The Dream of AR
The Target Market
Number
of
Professors teaching Number of Students enrolledUse of technology in classroom?Willingness to implement more tech usage?UG Government19,00042,813
✓
✓ ✓
✓UG Politics21,000Masters Government12,00026,321Masters Politics13,000Law School10,232 full-time
17,021 part-time38,392
Target Market Challenge
The education market has been around for 100’s of years
Unique structure
Same uniform curriculum
Are teachers and professors ready for the change?
Set in old ways
Expanding their horizon
Unique structure
Uniform curriculum
Well structured
well respected
?
Willing to change
Jt
Partners
Undergraduate and graduate school with democracy programs and organizations.
What courses and organizations exist now?
EDX: Massive open online course (MOCC)
The university of Missouri: Constitutionalism and Democracy series
Georgetown College: M.A. program in democracy and governance
ADP: a network focused on engaged citizens for our democracy. ( American Democracy project)
Colgate University: DM is a nonpartisan organization for educating people about the role of private money in politics and its impact on democracy.
Who:Herbert N. Ramy,Professor of Academic Support Director, Academic Support Program. Law Writing class.
Summary:
glad to use technical tools to help him to teach the class.
Just 5 points to the video game to willingness.(1-10)
Never uses Role simulation to teach students.
He didn’t exclude teaching with video games, but the content must match the courses.
Increase educational technology into undergraduate studies.
Conclusion:
He believes in technology, doesn't really use it, he cares about the relevance of content with his class content.
If we educate democracy in the form of video games, our audience may be particularly small.
For that, we gave up the video game instead of AR.
The interview with Law School professor
Survey Analysis
Do you prefer using hardcover textbooks or eBooks?
Do you think a cell phone or tablet can be valuable in class?
Do you think technology helps the learning process?
Survey Analysis Continued..
Imagine using your cell phones or tablets camera as a scanner, that scans a image on your eBook or textbook and then provides a better understanding of what you are learning through a pre recording of a professor speaking to you.Would you be interested?
Would you be interested in learning about a subject through an app you downloaded on your cell phone or tablet?
How can we promote democracy better?
AR
Because of target market challenge,
Give up video game
Choose Augmented Reality
What is Augmented Reality?
Augmented reality is an interactive experience of a real-world environment where the objects that reside in the real-world are "augmented"
computer-generated perceptual information, sometimes across multiple sensory modalities, including visual, auditory, haptic, and olfactory.
Video:
https://w.
1. The Dream of AR
The Target Market
Number
of
Professors teaching Number of Students enrolledUse of
technology in classroom?Willingness to implement more tech
usage?UG Government19,00042,813
✓
✓ ✓
✓UG Politics21,000Masters Government12,00026,321Masters
Politics13,000Law School10,232 full-time
17,021 part-time38,392
Target Market Challenge
The education market has been around for 100’s of years
Unique structure
Same uniform curriculum
Are teachers and professors ready for the change?
Set in old ways
2. Expanding their horizon
Unique structure
Uniform curriculum
Well structured
well respected
?
Willing to change
Jt
Partners
Undergraduate and graduate school with democracy programs
and organizations.
What courses and organizations exist now?
EDX: Massive open online course (MOCC)
The university of Missouri: Constitutionalism and Democracy
series
Georgetown College: M.A. program in democracy and
governance
ADP: a network focused on engaged citizens for our democracy.
3. ( American Democracy project)
Colgate University: DM is a nonpartisan organization for
educating people about the role of private money in politics and
its impact on democracy.
Who:Herbert N. Ramy,Professor of Academic Support
Director, Academic Support Program. Law Writing class.
Summary:
glad to use technical tools to help him to teach the class.
Just 5 points to the video game to willingness.(1-10)
Never uses Role simulation to teach students.
He didn’t exclude teaching with video games, but the content
must match the courses.
Increase educational technology into undergraduate studies.
Conclusion:
He believes in technology, doesn't really use it, he cares about
the relevance of content with his class content.
If we educate democracy in the form of video games, our
audience may be particularly small.
For that, we gave up the video game instead of AR.
The interview with Law School professor
4. Survey Analysis
Do you prefer using hardcover textbooks or eBooks?
Do you think a cell phone or tablet can be valuable in class?
Do you think technology helps the learning process?
Survey Analysis Continued..
Imagine using your cell phones or tablets camera as a scanner,
that scans a image on your eBook or textbook and then provides
a better understanding of what you are learning through a pre
recording of a professor speaking to you.Would you be
interested?
Would you be interested in learning about a subject through an
app you downloaded on your cell phone or tablet?
How can we promote democracy better?
AR
Because of target market challenge,
Give up video game
5. Choose Augmented Reality
What is Augmented Reality?
Augmented reality is an interactive experience of a real-world
environment where the objects that reside in the real-world are
"augmented"
computer-generated perceptual information, sometimes across
multiple sensory modalities, including visual, auditory, haptic,
and olfactory.
Video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=9&v=GbpqwU
UfMAQ
(magic leap whale)
javie
Different kinds of approaches Trusted
ContentAttractiveConvenienceProfessor TrainingStudents
ResponsibilityUse of MobilityVirtual Reality ✕ ✓ ✕
✓ ✓ ✕
Role Simulation
Video game ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✕
Board Game ✓ ✕
✓ ✓ ✕
✕
Augmented Reality ✓ ✓ ✓ ✕
6. ✓ ✓
javier
The advantages of AR
For product promotion
If you can imagine, AR can do it.
Create advantages for product
Improving students’ experience by raising the degree of
awareness and helping them understand what they want
Flexible
Tong
How Augmented Reality Works?
Augmented Reality works by deploying virtual images over
real-world objects.
The overlay is executed immediately with the input received
from a camera or another input device like smart glasses.
Augmented Reality technology brings virtual objects into the
surrounding environment.
Javie
Tiny Book solution for students
7. Javier. We specialize in the pain points of our consumers.
We came up with this as we tried ourselves using AR on books.
We realized we needed to have a desk in front of us.
10 million copies in europe, penguin picked it up.
Patent it !!!
Tiny books in the shape of a phone with AR codes.
javier
Tiny book Price Point
Typically, Tiny books are priced at $4.99-$29.99.
Our Tiny book price: $24.99
Calculated process from Survey:
Competitors and Threats
Other AR books using this technology to teach
Research shows AR is only being used for explaining and
teaching astronomy, human and animal anatomy
8. Well branded and established textbooks and technology
companies looking to create a new way of teaching
App creators who are hired just to create
There are no government textbooks or applications using
Augmented Reality!
jt
Price Point
What Is Fair And Reasonable Price?
Do Analysis
Understand User Expectations
Free or $0.99
More complex utilities $2.99-$4.99
$4.99+ require a wide feature set and a lot of touches
Experiment
Identify Your Target Customer
To create and make a new Augmented Reality application: At
least $100,000-$200,000
Simple AR application: $30-50,000
Our Augmented Reality Publish Price: FREE
Freda
The key to pricing your app is to find a balance between
functionality and user expectations. If they are not happy, they
will tell them by comments and ratings. Try different price
ranges and, most importantly, don't rely on the app's initial
sales price to increase revenue.
Augmented/ Virtual Reality Revenue Forecast ($B)
9. Freda
By 2020, the AR/VR industry is conservatively projected to be
worth upwards of $120 Billion.
Recommendation
Choosing a trustworthy software creator
AppInstitute
Appy Pie
GoodBarber
Choosing a Small book company to publish
Tiny Fox Press
C & R Press
Tupelo Press
Red Hen Press
Our recommendation revolves around the fact that we need to
secure the patent and choose a software creator and small book
publisher
Ensuring complete safety when going onto the next step
Jeff
Conclusion
16. The Recommendation
2
javier
Talk about the outline of the story,
Mention the size of our surveys and interviews plus 2dary
research.
Survey Demographics
3
N: 12
How long: 1 week
Classes taught: BLE, MKT, Social Change, Public Policy.
Why: Get more preferences and thoughts from
teachers
N: 38
How long: 1 week
Why: Our target market is mainly college students
javier
We also run interviews.
The Knowledge of Democracy
100% of professors surveyed are interested in implementing
democracy in their class.
17. Students learning interest:
Knowledge on Democracy is assumed, it’s not taught!
4
interested
not
interested
jeffrey
Talk about professors as well. They want to teach democracy
Back up data for taking for granted. (prof interview)
It’s not part of most curriculums and there is no specific class
about it.
It’s a topic that’s given for granted that we all know about.
Just like grammar, or calculous.
The Market Challenge
Current Education Content & Pricing
Expensive ($48-$384)
Bulky Textbooks (1.2- 4.8 lbs)
Well established and structured curriculum
Over 100,000 students studying law & politics
Roughly 60,000 professors teaching government
19. Only 3 out of 12 professors liked it.
91% of students don’t have headsets.
Risky tech.
7
javier
In paper vr is the best option. Incredibly real experiences,
students would love it and it would totally do an amazing job of
teaching democracy. Outside of paper, in reality, it’s not
feasible:
One of our biggest pushers of our product would not support it.
Professors did not choose virtual reality at all in the survey.
It’s invasive, and not every professor might feel comfortable
wearing one of those on their face with everyone watching.
The technology is very young and a lot could go wrong when
trying to do an exercise all at the same time.
Not many students have headsets. (figure out number from
survey) no space in a classroom.
Do to the novelty, there is lack of workforce and a lack of
competitive pricing when developing this.
20. Role Simulation Video Game
8
Positives:
Great learning tool
Negatives:
Training for professors needs to be provided.
Not used at home
Takes one class to learn how to use
Complex development.
Takes one class to teach, and another to learn (Students take on
average a class to get a hold of how to play. (survey)
Training for professors needs to be provided (dents, 2018)
Javier
What else can be learned from survey
It’s great because of this: immersive it is, it is new therefore
better welcomed, usually through role playing it allows users to
experience in a very direct way the life of a decision maker for
example.
On our survey we learned that people have laptops. Our
secondary research tells us community colleges might not have
them.
21. Development is very expensive. Due to the immersive nature of
the technology. Role playing requires many small details.
Too complex for prof. We know that
The reason that killed it for us was that professors had a hard
time implementing it in their class. Secondary research tells us
it’s very important that they are aware and knowledgeable on
how the game works.
Our survey tells us that it might just be too intrusive, specially
when democracy is not part on anyone's curriculum.
They require a big learning curve. (did you have trouble
learning how to play?)
