This document summarizes a study on the development of digital literacy among Chinese international postgraduate students adapting to the UK learning environment. It outlines the research background, methodology, and conceptual framework. Key findings from interviews suggest students' digital literacy practices transitioned as they relied more on institutional resources like Blackboard and email for communication. Practices were shaped by individual and contextual factors like discipline, technology access, and expectations of study.
Developing Metaliterate Learners: Transforming Literacy across DisciplinesTom Mackey
This was the opening keynote presentation by Tom Mackey and Trudi Jacobson for the SUNY "Conversations in the Disciplines" one-day conference focused on metaliteracy.
This presentation examines the metaliteracy framework developed by Tom Mackey and Trudi Jacobson. Metaliteracy will be examined as a reframing of information literacy. This presentation also reports on the successful Innovative Instruction Technology Grant (IITG) at SUNY that led to new metaliteracy learning objectives.
Promoting Metaliteracy and Metacognition in Collaborative Teaching and LearningTom Mackey
Trudi Jacobson and Tom Mackey present on metaliteracy as part of a panel at the NOLA Information Literacy Collective on Friday, August 11, 2017. This virtual presentation defines metaliteracy, discusses the ACRL Framework for Information Literacy for Higher Education, and examines the metaliteracy learning goals and objectives. Specific metaliteracy related projects such as the competency based digital badging system and Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) are examined as well.
Metaliteracy as an Empowering Model for Teaching Mobile and Social LearnersTom Mackey
Tom Mackey and Trudi Jacobson presented a collaborative keynote on metaliteracy at The University of Puerto Rico’s Mobile Learning Week event on Monday, March 20 at 10am eastern time. In a presentation entitled “Metaliteracy as an Empowering Model for Teaching Mobile and Social Learners,” Tom and Trudi will explored the theory of metaliteracy while illustrating practical applications that can be applied in a variety of teaching and learning situations. In today’s mobile media environments our learners are continuously engaged with information in a variety of forms using a range of technologies. Learners from around the world are texting, posting, and sharing documents they find online through a multitude of social media spaces and mobile devices. But how much of this information can be trusted?
Crossing the Threshold: Envisioning Information Literacy through the Lens of ...Tom Mackey
Twitter is abuzz with comments about metaliteracy, threshold concepts, and frameworks. Information literacy is being reframed, reinvented, and reimagined in articles, books, conference presentations, and lively discussions in the field. What happened to the more traditional elements of information literacy and the iconic ACRL Information Literacy Competency Standards for Higher Education? Why are these alternative models appearing now, and what do they bring to the conversation? This collaborative keynote will provide an opportunity to learn more about these new models, and to reflect on how they might inform your teaching and your students’ learning. We will explore these developments by highlighting key aspects of our new book Metaliteracy: Reinventing Information Literacy to Empower Learners. Trudi Jacobson will also relate these questions to her work as Co-Chair of the ACRL Task Force that is shifting the original standards to a framework informed by a scaffolding of threshold concepts.
Empowering Yourself in a Connected World: Designing an Open SUNY Coursera MOO...Tom Mackey
A collaborative team within SUNY that includes both Empire State College and The University at Albany designed a learner-centered Open SUNY Coursera MOOC based on the concept of metaliteracy. We reached a global audience through the Coursera platform that influenced our design decisions and expanded our understanding of digital literacies internationally.
Developing Metaliterate Learners: Transforming Literacy across DisciplinesTom Mackey
This was the opening keynote presentation by Tom Mackey and Trudi Jacobson for the SUNY "Conversations in the Disciplines" one-day conference focused on metaliteracy.
This presentation examines the metaliteracy framework developed by Tom Mackey and Trudi Jacobson. Metaliteracy will be examined as a reframing of information literacy. This presentation also reports on the successful Innovative Instruction Technology Grant (IITG) at SUNY that led to new metaliteracy learning objectives.
