2. • Three meetings of the OECD Expert Group on Polymer Definitions
held in 1990, 1991, and 1993
– Developed consideration for polymers of low concern to aid countries in
decision-making
– Seven main criteria were discussed
– Specific parameters for each criterion were not agreed at the OECD
• Several countries implemented criteria for reduced regulatory
requirements for polymers
– Australia, Canada, Japan, Korea, New Zealand and the United States
• Not all implemented them in the same way
Background (1)
3. PLC criteria used in different jurisdictions
Groh et al. 2023. https://doi.org/10.1039/D2EM00386D
Source: Reproduced from Environ. Sci.: Processes Impacts, 2023,25,10-25 via the Creative Commons CC BY-NC 3.0 licence
4. • 2007 OECD Expert Group Meeting of Expert Group on polymers under Task Force on New
Chemicals Notification and Assessment
– held in Tokyo, Japan.
– meeting was organised to share information and consider commonalities in criteria and
approaches
• EG recommended an analysis of data submitted to OECD regulatory authorities to identify
correlations between polymer characteristics and potential for health or ecotoxicological
concern
– Led by Australia (2007-2008) For polymers that met the PLC criteria, 87.8% showed low health
concern and/or low ecotoxicological concern.
– Data were of variable quality and it was not possible to critically evaluate health concerns that
were reported
– examination of specific effects was not possible
– Report published in 2009 ENV/JM/MONO(2009)1
• No subsequent work at OECD
Background (2)
5. • Several scientific papers review criteria used
• Include additional criteria not included in PLC criteria
– Lipophilicity
– Particle size/respirability
– Production volume
– Intended uses
• Additional criteria used in some jurisdictions
– Hazard classification
– Fluorinated polymers
– Water absorption
– Unreacted monomers
– Surface activity
External work
6. Recent attention because:
1. EU is discussing introducing reporting requirements for polymers under REACH
regulation
• Many of the elements under consideration for identifying polymers requiring registration under
REACH draw from the application of criteria in other countries.
• In addition, recent science in this area has been highlighted.
• Criteria not used to identify PLC but identify polymers requiring registration
2. Many countries are planning to regulate PFAS and need to decide on how to deal with
fluoropolymers.
• OECD criteria for PLC have been applied to justify low concern for fluoropolymers.
• There is not agreement that they are of low concern or that all fluoropolymers meet the criteria.
3. Initial negotiations on international legal instrument to reduce plastic pollution
• In this context, criteria for PLC needed
Current issues
7. Many regulatory approaches were based on the early 1990s OECD
work, which is still frequently cited.
Given the experience in many countries with varied application
applying criteria and recent scientific advances in this area,
OECD recommends the regulatory schemes of individual countries
should be consulted.
OECD Recommendations