3. Theories of Social and Personality
Development
Psychoanalytic Perspectives: Freud
Genital Stage
Primary developmental task: libido
channeled into healthy sexual relationship
Psychosexual maturity achieved
4. Psychoanalytic Perspectives
Psychosocial Perspective: Erickson
Identity versus Role Confusion Stage
Primary developmental task: Achievement of
personal identity
Reflects understanding of one’s unique traits
and how they manifest across ages and
social roles
5. Psychoanalytic Perspectives
Erickson: Identity versus Role Confusion
Sense of self becomes integrated
Identification with peer groups
or
Inability to have an integrated view of self
6. Marcia’s Theory of Identity
Achievement
Overview
Identify statuses rooted in Erikson’s identity
process
Identity formation has two key parts
Crisis
Commitment
8. Four Identity Statuses
Figure 12.1 Marcia’s Identity Statuses
Four identity
statuses proposed
by Marcia based on
Erikson’s theory.
For fully achieved
identity, young
person must have
both examined
value/goals and
reached firm
commitment.
9. Stop and Think
What influence does culture have
within this theoretical perspective?
10. Self-Understanding
Components of self-understanding
More abstract definition of psychological
self
Academic self-concepts from internal
comparisons and external comparisons
Social self-concepts predict behavior
11. Mirror, Mirror on the Wall
Figure 12.2 Changes in Teens’ Self-Descriptions
As they grow
older, children
and adolescents
define themselves
less and less by
what they look
like and more and
more by what
they feel.
12. Self-Concept
Social Self-Concept and Gender
Gender Differences
Different manifestation by gender
Girls influenced by internal and external
comparisons
Boys influence more internal and self-
defined
14. Self-Concept
Gender Role Identity
Gender role: Gender-related aspects of
psychological self
Adolescents continue to understand sex
roles as social conventions
Gender role identity more flexible
15. Check the next slide!
Can you see how dimensions of
masculinity and femininity interact
to produce different types of sex-
role orientations?
Do these orientations make sense
to you?
17. Self-Concept
Ethnic Identity
Ethnic identity: Self-identification as member
of specific group and unique individual
Jean Phinney’s three stages of ethnic identity
formation
Unexamined ethnic identity
Ethnic identity search
Clear ethnic identity
20. Moral Development
Kohlberg’s Theory of Moral Reasoning
Preconventional reasoning: Judgments
based on positive or negative consequences
to the child
Protocol response to moral dilemmas
3 levels with 2 substages each
22. Figure 12.4 Colby & Kohlberg’s Longitudinal
Study of Moral Reasoning
Figure 12.5
23. Causes and Consequences of Moral
Development
Causes
Progression in age and corresponding
cognitive development
Decline of egocentrism
Improvement in role-taking
Support from social environment
24. Causes and Consequences of Moral
Development
Fill in the blanks
Growth of moral reasoning associated
with ______in adolescent prosocial
behaviors and ______ in antisocial
behavior.
25. Criticisms of Kohlberg’s Theory
Culture and Moral Reasoning
Narrow approach not universal
Non-Western cultures do not fit well with
Kohlberg’s approach
26. Criticisms of Kohlberg’s Theory
Moral Reasoning and Emotions
Nancy Eisenberg
Empathy: Ability to identify with others’
emotions both cause and consequence of
moral development
Inability to control emotional triggers
(antisocial behaviors)
Age-related and individual differences in
ability to regulate emotions
27. Criticisms of Kohlberg’s Theory
Moral Reasoning and Emotions
Carol Gilligan
Ethics based on caring for others and on
maintaining social relationships
Two distinct orientations
Gender differences
North American bias
29. Moral Development and Antisocial
Behavior
Overview
Delinquency: Adolescent behavior that breaks
laws
Two sub-variations by age of delinquency
onset
Child onset is more serious and likely to
present into adulthood
Adolescent onset is milder and more
transitory; peer group influenced
30. Moral Development and Antisocial
Behavior
Delinquency
Deliquents:
Lack empathy (for parents, victims)
Behind peers in moral reasoning
Deficits in role-taking skills
31. Social Relationships
Parents
Adolescents have two contradictory
tasks: establish autonomy and maintain
relatedness
Conflicts with parents increase but
attachment still high
• Individual traits and cultural factors affect
degree and meaning of parent–teen conflict
32. Relationships with Parents
Attachment
Strong attachment to parents matter!
