The Value of Content
Annenberg G d t F ll
A    b    Graduate Fellowship P
                          hi Program Micro-Seminar
                                     Mi    S  i




                 Dana Chinn
                 August 2011
• Introductions
        How will understanding the value of content help you
        in your studies?

• Why content value is both device-based and device-agnostic

• The blurring of content p
             g            producers, distributors, device manufacturers
                                   ,             ,

• How cloud storage options affect content value

• Valuing audiences based on the intensity of interest
  in a topic and device ownership

• Digital asset management

• Using web analytics to understand content value
Do I know enough about
 you t sell you content?
     to  ll        t t?



What I know for sure




              What I can infer guess
                               g

                   Gender

                   Age

                   ?
Life used to be easy…
Limited ways to get content
led to advertising-dependent business models
         and thus, more free content)
           d th         f       t t)
   Publishers with display advertising



        Newspapers
                         Magazines
          Radio                      TV
            Direct mail             Yellow
                                    Pages
             Outdoor
   Advertisers made decisions based on little
   more than gender, age, education             5
More ways = more content = more discerning
          audiences = more info about audiences
                                                                                                 *




                           Company
                             site
                                             E-mail

                                    Video



                                                                           Buy ads on
                                                                           social
                                                                           media, too!

                                                                                                                               6
*A “starting point” – doesn’t include search, lead generation, international, others. Ted Kawaja in paidContent.org, 9/28/10
People will pay for content
based on their level of interest,
                                ,
             need
Unique content people want and/or need




                                                    Solid
                                                    understanding of
                                                       d   t di       f
                                                    the value of its
                                                    print and digital
                       regular rate:
                                                    p
                                                    products both
                       $7.50/week                   together and
                                                    separately




Holes or brilliant pricing structure?
    Sunday print + All Digital A
    S d         i       Di i l Access: $7 50/
                                       $7.50/week
                                                k
    All Digital Access: $8.75/week


    “Share access with a family member”
                              y
Device-specific pricing requires you to
       decide where you’re going to get the NYT
                                         computer or
                                         mobile web




-- Still doesn’t include e-readers!




-- Those who would pay anything
to get NYT crosswords…do
What is the value of a content app?
Tribune?




    http://www.clickz.com/clickz/column/2098816/tablets-advertising-revolution by
    Gary Stein, 8/12/11
Producers,
         ,                   Device          Cloud
aggregators   Distributors   manufacturers   storage
Do you buy content because of the device
or buy a device because of the content?


Woke up to NPR/Morning Edition via KPCC on a
radio

Listened to music on an iPod in the car

Listened to an alternative music stream on
Pandora on a PC

Watched an episode of The Office on Tivo via
Netflix on a PC and on a TV

Played Scrabble on an iPad and an iPhone

Read some articles in The Economist (don’t
remember where)

Posted on Facebook (don’t remember what was
used)
Every purchase, product and price change
         prompts an evaluation
               t        l ti
Reallocate or increase the
    amount spent on content?
           t     t       t t?

Buy a new iPad?               Get a Nook to get
                                             g
                              content I can’t get
      Continue with Hulu      on a Kindle?
      Plus? Drop Netflix?                Use the Amazon
                                         Cloud service in
   Switch to an Android phone?           addition to Apple’s?


       Discontinue Tivo service?                    Switch from
                                                    Dropbox to Apple
 Buy the sports package on Time                     storage? Google
 Warner Cable to get The Tennis                     storage?
                                                           ?
 Channel?

                     More important than cost?
                     Lifetime, interest, usage, value, past experience
However,
However you still get multiple ads
                               ads…




        …you must get
        ads to help Hulu
        out!
Are these ad options worth anything?
Hulu/HuluPlus vs. Netflix:
     It’s th
     It’ the content
                t t




       Current episodes
But, available for free…

                       Current season
                       episodes (with
                       ads)

                       Additional
                       features

                       Community /
                       social media
                          i l   di
Amazon has the most information about
people’s content needs, wants – and b d t
    l ’     t t     d      t      d budget

                                                                      Amazon sells
                                                                      -- Physical content
                                                                      -- Digital content
                                                                      -- Non-content
                                                                      -- Devices
                                                                      -- Cloud storage

