SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
Examining Perceptions of E-Governance Participation in Public
Management and Water Conservation
The E-Water Gap
Brandon F. De Bruhl
Masters of Public Policy and Masters of Science in Analytics
Emily Chen (Yix
Masters of Public Policy
Rhett Parnaey
Masters of Public Policy and Masters of Planning
Prepared for the 2015 Los Angeles Symposium hosted at the RAND Corporation and Sponsored by the Price School of Public Policy
Finalist in the Fels Policy Challenge
Policy Solution:
LA Saves – A Water Engagement
E-Governance Platform.
Contest Award:
$5,000
Neubauer Gant Award:
$3,700
Total Funding:
$8,700
1 Introduction
Water is a California Problem
2 Background
Provided by the
United States
Geological Service
and the National
Geospatial Institute
for Resource
Management,
University of
California, Berkeley.
Los Angeles Water Management
(MWD,SCE and LADWP)
3 Background
Courtesy of the
Metropolitan
Water District,
Southern
California Edison
and the Los
Angeles County
Department of
Power and
Water.
Number of Water
Districts:
27
Individuals Served
6.7 Million
Number of Combined
Administrative
Offices:
114
Internal Water E-Government Practices
(Research Questions)
4 Project
Digital Governance in LA
(Status Quo)
5 Project
Capturing Public Administration of Water
(Methodical Approach)
6 Project
Survey Instruments
(Convince Sampling)
Data Collection
Survey Instrument:
Technical Panel:
Water Engineers
Administrative Panel:
Water Program Managers
Expert Elicitation
Policy Panel
City Officials
Water District Officials
Data Sources
Baseline Data:
Santa Catalina Company
(Southern California Edison)
Data Collection Participants:
Southern California Edison
Metropolitan Water District
Los Angeles Water and Power
7 Analysis
Multi-Attribute Utility Theory
(Decision Model)
Attributes Evaluated
Technological Perception of
E-Governance in Utility Score.
Administrative Perception of
E-Governance in Utility Score.
Policy Perceptions of E-
Governance in Utility Score.
Cost of a Internal E-
Governance System*.
8 Analysis
The decision process for water policy adoption.
Informing Water Governance
(Expected Results)
9 Analysis
Outcome One: Inform Decision Makers
Providing a Framework for Public Water Decision Makers to
understand and leverage e-governance in water.
Outcome Two: A Vehicle for Political Dialog
To provide a point of discussion to State and Municipal leaders
around the use of e-governance as a way to improve water
management.
Outcome Three: E-Governance Preference in Public Utilities
To open the public policy dialog around the use of e-governance in
the public utility space.
Limitations & Sensitivity
Sensitivity
Sensitivity Outside the Context of LA County
Value is Sensitive to Water Availability
Cost
Technology
Limitations of the Project
Sampling Bias
Omitted Variable Bias
Constrained by Time and Geography
Utility Score is only Represents the Values of Participants
9 Analysis
Brandon F. De Bruhl
Masters of Public Policy and Masters of Science in Analytics
Emily Chen
Masters of Public Policy
Rhett Parnaey
Masters of Public Policy and Masters of Planning
Prepared for the 2015 Los Angeles Symposium hosted at the RAND Corporation and Sponsored by the Price School of Public Policy
A Special Thank you to….
Daniel A. Mazmanian Ph.D
Academic Director, USC Schwarzenegger Institute for State and Global Policy
Diane Yoder Ph.D
Professional Practice of Public Administration

More Related Content

What's hot

Tony Maas, WWF - Investigating Shared Risk: What business does a Panda have t...
Tony Maas, WWF - Investigating Shared Risk: What business does a Panda have t...Tony Maas, WWF - Investigating Shared Risk: What business does a Panda have t...
Tony Maas, WWF - Investigating Shared Risk: What business does a Panda have t...
CWS_2010
 
GRI_Blue-Jobs-final-web
GRI_Blue-Jobs-final-webGRI_Blue-Jobs-final-web
GRI_Blue-Jobs-final-web
Holly Beilin
 
2. chapter 1 part 2 principles
2. chapter 1  part 2 principles2. chapter 1  part 2 principles
2. chapter 1 part 2 principles
Andrey Skopenko
 
