototype/ Design Validation
Implementation of Design, Development and
construction of a working prototype or actual
system
First
Semester
(Phase
1)
13
Weeks
Student decides to
drop out
Second
Semester
(Phase
2)
13
weeks
Is Student successful
in final Project
Examination?
Prepare the student file for
Graduation
No
Yes
No
Yes
START
Proposal Preparation and Preliminary Review /
Appointment of UTT Project Supervisor
7 Results and experiences
Till date, 123 students (Electrical Engineering: 57 and Mechanical Engineering: 66) have
completed their capstone projects. The student success and failure rate are 95% and 5%
in the first attempt. The detailed distribution of the final grades and the student numbers
is shown in Figure 3. Trends of student success and failure rates indicate that the existing
administrative processes and management strategies yielded good and healthy results.
386 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh
Faculty members and supervisors encouraged students to publish their works in refereed
international conferences and journals. Few students have responded and started working
with faculty members to contribute to the local, regional conferences and journals. This
engulfed the enthusiasm in other students and now more students who are very successful
in their projects are working actively on publishing their works (Sangster et al., 2007;
Dial et al., 2008; Mangal et al., 2008; Ramsingh and Sastry, 2009; Roberts et al., 2009;
Ugas and Sastry, 2009). Though students face some level of stress in the first few weeks
of project, at the end, they are proud of their achievements. Some students have been able
to gain better employment based on the project experience. Industries and utilities
are keen to study the technology projects undertaken in their premises for possible
implementation. Few projects have been adopted by the respective industries already.
Some students have received positive encouragement to implement their findings on a
pilot basis or to submit a deployment feasibility report. In some cases, employers have
restrained the students from disclosing the vital design aspects and other key information
related to their internal processes. Interestingly, all students in such cases were promoted
to higher positions.
Figure 3 Throughput analysis of capstone projects in UWI-UTT BTech programmes
This positive response from local industries and utilities indicates the applicability of the
end deliverables, overall effectiveness of the technology programmes and the training
involved and the success of administrative framework of the capstone projects. To
provide a general understanding, details of few selected technology projects completed
so far are presented in Table 3.
To compliment the above policy framework, the faculty of Engineering at the UWI
organises ‘Engineering Management Final-Year Students’ Project Competition’ to
recognise the best student projects and this competition is open to all engineering
programmes in both the UWI and the UTT. Some of the students in the technology
programme have participated and successful in achieving the awards.
Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 387
Table 3 Description of selected technology capstone projects
Project title, name
of the company Brief description
A Novel Control Strategy
for an Ammonia Marine
Loading Arm – YARA,
Trinidad
Using a state of art, industry standard monitoring and control
equipment, an operator friendly, real-time visual interface is
developed to display overall operating process. This approach
reduces the overall operating cost and improves safety standards
during product loading (Ugas and Sastry, 2009).
A New, Locally
Engineered Hydro Test
Bench for testing the Gate
Valves – United
Engineering Services
Limited, Trinidad
A new hydraulically operated test bench has been designed, built
and tested successfully. This equipment is found to be having
higher overall testing efficiency in testing and maintenance of
gate valves. Presently, this equipment is adopted by the company
for regular use (Dial et al., 2008).
Design, Construction and
Testing of an Automatic
Bottle Cap Feed Hopper
System – National
Petroleum Co Ltd.,
Trinidad
This is an automation solution to a manual process of filling the
cap sorter bin with caps and eliminated the need of an attendant
having to do it and eliminate any unnecessary line stoppage due
to low cap level in the cap sorter bin. This has been successfully
incorporated into process line of the company. The hopper
system, with the conveyer carrying the caps in the bottle filling
process line is shown in Figure 4.
Wireless Control for
Function Testing
Automatic Spreader Bars –
Point Lisas Industrial Port
Development Corporation
(PLIPDECO), Trinidad
A real time wireless control mechanism, using Bluetooth
technology has been designed, tested and integrated with a
newly engineered test kit to control a BROMMA EH5 spreader
bar. This has replaced the conventional, manual system and the
associated processes. The operators are now provided with a
friendly computer interface to operate the spreader bars in real
time. The real-time interface is shown in Figure 5.
Figure 4 Automatic Bottle Cap Feed Hopper System designed and built at NPC, Ltd.
(see online version for colours)
388 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh
Figure 5 A real-time operator interface to control the spreader bars at the PLIPDECO
(see online version for colours)
8 Scope for further research
From the above sections, it is clear that the joint technology programmes in Trinidad and
Tobago have typical arrangements governing the technology projects. These arrangements
have been established based on the MOU, working relations of the partnering
universities, international standards, and local industry and utility requirements. The
approach suggested in this paper can be adopted in any technology programme with
similar inputs and outputs. However, further research should be carried out to study the
global practices and trends in this area as it is the capstone project really, in which the
student takes up a technologically challenging professional responsibility without
any formal teaching. Additionally, work needs to be carried out to clearly define the
standards and terms of reference for technology capstone projects. Such benchmarks can
be used by various professional engineering and technology institutions (such as IET)
around the world for accreditation and professional registration purposes.
9 Conclusion
Technology capstone projects are quite different from conventional engineering projects.
Administration of such projects in joint degree programmes requires a well-defined
policy framework and administrative process due to their uniqueness and distinct inputs
Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 389
and outputs. It can be seen that the implementation of these policies, supplemented with a
continuous monitoring of student progress has yielded successful results. As seen from
the discussion on few sample projects and the industry perspective, it can be observed
that the framework presented in this paper has helped the partnering universities in
the successful completion of the programmes and also helped the students to earn
professional respect from their employers. This experience can be replicated or adopted
in any technology programmes with necessary adjustments as required.
References
Armstrong, P., Kee, R., Kenny, R. and Cunningham, G. (2006) ‘The development of a capstone
project course based on CDIO principles’, World Transactions on Engineering and
Technology Education, Vol. 5, No. 2, pp.229–302.
Bachnak, R. (2006) ‘An approach for successful capstone projects’, 35th ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in
Education Conference, pp.F4D18–F4D22.
Bhurtum, C., Jahmeerbacus, I., Oolum, K. and Feliachi, A. (1999, May) ‘Short-term practical
training for electrical engineering undergraduates’, IEEE Transactions on Engineering
Education, Vol. 42, No. 2, pp.109–113.
Campbell, S. and Sobel, A. (2003) ‘Hard lessons learned using hardware-oriented capstone
projects’, 33rd ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference, pp.F4C7–F4C12.
Dial, R., Singh, K., Ali, R. and Sastry, M.K.S. (2008) ‘A new, locally engineered hydro test bench
for testing the gate valves’, 16th Biennial CAS Conference, 11–13 October, Grenada,
pp.134–138.
EC-UK (2003) ‘Chartered Engineer and Incorporated Engineer Standard’, UK Standard for
Professional Engineering Competence, Engineering Council, UK.
Fabiano, P. (1992) ‘Concurrent approaches in engineering technology capstone projects’,
IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference, pp.821–824.
Gol, O., Nafalski, A. and McDermott, K. (2001) ‘The role of industry-inspired projects in
engineering education’, 31st ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference, pp.F3E1–F3E4.
Hudson, C. and Harding, P. (2002) ‘Improving project work on degree courses’, IEE 2nd Annual
Symposium on Engineering Education (Ref. No. 2002/056), 3–4 January, Vol. 1, No. 56,
pp.17/1–17/6.
Mangal, D., Singh, K. and Sastry, M.K.S. (2008) ‘Design and development of a novel Cathode Ray
Tube (CRT) crusher’, 16th Biennial CAS Conference, 11–13 October, Grenada, pp.103–107.
Morales, C.J. (2006) ‘A capstone triumvirate of courses to satisfy ABET’s major design experience
requirements’, 9th International Conference on Engineering Education, pp.T1H19–T1H24.
Ramsingh, S. and Sastry, M.K.S. (2009) ‘Effective asset management to improve the satisfaction
of mobile telephone customers’, International Conference on Technology Innovation and
Industrial Management (TIIM), 18–20 June, Bangkok.
Ray, L.J. (2003) ‘Industry-academic partnerships for successful capstone projects’,
33rd ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference, pp.S2B24–S2B29.
Roberts, K., Kupid, K., Singh, K. and Sastry, M.K.S. (2009) ‘Novel, locally engineered crude
asphalt crusher’, Latin American and Caribbean Conference for Engineering and Technology
(LACCET’2009), 1–5 June, San Cristobal, Venezuela.
Sangster, N., Persad, P. and Ramoutar, S. (2007) ‘Fuzzy logic for traffic light control at an
overpass’, 23rd ISPE International Conference on CAD/CAM Robotics & Factories of the
Future, 16–18 August, Bogotá, pp.356–361.
390 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh
Sastry, M.K.S, Sankat, C.K., Exall, D., Srivastava, K.D., Khan, H., Copeland, B., Lewis, W. and
Bhajan, D. (2007, April) ‘An appraisal of tertiary level institutional collaboration and joint
degree programs in Trinidad and Tobago’, Latin American and Caribbean Journal of
Engineering Education, Vol. l, No. 1, pp.27–34.
Sastry, M.K.S., Sankat, C.K., Khan, H. and Bhajan, D. (2008) ‘The need for technologists and
applied technology programmes: an experience from Trinidad and Tobago’, International
Journal of Management in Education, Vol. 2, No. 2, pp.222–233.
Teo, C.Y. and Ho, D.J. (1998, February) ‘A systematic approach to the implementation of final
year project in an electrical engineering undergraduate course’, IEEE Transactions on
Education, Vol. 41, No. 1, pp.25–30.
Ugas, N. and Sastry, M.K.S. (2009) ‘A novel control strategy for an ammonia marine loading arm’,
Journal of the Association of Professional Engineers of Trinidad and Tobago.
Wang, S.L. and Pai, D. (2006) ‘Engaging stakeholders in the assessment of ABET outcomes
in a capstone design course’, 9th International Conference on Engineering Education,
pp.T4A10–T4A13.