                                                                      Service

                                                                      Convenience




      Some things it doesn’t know about me – yet
      music, movies, health, residence, travel, politics, religion,
      friends/family, other pets
Original core competency: “Books”
                           Books
How much is ad-free content
     worth t you?
         th to     ?
Is content less valuable on a Nook if
      you have other devices?
B&N suggests you
select a Nook
based on your
behaviors,
behaviors
not just content
Amazon




         iTunes
Will you also pay twice as much for iCloud…


Amazon
…so downloads are easier and all of your content is in the same
place?




                  iTunes Match -
                  $24.99/year – will
                  make it easy to
                  store non-iTunes
                  purchases
Apple – iTunes digital music is worth more
   when it’s stored in the same place –
worth convenience of uploading to devices
   th         i      f   l di    t d i
            (if you have them)
Do you need more than one cloud?
Amazon
Why do content producers ask useless questions such as
“Will you pay for newspaper content?”



The values you put on content
         varies widely
      by your devices and
the intensity of your interests,
            desires
…not by gender, age, income, education


  Thus, your value to a content company varies equally widely

                                     Will not pay for NYT crosswords
                                     in print or online
                          Person A
                          P




                                                       Will to pay $7.50 to get
                                                       the NYT Sunday Style
                                            Also
                                            Person A   section in print
Some factors other than topic that affect value

text, video, photo, audio
    ,       ,p     ,
short vs. long
used vs new
latest version vs. one that’s good enough

news
entertainment
work or school materials

required vs optional

commodity vs. unique / value of brand
          vs

trust in payment systems

convenience
      i

timeliness

ongoing vs. impulse

aspirational vs. what you really read/watch
Search engine optimization has led to better digital asset
         management




http://www.clickz.com/clickz/column/2099911/leveraging-
keyword-research-digital-asset-optimization by Ron Jones
8/12/11
Is a site set up…




….with navigation that uses terms
that appeal to your audience and help them find what
they’re looking for?

        ….so you can track traffic by topic throughout
          so
        your site?
                                                    37
OnCentral believes that News & Politics stories are crucial to
serving audiences who live and work in the Central Avenue area.

   How many News & Politics stores are produced each week?

   How much traffic do News & Politics stories get per week?
What is “news” and what is “politics?”
       How many political stories are there? What types of politics?

How much traffic did political stories get the week of March 13?
Is each page coded in a way to get this information?
Web traffic data gives few insights…
…unless each story is coded or classified.

Does OnCentral have enough
local politics stories to build
a Central Avenue audience?

How many stories on local
politics did it have the week
of March 13? What percent of
                    p
OnCentral’s content is about
local politics?

How much traffic did local
politics stories get the week of
March 13?

Does it have enough
multimedia content on local        Note: In Google Analytics use
politics?                          unique page views as a proxy for
                                   visits
Does it have stories from all
areas of OnCentral?
Web analytics:
 Tools to help determine the value of content
             p
                and audiences
Behavioral research

        What people did
        when they came to your site,
        as captured by
        an action taken on a keyboard or mouse



Attitudinal research

         What people  say they did
                what they think
                and
                why
         as captured by
         surveys, focus groups, social media, usability studies
                                                                  43
“So what?” metrics waste time,
lead to analysis paralysis


         Our site has 5,000 monthly unique visitors.

              Last Tuesday that story got 20,000 page views.
         The average time spent on our site last week
         was 24 minutes.
                 Our iPhone app was downloaded 10,000 times.
         We have 2,000 fans on our Facebook page
                 2 000                      page.
                        We have 5,000 Twitter followers.



            Measure only
            what’s meaningful and useful
            to make decisions
                                                           44
Each content product needs
  specific audience goals




             Is the product reaching and
             engaging its highest priority
             targeted audiences?
             t     t d  di      ?


             Does it have the content it needs to
               oes t a e t e co te t t eeds
             reach its targeted audiences?




                                              45
actions
What verbs indicate engagement?


