13 November, 2010 Two States Created in Name of Religion by classes not really religious ! Does the Pakistani liberal Exist Does the Pakistani liberal Exist ? An explanation why misuse of religion by so called liberal Indo Pak Muslims made Pakistan the most dangerous place in the world. So called secular Muslims of Indo Pak were speraheads of creation of separate Muslim majority state of India as they wanted political powers , and jobs and to monopolise the business and finance. While the so called fundamentalist Muslims who we now call extremists were in favour of living with non Muslims in a united India ! As a matter of fact Islamic Party leader Maududi dismissed Pakistans war with India in 1947-48 as a war that cannot be termed as a Jihad. This is very similar to case of Israel where secular Jews or Zionists wanted a separate Jewish state whereas the orthodox Jews were opposed to a Jewish state. After all the aim of creation of a state is not religion at all ,a lthough religion may be used as like a condom to achieve an end as in case of both Pakistan and Israel ! The real aim of creation of both states was patronage and domination over jobs, business and political power and this was successfully achieved by both Muslim classes in Pakistan and Jews in Israel , both of whom were not really interested in actual essence of Islam or Judaism ! A great British author Prof Francis Robinson brilliantly researched this thesis in his magnum bonum “ Separatism among Indian Muslims” while another brilliant US professor David Lelyveld brilliantly researched the same theme in “Aligarh –The First Generation”. As my grandfathers both paternal and maternal belong to this so called secular generation who wanted Pakistan , I can perfectly understand this ! And the net result since both Pakistan and Israel were created in name of religion whith which they had little real connection , both are destabilizing factors , and to make it more difficult both are nuclear weapon armed states ! Both were created with British support or American support and both are now biggest headaches today for the USA.But the USA cannot do anything about it ! Does the Pakistani liberal Exist ? by Major Agha H Amin (Retired) 13 November 2010 Misuse of Islam by westernised Muslim elite to achieve petty and narrow political and class agendas laid the foundation of Muslim extremism in India and Pakistan after 1947

1. 13 November, 2010
Does the Pakistani liberal Exist
Does the Pakistani liberal Exist ?
An explanation why misuse of religion by so
called liberal Indo Pak Muslims made
Pakistan the most dangerous place in the
world.
So called secular Muslims of Indo Pak were
speraheads of creation of separate Muslim
majority state of India as they wanted
political powers , and jobs and to monopolise
the business and finance.
While the so called fundamentalist Muslims
who we now call extremists were in favour of
living with non Muslims in a united India !
As a matter of fact Islamic Party leader
Maududi dismissed Pakistans war with India
in 1947-48 as a war that cannot be termed as
a Jihad.
This is very similar to case of Israel where
secular Jews or Zionists wanted a separate
Jewish state whereas the orthodox Jews
were opposed to a Jewish state.

2. After all the aim of creation of a state is not
religion at all ,a lthough religion may be used
as like a condom to achieve an end as in case
of both Pakistan and Israel !
The real aim of creation of both states was
patronage and domination over jobs,
business and political power and this was
successfully achieved by both Muslim classes
in Pakistan and Jews in Israel , both of whom
were not really interested in actual essence
of Islam or Judaism !
A great British author Prof Francis Robinson
brilliantly researched this thesis in his
magnum bonum “ Separatism among Indian
Muslims” while another brilliant US professor
David Lelyveld brilliantly researched the
same theme in “Aligarh –The First
Generation”.
As my grandfathers both paternal and
maternal belong to this so called secular
generation who wanted Pakistan , I can
perfectly understand this !
And the net result since both Pakistan and
Israel were created in name of religion whith
which they had little real connection , both
are destabilizing factors , and to make it more