Can’t be used for one single class. But no more than 3, they
take too much in the curriculum. (for how many classes did you
use it?)
(did you use it outside the classroom)
Usable only once
The Board Game
No mobility
22. Home, Classrooms
Professors won’t invest time
It takes one class just to figure out how to play
Professor funded
9
Jeffrey
Augmented Reality (AR)
10
Javier
Think of it as watching a vid on a book.
It expands the knowledge in a book with a video like
experience,
It’s a new technology, half of the technology is going to be in
the book
Low risk. You can simply use the book if there is a problem
with democracy.
23. Augmented Reality + Books
11
Expectations
TIME
AR
Javier.
The non boring and inmersive youtube videos and the
credibility of books.
Why partner with a book. Get ahead of the curve.
Close to 90% of students believed a book is most credible than
an app or a simulation game.
SHE IS GETTING AHEAD AHEAD OF THE CURVE, THE
OPPORTUNITY IS NOW.
Low cost of development. Low risk.
It’s able to do this: Still images in a book now show more than
a 1000 words. Without having to google, waste time with videos
you don’t want to watch.
Content in books is trusted more than simulations, apps.
(Student survey)
Why partner up with books.
Prof more willing to implement (survey)
Students are already ivesting a lot in them (survey)
They like books. The feel, the ownership. (survey)
24. Augmented Reality + Books
Students View
Already pay for books
Ownership of book for future reference
Perfect balance of internet and books
Professors View
Better if no training required
Better if no technology issues
More likely to recommend a book
12
javier
Survey says students study better with books, but google is a
big player as well. Balancing both out is important. While
getting rid of the bad experience of each. Boring book, and
distracting internet.
Think of it as watching a vid on a book.
It expands the knowledge in a book with a video like
experience,
It’s a new technology, half of the technology is going to be in
the book
Low risk. You can simply use the book if there is a problem
with democracy.
25. College students still like studying from books. They like
(survey)
Professors are more likely to suggest a book (survey
Professors won’t need to be trained.
Students are already paying high amounts of money for books.
(survey
Students like to keep their books (survey)
No big risk required from anyone, if AR (new tech) fails there
is still a book to back it up.
Entering the market with AR
Students will buy the book if recommended by professor
Student’s view
80% students would buy supplementary books.
13
Professor’s view
No democracy professors
Interested in making it a part in 1 class only
They need a prepared package
Remember, democracy is not yet even an entire class in most
universities.
This is more about prof interest in democracy versus the tech.
Prof wouldn’t dedicate more than 1 class to the topic. We can’t
26. go from not being taught at all to suddenly everyone caring.
Not dependent on being on the curriculum. Book can be bought
by individuals of all walks of life, then read it at the comfort of
their home.
Students in the survey showed more willingness to spend 20$ on
a physical book than on an app.
Professors liked the medium as material for extra
knowledge.(survey)
Survey.
Professors like the idea of testing students on the content of the
book, or having a short project due. (Interview)
Competition
14
Jeffrey
https://tophat.com/blog/textbook-companies-disrupted/
Flipbacks
27. Vertical Structure
Size of a Kindle Reader
10 million copies sold as of 2017
Potential
15
jeffrey
Need for content
Need for marketing space
Flipbacks as Supplementary Books
80% of students would buy supplementary books.
90% Students like the idea of being able to multitask
Only one hand is busy while using the flipback
Study with Google 30% and 70% with books
57% of students would buy a book if recommended by professor
28. 16
Javier
Find out how much students liked the product. Insert
percentage.
Need for content
Need for marketing space
Flipback Advantages
Patented ✓
17
Freda
This is not the normal book,Flipback in the shape of a phone
with AR codes. And we will obtain the patented.
According to the survey, students like to using books, because
they can Writing on it to take a note and highlighting sth they
think useful/important; the feel of it on your hands.
29. Price
18
Price Point ✓
Survey Statistic: $21-25
$24.99
To create and make a new AR App : $100,000-$200,000
Simple AR application: $30,000-50,000
Our AR App Publish Price: FREE
Freda
According to the survey, students invested lots of money, like
$300-450 on textbooks each semester,
As a student, they don’t want to pay more on an app. The
purpose of our app, is to give students a better understanding of
knowledge.
And the price we set up for flipback is also include the app. So
if you pay on flipback for $24.99 you will get the free app.
Recommendation
30. Small Publishers + Small App Developer
19
Freda
We choose the small company, because there is a change
happening in marketplace.The five main textbook companies
which Jeffery mentioned before are being disrupted. Change is
happening. We are getting a head. Before that happens, we will
figure out the solutions.
It is good for work with small publishers and work with small
application developer. we don’t want to be super big.
First Client
.
Undergraduate and graduate schools with democracy programs
and organizations
31. 20
Students are interested in learning about democracy.
___ Pedagogical value of polling-place observation by students
Tong
There are existed democracy programs and organizations.
Her study shows that students are interested in learning about
democracy.
Recommendation Continued
Distribution Channel
.
In survey people use Amazon
Therefore:
Insert logo from Amazon.
Recomednations from Amazon.
32. 21
Tong
Amazon quote on the survey.
Flipbooks + AR
.
Like harry potter paintings, flipback books will bring boring to
life.
Technology will keep developing over the years, and books like
this will become the norm
33. Safeguard Democracy
They say voter ignorance is killing democracy, maybe we have
stumbled with a much bigger solution.
22
javier
Thank you
23
Reference
35. Business Opportunities for International Forest Products
within the Agricultural Chemicals and Fertilizers Industry
Written for International Forest Products
Chief Operating Officer
Vice President Marketing Intelligence
Vice President Global Transportation
Chief Financial Officer
Vice President Operations
Running head: BUSINESS OPPORTUNITES FOR
INTERNATIONAL FOREST PRODUCTS
2
BUSINESS OPPORTUNITES FOR INTERNATIONAL FOREST
PRODUCTS
Table of Contents
Executive Summary 1
Project Focus 1
Research Findings 1
Recommendations 2
Introduction 2
Project Overview 2
36. Research Overview 3
Company Overview 3
Industry Analysis 4
Chemicals Industry 4
Tariffs 5
Industry Drivers 6
Industry Challenges 7
Major Players 8
Value Chain 10
Opportunities 12
Research 12
Latin America 14
Africa 16
Conclusion 17
Recommendations 19
Bibliography 20
Appendix A 23
Appendix B 25
List of Tables and Figures 37
BUSINESS OPPORTUNITES FOR INTERNATIONAL FOREST
PRODUCTS
Executive Summary
Project Focus
The focus of this report was to address whether is there an
opportunity in the agricultural chemicals industry for
International Forest Products. By conducting primary and
secondary research, we were able to understand agricultural
chemicals industry through exploration of the tariffs, industry
drivers, industry challenges, major players, and the value chain.
Our research of these key parts of the agricultural chemicals
industry allowed us to identify potential business opportunities
and offer recommendations for.
37. Research Findings
Our research found that chemical industry is 69 percent of the
larger sector of the materials industry, and is broken down in
five sectors -- specialty; diversify; fertilizers and agricultural;
industrial gas; and commodity[footnoteRef:1]. We focused our
research on the agricultural chemicals and fertilizers sector of
the chemicals industry which makes up 15 percent of the total
industry1. Through our research into Chapter 31 of the
Harmonized System (HS) codes, we found that the major raw
components of fertilizer are 3102 Nitrogen, 3103 Phosphate,
and 3104 Potash, and that all fertilizers imported into the
United States are duty free[footnoteRef:2] [footnoteRef:3]. Our
research also revealed three key industry drivers energy prices,
government regulations, and commodity pricing[footnoteRef:4].
We also found that there are four industry challenges:
Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs); organic foods; safety;
and the short product life cycle of fertilizers[footnoteRef:5].
Through our research into the production of Potash, Nitrogen
and Phosphate, we identified five major players in the
agricultural chemicals industry. These include ICL, Mosaic, CF,
Potash, and Agrium[footnoteRef:6] [footnoteRef:7]
[footnoteRef:8] [footnoteRef:9] [footnoteRef:10]. Potash and
Agrium merged into Nutrien in January 20186 8. We also found
that companies that produce agricultural chemicals and
fertilizers are typically involved in every part of the value chain
from extraction to retail. [1: Chemicals Industry Surveys
(2017, November). Retrieved from
https://www.capitaliq.com/CIQDotNet/Research/DocumentView
er.aspx?documentViewerDocumentId=37881073#
] [2: Harmonized Tariff Schedule. (2018, March 29). Retrieved
from hts.usitc.gov: https://hts.usitc.gov/current
] [3: U.S. International Trade Commission. (n.d.). Harmonized
Tariff Schedule Search. Retrieved April 11, 2018, from
https://hts.usitc.gov/
] [4: Dun and Bradstreet. (2018, February 19). Agricultural
38. Chemical Manufacturing. Retrieved from
http://www.mergentintellect.com/index.php/search/firstResearch
Report/CHMA/Agriculturalchemical20180219.pdf
] [5: Loria, K. (2017, February 23). GMO market growing at
3.2% CAGR. Retrieved from
https://www.fooddive.com/news/gmo-market-growing-at-32-
cagr/436711/
] [6: Agrium. (2018, February). Annual Report. Retrieved
April 11, 2018, from
https://www.nutrien.com/sites/default/files/uploads/2018-
02/2017 AGRIUM Annual Report FINAL.pdf ] [7: The Mosaic
Company. (2017, February 3). ANNUAL REPORT PURSUANT
TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE
ACT OF 1934. Retrieved April 5, 2018, from
http://investors.mosaicco.com/Cache/c38082405.html ] [8:
Potash Corp. (2018, February). Annual Report. Retrieved April
11, 2018, from
https://www.nutrien.com/sites/default/files/uploads/2018-
02/2017 PotashCorp Annual Report.pdf ] [9: Israel Chemicals.