       Visit
       Vi it , regularly
                   l l



               Read/view content, a l
               R d/ i               lot


Interact,
Interact often
  -- rate, print, vote, take a poll, click on an ad
  -- share, e-mail, comment, contribute




                                                      46
Audiences, actions, metrics differ by channel


                                            SITES           SOCIAL MEDIA
                                                                                *
                                                                           Totals

1. Who? How many?
   In target audience?               ?      ?       ?   ?   ?   ?    ?

2. No. f i i ?
2 N of visits?
   How often?                        ?      ?       ?   ?   ?   ?    ?

3. What did they see?                ?      ?       ?   ?   ?   ?    ?
   Did they get want
   they wanted?

4. Did they interact?
          y                          ?      ?       ?   ?   ?   ?    ?
   What did they do?
   How much?
                                                                           47
 * Different metrics, methodologies for each channel!
Producers,
         ,                   Device          Cloud
aggregators   Distributors   manufacturers   storage

The Value of Content

  • 1.
    The Value ofContent Annenberg G d t F ll A b Graduate Fellowship P hi Program Micro-Seminar Mi S i Dana Chinn August 2011
  • 2.
    • Introductions How will understanding the value of content help you in your studies? • Why content value is both device-based and device-agnostic • The blurring of content p g producers, distributors, device manufacturers , , • How cloud storage options affect content value • Valuing audiences based on the intensity of interest in a topic and device ownership • Digital asset management • Using web analytics to understand content value
  • 3.
    Do I knowenough about you t sell you content? to ll t t? What I know for sure What I can infer guess g Gender Age ?
  • 4.
    Life used tobe easy…
  • 5.
    Limited ways toget content led to advertising-dependent business models and thus, more free content) d th f t t) Publishers with display advertising Newspapers Magazines Radio TV Direct mail Yellow Pages Outdoor Advertisers made decisions based on little more than gender, age, education 5
  • 6.
    More ways =more content = more discerning audiences = more info about audiences * Company site E-mail Video Buy ads on social media, too! 6 *A “starting point” – doesn’t include search, lead generation, international, others. Ted Kawaja in paidContent.org, 9/28/10
  • 7.
    People will payfor content based on their level of interest, , need
  • 8.
    Unique content peoplewant and/or need Solid understanding of d t di f the value of its print and digital regular rate: p products both $7.50/week together and separately Holes or brilliant pricing structure? Sunday print + All Digital A S d i Di i l Access: $7 50/ $7.50/week k All Digital Access: $8.75/week “Share access with a family member” y
  • 9.
    Device-specific pricing requiresyou to decide where you’re going to get the NYT computer or mobile web -- Still doesn’t include e-readers! -- Those who would pay anything to get NYT crosswords…do
  • 10.
    What is thevalue of a content app?
  • 11.
    Tribune? http://www.clickz.com/clickz/column/2098816/tablets-advertising-revolution by Gary Stein, 8/12/11
  • 12.
    Producers, , Device Cloud aggregators Distributors manufacturers storage
  • 13.
    Do you buycontent because of the device or buy a device because of the content? Woke up to NPR/Morning Edition via KPCC on a radio Listened to music on an iPod in the car Listened to an alternative music stream on Pandora on a PC Watched an episode of The Office on Tivo via Netflix on a PC and on a TV Played Scrabble on an iPad and an iPhone Read some articles in The Economist (don’t remember where) Posted on Facebook (don’t remember what was used)
  • 14.
    Every purchase, productand price change prompts an evaluation t l ti
  • 15.
    Reallocate or increasethe amount spent on content? t t t t? Buy a new iPad? Get a Nook to get g content I can’t get Continue with Hulu on a Kindle? Plus? Drop Netflix? Use the Amazon Cloud service in Switch to an Android phone? addition to Apple’s? Discontinue Tivo service? Switch from Dropbox to Apple Buy the sports package on Time storage? Google Warner Cable to get The Tennis storage? ? Channel? More important than cost? Lifetime, interest, usage, value, past experience
  • 17.
    However, However you stillget multiple ads ads… …you must get ads to help Hulu out!
  • 18.
    Are these adoptions worth anything?
  • 19.
    Hulu/HuluPlus vs. Netflix: It’s th It’ the content t t Current episodes
  • 20.
    But, available forfree… Current season episodes (with ads) Additional features Community / social media i l di
  • 21.