Promoting Metaliteracy and Metacognition in Collaborative Teaching and LearningTom Mackey
Trudi Jacobson and Tom Mackey present on metaliteracy as part of a panel at the NOLA Information Literacy Collective on Friday, August 11, 2017. This virtual presentation defines metaliteracy, discusses the ACRL Framework for Information Literacy for Higher Education, and examines the metaliteracy learning goals and objectives. Specific metaliteracy related projects such as the competency based digital badging system and Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) are examined as well.
Metaliteracy as an Empowering Model for Teaching Mobile and Social LearnersTom Mackey
Tom Mackey and Trudi Jacobson presented a collaborative keynote on metaliteracy at The University of Puerto Rico’s Mobile Learning Week event on Monday, March 20 at 10am eastern time. In a presentation entitled “Metaliteracy as an Empowering Model for Teaching Mobile and Social Learners,” Tom and Trudi will explored the theory of metaliteracy while illustrating practical applications that can be applied in a variety of teaching and learning situations. In today’s mobile media environments our learners are continuously engaged with information in a variety of forms using a range of technologies. Learners from around the world are texting, posting, and sharing documents they find online through a multitude of social media spaces and mobile devices. But how much of this information can be trusted?
Crossing the Threshold: Envisioning Information Literacy through the Lens of ...Tom Mackey
Twitter is abuzz with comments about metaliteracy, threshold concepts, and frameworks. Information literacy is being reframed, reinvented, and reimagined in articles, books, conference presentations, and lively discussions in the field. What happened to the more traditional elements of information literacy and the iconic ACRL Information Literacy Competency Standards for Higher Education? Why are these alternative models appearing now, and what do they bring to the conversation? This collaborative keynote will provide an opportunity to learn more about these new models, and to reflect on how they might inform your teaching and your students’ learning. We will explore these developments by highlighting key aspects of our new book Metaliteracy: Reinventing Information Literacy to Empower Learners. Trudi Jacobson will also relate these questions to her work as Co-Chair of the ACRL Task Force that is shifting the original standards to a framework informed by a scaffolding of threshold concepts.
Empowering Yourself in a Connected World: Designing an Open SUNY Coursera MOO...Tom Mackey
A collaborative team within SUNY that includes both Empire State College and The University at Albany designed a learner-centered Open SUNY Coursera MOOC based on the concept of metaliteracy. We reached a global audience through the Coursera platform that influenced our design decisions and expanded our understanding of digital literacies internationally.
Challenges in Defining, Designing, and Measuring “Digital Literacy” Developm...Rebecca Reynolds
This presentation discusses scholarly definitions for the research construct “digital literacy,” identifies limitations in conceptualizations to-date, fand presents a proposed framework of Six Contemporary Learning Abilities (or 6-CLAs: Create, Manage, Publish, Socialize, Research, Surf). This explicated framework offers a more structured definition based on student-centered social constructivist learning theory. The article then presents an empirical investigation of digital literacy development, drawing on the framework, and its proposed approach for operationalizing technology activities (whether as research constructs or instructional activities). The empirical analysis is situated in the context of an innovative educational program implementation of game design based learning for middle and high school students offered in a U.S. state, in the 2011/2012 school year. The study explores how student engagement in activities representing the 6-CLA dimensions factor, inter-correlate, change from pre- to post-program, and bring about student transfer of that engagement, from school to home environments. Findings reveal that the dimensions proposed hang together well, students change in their engagement as a result of the intervention across multiple dimensions in both school and home contexts, and at-school engagement in the dimensions contributes to at-home engagement in them (in various ways as reported). The study offers support for the proposed framework, provides some evidence of digital divide effects for the intervention, presents questions for further inquiry, and offers a conceptual and research design stake in the ground for other researchers interested in the digital literacy construct.
Stewart, benjamin english language educators and technology ije v5 n1 20...William Kritsonis
Published by NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - A group of national refereed, peer-reviewed, scholarly, academic periodicals. William Allan Kritsonis, PhD, Editor-in-Chief, NFJ (Since 1982)
This is an expanded version of my Engaging Digital Natives Presentation. It is designed to accompany a full-day hand-on lab session and workshop. http://jdorman.wikispaces.com/digitalnatives
A group of early adopter-teachers in the state of NH engage in a blended model of professional development. Research conducted, authored and presented by Vanessa Vartabedian at AERA Conference, 2012.