More Related Content

Similar to Administration And Management Of Undergraduate Capstone Projects In Joint Degree Technology Programmes

4.39 te-electronics-engg
4.39 te-electronics-engg4.39 te-electronics-engg
4.39 te-electronics-enggAmit Khowala
 
Galgotias University Admission Brochure 2013-14
Galgotias University Admission Brochure 2013-14Galgotias University Admission Brochure 2013-14
Galgotias University Admission Brochure 2013-14Kiran Verma
 
Thapar university btech admission 2018
Thapar university  btech admission 2018Thapar university  btech admission 2018
Thapar university btech admission 2018Deepika Sharma
 
Examining the Preparedness of Water Program Graduates in Egypt: Industries Pe...
Examining the Preparedness of Water Program Graduates in Egypt: Industries Pe...Examining the Preparedness of Water Program Graduates in Egypt: Industries Pe...
Examining the Preparedness of Water Program Graduates in Egypt: Industries Pe...IIJSRJournal
 
FT-CEPT-Open-House 26-04-2014
FT-CEPT-Open-House 26-04-2014FT-CEPT-Open-House 26-04-2014
FT-CEPT-Open-House 26-04-2014CEPT University
 
Relationship between Technical Skills Acquired and Skills Required on Electri...
Relationship between Technical Skills Acquired and Skills Required on Electri...Relationship between Technical Skills Acquired and Skills Required on Electri...
Relationship between Technical Skills Acquired and Skills Required on Electri...Dr. Amarjeet Singh
 
An appraisal of technical skills possessed by technical college auto mechanic...
An appraisal of technical skills possessed by technical college auto mechanic...An appraisal of technical skills possessed by technical college auto mechanic...
An appraisal of technical skills possessed by technical college auto mechanic...Alexander Decker
 
NITG-placement brochure 2016-17
NITG-placement brochure 2016-17NITG-placement brochure 2016-17
NITG-placement brochure 2016-17Akash Kotha
 
Svu 2020 ty syllabus
Svu 2020 ty syllabusSvu 2020 ty syllabus
Svu 2020 ty syllabusShivangiRuparel1
 
B tech-mechanical second-third-yr-13.5.2019-1(1)
B tech-mechanical second-third-yr-13.5.2019-1(1)B tech-mechanical second-third-yr-13.5.2019-1(1)
B tech-mechanical second-third-yr-13.5.2019-1(1)Nikhil Pai
 
2013 Admission Instructions
2013 Admission Instructions2013 Admission Instructions
2013 Admission InstructionsEmil Mazan
 
Rit dubai bachelor mechanical engeering
Rit dubai bachelor mechanical engeeringRit dubai bachelor mechanical engeering
Rit dubai bachelor mechanical engeeringRit Dubai
 
Private Engineering Colleges in Gurgaon
Private Engineering Colleges in GurgaonPrivate Engineering Colleges in Gurgaon
Private Engineering Colleges in GurgaonDronacharya
 
50140-002-pam-en.pdf
50140-002-pam-en.pdf50140-002-pam-en.pdf
50140-002-pam-en.pdfhasan275936
 
information-technology-engineering-syllabus-sem-v-mumbai-university.pdf
information-technology-engineering-syllabus-sem-v-mumbai-university.pdfinformation-technology-engineering-syllabus-sem-v-mumbai-university.pdf
information-technology-engineering-syllabus-sem-v-mumbai-university.pdfVirajKale9
 
FDP_ Aero@TKMCE - Final (2) (1)-converted word.pdf
FDP_ Aero@TKMCE - Final (2) (1)-converted word.pdfFDP_ Aero@TKMCE - Final (2) (1)-converted word.pdf
FDP_ Aero@TKMCE - Final (2) (1)-converted word.pdfRebyRoy2
 
ENIT introduction
ENIT introductionENIT introduction
ENIT introductionOlivier RABY
 

Similar to Administration And Management Of Undergraduate Capstone Projects In Joint Degree Technology Programmes (20)

Electrical depy.ppt
Electrical depy.pptElectrical depy.ppt
Electrical depy.ppt
 
4.39 te-electronics-engg
4.39 te-electronics-engg4.39 te-electronics-engg
4.39 te-electronics-engg
 
Galgotias University Admission Brochure 2013-14
Galgotias University Admission Brochure 2013-14Galgotias University Admission Brochure 2013-14
Galgotias University Admission Brochure 2013-14
 
Thapar university btech admission 2018
Thapar university  btech admission 2018Thapar university  btech admission 2018
Thapar university btech admission 2018
 
Examining the Preparedness of Water Program Graduates in Egypt: Industries Pe...
Examining the Preparedness of Water Program Graduates in Egypt: Industries Pe...Examining the Preparedness of Water Program Graduates in Egypt: Industries Pe...
Examining the Preparedness of Water Program Graduates in Egypt: Industries Pe...
 