(2018, February). Annual Report. Retrieved April 11, 2018,
from http://iclgroupv2.s3.amazonaws.com/corporate/wp-
content/uploads/sites/1004/2018/03/ICL-2017-Annual-Report-
20-F.pdf ] [10: CF Industries. (2018, February). Annual
Report. Retrieved April 11, 2018, from
https://www.snl.com/Cache/1001234503.PDF?O=PDF&T=&Y=
&D=&FID=1001234503&iid=4533245 ]
When researching opportunities for International Forest
Products, our team found that there are three major factors that
increase the need for fertilizer and they are high population, the
production of corn, and the production of
cotton[footnoteRef:11] [footnoteRef:12] [footnoteRef:13]. In
addition to these three factors, we also researched the countries
that produce the most bananas (as it was noted that International
Forest Products maintains relationships with Dole and
Chiquita). We concluded that the places with the biggest
39. business opportunities for International Forest Products are
Latin America and West Africa. In Latin America, the country
of Brazil is dependent upon imported fertilizer to make up the
gap between domestic production and
consumption[footnoteRef:14]. This gap could provide an
opportunity for International Forest Products to enter the
Brazilian market West Africa also is dependent on imported
fertilizer and has been expanding its harvesting land area to
increase its crop production[footnoteRef:15]. [11:
Keshrinandan Enterprise. (2016). World Corn Production
2015/2016. Retrieved from
https://www.keshrinandan.com/corn/world-corn-production-
20152016/ ] [12: USDA. (2018). Retrieved from
https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/ogamaps/map.aspx?cmdty=Cotton&attr
ibute=Production ] [13: World Atlas (2017). Top Banana
Producing Countries In The World. Retrieved from
https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/top-banana-producing-
countries-in-the-world.html ] [14: Simões, D. C., Caixeta-
Filho, J. V., & Palekar, U. S. (2018). Fertilizer distribution
flows and logistic costs in Brazil: changes and benefits arising
from investments in port terminals. International Food &
Agribusiness Management Review, 21(3), 407-422.
doi:10.22434/IFAMR2017.0037
http://ezproxysuf.flo.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/
login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=128757921&site=ehost-
live ] [15: Mulholland, S. (2017, JULY 07). CRU. Retrieved
from CRU INTERNATIONAL LTD:
https://www.crugroup.com/knowledge-and-
insights/spotlights/is-2017-a-turning-point-for-west-african-
fertilizer-demand/ ]
Recommendations
1
BUSINESS OPPORTUNITES FOR INTERNATIONAL FOREST
PRODUCTS
40. Our three recommendations to International Forest Products are
as follows: Match buyers to suppliers in West Africa and Brazil;
finance smaller players in the market; or, conversely, not enter
the agricultural chemicals industry.
Introduction
Project Overview
Our project explored the business opportunities for International
Forest Products within the agricultural chemicals and fertilizers
industry. Our goal was to determine if there was an opportunity
for International Forest Products to enter the agricultural
chemicals industry through financing. By conducting primary
and secondary research, we were able to understand the current
climate of the agricultural chemicals industry, such as what the
major ingredients are in agricultural chemicals and what
countries need these chemicals the most. This understanding
allowed us to identify potential business opportunities in these
areas. In addition,, we could determine the major manufacturers
and distributors of key chemicals and fertilizers, which allowed
us to examine which companies need logistics and financing
services, thus providing an opportunity for IFP to enter the
market through those portals. . This report provides an in-depth
examination of the international agricultural chemicals industry,
the current climate within the industry, business opportunities,
and several recommendations on how to enter the agricultural
chemicals industry through logistics and financing.
Research Overview
To gain a better understanding of the agricultural chemicals
industry, we started our research focusing broadly on the
chemicals and fertilizer industry. First we defined the chemical
industry as being an umbrella term used for various sub
industries, including the fertilizer industry. We then defined the
agricultural chemical industry as being a subset of the chemical
industry and as being an umbrella term for the fertilizer
industry. We wanted to understand how this industry looked
41. internationally, what were the major drivers of the market, who
were the major players, and what countries used agricultural
chemicals the most and for what purpose.
Company Overview
International Forest Products is a privately-owned subsidiary of
the Kraft Group that handles the international logistics and
transportation of paper products, including paper, pulp and
wood, for other companies. International Forest Products
currently is ranked the sixth largest exporter in the
U.S.[footnoteRef:16]. For research purposes, we defined
International Forest Products industry as “paper and pulp
manufacturing”. Figure 1, from Mergent First Research
database, shows the growth rate of the paper and pulp
manufacturing industry from 2017 to a projected 2022. [16:
International Forest Products. (2016). International Forest
Products General Business Overview. Retrieved from
file:///C:/Users/Mia/Downloads/IFP General Presentation
(2).pdf
]
Figure 1: Paper and Pulp Manufacturing Industry Annual
Growth Rate
Retrieved From: Mergent. (2018, March 12). Paper & Paper
Products Manufacturing.
The paper and pulp manufacturing industry revenue is expected
to grow at an annual compounding rate of 2 percent between the
years 2018 to 2022[footnoteRef:17]. [17: Mergent. (2018,
March 12). Paper & Paper Products Manufacturing. Retrieved
from http://mergent.firstresearch-
learn.com/industry.aspx?chapter=0&pid=145
]
42. Since International Forest Products is a privately held company,
certain types of financial information is not available. However,
based on what we were told in the client's initial presentation to
us, we can assume that International Forest Products has strong
financial backing from the Kraft Group. Other assumptions that
were made include the idea that the company provides a high
level of customer service to its clients and that it can expand its
business with its current clients. These assumptions were all
based on extensive meetings with the clients over the course of
several months.
Industry Analysis
Chemicals Industry
According to an industry survey conducted by Standard and
Poor’s NetAdvantage, the chemical industry is 69 percent of the
larger sector of the materials industry[footnoteRef:18]. The
chemicals industry is broken down in five sectors -- specialty,
diversify, fertilizers and agricultural, industrial gas and
commodity3. Figure 2 shows the five sectors by percentage of
the industry. [18: Chemicals Industry Surveys (2017,
November). Retrieved from
https://www.capitaliq.com/CIQDotNet/Research/DocumentView
er.aspx?documentViewerDocumentId=37881073#
]
Figure 2: Chemical Industry Sectors
Retrieved From: Chemicals Industry Surveys (2017, November).
The fertilizers and agricultural chemicals sector makes up 15
percent of the industry3. This sizable percentage was a factor
that helped us to decide to focus our research on the fertilizers
and agricultural chemicals sector.
The outlook for the agricultural chemical manufacturing
industry is predicted to grow at a higher rate than the paper and
pulp manufacturing industry. Figure 3 visualizes the annual
43. revenue rate of the agricultural chemicals manufacturing
industry.
Figure 3: Agricultural Chemicals Manufacturing Industry
Growth Rate Retrieved From: Mergent (2017, November 13).
First Research.
According to Mergent First Research database, this sector is
projected to grow at an annual compounding rate of 5 percent
between the years 2018 to 2022[footnoteRef:19]. Compared to
the 2 percent predicted growth rate of International Forest
Products current industry, the agricultural chemicals industry
presents an attractive opportunity for International Forest
Products. [19: Mergent (2017, November 13). First Research.
http://mergent.firstresearch-
learn.com/industry.aspx?chapter=0&pid=161
]
Tariffs
To understand the tariffs on agricultural chemicals and
fertilizers, we looked at the Harmonized System codes, or HS
codes, on fertilizers. Appendix A is a table that deals with
Chapter 31, which contains all the HS codes dealing with
fertilizer and agricultural chemicals[footnoteRef:20]
[footnoteRef:21]. The relevant HS codes for the agricultural
chemical industry were 3102 Nitrogen, 3103 Phosphate, and
3104 Potash5 6. According to the Chapter 31, as of 2018, all
fertilizers imported into the United States are duty free5 6.
Database restrictions did not allow us to find the tariffs for
fertilizers in other countries. [20: Harmonized Tariff Schedule.
(2018, March 29). Retrieved from hts.usitc.gov:
https://hts.usitc.gov/current
] [21: U.S. International Trade Commission. (n.d.).
Harmonized Tariff Schedule Search. Retrieved April 11, 2018,
from https://hts.usitc.gov/
44. ]
Industry Drivers
In an industry report by Mergent First Research on the
agricultural chemicals industry, we located three key industry
drivers. The first industry driver is energy prices. The cost of
chemicals is directly related to cost of natural
gas[footnoteRef:22]. Natural gas is used in the production of
nitrogen, a key chemical ingredient in most fertilizers. Natural
gas is used as a source of hydrogen and heat in the production
of Nitrogen7. The second driver is government regulations.
Regulations for fertilizer in the United States come from both
the state level, as individual states have their own regulations,
and the federal level from the Department of Agriculture. The
Environmental Protection Agency also sets regulations and
standards for fertilizers. The third driver is commodity prices
such as the price of crops, metal and other raw materials. Crops
and fertilizer have a direct relationship with one another as
fertilizer is used to grow crops and fertilizer is dependent on the
production of crops. Metals and fertilizer have a direct
relationship with one another as the containers that are used to
transport, and store fertilizers are made from various metals.
[22: Dun and Bradstreet. (2018, February 19). Agricultural
Chemical Manufacturing. Retrieved from
http://www.mergentintellect.com/index.php/search/firstResearch
Report/CHMA/Agriculturalchemical20180219.pdf
]
This chart, retrieved from the United States Department of
Agriculture’s website, depicts the historical price of fertilizer
and the raw ingredients of fertilizer over the course of 16 years
beginning in 2000[footnoteRef:23]. [23: Mosheim, R. (2018,
February 21). United States Department of Agriculture.
Retrieved from usds.gov: https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-
products/fertilizer-use-and-price.aspx
45. ]
Figure 4: Fertilizer Price Index
Retrieved From: Mosheim, R. (2018, February 21). United
States Department of Agriculture.
The graph shows the historic prices of nitrogen and phosphate
but excludes potash8. The Department of Agriculture, for
reasons unknown, ceased collection potash data in 1983. The
price that farmers paid for fertilizer is significantly lower than
the price of the individual fertilizer components, most likely
since most farmers purchase fertilizer in bulk and therefore can
pay significantly less than retailers would pay for fertilizer.
Industry Challenges
The agricultural chemicals industry also faces many challenges.
One of the primary challenges is GMOs, or Genetically
Modified Organisms. GMOs are being used as a substitute for
fertilizer and agricultural chemicals. In the United States alone,
the use of GMOs is expected to grow 3.2 percent annually from
2018 through 2021[footnoteRef:24]. This poses a significant
problem for the agricultural chemicals industry because GMOs
do not require fertilizers. Another significant challenge is the
rising popularity of organic foods. The organic food industry is
currently being estimated to be growing at a rate of 14 percent
in the United States alone[footnoteRef:25]. The increase of
sales in organic foods could reduce farmer’s consumption of
agricultural chemicals. [24: Loria, K. (2017, February 23).
