SlideShare a Scribd company logo
When is Driver-Based Modeling Applicable?
Nilly Essaides
Director, FP&A Practice, The Association for Financial Professionals
More companies are looking to put science in their forecasting and planning processes. To this
end, they’re basing more and more of their forecasting models on key business drivers – those
factors that can really move the needle and affect enterprise performance.
“Driver-based modeling and planning use operational drivers to predict financial results,” said
Philip Peck, Vice President, Financial Transformation at consulting firm Peloton Group.
These models are essentially equations that represent mathematical relationship between key
operational drivers (e.g. volume, rates, conversion ratios, brand awareness, etc.) and anticipated
financial outcomes.
The driver-based models have several key advantages: they’re more accurate, more efficient, can
be run on the fly and enable FP&A to come up with actionable information more quickly, at a
time when senior management is facing an increasingly complex and uncertain business
environment. They also help balance the inherent bias managers have in producing forecasting
data -- a combination of human error, politics and over-optimism. Of course, to do this they have
to be correct.
When does it work?
According to Mitch Max, CEO and President of BetterVu, forecasting is one of the first areas
where driver-based models can be applied. “As a basic example, if I’m forecasting a product or
series of products, and have a price, the driver is typically volume; it’s a simple metric
calculation of rate X volume. It’s applicable in many volume-sensitive calculations. But it can
also be used for non-volume-sensitive items, for example, you can apply a driver-based
calculation to payroll and multiply by average salary,” Max said.
“What’s important is the level of detail. Even drivers have different levels of detail,” said
Sholape Kolawole, EPM Transformation Associate Principle at The Hackett Group. The level of
detail should be aligned with the applicability to each planning cycle. For example, a quick
monthly forecast or the strategic plan would call for a less detailed driver approach.
According to Vic Datta, CEO of Resilicore: “The models enable the company to move away
from allocation-based budgeting to a more anticipatory approach, with an “activity-based”
costing approach as the precursor. “Driver-based models are outcome based, rather than the more
traditional inward-looking models,” Datta explained.
But driver-based models may not work everywhere.
Craig Schiff, Owner of consultancy BPM Partners Schiff said that he thinks driver-based
modeling is very applicable in the forecasting and long-range planning processes in FP&A but
less so in the detailed budgeting process. “When you look at budgeting it’s not ideal,” he noted.
“The budget includes a very detailed expenses and revenue lines for the year,” he said, “whereas
driver-based models are better suited to higher-level, quicker and more frequent forecast and
planning processes.” Budgeting often involves mapping expenses by area, by month. A true
driver-based model won’t produce these results.
Another area where driver-based models don't work is in fixed costs, for example rent, or
charitable donations.
In addition, according to Curtis Gratz, Director at Huron Consulting Group, driver-based
modeling is not applicable where there are only very loose relationships between drivers and
outputs, or if these items are not material or actionable.
“Building this additional, low value add, details encumbers participants to plan at a detail that
does not help the goals and mission of the corporation and just takes up time,” Gratz said.

More Related Content

What's hot

Beyond Budgeting: Driver-Based Forecasting and Performance Management
Beyond Budgeting: Driver-Based Forecasting and Performance ManagementBeyond Budgeting: Driver-Based Forecasting and Performance Management
Beyond Budgeting: Driver-Based Forecasting and Performance Management
Lean Enterprise Software and Systems Conference
 
Anaplan SPM webinar series, part 4: Motivating the right behavior with incent...
Anaplan SPM webinar series, part 4: Motivating the right behavior with incent...Anaplan SPM webinar series, part 4: Motivating the right behavior with incent...
Anaplan SPM webinar series, part 4: Motivating the right behavior with incent...
Anaplan
 
Dynamic Planning & Forecasting w Big Data
Dynamic Planning & Forecasting w Big DataDynamic Planning & Forecasting w Big Data
Dynamic Planning & Forecasting w Big Data
Atul Patel
 
