Perspective   Roman Friedrich
              Florian Gröne
              Klaus Hölbling
              Michael Peterson




The Rise of
Mobile Marketing
New Opportunities
for Consumer
Companies and
Mobile Operators
Contact Information

Berlin
Florian Gröne
Senior Associate
+49-30-88705-844
florian.groene@booz.com

Düsseldorf
Roman Friedrich
Partner
+49-211-3890-165
roman.friedrich@booz.com

Munich
Michael Peterson
Partner
+49-89-54525-640
michael.peterson@booz.com

Vienna
Klaus Hölbling
Partner
+43-1-518-22-907
klaus.hoelbling@booz.com




                            Booz & Company
EXECUTIVE        The mobile channel offers an exciting opportunity for
                 marketers—one that most have yet to fully embrace. One
SUMMARY
                 avenue to pursue is the creation of a branded mobile offering,
                 in which the marketer creates a portal dedicated to its product,
                 service, or brand. With constant access to each customer,
                 branded mobile portals can build interactive relationships by
                 identifying consumers not only in terms of personal identity,
                 but also in terms of commercial behavior, geographic location,
                 and social and communication patterns. When consumers
                 sign up for a branded mobile channel, they get access to
                 a variety of distinct offerings that can include exclusive
                 content as well as applications, games, special opportunities,
                 incentives, and emotional experiences—all of which reinforce
                 the value of the sponsoring brand far beyond its standard
                 uses. The rewards for companies that capitalize on these
                 possibilities—deeper engagement with consumers, increased
                 brand loyalty, and enhanced customer lifetime value—are not
                 to be missed.




Booz & Company                                                                  1
A Powerful         Of all the opportunities for market-
                   ing made available by new media,
                                                               The technology chain is relatively
                                                               simple: A company offering services
New Platform       the mobile platform perhaps holds           or products contracts with a mobile-
                   the most potential. Indeed, the use of      service provider to create a mobile
                   mobile devices represents an unprec-        brand. The mobile brand speaks to
                   edented and unparalleled shift in how       customers—loyal users who identify
                   consumers use media. But the mobile         with the sponsor, as well as new
                   channel’s growth as a marketing and         audiences drawn by the simple value
                   advertising vehicle has been so fast that   proposition of better service at a
                   some of the world’s most sophisticated      lower price. The result? More power-
                   marketers have yet to determine how         ful customer relationships and new
                   to fully embrace it—not for lack of         revenue streams.
                   desire, but for lack of experience.
                                                               A European football team connects
                   New business models for mobile mar-         with its most ardent supporters via a
                   keting are turning the mobile phone         mobile service that provides not just
                   into a marketer-exclusive platform.         player information and game statis-
                   Marketers can create mobile portals         tics but also the chance to purchase
                   dedicated to their business or brand        tickets, T-shirts, and memorabilia.
                   (giving their message exclusive airtime     A discount convenience store rein-
                   with their best customers), a choice        forces its image as a place for quick,
                   of tailored handsets (to match the          inexpensive service with a branded
                   brand), preloaded applications that         low-cost mobile offering. Customers
                   drive further contact with the brand,       who want to buy more minutes can
                   and any number of other develop-            just stop by the store—where they
                   ing technologies that drive home the        might be drawn in by, say, the store’s
                   exclusivity of the message.                 new cereal promotion (communicated
                                                               via text message, of course). Although
                   Take the case of mobile phones              most U.S. marketers have been slow
                   branded by Bild, the largest mass-          to respond to the mobile challenge,
                   market newspaper in Germany: The            the Polo Ralph Lauren Corporation—
                   mobile device belongs to the customer       that most American of retailers—is
                   to use in whatever way he or she            giving tech-smart fashionistas the
                   chooses. But everything about it—           chance to shop by phone. It can talk
                   from the message on the screen to the       directly with its best customers over
                   games and gimmicks on the portal to         its own dedicated (and branded)
                   the no-frills rate plan—says “Bild” in      mobile service.
                   a loud (but consumer-friendly) voice.




The result? More powerful
customer relationships
and new revenue streams.


2                                                                                    Booz & Company
Reaching         For marketing managers, the omni-
                 presence of ever more personalized
                                                            access advantage over other
                                                            channels, but it is not exclusive or
the Segment      digital media means that consumers         entirely transportable. Mobile is
of One           are better informed, more demand-
                 ing, and more focused on individual
                                                            exclusively available to the primary
                                                            users—not just in fixed locations,
                 needs than ever before. In trying to       but wherever they go.
                 reach this “segment of one,” market-
                 ers find that traditional metrics like   • Customer Insight: The mobile
                                                            
                 gross reach pale in comparison with        channel gives companies access
                 such informed measures as digital          to a wide range of consumer
                 net reach and cost per transaction.        data, including demographics,
                 Mobile channels, in particular, allow      communication and social patterns,
                 game-changing marketing plays that         and—with consumer consent—even
                 address individual customer needs          geographic movement patterns,
                 and interests. And, by doing so, they      thanks to GPS or network
                 also maximize net reach impact.            cell information. Once mobile
                                                            commerce gains traction—and it
                 In its potential to shape and monetize     is only a matter of time before it
                 the customer relationship, there are       does—businesses can add shopping
                 five ways in which mobile outper-          history, online store preferences,
                 forms all other marketing channels         and spending patterns to the list.
                 and platforms (see Exhibit 1, page 4).
                                                          • Customer Dialogue: Although
                                                            
                 • Customer Access: The mobile
                                                           mobile channels do not offer
                   channel provides virtually               the multimedia home theater
                   continuous access to consumers           experience that many PCs
                   via voice, messaging, or portal          provide (and mobile channels
                   platforms. The Internet has an           will obviously never match screen




Booz  Company                                                                                  3
size), their content-rich, real-time       phone is truly interactive, allowing              generation of iPhones.) Because
    visual and acoustic platform can be        consumers to respond by click,                    of that emotional statement, users
    uniquely tailored to an individual         voice, text, or multimedia message.               are highly attached to their mobile
    consumer. Families, co-workers,                                                              devices as not only essential tools
    and friends share computer use.         •  ustomer Emotions: A consumer’s
                                              C                                                  but familiar parts of their everyday
    The mobile phone is a distinctly          choice of a mobile device often is                 lives. Because the mobile channel
    personal device that reflects the use     a strong lifestyle statement. (Just                enjoys a universal always-on
    and interests of its primary user.        ask the thousands of people who                    presence in people’s lives, it is a
    And like the Internet, the mobile         have stood in line to buy the next                 powerful platform for advocates,