Sense of well-being more strongly correlated
with quality of parent than peer attachment
Strong attachments associated positive short-
term and long-term outcomes
35. Relationships with Peers
Friendships
Skills
Considerable variation in interpersonal skills
needed to maintain friendships
Often dependence on electronic
communication
Individual differences
36. Relationships with Peers
Overview
Peer Groups
Relatively stable
Share values, behaviors, identity status
Explicit peer pressure more likely directed
toward positive activities
38. Relationships with Peers
Couple Formation
Adolescent Romantic Relationships
12-13 years have concepts of being “in love”
Gender differences
Income differences
Age of puberty onset differences
Variations across cultures
39. Relationships with Peers
Romantic Relationships
Heterosexual Teen Relationships
Relationships proceed at faster pace for girls
than boys
Use skills gained in relating to other-sex
peers in friendships and mixed groups to
prepare for romantic relationships
40. Relationships with Peers
Romantic Relationships
Homosexual Teens
Awareness of same-sex attraction around
ages 11 or 12
May initially experiment with heterosexual
relationships
Gender differences
Social support important
41. Did you have a best friend or friends when
growing up? Was your group of friends like
what those described by research? Were
your grade school friends important to you?
What stage of identity development, as
described by Marcia, have you achieved?
Why? How does one get to identity
achievement?
Questions To PonderQuestions To PonderQuestions To PonderQuestions To Ponder
Editor's Notes
“Last stage” of personality development
Includes both adolescents and adults
Identity versus Role Confusion
Primary developmental task: Achievement of personal identity
Identity is a sense of self-continuity
Reflects understanding of one’s unique traits and how they manifest across ages and social roles
Sense of self becomes integrated because of rapid growth and sexual changes of puberty
Sense of self becomes integrated
Identity crisis
Identification with peer groups protects against emotional turmoil
Role confusion results from the inability to have an integrated view of self
New demands and roles create many challenges
Identify statuses rooted in Erikson’s identity process
Identity formation has two key parts
Crisis
Period of decision-making when old values and choices are reexamined
Commitment
Follow some specific role, value, goal, or ideology
Identity achievement – both crisis and commitment have been processed.
Moratorium – currently experiencing crisis but no commitment has been made.
Foreclosure – commitment without crisis; accepted parental or culturally defined commitment.
Identity Diffusion – no crisis or commitment.
The quest for personal identity continues throughout the lifespan with alternating periods of instability and stability.
Family rooted in and influenced by current cultural assumptions
Family rooted in cultural assumptions and strongly influenced by current cultural assumptions
Appearance prominent in pre-teen and early teen but less important in later adolescence
More abstract definition of psychological self
Comprised of enduring traits, beliefs, personal philosophy, and moral standards
Able to see oneself in different roles
Different roles as a student than with friends, with parents, with romantic partners, etc.
Academic self-concepts come from internal comparisons and external comparisons.
Internal comparison – to a self-generated ideal.
External comparison – to peer performance.
Social self-concepts predict behavior.
The perceived lack of competency in family relations appears to be distinct from other components of self-concept.
Appearance prominent in pre-teen and early teen but less important in later adolescence
More abstract definition of psychological self
Comprised of enduring traits, beliefs, personal philosophy, and moral standards
Able to see oneself in different roles
Different roles as a student than with friends, with parents, with romantic partners, etc.
Academic self-concepts come from internal comparisons and external comparisons.
Internal comparison – to a self-generated ideal.