FT-CEPT-Open-House 26-04-2014
FT-CEPT-Open-House 26-04-2014FT-CEPT-Open-House 26-04-2014
FT-CEPT-Open-House 26-04-2014
 
Relationship between Technical Skills Acquired and Skills Required on Electri...
Relationship between Technical Skills Acquired and Skills Required on Electri...Relationship between Technical Skills Acquired and Skills Required on Electri...
Relationship between Technical Skills Acquired and Skills Required on Electri...
 
An appraisal of technical skills possessed by technical college auto mechanic...
An appraisal of technical skills possessed by technical college auto mechanic...An appraisal of technical skills possessed by technical college auto mechanic...
An appraisal of technical skills possessed by technical college auto mechanic...
 
NITG-placement brochure 2016-17
NITG-placement brochure 2016-17NITG-placement brochure 2016-17
NITG-placement brochure 2016-17
 
Svu 2020 ty syllabus
Svu 2020 ty syllabusSvu 2020 ty syllabus
Svu 2020 ty syllabus
 
B tech-mechanical second-third-yr-13.5.2019-1(1)
B tech-mechanical second-third-yr-13.5.2019-1(1)B tech-mechanical second-third-yr-13.5.2019-1(1)
B tech-mechanical second-third-yr-13.5.2019-1(1)
 
2013 Admission Instructions
2013 Admission Instructions2013 Admission Instructions
2013 Admission Instructions
 
Best Engineering Colleges in Ghatkesar, Hyderabad, Telangana.
Best Engineering Colleges in Ghatkesar, Hyderabad, Telangana.Best Engineering Colleges in Ghatkesar, Hyderabad, Telangana.
Best Engineering Colleges in Ghatkesar, Hyderabad, Telangana.
 
Rit dubai bachelor mechanical engeering
Rit dubai bachelor mechanical engeeringRit dubai bachelor mechanical engeering
Rit dubai bachelor mechanical engeering
 
Private Engineering Colleges in Gurgaon
Private Engineering Colleges in GurgaonPrivate Engineering Colleges in Gurgaon
Private Engineering Colleges in Gurgaon
 
50140-002-pam-en.pdf
50140-002-pam-en.pdf50140-002-pam-en.pdf
50140-002-pam-en.pdf
 
information-technology-engineering-syllabus-sem-v-mumbai-university.pdf
information-technology-engineering-syllabus-sem-v-mumbai-university.pdfinformation-technology-engineering-syllabus-sem-v-mumbai-university.pdf
information-technology-engineering-syllabus-sem-v-mumbai-university.pdf
 
Engineering College Admissions 2020 - RRCE Bangalore
Engineering College Admissions 2020 - RRCE BangaloreEngineering College Admissions 2020 - RRCE Bangalore
Engineering College Admissions 2020 - RRCE Bangalore
 
FDP_ Aero@TKMCE - Final (2) (1)-converted word.pdf
FDP_ Aero@TKMCE - Final (2) (1)-converted word.pdfFDP_ Aero@TKMCE - Final (2) (1)-converted word.pdf
FDP_ Aero@TKMCE - Final (2) (1)-converted word.pdf
 
ENIT introduction
ENIT introductionENIT introduction
ENIT introduction
 

More from Nat Rice

Entering College Essay. Top 10 Tips For College Admiss
Entering College Essay. Top 10 Tips For College AdmissEntering College Essay. Top 10 Tips For College Admiss
Entering College Essay. Top 10 Tips For College AdmissNat Rice
 
006 Essay Example First Paragraph In An Thatsno
006 Essay Example First Paragraph In An Thatsno006 Essay Example First Paragraph In An Thatsno
006 Essay Example First Paragraph In An ThatsnoNat Rice
 
PPT - Urgent Essay Writing Help PowerPoint Presentation, Free Dow
PPT - Urgent Essay Writing Help PowerPoint Presentation, Free DowPPT - Urgent Essay Writing Help PowerPoint Presentation, Free Dow
PPT - Urgent Essay Writing Help PowerPoint Presentation, Free DowNat Rice
 
How To Motivate Yourself To Write An Essay Write Ess
How To Motivate Yourself To Write An Essay Write EssHow To Motivate Yourself To Write An Essay Write Ess
How To Motivate Yourself To Write An Essay Write EssNat Rice
 
PPT - Writing The Research Paper PowerPoint Presentation, Free D
PPT - Writing The Research Paper PowerPoint Presentation, Free DPPT - Writing The Research Paper PowerPoint Presentation, Free D
PPT - Writing The Research Paper PowerPoint Presentation, Free DNat Rice
 
Self Evaluation Essay Examples Telegraph
Self Evaluation Essay Examples TelegraphSelf Evaluation Essay Examples Telegraph
Self Evaluation Essay Examples TelegraphNat Rice
 
How To Start A Persuasive Essay Introduction - Slide Share
How To Start A Persuasive Essay Introduction - Slide ShareHow To Start A Persuasive Essay Introduction - Slide Share
How To Start A Persuasive Essay Introduction - Slide ShareNat Rice
 
Art Project Proposal Example Awesome How To Write A
Art Project Proposal Example Awesome How To Write AArt Project Proposal Example Awesome How To Write A
Art Project Proposal Example Awesome How To Write ANat Rice
 
The Importance Of Arts And Humanities Essay.Docx - T
The Importance Of Arts And Humanities Essay.Docx - TThe Importance Of Arts And Humanities Essay.Docx - T
The Importance Of Arts And Humanities Essay.Docx - TNat Rice
 
For Some Examples, Check Out Www.EssayC. Online assignment writing service.
For Some Examples, Check Out Www.EssayC. Online assignment writing service.For Some Examples, Check Out Www.EssayC. Online assignment writing service.
For Some Examples, Check Out Www.EssayC. Online assignment writing service.Nat Rice
 
Write-My-Paper-For-Cheap Write My Paper, Essay, Writing
Write-My-Paper-For-Cheap Write My Paper, Essay, WritingWrite-My-Paper-For-Cheap Write My Paper, Essay, Writing
Write-My-Paper-For-Cheap Write My Paper, Essay, WritingNat Rice
 
Printable Template Letter To Santa - Printable Templates
Printable Template Letter To Santa - Printable TemplatesPrintable Template Letter To Santa - Printable Templates
Printable Template Letter To Santa - Printable TemplatesNat Rice
 
Essay Websites How To Write And Essay Conclusion
Essay Websites How To Write And Essay ConclusionEssay Websites How To Write And Essay Conclusion
Essay Websites How To Write And Essay ConclusionNat Rice
 
Rhetorical Analysis Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Rhetorical Analysis Essay. Online assignment writing service.Rhetorical Analysis Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Rhetorical Analysis Essay. Online assignment writing service.Nat Rice
 
Hugh Gallagher Essay Hugh G. Online assignment writing service.
Hugh Gallagher Essay Hugh G. Online assignment writing service.Hugh Gallagher Essay Hugh G. Online assignment writing service.
Hugh Gallagher Essay Hugh G. Online assignment writing service.Nat Rice
 
An Essay With A Introduction. Online assignment writing service.
An Essay With A Introduction. Online assignment writing service.An Essay With A Introduction. Online assignment writing service.
An Essay With A Introduction. Online assignment writing service.Nat Rice
 