Exhibit 1:
Major Channels’ Potential to Reach Customers


                                            I. Access




                                                                     Mobile
                         TV, Radio,
                            Print




V. Transactions                                                                        II. Insight




                                                                               Catalogue,
                                                                               Direct Mail



             PC-based
              Internet


                                                                              Retail




                     IV. Emotions                                   III. Dialogue

Source: Booz  Company




4                                                                                                                    Booz  Company
believers, and supporters of a             to the airport. And merchants can      location, and social and communica-
  certain topic, product, brand, or          respond to consumer interest in        tion patterns. Most important, inter-
  way of life. In short, people get          an e-commerce venue by instantly       action within the business or social
  excited about their mobile phones          updating prices or pushing new         environment can occur immediately
  in a way they never do about the           offers.                                through the multimedia capabilities of
  PC or the TV.                                                                     a mobile phone.
                                           These five dimensions of the mobile
•  ustomer Transactions: There
  C                                        customer’s relationship provide          By creating a relevant user experience,
  are few physical boundaries for          a distinct context for marketers         mobile devices give consumers more
  mobile devices. And that mobility        who must present a unique value          of what they want while providing
  means that direct click-through,         proposition to connect with their        marketers with a powerful platform
  e-commerce applications, or mobile       customers. In highly competitive         for multitiered, next-generation
  payment solutions are easily             markets, in particular, consumers are    marketing campaigns. Because it can
  available to consumers no matter         becoming accustomed to end-to-end        literally put a product or service in a
  where they are. In markets such as       brand experiences that stretch across    prime prospect’s hands, the mobile
  Korea and Japan, customers can           the physical and digital world.          platform is a channel that can imme-
  purchase goods from the windows                                                   diately enhance a brand’s value. It
  of a store that closed to foot traffic   Mobile channels, with 24/7 access        adds immediacy, relevance, timeliness,
  hours earlier; the same may soon         to a unique consumer, can build          access, and unique customer insight.
  be true in Europe and the United         interactive relationships by identify-   And, with those advantages, it offers
  States. If travelers are late for a      ing customers not only in terms of       marketers new opportunities to boost
  flight, they can make up time by         personal identity, but also in terms     (and measure) their return on market-
  checking in from a cab on the way        of commercial behavior, geographic       ing investments.




In highly competitive markets, consumers
are accustomed to brand experiences that
stretch across the physical and digital world.




Booz  Company                                                                                                           5
The          Depending on how they want to reach
             their customers and on their strategic
                                                      Or marketers might use the digital
                                                      channel to respond to loyal custom-
Parameters   objectives and positioning, marketers    ers’ behavior patterns with rewards
of Mobile    can use branded mobile offerings in
             a number of ways to generate value,
                                                      triggered by certain behaviors: “Spend
                                                      45 minutes browsing stock informa-
Branding     first for consumers and ultimately for   tion on our financial-services mobile
             the bottom line.                         channel and receive a discounted
                                                      stock trade offer.”
             It is important to remember that
             there is no one-size-fits-all formula    Brand-centric content and interactive
             for mobile platforms. Each product       applications can build brand loyalty
             or service has specific brand-building   with videos and product demonstra-
             needs that will shape the nature of      tions, as well as through games and
             its mobile offering. And the deep        competitions. Such easily accessible
             toolbox available allows marketers to    content can also manage desired
             pick and choose what best suits their    channel migration to lower-cost offer-
             short- and long-term objectives.         ings: “Purchase your airline tickets
                                                      through our branded travel mobile
             In its most basic form, a branded        offering and check in with discounts,
             mobile play would look to do little      free calls, or loyalty points.”
             more than reinforce brand recogni-
             tion with classic push advertising       Master-class mobile models fully tap
             and enhanced brand visibility. Such      into the platform’s potential by using
             a program would give a prequalified      digital channels to build interactive,
             audience easy access to special offers   collaborative customer programs
             and promotions via e-mail, portal,       that enable transactions. Think of a
             and SMS/MMS tools. Although rev-         branded credit card with an interac-
             enue sharing—new income driven by        tive communications device attached
             incremental network traffic, mobile      and you can begin to imagine the pos-
             usage, and data downloads—is an          sibilities inherent in product and ser-
             easily quantifiable asset of a basic     vice transactions enabled via mobile
             channel, revenue diversification in      devices. Collaborative programs—user
             itself is not a compelling reason to     forums, user-generated content, mobile
             move into mobile media.                  focus groups, and digital beta testing,
                                                      to name a few—further increase the
             Consumer insight and engagement are      relevance of the content. For superior
             the hallmarks of an advanced tier of     credibility, master-class platforms can
             mobile models. By creating a mul-        offer such location-based mobile ser-
             timedia user experience targeted to      vices as region-specific content, sight-
             subscribers’ specific needs or inter-    seeing or shopping guides, and even
             ests, this next-generation platform      train connections that leave from the
             generates business value in a number     customer’s current location in the next
             of ways. For instance, marketers can     hour. From a business-management
             cross-sell or up-sell their products     perspective, these platforms can call
             and services using customized content    on subscribers with real-time queries:
             offered by online media and mobile       “Call or text us free to tell us what
             applications. Such incentives encour-    you think of our new gizmo.” Such
             age customers to accrue usage-based      collaborative approaches to product
             points that they can redeem for          development can cut the costs—and
             brand-related products or services.      turnaround time—of innovation.