Thanks in part to efficient search engines such as Google, on-line reading has become for many the primary way that people read. This talk will discuss how a wide range of research in web usability, psychology, education, and communication theory provides corroborating evidence that on-line reading is transforming cognition, learning, and the very nature of knowledge in some disturbing ways.
Studying young people’s online social practices - Combining virtual ethnography, participant observation, online conversations and questionnaire data.
Guest lecture by Malene Charlotte Larsen, Assistant Professor at Aalborg University, at the PhD course: Mixed Methods Research: Theory and Practice, AAU, Jan 31 2013
UGS 302 Syllabus: The role of technology among youth in society and education...Joan E. Hughes, Ph.D.
Fall 2013. A semester-long, writing-intensive course that leads first-year students in considering inventions and innovations (technological and historical) that have changed society and education. We weave from exploring current trends to historical shifts to again current digital innovations with critique from a range of perspectives (educational, political, advertising/marketing, technical, psychological). This course includes university-level requirements including: visiting remarkable places at UT (Harry Ransom Center, TACC VisLab), attending university lectures, engaging in research, writing and oral presenting, and being taught by a Ph.D. tenured faculty member.
Challenges in Defining, Designing, and Measuring “Digital Literacy” Developm...Rebecca Reynolds
This presentation discusses scholarly definitions for the research construct “digital literacy,” identifies limitations in conceptualizations to-date, fand presents a proposed framework of Six Contemporary Learning Abilities (or 6-CLAs: Create, Manage, Publish, Socialize, Research, Surf). This explicated framework offers a more structured definition based on student-centered social constructivist learning theory. The article then presents an empirical investigation of digital literacy development, drawing on the framework, and its proposed approach for operationalizing technology activities (whether as research constructs or instructional activities). The empirical analysis is situated in the context of an innovative educational program implementation of game design based learning for middle and high school students offered in a U.S. state, in the 2011/2012 school year. The study explores how student engagement in activities representing the 6-CLA dimensions factor, inter-correlate, change from pre- to post-program, and bring about student transfer of that engagement, from school to home environments. Findings reveal that the dimensions proposed hang together well, students change in their engagement as a result of the intervention across multiple dimensions in both school and home contexts, and at-school engagement in the dimensions contributes to at-home engagement in them (in various ways as reported). The study offers support for the proposed framework, provides some evidence of digital divide effects for the intervention, presents questions for further inquiry, and offers a conceptual and research design stake in the ground for other researchers interested in the digital literacy construct.
Stewart, benjamin english language educators and technology ije v5 n1 20...William Kritsonis
Published by NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - A group of national refereed, peer-reviewed, scholarly, academic periodicals. William Allan Kritsonis, PhD, Editor-in-Chief, NFJ (Since 1982)
This is an expanded version of my Engaging Digital Natives Presentation. It is designed to accompany a full-day hand-on lab session and workshop. http://jdorman.wikispaces.com/digitalnatives
A group of early adopter-teachers in the state of NH engage in a blended model of professional development. Research conducted, authored and presented by Vanessa Vartabedian at AERA Conference, 2012.
Thanks in part to efficient search engines such as Google, on-line reading has become for many the primary way that people read. This talk will discuss how a wide range of research in web usability, psychology, education, and communication theory provides corroborating evidence that on-line reading is transforming cognition, learning, and the very nature of knowledge in some disturbing ways.
Studying young people’s online social practices - Combining virtual ethnography, participant observation, online conversations and questionnaire data.
Guest lecture by Malene Charlotte Larsen, Assistant Professor at Aalborg University, at the PhD course: Mixed Methods Research: Theory and Practice, AAU, Jan 31 2013
UGS 302 Syllabus: The role of technology among youth in society and education...Joan E. Hughes, Ph.D.