External comparison – to peer performance.
Social self-concepts predict behavior.
The perceived lack of competency in family relations appears to be distinct from other components of self-concept.
Sense of global self-worth
Overall, self-esteem rises through adolescence but drops at beginning of adolescence
High self-esteem associated with positive developmental outcomes such as good grades or resisting peer pressure
Boys more likely than girls to either have continuous high self-esteem or rising self-esteem during adolescence
Parental attitudes and parental behavior become increasingly important in shaping teens’ ideas about gender and sex roles.
Masculine and Feminine are not polar opposites, but dimensions along a continuum.
Sandra Bem’s typology
Masculine
Feminine
Androgynous
Undifferentiated
Androgynous and masculine gender roles associated with higher self-esteem among boys and girls
Feminine gender identity more prone to rumination
Adoption of androgynous or masculine identity by girls lead to lower self-esteem
Ethnic Identity
Self-identification as a member of their specific group,
Commitment to that group and its values and attitudes,
Development of some attitudes about the group which they belong.
Often poorly supported by dominant culture
Family support and teaching helps form a strong sense of ethnic identity
Jean Phinney’s 3 stages of ethnic identity formation
Unexamined ethnic identity – includes negative images and stereotypes common in the wider culture and how his own group is perceived by the majority culture.
Ethnic identity search – triggered by some experience that makes ethnicity relevant.
Clear ethnic identity – resolution of conflicts and contradictions.
Some choose their own ethnic group pattern exclusively.
Others choose a bicultural identity – consistently flow between the ethnic and majority culture.
Achieving identity may be more complex—difference between biological aspects of race and psychological nature of ethnic identity
Range of factors interact with teen’s personality:
Hazing and emotional trauma
Family variables
Neighborhood variables
Presence of other salient identities
Possible clashes between parents’ cultural values and the new culture
Communal versus individualism for Asian-American teens
May feel guilty about individualist strivings
3 levels with 2 substages each
Preconvention
Conventional
Postconventional
Level 1: Preconventional reasoning
Judgments are based on sources of authority – usually parents.
The outcome or consequence of an action determines the rightness or wrongness of the action.
Stage 1 – punishment and obedience orientation: Physical consequences determine right or wrong – if he is punished, it’s wrong.
Stage 2 – individualism, instrumental purpose, and exchange: You should do things that are rewarded and avoid things that are punished.
naïve hedonism: If you help me, I’ll help you.
Level 2: Conventional reasoning
Judgments are based on rules or norms of a group to which the individual belongs.
Stage 3 – Mutual interpersonal expectations, relationships, and interpersonal conformity.
Sometimes called good boy/nice girl stage.
Good behavior is what pleases other people.
They value loyalty, respect, trust, and maintenance of mutual relationships.
Stage 4 – Individualism, instrumental purpose, and exchange.
Norms of a large reference group – the stage of social systems or conscience.
Adhering to a complex set of regulations. Morality and legality are equivalent.
Level 3: Postconventional reasoning
Judgments are based on emergence of a personal authority.
Stage 5 – Social contracts orientation.
Rules, laws, and regulations ensure fairness. Laws may need to be ignored to ensure fairness.
Civil disobedience – deliberately breaking laws that were believed to be immoral are examples.
Stage 6 – The universal ethical principles orientation.
Explains moral decisions based on universal ethical principles such as right to life.
View these findings from a longitudinal study of boys from age 10 through adulthood. With age, how did the stage or level of their answers change?
Longitudinal research relating parenting styles and family climate to moral reasoning suggest that Kohlberg is right about the need for social support.
Age and corresponding cognitive development needed to progress from stage to stage
Decline of egocentrism is critical
Role-taking improves an adolescent’s ability to reason from another’s perspective
Support from the social environment needed to sustain moral reasoning
Growth of moral reasoning associated with increases in adolescent prosocial behaviors and decreases in antisocial behavior
Longitudinal research relating parenting styles and family climate to moral reasoning suggest that Kohlberg is right about the need for social support.