6                                                                            Booz  Company
Cutting-Edge        In a previous generation of media
                    consumption, one of the most dif-
                                                              • Is there a robust pipeline of ideas to
                                                              tailor enough content, applications,
Mobile              ficult challenges was moving readers      games, tools, campaigns, and promo-
Opportunities       from one daily newspaper to another.
                    Habit—not quality or relevance of
                                                              tions to keep the user interested?

                    content—was the key reason for con-       Does the mobile channel align with
                    sumer loyalty. And so it is in this new   the brand’s core values?
                    generation: An offering has to be con-
                    vincingly superior to make customers      •  an we rule out potential damage
                                                                C
                    change familiar habits. To persuade         to the brand, such as misaligned
                    a customer to move to a branded             mobile and offline offerings,
                    mobile service, a marketer must find        insufficient network quality,
                    positive answers to a number of             and inadequate data-delivery
                    daunting questions, each of which           connections?
                    invites more specific considerations:
                                                              •  an the mobile offering be tailored
                                                                C
                    Does the branded mobile channel             well enough so that it becomes
                    create genuine value for the brand’s        aligned with core brand values,
                    consumers?                                  on the one hand, and customer
                                                                expectations, on the other?
                    •  hat can the branded mobile
                      W
                      channel add to the customer             •  ill the service be aimed at the
                                                                W
                      experience that existing marketing        mass market or exclusive? Or will
                      channels cannot?                          it draw on both options, offering




An offering has to be
convincingly superior to make
customers change familiar habits.


Booz  Company                                                                                         7
discount pricing that still provides     and avoid the potential brand            •  re there realistic options for
                                                                                        A
    exclusive brand or content messages      damage of a less-than-satisfying           outsourcing noncore activities and
    to generate consumer insight?            mobile experience?                         complementing in-house resources?

•  ill the pricing program reinforce
  W                                         Is the business capable of providing a    It is essential for any enterprise to care-
  the overall perception of the brand?      branded mobile service?                   fully evaluate its responses to this full
                                                                                      list of questions; however, the business
What is the economic significance of        •  an the organization deliver the
                                              C                                       (or brand) best suited for a mobile chan-
the branded mobile channel?                   required content and applications to    nel typically is characterized by a strong
                                              implement and support the branded       presence in its customers’ everyday lives;
•  an the program reach sufficient
  C                                           channel?                                a brand or product to which customers
  scale to realize the expected benefits?                                             have an intense emotional attachment
                                            •  an the organization deliver
                                              C                                       and for which there is a solid network
•  ill the branded experience be
  W                                           effectively? Can it keep the pipeline   of consumer advocates; and a cus-
  strong enough to get word-of-mouth          filled with viable, engaging content,   tomer base whose loyalty is grounded
  and viral community endorsement             campaigns, and promotions?              in a deep sense of community.




Is the business capable of providing
a branded mobile service?




8                                                                                                              Booz  Company
The Feasibility   Marketers have any number of
                  reasons to be reluctant to break with
                                                             services in increasingly competitive
                                                             markets. At that early stage of devel-
of Mobile         tradition and jump on the mobile           opment, differentiation of consumer
                  bandwagon. Marketers are not tech-         experience was minimal or nonex-
                  nologists. And, as a subset of commu-      istent. As we described above, its
                  nication technology, mobile services       “basic” purpose was to put the brand
                  is not a field in which anyone expects     in front of the customer in a passive
                  marketers to be specialists. Until         (but friendly and favorable) manner.
                  recently, a branded mobile offering
                  required marketers to spend a good         Today’s mobile service player land-
                  share of their time and money devis-       scape is very different. The vertical
                  ing ways to run back-end processes—        dis-integration of the mobile value
                  such as portal platforms, billing          chain and the increasing commoditi-
                  systems, and digital customer-care         zation of network services translate
                  procedures—which often led to fail-        into far more differentiation than
                  ure and frustration.                       MVNOs were able to provide even
                                                             just a few years ago (see Exhibit 2,
                  The good news is that building a           page 10).
                  branded mobile offering no longer
                  requires a major up-front investment.      What does this mean for marketers?
                  Marketers can provide the brand and        For starters, they can relax: Becoming
                  content, and a service provider can do     a mobile player is no longer too risky
                  the rest of the work.                      or expensive. They do not need to go
                                                             out and buy a whole new set of tools;
                  The business models for delivering         there are partners eager to provide
                  mobile services have evolved over the      reasonably priced services at every
                  last five years or so, most quickly in     stage of the new value chain.
                  Asia, followed by Europe and then
                  the United States. What began as an        More specifically, mobile plays no
                  investment-heavy model dominated           longer require businesses to become
                  by a few integrated players is now         network operators, virtual or
                  a more open, dynamic market with           otherwise. Entry barriers have been
                  specialists at virtually every step of     lowered across the board: Capital
                  the value chain managing different         expenditures are close to zero,
                  aspects of technology and audience         and economically viable services
                  development.                               allow brand sponsors to efficiently
                                                             approach smaller target groups.
                  The first wave of value chain dis-inte-    The new service provider ecosystem
                  gration introduced new players that        allows marketers to take a calmer, less
                  used excess network capacity from          expensive launch-and-learn approach
                  mobile network operators (MNOs)            to mastering mobile channels.
                  as a platform for virtual players
                  (mobile virtual network operators, or      The presence of a rich variety of
                  MVNOs), whose primary focus was            service providers opens the customer-
                  delivering no-frills, low-cost telephony   facing end of the value chain to a




Booz  Company                                                                                       9
broad range of players. Concerned                       The upswing in mobile is just
about mobile network infrastructure,                    beginning, even in the world’s most
handset design and configuration,                       technologically savvy markets. The
portals, application development,                       blogosphere is buzzing with rumors
back-end processes, content                             of branded mobile services sponsored
management, and preconfigured                           by the likes of social networkers
advertising campaigns? Outsource                        Facebook, LinkedIn, MySpace,
it all or pick the pieces you want to                   studiVZ, and XING. And, from a
control directly. With next-generation                  more traditional perspective, the
mobile platform development,                            barriers to entry are low for any
marketers have complete flexibility                     brand-driven business across luxury
in deciding how much or how little                      niches or broader mass-consumer
they want to be involved in the more                    segments—media and entertainment;
upstream aspects of the mobile play.                    fashion; retail; membership-driven
And that allows them to go back                         organizations, including sports or
to basics and do what they do best:                     charities; financial services; travel and
embrace the customer, in this case                      leisure; even automotive.
with a unique mobile offering.