Acadia Invasive Species Workshop December 2008
Acadia Invasive Species Workshop December 2008Acadia Invasive Species Workshop December 2008
Acadia Invasive Species Workshop December 2008
cconrad
 
Policy framework and ways forward Walid Saleh
Policy framework and ways forward Walid SalehPolicy framework and ways forward Walid Saleh
Policy framework and ways forward Walid Saleh
WANA forum
 

What's hot (20)

Topic 2
Topic 2Topic 2
Topic 2
 
Ensuring Clean Water Through Stormwater Rulemaking
Ensuring Clean Water Through Stormwater RulemakingEnsuring Clean Water Through Stormwater Rulemaking
Ensuring Clean Water Through Stormwater Rulemaking
 
Sustainability of borehole water schemes through community participation in e...
Sustainability of borehole water schemes through community participation in e...Sustainability of borehole water schemes through community participation in e...
Sustainability of borehole water schemes through community participation in e...
 
2 Do Close Elections Benefit the Poor, Johanna Koehler
2 Do Close Elections Benefit the Poor, Johanna Koehler 2 Do Close Elections Benefit the Poor, Johanna Koehler
2 Do Close Elections Benefit the Poor, Johanna Koehler
 
Water-Energy-Food Tradeoffs
Water-Energy-Food TradeoffsWater-Energy-Food Tradeoffs
Water-Energy-Food Tradeoffs
 
Abdelrahim, s. (2017). using citizen based observations to plan..
Abdelrahim, s. (2017). using citizen based observations to plan..Abdelrahim, s. (2017). using citizen based observations to plan..
Abdelrahim, s. (2017). using citizen based observations to plan..
 
Summary - Lecture 6: Urban Water Security
Summary - Lecture 6: Urban Water SecuritySummary - Lecture 6: Urban Water Security
Summary - Lecture 6: Urban Water Security
 
Newport Blue Economy Best Practices
Newport Blue Economy Best PracticesNewport Blue Economy Best Practices
Newport Blue Economy Best Practices
 
Tony Maas, WWF - Investigating Shared Risk: What business does a Panda have t...
Tony Maas, WWF - Investigating Shared Risk: What business does a Panda have t...Tony Maas, WWF - Investigating Shared Risk: What business does a Panda have t...
Tony Maas, WWF - Investigating Shared Risk: What business does a Panda have t...
 
1.1 Tony Maas
1.1 Tony Maas1.1 Tony Maas
1.1 Tony Maas
 
The Delta and its relationship to Integrated Water Resources Management
The Deltaand its relationship toIntegrated Water Resources ManagementThe Deltaand its relationship toIntegrated Water Resources Management
The Delta and its relationship to Integrated Water Resources Management
 
GRI_Blue-Jobs-final-web
GRI_Blue-Jobs-final-webGRI_Blue-Jobs-final-web
GRI_Blue-Jobs-final-web
 
TRIMS Features
TRIMS FeaturesTRIMS Features
TRIMS Features
 
The Impact of Human Activity on Lake Biwa and the Need for Water Management
The Impact of Human Activity on Lake Biwa and the Need for Water ManagementThe Impact of Human Activity on Lake Biwa and the Need for Water Management
The Impact of Human Activity on Lake Biwa and the Need for Water Management
 
Global River Flood Risks
Global River Flood RisksGlobal River Flood Risks
Global River Flood Risks
 
2. chapter 1 part 2 principles
2. chapter 1  part 2 principles2. chapter 1  part 2 principles
2. chapter 1 part 2 principles
 
Sustainability of Ground-Water Use in the San Pedro River Basin, Cochise Coun...
Sustainability of Ground-Water Use in the San Pedro River Basin, Cochise Coun...Sustainability of Ground-Water Use in the San Pedro River Basin, Cochise Coun...
Sustainability of Ground-Water Use in the San Pedro River Basin, Cochise Coun...
 