Anaplan SPM Webinar series, part 3: Creating a comprehensive approach to sale...
Anaplan SPM Webinar series, part 3: Creating a comprehensive approach to sale...Anaplan SPM Webinar series, part 3: Creating a comprehensive approach to sale...
Anaplan SPM Webinar series, part 3: Creating a comprehensive approach to sale...
Anaplan
 
Making driver-based planning and budgeting work
Making driver-based planning and budgeting workMaking driver-based planning and budgeting work
Making driver-based planning and budgeting work
Anaplan
 
Strengthening the connection between the business and supply chain network
Strengthening the connection between the business and supply chain networkStrengthening the connection between the business and supply chain network
Strengthening the connection between the business and supply chain network
Anaplan
 
Anaplan and Valizant webinar: Improving your S&OP investment
Anaplan and Valizant webinar: Improving your S&OP investmentAnaplan and Valizant webinar: Improving your S&OP investment
Anaplan and Valizant webinar: Improving your S&OP investment
Anaplan
 
Transforming finance: Plan globally, compete locally
Transforming finance: Plan globally, compete locallyTransforming finance: Plan globally, compete locally
Transforming finance: Plan globally, compete locally
Anaplan
 
Unlocking the Spend analysis myth
Unlocking the Spend analysis mythUnlocking the Spend analysis myth
Unlocking the Spend analysis myth
mybestluxe.com
 
Webinar with Anaplan and IDC: The benefits of connected planning
Webinar with Anaplan and IDC: The benefits of connected planningWebinar with Anaplan and IDC: The benefits of connected planning
Webinar with Anaplan and IDC: The benefits of connected planning
Anaplan
 
Identifying and Measuring KPIs
Identifying and Measuring KPIsIdentifying and Measuring KPIs
Identifying and Measuring KPIs
Blackbaud
 
Wettemann
WettemannWettemann
The Future of Financial Planning and Analysis
The Future of Financial Planning and AnalysisThe Future of Financial Planning and Analysis
The Future of Financial Planning and Analysis
SAP Analytics
 
From KPIs to dashboards
From KPIs to dashboardsFrom KPIs to dashboards
From KPIs to dashboards
Ani Lopez
 
Steelwedge Integrated Business Planning
Steelwedge Integrated Business PlanningSteelwedge Integrated Business Planning
Steelwedge Integrated Business Planning
steelwedge2000
 
Fall Directors Meeting 2014: Program Quality - Developing Key Performance Ind...
Fall Directors Meeting 2014: Program Quality - Developing Key Performance Ind...Fall Directors Meeting 2014: Program Quality - Developing Key Performance Ind...
Fall Directors Meeting 2014: Program Quality - Developing Key Performance Ind...
Bonner Foundation
 
Huron_Spend_Analysis_PitfallsPainPromise_vFinal
Huron_Spend_Analysis_PitfallsPainPromise_vFinalHuron_Spend_Analysis_PitfallsPainPromise_vFinal
Huron_Spend_Analysis_PitfallsPainPromise_vFinal
Jens Brown
 
Baxter Planning Systems
Baxter Planning SystemsBaxter Planning Systems
Baxter Planning Systems
manderson1957
 
Key Performance Indicators
Key Performance IndicatorsKey Performance Indicators
Key Performance Indicators
kmaou
 

What's hot (19)

Beyond Budgeting: Driver-Based Forecasting and Performance Management
Beyond Budgeting: Driver-Based Forecasting and Performance ManagementBeyond Budgeting: Driver-Based Forecasting and Performance Management
Beyond Budgeting: Driver-Based Forecasting and Performance Management
 
Anaplan SPM webinar series, part 4: Motivating the right behavior with incent...
Anaplan SPM webinar series, part 4: Motivating the right behavior with incent...Anaplan SPM webinar series, part 4: Motivating the right behavior with incent...
Anaplan SPM webinar series, part 4: Motivating the right behavior with incent...
 
