SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 31
EFFECTS OF PAINT ON PLASTICS:
TEST –
DON’T
GUESS!
Dave Palmer, P.E.
Materials Engineer, BRP Marine Propulsion
Systems Division
Mass Customization
2
Paint vs. Mold-in-color
3
Advantages of molded-in-color
Lower part cost
No secondary operations
Same color through thickness of part
Paint vs. Mold-in-color
4
So, why paint plastics?
Volume may not justify a press run
Color/effect may not be available in resin
Improved environmental resistance
Aftermarket refinishing/repair
Materials and Coatings
5
In general, coatings are applied to materials…
To change the material’s properties and/or
performance in some way
Examples:
Color, appearance, aesthetics
Environmental resistance
Abrasion, wear, friction
Electrical conductivity
Thermal conductivity
Static dissipation
Materials and Coatings
6
But sometimes…
Material properties change in unexpected
ways
Example: Nickel
plating on steel
(J.O. Almen,
1951)
Materials and Coatings
7
Materials and coatings interact with…
• Each other
• Their environment
• Other materials and coatings
Example: Zinc-plated
steel nut and nylon-
6,6 blowoff valve
Paint and Plastics
8
Paints interact with plastics in three ways…
• Chemical
• Thermal (i.e. cure cycle)
• Mechanical
Chemical Interactions
9
Solvents (including paint solvents) can cause …
• Swelling of the polymer
• Dissolution of the polymer
• Environmental stress cracking (ESC)
• Changes in molecular entanglement
Example: ESC of
ABS part due to
threadlocking
compound
Thermal Interactions
10
Curing of paint at elevated temperatures can cause …
• Accelerated solvent diffusion into plastic
• Relief of molded-in stresses
• Paint shrinkage (residual stress)
• Thermal degradation of plastic
Mechanical Interactions
11
Mechanical interactions depend on…
• Elastic mismatch
• Interfacial strength
• Film thickness
Figure adapted
from Hu and
Evans, 1989
How Can You Predict The Effects?
You can’t.
That’s why you test.
12
Experimental Set-up
13
Four plastic substrates…
Typically painted
Not typically
painted
All have similar mold shrinkage
(.006 - .008)
Substrates
General purpose ABS
High impact ABS
Weather resistant ASA
PA-6/PE ionomer blend
(Surlyn)
Experimental Set-up
14
Topcoat
Adhesion
promoter
#2
Adhesion
promoter
#1
Baseline
(no coating)
Topcoat: 2K acrylic
polyurethane
Adhesion promoter
#1: 40% aromatic
hydrocarbons
Adhesion promoter
#2: <2% aromatic
hydrocarbons
Testing
15
• Tensile modulus
• Tensile strength
• Strain at break
• Notched Izod impact strength
Baseline Results
16
General
purpose ABS
High impact
ABS
Weather
resistant ASA
PA-6/PE
ionomer blend
(mineral filled)
Tensile
modulus
(MPa)
2409 2004 2410 2195
Tensile
strength
(MPa)
41 37 42 38
Strain at
break 22% 5% 9% 38%
Impact
strength
(J/m)
360 616 137 306
Tensile Modulus
17
Tensile Modulus
18
General
purpose ABS
High impact
ABS
Weather
resistant ASA
PA-6/PE
ionomer blend
Topcoat only + 0 0 -
Adpro #1 only 0 + 0 -
Adpro #1 w/
topcoat - - 0 -
Adpro #2 only - - 0 -
Adpro #2 w/
topcoat - - 0 -
Statistically significant effects at 95% confidence level
Tensile Strength
19
Tensile Strength
20
General
purpose ABS
High impact
ABS
Weather
resistant ASA
PA-6/PE
ionomer blend
Topcoat only 0 - 0 +
Adpro #1 only - 0 0 +
Adpro #1 w/
topcoat 0 - 0 +
Adpro #2 only 0 - 0 +
Adpro #2 w/
topcoat 0 - - +
Statistically significant effects at 95% confidence level
Strain at Break
21
Strain at Break (Suryln)
22
Strain at Break
23
General
purpose ABS
High impact
ABS
Weather
resistant ASA
PA-6/PE
ionomer blend
Topcoat only - - 0 +
Adpro #1 only 0 0 0 +
Adpro #1 w/
topcoat 0 0 0 +
Adpro #2 only 0 0 0 +
Adpro #2 w/
topcoat 0 - 0 +
Statistically significant effects at 95% confidence level
Impact Strength
24
Impact Strength (Surlyn)
25
Impact Strength
26
General
purpose ABS
High impact
ABS
Weather
resistant ASA
PA-6/PE
ionomer blend
Topcoat only - - 0 +
Adpro #1 only - - 0 +
Adpro #1 w/
topcoat - - - +
Adpro #2 only - - - +
Adpro #2 w/
topcoat - - - +
Statistically significant effects at 95% confidence level
Observations
27
Styrenic polymers
(ABS and ASA):
Uncoated → necking
Coated → crazing
Crazing = less efficient
energy dissipation
mechanism
(lower impact strength)
Observations
28
PA-6/PE ionomer blend:
Uncoated → necking
Coated → more stable necking
Shear bands shown by
ruptured paint film
Conclusions
29
Painting can have significant effects on
mechanical strength of plastics.
These effects are complex and (at
present) difficult to predict.
The best way to determine the effect of
a given paint on a given plastic is to test.
Final Thoughts
30
“One good test is
worth 1000
expert opinions.”
– Wernher von Braun
(attributed)
For More Information
31
“Understanding the Effects of
Paint on Plastics,” Plastics
Technology, October 2014.
“Effects of Painting on Mechanical Properties
of Injection Molded Plastics,” Society of
Plastics Engineers ANTEC 2014.