Exhibit 2:
The Evolution of Mobile Operators’ Business Models



 Equipment       Network       Enabling       Application  Application     Customer     Sales          Customer
  Device        Operation      Technology     Development Service         Care           Marketing   Proposition
 Manufacturing                                              Provision        Billing                    Branding
                                                              Hosting

                                               Content         Portal
                                               Development    Service



 Original        Mobile Network Operators
 Equipment                                                                                                           The Old Days       • ncreasing Customer
                                                                                                                                          I
 Manu-                                                                                                               1990–2004            Segmentation
 facturer
                                                                        Resellers                                                       • ncreasing Differentiation
                                                                                                                                          I
                                                                                                                                          of Offerings
                                             Mobile Virtual Network Operators                                                           • Increasing Specialization
                                                                                                                                          
                                                                                                                     Virtualization       Along Value Chain
                                                                                                                     2004–2007          •  ecreasing Entry
                                                                                                                                          D
                                             Channel Enablers                                                                             Barriers and
                                             • Mobile Virtual Network Enablers                                                            Capital Expenditure
                                             • Application Developers                                                                     Requirements
                                             • Managed Service System Providers
                                             • Multimedia and Advertising Agencies                                   Brand-centricity
                                                                                                        Branded      2007–
                                                                                                 Mobile Channel



Source: Booz  Company




10                                                                                                                                          Booz  Company
The Time         Consumers have long recognized the
                 convenience and comfort of mobile
                                                            Most particularly, they want the
                                                            access that mobile devices provide to
Has Come         devices. And, at last, the barriers that   seamless customer experiences that
                 limited mobile consumer experiences        can link them to other parts of their
                 have been removed.                         offline and online lives.

                 A feature-rich generation of attrac-       Finally, branded mobile channels
                 tive mobile devices like the iPhone        now offer marketers in consumer-
                 (with touchscreen commands, crisp          focused businesses a rich tool with
                 displays, and intuitive entry modes),      significant potential to build brands
                 BlackBerry, and others has arrived,        and generate value. For the first time
                 and the devices now commonly               in the history of the mobile channel,
                 include GPS navigation, MP3 players,       entry barriers have been lowered
                 cameras, and various other multime-        sufficiently to make branded mobile
                 dia features. High-speed connectiv-        plays not only conceptually attractive
                 ity, including broadband and 3G, is        but economically feasible.
                 widely available to the vast majority
                 of people in developed markets.            With the elimination of financial
                                                            and economic barriers, marketers
                 As usage-based tariffs are replaced        finally have the chance to leverage the
                 by attractive flat rates, regulators       new business model and address the
                 are also cracking down on roaming          opportunities of mobile marketing:
                 and termination fees. And cost has         real-time access to customers, deep
                 disappeared as a major roadblock for       insights into consumer behavior, and
                 data-rich multimedia services.             value generation for customers. The
                                                            rewards for those who capitalize on
                 Further, as a social driver in the         these opportunities—deeper engage-
                 move to mobile services, the broad         ment with consumers, increased
                 acceptance of the medium across            brand loyalty, and enhanced customer
                 regions and cultures demonstrates          lifetime value—not only are clear, but
                 that the devices have become lifestyle     are not to be missed.
                 icons that consumers decidedly want.




Booz  Company                                                                                   11
Mobile Manual: A Six-Point Checklist for Marketers

     Although each branded mobile offering has its own characteristics, any marketer
     interested in the medium needs to address six steps for a successful program.

     Develop a pipeline of content that can bring the channel to life and keep its
     buzz going: Recycled offline offerings usually do not work. The mobile offering
     demands a pipeline of tailored, differentiated, exclusive components. A small
     team needs to focus on ongoing marketing execution (digital marketing, next-
     generation campaign management) and third-party management.

     Design customized content that reinforces the core brand values and engages
     targeted customers: To avoid damaging the brand (and losing customers), there
     must be alignment among brand, customer characteristics, and the mobile
     proposition. To differentiate a marketer’s product from a spate of discount of-
     ferings, brand and mobile offerings should match up in terms of the device’s
     design and features and the pricing model—including whether it is low-cost or
     premium, delivered for a flat fee or subsidized by advertising.

     Review the business case and verify value-added components and benefits:
     Examine customer loyalty levels, user uptake, penetration, growth projections,
     targets, critical scale and break-even points, and possible cannibalization or
     cross-fertilization of the non-mobile business. Outsourcing operations can mini-
     mize investment as well as financial and operational risk.

     Align the configuration of the mobile service value chain with core business capa-
     bilities: Define the proper level of outsourcing in noncore activities (infrastructure
     operations, business support services, portal management) and focus on de-
     livery capacity in core value-added activities (marketing, content development,
     campaigns, advertising). Support the integration of the mobile offering with such
     customized applications as unique messaging tools.

     Pick a service provider whose offerings match your brand’s needs: The service
     provider can make or break the user experience. For content-rich interactive
     offerings, one of the critical issues is access—not just capacity but also control,
     security, customer data integrity, privacy, property rights, content control, and the
     reliability of content partners.

     Launch branded mobile offerings with an orchestrated, high-impact program:
     Compelling content and applications can make a powerful impression from Day
     One. Test before you launch. Optimize events with special sales, promotions,
     and quick trial-and-error programs that invite engagement. Orchestrate mes-
     sages across other channels, including traditional broadcast outlets; proactively
     stimulate mobile uptake by promoting special mobile content or offers via non-
     mobile channels.




12                                                                        Booz  Company
Resources
Olaf Acker, Florian Gröne, and Klaus Hölbling, “Beyond the
Mass Mailing,” Booz  Company, March 2008: www.booz.com/
global/home/what_we_think/reports_and_white_papers/ic-
display/41901862

Christopher Vollmer, Always On: Advertising, Marketing,
and Media in an Era of Consumer Control, McGraw-Hill, 2008:
www.businessfuture.com/fbs/alwayson/26655293




About the Authors

Roman Friedrich is a partner        Klaus Hölbling is a partner with
with Booz  Company based           Booz  Company in Vienna. He
in Düsseldorf and is the head       specializes in marketing, sales,
of the European communica-          and customer service capabili-
tions, media, and technology        ties for the telecom, high-tech,
practice. He focuses on the         and transportation industries.
strategic transformation of lead-
ing telecom organizations in        Michael Peterson is a partner
the European mobile, fixed-line,    with Booz  Company in
and Internet markets.               Munich. He specializes in strat-
                                    egy development, particularly
Florian Gröne is a senior asso-     in marketing, sales, and other
ciate with Booz  Company in        customer-facing activities, for
Berlin. He focuses on improving     communications and technol-
operating models and develop-       ogy companies.
ing technology capabilities in
marketing, sales, and customer
service for telecom organizations
and other IT-driven businesses.