How To Write A Philosophical Essay An Ultimate Guide
How To Write A Philosophical Essay An Ultimate GuideHow To Write A Philosophical Essay An Ultimate Guide
How To Write A Philosophical Essay An Ultimate GuideNat Rice
 
50 Self Evaluation Examples, Forms Questions - Template Lab
50 Self Evaluation Examples, Forms Questions - Template Lab50 Self Evaluation Examples, Forms Questions - Template Lab
50 Self Evaluation Examples, Forms Questions - Template LabNat Rice
 
40+ Grant Proposal Templates [NSF, Non-Profi
40+ Grant Proposal Templates [NSF, Non-Profi40+ Grant Proposal Templates [NSF, Non-Profi
40+ Grant Proposal Templates [NSF, Non-ProfiNat Rice
 
Nurse Practitioner Essay Family Nurse Practitioner G
Nurse Practitioner Essay Family Nurse Practitioner GNurse Practitioner Essay Family Nurse Practitioner G
Nurse Practitioner Essay Family Nurse Practitioner GNat Rice
 

More from Nat Rice (20)

Entering College Essay. Top 10 Tips For College Admiss
Entering College Essay. Top 10 Tips For College AdmissEntering College Essay. Top 10 Tips For College Admiss
Entering College Essay. Top 10 Tips For College Admiss
 
006 Essay Example First Paragraph In An Thatsno
006 Essay Example First Paragraph In An Thatsno006 Essay Example First Paragraph In An Thatsno
006 Essay Example First Paragraph In An Thatsno
 
PPT - Urgent Essay Writing Help PowerPoint Presentation, Free Dow
PPT - Urgent Essay Writing Help PowerPoint Presentation, Free DowPPT - Urgent Essay Writing Help PowerPoint Presentation, Free Dow
PPT - Urgent Essay Writing Help PowerPoint Presentation, Free Dow
 
How To Motivate Yourself To Write An Essay Write Ess
How To Motivate Yourself To Write An Essay Write EssHow To Motivate Yourself To Write An Essay Write Ess
How To Motivate Yourself To Write An Essay Write Ess
 
PPT - Writing The Research Paper PowerPoint Presentation, Free D
PPT - Writing The Research Paper PowerPoint Presentation, Free DPPT - Writing The Research Paper PowerPoint Presentation, Free D
PPT - Writing The Research Paper PowerPoint Presentation, Free D
 
Self Evaluation Essay Examples Telegraph
Self Evaluation Essay Examples TelegraphSelf Evaluation Essay Examples Telegraph
Self Evaluation Essay Examples Telegraph
 
How To Start A Persuasive Essay Introduction - Slide Share
How To Start A Persuasive Essay Introduction - Slide ShareHow To Start A Persuasive Essay Introduction - Slide Share
How To Start A Persuasive Essay Introduction - Slide Share
 
Art Project Proposal Example Awesome How To Write A
Art Project Proposal Example Awesome How To Write AArt Project Proposal Example Awesome How To Write A
Art Project Proposal Example Awesome How To Write A
 
The Importance Of Arts And Humanities Essay.Docx - T
The Importance Of Arts And Humanities Essay.Docx - TThe Importance Of Arts And Humanities Essay.Docx - T
The Importance Of Arts And Humanities Essay.Docx - T
 
For Some Examples, Check Out Www.EssayC. Online assignment writing service.
For Some Examples, Check Out Www.EssayC. Online assignment writing service.For Some Examples, Check Out Www.EssayC. Online assignment writing service.
For Some Examples, Check Out Www.EssayC. Online assignment writing service.
 
Write-My-Paper-For-Cheap Write My Paper, Essay, Writing
Write-My-Paper-For-Cheap Write My Paper, Essay, WritingWrite-My-Paper-For-Cheap Write My Paper, Essay, Writing
Write-My-Paper-For-Cheap Write My Paper, Essay, Writing
 
Printable Template Letter To Santa - Printable Templates
Printable Template Letter To Santa - Printable TemplatesPrintable Template Letter To Santa - Printable Templates
Printable Template Letter To Santa - Printable Templates
 
Essay Websites How To Write And Essay Conclusion
Essay Websites How To Write And Essay ConclusionEssay Websites How To Write And Essay Conclusion
Essay Websites How To Write And Essay Conclusion
 
Rhetorical Analysis Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Rhetorical Analysis Essay. Online assignment writing service.Rhetorical Analysis Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Rhetorical Analysis Essay. Online assignment writing service.
 
Hugh Gallagher Essay Hugh G. Online assignment writing service.
Hugh Gallagher Essay Hugh G. Online assignment writing service.Hugh Gallagher Essay Hugh G. Online assignment writing service.
Hugh Gallagher Essay Hugh G. Online assignment writing service.
 
An Essay With A Introduction. Online assignment writing service.
An Essay With A Introduction. Online assignment writing service.An Essay With A Introduction. Online assignment writing service.
An Essay With A Introduction. Online assignment writing service.
 
How To Write A Philosophical Essay An Ultimate Guide
How To Write A Philosophical Essay An Ultimate GuideHow To Write A Philosophical Essay An Ultimate Guide
How To Write A Philosophical Essay An Ultimate Guide
 
50 Self Evaluation Examples, Forms Questions - Template Lab
50 Self Evaluation Examples, Forms Questions - Template Lab50 Self Evaluation Examples, Forms Questions - Template Lab
50 Self Evaluation Examples, Forms Questions - Template Lab
 
40+ Grant Proposal Templates [NSF, Non-Profi
40+ Grant Proposal Templates [NSF, Non-Profi40+ Grant Proposal Templates [NSF, Non-Profi
40+ Grant Proposal Templates [NSF, Non-Profi
 
Nurse Practitioner Essay Family Nurse Practitioner G
Nurse Practitioner Essay Family Nurse Practitioner GNurse Practitioner Essay Family Nurse Practitioner G
Nurse Practitioner Essay Family Nurse Practitioner G
 

Recently uploaded

Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)eniolaolutunde
 
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionMastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionSafetyChain Software
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfSoniaTolstoy
 
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxOrganic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxVS Mahajan Coaching Centre
 
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfEnzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfSumit Tiwari
 
mini mental status format.docx
mini    mental       status     format.docxmini    mental       status     format.docx
mini mental status format.docxPoojaSen20
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactdawncurless
 
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...M56BOOKSTORE PRODUCT/SERVICE
 
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and ActinidesSeparation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and ActinidesFatimaKhan178732
 
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityParis 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityGeoBlogs
 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Educationpboyjonauth
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Celine George
 
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communicationInteractive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communicationnomboosow
 
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptxContemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptxRoyAbrique
 
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfSanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfsanyamsingh5019
 
How to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptx
How to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptxHow to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptx
How to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptxmanuelaromero2013
 
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdfssuser54595a
 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxpboyjonauth
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
 
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionMastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
 
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdfBASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK  LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
BASLIQ CURRENT LOOKBOOK LOOKBOOK(1) (1).pdf
 
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxOrganic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
 
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfEnzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
 
mini mental status format.docx
mini    mental       status     format.docxmini    mental       status     format.docx
mini mental status format.docx
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
 
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
 
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and ActinidesSeparation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
Separation of Lanthanides/ Lanthanides and Actinides
 
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityParis 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
 
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communicationInteractive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
 
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptxContemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
 
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfSanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
 
How to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptx
How to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptxHow to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptx
How to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptx
 