Dynamic Planning & Forecasting w Big Data
Dynamic Planning & Forecasting w Big DataDynamic Planning & Forecasting w Big Data
Dynamic Planning & Forecasting w Big Data
 
Anaplan SPM Webinar series, part 3: Creating a comprehensive approach to sale...
Anaplan SPM Webinar series, part 3: Creating a comprehensive approach to sale...Anaplan SPM Webinar series, part 3: Creating a comprehensive approach to sale...
Anaplan SPM Webinar series, part 3: Creating a comprehensive approach to sale...
 
Making driver-based planning and budgeting work
Making driver-based planning and budgeting workMaking driver-based planning and budgeting work
Making driver-based planning and budgeting work
 
Strengthening the connection between the business and supply chain network
Strengthening the connection between the business and supply chain networkStrengthening the connection between the business and supply chain network
Strengthening the connection between the business and supply chain network
 
Anaplan and Valizant webinar: Improving your S&OP investment
Anaplan and Valizant webinar: Improving your S&OP investmentAnaplan and Valizant webinar: Improving your S&OP investment
Anaplan and Valizant webinar: Improving your S&OP investment
 
Transforming finance: Plan globally, compete locally
Transforming finance: Plan globally, compete locallyTransforming finance: Plan globally, compete locally
Transforming finance: Plan globally, compete locally
 
Unlocking the Spend analysis myth
Unlocking the Spend analysis mythUnlocking the Spend analysis myth
Unlocking the Spend analysis myth
 
Webinar with Anaplan and IDC: The benefits of connected planning
Webinar with Anaplan and IDC: The benefits of connected planningWebinar with Anaplan and IDC: The benefits of connected planning
Webinar with Anaplan and IDC: The benefits of connected planning
 
Identifying and Measuring KPIs
Identifying and Measuring KPIsIdentifying and Measuring KPIs
Identifying and Measuring KPIs
 
Wettemann
WettemannWettemann
Wettemann
 
The Future of Financial Planning and Analysis
The Future of Financial Planning and AnalysisThe Future of Financial Planning and Analysis
The Future of Financial Planning and Analysis
 
From KPIs to dashboards
From KPIs to dashboardsFrom KPIs to dashboards
From KPIs to dashboards
 
Steelwedge Integrated Business Planning
Steelwedge Integrated Business PlanningSteelwedge Integrated Business Planning
Steelwedge Integrated Business Planning
 
Fall Directors Meeting 2014: Program Quality - Developing Key Performance Ind...
Fall Directors Meeting 2014: Program Quality - Developing Key Performance Ind...Fall Directors Meeting 2014: Program Quality - Developing Key Performance Ind...
Fall Directors Meeting 2014: Program Quality - Developing Key Performance Ind...
 
Huron_Spend_Analysis_PitfallsPainPromise_vFinal
Huron_Spend_Analysis_PitfallsPainPromise_vFinalHuron_Spend_Analysis_PitfallsPainPromise_vFinal
Huron_Spend_Analysis_PitfallsPainPromise_vFinal
 
Baxter Planning Systems
Baxter Planning SystemsBaxter Planning Systems
Baxter Planning Systems
 
Key Performance Indicators
Key Performance IndicatorsKey Performance Indicators
Key Performance Indicators
 

Similar to When is Driver-Based Modeling Applicable

Integrated Planning Part 2
Integrated Planning Part 2Integrated Planning Part 2
Integrated Planning Part 2
Nilly Essaides
 
integrated planning part 1
integrated planning part 1integrated planning part 1
integrated planning part 1
Nilly Essaides
 
2016-how-fp-a-can-become-a-better-business-partner
2016-how-fp-a-can-become-a-better-business-partner2016-how-fp-a-can-become-a-better-business-partner
2016-how-fp-a-can-become-a-better-business-partner
Anders Liu-Lindberg
 
Jenny Okonkwo How FP&A Can Become a Better Business Partner
Jenny Okonkwo How FP&A Can Become a Better Business PartnerJenny Okonkwo How FP&A Can Become a Better Business Partner
Jenny Okonkwo How FP&A Can Become a Better Business Partner
Transform Consulting Inc
 