Booz  Company                                                         13
The most recent list of     Worldwide        Bangkok        Madrid        Dubai           South America
our office addresses and    Offices          Brisbane       Milan         Riyadh          Buenos Aires
telephone numbers can                        Canberra       Moscow                        Rio de Janeiro
be found on our website,    Asia             Jakarta        Munich        North America   Santiago
www.booz.com                Beijing          Kuala Lumpur   Oslo          Atlanta         São Paulo
                            Hong Kong        Melbourne      Paris         Chicago
                            Mumbai           Sydney         Rome          Cleveland
                            Seoul                           Stockholm     Dallas
                            Shanghai         Europe         Stuttgart     Detroit
                            Taipei           Amsterdam      Vienna        Florham Park
                            Tokyo            Berlin         Warsaw        Houston
                                             Copenhagen     Zurich        Los Angeles
                            Australia,       Dublin                       McLean
                            New Zealand     Düsseldorf     Middle East   Mexico City
                            Southeast Asia   Frankfurt      Abu Dhabi     New York City
                            Adelaide         Helsinki       Beirut        Parsippany
                            Auckland         London         Cairo         San Francisco




Booz  Company is a leading global management
consulting firm, helping the world’s top businesses,
governments, and organizations.

Our founder, Edwin Booz, defined the profession
when he established the first management consulting
firm in 1914.

Today, with more than 3,300 people in 58 offices
around the world, we bring foresight and knowledge,
deep functional expertise, and a practical approach
to building capabilities and delivering real impact.
We work closely with our clients to create and deliver
essential advantage.

For our management magazine strategy+business,
visit www.strategy-business.com.

Visit www.booz.com to learn more about
Booz  Company.




Printed in USA
©2008 Booz  Company Inc.

