Dennis L. Thomas, Ph. D.

       Co-Chair, Phase I
El Paso/ Southern New Mexico
Regional Clean Energy Initiative
Renewable Energy Projects
              Currently in Operation
        46 MW = $184 million (@ $4,000/kW)


•   El Paso Electric—31.9 MW
•   City of El Paso—12.71 MW
•   Housing Auth.,El Paso—185 kW
•   Ft. Bliss—1.2 MW
•   City of Las Cruces—172 kW
•   UTEP—186 kW
•   Franklin College—20 kW

                                             2
Renewable Energy Projects
                  Under Development
          219 MW = $876 million (@ $4,000/kW)


EPE               22 MW Solar Power Projects (Dona Ana County)
                         10 MW Chaparral Solar Field
                         12 MW Las Cruces Airport

                  2.5 MW Solar Project at Newman Generating Station
                  21 kW Solar Project in Van Horn
Ft. Bliss and EPE 20 MW Solar Facility on Fort Bliss
Ft. Bliss and City 140 MW Waste-to-Energy and Solar Thermal Plant




                                                                      3
City of El Paso       1 MW landfill gas recovery on Clint Landfill
                      2-5 MW rooftop solar (3rd party PPA)
                      2 MW of rooftop solar at Airport
                      Renewable energy incentive program - $1.25 million (solar rebates)
City of Las Cruces    12 MW SunEdison solar project for EPE
                      400 kW expansion of F&A Dairy (cheese) solar project
White Sands Missile R. 4.5 MW Solar PV System at Missile Range Center (Siemens)
NASA – White Sands 1-3 MW Solar PV
El Paso County        6 MW of ground and rooftop solar (PPA)
UTEP                  5.5 MW rooftop solar PV project
                      20 electric vehicle charging station projects
El Paso Com. College Install additional solar panels at ATC (Building 2)


                                                                                           4
Proposed Projects

1.    Become a Net Solar Exporter
2.    Attract Solar Manufacturer to Region
3.    Learn from & Collaborate on Advanced Energy Economy
4.    Assist Military and Federal Facilities Achieve “Net Zero” Goals
5.    Recognition as Regional Renewable Energy Leader
6.    Prepare Study on Clean Energy Business Potential
7.    10,000 DRG Solar Roof Initiative
8.    HUB-UTEP Incubator Programs
9.    Public Awareness and Feedback
10.   El Paso Solar Energy Association Initiative
11.   Establish a Renewable Energy Certification Center
12.   Ysleta Solar & Clean Energy Demo Project
13.   White Sands 40 MW Solar
14.   Develop Solar Canopies at Ports of Entry




                                                                        5
6
7
8
9
10
Project: Help Establish a Solar CREZ Zone



Concept: The CREZ zones have been an effective way to get transmission built to
access the rich wind resources in Texas. The last of the wind CREZ lines will be
completed in 2013. Texas is also rich in solar resources, especially in far West
Texas. Under this concept, interested groups would work to test the economic
feasibility of developing a CREZ zone for solar resources.
Background: The cost of solar power has dropped significantly in the 2nd and 3rd
quarters of 2012. Solar panels started 2012 above a dollar a watt, and now
average 84 cents a watt and are expected to go to 60 cents a watt. All in cost
(installed cost) for large scale solar projects in far West Texas were $2.85 a watt
three months ago, and are currently being bid at $2.10 a watt.
The rumored prices for the winning solar bids in the CPS Energy 400 MW
solicitation were mid $80 per MWh. By comparison, West Texas wind is being
priced below $40 MWh, and coastal wind is being priced in the mid-$40’s MWh.
Solar has the advantage of being coincident with peak usage.
Conclusion: Within 3-5 years, solar will be a competitive resource in the better
solar areas of Texas. There will be a demand for improved transmission to access
that solar in far West Texas.

                                                                                  11
Program Overview (from PUC website)


Description of CREZ: The utilities code section 39.904 in conjunction with
Senate Bill 20 (2005) established Texas's Renewable Energy Program and
directed the PUC to identify Competitive Renewable Energy Zones (CREZ). A
CREZ is a geographic area where wind generation facilities will be
constructed. In 2008, PUC issued order 33672 designating five CREZs for the
generation of wind power and defining the required transmission upgrades to
deliver wind generated energy to Texas consumers.

Transmission build-out program: The CREZ project is the PUC’s response to a
public mandate to increase renewable energy in Texas to serve the electric
needs of the state. The Texas Legislature passed Senate Bill (SB) 7 in
1999, which restructured the state’s electric industry and allowed
Transmission Service Providers (TSPs) to offer transmission services to other
utilities throughout Texas. Ultimately, the CREZ effort will significantly
increase Texas’s current level of wind generation capacity to 18,456 MW.