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
 
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdfTataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
 

Administration And Management Of Undergraduate Capstone Projects In Joint Degree Technology Programmes

  • 1. 376 Int. J. Management in Education, Vol. 4, No. 4, 2010 Copyright © 2010 Inderscience Enterprises Ltd. Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects in joint degree technology programmes M.K.S. Sastry* Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of the West Indies, St. Augustine Campus, Trinidad and Tobago Email: mks_sastry@ieee.org *Corresponding author Clement K. Sankat University of the West Indies, St. Augustine Campus, Trinidad and Tobago Email: clement.sankat@sta.uwi.edu Kamel Singh Applied Engineering Programs, University of Trinidad and Tobago, Trinidad and Tobago Email: kamel.singh@utt.edu.tt Abstract: Managing undergraduate capstone projects is a specialised task which depends on the nature of programmes, availability of resources, inputs and the expected outcomes. Technology programmes are different from conventional engineering programmes and hence the training in technology capstone projects should be aligned with the programme objectives and expectations. This paper describes an effective policy framework and administrative process for managing the capstone projects in typical joint technology degree programmes in Trinidad and Tobago. Uniqueness of technology capstone projects and their distinct inputs and expected outcomes are illustrated. Detailed management process, assessment criteria and the experiences gained so far are presented. Few technology projects of these programmes under this framework are briefly described. Keywords: capstone projects; technology programmes; technologists; joint degrees; engineering programmes. Reference to this paper should be made as follows: Sastry, M.K.S., Sankat, C.K. and Singh, K. (2010) ‘Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects in joint degree technology programmes’, Int. J. Management in Education, Vol. 4, No. 4, pp.376–390.
  • 2. Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 377 Biographical notes: M.K.S. Sastry is currently with the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of the West Indies (UWI) and also the Programme Coordinator, BTech Degree Programmes jointly offered by UWI and University of Trinidad and Tobago (UTT). He received his Doctoral degree in Electrical Engineering from National Institute of Technology, India. He is a senior member of Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE), USA, and a member of Institution of Engineering and Technology (IET), UK. His research interests include Engineering Education, Information Systems, Computer Applications in Power Engineering, and Asset and Facility Management. Clement K. Sankat is presently Pro-Vice Chancellor and Campus Principal for the University of West Indies, St. Augustine Campus. Prior to this, he served UWI in different capacities including Dean, Faculty of Engineering; Head and Professor of Department of Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering; Chairman, Executive Management Committee for UWI–UTT Joint Degree Programmes. His teaching and research activities have covered an extended area of Mechanical Engineering and related domains. Kamel Singh is a Senior Instructor and Programme Leader for the Bachelor of Applied Technology and Bachelor of Engineering in Applied Process and Utilities Technology Programmes at the University of Trinidad and Tobago. He has 18 years of industrial experience in the design and construction of process plant, pressure vessel, storage tank, pipeline, offshore production facilities, welding engineering, quality control and maintenance management. His research interests include modern energy systems, engineering curricula development and machine design. 1 Introduction Capstone project is a significant component in engineering or technology curricula and provides an opportunity to the student in developing professional skills like problem solving, analysis, synthesis and evaluation. Most often, the words ‘Engineer’, ‘Technologist’, ‘Engineering Programmes’, ‘Technology Programmes’ are used synonymously. However, these words are completely different and the Institution of Engineering and Technology (IET), UK, clearly defines these terms with respective meaning, inputs, outputs and expectations. The underlying spirit of technology programmes is to produce more industry-ready graduates with hands-on skills in using innovative tools, processes and technologies, as opposed to engineers who design and simulate the systems or processes (Sastry et al., 2007). Hence, technology training is reinforced by ‘hands-on’ laboratory training and real world exposure to the utility engineering/industry environment, through internships. Technology programmes have different structures, standards and outcomes than the conventional engineering degree programmes and produce ‘Incorporated Engineers’. Currently, there are several technology programmes around the world which produce ‘Technologists’. The discussion in this paper focuses on the administrative aspects of capstone projects in technology programmes offered jointly by the University of the West Indies (UWI) and the University of Trinidad and Tobago (UTT). These programmes are unique with distinct features to serve the needs of local
  • 3. 378 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh industries and utilities (Sastry et al., 2008) and essentially offered on part-time basis in the evening. Further, about 95% of the students are full-time employees of local industries and utilities. Capstone projects in these programmes are differently administrated and managed to meet the programme expectations and global quality standards. From the literature it is clear that engineering faculties across the globe have experimented with capstone projects in several ways to achieve better throughput, to maintain the quality standards and to improve the existing knowledge base. These experiments included changing the duration of projects, group and individual projects, assessment strategies and colloboration with industry. Few authors reported that couple of cycles of expereinces were required to perfect the administrative framework governing the capstone (Armstrong et al., 2006; Bachnak, 2006; Morales, 2006). During the early 1990s, few universities offered this course as a combination of classroom teaching and a hands-on design labotorary training (Fabiano, 1992) over one, final semester. However, administration and management of capstone projects in engineering programmes has changed considerably since then. New strategies in the assessment process to normalise the capstone grades and to minimise the differences among the examiners and the experiences have been presented by Teo and Ho (1998). Incorportation of necessary courses and training programmes to prepare students to take up challenging capstone projects is preferred by some univeristies (Bhurtum et al., 1999). Universities have set up industry-based projects to provide real-world exposure and training to the students (Gol et al., 2001; Ray, 2003; Wang and Pai, 2006). However, Morales (2006) reported on attempts to minimise the role of industry inputs on the basis of student feedback expressing the lesser availability of industry personnel to interact with the students. Difficulties of administering the capstone projects to meet the accreditation standards are also presented by Hudson and Harding (2002) and Campbell and Sobel (2003). In summary, administration and management of capstone projects is a specialised task which depends on nature of programme, availability of resources and expected outcomes. However, not much information is available on the capstone technology projects in case of degrees offered jointly by two different univerisites. In this paper, an attempt is made to explain the administrative and management framework goverining these unique capstone technology projects. This paper is organised as follows. Section 2 explains a brief background of the programmes. Section 3 provides the methodology in defining the policy framework for the capstone projects. Section 4 explains the administrative framework, inputs, expected outcomes and assessment criteria. The unique aspects of capstone projects are presented in Section 5. Overall management process is presented in Section 6. Section 7 illustrates our experiences so far, throughput analysis of student performance, student reaction and industry perspective. 2 Background of UWI–UTT joint degrees The UWI is a regional university which serves the 15 English-speaking countries of the Caribbean region and which was established nearly 60 years ago. The UTT has been established in the year 2004 and partnered with the UWI through a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) to offer two undergraduate degrees, viz. the Bachelor of Applied