GMO market growing at 3.2% CAGR. Retrieved from
https://www.fooddive.com/news/gmo-market-growing-at-32-
cagr/436711/
] [25: Organic Food and Beverage Market Growth Projected at
14 Percent Before 2021. (2018, January 03). Retrieved April 19,
2018, from http://www.organicauthority.com/organic-food-and-
46. beverage-market-growth-projected-at-14-percent-before-2021/
]
One of the biggest challenges of the agricultural chemicals
industry is safety. Transportation of fertilizers and agricultural
chemicals is extremely dangerous and heavily regulated due to
the risk of explosion 7. This also makes the agricultural
chemical a high target for terrorists, because their potential use
in creating explosives for attacks. The final challenge faced by
this industry is the short product life cycle of agricultural
chemicals and fertilizers. When these products are used
constantly, diseases and insects become immune over time to
the fertilizers and chemicals7. This creates the short product
life cycle as producers of fertilizers need to create different
formulas to stay effective and keep up with demand.
Major Players
Now that we have examined the agricultural chemicals industry,
we are going to focus in and explore the major players of the
agricultural chemicals industry. The chemicals industry analysis
graph depicts the capacity of each company by millions of tons
per year, broken down by potash, phosphate and nitrogen, the
three major components of fertilizer[footnoteRef:26]. [26:
Jones, A. (2017). Who Are the Biggest Players in the Fertilizer
Industry? Retrieved April 11, 2018, from
https://marketrealist.com/2017/01/industry-overview-biggest-
players-fertilizer-industry
]
Figure 5: Chemical Industry Analysis Companies by Total NPK
Capacity
Retrieved From: Jones, A. (2017). Who Are the Biggest Players
in the Fertilizer Industry? Retrieved April 11, 2018
47. Most of these companies do not produce all three of the
chemicals. It is also important to note that two companies,
Potash Corp and Agrium, as of January 2018, merged to become
Nutrien11 and that on the graph, the bar for the company is a
project capacity based on the capacity of the two former
companies. In our research we found that some of the
companies such as Uralkali and Belaruskali are Russian, and we
excluded them due to the current political climate between the
United States and Russia.
We consolidated the major industry players into five major
companies and created a graphic to represent these companies
which we believe have or hold the most potential for
International Forest Products.
Figure 6: Major Industry Players
Retrieved From: Agrium. (2018, February). Annual Report.
Retrieved April 11, 2018; The Mosaic Company. (2017,
February 3). ANNUAL REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13
OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934.
Retrieved April 5, 2018; Potash Corp. (2018, February). Annual
Report. Retrieved April 11, 2018; CF Industries. (2018,
February). Annual Report. Retrieved April 11, 2018
Companies are organized by region, with ICL from Israel,
Mosaic and CF from the United States, and Potash and Agrium
from Canada[footnoteRef:27] [footnoteRef:28] [footnoteRef:29]
[footnoteRef:30] [footnoteRef:31]. It is important to note that
Potash and Agrium are highlighted in green due to the merger
into Nutrien, and that the information for Potash and Agrium is
based on pre-merger information12 14. Agrium has the highest
total revenue of all the companies and that is expected to grow
with the recent merger. The gross margin for these five
companies ranges from 10.4 percent to 30.8 percent, with ICL
having the highest gross margin of the five companies12 13 14
15 16. One very important factor is that of the three major
chemical components of fertilizer, only Agrium and Potash
48. produce all three12 14. ICL is one of the smallest companies of
the five companies that we examined. Because ICL is a small
company -- it sells two out of the three major fertilizer
components and has one of the highest gross margins of all five
companies -- we believe that ICL would be an ideal company
for International Paper Products to explore for financing
opportunities. [27: Agrium. (2018, February). Annual Report.
Retrieved April 11, 2018, from
https://www.nutrien.com/sites/default/files/uploads/2018-
02/2017 AGRIUM Annual Report FINAL.pdf
] [28: The Mosaic Company. (2017, February 3). ANNUAL
REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE
SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934. Retrieved April 5,
2018, from
http://investors.mosaicco.com/Cache/c38082405.html
] [29: Potash Corp. (2018, February). Annual Report.
Retrieved April 11, 2018, from
https://www.nutrien.com/sites/default/files/uploads/2018-
02/2017 PotashCorp Annual Report.pdf
] [30: Israel Chemicals. (2018, February). Annual Report.
Retrieved April 11, 2018, from
http://iclgroupv2.s3.amazonaws.com/corporate/wp-
content/uploads/sites/1004/2018/03/ICL-2017-Annual-Report-
20-F.pdf
] [31: CF Industries. (2018, February). Annual Report.
Retrieved April 11, 2018, from
https://www.snl.com/Cache/1001234503.PDF?O=PDF&T=&Y=
&D=&FID=1001234503&iid=4533245
]
Value Chain
The value chain is based on the information gathered on the
production cycle of nitrogen, phosphate, and potash, and how
these components become fertilizers.
49. Figure 7: Agricultural Chemicals Value Chain
Phosphate and potash are both extracted in their raw form via a
mining process; nitrogen is produced through a process that
extracts it from air via hydrogen and heat7. This map shows the
parts of the world where potash and phosphate is extracted.
Figure 8: Potash and Phosphate Rock Reserves Map
Retrieved From: Jones, A. (2017). Who Are the Biggest Players
in the Fertilizer Industry? Retrieved April 11, 2018, from
https://marketrealist.com/2017/01/industry-overview-biggest-
players-fertilizer-industry
Most the world’s potash is primarily in and extracted from
Canada and Russia11, while much of the world’s phosphate is
primarily in and extracted from the continent of Africa and
some from China11. These raw materials, once extracted, go to
the materials processing sector to be processed into workable
forms. Once they are processed they are brought to
manufacturers who transform them into their final fertilizer
forms. These fertilizers then go to wholesalers who either
distribute the product to the farmers or to the retail sector.
Opportunities
Research
Based on our research on the agricultural chemicals industry,
we found three main factors that increase the need for fertilizer.
The map below visually depicts the three main factors that
increase the need for fertilizers.
Figure 9: World Map of Population Concentration, Corn,
50. Cotton, and Banana Production
Retrieved From: Keshrinandan Enterprise. (2016). World Corn
Production 2015/2016.; USDA. (2018).; World Atlas (2017).
Top Banana Producing Countries In The World.
The first factor is high population, which is displayed on this
map of the world by the high concentrations of red. The next
factor is the farming of corn. The corn stalks on the map
represent where and how much corn is harvested around the
world[footnoteRef:32]. The next factor is the production of
cotton, as depicted by the cotton plant graphic on the
map[footnoteRef:33]. In addition to looking at corn and cotton
production, we also looked at where the most bananas are grown
in the world. During our meetings with Daniel Moore, he
mentioned some of International Forest Products major
customers are companies such as Dole and Chiquita, so we also
took that into consideration when we focused on different
regions of the world[footnoteRef:34]. Our research shows that
the middle of the U.S., Brazil, West Africa, India, and China are
the regions that need the most fertilizers. We are not
recommending China due to the potential for a trade war
brought on by the current political climate, an uncertainty of the
tariffs on fertilizer, or whether the country will allow the import
of the product from the U.S. Additionally, we will not be
recommending India, as India has decided they will cease
importing fertilizer within in the next five years. [32:
Keshrinandan Enterprise. (2016). World Corn Production
2015/2016. Retrieved from
https://www.keshrinandan.com/corn/world-corn-production-
20152016/
] [33: USDA. (2018). Retrieved from
https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/ogamaps/map.aspx?cmdty=Cotton&attr
ibute=Production
] [34: World Atlas (2017). Top Banana Producing Countries In
The World. Retrieved from
https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/top-banana-producing-
51. countries-in-the-world.html]
Based on our examination of the production of corn, cotton and
bananas around the world, we concluded that the United States,
Brazil and other Latin American countries, and West Africa
need the most fertilizer. To understand this need for fertilizers
further, we examined where the United States is exporting to
currently. This graph depicts the countries that the United
States exports fertilizer to by metric tons.
Figure 10: U.S. Fertilizer Exports by Metric Ton
Retrieved From: Datamyne. (n.d.). Retrieved April 11, 2018,
from http://www.datamyne.com/
We looked at the United States exports of Chapter 31, the
fertilizer chapter, using the Datamyne database. One important
fact that we wanted to highlight is that while the United States
currently exports fertilizer to China, Mexico, and the Ivory
Coast, countries such as Brazil and regions such as West Africa
do not receive a great deal of fertilizer from the
U.S.[footnoteRef:35]. Unfortunately, due to our restricted
access to Datamyne, we were only able to find information on
the United States imports and exports. As a result, we were not
able to find any information on any other countries imports and
exports of fertilizer. [35: Datamyne. (n.d.). Retrieved April 11,
2018, from http://www.datamyne.com/
]
Latin America
Based on the high production of corn, cotton and bananas in
Latin America, we view it as an opportunity to enter the
agricultural chemicals industry. The expansion in the building
of railroads in Latin America right now is being funded by
outside Chinese investment[footnoteRef:36]. One project seeks
52. to link ports in Brazil to ports in Peru so that cargo can move
more easily between the two2122. There has also been a shift in
ports to places like Callao Panama due to this port lowering its
costs to ship large shipments, thus making it more
competitive[footnoteRef:37]. Brazil presents opportunities as
the country relies heavily on imported fertilizer and, in 2015,
used nearly 30.2 million metric tons of it[footnoteRef:38].
However, Brazil is also heavily reliant on trucking, which is
something that needs to be accounted for in that
country[footnoteRef:39]. [36: Tegel, S. (2017). Latin America's
Delicate Dance With China. U.S. News - The Report, c20-c21.
http://ezproxysuf.flo.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/
login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=125669731&site=ehost-
live
] [37: BRUNS, A. (2017). Ports Are in a Storm, but Central
America will help the region find smoother water in 2017. Site
Selection, 62(1), 45-47.
http://ezproxysuf.flo.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/
login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=120681213&site=ehost-
live
] [38: Simões, D. C., Caixeta-Filho, J. V., & Palekar, U. S.
(2018). Fertilizer distribution flows and logistic costs in Brazil:
changes and benefits arising from investments in port terminals.