More Related Content

What's hot

Technical Termopol presentation
Technical Termopol presentationTechnical Termopol presentation
Technical Termopol presentation
Oguz Turan
 
Elastomers(polymer)
Elastomers(polymer)Elastomers(polymer)
Elastomers(polymer)
Samyak Suyal
 
Thermoplastics Presentation 2012
Thermoplastics Presentation 2012Thermoplastics Presentation 2012
Thermoplastics Presentation 2012
DominiqueAdecco
 
Thermoset sales slides
Thermoset sales slidesThermoset sales slides
Thermoset sales slides
nabadie
 

What's hot (19)

Technical Termopol presentation
Technical Termopol presentationTechnical Termopol presentation
Technical Termopol presentation
 
Thermosets vs thermoplastic
Thermosets vs thermoplasticThermosets vs thermoplastic
Thermosets vs thermoplastic
 
Elastomers
ElastomersElastomers
Elastomers
 
Sebs polymer 502
Sebs polymer 502Sebs polymer 502
Sebs polymer 502
 
Everything You Need to Know About TPE Compounds, Chemistry, and Capabilities
Everything You Need to Know About TPE Compounds, Chemistry, and CapabilitiesEverything You Need to Know About TPE Compounds, Chemistry, and Capabilities
Everything You Need to Know About TPE Compounds, Chemistry, and Capabilities
 
Mechanical properties of polymer composite materials
Mechanical properties of polymer composite materialsMechanical properties of polymer composite materials
Mechanical properties of polymer composite materials
 
Elastomers(polymer)
Elastomers(polymer)Elastomers(polymer)
Elastomers(polymer)
 
Thermoplastics Presentation 2012
Thermoplastics Presentation 2012Thermoplastics Presentation 2012
Thermoplastics Presentation 2012
 
Plastics
PlasticsPlastics
Plastics
 
the Influence of the Anodizing Parameters on the anodized copper hardness
the Influence of the Anodizing Parameters on the anodized copper hardness the Influence of the Anodizing Parameters on the anodized copper hardness
the Influence of the Anodizing Parameters on the anodized copper hardness
 
Thermoplastic elastomers (TPE)
Thermoplastic elastomers (TPE)Thermoplastic elastomers (TPE)
Thermoplastic elastomers (TPE)
 
Thermoplastics and thermosetting plastics
Thermoplastics and thermosetting plasticsThermoplastics and thermosetting plastics
Thermoplastics and thermosetting plastics
 
Thermoset sales slides
Thermoset sales slidesThermoset sales slides
Thermoset sales slides
 
Plastics
PlasticsPlastics
Plastics
 
Tribological study of HDPE.pptx
Tribological study of HDPE.pptxTribological study of HDPE.pptx
Tribological study of HDPE.pptx
 
Thermoplastic and thermosetting polymers
Thermoplastic and thermosetting polymersThermoplastic and thermosetting polymers
Thermoplastic and thermosetting polymers
 