  • 4. Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 379 Technology Degrees (BTech) in Mechanical and Electrical Engineering. The primary outputs of these two degrees are technologists (also known as Incorporated Engineers) for the local industrial and service sectors. These programmes are being governed by a Joint Management Executive Committee (JMEC) in which senior fauclty members of both institutions are members (Sastry et al., 2007). The Institution of Engineering and Technology (the IET), UK, has accredited these programmes after a succesful visit in the year 2007. According to standards of the IET, The Incorporated Engineers are characterized by their ability to act as exponents of today’s technology through creativity and innovation (EC-UK, 2003). To this end, they maintain and manage applications of current and developing technology, and may undertake engineering design, development, manufacture, construction and operation. Incorporated Engineers are variously engaged in technical and commercial management and also possess effective interpersonal skills. 3 Methodology for creation of policy framework Unfortunately, not much information is available in the literature about the policies and processes governing technology projects to help JMEC in the initial planning. This task is challenging in a sense that mostly technologies are imported, but managed locally in Trinidad and Tobago, which has a vibrant energy industry sector. The senior members of JMEC engaged themselves in series of brain storming sessions on different occassions, discussed on the needs of the local industries, international accreditation statndards and overall expectations of the technology programmes. As a result of their efforts, a well-defined administrative policy framework for producing high-quality projects is devised. This policy framework ensures that the technology projects in these programmes provide much required hands-on and high skills training to the students. This policy is then translated administrative process. 4 Administrative process The JMEC has laid out a well-defined adminstrative process in terms of types of projects that can be taken up, availability of resources, expected outcomes, assessment criteria and the related rules and regulations. Each student of these programmes has to register for the course titled ‘Integrated Project in Industry’ after having completed all the courses in the programme successfully. The duration of the capstone project is two semesters, 13 weeks each with a total weighting of six credits. Capstone project is completely different from the rest of courses in the programme and does not follow the usual protocol of regular instruction, course work and examinations, etc. Further, technology projects are closely coupled to local industry processes and practices to provide a complete work-related experience in the real world. Student is responsible for project selection, supervisor selection, and conduct and progress of the work. Obviously, this requires a considerable shift in the attitude of the student, and management skills in realising the set objectives of the chosen project within the specified time frame. The various aspects of administrative framework are discussed briefly in the following sections.
  • 5. 380 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh 4.1 Types of projects Capstone projects can be of different types based on the area of engineering specialisation, student’s background and interests of the industries and local utilities. Keeping the overall outcomes of the technology programmes and the standards, the technology projects are broadly classified into four categories which are summarised hereafter. • Problem identification and solving: The projects under this category can be an existing major problem in an industry or a utility, or a time consuming task in a complex process. This type of projects require modelling of the plant/system and rigorous analysis of the problem and the student’s own approach or strategy to solve the same using a feasible and cost effective solution. • Design and build: Design of complex engineering systems based on standard specifications and benchmarks. A fully functional working prototype must be designed and built based on custom specifications. Design validation and extensive analysis must be undertaken. The same must be tested and demonstrated during the examinations. • Implementation (or re-engineering): Development of a working prototype based on an existing methodology/standard technique, such as new electronic circuits, working tools or machines. Under this category, a working prototype must be built based on available designs and standard specifications. The same must be tested and demonstrated during the examinations. • Software simulation: Development of software for engineering applications through standard software process and using any approved technologies must be developed to solve specific problem. The developed software must be tested thoroughly and demonstrated during the examinations. Students enjoy freedom to choose any type of project. An interactive orientation session will be held by the programme coordinator to help students to understand the overall governing process for this course. During this orientation, students are advised to identify problems in their own work places, local industries or even from the literature. Each student is expected to define the problem and formulate the objectives, scope and expected deliverables. 4.2 Inputs and expected outcomes Though there is no formal teaching or training to the students, during the two semester period, they are provided with wide range of inputs throughout the programme and even during to meet the standard expectations. These inputs and resources are provided to the students to inculcate the notion of design, analysis and awareness of interdisciplinary nature of engineering practice. The various inputs and outcomes are outlined below as well as in Figure 1.
  • 6. Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 381 4.2.1 Academic inputs Students of these joint degree programmes receive training in wide ranging courses in ‘Core Engineering’, ‘Technology Management’, ‘Basic Sciences and Mathematics’, ‘Languages and Humanities’ (Sastry et al., 2008). These courses impart a variety of skills, knowledge and hands-on experience to the students, thus making them ready to face the likely challenges during the capstone project. The UTT has developed good relations with several senior industry personnel and engaged them in as part-time instructors to teach technology courses in the same programmes. Figure 1 Inputs and expected outcomes of technology capstone projects Final Year Individual, Capstone Project Conceive Design Develop Test Analyse Employer/Ind ustry Support Academic Inputs through Courses: Core Engineering, Technology Management, Maths and Science, Languages and Humanities Technical guidance from Supervisor Overall Progress monitoring by panel of examiners Guidance on technical report writing, Laboratory and Library Facilities Expected Outcomes Fully working system Functional prototype A new Strategy/ Methodology This strategy provided students an opportunity to develop close relations with the senior engineers directly in the classroom who can help them in problem identification and formulation of the projects. This nature of classroom interactions can pave the way forward for effective cross-industry partnership, technology and knowledge transfer to identify the solutions to the existing or known technological problems. 4.2.2 Technical guidance from supervisor Most of the students are employed in local industries and utilities. About 95% of the students formulate their capstone projects based on the problems or the topics which are of interest to their respective employers. Students can identify the project supervisors
  • 7. 382 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh from their work place or from the university faculty. If a student is not able to identify an appropriate supervisor, then the UTT will circulate the proposal and then identify one for that project. Students consult their project supervisor for necessary guidance periodically. Supervisors work with the student very closely, make necessary visits to the project sites to understand, analyse and then help the student. In most cases, it will be a learning experience for the supervisors too. This approach provided the much needed interaction between university teaching staff and the industry. 4.2.3 Employer/industry support The support from the employer is vital to the student in carrying out the project successfully. Usually employers provide necessary permissions and approvals to use their equipment and resources due to the fact that some of their long pending problems are likely to be solved through their own employees. It is also interesting to note that employers are very happy to see that their staff, who are students of the technology programmes, engaged in technologically challenging projects (Ugas and Sastry, 2009) and progressing well in terms of professional development. Some industries funded and closely monitored the progress of the projects to ensure the expected results and derive benefits (Dial et al., 2008; Roberts et al., 2009). 4.2.4 Infrastructural facilities of the universities As the BTech degrees are jointly offered by the UWI and the UTT, the students have access to the libraries, simulators, laboratories and workshops of both the universities and this has helped the students in understanding the concepts, experimentation process and analysing information related to their projects. In addition, the UTT has devised a student friendly purchase procedures for equipment procurement, which is a great challenge, given the fact that Trinidad and Tobago is an island country and most of the equipment need to be procured from the USA or UK. Despite such challenges, a wide range of instruments, equipment and other apparatus have been purchased without losing the time. Two faculty members from the languages department of the UTT trained the students in technical report writing and also assisted them in proof reading their reports. 4.2.5 Overall monitoring and assessment Students meet the project supervisors regularly to seek consultation. The respective engineering departments at the UWI appoint a panel of examiners to assess the student performance. The panel makes the necessary field visits, before commencement of the project and after completion of the project. Through these field visits, the panel can examine the student closely from project commencement to the completion. Normally, the panel suggests the suitable solutions to the likely and potential challenges in the project as well as their expectations during the site visits. In addition to this, at the end of first semester, students have to present their progress reports to the same panel of examiners and this examination has a weighting of 20% of final grade. During this examination, students present the progress made thus far and what needs to be done in the coming semester. Panel carefully analyses the progress of the student and provides a