Fall 2013. A semester-long, writing-intensive course that leads first-year students in considering inventions and innovations (technological and historical) that have changed society and education. We weave from exploring current trends to historical shifts to again current digital innovations with critique from a range of perspectives (educational, political, advertising/marketing, technical, psychological). This course includes university-level requirements including: visiting remarkable places at UT (Harry Ransom Center, TACC VisLab), attending university lectures, engaging in research, writing and oral presenting, and being taught by a Ph.D. tenured faculty member.
Pedagogy and School Libraries: Developing agile approaches in a digital ageJudy O'Connell
Libraries for future learners: one day conference to inspire, connect and inform teacher librarians and school leaders thinking about future learning needs. This presentation was a keynote conversation starter to open up a wide range of topics for other presentations and workshop activities sharing examplars, tools and strategies related to future learning. Held at Rydges World Square, Sydney.
Invited opening talk for University of Brighton Pedagogic Research Conference, February 2017
https://staff.brighton.ac.uk/clt/Pages/Events/enhancing%20higher%20education.aspx
Operation “Blue Star” is the only event in the history of Independent India where the state went into war with its own people. Even after about 40 years it is not clear if it was culmination of states anger over people of the region, a political game of power or start of dictatorial chapter in the democratic setup.
The people of Punjab felt alienated from main stream due to denial of their just demands during a long democratic struggle since independence. As it happen all over the word, it led to militant struggle with great loss of lives of military, police and civilian personnel. Killing of Indira Gandhi and massacre of innocent Sikhs in Delhi and other India cities was also associated with this movement.
The French Revolution, which began in 1789, was a period of radical social and political upheaval in France. It marked the decline of absolute monarchies, the rise of secular and democratic republics, and the eventual rise of Napoleon Bonaparte. This revolutionary period is crucial in understanding the transition from feudalism to modernity in Europe.
For more information, visit-www.vavaclasses.com
Ethnobotany and Ethnopharmacology:
Ethnobotany in herbal drug evaluation,
Impact of Ethnobotany in traditional medicine,
New development in herbals,
Bio-prospecting tools for drug discovery,
Role of Ethnopharmacology in drug evaluation,
Reverse Pharmacology.
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdfTechSoup
In this webinar you will learn how your organization can access TechSoup's wide variety of product discount and donation programs. From hardware to software, we'll give you a tour of the tools available to help your nonprofit with productivity, collaboration, financial management, donor tracking, security, and more.
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS ModuleCeline George
Bills have a main role in point of sale procedure. It will help to track sales, handling payments and giving receipts to customers. Bill splitting also has an important role in POS. For example, If some friends come together for dinner and if they want to divide the bill then it is possible by POS bill splitting. This slide will show how to split bills in odoo 17 POS.
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptxPavel ( NSTU)
Synthetic fiber production is a fascinating and complex field that blends chemistry, engineering, and environmental science. By understanding these aspects, students can gain a comprehensive view of synthetic fiber production, its impact on society and the environment, and the potential for future innovations. Synthetic fibers play a crucial role in modern society, impacting various aspects of daily life, industry, and the environment. ynthetic fibers are integral to modern life, offering a range of benefits from cost-effectiveness and versatility to innovative applications and performance characteristics. While they pose environmental challenges, ongoing research and development aim to create more sustainable and eco-friendly alternatives. Understanding the importance of synthetic fibers helps in appreciating their role in the economy, industry, and daily life, while also emphasizing the need for sustainable practices and innovation.
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdfkaushalkr1407
The Roman Empire, a vast and enduring power, stands as one of history's most remarkable civilizations, leaving an indelible imprint on the world. It emerged from the Roman Republic, transitioning into an imperial powerhouse under the leadership of Augustus Caesar in 27 BCE. This transformation marked the beginning of an era defined by unprecedented territorial expansion, architectural marvels, and profound cultural influence.
The empire's roots lie in the city of Rome, founded, according to legend, by Romulus in 753 BCE. Over centuries, Rome evolved from a small settlement to a formidable republic, characterized by a complex political system with elected officials and checks on power. However, internal strife, class conflicts, and military ambitions paved the way for the end of the Republic. Julius Caesar’s dictatorship and subsequent assassination in 44 BCE created a power vacuum, leading to a civil war. Octavian, later Augustus, emerged victorious, heralding the Roman Empire’s birth.