The Rise of Mobile Marketing

  • 1.
    Perspective Roman Friedrich Florian Gröne Klaus Hölbling Michael Peterson The Rise of Mobile Marketing New Opportunities for Consumer Companies and Mobile Operators
  • 2.
    Contact Information Berlin Florian Gröne SeniorAssociate +49-30-88705-844 florian.groene@booz.com Düsseldorf Roman Friedrich Partner +49-211-3890-165 roman.friedrich@booz.com Munich Michael Peterson Partner +49-89-54525-640 michael.peterson@booz.com Vienna Klaus Hölbling Partner +43-1-518-22-907 klaus.hoelbling@booz.com Booz & Company
  • 3.
    EXECUTIVE The mobile channel offers an exciting opportunity for marketers—one that most have yet to fully embrace. One SUMMARY avenue to pursue is the creation of a branded mobile offering, in which the marketer creates a portal dedicated to its product, service, or brand. With constant access to each customer, branded mobile portals can build interactive relationships by identifying consumers not only in terms of personal identity, but also in terms of commercial behavior, geographic location, and social and communication patterns. When consumers sign up for a branded mobile channel, they get access to a variety of distinct offerings that can include exclusive content as well as applications, games, special opportunities, incentives, and emotional experiences—all of which reinforce the value of the sponsoring brand far beyond its standard uses. The rewards for companies that capitalize on these possibilities—deeper engagement with consumers, increased brand loyalty, and enhanced customer lifetime value—are not to be missed. Booz & Company 1
  • 4.
    A Powerful Of all the opportunities for market- ing made available by new media, The technology chain is relatively simple: A company offering services New Platform the mobile platform perhaps holds or products contracts with a mobile- the most potential. Indeed, the use of service provider to create a mobile mobile devices represents an unprec- brand. The mobile brand speaks to edented and unparalleled shift in how customers—loyal users who identify consumers use media. But the mobile with the sponsor, as well as new channel’s growth as a marketing and audiences drawn by the simple value advertising vehicle has been so fast that proposition of better service at a some of the world’s most sophisticated lower price. The result? More power- marketers have yet to determine how ful customer relationships and new to fully embrace it—not for lack of revenue streams. desire, but for lack of experience. A European football team connects New business models for mobile mar- with its most ardent supporters via a keting are turning the mobile phone mobile service that provides not just into a marketer-exclusive platform. player information and game statis- Marketers can create mobile portals tics but also the chance to purchase dedicated to their business or brand tickets, T-shirts, and memorabilia. (giving their message exclusive airtime A discount convenience store rein- with their best customers), a choice forces its image as a place for quick, of tailored handsets (to match the inexpensive service with a branded brand), preloaded applications that low-cost mobile offering. Customers drive further contact with the brand, who want to buy more minutes can and any number of other develop- just stop by the store—where they ing technologies that drive home the might be drawn in by, say, the store’s exclusivity of the message. new cereal promotion (communicated via text message, of course). Although Take the case of mobile phones most U.S. marketers have been slow branded by Bild, the largest mass- to respond to the mobile challenge, market newspaper in Germany: The the Polo Ralph Lauren Corporation— mobile device belongs to the customer that most American of retailers—is to use in whatever way he or she giving tech-smart fashionistas the chooses. But everything about it— chance to shop by phone. It can talk from the message on the screen to the directly with its best customers over games and gimmicks on the portal to its own dedicated (and branded) the no-frills rate plan—says “Bild” in mobile service. a loud (but consumer-friendly) voice. The result? More powerful customer relationships and new revenue streams. 2 Booz & Company
  • 5.
    Reaching For marketing managers, the omni- presence of ever more personalized access advantage over other channels, but it is not exclusive or the Segment digital media means that consumers entirely transportable. Mobile is of One are better informed, more demand- ing, and more focused on individual exclusively available to the primary users—not just in fixed locations, needs than ever before. In trying to but wherever they go. reach this “segment of one,” market- ers find that traditional metrics like • Customer Insight: The mobile gross reach pale in comparison with channel gives companies access such informed measures as digital to a wide range of consumer net reach and cost per transaction. data, including demographics, Mobile channels, in particular, allow communication and social patterns, game-changing marketing plays that and—with consumer consent—even address individual customer needs geographic movement patterns, and interests. And, by doing so, they thanks to GPS or network also maximize net reach impact. cell information. Once mobile commerce gains traction—and it In its potential to shape and monetize is only a matter of time before it the customer relationship, there are does—businesses can add shopping five ways in which mobile outper- history, online store preferences, forms all other marketing channels and spending patterns to the list. and platforms (see Exhibit 1, page 4). • Customer Dialogue: Although • Customer Access: The mobile mobile channels do not offer channel provides virtually the multimedia home theater continuous access to consumers experience that many PCs via voice, messaging, or portal provide (and mobile channels platforms. The Internet has an will obviously never match screen Booz Company 3
  • 6.
    size), their content-rich,real-time phone is truly interactive, allowing generation of iPhones.) Because visual and acoustic platform can be consumers to respond by click, of that emotional statement, users uniquely tailored to an individual voice, text, or multimedia message. are highly attached to their mobile consumer. Families, co-workers, devices as not only essential tools and friends share computer use. • ustomer Emotions: A consumer’s C but familiar parts of their everyday The mobile phone is a distinctly choice of a mobile device often is lives. Because the mobile channel personal device that reflects the use a strong lifestyle statement. (Just enjoys a universal always-on and interests of its primary user. ask the thousands of people who presence in people’s lives, it is a And like the Internet, the mobile have stood in line to buy the next powerful platform for advocates, Exhibit 1: Major Channels’ Potential to Reach Customers I. Access Mobile TV, Radio, Print V. Transactions II. Insight Catalogue, Direct Mail PC-based Internet Retail IV. Emotions III. Dialogue Source: Booz Company 4 Booz Company
  • 7.
    believers, and supportersof a to the airport. And merchants can location, and social and communica- certain topic, product, brand, or respond to consumer interest in tion patterns. Most important, inter- way of life. In short, people get an e-commerce venue by instantly action within the business or social excited about their mobile phones updating prices or pushing new environment can occur immediately in a way they never do about the offers. through the multimedia capabilities of PC or the TV. a mobile phone. These five dimensions of the mobile • ustomer Transactions: There C customer’s relationship provide By creating a relevant user experience, are few physical boundaries for a distinct context for marketers mobile devices give consumers more mobile devices. And that mobility who must present a unique value of what they want while providing means that direct click-through, proposition to connect with their marketers with a powerful platform e-commerce applications, or mobile customers. In highly competitive for multitiered, next-generation payment solutions are easily markets, in particular, consumers are marketing campaigns. Because it can available to consumers no matter becoming accustomed to end-to-end literally put a product or service in a where they are. In markets such as brand experiences that stretch across prime prospect’s hands, the mobile Korea and Japan, customers can the physical and digital world. platform is a channel that can imme- purchase goods from the windows diately enhance a brand’s value. It of a store that closed to foot traffic Mobile channels, with 24/7 access adds immediacy, relevance, timeliness, hours earlier; the same may soon to a unique consumer, can build access, and unique customer insight. be true in Europe and the United interactive relationships by identify- And, with those advantages, it offers States. If travelers are late for a ing customers not only in terms of marketers new opportunities to boost flight, they can make up time by personal identity, but also in terms (and measure) their return on market- checking in from a cab on the way of commercial behavior, geographic ing investments. In highly competitive markets, consumers are accustomed to brand experiences that stretch across the physical and digital world. Booz Company 5
  • 8.