  • 8. Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 383 cursory feedback and its views on the student performance. In summary, site visits, support from supervisor and progress report presentation, help students to check their own progress as well as making necessary changes in time, if necessary. 4.2.6 Expected outcomes At the end of the two semesters, every capstone project should ideally result in any one of the three outcomes (a) fully working system, (b) functional prototype and (c) a new strategy/methodology to improve an existing process. In addition to this, students are expected to submit a thesis on their work. The students will gain the unique experience of solving technical problems, within demanding work-time schedules, using available resources. With this experience, they will be able to address real-world problems and new technological challenges in an effective manner. 4.2.7 Assessment mechanism Assessment is done by a panel consisting of project supervisor and two additional examiners drawn from both universities. Each student is examined in three major areas (a) technical report writing skills (b) oral presentation and communication skills and (c) professional conduct and progression during the project execution. Table 1 illustrates various assessment components that are used to examine the student skills and the quality of work done in completing the project. Table 1 Assessment components with weightings for evaluation of capstone projects Assessment component Percentage weighting 1 Technical report writing skills Presentation quality 10 Technical content 30 Research 20 2 Oral presentation and communication skills Presentation quality 10 Delivery 10 Defence 10 3 Professional conduct and progression 10 Total 100 5 Distinction of technology capstone projects in joint degree programmes As can be seen from Section 4, the technology capstones projects are distinctly different from the conventional engineering capstone projects at the UWI with typical sets of inputs and outcomes. Table 2 summarises the similarities and differences between the technology and engineering capstone projects.
  • 9. 384 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh Table 2 Comparison between technology and engineering projects Technology capstone projects Traditional engineering capstone projects at the UWI Students identify their own problem and develop the project proposal with objectives and expected deliverables Teaching staff conceive the projects and make the ready-made proposals available to students About 95% of the technology capstone projects are based on the real-world problems in industries or utilities where the student is working Less than 5% of engineering projects are carried out in local industries and utilities, as the students are with the university on full-time basis Students use propriety technologies, tools and software systems to analyse, design and develop the systems during their project work More than 95% of engineering projects involve developing new tools, algorithms, software applications, simulation and in-depth analysis of complex systems, etc. Research is not a significant component of technology projects. As the problems are unique and specific to the local industries and utilities, it is very difficult to find the previously published articles. Students are expected to carry out in-depth analysis and develop a feasible solution Research is a significant component of engineering projects and students are expected to undertake an in-depth literature survey on the chosen problem and compare their results with international benchmarks which may be available in the refereed journals Final outcomes of the technology projects include a fully working system or a prototype system or an effective strategy to improve or maintain an existing process Final outcomes of engineering projects include new processes, systems or algorithms to solve complex problems or software applications Project duration is two semesters Project duration is two semesters 6 Overall management process The administrative framework is translated into a systematic management process, which is used by the teaching faculty and administrative staff for the management of student projects. Eligible students register for their capstone projects at the start of the semester, just as they register for other courses. During the registration week, the UTT organises orientation classes to explain about the procedures, expectations, deadlines, resources and previous experiences of students as well as those of supervisors. Students are required to identify a topic or a work-related problem on their own and then submit a project proposal in the prescribed format within the first week. The proposal consists of title, problem statement, objectives and scope, a brief introduction of the problem, background expected end deliverables, tools and technologies that will be used, resources needed from universities, etc. The senior faculty from respective engineering departments at the UWI will review the proposals according to the expected standards and approve them based on their merit, subjected to modifications. After securing the approval for the project, student arranges a site visit to explain the problem to the UWI examiners and programme coordinators. During this site visit, the panel will identify the technical challenges involved and give suggestions that can help student to solve the same. A supervisor will be identified either from industry or from the UTT to monitor the progress of the student. The first semester is called Phase 1 and the second semester as Phase 2. Student will be coordinating activities like problem analysis,
  • 10. Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 385 resource identification, equipment procurement, solution formulation and design, etc. in the Phase 1. At the end of the first semester a progress report is required to be submitted and all the Phase 1 students will be examined for the progress made thus far and for their action plan for the Phase 2. Examination panel provides necessary inputs, suggestions and recommendations to the students to encourage them towards successful completion of their projects. Students who could not make enough progress can opt to withdraw from the project and restart. However, they need to identify a new problem and a new supervisor different from the past project, in order to keep the uniform challenges to all the students. During the Phase 2, students undertake building the prototypes, cost benefit analysis, testing and comparison, final report writing, etc. Students meet their respective supervisors periodically and note the proceedings of the meetings in a project log book, issued by the BTech department. Upon completion of the project, student arranges another site visit to demonstrate the outcome of the project to the examiners. The overall process and the intermediate activities are illustrated in Figure 2. Figure 2 Overall process of capstone projects with intermediate activities Project Registration/ Preliminary Orientation Review of the Project Proposal by UWI Senior Faculty and appointment of UWI Examiners Site visit and inspection by UWI Examiners Identify suitable project supervisors from UTT and from Industry . Student starts working on the approved project Progress Report Presentation - Phase 1 Examination at the end of First Semester Final Project Presentation - Phase 2 Examination at the end of Second Semester Final Project Submission and Demonstration of Working Prototype Site visit and inspection by UWI Examiners to check the completed project in working condition Identify the Overall features and requirements , Formulate solution Strategy , Design the solution/ Prototype/ Design Validation Implementation of Design, Development and construction of a working prototype or actual system First Semester (Phase 1) 13 Weeks Student decides to drop out Second Semester (Phase 2) 13 weeks Is Student successful in final Project Examination? Prepare the student file for Graduation No Yes No Yes START Proposal Preparation and Preliminary Review / Appointment of UTT Project Supervisor 7 Results and experiences Till date, 123 students (Electrical Engineering: 57 and Mechanical Engineering: 66) have completed their capstone projects. The student success and failure rate are 95% and 5% in the first attempt. The detailed distribution of the final grades and the student numbers is shown in Figure 3. Trends of student success and failure rates indicate that the existing administrative processes and management strategies yielded good and healthy results.