International Food & Agribusiness Management Review, 21(3),
407-422. doi:10.22434/IFAMR2017.0037
http://ezproxysuf.flo.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/
login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=128757921&site=ehost-
live
] [39: Ward, R. (2017). Brazil largely unscathed by customs
strike, truck delays remain. Joc Online, 1.
http://ezproxysuf.flo.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/
login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=123540017&site=ehost-
live
]
This map of Latin America from 2016 depicts the most active
53. ports and measures the ports activity in how many TEU, or
Twenty-foot Equivalent Units, passed through each port in
2016.
Figure 11: Latin American Port Activity by TEU in 2016
Retrieved From: BRUNS, A. (2017). Ports Are in a Storm, but
Central America will help the region find smoother water in
2017. Site Selection, 62(1), 45-47.
http://ezproxysuf.flo.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/
login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=120681213&site=ehost-
live
The number one port, Santos, is in Brazil, and had more than 3
million TEU’s pass through it in 201622. The port of Callao in
Peru, as of 2016, is the sixth largest port in Latin America.
However, due to the recent shift of shipping prices within this
port, it can be expected to move up in rank as it becomes more
competitive. In addition to examining the Latin American
climate, we also examined Brazil due to its gap between its
domestic production of fertilizer and its consumption and Brazil
having the most active port in Latin America. This graph
predicts the port capacity vs the demand for fertilizer imports
into Brazil from 2014 to 2025.
Figure 12: Port Capacity VS Demand for Fertilizer Imports in
Brazil (2014-2025)
Retrieved From: Simões, D. C., Caixeta-Filho, J. V., & Palekar,
U. S. (2018). Fertilizer distribution flows and logistic costs in
Brazil: changes and benefits arising from investments in port
terminals. International Food & Agribusiness Management
Review, 21(3), 407-422. doi:10.22434/IFAMR2017.0037
http://ezproxysuf.flo.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/
login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=128757921&site=ehost-
54. live
As you can see there is capacity from 2014 (orange line) and is
compared with the imports (gray line), and the port capacity
(dash line). This graph predicts a steady rise in both demand for
fertilizer and in the port capacity for Brazil, thus allowing port
capacity to keep up with demand in the coming years24. This
means that Brazil will not only need more fertilizer but will
have the port capacity to accommodate this increase in imported
fertilizer.
Africa
In addition to examining the business opportunities in Latin
America, we also looked at those in Africa, and, more
specifically, West Africa. In West Africa there is a significant
need for fertilizer as the crop yields here are very low by
international standards[footnoteRef:40]. This has led the region
to a dependence on imported food 25. West Africa also has
inadequate access to domestic fertilizer and as a result, is
heavily dependent on imported fertilizer25. This provides an
opportunity for a third-party importer to potentially export to
West Africa to meet the demand for imported fertilizer.
Infrastructure around ports has been increasing in the region as
with new construction projects on ports to greatly improve
infrastructure. For instance, there is currently a $1.5 billion
infrastructure project currently being carried out in Tema Port
in Ghana, which seeks to triple capacity by the end of 201925.
There is also an opportunity to provide financing as more
international companies are investing via financing in West
Africa25. West Africa’s need for financing presents
International Forest Products with a way to enter into the
agricultural chemicals industry and the West African market.
However, itis important to note that there is a significant lack of
transportation infrastructure of any kind in the region which
could create challenges with shipping products. This graph
shows the increase in harvested land area by country in West
55. Africa from 1970 to a projected 2022. [40: Mulholland, S.
(2017, JULY 07). CRU. Retrieved from CRU
INTERNATIONAL LTD:
https://www.crugroup.com/knowledge-and-
insights/spotlights/is-2017-a-turning-point-for-west-african-
fertilizer-demand/]
Figure 13: West Africa Harvested Land Area from 1970 to 2022
Retrieved From: Mulholland, S. (2017, JULY 07). CRU.
Retrieved from CRU INTERNATIONAL LTD:
https://www.crugroup.com/knowledge-and-
insights/spotlights/is-2017-a-turning-point-for-west-african-
fertilizer-demand/
From 1970 all the way up to a projected 2022, there is a
significant increase in harvesting area for every country. The
most dramatic growth can be seen in Nigeria, which has the
highest increase in harvesting area25. Nigeria could provide
significant opportunity to ship fertilizer and agricultural
chemicals to as the predicted rise in last will ultimately lead to
an increase in crops and the need for fertilizer.
Conclusion
Based on our research, we have concluded that there are three
choices for International Forest Products to enter the
agricultural chemicals and fertilizers industry. We organized
our three conclusions into a risk matrix with probability of risk
on the vertical axis and impact of risk on International Forest
Products on the horizontal axis as depicted by Figure 14.
Figure 14: Recommendation Risk Matrix
Each conclusion is categorized by the probability and the
56. impact on a low, medium, high scale. Our first conclusion is
high risk probability, high risk impact and it is to match buyers
to suppliers in West Africa and Brazil. International Forest
Products can use their already successful model of matching
buyers and suppliers of paper products and apply that same
model to agricultural chemicals and fertilizers. We believe that
IFP can utilize its current relationships with Dole and Chiquita
to connect them with suppliers of fertilizer and agricultural
chemicals for their banana crops in Brazil. We also believe that
it can connect with other smaller producers of cotton and corn
in Brazil and utilize the dependence on imported fertilizer in
Brazil. Additionally, IFP can connect with smaller producers in
West Africa, particularly Nigeria, as there is a dependence on
imported fertilizer there as well. We categorized this course of
action as having a high probability of risk and a high-risk
impact because it involves a significant financial and time
investment for International Forest Products that could
potentially lead to failure.
Our second conclusion is medium risk probability, medium risk
impact and it is for International Forest Products to finance
smaller players in the market. International Forest Products
already finances paper products companies, and, in our
meetings, we were told that IFP would be interested in
financing smaller companies in the agricultural chemicals
industry. We believe that ICL is an ideal company for
International Forest Products to finance to enter the agricultural
chemicals industry. ICL is one of the smaller players in the
agricultural chemicals industry and is an international company.
With the recent merger between Agrium and Potash into
Nutrien, smaller companies are going feel the pressure from the
merger and feel the need to stay competitive to compete with
Nutrien. International Forest Products can offer financial
backing to smaller players like ICL, and give them the
advantage that they need to stay in the market. Through this
financing, International Forest Products can enter the industry
with less of an overall risk to themselves and develop a
57. relationship with an international company such as ICL. We
categorized this course of action as being both medium risk
probability and medium risk impact because financing poses
less of a financial burden on International Forest Products and
allows the company to enter into the market with a company
that already has a place in the agricultural chemicals industry.
International Forest Products will have less of a risk to
themselves and have less of a risk of failure through financing a
smaller company.
Our third conclusion is low risk probability and low risk impact
and that is to not enter the agricultural chemicals industry at
this time. Based on our research into the agricultural chemicals
industry, we found that the industry is extremely difficult to
enter due to three major barriers to entry. The first barrier to
entry is that there a high level of expertise needed in
agricultural chemicals. Agricultural chemicals are complex and
companies that produce them are usually solely dedicated to the
product on these chemicals. International Forest Products does
not have this level of expertise in the production and creation of
agricultural chemicals and fertilizers, therefore it is more
difficult to enter the industry with this significant lack of
knowledge. The second barrier to entry is the financial
resources needed to enter the agricultural chemicals industry is
too high for International Forest Products. Agricultural
chemicals cost a great deal to produce and transport as many
chemicals require delicate handling because of their explosive
nature during production and transport. These costs and the risk
of accidents are extremely high. Therefore, it would be too
costly for International Forest Products to enter the agricultural
chemicals industry. The third barrier to entry is that the
industry is already dominated by large companies and those
smaller companies that have merged, leaving little room for
entry from what would be essentially a third party. The industry
has begun to shrink with the introduction of Nutrien. Also,
companies such as Nutrien are involved with almost every
aspect of the value chain leaving little room for a company such
58. as International Forest Products to enter the transportation and
logistics parts of the value chain.
Recommendations
Our objective of our research was to address and answer the
question of is there an opportunity in the agricultural chemicals
industry for International Forest Products. Our client meetings
with IFC, in combination with our extensive research on the
agricultural chemicals industry gave us insight into creating
recommendations that International Forest Products can act on.
Based on our research, we concluded that there is some
opportunity in the agricultural chemicals market for
International Forest Products. However, we recommend that
International Forest Products should not enter the agricultural
chemicals industry because the benefits do not outweigh the
costs it would take to enter the industry.
Bibliography
(n.d.).
Agrium. (2018). Annual Report. Retrieved April 11, 2018 from
https://www.nutrien.com/sites/default/files/uploads/2018-
02/2017 AGRIUM Annual Report FINAL.pdf
BRUNS, A. (2017). Ports Are in a Storm, but Central America
will help the region find smoother water in 2017. From
http://ezproxysuf.flo.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/
login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=120681213&site=ehost-
live
CF Industries. (2018). Annual Report. Retrieved April 11, 2018
from
https://www.snl.com/Cache/1001234503.PDF?O=PDF&T=&Y=
&D=&FID=1001234503&iid=4533245
Chemicals Industry Surveys. (2017). From
https://www.capitaliq.com/CIQDotNet/Research/DocumentView
er.aspx?documentViewerDocumentId=37881073#
59. Datamyne. (n.d.). Retrieved April 11, 2018 from
http://www.datamyne.com/
Dun and Bradstreet. (2018). Agricultural Chemical
Manufacturing. Retrieved February 19, 2018 from
http://www.mergentintellect.com/index.php/search/firstResearch
Report/CHMA/Agriculturalchemical20180219.pdf
(2018). Harmonized Tariff Schedule. Retrieved March 29, 2018
from https://hts.usitc.gov/current
International Forest Products. (2016). International Forest
Products General Business Overview. Retrieved 2018 from
file:///C:/Users/Mia/Downloads/IFP General Presentation
(2).pdf
Israel Chemicals. (2018). Annual Report. Retrieved April 11,
2018 from http://iclgroupv2.s3.amazonaws.com/corporate/wp-
content/uploads/sites/1004/2018/03/ICL-2017-Annual-Report-
20-F.pdf
Jones, A. (2017). Who Are the Biggest Players in the Fertilizer
Industry? Retrieved April 11, 2018 from
https://marketrealist.com/2017/01/industry-overview-biggest-
players-fertilizer-industry
Keshrinandan Enterprise. (2016). World Corn Production
2015/2016. From https://www.keshrinandan.com/corn/world-
corn-production-20152016/
Loria, K. (2017). GMO market growing at 3.2% CAGR. From
https://www.fooddive.com/news/gmo-market-growing-at-32-
cagr/436711/
Mergent. (2017). First Research. From
60. http://mergent.firstresearch-
learn.com/industry.aspx?chapter=0&pid=161
Mergent. (2018). Paper & Paper Products Manufacturing.