    The Depending on how they want to reach their customers and on their strategic Or marketers might use the digital channel to respond to loyal custom- Parameters objectives and positioning, marketers ers’ behavior patterns with rewards of Mobile can use branded mobile offerings in a number of ways to generate value, triggered by certain behaviors: “Spend 45 minutes browsing stock informa- Branding first for consumers and ultimately for tion on our financial-services mobile the bottom line. channel and receive a discounted stock trade offer.” It is important to remember that there is no one-size-fits-all formula Brand-centric content and interactive for mobile platforms. Each product applications can build brand loyalty or service has specific brand-building with videos and product demonstra- needs that will shape the nature of tions, as well as through games and its mobile offering. And the deep competitions. Such easily accessible toolbox available allows marketers to content can also manage desired pick and choose what best suits their channel migration to lower-cost offer- short- and long-term objectives. ings: “Purchase your airline tickets through our branded travel mobile In its most basic form, a branded offering and check in with discounts, mobile play would look to do little free calls, or loyalty points.” more than reinforce brand recogni- tion with classic push advertising Master-class mobile models fully tap and enhanced brand visibility. Such into the platform’s potential by using a program would give a prequalified digital channels to build interactive, audience easy access to special offers collaborative customer programs and promotions via e-mail, portal, that enable transactions. Think of a and SMS/MMS tools. Although rev- branded credit card with an interac- enue sharing—new income driven by tive communications device attached incremental network traffic, mobile and you can begin to imagine the pos- usage, and data downloads—is an sibilities inherent in product and ser- easily quantifiable asset of a basic vice transactions enabled via mobile channel, revenue diversification in devices. Collaborative programs—user itself is not a compelling reason to forums, user-generated content, mobile move into mobile media. focus groups, and digital beta testing, to name a few—further increase the Consumer insight and engagement are relevance of the content. For superior the hallmarks of an advanced tier of credibility, master-class platforms can mobile models. By creating a mul- offer such location-based mobile ser- timedia user experience targeted to vices as region-specific content, sight- subscribers’ specific needs or inter- seeing or shopping guides, and even ests, this next-generation platform train connections that leave from the generates business value in a number customer’s current location in the next of ways. For instance, marketers can hour. From a business-management cross-sell or up-sell their products perspective, these platforms can call and services using customized content on subscribers with real-time queries: offered by online media and mobile “Call or text us free to tell us what applications. Such incentives encour- you think of our new gizmo.” Such age customers to accrue usage-based collaborative approaches to product points that they can redeem for development can cut the costs—and brand-related products or services. turnaround time—of innovation. 6 Booz Company
  • 9.
    Cutting-Edge In a previous generation of media consumption, one of the most dif- • Is there a robust pipeline of ideas to tailor enough content, applications, Mobile ficult challenges was moving readers games, tools, campaigns, and promo- Opportunities from one daily newspaper to another. Habit—not quality or relevance of tions to keep the user interested? content—was the key reason for con- Does the mobile channel align with sumer loyalty. And so it is in this new the brand’s core values? generation: An offering has to be con- vincingly superior to make customers • an we rule out potential damage C change familiar habits. To persuade to the brand, such as misaligned a customer to move to a branded mobile and offline offerings, mobile service, a marketer must find insufficient network quality, positive answers to a number of and inadequate data-delivery daunting questions, each of which connections? invites more specific considerations: • an the mobile offering be tailored C Does the branded mobile channel well enough so that it becomes create genuine value for the brand’s aligned with core brand values, consumers? on the one hand, and customer expectations, on the other? • hat can the branded mobile W channel add to the customer • ill the service be aimed at the W experience that existing marketing mass market or exclusive? Or will channels cannot? it draw on both options, offering An offering has to be convincingly superior to make customers change familiar habits. Booz Company 7
  • 10.
    discount pricing thatstill provides and avoid the potential brand • re there realistic options for A exclusive brand or content messages damage of a less-than-satisfying outsourcing noncore activities and to generate consumer insight? mobile experience? complementing in-house resources? • ill the pricing program reinforce W Is the business capable of providing a It is essential for any enterprise to care- the overall perception of the brand? branded mobile service? fully evaluate its responses to this full list of questions; however, the business What is the economic significance of • an the organization deliver the C (or brand) best suited for a mobile chan- the branded mobile channel? required content and applications to nel typically is characterized by a strong implement and support the branded presence in its customers’ everyday lives; • an the program reach sufficient C channel? a brand or product to which customers scale to realize the expected benefits? have an intense emotional attachment • an the organization deliver C and for which there is a solid network • ill the branded experience be W effectively? Can it keep the pipeline of consumer advocates; and a cus- strong enough to get word-of-mouth filled with viable, engaging content, tomer base whose loyalty is grounded and viral community endorsement campaigns, and promotions? in a deep sense of community. Is the business capable of providing a branded mobile service? 8 Booz Company
  • 11.
    The Feasibility Marketers have any number of reasons to be reluctant to break with services in increasingly competitive markets. At that early stage of devel- of Mobile tradition and jump on the mobile opment, differentiation of consumer bandwagon. Marketers are not tech- experience was minimal or nonex- nologists. And, as a subset of commu- istent. As we described above, its nication technology, mobile services “basic” purpose was to put the brand is not a field in which anyone expects in front of the customer in a passive marketers to be specialists. Until (but friendly and favorable) manner. recently, a branded mobile offering required marketers to spend a good Today’s mobile service player land- share of their time and money devis- scape is very different. The vertical ing ways to run back-end processes— dis-integration of the mobile value such as portal platforms, billing chain and the increasing commoditi- systems, and digital customer-care zation of network services translate procedures—which often led to fail- into far more differentiation than ure and frustration. MVNOs were able to provide even just a few years ago (see Exhibit 2, The good news is that building a page 10). branded mobile offering no longer requires a major up-front investment. What does this mean for marketers? Marketers can provide the brand and For starters, they can relax: Becoming content, and a service provider can do a mobile player is no longer too risky the rest of the work. or expensive. They do not need to go out and buy a whole new set of tools; The business models for delivering there are partners eager to provide mobile services have evolved over the reasonably priced services at every last five years or so, most quickly in stage of the new value chain. Asia, followed by Europe and then the United States. What began as an More specifically, mobile plays no investment-heavy model dominated longer require businesses to become by a few integrated players is now network operators, virtual or a more open, dynamic market with otherwise. Entry barriers have been specialists at virtually every step of lowered across the board: Capital the value chain managing different expenditures are close to zero, aspects of technology and audience and economically viable services development. allow brand sponsors to efficiently approach smaller target groups. The first wave of value chain dis-inte- The new service provider ecosystem gration introduced new players that allows marketers to take a calmer, less used excess network capacity from expensive launch-and-learn approach mobile network operators (MNOs) to mastering mobile channels. as a platform for virtual players (mobile virtual network operators, or The presence of a rich variety of MVNOs), whose primary focus was service providers opens the customer- delivering no-frills, low-cost telephony facing end of the value chain to a Booz Company 9
  • 12.