  • 11. 386 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh Faculty members and supervisors encouraged students to publish their works in refereed international conferences and journals. Few students have responded and started working with faculty members to contribute to the local, regional conferences and journals. This engulfed the enthusiasm in other students and now more students who are very successful in their projects are working actively on publishing their works (Sangster et al., 2007; Dial et al., 2008; Mangal et al., 2008; Ramsingh and Sastry, 2009; Roberts et al., 2009; Ugas and Sastry, 2009). Though students face some level of stress in the first few weeks of project, at the end, they are proud of their achievements. Some students have been able to gain better employment based on the project experience. Industries and utilities are keen to study the technology projects undertaken in their premises for possible implementation. Few projects have been adopted by the respective industries already. Some students have received positive encouragement to implement their findings on a pilot basis or to submit a deployment feasibility report. In some cases, employers have restrained the students from disclosing the vital design aspects and other key information related to their internal processes. Interestingly, all students in such cases were promoted to higher positions. Figure 3 Throughput analysis of capstone projects in UWI-UTT BTech programmes This positive response from local industries and utilities indicates the applicability of the end deliverables, overall effectiveness of the technology programmes and the training involved and the success of administrative framework of the capstone projects. To provide a general understanding, details of few selected technology projects completed so far are presented in Table 3. To compliment the above policy framework, the faculty of Engineering at the UWI organises ‘Engineering Management Final-Year Students’ Project Competition’ to recognise the best student projects and this competition is open to all engineering programmes in both the UWI and the UTT. Some of the students in the technology programme have participated and successful in achieving the awards.
  • 12. Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 387 Table 3 Description of selected technology capstone projects Project title, name of the company Brief description A Novel Control Strategy for an Ammonia Marine Loading Arm – YARA, Trinidad Using a state of art, industry standard monitoring and control equipment, an operator friendly, real-time visual interface is developed to display overall operating process. This approach reduces the overall operating cost and improves safety standards during product loading (Ugas and Sastry, 2009). A New, Locally Engineered Hydro Test Bench for testing the Gate Valves – United Engineering Services Limited, Trinidad A new hydraulically operated test bench has been designed, built and tested successfully. This equipment is found to be having higher overall testing efficiency in testing and maintenance of gate valves. Presently, this equipment is adopted by the company for regular use (Dial et al., 2008). Design, Construction and Testing of an Automatic Bottle Cap Feed Hopper System – National Petroleum Co Ltd., Trinidad This is an automation solution to a manual process of filling the cap sorter bin with caps and eliminated the need of an attendant having to do it and eliminate any unnecessary line stoppage due to low cap level in the cap sorter bin. This has been successfully incorporated into process line of the company. The hopper system, with the conveyer carrying the caps in the bottle filling process line is shown in Figure 4. Wireless Control for Function Testing Automatic Spreader Bars – Point Lisas Industrial Port Development Corporation (PLIPDECO), Trinidad A real time wireless control mechanism, using Bluetooth technology has been designed, tested and integrated with a newly engineered test kit to control a BROMMA EH5 spreader bar. This has replaced the conventional, manual system and the associated processes. The operators are now provided with a friendly computer interface to operate the spreader bars in real time. The real-time interface is shown in Figure 5. Figure 4 Automatic Bottle Cap Feed Hopper System designed and built at NPC, Ltd. (see online version for colours)
  • 13. 388 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh Figure 5 A real-time operator interface to control the spreader bars at the PLIPDECO (see online version for colours) 8 Scope for further research From the above sections, it is clear that the joint technology programmes in Trinidad and Tobago have typical arrangements governing the technology projects. These arrangements have been established based on the MOU, working relations of the partnering universities, international standards, and local industry and utility requirements. The approach suggested in this paper can be adopted in any technology programme with similar inputs and outputs. However, further research should be carried out to study the global practices and trends in this area as it is the capstone project really, in which the student takes up a technologically challenging professional responsibility without any formal teaching. Additionally, work needs to be carried out to clearly define the standards and terms of reference for technology capstone projects. Such benchmarks can be used by various professional engineering and technology institutions (such as IET) around the world for accreditation and professional registration purposes. 9 Conclusion Technology capstone projects are quite different from conventional engineering projects. Administration of such projects in joint degree programmes requires a well-defined policy framework and administrative process due to their uniqueness and distinct inputs
  • 14. Administration and management of undergraduate capstone projects 389 and outputs. It can be seen that the implementation of these policies, supplemented with a continuous monitoring of student progress has yielded successful results. As seen from the discussion on few sample projects and the industry perspective, it can be observed that the framework presented in this paper has helped the partnering universities in the successful completion of the programmes and also helped the students to earn professional respect from their employers. This experience can be replicated or adopted in any technology programmes with necessary adjustments as required. References Armstrong, P., Kee, R., Kenny, R. and Cunningham, G. (2006) ‘The development of a capstone project course based on CDIO principles’, World Transactions on Engineering and Technology Education, Vol. 5, No. 2, pp.229–302. Bachnak, R. (2006) ‘An approach for successful capstone projects’, 35th ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference, pp.F4D18–F4D22. Bhurtum, C., Jahmeerbacus, I., Oolum, K. and Feliachi, A. (1999, May) ‘Short-term practical training for electrical engineering undergraduates’, IEEE Transactions on Engineering Education, Vol. 42, No. 2, pp.109–113. Campbell, S. and Sobel, A. (2003) ‘Hard lessons learned using hardware-oriented capstone projects’, 33rd ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference, pp.F4C7–F4C12. Dial, R., Singh, K., Ali, R. and Sastry, M.K.S. (2008) ‘A new, locally engineered hydro test bench for testing the gate valves’, 16th Biennial CAS Conference, 11–13 October, Grenada, pp.134–138. EC-UK (2003) ‘Chartered Engineer and Incorporated Engineer Standard’, UK Standard for Professional Engineering Competence, Engineering Council, UK. Fabiano, P. (1992) ‘Concurrent approaches in engineering technology capstone projects’, IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference, pp.821–824. Gol, O., Nafalski, A. and McDermott, K. (2001) ‘The role of industry-inspired projects in engineering education’, 31st ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference, pp.F3E1–F3E4. Hudson, C. and Harding, P. (2002) ‘Improving project work on degree courses’, IEE 2nd Annual Symposium on Engineering Education (Ref. No. 2002/056), 3–4 January, Vol. 1, No. 56, pp.17/1–17/6. Mangal, D., Singh, K. and Sastry, M.K.S. (2008) ‘Design and development of a novel Cathode Ray Tube (CRT) crusher’, 16th Biennial CAS Conference, 11–13 October, Grenada, pp.103–107. Morales, C.J. (2006) ‘A capstone triumvirate of courses to satisfy ABET’s major design experience requirements’, 9th International Conference on Engineering Education, pp.T1H19–T1H24. Ramsingh, S. and Sastry, M.K.S. (2009) ‘Effective asset management to improve the satisfaction of mobile telephone customers’, International Conference on Technology Innovation and Industrial Management (TIIM), 18–20 June, Bangkok. Ray, L.J. (2003) ‘Industry-academic partnerships for successful capstone projects’, 33rd ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference, pp.S2B24–S2B29. Roberts, K., Kupid, K., Singh, K. and Sastry, M.K.S. (2009) ‘Novel, locally engineered crude asphalt crusher’, Latin American and Caribbean Conference for Engineering and Technology (LACCET’2009), 1–5 June, San Cristobal, Venezuela. Sangster, N., Persad, P. and Ramoutar, S. (2007) ‘Fuzzy logic for traffic light control at an overpass’, 23rd ISPE International Conference on CAD/CAM Robotics & Factories of the Future, 16–18 August, Bogotá, pp.356–361.
  • 15. 390 M.K.S. Sastry, C.K. Sankat and K. Singh Sastry, M.K.S, Sankat, C.K., Exall, D., Srivastava, K.D., Khan, H., Copeland, B., Lewis, W. and Bhajan, D. (2007, April) ‘An appraisal of tertiary level institutional collaboration and joint degree programs in Trinidad and Tobago’, Latin American and Caribbean Journal of Engineering Education, Vol. l, No. 1, pp.27–34. Sastry, M.K.S., Sankat, C.K., Khan, H. and Bhajan, D. (2008) ‘The need for technologists and applied technology programmes: an experience from Trinidad and Tobago’, International Journal of Management in Education, Vol. 2, No. 2, pp.222–233. Teo, C.Y. and Ho, D.J. (1998, February) ‘A systematic approach to the implementation of final year project in an electrical engineering undergraduate course’, IEEE Transactions on Education, Vol. 41, No. 1, pp.25–30. Ugas, N. and Sastry, M.K.S. (2009) ‘A novel control strategy for an ammonia marine loading arm’, Journal of the Association of Professional Engineers of Trinidad and Tobago. Wang, S.L. and Pai, D. (2006) ‘Engaging stakeholders in the assessment of ABET outcomes in a capstone design course’, 9th International Conference on Engineering Education, pp.T4A10–T4A13.