                                                                            12
Crez Zones




             13
Crez Zones




             14

2012 Reenergize the Americas 1A: Dennis Thomas

  • 1.
    Dennis L. Thomas,Ph. D. Co-Chair, Phase I El Paso/ Southern New Mexico Regional Clean Energy Initiative
  • 2.
    Renewable Energy Projects Currently in Operation 46 MW = $184 million (@ $4,000/kW) • El Paso Electric—31.9 MW • City of El Paso—12.71 MW • Housing Auth.,El Paso—185 kW • Ft. Bliss—1.2 MW • City of Las Cruces—172 kW • UTEP—186 kW • Franklin College—20 kW 2
  • 3.
    Renewable Energy Projects Under Development 219 MW = $876 million (@ $4,000/kW) EPE 22 MW Solar Power Projects (Dona Ana County) 10 MW Chaparral Solar Field 12 MW Las Cruces Airport 2.5 MW Solar Project at Newman Generating Station 21 kW Solar Project in Van Horn Ft. Bliss and EPE 20 MW Solar Facility on Fort Bliss Ft. Bliss and City 140 MW Waste-to-Energy and Solar Thermal Plant 3
  • 4.
    City of ElPaso 1 MW landfill gas recovery on Clint Landfill 2-5 MW rooftop solar (3rd party PPA) 2 MW of rooftop solar at Airport Renewable energy incentive program - $1.25 million (solar rebates) City of Las Cruces 12 MW SunEdison solar project for EPE 400 kW expansion of F&A Dairy (cheese) solar project White Sands Missile R. 4.5 MW Solar PV System at Missile Range Center (Siemens) NASA – White Sands 1-3 MW Solar PV El Paso County 6 MW of ground and rooftop solar (PPA) UTEP 5.5 MW rooftop solar PV project 20 electric vehicle charging station projects El Paso Com. College Install additional solar panels at ATC (Building 2) 4
  • 5.
    Proposed Projects 1. Become a Net Solar Exporter 2. Attract Solar Manufacturer to Region 3. Learn from & Collaborate on Advanced Energy Economy 4. Assist Military and Federal Facilities Achieve “Net Zero” Goals 5. Recognition as Regional Renewable Energy Leader 6. Prepare Study on Clean Energy Business Potential 7. 10,000 DRG Solar Roof Initiative 8. HUB-UTEP Incubator Programs 9. Public Awareness and Feedback 10. El Paso Solar Energy Association Initiative 11. Establish a Renewable Energy Certification Center 12. Ysleta Solar & Clean Energy Demo Project 13. White Sands 40 MW Solar 14. Develop Solar Canopies at Ports of Entry 5
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Project: Help Establisha Solar CREZ Zone Concept: The CREZ zones have been an effective way to get transmission built to access the rich wind resources in Texas. The last of the wind CREZ lines will be completed in 2013. Texas is also rich in solar resources, especially in far West Texas. Under this concept, interested groups would work to test the economic feasibility of developing a CREZ zone for solar resources. Background: The cost of solar power has dropped significantly in the 2nd and 3rd quarters of 2012. Solar panels started 2012 above a dollar a watt, and now average 84 cents a watt and are expected to go to 60 cents a watt. All in cost (installed cost) for large scale solar projects in far West Texas were $2.85 a watt three months ago, and are currently being bid at $2.10 a watt. The rumored prices for the winning solar bids in the CPS Energy 400 MW solicitation were mid $80 per MWh. By comparison, West Texas wind is being priced below $40 MWh, and coastal wind is being priced in the mid-$40’s MWh. Solar has the advantage of being coincident with peak usage. Conclusion: Within 3-5 years, solar will be a competitive resource in the better solar areas of Texas. There will be a demand for improved transmission to access that solar in far West Texas. 11
  • 12.
    Program Overview (fromPUC website) Description of CREZ: The utilities code section 39.904 in conjunction with Senate Bill 20 (2005) established Texas's Renewable Energy Program and directed the PUC to identify Competitive Renewable Energy Zones (CREZ). A CREZ is a geographic area where wind generation facilities will be constructed. In 2008, PUC issued order 33672 designating five CREZs for the generation of wind power and defining the required transmission upgrades to deliver wind generated energy to Texas consumers. Transmission build-out program: The CREZ project is the PUC’s response to a public mandate to increase renewable energy in Texas to serve the electric needs of the state. The Texas Legislature passed Senate Bill (SB) 7 in 1999, which restructured the state’s electric industry and allowed Transmission Service Providers (TSPs) to offer transmission services to other utilities throughout Texas. Ultimately, the CREZ effort will significantly increase Texas’s current level of wind generation capacity to 18,456 MW. 12
  • 13.
  • 14.