Polymer chemistry
Polymer chemistryPolymer chemistry
Polymer chemistry
 
Adhesive Guide
Adhesive GuideAdhesive Guide
Adhesive Guide
 
Sebs polymer 502 t
Sebs polymer 502 tSebs polymer 502 t
Sebs polymer 502 t
 

Viewers also liked

Babcock Ntuthuko Generation_Engineering_Capability
Babcock Ntuthuko Generation_Engineering_CapabilityBabcock Ntuthuko Generation_Engineering_Capability
Babcock Ntuthuko Generation_Engineering_Capability
Obakeng Serame Pr. Eng
 
Investigation on the corrosion of metal reinforcement in clay brick masonry
Investigation on the corrosion of metal reinforcement in clay brick masonryInvestigation on the corrosion of metal reinforcement in clay brick masonry
Investigation on the corrosion of metal reinforcement in clay brick masonry
Hsui Han Wong
 
Stress Ratio Effects in Fatigue of Lost Foam Aluminum Alloy 356
Stress Ratio Effects in Fatigue of Lost Foam Aluminum Alloy 356 Stress Ratio Effects in Fatigue of Lost Foam Aluminum Alloy 356
Stress Ratio Effects in Fatigue of Lost Foam Aluminum Alloy 356
Dave Palmer, P.E.
 
Effect of Surface Hardening Technique and Case Depth on Rolling Contact Fatig...
Effect of Surface Hardening Technique and Case Depth on Rolling Contact Fatig...Effect of Surface Hardening Technique and Case Depth on Rolling Contact Fatig...
Effect of Surface Hardening Technique and Case Depth on Rolling Contact Fatig...
Dave Palmer, P.E.
 

Viewers also liked (13)

Babcock Ntuthuko Generation_Engineering_Capability
Babcock Ntuthuko Generation_Engineering_CapabilityBabcock Ntuthuko Generation_Engineering_Capability
Babcock Ntuthuko Generation_Engineering_Capability
 
Presentacion lost foam
Presentacion lost foamPresentacion lost foam
Presentacion lost foam
 
Investigation on the corrosion of metal reinforcement in clay brick masonry
Investigation on the corrosion of metal reinforcement in clay brick masonryInvestigation on the corrosion of metal reinforcement in clay brick masonry
Investigation on the corrosion of metal reinforcement in clay brick masonry
 
Alloy casting tanoy
Alloy casting tanoyAlloy casting tanoy
Alloy casting tanoy
 
SAE 2015 World Congress: Chat With The Experts
SAE 2015 World Congress: Chat With The ExpertsSAE 2015 World Congress: Chat With The Experts
SAE 2015 World Congress: Chat With The Experts
 
Stress Ratio Effects in Fatigue of Lost Foam Aluminum Alloy 356
Stress Ratio Effects in Fatigue of Lost Foam Aluminum Alloy 356 Stress Ratio Effects in Fatigue of Lost Foam Aluminum Alloy 356
Stress Ratio Effects in Fatigue of Lost Foam Aluminum Alloy 356
 
Model Based Design of Hybrid and Electric Powertrains
Model Based Design of Hybrid and Electric PowertrainsModel Based Design of Hybrid and Electric Powertrains
Model Based Design of Hybrid and Electric Powertrains
 
Lost Foam Casting (LFC) Process
Lost Foam Casting (LFC) ProcessLost Foam Casting (LFC) Process
Lost Foam Casting (LFC) Process
 
Effect of Surface Hardening Technique and Case Depth on Rolling Contact Fatig...
Effect of Surface Hardening Technique and Case Depth on Rolling Contact Fatig...Effect of Surface Hardening Technique and Case Depth on Rolling Contact Fatig...
Effect of Surface Hardening Technique and Case Depth on Rolling Contact Fatig...
 
Lost foam cast process
Lost foam cast processLost foam cast process
Lost foam cast process
 
東海大學使用 NVIDIA Quadro & GRID 技術在教育雲端創新服務的經驗分享
 東海大學使用 NVIDIA Quadro & GRID 技術在教育雲端創新服務的經驗分享 東海大學使用 NVIDIA Quadro & GRID 技術在教育雲端創新服務的經驗分享
東海大學使用 NVIDIA Quadro & GRID 技術在教育雲端創新服務的經驗分享
 
資料永續與交換
資料永續與交換資料永續與交換
資料永續與交換
 
程式設計首日封
程式設計首日封程式設計首日封
程式設計首日封
 

Similar to Molding-2015-Palmer

What is UV curing systems 11 in industrial.ppt
What is UV curing systems 11 in industrial.pptWhat is UV curing systems 11 in industrial.ppt
What is UV curing systems 11 in industrial.ppt
goomang
 