Acadia Invasive Species Workshop December 2008
Acadia Invasive Species Workshop December 2008Acadia Invasive Species Workshop December 2008
Acadia Invasive Species Workshop December 2008
 
Policy framework and ways forward Walid Saleh
Policy framework and ways forward Walid SalehPolicy framework and ways forward Walid Saleh
Policy framework and ways forward Walid Saleh
 
Sustainable Health - A New Vision for Programming JONATHAN FINK
Sustainable Health - A New Vision for Programming JONATHAN FINKSustainable Health - A New Vision for Programming JONATHAN FINK
Sustainable Health - A New Vision for Programming JONATHAN FINK
 

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (12)

April 2015 content 3
April 2015 content 3April 2015 content 3
April 2015 content 3
 
República de gambia
República de gambiaRepública de gambia
República de gambia
 
ACTIVIDAD DE EVALUACION 3
ACTIVIDAD DE EVALUACION 3ACTIVIDAD DE EVALUACION 3
ACTIVIDAD DE EVALUACION 3
 
الصدق - گرنگی ڕاستگۆيي -سوده‌كانی ڕاستگۆيیی - ئاودێر أحمد عبدالله-راستگۆ-Aw...
  الصدق - گرنگی ڕاستگۆيي -سوده‌كانی ڕاستگۆيیی - ئاودێر أحمد عبدالله-راستگۆ-Aw...  الصدق - گرنگی ڕاستگۆيي -سوده‌كانی ڕاستگۆيیی - ئاودێر أحمد عبدالله-راستگۆ-Aw...
الصدق - گرنگی ڕاستگۆيي -سوده‌كانی ڕاستگۆيیی - ئاودێر أحمد عبدالله-راستگۆ-Aw...
 
La Venus del Mirall , Velazquez (alumnes 3r ESO)
La Venus del Mirall , Velazquez (alumnes 3r ESO)La Venus del Mirall , Velazquez (alumnes 3r ESO)
La Venus del Mirall , Velazquez (alumnes 3r ESO)
 
Biomax presentacion
Biomax presentacionBiomax presentacion
Biomax presentacion
 
Amanda Whitt-Seminar Paper
Amanda Whitt-Seminar PaperAmanda Whitt-Seminar Paper
Amanda Whitt-Seminar Paper
 
Παιχνίδι με συλλαβές 2 (Πού είναι ο Άρης;)
Παιχνίδι με συλλαβές 2 (Πού είναι ο Άρης;)Παιχνίδι με συλλαβές 2 (Πού είναι ο Άρης;)
Παιχνίδι με συλλαβές 2 (Πού είναι ο Άρης;)
 
московский центр переговоров 2016 r
московский центр переговоров 2016 rмосковский центр переговоров 2016 r
московский центр переговоров 2016 r
 
العلم والتعلم
العلم والتعلمالعلم والتعلم
العلم والتعلم
 
Islm g3 p2 03 الصوم
Islm g3 p2 03 الصومIslm g3 p2 03 الصوم
Islm g3 p2 03 الصوم
 
Leonardo da Vinci
Leonardo da VinciLeonardo da Vinci
Leonardo da Vinci
 

Similar to Rand_E-Water Paper

BC Municipal Water Survey 2016
BC Municipal Water Survey 2016BC Municipal Water Survey 2016
BC Municipal Water Survey 2016
Dan Ward
 
UN Paper FINAL Published Version
UN Paper FINAL Published VersionUN Paper FINAL Published Version
UN Paper FINAL Published Version
Caroline Stevens
 
A Decade of Lessons Learned| COLSEN
A Decade of Lessons Learned| COLSENA Decade of Lessons Learned| COLSEN
A Decade of Lessons Learned| COLSEN
Cathy Olsen
 
Research Report - Kuldeep Ulhe
Research Report - Kuldeep UlheResearch Report - Kuldeep Ulhe
Research Report - Kuldeep Ulhe
Kuldeep Ulhe
 
Research Report - Kuldeep Ulhe
Research Report - Kuldeep UlheResearch Report - Kuldeep Ulhe
Research Report - Kuldeep Ulhe
Kuldeep Ulhe
 
Scaling Up in Watershed Management Research Projects
Scaling Up in Watershed Management Research ProjectsScaling Up in Watershed Management Research Projects
Scaling Up in Watershed Management Research Projects
AndesBFP
 
Deanna’s Input for Question 1As Chief Executive Officer of Ri.docx
Deanna’s Input for Question 1As Chief Executive Officer of Ri.docxDeanna’s Input for Question 1As Chief Executive Officer of Ri.docx
Deanna’s Input for Question 1As Chief Executive Officer of Ri.docx
edwardmarivel
 