    Amazon has themost information about people’s content needs, wants – and b d t l ’ t t d t d budget Amazon sells -- Physical content -- Digital content -- Non-content -- Devices -- Cloud storage Service Convenience Some things it doesn’t know about me – yet music, movies, health, residence, travel, politics, religion, friends/family, other pets
  • 22.
    Original core competency:“Books” Books
  • 23.
    How much isad-free content worth t you? th to ?
  • 24.
    Is content lessvaluable on a Nook if you have other devices?
  • 25.
    B&N suggests you selecta Nook based on your behaviors, behaviors not just content
  • 26.
    Amazon iTunes
  • 28.
    Will you alsopay twice as much for iCloud… Amazon
  • 29.
    …so downloads areeasier and all of your content is in the same place? iTunes Match - $24.99/year – will make it easy to store non-iTunes purchases
  • 30.
    Apple – iTunesdigital music is worth more when it’s stored in the same place – worth convenience of uploading to devices th i f l di t d i (if you have them)
  • 31.
    Do you needmore than one cloud? Amazon
  • 32.
    Why do contentproducers ask useless questions such as “Will you pay for newspaper content?” The values you put on content varies widely by your devices and the intensity of your interests, desires …not by gender, age, income, education Thus, your value to a content company varies equally widely Will not pay for NYT crosswords in print or online Person A P Will to pay $7.50 to get the NYT Sunday Style Also Person A section in print
  • 35.
    Some factors otherthan topic that affect value text, video, photo, audio , ,p , short vs. long used vs new latest version vs. one that’s good enough news entertainment work or school materials required vs optional commodity vs. unique / value of brand vs trust in payment systems convenience i timeliness ongoing vs. impulse aspirational vs. what you really read/watch
  • 36.
    Search engine optimizationhas led to better digital asset management http://www.clickz.com/clickz/column/2099911/leveraging- keyword-research-digital-asset-optimization by Ron Jones 8/12/11
  • 37.
    Is a siteset up… ….with navigation that uses terms that appeal to your audience and help them find what they’re looking for? ….so you can track traffic by topic throughout so your site? 37
  • 38.
    OnCentral believes thatNews & Politics stories are crucial to serving audiences who live and work in the Central Avenue area. How many News & Politics stores are produced each week? How much traffic do News & Politics stories get per week?
  • 39.
    What is “news”and what is “politics?” How many political stories are there? What types of politics? How much traffic did political stories get the week of March 13?
  • 40.
    Is each pagecoded in a way to get this information?
  • 41.
    Web traffic datagives few insights…
  • 42.
    …unless each storyis coded or classified. Does OnCentral have enough local politics stories to build a Central Avenue audience? How many stories on local politics did it have the week of March 13? What percent of p OnCentral’s content is about local politics? How much traffic did local politics stories get the week of March 13? Does it have enough multimedia content on local Note: In Google Analytics use politics? unique page views as a proxy for visits Does it have stories from all areas of OnCentral?
  • 43.
    Web analytics: Toolsto help determine the value of content p and audiences Behavioral research What people did when they came to your site, as captured by an action taken on a keyboard or mouse Attitudinal research What people say they did what they think and why as captured by surveys, focus groups, social media, usability studies 43
  • 44.
    “So what?” metricswaste time, lead to analysis paralysis Our site has 5,000 monthly unique visitors. Last Tuesday that story got 20,000 page views. The average time spent on our site last week was 24 minutes. Our iPhone app was downloaded 10,000 times. We have 2,000 fans on our Facebook page 2 000 page. We have 5,000 Twitter followers. Measure only what’s meaningful and useful to make decisions 44
  • 45.
    Each content productneeds specific audience goals Is the product reaching and engaging its highest priority targeted audiences? t t d di ? Does it have the content it needs to oes t a e t e co te t t eeds reach its targeted audiences? 45
  • 46.
    actions What verbs indicateengagement? Visit Vi it , regularly l l Read/view content, a l R d/ i lot Interact, Interact often -- rate, print, vote, take a poll, click on an ad -- share, e-mail, comment, contribute 46
  • 47.
    Audiences, actions, metricsdiffer by channel SITES SOCIAL MEDIA * Totals 1. Who? How many? In target audience? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? 2. No. f i i ? 2 N of visits? How often? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? 3. What did they see? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? Did they get want they wanted? 4. Did they interact? y ? ? ? ? ? ? ? What did they do? How much? 47 * Different metrics, methodologies for each channel!
  • 48.
    Producers, , Device Cloud aggregators Distributors manufacturers storage