How FP&A Can Become a Better Business Partner
How FP&A Can Become a Better Business PartnerHow FP&A Can Become a Better Business Partner
How FP&A Can Become a Better Business Partner
Carl Seidman
 
hbr-campaign-brochure-eb2-v9-2288453
hbr-campaign-brochure-eb2-v9-2288453hbr-campaign-brochure-eb2-v9-2288453
hbr-campaign-brochure-eb2-v9-2288453
Mike Metcalf
 
Cfo as Economic Guardian
Cfo as Economic GuardianCfo as Economic Guardian
Cfo as Economic Guardian
accenture
 
PrinciplesBasedApprochtoCPM
PrinciplesBasedApprochtoCPMPrinciplesBasedApprochtoCPM
PrinciplesBasedApprochtoCPM
Joseph Alenchery
 
Organizational effectiveness goes digital
Organizational effectiveness goes digital  Organizational effectiveness goes digital
Organizational effectiveness goes digital
Strategy&, a member of the PwC network
 
My singlepoint - Strategy Execution Suite
My singlepoint - Strategy Execution SuiteMy singlepoint - Strategy Execution Suite
My singlepoint - Strategy Execution Suite
PHILIPPE CORNETTE
 
Revitalizing Finance
Revitalizing FinanceRevitalizing Finance
Revitalizing Finance
Cognizant
 
RoleofCFO_Oracle
RoleofCFO_OracleRoleofCFO_Oracle
RoleofCFO_Oracle
Michael Jenkins
 
Planning budgeting forecasting
Planning budgeting forecastingPlanning budgeting forecasting
Planning budgeting forecasting
Enrique de Nicolás Marín
 
Planning and Forecasting - Aligning Finance Models to Streamline Business Pro...
Planning and Forecasting - Aligning Finance Models to Streamline Business Pro...Planning and Forecasting - Aligning Finance Models to Streamline Business Pro...
Planning and Forecasting - Aligning Finance Models to Streamline Business Pro...
QueBIT Consulting
 
report-kpmg-acca-pbf.pdf
report-kpmg-acca-pbf.pdfreport-kpmg-acca-pbf.pdf
report-kpmg-acca-pbf.pdf
orangepony
 
oracle-cfo-whitepaper-epm
oracle-cfo-whitepaper-epmoracle-cfo-whitepaper-epm
oracle-cfo-whitepaper-epm
Matt Holder ?
 
White Paper: Predictability Through Planning Agility
White Paper: Predictability Through Planning AgilityWhite Paper: Predictability Through Planning Agility
White Paper: Predictability Through Planning Agility
Host Analytics
 
Future of finance, in the law firm
Future of finance, in the law firmFuture of finance, in the law firm
Future of finance, in the law firm
Tanbir Jasimuddin
 
Using Mobility to Expand Planning and Performance Management Best Practices
Using Mobility to Expand Planning and Performance Management Best PracticesUsing Mobility to Expand Planning and Performance Management Best Practices
Using Mobility to Expand Planning and Performance Management Best Practices
SAP Analytics
 
Stepping into the cockpit- Redefining finance's role in the digital age
Stepping into the cockpit- Redefining finance's role in the digital ageStepping into the cockpit- Redefining finance's role in the digital age
Stepping into the cockpit- Redefining finance's role in the digital age
PwC
 

Similar to When is Driver-Based Modeling Applicable (20)

Integrated Planning Part 2
Integrated Planning Part 2Integrated Planning Part 2
Integrated Planning Part 2
 
integrated planning part 1
integrated planning part 1integrated planning part 1
integrated planning part 1
 
2016-how-fp-a-can-become-a-better-business-partner
2016-how-fp-a-can-become-a-better-business-partner2016-how-fp-a-can-become-a-better-business-partner
2016-how-fp-a-can-become-a-better-business-partner
 
Jenny Okonkwo How FP&A Can Become a Better Business Partner
Jenny Okonkwo How FP&A Can Become a Better Business PartnerJenny Okonkwo How FP&A Can Become a Better Business Partner
Jenny Okonkwo How FP&A Can Become a Better Business Partner
 