Retrieved March 12, 2018 from http://mergent.firstresearch-
learn.com/industry.aspx?chapter=0&pid=145
Mosheim, R. (2018). United States Department of Agriculture.
From https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/fertilizer-use-and-
price.aspx
Mulholland, S. (2017). CRU. From
https://www.crugroup.com/knowledge-and-
insights/spotlights/is-2017-a-turning-point-for-west-african-
fertilizer-demand/
(2018). Organic Food and Beverage Market Growth Projected at
14 Percent Before 2021. Retrieved April 19, 2018 from
http://www.organicauthority.com/organic-food-and-beverage-
market-growth-projected-at-14-percent-before-2021/
Potash Corp. (2018). Annual Report. Retrieved April 11, 2018
from https://www.nutrien.com/sites/default/files/uploads/2018-
02/2017 PotashCorp Annual Report.pdf
Simões, D. C.-F. (2018). Fertilizer distribution flows and
logistic costs in Brazil: changes and benefits arising from
investments in port terminals. International Food &
Agribusiness Management Review, 21(3), 407-422.
doi:10.22434/IFAMR2017.0037
Tegel, S. (2017). Latin America's Delicate Dance With China.
U.S. News - The Report, c20-c21. From
http://ezproxysuf.flo.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/
login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=125669731&site=ehost-
live
61. The Mosaic Company. (2017). ANNUAL REPORT PURSUANT
TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE
ACT OF 1934. Retrieved April 5, 2018 from
http://investors.mosaicco.com/Cache/c38082405.html
U.S. International Trade Commission. (n.d.). Harmonized Tariff
Schedule Search. Retrieved April 11, 2018 from
https://hts.usitc.gov/
USDA. (2018). From
https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/ogamaps/map.aspx?cmdty=Cotton&attr
ibute=Production
Ward, R. (2017). Brazil largely unscathed by customs strike,
truck delays remain. Joc Online, 1. From
http://ezproxysuf.flo.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/
login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth&AN=123540017&site=ehost-
live
World Atlas. (2017). Top Banana Producing Countries In The
World. From https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/top-banana-
producing-countries-in-the-world.html
Appendix A
Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the United States (2018)
Revision 2 (Posted March 29, 2018)
Heading/
Subheading
Stat.
Suffix
Article Description
Unit Rates of Duty
62. of
Quantity
General
Special
2
3101.00.00
00
Animal or vegetable fertilizers, whether or not mixed together
or chemically treated; fertilizers produced by the mixing or
chemical treatment of animal or vegetable products
T
Free
Free
3102
Mineral or chemical fertilizers, nitrogenous:
3102.10.00
Urea, whether or not in aqueous solution.
. Free
Free
10
Solid urea
Other:
T
63. 30
Diesel exhaust fluid (DEF) of a kind meeting ISO
22241
T
50
Other:
T
3103
3103.11.00
3103.19.00
3103.90.01
3104
3104.20.00
3104.30.00
3105
3105.20.00
64. 00
00
00
00
00
00
Mineral or chemical fertilizers, phosphatic:
Superphosphates:
Containing by weight 35 percent or more of diphosphorous
pentaoxide (P2O5).
Other
Other
Mineral or chemical fertilizers, potassic:
Potassium chloride
Potassium sulfate
Mineral or chemical fertilizers containing two or three of the
fertilizing elements nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium; other
fertilizers; goods of this chapter in tablets or similar forms or
in packages of a gross weight not exceeding 10 kg:
Mineral or chemical fertilizers containing the three fertilizing
elements nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium
66. Free
Free
Free
Free
Free
Free
Appendix B
List of Tables and Figures
Figure 1: Paper and Pulp Manufacturing Industry Annual
Growth Rate3
Figure 2: Chemical Industry Sectors4
Figure 3: Agricultural Chemicals Manufacturing Industry
Growth Rate4
67. Figure 4: Fertilizer Price Index6
Figure 5: Chemical Industry Analysis Companies by Total NPK
Capacity8
Figure 6: Major Industry Players9
Figure 7: Agricultural Chemicals Value Chain11
Figure 8: Potash and Phosphate Rock Reserves Map12
Figure 9: World Map of Population Concentration, Corn,
Cotton, and Banana Production13
Figure 10: U.S. Fertilizer Exports by Metric Ton14
Figure 11: Latin American Port Activity by TEU in 201616
Figure 12: Port Capacity VS Demand for Fertilizer Imports in
Brazil (2014-2025)17
Figure 13: West Africa Harvested Land Area from 1970 to
202218
Figure 14: Recommendation Risk Matrix19
Business Opportunities for Sample Company A within Boston’s
Large Pharma Market
Executive Summary
Jodi's PC
INTRODUCTION
Project Overview
Our project explored the business opportunities for Sample
Company A within Boston’s large pharma market. Our goal was
to understand the benefits potential clients gain from using your
68. services and why a client would choose you over another
vendor. By conducting primary and secondary research, we were
able to understand your target market’s main business
objectives, such as reducing costs and speeding up the drug
discovery pipeline, which serve as major areas of opportunity
for you. Additionally, we were able to identify the services
offered by your competitors which allowed us to conduct a
competitive analysis. This report provides insights into the
large pharma industry nationally and locally, recent outsourcing
trends, business opportunities for you, and recommendations on
how to enter the market as a compound management (CM)
partner of choice.
Research Process
To gain a deeper understanding of the large pharma
industry, we approached our project as if we were a potential
client. We determined the definition of a “large pharma
company” to be a company with annual revenues over $20B. We
wanted to know what the industry looks like nationally and
locally with a specific focus on various trends occurring within
the market. We found over fifty articles specific to the large
pharma industry, with data relating to compound management,
drug development, and outsourcing. This approach led us to
look into various competitors, as if we were a potential client
looking for a CM partner, in order to determine the services
provided by your competition. This secondary research,
combined with two primary interviews, allowed us to shape our
recommendations that provide the framework for your continued
growth within Boston’s large pharma market.
Industry Analysis
Pharma Industry
According to the Economist Intelligence Unit, the U.S.
pharma industry is the largest in the world and it continues to
experience steady growth. As noted in figure 1, in 2011 U.S.
pharma sales are estimated to be $396B. As a whole, the pharma
69. industry is a free market, where government agencies cannot
negotiate with drug suppliers for lower prices. As a result,
consumers in the U.S. pay more for prescription drugs than in
any other country. However, as patents expire large pharma
companies are losing profits on their blockbuster drugs due to
the entry of generic drugs, which makes up 80% of drug sales
based on volume. Similarly, due to recent trends in innovative
pricing arrangements for biopharmaceuticals and tiered drug
pricing, insurers are trending towards cutting costs for
prescription drugs.[footnoteRef:1] [1: Economist Business
Intelligence Unit, 2012]
Figure 1: U.S. Pharmaceutical Sales: 2006 - 2015
Source: The Economist Intelligence Unit, 2012
Outsourcing Trends
To stay competitive within the industry, large pharma
companies are looking to increase their profit margins through
outsourcing. In 2005, the total pharmaceutical outsourcing
market was estimated at $33B and was expected to grow to
$48B. Outsourcing can reduce overall costs by 30% - 50% and
increase the pace of drug discovery processes.[footnoteRef:2]
A survey conducted by Pharmaceutical Outsourcing showed that
large pharma companies have increased the number of contract
research and manufacturing organizations (CROs and CMOs)
that they outsource to. These companies are outsourcing to
vendors with the goal of reducing overall costs in three main
areas: manufacturing; process development; and research and
development.[footnoteRef:3] A significant portion of this
outsourcing is sent to China and India; however, there is data to
suggest that companies are looking to move these processes
back to the U.S. as wages increase in foreign countries and
70. regulations become more stringent. [2: Chaturvedi, 2005] [3:
Langer, 2012]
Boston Market
There are over 240 biotech and pharma companies that
have operations in Massachusetts. As noted in table 1, large
pharma companies have a major presence in the state which has
a significant on the Massachusetts economy:[footnoteRef:4] [4:
Contract Pharma, 2012]
Table 1: Top Pharmaceutical Companies
Company Name
2011 Revenue
Pfizer
$57.7B
Novartis
$47.9B
Sanofi
$42.7B
Merck
$41.2B
GlaxoSmithKline
$35.5B
Astra Zeneca
$32.9B
Johnson & Johnson
$24.3B
Abbott
$22.4B
Source: Contract Pharma, July/August 2012
In an industry analysis of Boston’s large pharma market, MBC
reports that the market has experienced trends toward
innovation and cost reduction efforts, such as:
· Increased partnerships and merger and acquisition (M&A)
71. deals to diversify product portfolios due to weak drug pipelines
and expiring patents;
· Convergence of drugs, diagnostics, and medical devices to
drive development;
· Focus on flexibility and cost reduction within operating
models; and,
· Development of strategic partnerships to increase value to the
organization and consumers. [footnoteRef:5] [5: Massachusetts
Biotechnology Council, 2009]
Business Opportunities
We found the main business objectives of your potential clients
to be cost reduction and improving operational efficiencies. A
survey released by MBC in 2009 reported that large pharma
companies are looking for new models that improve their
operating cost structures and margins; outsourcing opportunities
to reduce costs in research and development; and, streamlined
processes to expand manufacturing and R&D functions within
the state. [footnoteRef:6] Additionally, the results of an
industry-wide survey conducted by Pharma IQ of 4,000
compound management specialists shows that there are three
primary concerns within their department: the quality of
samples; management of sample data; and the need to construct
new libraries to support research requirements. [6:
Massachusetts Biotechnology Council, 2009]
Figure 2: Client Compound Management Needs
Source: Pharma IQ, May 2012
The survey revealed that quality perseverance, safeguarding
sample quality, and introducing an effective identification and
tracking system are key priorities for compound managers and
72. their departments.[footnoteRef:7] [7: Pharma IQ, 2012]
The largest area of opportunity for you within the large
pharma market is during the M&A transition phase. Large
pharma companies have the human and financial capital
available for in-house sample management and procurement.
