The document summarizes a discussion between students about a story involving a fisherman, his wife, and a fish that is actually a prince under a curse. The students did not feel sorry for the greedy wife who kept asking her husband to make additional wishes to the fish, despite the fish warning of consequences. They proposed a happier ending where the wife realizes her greed and thanks the fish. The students said the key lessons are to not be greedy and to be grateful for what one has.

1. GROUP 6
Rina Yuliati (22)
Salma Maulida (23)
Umi Nur H. (29)
XI MIPA 1

2. 1. Did the fisherman like asking the fish for wishes?
How did he feel about it?
Do you think he could have done something
else instead
of going back to the fish again and again?
No. He didn’t. His feel heavy heart.
Yes, we think he could have done something
else instead of going back the fish again and
again.

3. 2. The story doesn’t
reveal how the prince
was turned into a fish.
What do you think might
have happened?
It is maybe the prince
is came from the sky.

4. 3. Do you think the prince
will stay a fish forever?
No, we think the prince
doesn’t will stay a fish
forever.

5. 4. What happened at the end of the story? Please describe?
The fisherman and his wife back to their
old life because his wife very greedy.

6. 5. Why did the fisherman’s wife keep asking
her husband to go back to the fish?
Because she was greedy

7. 6. What do you think of fisherman’s wife? Do you feel sorry
for her? Or do you feel angry with her?
We feel angry with her because she
was very greedy.

8. 7. If you had a chance to rewrite the
story, how would the story end?
Write your ending of the story.
Happy ending. The fisherman wife
to become conscious that her
greedy and finally she giving sorry
and greeting thanks for the fish.

9. Today was daylight, there was something that goes into water. I approached,
it turns out it is a hook. I tried to touch it with my mouth. Because, I’ve been cursed
into a fish, although originally I’am a prince. I panicked when it lifted the hook. It turns
out that a fisherman who caught me. I beg to escape, and eventually he let me go.
The next day, the fisherman was calling my name I appeared. Apparently he
asked for a request was a request of his wife. His wife asked for nice home, then I grant
it. Next day again, the fisherman coming back. His wife wanted to be emperor, I grant
it.
Next day again, the fisherman come again. I began to get nervous. Greedy
fisherman’s wife once. And now the fisherman’s wife asked to be the Queen of the
moon and the sun. I told the fisherman home. As a result of the greed of his wife, a
strom came and eventually the lives of fisherman and the greedy wife turns poor
again.
8. Imagine you are the fish in the story. Can you
narrate the story from his point image of view?

10. We learn from
• We don’t be greedy
The story that
• Give thanks to want God haven
given to your life
9. What lesson did you learn from this story?

11. Thank’s
for your
Attention