    broad range ofplayers. Concerned The upswing in mobile is just about mobile network infrastructure, beginning, even in the world’s most handset design and configuration, technologically savvy markets. The portals, application development, blogosphere is buzzing with rumors back-end processes, content of branded mobile services sponsored management, and preconfigured by the likes of social networkers advertising campaigns? Outsource Facebook, LinkedIn, MySpace, it all or pick the pieces you want to studiVZ, and XING. And, from a control directly. With next-generation more traditional perspective, the mobile platform development, barriers to entry are low for any marketers have complete flexibility brand-driven business across luxury in deciding how much or how little niches or broader mass-consumer they want to be involved in the more segments—media and entertainment; upstream aspects of the mobile play. fashion; retail; membership-driven And that allows them to go back organizations, including sports or to basics and do what they do best: charities; financial services; travel and embrace the customer, in this case leisure; even automotive. with a unique mobile offering. Exhibit 2: The Evolution of Mobile Operators’ Business Models Equipment Network Enabling Application Application Customer Sales Customer Device Operation Technology Development Service Care Marketing Proposition Manufacturing Provision Billing Branding Hosting Content Portal Development Service Original Mobile Network Operators Equipment The Old Days • ncreasing Customer I Manu- 1990–2004 Segmentation facturer Resellers • ncreasing Differentiation I of Offerings Mobile Virtual Network Operators • Increasing Specialization Virtualization Along Value Chain 2004–2007 • ecreasing Entry D Channel Enablers Barriers and • Mobile Virtual Network Enablers Capital Expenditure • Application Developers Requirements • Managed Service System Providers • Multimedia and Advertising Agencies Brand-centricity Branded 2007– Mobile Channel Source: Booz Company 10 Booz Company
  • 13.
    The Time Consumers have long recognized the convenience and comfort of mobile Most particularly, they want the access that mobile devices provide to Has Come devices. And, at last, the barriers that seamless customer experiences that limited mobile consumer experiences can link them to other parts of their have been removed. offline and online lives. A feature-rich generation of attrac- Finally, branded mobile channels tive mobile devices like the iPhone now offer marketers in consumer- (with touchscreen commands, crisp focused businesses a rich tool with displays, and intuitive entry modes), significant potential to build brands BlackBerry, and others has arrived, and generate value. For the first time and the devices now commonly in the history of the mobile channel, include GPS navigation, MP3 players, entry barriers have been lowered cameras, and various other multime- sufficiently to make branded mobile dia features. High-speed connectiv- plays not only conceptually attractive ity, including broadband and 3G, is but economically feasible. widely available to the vast majority of people in developed markets. With the elimination of financial and economic barriers, marketers As usage-based tariffs are replaced finally have the chance to leverage the by attractive flat rates, regulators new business model and address the are also cracking down on roaming opportunities of mobile marketing: and termination fees. And cost has real-time access to customers, deep disappeared as a major roadblock for insights into consumer behavior, and data-rich multimedia services. value generation for customers. The rewards for those who capitalize on Further, as a social driver in the these opportunities—deeper engage- move to mobile services, the broad ment with consumers, increased acceptance of the medium across brand loyalty, and enhanced customer regions and cultures demonstrates lifetime value—not only are clear, but that the devices have become lifestyle are not to be missed. icons that consumers decidedly want. Booz Company 11
  • 14.
    Mobile Manual: ASix-Point Checklist for Marketers Although each branded mobile offering has its own characteristics, any marketer interested in the medium needs to address six steps for a successful program. Develop a pipeline of content that can bring the channel to life and keep its buzz going: Recycled offline offerings usually do not work. The mobile offering demands a pipeline of tailored, differentiated, exclusive components. A small team needs to focus on ongoing marketing execution (digital marketing, next- generation campaign management) and third-party management. Design customized content that reinforces the core brand values and engages targeted customers: To avoid damaging the brand (and losing customers), there must be alignment among brand, customer characteristics, and the mobile proposition. To differentiate a marketer’s product from a spate of discount of- ferings, brand and mobile offerings should match up in terms of the device’s design and features and the pricing model—including whether it is low-cost or premium, delivered for a flat fee or subsidized by advertising. Review the business case and verify value-added components and benefits: Examine customer loyalty levels, user uptake, penetration, growth projections, targets, critical scale and break-even points, and possible cannibalization or cross-fertilization of the non-mobile business. Outsourcing operations can mini- mize investment as well as financial and operational risk. Align the configuration of the mobile service value chain with core business capa- bilities: Define the proper level of outsourcing in noncore activities (infrastructure operations, business support services, portal management) and focus on de- livery capacity in core value-added activities (marketing, content development, campaigns, advertising). Support the integration of the mobile offering with such customized applications as unique messaging tools. Pick a service provider whose offerings match your brand’s needs: The service provider can make or break the user experience. For content-rich interactive offerings, one of the critical issues is access—not just capacity but also control, security, customer data integrity, privacy, property rights, content control, and the reliability of content partners. Launch branded mobile offerings with an orchestrated, high-impact program: Compelling content and applications can make a powerful impression from Day One. Test before you launch. Optimize events with special sales, promotions, and quick trial-and-error programs that invite engagement. Orchestrate mes- sages across other channels, including traditional broadcast outlets; proactively stimulate mobile uptake by promoting special mobile content or offers via non- mobile channels. 12 Booz Company
  • 15.
    Resources Olaf Acker, FlorianGröne, and Klaus Hölbling, “Beyond the Mass Mailing,” Booz Company, March 2008: www.booz.com/ global/home/what_we_think/reports_and_white_papers/ic- display/41901862 Christopher Vollmer, Always On: Advertising, Marketing, and Media in an Era of Consumer Control, McGraw-Hill, 2008: www.businessfuture.com/fbs/alwayson/26655293 About the Authors Roman Friedrich is a partner Klaus Hölbling is a partner with with Booz Company based Booz Company in Vienna. He in Düsseldorf and is the head specializes in marketing, sales, of the European communica- and customer service capabili- tions, media, and technology ties for the telecom, high-tech, practice. He focuses on the and transportation industries. strategic transformation of lead- ing telecom organizations in Michael Peterson is a partner the European mobile, fixed-line, with Booz Company in and Internet markets. Munich. He specializes in strat- egy development, particularly Florian Gröne is a senior asso- in marketing, sales, and other ciate with Booz Company in customer-facing activities, for Berlin. He focuses on improving communications and technol- operating models and develop- ogy companies. ing technology capabilities in marketing, sales, and customer service for telecom organizations and other IT-driven businesses. Booz Company 13
  • 16.
    The most recentlist of Worldwide Bangkok Madrid Dubai South America our office addresses and Offices Brisbane Milan Riyadh Buenos Aires telephone numbers can Canberra Moscow Rio de Janeiro be found on our website, Asia Jakarta Munich North America Santiago www.booz.com Beijing Kuala Lumpur Oslo Atlanta São Paulo Hong Kong Melbourne Paris Chicago Mumbai Sydney Rome Cleveland Seoul Stockholm Dallas Shanghai Europe Stuttgart Detroit Taipei Amsterdam Vienna Florham Park Tokyo Berlin Warsaw Houston Copenhagen Zurich Los Angeles Australia, Dublin McLean New Zealand Düsseldorf Middle East Mexico City Southeast Asia Frankfurt Abu Dhabi New York City Adelaide Helsinki Beirut Parsippany Auckland London Cairo San Francisco Booz Company is a leading global management consulting firm, helping the world’s top businesses, governments, and organizations. Our founder, Edwin Booz, defined the profession when he established the first management consulting firm in 1914. Today, with more than 3,300 people in 58 offices around the world, we bring foresight and knowledge, deep functional expertise, and a practical approach to building capabilities and delivering real impact. We work closely with our clients to create and deliver essential advantage. For our management magazine strategy+business, visit www.strategy-business.com. Visit www.booz.com to learn more about Booz Company. Printed in USA ©2008 Booz Company Inc.