However, large pharma companies will continue to acquire
biotech companies with rich pipeline potential for product
diversification and innovation. To avoid internal conflict and
disruption of workflows, large pharma companies look for CM
partners, such as yourself, that are neutral parties during the
transition.[footnoteRef:8] As companies continue to expand
operations domestically and internationally, there is also a need
to keep some compounds close to new satellite locations. [8:
Wigglesworth & Wood, 2012]
From the client perspective, there are a few conditions that
will make outsourcing CM successful for an organization. First
and foremost, it must provide cost savings for the client.
Additionally, it must increase their operational efficiency and
optimize their resource allocation which enables the client to
work on other projects. Lastly, relationships with partners like
yourself must be built on quality; customer service; scientific
knowledge; reputation; and, cost effectiveness. According to
Pharmaceutical Outsourcing, there are five key competencies
clients require from their CM partners: [footnoteRef:9] [9:
Boucharens, 2010]
· Privacy protection for samples
· Robust chain of custody procedures for samples
· Appropriate conditions for sample storage and disposal
· Procedures to comply with regulations
· Sample coding
Competitive Analysis
We found over 25 companies that provide compound
73. management services to the pharmaceutical industry. To
conduct a competitive analysis, we identified four major
competitors that provide service offerings similar to yours.
Table 2 provides a snapshot of your competition with their
annual sales revenue and services provided, as stated on their
websites.
Table 2: Competitor Snapshot
Company
2011 Sales
Company Snapshot
Frontier Scientific
Logan, UT
$7.1M
FSI has a reputation for high purity and fast delivery. FSI has a
R&D department focusing on new generation compounds and
custom synthesis. They can provide customers with unique
compounds that are not available on a commercial basis
anywhere else. FSI provides contract research services and
compounds at competitive rates.[footnoteRef:10] [10: Frontier
Scientific, Inc., 2012]
Enzo Life Sciences
Farmingdale, NY
$4.4M
Enzo Life Sciences identifies, synthesizes and commercializes
known bioactives. They have a catalog of over 3,000 stand-
alone small molecules and a unique collection of small
molecules including inhibitors, activators, and inducers which
can be ordered individually and in any volume. The library
collections are supplied with complete documentation for
integration into a client’s compound database. In addition, they
offer a custom library solution for hard-to-source compounds.
Enzo boasts having stringent quality control with state-of-the-
art technology.[footnoteRef:11] [11: Enzo Life Sciences, 2012]
74. AsisChem, Inc.
Watertown, MA
$1.1M
AsisChem maintains an extensive catalog of building blocks and
screening compounds which can be supplied within weeks. They
work on custom synthesis and design libraries for screening.
They have a small molecule collection designed as a universal
screening library, which is used for primary screening against a
wide range of biological targets, including those where no
structural information is available providing their customers
with diverse and novel drug-like small molecules.
AsisChem serves the pharmaceutical and biotechnology
industries in the area of new drug research and discovery. 55%
of AsisChem's current customers are pharmaceutical and
biotechnology companies. They are also a preferred partner for
dozens of universities and non-profit institutes.[footnoteRef:12]
[12: AsisChem, Inc., 2012]
Hamilton Storage
Hopkington, MA
Privately held;
no sales data
Hamilton is a leader in the design and manufacture of liquid
handling, process analytics, robotic workstations and automated
storage solutions which is ISO 9001 certifed. They are
introducing the next generation of ultra-low temperature
biological sample storage systems, which protects samples from
warming events, ensuring maximum sample quality is
maintained.[footnoteRef:13] [13: Hamilton Storage, 2012]
75. To conduct a competitive analysis, we compared your services
offerings against your competitors to those potential clients in
the Boston area would look for in a CM partner:
· Customer Service
· Privacy protection for samples; quality and assurance controls
· Appropriate conditions for sample storage
· Online inventory management and sample coding
· Proximity to Greater Boston / Kendall Square
We found that an area of opportunity for you lies in
differentiating your service offerings from your competitors. As
seen in figure 3, there is a lot of overlap in service offerings
between you and your competitors. In order to gain market
share in this area, you will need to set yourself apart from your
competitors.
Figure 3: Sample Company A Competitive Analysis
Recommendations
To enter Boston’s large pharma market as a preferred partner
for CM services, we recommend that you focus on
differentiating your service offerings from your competitors.
This can be done through your online and print collateral.
Additionally, building relationships with decision makers within
large pharma companies will be beneficial as you will be able to
further understand what their business objectives are and
provide innovative solutions to them. Trust is an important
factor in the CM industry and building business relationships at
every level of the organization is critical. By developing these
relationships, you will gain inside information regarding hot
biotech companies that are likely to be acquired by large
pharma companies. This will give you an edge against your
competitors. Lastly, you can build visibility and network with
potential clients by attending and speaking at conferences such
as the Compound Management & Integrity Summit. Based on
our findings, we believe that implementing the
76. recommendations outlined above will leverage your core
business competencies and enable you to enter Boston’s large
pharma market as a CM partner offering unique and high-
quality services to clients.
Bibliography
AsisChem, Inc. (2012). Screening Compounds. Retrieved
November 28, 2012, from AsisChem, Inc.:
http://www.asischem.com/screeninglib.aspx
Boucharens, P. S. (2010, November 1). Outsourcing Compound
Inventory Trend or Real Benefits? Retrieved November 8, 2012,
from Pharmaceutical Outsourcing:
http://www.pharmoutsourcing.com/Featured-Articles/37498-
Outsourcing-Compound-Inventory-Trend-or-Real-Benefits/
Chaturvedi, S. (2005). Outsourcing in Pharmaceutical Industry.
New York, NY, United States of America. Retrieved November
26, 2012, from
http://www.bionity.com/en/whitepapers/49803/outsourcing-in-
pharmaceutical-industry.html
Contract Pharma. (2012, July/August). Top 20 Pharma Report.
(G. Roth, Editor) Retrieved October 8, 2012, from Contract
Pharma: http://www.contractpharma.com/issues/2012-
07/view_features/top-20-pharma-report/
Enzo Life Sciences. (2012). Compound Libraries. Retrieved
December 5, 2012, from Enzo Life Sciences:
http://www.enzolifesciences.com/welcome/compound-libraries/
Frontier Scientific, Inc. (2012). About FSI. Retrieved December
5, 2012, from http://www.frontiersci.com/about.html
Hamilton Storage. (2012). About Hamilton Storage
Technologies. Retrieved December 6, 2012, from Hamilton
Storage: http://www.hamilton-storage.com/topnav/about-us/
Langer, E. (2012, September 17). Biopharmaceutical Industry
Outsourcing Trends: China and India Continuing Full-court
Press. Pharmaceutical Outsourcing, 13. Rockville, MD, USA.
Retrieved November 26, 2012, from
http://www.pharmoutsourcing.com/Featured-Articles/121110-
77. Biopharmaceutical-Industry-Outsourcing-Trends-China-and-
India-Continuing-Full-court-Press/
Massachusetts Biotechnology Council. (2009, April). Strategic
Outlook for 2015 and Strategic Plan. Retrieved November 19,
2012, from Massachusetts Biotechnology Council:
http://www.massbio.org/writable/files/2015_Report/full_2015_r
eport_for_distribution.pdf
Pharma IQ. (2012, May 21). Expanding Sample Libraries Tops
the Wish List for Compound and Sample Managers. Retrieved
November 8, 2012, from Pharma IQ: http://www.pharma-
iq.com/pre-clinical-discovery-and-
development/articles/expanding-sample-libraries-tops-the-wish-
list-for/
The Economist Intelligence Unit. (2012, June 1). USA:
Healthcare and Pharmaceuticals Report. New York, NY, USA.
Retrieved Novembe 26, 2012, from
http://www.eiu.com/index.asp?layout=ib3Article&article_id=18
69250771&country_id=1530000153&pubtypeid=1152462500&i
ndustry_id=&category_id=775133077
Wigglesworth, M., & Wood, T. (2012). Management of
Chemical and Biological Samples for Screening Applications.
Weinheim, Germany: Wiley-VCH. Retrieved November 8, 2012,
from
http://books.google.com/books?id=Hd6HRB4AWf8C&pg=PA26
5&dq=sample+library+pharma&source=gbs_toc_r&cad=4#v=on
epage&q&f=false
Report TitleHeader 1
This is your overview paragraph where you describe the main
point and how the report is laid out.
Header 2
Aas;ldkfjal;sjflakjlasjflajflajflajflajflasjflajflak;sjflk;ajflajsdflk
ajflkajflkajflajflkajsflkajflkajsfljaslfkjalkfjalsfjalskjfaljflajflajfa
78. lsjfalsjfalsjfalksjfalskfjalsjfalkjfakljflaksjflasjfal;jflasdjflak;sjfl
;akdjf
1. subheader: a;lskfjal;sdkfjas lfjaslkjfalskfjalsjfalsjfalskjflas
flasjflaksjflaksjflaksjflaksjfla;ksjflkasjfl;asjflkasjflkasjfklasjdfl
k;thialkjsdf;lkasdfj;laksjdfl;ajfljaslfjaslfjalfjasl;kdjfasd;lfkjal;sf
jaljflajflajflajflasjflasjdflasjflasjflasjfl;kaj
2. sub header 2 : This was discussed extensively and
wlkjslklkjlkjlkjlkjlsdflkjdlkjlkjasldkjflaksdjflaskjflskdjflskjflksj
flaksjf;qpwoeiurqopwieuropqiuroqpwieuroqieuropqiuropqiruiu
pqoiuopiuopqiwueropiuopiu
upoiupoiuopiquweopruiqowruqwopiruowipruopiuoiuasy to
follow. This could include
· bullet 1
· Bullet 2
· Bullet 3
· Bullet 4
· Bullet 5
3. subheader 3: : Determine which of the brainstormed to
resolve them.
Header 3
Asdf;kljas;dlkjfl;kajsl;djf;ljk
End of document.
Your Group Name and/or Suffolk University
79. Report Date
Final Report Check List
Please ensure that your final Report includes:
Description
Completed
· Footer including page number
· Footer including Final Business Report to Client Name
· Endnotes for all research including primary. All interviews
should include name/date/time/title
· Do you have a strong and compelling introduction and
conclusion?
· Powerpoint as one of the appendices
· All useful data as appendices
1. List your team objective/overall question
In my team, Our have to consider Laura‘s requirements from
law and politics. After our meeting, we wanted to use AR as a
key solution. Now, we need to do our researches from 5 parts(
Market description, Competition, Potential consumers, The
market of AR, and Pricepoint.)
2. List your specific tasks assigned for this deliverable
My specific task is looking for our potential consumers for AR.