Conference Paper: Citizen Field Engineers: Crowdsourced Maintenance of Connec...
Conference Paper: Citizen Field Engineers: Crowdsourced Maintenance of Connec...Conference Paper: Citizen Field Engineers: Crowdsourced Maintenance of Connec...
Conference Paper: Citizen Field Engineers: Crowdsourced Maintenance of Connec...
Ericsson
 

Similar to Rand_E-Water Paper (20)

TWJ_feedback interfaces 2016
TWJ_feedback interfaces 2016TWJ_feedback interfaces 2016
TWJ_feedback interfaces 2016
 
Most Pressing Water Issues
Most Pressing Water IssuesMost Pressing Water Issues
Most Pressing Water Issues
 
What are the Mos Pressing Water Issues Facing the U.S.?
What are the Mos Pressing Water Issues Facing the U.S.?What are the Mos Pressing Water Issues Facing the U.S.?
What are the Mos Pressing Water Issues Facing the U.S.?
 
BC Municipal Water Survey 2016
BC Municipal Water Survey 2016BC Municipal Water Survey 2016
BC Municipal Water Survey 2016
 
DAFNE project presentation: Supporting decision making for sustainable resour...
DAFNE project presentation: Supporting decision making for sustainable resour...DAFNE project presentation: Supporting decision making for sustainable resour...
DAFNE project presentation: Supporting decision making for sustainable resour...
 
UN Paper FINAL Published Version
UN Paper FINAL Published VersionUN Paper FINAL Published Version
UN Paper FINAL Published Version
 
A Decade of Lessons Learned| COLSEN
A Decade of Lessons Learned| COLSENA Decade of Lessons Learned| COLSEN
A Decade of Lessons Learned| COLSEN
 
Research Report - Kuldeep Ulhe
Research Report - Kuldeep UlheResearch Report - Kuldeep Ulhe
Research Report - Kuldeep Ulhe
 
Research Report - Kuldeep Ulhe
Research Report - Kuldeep UlheResearch Report - Kuldeep Ulhe
Research Report - Kuldeep Ulhe
 
Feurt Practice And Potential Of Ebm
Feurt Practice And Potential Of EbmFeurt Practice And Potential Of Ebm
Feurt Practice And Potential Of Ebm
 
Feurt Practice And Potential Of Ebm
Feurt Practice And Potential Of EbmFeurt Practice And Potential Of Ebm
Feurt Practice And Potential Of Ebm
 
Scaling Up in Watershed Management Research Projects
Scaling Up in Watershed Management Research ProjectsScaling Up in Watershed Management Research Projects
Scaling Up in Watershed Management Research Projects
 
Drainage Problem Analysis of Pabna City(Ward-10)
Drainage Problem Analysis of Pabna City(Ward-10)Drainage Problem Analysis of Pabna City(Ward-10)
Drainage Problem Analysis of Pabna City(Ward-10)
 
PROGRESS IN DEFINING THE WATER-ENERGY NEXUS: WHAT’S NEXT?
PROGRESS IN DEFINING THE WATER-ENERGY NEXUS: WHAT’S NEXT?PROGRESS IN DEFINING THE WATER-ENERGY NEXUS: WHAT’S NEXT?
PROGRESS IN DEFINING THE WATER-ENERGY NEXUS: WHAT’S NEXT?
 
Deanna’s Input for Question 1As Chief Executive Officer of Ri.docx
Deanna’s Input for Question 1As Chief Executive Officer of Ri.docxDeanna’s Input for Question 1As Chief Executive Officer of Ri.docx
Deanna’s Input for Question 1As Chief Executive Officer of Ri.docx
 
Conference Paper: Citizen Field Engineers: Crowdsourced Maintenance of Connec...
Conference Paper: Citizen Field Engineers: Crowdsourced Maintenance of Connec...Conference Paper: Citizen Field Engineers: Crowdsourced Maintenance of Connec...
Conference Paper: Citizen Field Engineers: Crowdsourced Maintenance of Connec...
 
Impacts of On-site Wastewater Treatment Systems on Water Quality and Quantity...
Impacts of On-site Wastewater Treatment Systems on Water Quality and Quantity...Impacts of On-site Wastewater Treatment Systems on Water Quality and Quantity...
Impacts of On-site Wastewater Treatment Systems on Water Quality and Quantity...
 