How FP&A Can Become a Better Business Partner
How FP&A Can Become a Better Business PartnerHow FP&A Can Become a Better Business Partner
How FP&A Can Become a Better Business Partner
 
hbr-campaign-brochure-eb2-v9-2288453
hbr-campaign-brochure-eb2-v9-2288453hbr-campaign-brochure-eb2-v9-2288453
hbr-campaign-brochure-eb2-v9-2288453
 
Cfo as Economic Guardian
Cfo as Economic GuardianCfo as Economic Guardian
Cfo as Economic Guardian
 
PrinciplesBasedApprochtoCPM
PrinciplesBasedApprochtoCPMPrinciplesBasedApprochtoCPM
PrinciplesBasedApprochtoCPM
 
Organizational effectiveness goes digital
Organizational effectiveness goes digital  Organizational effectiveness goes digital
Organizational effectiveness goes digital
 
My singlepoint - Strategy Execution Suite
My singlepoint - Strategy Execution SuiteMy singlepoint - Strategy Execution Suite
My singlepoint - Strategy Execution Suite
 
Revitalizing Finance
Revitalizing FinanceRevitalizing Finance
Revitalizing Finance
 
RoleofCFO_Oracle
RoleofCFO_OracleRoleofCFO_Oracle
RoleofCFO_Oracle
 
Planning budgeting forecasting
Planning budgeting forecastingPlanning budgeting forecasting
Planning budgeting forecasting
 
Planning and Forecasting - Aligning Finance Models to Streamline Business Pro...
Planning and Forecasting - Aligning Finance Models to Streamline Business Pro...Planning and Forecasting - Aligning Finance Models to Streamline Business Pro...
Planning and Forecasting - Aligning Finance Models to Streamline Business Pro...
 
report-kpmg-acca-pbf.pdf
report-kpmg-acca-pbf.pdfreport-kpmg-acca-pbf.pdf
report-kpmg-acca-pbf.pdf
 
oracle-cfo-whitepaper-epm
oracle-cfo-whitepaper-epmoracle-cfo-whitepaper-epm
oracle-cfo-whitepaper-epm
 
White Paper: Predictability Through Planning Agility
White Paper: Predictability Through Planning AgilityWhite Paper: Predictability Through Planning Agility
White Paper: Predictability Through Planning Agility
 
Future of finance, in the law firm
Future of finance, in the law firmFuture of finance, in the law firm
Future of finance, in the law firm
 
Using Mobility to Expand Planning and Performance Management Best Practices
Using Mobility to Expand Planning and Performance Management Best PracticesUsing Mobility to Expand Planning and Performance Management Best Practices
Using Mobility to Expand Planning and Performance Management Best Practices
 
Stepping into the cockpit- Redefining finance's role in the digital age
Stepping into the cockpit- Redefining finance's role in the digital ageStepping into the cockpit- Redefining finance's role in the digital age
Stepping into the cockpit- Redefining finance's role in the digital age
 

More from Nilly Essaides

10 ways
10 ways10 ways
FPandA Leadership Within Business Units
FPandA Leadership Within Business UnitsFPandA Leadership Within Business Units
FPandA Leadership Within Business Units
Nilly Essaides
 
Building an analytics hub
Building an analytics hubBuilding an analytics hub
Building an analytics hub
Nilly Essaides
 
How FPandA can Plan for and during a crisis
How FPandA can Plan for and during a crisisHow FPandA can Plan for and during a crisis
How FPandA can Plan for and during a crisis
Nilly Essaides
 
Algorithmic Forecasting
Algorithmic ForecastingAlgorithmic Forecasting
Algorithmic Forecasting
Nilly Essaides
 
The C in FPAandC
The C in FPAandCThe C in FPAandC
The C in FPAandC
Nilly Essaides
 
Reverse Engineering The Budget
Reverse Engineering The BudgetReverse Engineering The Budget
Reverse Engineering The Budget
Nilly Essaides
 
Finance, Forward Looking October 2016
Finance, Forward Looking October 2016Finance, Forward Looking October 2016
Finance, Forward Looking October 2016
Nilly Essaides
 