Under Augustus, the empire experienced the Pax Romana, a 200-year period of relative peace and stability. Augustus reformed the military, established efficient administrative systems, and initiated grand construction projects. The empire's borders expanded, encompassing territories from Britain to Egypt and from Spain to the Euphrates. Roman legions, renowned for their discipline and engineering prowess, secured and maintained these vast territories, building roads, fortifications, and cities that facilitated control and integration.
The Roman Empire’s society was hierarchical, with a rigid class system. At the top were the patricians, wealthy elites who held significant political power. Below them were the plebeians, free citizens with limited political influence, and the vast numbers of slaves who formed the backbone of the economy. The family unit was central, governed by the paterfamilias, the male head who held absolute authority.
Culturally, the Romans were eclectic, absorbing and adapting elements from the civilizations they encountered, particularly the Greeks. Roman art, literature, and philosophy reflected this synthesis, creating a rich cultural tapestry. Latin, the Roman language, became the lingua franca of the Western world, influencing numerous modern languages.
Roman architecture and engineering achievements were monumental. They perfected the arch, vault, and dome, constructing enduring structures like the Colosseum, Pantheon, and aqueducts. These engineering marvels not only showcased Roman ingenuity but also served practical purposes, from public entertainment to water supply.
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17Celine George
It is possible to hide or invisible some fields in odoo. Commonly using “invisible” attribute in the field definition to invisible the fields. This slide will show how to make a field invisible in odoo 17.
How to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERPCeline George
The map views are useful for providing a geographical representation of data. They allow users to visualize and analyze the data in a more intuitive manner.
The development of digital literacy in adapting to the UK learning environment
1. The Development of Digital Literacy in Adapting to the UK Learning Environment-A
Learner Experience Study on Chinese International Postgraduate Students
Mengjie JIANG (mjj16@le.ac.uk)
School of Education TEL sig
University of Leicester, 23 June 2017
Image courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
3. Ubiquitous learning and substantial efforts invested in developing
and promoting digital literacy.
• European Projects
• JISC funded research
Image courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
Research Background
4. What is digital literacy?
‘As the chapters that follow attest, the
most immediately obvious facts about
accounts of digital literacy are that they
are many of them and that there are
significantly different kinds of concepts
on offer.’
(Lankshear & Knobel, 2008, p. 2)
Research Background
5. DL as
engagement in
digital cultures
and social
practices
DL as the
acquisition of
‘information age’
skills
Conceptualisation on digital literacy
DL as the
cultivation of
‘habits of mind’
Meyers, Erickson and Small (2013)
6. DL as the acquisition of ‘information age’ skills
SCOUNL (2011)
7. DL as the
acquisition of
‘information age’
skills
DL as the
cultivation of
‘habits of mind’
DL as
engagement in
social practices
Meyers, Erickson and Small (2013)
Conceptualisation on digital literacy
‘Information literacy is a way of thinking rather than a set of
skills…It is a matrix of critical and reflective capacities, as well
as disciplined creative thought, that impels the students to range
widely through the information environment…when sustained
through a supportive learning environment at course, program,
or institutional level, information literacy can become a
dispositional habit… ‘a habit of mind’ that seeks ongoing
improvement and self-discipline in inquiry, research and
integration of knowledge from varied sources (the Centre for
Intellectual Property in the Digital Environment, 2005, viii-ix).’
8. ‘Representation.’ Digital media provides specific interpretations of the world, and selectively represents reality in such a manner as to
express implicit values and ideologies. This requires Internet users to be able to evaluate the material they come across, for instance, by
questioning the authority and reliability of the texts – assessing the motivations of the authors and validating the information with
multiple sources (Buckingham, 2007).
‘Language.’ As an integral part of the Internet, language functions in certain ways to compensate for the communication modality and
the impact of interactivity. This requires one to develop analytical as well as meta skills so as to understand how language works in the
online environment, and to understand “conventions of particular genres” as well as “how digital media are constructed” with the use of
particular rhetorics. For example, using the Internet may involve understanding “how sites are designed and structured, and the rhetorical
functions of links between sites” (Burbules & Callister, 2000, p. 85-90, cited in Buckingham, 2007).
