Published on

Published in: Business, Technology
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide


  1. 1. A New Educational Model Promoting Research and Innovation Team Details: Angad Singi Shivam Gupta Komal Saraf Rahim Malik Palash Mathnikar Manthan Topic : Brain Gain
  2. 2. Entire graduatingclassesof the prestigiousIndian Institutes of Technology (IIT) left for graduate studiesin universities in the United States in the 1970s and 1980s, many stayingon to work after obtaining their advanced degrees (Morning 2001). India is a major source of migrants, especially of highly-skilled and well-trained workers. Even with a high number of Indian talents abroad, India – as well as destination countries – takes advantage of the resources generated by this population. Traditionally the flows of Indian professionals have been directed towards the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom and other similar destinations. Recently, however, Western European countries are being selected as migration options. The highly-skilled nationals of India are most prominent in the United Kingdom. Among 12,852 permits issued for Indian highly-skilled workers in 2010, 5,615 or 44% were issued by the UK. Italy is the first European destination for seasonal workers. In 2010 Italy issued 3,479 permits accounting for 92% of Indian seasonal workers in the EU. According to the US Department of Homeland Security India was, in 2009, the first country of origin among foreign students enrolled in US universities: indeed, 16% of all foreign students were Indian. Desai, Kapur and McHale (2001) found that the 1 million Indians in the United States who represent only 0.1 percent of India’s population earn the equivalent of about 10% of India’s national income.
  3. 3. In this context, the loss of skilled labour is of vital importance for development and development potential. The loss of teachers undermines the ability of schools and education systems to function, the loss of nurses impairs efforts to deliver even basic healthcare and public health programmes and the loss of other skilled professionals acts as a barrier to institutional capacity building, the efficient utilisation of external assistance and private sector growth. The ‘Brain Drain’, as the flow of skilled professionals out of developing countries has become known, thus marks a potentially serious barrier to economic growth, development and poverty reduction.’ Positive effects Negative effects " Provides rewarding opportunities to educated workers not available at home. " Inflow of remittances and foreign exchange " Induced stimulus to investment in domestic education and individual human capital investments " Return of skilled persons increases local human capital, transfer of skills and links to foreign networks " Technology transfer, investments by diasporas " Circulation of brains promotes integration into global markets (India, Taiwan, (China)). " Short term movements of service providers (GATS Mode 4) generate benefits for both receiving and sending countries. " ICT allows countries to benefit from diasporas. " Net decrease in human capital stock, especially those with valuable professional experience " Reduced growth and productivity because of the lower stock of human capital " Fiscal loss of heavy investments in subsidized education " Remittances from skilled migration may taper off. " Reduced quality of essential services of health and education " Students educated at government expense or own resources in foreign countries imply further drain " Opportunities for short-term movement of natural persons is seriously constrained by immigration policies of developed countries. " Causes increasing disparities in incomes in country of origin. Brain Drain Balance
  4. 4. Return of migrants to their source country Permanent return focus of most policies Restriction of international mobility Restrictive emigration/immigration policies (explicit and e.g. national trades) Recruitment of international migrants Court foreign workers (tax incentives, simplified visa regimes) Reparation for loss of human capital (tax) Compensate source countries, or emigrants directly submit taxes, to deal with externalities created by the immediate loss of human capital Resourcing expatriates (Diaspora options) Significant resource, if ongoing contact between academic and private sector institutions is fostered. Government and private sector initiatives seek to increase communications, knowledge transfer, remittances, and investment. Retention though educational sector policies Creating a highly educated workforce begins with strengthening domestic educational institutions. A viable system that encourages graduates to stay with the system, that retains people, ensures that the source country keeps its original investment. Retention through economic development Giving people a reason to stay (or return) is doubtless the most effective policy for reducing emigration and the surest long-term means of boosting average human capital, as well as economic growth. Policy Option : 6 R’s
  5. 5. The Common Patterns in brain gain strategies A reasonable levels of economic and political stability preceded successful brain gain strategies; • Earlier investments in quality education and its linkage with the labor market needs often the case behind the success stories on brain gain; • Governments’ recognition of and commitment to the role of diasporas in the national development processes; • The creation of a conducive enabling environment and designing specific policy and financial incentive packages as part of the strategies; • Expatriate Knowledge Networks share similar organizational and administrative structures – website and databases of expertise; • The knowledge networks have links with governmental structures and process.
  6. 6. The Uncommon Patterns in brain gain strategies • Concentration of critical mass of expatriates in a particular sector and location (Indian and Chinese communities in Silicon Valley); • Strong transnational community living simultaneously in two countries (Taiwan) • Promotion of university-industry collaboration in R&D (China) • Dual citizenship rights for Diaspora (Ghana) including the right to vote and the right to return and indefinite stay for Africans (including non- Ghanaians) in the Diaspora • Open membership in knowledge networks for nationals other than country of origin (South Africa and Colombia) • Building on relative advantage (software sector in India, hardware and semiconductors in China and the shift to value added software products in Taiwan)
  7. 7. Converting BRAIN DRAIN to BRAIN GAIN. Here we provide a holistic and multifaceted strategy in addressing the brain drain issue. The approach adopted is composed of enabling legal frameworks; national initiatives; public sector focus which concentrates on the recruitment and retention of scarce skills in the public service to deliver public services efficiently and on an affordable basis to the people of India We can also design a programme to encourage its citizens with expertise residing overseas to return home and put in place incentive package that includes tax relief on personal effects and vehicles brought by returning citizens, educational incentives for their children.
  8. 8. •These professionals contribute not only to the development of the country where they live and work but also to the economy of the country of origin. Indian human capital abroad can be leveraged by India to take advantage of its resources but also by destination countries for the fulfillment of skill shortages. •With a large number of young and educated people, India plays a major role in international migration. In the context of the intensification of a global knowledge economy, the demographic trends and the changes induced by the crisis, the destination countries could take advantage of Indian. •The redirection of mobility flows between evolutionary poles of migration emphasizes the changing geopolitics at work: asymmetric traditional relationships have diminished and the circulation paradigm redistributes current moves, opening new options and perspectives. Concerns
  9. 9. The Bangalore cluster is a relevant example of win-win scenario. It played a crucial role in the development of the Indian IT industry, as well as of IT companies from Silicon Valley. The destination country took advantage of the knowledge of Indian specialists while the origin countries benefited from foreign direct investment and, from the Diaspora networks which facilitated the emergence of India as preferred outsourcing destination. Win-Win Situation The two emerging social trends support the assumption that other countries can benefit from brain gain • The trend towards transnationalisation due to globalisation which makes it possible to live in two countries simultaneously • The trend towards a “knowledge society”, in which the importance of human beings – who carry the knowledge - in the development process is increasing.
  10. 10. India’s governments need to pay enough attention to design and promote innovative policy environments that could be instrumental to benefit from the ‘brain gain’ potential. Such policy reforms might include, but not limited to, monetary and non-monetary incentive packages; tax and bureaucratic reforms; targeted infrastructure development; political and administrative support to the knowledge and business networks; linking education programmes with labour market needs; fostering partnership between universities and industries; etc. Specific policy interventions and incentive packages provided by India, China, Taiwan, South Africa, etc. show case their impact on ‘brain gain’ both to the home country as well as their contribution to the international human capital stock and knowledge flows. CONCLUSION
  11. 11. References • • •‎ • › Group Discussion‎