More from Nilly Essaides (8)

10 ways
10 ways10 ways
10 ways
 
FPandA Leadership Within Business Units
FPandA Leadership Within Business UnitsFPandA Leadership Within Business Units
FPandA Leadership Within Business Units
 
Building an analytics hub
Building an analytics hubBuilding an analytics hub
Building an analytics hub
 
How FPandA can Plan for and during a crisis
How FPandA can Plan for and during a crisisHow FPandA can Plan for and during a crisis
How FPandA can Plan for and during a crisis
 
Algorithmic Forecasting
Algorithmic ForecastingAlgorithmic Forecasting
Algorithmic Forecasting
 
The C in FPAandC
The C in FPAandCThe C in FPAandC
The C in FPAandC
 
Reverse Engineering The Budget
Reverse Engineering The BudgetReverse Engineering The Budget
Reverse Engineering The Budget
 
Finance, Forward Looking October 2016
Finance, Forward Looking October 2016Finance, Forward Looking October 2016
Finance, Forward Looking October 2016
 

When is Driver-Based Modeling Applicable

  • 1. When is Driver-Based Modeling Applicable? Nilly Essaides Director, FP&A Practice, The Association for Financial Professionals More companies are looking to put science in their forecasting and planning processes. To this end, they’re basing more and more of their forecasting models on key business drivers – those factors that can really move the needle and affect enterprise performance. “Driver-based modeling and planning use operational drivers to predict financial results,” said Philip Peck, Vice President, Financial Transformation at consulting firm Peloton Group. These models are essentially equations that represent mathematical relationship between key operational drivers (e.g. volume, rates, conversion ratios, brand awareness, etc.) and anticipated financial outcomes. The driver-based models have several key advantages: they’re more accurate, more efficient, can be run on the fly and enable FP&A to come up with actionable information more quickly, at a time when senior management is facing an increasingly complex and uncertain business environment. They also help balance the inherent bias managers have in producing forecasting data -- a combination of human error, politics and over-optimism. Of course, to do this they have to be correct. When does it work? According to Mitch Max, CEO and President of BetterVu, forecasting is one of the first areas where driver-based models can be applied. “As a basic example, if I’m forecasting a product or series of products, and have a price, the driver is typically volume; it’s a simple metric calculation of rate X volume. It’s applicable in many volume-sensitive calculations. But it can also be used for non-volume-sensitive items, for example, you can apply a driver-based calculation to payroll and multiply by average salary,” Max said.
  • 2. “What’s important is the level of detail. Even drivers have different levels of detail,” said Sholape Kolawole, EPM Transformation Associate Principle at The Hackett Group. The level of detail should be aligned with the applicability to each planning cycle. For example, a quick monthly forecast or the strategic plan would call for a less detailed driver approach. According to Vic Datta, CEO of Resilicore: “The models enable the company to move away from allocation-based budgeting to a more anticipatory approach, with an “activity-based” costing approach as the precursor. “Driver-based models are outcome based, rather than the more traditional inward-looking models,” Datta explained. But driver-based models may not work everywhere. Craig Schiff, Owner of consultancy BPM Partners Schiff said that he thinks driver-based modeling is very applicable in the forecasting and long-range planning processes in FP&A but less so in the detailed budgeting process. “When you look at budgeting it’s not ideal,” he noted. “The budget includes a very detailed expenses and revenue lines for the year,” he said, “whereas driver-based models are better suited to higher-level, quicker and more frequent forecast and planning processes.” Budgeting often involves mapping expenses by area, by month. A true driver-based model won’t produce these results. Another area where driver-based models don't work is in fixed costs, for example rent, or charitable donations. In addition, according to Curtis Gratz, Director at Huron Consulting Group, driver-based modeling is not applicable where there are only very loose relationships between drivers and outputs, or if these items are not material or actionable. “Building this additional, low value add, details encumbers participants to plan at a detail that does not help the goals and mission of the corporation and just takes up time,” Gratz said.