‘Production.’ Digital content is neither politically nor socially neutral and too little attention is paid to the commercial environment in
which media content is created, marketed and circulated (Dowdall,2009). Therefore, literacy practices demand readers to develop their
awareness towards the growing commercial influences that often seem ‘invisible’ to them. Specifically, young people need to be able to
tell how information is presented by commercial organisations. In a broader aspect, these need to be aware of “the global role of
advertising, promotion and sponsorship, and how they influence the nature of the information” presented (Buckingham, 2007). These
meta-skills can also be extended to the assessment of content by non-commercial interest groups.
‘Audience’. This includes building understanding of the ‘nature of online participation’, ranging from Web polls to bulletin boards to
user-generated content. It also involves “how media are targeted at audiences, and how different audiences use and respond to them”
(Buckingham, 2007). It also means being able to recognise various ways in which the media is used in everyday life by different groups.
DL as the cultivation of ‘habits of mind’
9. DL as the
acquisition of
‘information age’
skills
DL as the
cultivation of
‘habits of mind’
DL as
engagement in
social practices
Meyers, Erickson and Small (2013)
Conceptualisation on digital literacy
‘A way of reading a certain type of text is acquired only
when it is acquired in a ‘fluent’ way, by one’s being
embedded in (apprenticed as a member of) a social
practice wherein people not only read texts of this type
in these ways but also talk about such texts in certain
ways, hold certain beliefs and values about them, and
socially interact over them in certain ways…. (Gee, Hull
& Lankshear, 1996, p. 3)
10. Image courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
Internationalisation within higher education and mobility of students.
• Mobilities perspective for the conceptualization and research on digital literacies-
JISC funded project ‘Digital Literacies as a Postgraduate Attribute’.
• China is the top non EU sending country (UKCISA, 2016).
Research gap
12. Adaptation both in physical and in digital learning context
Image courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net
13. Elements of digital literacy Drawn on the literature
Individual literacy landscape UK Society of College, National and University Libraries (SCONUL, 2011)
Critical thinking Calvani et al (2009); ACRL (2000); SCONUL (2011); Martin and Grudziecki (2007); Jenkins et al (2006); Hauge and Payton (2010)
Intercultural understanding ‘Negotiation’- Jenkins et al (2006, p. 8)
Social participation Jenkins et al (2006)
Identities ‘Performance’- Jenkins et al (2006, p.8); Weller (2011, p. 99)
Problem solving ‘Play’- Jenkins et al (2006, p.8); ‘Intellectual capabilities’- the US National Research Council (NRC, 1999)
Ethical Calvani et al (2009); ACRL (2000); SCONUL (2011)
E-safety Hauge and Payton (2010)
Technological skills NRC (1999); Martin and Grudziecki (2007)
Distributed technologies ‘Distribution intelligence’- Jenkins et al (2006)
Functional concepts NRC (1999); Martin and Grudziecki (2007)
Creative appropriation Hauge and Payton (2010); Martin and Grudziecki (2007)
14. Conceptual framework
Individual digital
literacy landscape
Problem
solving
Ethical
Identities
E-safety
Technological
skills
Social
participation
Intercultural
understanding
Critical
evaluation of
information
Functional
concept
Distributed
technology
Creative
appropriation
Figure 3: The proposed conceptual framework for this study
15. Working definition of digital literacy
In the context of this study, digital literacy is conceptualised as
behaviours, habits and attitudes acquired, developed and presented by
learners over a period of higher education studying experience, in
relation to digital media. This constitutes diverse knowledge and skills
developed by interacting with different social and cultural practices.
Also, it is understood as underpinning practices that construct students’
learning development, as a method by which a student approaches
learning (Hampton-Reeve et al., 2009; Chaka, 2009; Pope & Walton,
2009).