Psa's and tapes the mfgr process
Psa's and tapes  the mfgr processPsa's and tapes  the mfgr process
Psa's and tapes the mfgr process
sachindesai055
 
2 Plastics - thermoplastics, thermosets and elastomers - a.docx
2 Plastics - thermoplastics, thermosets and elastomers - a.docx2 Plastics - thermoplastics, thermosets and elastomers - a.docx
2 Plastics - thermoplastics, thermosets and elastomers - a.docx
eugeniadean34240
 

Similar to Molding-2015-Palmer (20)

Fracture and failure analyses of plastics and reinforced plastics
Fracture and failure analyses of plastics and reinforced plasticsFracture and failure analyses of plastics and reinforced plastics
Fracture and failure analyses of plastics and reinforced plastics
 
What is UV curing systems 11 in industrial.ppt
What is UV curing systems 11 in industrial.pptWhat is UV curing systems 11 in industrial.ppt
What is UV curing systems 11 in industrial.ppt
 
Migrating vs non migrating in polymer
Migrating  vs non migrating in polymerMigrating  vs non migrating in polymer
Migrating vs non migrating in polymer
 
Session 40 Prabir Kumar Das
Session 40 Prabir Kumar DasSession 40 Prabir Kumar Das
Session 40 Prabir Kumar Das
 
Marine Corrosion Protection
Marine Corrosion ProtectionMarine Corrosion Protection
Marine Corrosion Protection
 
Functional and Design Opportunities Using PVD + UV Coatings
Functional and Design Opportunities Using PVD + UV CoatingsFunctional and Design Opportunities Using PVD + UV Coatings
Functional and Design Opportunities Using PVD + UV Coatings
 
Psa's and tapes the mfgr process
Psa's and tapes  the mfgr processPsa's and tapes  the mfgr process
Psa's and tapes the mfgr process
 
2 Plastics - thermoplastics, thermosets and elastomers - a.docx
2 Plastics - thermoplastics, thermosets and elastomers - a.docx2 Plastics - thermoplastics, thermosets and elastomers - a.docx
2 Plastics - thermoplastics, thermosets and elastomers - a.docx
 
PPT.pptx
 PPT.pptx PPT.pptx
PPT.pptx
 
PPT_sample format.pptx
PPT_sample format.pptxPPT_sample format.pptx
PPT_sample format.pptx
 
Plastics
PlasticsPlastics
Plastics
 
1
11
1
 
Plasma Plastics UV Cured Powder Coating
Plasma Plastics UV Cured Powder CoatingPlasma Plastics UV Cured Powder Coating
Plasma Plastics UV Cured Powder Coating
 
Product design and testing topics.pptx
Product design and testing topics.pptxProduct design and testing topics.pptx
Product design and testing topics.pptx
 
REINFORCED POLYMERIC COMPOSITE (RPC) MATERIALS
REINFORCED POLYMERIC COMPOSITE (RPC) MATERIALSREINFORCED POLYMERIC COMPOSITE (RPC) MATERIALS
REINFORCED POLYMERIC COMPOSITE (RPC) MATERIALS
 
HARDNESS AND TRIBOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF EPOXY COMPOSITE FILLED WITH REDU...
HARDNESS AND TRIBOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF EPOXY COMPOSITE FILLED WITH REDU...HARDNESS AND TRIBOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF EPOXY COMPOSITE FILLED WITH REDU...
HARDNESS AND TRIBOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF EPOXY COMPOSITE FILLED WITH REDU...
 
Design Fabrication and Static Analysis of Single Composite Lap Joint
Design Fabrication and Static Analysis of Single Composite Lap JointDesign Fabrication and Static Analysis of Single Composite Lap Joint
Design Fabrication and Static Analysis of Single Composite Lap Joint
 
POSTER
POSTERPOSTER
POSTER
 
IRJET- Fabrication and Testing of E-Glass with E-Waste as Filler Material
IRJET- Fabrication and Testing of E-Glass with E-Waste as Filler MaterialIRJET- Fabrication and Testing of E-Glass with E-Waste as Filler Material
IRJET- Fabrication and Testing of E-Glass with E-Waste as Filler Material
 
Experimental Test on Gfrp-Epoxy Composite Laminate for Mechanical, Chemical &...
Experimental Test on Gfrp-Epoxy Composite Laminate for Mechanical, Chemical &...Experimental Test on Gfrp-Epoxy Composite Laminate for Mechanical, Chemical &...
Experimental Test on Gfrp-Epoxy Composite Laminate for Mechanical, Chemical &...
 

Molding-2015-Palmer