3. difficult both are nuclear weapon armed
states !
Both were created with British support or
American support and both are now biggest
headaches today for the USA.But the USA
cannot do anything about it !
Does the Pakistani liberal Exist ?
by
Major Agha H Amin (Retired)
13 November 2010
Misuse of Islam by westernised Muslim elite
to achieve petty and narrow political and
class agendas laid the foundation of Muslim
extremism in India and Pakistan after 1947 .
Sir Syed Ahmad the so called father of Muslim
liberalism dismissed major Quranic Muslim
beliefs like Mairaj in his book interpreting
Quran but championed quotas in jobs on

4. basis of religion !
He dismissed anti British freedom fighters of
1857 as Paaji and Talangas ! He advised
British not to mix Hindus with muslims in the
army because it would eliminate religious
differences and lead to failure of British
policy of divide and rule ! Whereas before
1857 Muslims and Hindus were organised
amicably in mixed regiments ! The father of
Muslim renaissance despised Bengalis as
lower race !
Pakistans first use of Irregulars and Tribal
Warriors was done by a secular Governor
General and a Secular Prime Minister in
October 1947.
Pakistans first discriminatory law the
objectives resolution was passed by
Pakistans first educated Scotch drinking
Prime Minister Liaquat Ali Khan .
The blueprint of use of non state proxies in
neighbouring countries was laid in 1974 by
Pakistans most secular prime minister !

5. The most twisted and biased rightist army
chief with a twisted religious bug in his head
picked up by Pakistans most secular prime
minister !
Liquor banned and Friday declared a holiday
by Pakistans most secular prime minister in
1977 !
Military action launched in Balochistan by
Pakistans most secular prime minister !
Pakistans first major discriminatory law
declaring the Ahmadis as non Muslims was
created by its Barrister UK and Berkeley
educated Prime Minister and his brilliant
barrister Law Minister Hafeez Pirzada.
The Taliban the most extremist Islamists
were created by Pakistans liberal prime
ministers Benazir Bhuttos minister of interior
and supported by the PPP !
Pakistans most so called liberal army general

6. launches army regulars in Kargil and later
claims that these were all Mujahids ! The
regulars were disowned as Mujahids and
Indians had to give them Muslim burials !
Pakistans present prime minister was an
ardent member of Pakistans government
under Pakistans most notorious dictator Zia.
Pakistani liberalism does not exist but
Pakistani so called liberals have a history of
using religion for monetary and material
advantages !
Their bluff in name of Islam was well
understood after 9/11 and now the Islamists
are making the Pakistani state pay the price
through its nose !
ALL ALONG WITH UNEVEN GAPS PAKISTANS
SO CALLED SECULAR , WESTERNISED ,
DECADENT ,OPPORTUNISTIC ELITE AS
REPRESENTED BY ITS MILITARY AND
POLITICAL ELITE HAS BEEN MISUSING
PAKISTANS AND AFGHANISTANS CANNON
FODDER MASSES TO FIGHT PROXY WARS IN
NAME OF ISLAM ! AFTER 9/11 THE
CONTRADICTION WAS EXPOSED AND THE

7. RESULTANT ONGOING CIVIL WAR IN
PAKISTAN !
PAKISTANS ISLAMISTS AT A CERTAIN TIME
AND POINT IN HISTORY HAVE THE
POTENTIAL TO OVERWHELM THE PAKISTANI
STATE !
THIS CALCULATION AND ASSESSMENT IS
BASED ON A CLOSE STUDY OF THE
EXTREMISTS FROM 1979 TILL TO DATE AND
PARTICULARLY IN AFGHANISTAN AND FATA
FROM 2003 TILL TODATE !
Their bluff in name of Islam was well understood after 9/11 and now the Islamists are making the
Pakistani state pay the price through its nose !
--
http://www.scribd.com/doc/21693873/Indo-Pak-Wars-1947-71-A-STRATEGIC-AND-OPERATIONAL-
ANALYSIS-BY-A-H-AMIN
Man would indeed be in a poor way if he had to be restrained by fear of punishment and hope of
reward after death." --
Albert Einstein !!!