80. The following points are what I am looking for.
3. Secondary Research Notes
Category Suffolk Database
Date 4/4/2019
Key points
1. An evaluation of the pedagogical value of a research project
involving 23 colleges and universities across the country.
2. The goal of the American Democracy Project is to produce
college and university graduates who are equipped with the
knowledge, skills, attitudes and experiences they need to be
informed, engaged members of their communities.
Summary:
1. In this report, Students expressed interest in participating in
similar research in the future and would advise other students to
do so and expressed interest in learning more about the themes
of their experience centers. This is our potential consumers, not
only law school students. More and more democracy class will
occur.
2. No only democratic classes in the college, the universities,
and colleges also cooperated with each other and create
different projects. That will increase our potential markets.
Citation in APA format including the url:
81. 1. Mann, C. B., Alberda, G. A., Birkhead, N. A., Ouyang, Y.,
Singer, C., Stewart, C., . . . Wronski, J. (2018, May 16).
Pedagogical Value of Polling-Place Observation by Students.
Retrieved from https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/ps-
political-science-and-politics/article/pedagogical-value-of-
pollingplace-observation-by-
students/99A4823B2FE884356615DC578B80EB65/core-reader
https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/ps-political-science-
and-politics/article/pedagogical-value-of-pollingplace-
observation-by-
students/99A4823B2FE884356615DC578B80EB65/core-reader
2. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.aascu.org/programs/ADP/
http://www.aascu.org/programs/ADP/
Category Google
Date 4/4/2019
Key points
1. They formed a campus chapter of the nonpartisan national
student organization, the Democracy Matters (DM) Institute to
deepen democracy and promote civic engagement.
2. Our goal is to establish an expectation that every student will
engage in courses, programs and activities aimed at preparing
them for effective participation in democracy.
3. Suffolk University’s faculty, students, and alumni are
researching and reshaping the political landscape in
Massachusetts and around the world.
82. Summary: How do the points help you?
1. 1. Our AR not only can sell to students, but also the
organizations in the colleges.
2. 2. More than 10 years after our studies and others
demonstrated the value of experiential learning for political
engagement, there is little evidence that most higher education
institutions and individual faculty members have integrated
education for democracy into their programs and courses. For
this article, it showed that there is a huge potential market to
expand from common students.
3. That’s a great example for organizations. Many colleges have
similar organizations and we can cooperate with them.
Citation in APA format including the url:
1. Review, P. (2014, December 29). Democracy Matters at
Colgate University. Retrieved from
https://www.aacu.org/publications-
research/periodicals/democracy-matters-colgate-university
https://www.aacu.org/publications-
research/periodicals/democracy-matters-colgate-university
2. Inside Higher Ed. (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2018/07/23/colleges-
must-do-more-teach-students-about-voting-and-democracy-
opinion
https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2018/07/23/colleges-
must-do-more-teach-students-about-voting-and-democracy-
opinion
3. https://www.suffolk.edu/about/directory/public-policy-
practice-hub/democracy-and-government
Democracy & Government. (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://www.suffolk.edu/about/directory/public-policy-practice-
83. hub/democracy-and-government
Secondary Research Notes
Category Google
Date 4/4/2019
Key points
4. Curriculum and Requirements in the department of
government( Georgetown University)
5. “CONSTITUTIONALISM AND DEMOCRACY HONORS
COLLEGE COURSE SERIES”, that is a introduction of this
course and aim.
6. Get an introduction to democracy with online courses from
MIT, Harvard, and other major universities and institutions
worldwide.
7. Role of Schools in a Democratic Society: the committee
offers a powerful description of the habits and behaviors
integral to democratic citizenship. This description can serve to
guide efforts to center democratic goals for public education
and to reform curriculum, pedagogy, and the organization of
schooling.
Summary:
4. There is an M.A. program in democracy and governance.
Except for organizations in university and cooperated
84. institution, the special classes of democracy also are in common
colleges.
5. That’s another example for many well-known universities
have begun to attach importance to democratic education and
set up special courses.
6. Now more and more online courses appear in universities,
and our AR products can help students understand because they
don’t have a teacher’s explanation.
7. From this article, Nowadays, society is paying more and more
attention to democratic education, and this will reform or
increase related courses. In the future, this is also a big
potential market for us.
Citation in APA format including the url:
4.Curriculum and Requirements. (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://government.georgetown.edu/democracy-and-
governance/course-offerings
https://government.georgetown.edu/democracy-and-
governance/course-offerings
5. Constitutionalism and Democracy Honors College Course
Series. (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://democracy.missouri.edu/programs/undergraduate-
programs/honors-collegefig/
https://democracy.missouri.edu/programs/undergraduate-
programs/honors-collegefig/
6. Democracy. (2018, February 14). Retrieved from
https://www.edx.org/learn/democracy
https://www.edx.org/learn/democracy
7. Hytten, K. (2018, September 18). Democracy and Education
in the United States. Retrieved from
http://oxfordre.com/education/view/10.1093/acrefore/97801902
64093.001.0001/acrefore-9780190264093-e-2
http://oxfordre.com/education/view/10.1093/acrefore/97801902
85. 64093.001.0001/acrefore-9780190264093-e-2
Category Google
Date 4/4/2019
Key points
Summary: How do the points help you?
More than 10 years after our studies and others demonstrated
the value of experiential learning for political engagement,
there is little evidence that most higher education institutions
and individual faculty members have integrated education for
democracy into their programs and courses.
Citation in APA format including the url:
Inside Higher Ed. (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2018/07/23/colleges-
must-do-more-teach-students-about-voting-and-democracy-
opinion
https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2018/07/23/colleges-
must-do-more-teach-students-about-voting-and-democracy-
opinion
4.
Primary Research Notes
Category Interview (Chaofan Li and Tong Zhang)
Date 4/4/2019
86. Who you spoke with including their title
Herbert N. Ramy
Professor of Academic Support Director, Academic Support
Program
Where
Suffolk Law School
120 Tremont Street
Key points
1. He was glad using technical tools to help him to teach the
class.
2. He just gave 5 points to the video game to willingness.(1-10)
3. He never uses simulation to teach students and he has used
practical cases to help.
4. He didn’t exclude teaching with video games, but the content
must match the courses.
5. He thought that we can increase educational technology into
undergraduate studies.
Summary: How do the points help you?
For all of the points, I can be sure that the professor accepts the
use of educational tools for teaching, but it is not very
interesting, and there are also unique ideas for the content of
video games. In my opinion, if we educate democracy in the
87. form of video games, our audience may be particularly small.
For that, we gave up the video game instead of AR.
Citation in APA format including the url:
4. List the areas that you will not cover. This will be used in
case the client asks a question in this area.
If the basic class in university teach democracy?
If we have to focus on which colleges have related
organizations and curriculum for now?
For our research, we got a report of which name is the
88. pedagogical value of polling-place observation by students. In
this report, 257 students are all college students from 23
colleges and universities across the country. The professors and
public officials cooperate to work for the Election Day
experience.
For the result, the students expressed interest in more learning
and research about the topics central to their experience. At the
same time, students found their experiences to be valuable and
reported learning generally and specifically related to course
material. 75% of participants considered the time they spent on
the project to be very (24%) or somewhat (51%) valuable.
Deliverable: Final Business Report
Objective: To provide the client with the details of the analysis
and presentation in formal business report format.
Format: format business report format. Spelling and grammar
count. Write in prose with bullets and charts to organize the
data easily. Use charts from your presentation. Support all
your points with your research. Avoid using superlatives like
“great” or “large” or “growing.” Instead use specifics like
numbers or expert opinions to support your point. Include
· All points from your presentation. The report needs to be
comprehensive of all information from the presentation
· Additional information that you did not use in your
presentation can be included as an appendix
· Sources that were referenced
· Headers to outline the different sections
· Clear and smooth transitions between paragraphs
· Concisely and professionally written
Overview of Report Structure
Cover Page
Include an informative title that indicates the focus and nature
89. of the report
Include the date and the author's name, title, and organizational
affiliation
Indicate for whom the report was written
Executive Summary
Summarize the report in such a way that it could stand on its
own and would make sense to a managerial, public, or non-
technical audience
Stay within two to three paragraphs
Briefly explain the focus, context, and research method or main
headings of the report
Incorporate the key conclusions
Table of Contents
List all first- and second-level section headings
Reproduce the headings and numbering exactly from the body
of the report
Include the full titles of all appendices
List of Figures/ List of Tables
List all figures and tables (under separate headings) with page
number for each
Reproduce exactly the numbering and full titles of each figure
and table
Introduction
Introduce the report and briefly explain the focus and context
for the report
Provide sufficient background for general readers
Refrain from presenting conclusions and recommendations
Possible sections that can be included as part of the
introduction are Objective of the Study, Scope, Background
Required section is research overview where you discuss your
primary and secondary research approach (not the details just
your approach)
90. Body
Research methods – Describes how the research was carried out
Present, interpret, and discuss your findings
Include properly formatted citations. Use foot or endnotes.
The sections should correspond with directly with your
presentation structure and flow
Figures and Tables
Numbered in separate series (e.g., Table 1, Table 2, Figure 1,
Table 3, Figure 2)
Informatively titled (e.g., Table 1: Annual precipitation in
Calgary, 1980 - 1990)
Properly formatted, with the title for tables above and that for
figures below
Accompanied by legends or footnotes to explain abbreviations
or provide information
Interpret the information presented. It is essential for you to
introduce the figure/table, display it, then discuss what it
suggests.
Referred to and discussed in the body of the report
Accompanied by a source citation, if the information was
borrowed or adapted
Use figures/graphs from your presentation that are substantive
Large figures can be referenced as appendices
Include all primary research (raw data and all findings) in the
appendix. Be comprehensive.
Conclusions
Show the most important findings
Refrain from introducing new information
Show that the report’s objectives have been met
Recommendations
Suggest actions that can be taken or considered in light of the
report conclusions
91. References
Follow standard APA format. Be comprehensive. Include
everything you used. This list should be substantial and more
than 15 sources at least. (e.g. APA, MLA)
List all sources cited in the report
Appendices
Include other information that would be of interest to the
readers on the topic pertaining to the report
Pay attention to the audiences. Who will be reading the report?
Avoid wordiness. Be concise and straightforward.
Use active voice
Note for grammatical errors (e.g. parallelism, run-on
sentences, verb tenses, spelling, punctuation, etc.)
Transition and flow