Day 1- afternoon session: Christian Henning, University of Kiel and Jonathan Mockshell , University of Hohenheim: “Understanding the policy process and landscape through discourse and network analysis: qualitative and quantitative approaches.”
Workshop on Approaches and Methods for Policy Process Research, co-sponsored by the CGIAR Research Programs on Policies, Institutions and Markets (PIM) and Agriculture for Nutrition and Health (A4NH) at IFPRI-Washington DC, November 18-20, 2013.
1. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Understanding the policy process and landscape
through discourse and network analysis:
Qualitative and quantitative approaches
Prof. Dr. Dr. Christian H.C.A. Henning and Jonathan
Mockshell, Universität Kiel and Hohenheim
Presentation at the IFPRI Workshop on Approaches and Methods for Policy
Process Research
18. November 2013
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
2. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
3. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Relevant Research Questions
Political Diagnosis:
Representation of society's interests in the policy process:
-
How good are society's
interests represented in the policy process, e.g. to what extend
elected politician are accountable to their electorate?
- Government Capture: To what extend policy process is
biased in favor of particular interests at the expense of the
general public?
- Political Ownership: To what extend feel relevant society
group's committed to implemented governmental policies?
Governmental Accountability:
Eciency of policy choice:
-
To what extend incorporate policy
beliefs of relevant politicians available scientic knowledge on
how policy instruments translate into policy outcomes?
Political Knowledge:
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
4. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Relevant Research Questions
Political Therapy:
Identify relevant factors implying low political performance:
-
Identify relevant policy and non-policy voting
motives of dierent social groups and their impact on political
performance (accountability, capture, ownership and political
knowledge).
- Lobbying structures: Identify relevant lobbying network structures
and their impact on political performance.
- Political Communication structure: Identify relevant political
communication structures and their impact on political belief
formation and learning.
Voter behavior:
Identify political strategies to increase political performance:
-
Constitutional rules, ME-systems,
Agricultural Sector Reviews
- Informal Institutions Change policy network structures via
Peak Stakeholder Organizations, obligatory
scientic/stakeholder advisory boards, public relation
organizations.
Formal Institutions:
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
5. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Outline of methodological approach PEBAP
I. Step: Qualitative Analysis
Policy Network based Coalition Framework Approach:
- Identication of relevant stakeholder and interest groups:
Expert interviews
- Identication of relevant policy concerns and policy beliefs:
Discourse analysis
- Identication of relevant coalitions:
Expert interviews and discourse analysis
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
6. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Outline of methodological approach PEBAP
II. Step: Quantitative approach: CGPE (Henning 2013)
Modeling Political Participation:
- Extended Baron-Grossman-Helpman-Model
Voting Module: Probabilistic Voter model
Lobbying Module: Extended Grossmann/Helpman lobbying
model incorporating policy networks
Modeling Political belief formation:
- Extended Friedkin-model including naive observational and
communication learning in policy networks among governmental and
non-governmental organizations
Modeling Political decision-making:
- Extended Baron-Ferejohn model of legislative bargaining
Modeling Economic response to policies:
- Policy Impact function
- Micro-Macro-linked CGE
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
7. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Qualitative Analysis
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
8. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Qualitative Analysis
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
9. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Qualitative Analysis
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
10. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Qualitative Analysis
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
11. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Qualitative Analysis
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
12. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Qualitative Analysis
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
13. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Qualitative Analysis: Main results
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
14. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
A Network Based Approach to Evaluate Participatory Policy
Processes: An Application to CAADP in Malawi
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
15. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Block model structure of political communication in Malawi
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
16. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Inuence proles in CAADP policy network in Malawi
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
17. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Participation structures and political consensus in the
CAADP process of Malawi
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
18. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Diagnosis: Participation structures and Political Performance
in the CAADP process of Malawi
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
19. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
From Diagnosis to Therapy: The impact of changed
participation structures on political performance in Malawi
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
20. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Thank You for your attention!
More about the PEBAP Projekt:
https://pebap.agrarpol.uni-kiel.de/
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
21. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Total political power distribution by lobbying scenario in
Malawi
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
22. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Estimation results probabilistic voter model Malawi
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes
23. Theoretical Framework of PEBAP
Discourse Analysis Ghana and Uganda
Policy Network Analysis CAADP Malawi
Voter motives and government performance in Malawi
Henning / Mockshell , University of Kiel and Hohenheim
Network Approach to model and evaluate policy processes