Summer Smart Water Use: A Guide to Peak Season Water Demand Management - Mass...
Summer Smart Water Use: A Guide to Peak Season Water Demand Management - Mass...Summer Smart Water Use: A Guide to Peak Season Water Demand Management - Mass...
Summer Smart Water Use: A Guide to Peak Season Water Demand Management - Mass...
 
Ecological Regionalism: Sustainable Urban Environments within a Regional Fram...
Ecological Regionalism: Sustainable Urban Environments within a Regional Fram...Ecological Regionalism: Sustainable Urban Environments within a Regional Fram...
Ecological Regionalism: Sustainable Urban Environments within a Regional Fram...
 
Korteling 7558
Korteling 7558Korteling 7558
Korteling 7558
 

Rand_E-Water Paper

  • 1. Examining Perceptions of E-Governance Participation in Public Management and Water Conservation The E-Water Gap Brandon F. De Bruhl Masters of Public Policy and Masters of Science in Analytics Emily Chen (Yix Masters of Public Policy Rhett Parnaey Masters of Public Policy and Masters of Planning Prepared for the 2015 Los Angeles Symposium hosted at the RAND Corporation and Sponsored by the Price School of Public Policy
  • 2. Finalist in the Fels Policy Challenge Policy Solution: LA Saves – A Water Engagement E-Governance Platform. Contest Award: $5,000 Neubauer Gant Award: $3,700 Total Funding: $8,700 1 Introduction
  • 3. Water is a California Problem 2 Background Provided by the United States Geological Service and the National Geospatial Institute for Resource Management, University of California, Berkeley.
  • 4. Los Angeles Water Management (MWD,SCE and LADWP) 3 Background Courtesy of the Metropolitan Water District, Southern California Edison and the Los Angeles County Department of Power and Water. Number of Water Districts: 27 Individuals Served 6.7 Million Number of Combined Administrative Offices: 114
  • 5. Internal Water E-Government Practices (Research Questions) 4 Project
  • 6. Digital Governance in LA (Status Quo) 5 Project
  • 7. Capturing Public Administration of Water (Methodical Approach) 6 Project
  • 8. Survey Instruments (Convince Sampling) Data Collection Survey Instrument: Technical Panel: Water Engineers Administrative Panel: Water Program Managers Expert Elicitation Policy Panel City Officials Water District Officials Data Sources Baseline Data: Santa Catalina Company (Southern California Edison) Data Collection Participants: Southern California Edison Metropolitan Water District Los Angeles Water and Power 7 Analysis
  • 9. Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (Decision Model) Attributes Evaluated Technological Perception of E-Governance in Utility Score. Administrative Perception of E-Governance in Utility Score. Policy Perceptions of E- Governance in Utility Score. Cost of a Internal E- Governance System*. 8 Analysis The decision process for water policy adoption.
  • 10. Informing Water Governance (Expected Results) 9 Analysis Outcome One: Inform Decision Makers Providing a Framework for Public Water Decision Makers to understand and leverage e-governance in water. Outcome Two: A Vehicle for Political Dialog To provide a point of discussion to State and Municipal leaders around the use of e-governance as a way to improve water management. Outcome Three: E-Governance Preference in Public Utilities To open the public policy dialog around the use of e-governance in the public utility space.
  • 11. Limitations & Sensitivity Sensitivity Sensitivity Outside the Context of LA County Value is Sensitive to Water Availability Cost Technology Limitations of the Project Sampling Bias Omitted Variable Bias Constrained by Time and Geography Utility Score is only Represents the Values of Participants 9 Analysis
  • 12. Brandon F. De Bruhl Masters of Public Policy and Masters of Science in Analytics Emily Chen Masters of Public Policy Rhett Parnaey Masters of Public Policy and Masters of Planning Prepared for the 2015 Los Angeles Symposium hosted at the RAND Corporation and Sponsored by the Price School of Public Policy A Special Thank you to…. Daniel A. Mazmanian Ph.D Academic Director, USC Schwarzenegger Institute for State and Global Policy Diane Yoder Ph.D Professional Practice of Public Administration