Olympus	NDT	Canada,	Quebec		
	
Scalable	NDT	instruments	for	the	
inspec<on	of	variable	geometry	
components		
	
Presenter	|	E$enne	Grondin
Agenda	
1.  Introduc<on	and	evolu<on	of	NDE	in	the	avia<on	industry				
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
2.  Complex	geometry	inspec<on	challenges				
3.  Goals		
4.  Solu<on	:	Adap<ve	phased	array		
•  Design	introduc$on	&	overview		
•  Results	
5.  Conclusion	&	next	steps
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Introduc<on	
§  Ultrasonic (UT) technology & instruments
have been used in a wide variaty of
industries for NDE over the last 20 years
§  Introduction of carbon laminates composite,
in conjuction with recent low oil prices
helped airline companies to save money,
explaining above normal growth
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Introduc<on	
§  Consequently, aviation components manufacturers
are facing new challenges:
§  Rise in production rate
§  Increasingly complex geometry
§  Lack of skilled operators
§  More demanding inspection
requirements
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Introduc<on	
§  Evolution of PA instruments
help address these challenges
§  Scalable PA instruments
provide the following benefits
§  Faster inspection
§  Improved coverage for
better repeatability
§  Improved radius inspection
High	pulsing	frequency	
PRF	
Up	to	20	kHz	
High	data	transfer	rate	
Data	Throughput	
Up	to	30	MB/s
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Introduc<on	
§  Some challenges remain when full
volumetric inspection of varying
geometry (varying, flatten radius,
tilted parts) is required.
§  Today, these parts are either
inspected manually or via complex
mechanical devices that are error-
prone, hard to configure, and costly
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Challenges	
§  Inspection of carbon laminate parts with the following characteristics:
§  Variable radius
§  Variable opening angle
§  Twisted
§  Inspection of non-constant (weighted) radius generated by the
manufacturing process
§  Inspection of rounded flat surfaces generated by the inspection process
§  Part vs probe alignment (curved and flat arrays)
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Goals	
§  Improve & simplify the inspection of complex geometry components
§  Variable & weighted radius
§  Variable opening and twisted parts
§  Flexible solution to enable inspection from:
§  Inside & outside radius
§  Flat surface
§  Efficient solution
§  Inspection speed has to be similar to what is achieve today with standard phased array
§  Reliable & robust solution
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Introduc<on	
0dB
-3dB
-6dB
BeamWidth
Delay
PA probe
Wave front
Part
PA probe
Delay
Part
Wave front
§  What is the most desirable configuration?
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Introduc<on	
Delay
PA probe
Wave front
Part
PA probe
Delay
Part
Wave front
§  What is the most desirable configuration?
FW
BW ?
FW
BW
0dB
-3dB
-6dB
BeamWidth
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Introduc<on	
Delay
0dB
-3dB
-6dB
BeamWidth
PA probe
Wave front
Part
FW
BW ?
0dB
-3dB
-6dB
BeamWidth
PA probe
Delay
Part
Wave front
FW
BW
§  Adaptive phased array is an
iterative process that
enables the transmission of
a wave-front parallel to the
part n iterations
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Design	
Delay Bank
Pulser Nb.
Delay
Delay Bank
Pulser Nb.
Delay
L1
0 L2
0
…………………………………….......... Ln
0
0dB
-3dB
-6dB
BeamWidth
PA probe (Rx)
Part
BW ?
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Design	
0dB
-3dB
-6dB
BeamWidth
PA probe (Tx)
Wave front
Part
BW ?
Wave front
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Design
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Design	
Is the frontwall corrected within a predefined tolerance (δ ) ?
+δ
- δ
+δ
- δ
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Design	
Delay
Part
Wave front
0dB
-3dB
-6dB
BeamWidth
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Results	
§  Simulation
Configuration First iteration Last iteration
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Results	
§  Case 1: Varying radius
§  Part & scan parameters
§  Geometry: L shape
§  Radius : 5 mm to 10 mm
§  Scan : External face
§  Probe : 5CC25-32R4
§  Wedge : SR4-IE90
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Results	
§  Case 1: Varying radius
§  Results
§  Detection
§  2830 with APA
§  2030 without APA
§  Defect Size
§  77 mm2 with APA
§  66 mm2 without APA
§  SNR
§  23 dB with APA
§  9 dB without APA
Figure 1 : Amplitude C-scan with APA
Figure 2 : Position C-scan with APA
Figure 3 : Amplitude C-scan without APA
Figure 4 : Position C-scan without APA
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Results	
§  Case 2: Varying radius
§  Part & scan parameters
§  Geometry: L shape
§  Radius : 5mm to 10mm
§  Scan : Internal face
§  Probe : 5CC25-32R4
§  Wedge : SR4-IE90
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Results	
§  Case 2: Varying radius
§  Results
§  Detection
§  2630 with APA
§  1830 without APA
§  Defect Size (area in mm)
§  91 mm2 with APA
§  84 mm2 without APA
§  SNR
§  22 dB with APA
§  22 dB without APA
Figure 1 : Amplitude C-scan with APA
Figure 2 : Position C-scan with APA
Figure 3 : Amplitude C-scan without APA
Figure 4 : Position C-scan without APA
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Results	
§  Case 3: Varying & weighted radius
§  Part & scan parameters
§  Geometry: L shape
§  Radius: 5 mm to 10 mm
§  Weighted: 10 mm
§  Scan: Internal face
§  Probe: 5CC25-32R4
§  Wedge: SR4-IE90
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Results	
§  Case 3: Varying & weighted radius
§  Results
§  Detection
§  2630 with APA
§  1330 without APA
§  Defect Size (area in mm)
§  90 mm2 with APA
§  88 mm2 without APA
§  SNR
§  12 dB with APA
§  0 dB without APA
Figure 1 : Amplitude C-scan with APA
Figure 2 : Position C-scan with APA
Figure 3 : Amplitude C-scan without APA
Figure 4 : Position C-scan without APA
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Results	
§  Productivity
Parameters
Number of
elements
32
Aperture size 4
Aperture steps 1
Water path 25 mm
Material thickness 8.5 mm
Material velocity 2700 ms
Number of
iterations
5
PRF with APA PRF without APA
300 Hz 517 Hz
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Adap<ve	PA	Solu<on	Results	
§  Reliability and ruggedness
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Conclusion	
§  Improve & simplify the inspection of complex geometry components
§  Variable & weighted radius
§  Variable opening and twisted parts
§  Flexible solution enabling inspection from
§  Inside & outside radius
§  Flat surface
§  Efficient solution
§  Inspection speed has to be similar to what is acheive today with
standard phased array
§  Reliable & robust solution
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Conclusion	and	next	steps
OLYMPUS Scientific Solutions
Conclusion	and	next	steps		
Figure 1 : With first generation APA
Figure 2 : With second generation APA
Olympus	Scien<fic	Solu<ons	
Thank	you	
	
For	more	info	please	contact	
E<enne.grondin@olympus-ossa.com

Scalable NDT Instruments for the Inspection of Variable Geometry Components