Age and corresponding cognitive development needed to progress from stage to stage
Decline of egocentrism is critical
Role-taking improves an adolescent’s ability to reason from another’s perspective
Support from the social environment needed to sustain moral reasoning
Example – respect for elders is essentially more important than justice in some cultures.
Non-Western cultures do not fit well with Kohlberg’s approach
Although justice is an important moral concept around the world
Justice does not supercede all other moral considerations in non-Western cultures
Age-related and individual differences in ability to regulate emotions should be considered
Gilligan notes two distinct moral orientations – justice and care.
Girls reason based on care orientation; boys relatively more on justice
Recent research of sex differences suggests North American bias
Neither adolescents nor adults reason same way in every situation—situational factors may determine actual behavior
Negatives associated childhood-onset problems include: displays of overt aggression; rejection by peers; support from other delinquents; parents with histories of antisocial behaviors; likelihood to use drugs and alcohol; truancy and dropping out of school; and early and risky sexual behaviors.
Delinquents lack empathy (for parents, victims, etc)
Are behind peers in moral reasoning because of deficits in role-taking skills
Childhood-onset problems more serious and more often persist
Temperament and personality play a role.
Parents who fail at early attempts to control bad behavior may worsen the behaviors.
Delinquent adolescents may exhibit serious disturbances in thinking.
Adolescent-onset problems typically reflect peer-group influences
Negatives associated childhood-onset problems include: displays of overt aggression; rejection by peers; support from other delinquents; parents with histories of antisocial behaviors; likelihood to use drugs and alcohol; truancy and dropping out of school; and early and risky sexual behaviors.
Rise in conflicts with parents in adolescence.
Center around everyday issues such as chores or personal rights.
Hairstyles, dating, and amount of parental supervision.
Parent-teen conflicts appear to cause more stress for parents than for teens.
Remains strong during adolescence
Strong attachments associated with academic success and good peer relations; less risk for drug use and antisocial behavior in later life
May be influenced by pubertal status
Children and teems from different ethnic groups were asked about the amount and type of support they received from various sources
NOTE: For teens, friends become more significant source of support, but parents do not become less important
Friendships become increasingly intimate
Share more inner feelings and secrets
More knowledgeable about each other’s feelings
More stable than those of younger children
Electronic communication more important, such as email
Thus today’s teens have wider range of friendship than earlier generations did
Skills
Considerable variation in interpersonal skills needed to maintain friendships
Important to learn negotiation and conflict skills
Reasons for ending friendships reflect differences in rate of development of social skills.
Individual differences: temperament, personality, experiences, and rate of social skill development
Importance of popularity and peer acceptance strengthens from elementary years: peaks in early adolescence
These provide an identity prototype – labeling others and oneself as belonging to a group helps to create or reinforce the adolescent’s own identity.
It also identifies friends or foes.
Clique – 4 to 6 young people who are strongly attached to one another
Early years cliques are same-sex
Crowds – larger sets that include males and females
Break down into heterosexual cliques and then into loose associations of couples
Crowds are popular between 13 and 15, when the teen is most likely to display the greatest conformity to peer pressure.
Reputation-based group – teen identifies with group either by choice or by peer designation
Some relationship focus on love and other companionship
Gender differences: girls derive more psychological intimacy from early relationships than boys
Early dating and early sexual activity more common in poor of every ethnic group and those who experience early puberty
Heterosexual Teen Relationships
Proceed at a faster pace for girls than for boys
Skills gained in relating to other-sex peers in friendships and mixed groups prepare them for romantic relationships
Social competence in a variety of relationships prepares teens to move to romantic relationships
Physical sexuality coupled with skills in personal intimacy
The sense of being in love is an important factor in adolescent dating patterns
Boys act on same-sex attraction earlier than girls do
Social support from clubs and extracurricular activities is important for gay and lesbian teens