16. The research explores the adaptation of Chinese international
postgraduate students during the transition from undergraduate in China
to postgraduate study in the UK, with particular reference to their digital
literacy practices and development of their digital literacies, with following
main research questions:
• What are digital literacy practices among Chinese international students during the transition
from undergraduate study to master’s studies?
• How have Chinese international postgraduate students’ digital literacy skills developed
during master’s study?
• How can Chinese international students be supported in enhancing their digital literacy
practices to adapt their learning in a UK university?
Research questions
17. Pragmatism
Research strategy (Mixed methods)
Research design (Convergent parallel design)
Quantitative data collection and analysis
Qualitative data collection and analysis
Relate
Sampling: Convenience;
Snowball; Typical
Data collection: Survey;
Interview; Observation with
artefacts
Data analysis: Statistics; Descriptive
analysis, Thematic analysis
Interpretation
Research method
19. Data Collection (Quantitative data)
• Questionnaire was designed using Word Processing
• Online questionnaire administered from 11th July 2014
• Printed copies were sent out several times
• Questionnaire was translated into Chinese version
• Online survey closed on 31st January 2016
• Piloting and revising
20. • 14 mind maps about participants’ uses of digital technologies that
construct their own digital learning environments
• 14 day line maps about participants’ uses of digital technologies within
a typical day
• Photographic journaling and observation with 4 participants
• 30 semi-structured interviews
Data Collection (Qualitative data)
26. Digital device Number and percentage of
respondents who owned it for
undergraduate study
Number and percentage of
respondents who owned it
for postgraduate study
Desktop 221 (54%) 137 (33.5%)
Laptop 339 (82%) 350 (85.6%)
Digital camera 251 (61.4%) 131 (32%)
Phone with Internet 362 (88.5%) 358 (87.5%)
MP3 player/iPod 220 (53.8%) 135 (33.0%)
iPad/Tablet 313 (76.5%) 323 (79.0%)
Amazon Kindle/other
e-reader
79 (19.3%) 166 (40.6%)
Gaming device 75 (18.3%) 73 (17.8%)
Ownership of digital devices (n=409, questionnaire item 1)
29. Digital literacy practices during the transition from undergraduate study to master’s study.
Digital technologies mentioned by students fall into but not limited to the following:
• Search engines and databases (Baidu, Google, CNKI, University database; discipline databses)
• Institutional VLEs (Moodle and Blackboard)
• Email (communal email; university email; personal email)
• Microsoft office packages (Word; Excel; PowerPoint)
• Social Networking tools (WeChat; Facebook; Sina Weibo; Twitter; Linkedin; WhatsApp; Instagram)
• Bibliographic tools (RefWorks)
• Online encyclopaedia (Baidu Baike; Wikipedia; Zhihu; MBA lib)
• Web editing (Dreamweaver)
• Image editing (Photoshop; Procreate)
• Statistics software (SPSS; NVivo)
• Online lectures (YouTube)
• Podcasting (BBC news)
• Mooc (Coursera; Harvard open learning initative; NetEase)
• Online forums (Pute)
• Mobile apps
30. The nature of using digital technologies among research participants (n=30)
The rationale of using digital technologies comes down to six broad categories:
• Information searching and management;
• Communication and collaboration;
• Participation;
• Entertaining and online shopping;
• Specific education/professional development and accomplishment of assignment;
• Improving English.
31. ‘I watch YouTube because I am interested in political topics so I
watch political videos on YouTube. It is also related to my study.
For example, when the tutor is talking something about
management and if I do not understand those concepts very well, I
then search them on the YouTube. I also found some lectures about
them and watched them’ (P4, male, age 26, Management, line 346).
32. Digital literacy practice during the transition:
• Ongoing reliance on the authority of the institution when it
comes to using digital technologies and use web-based resources
(e.g., CNKI in China, quick uptake of Wikipedia, Google Scholar
and University database, Email in the UK).
• Slow uptake of the Western social media that are used for
communication
• Variations of experience, uses of technologies that shaped in
different contexts and discipline difference
• Discursive technical issues
33. Out of 30 students, 5 students reported using VLE for their undergraduate study in
China, such as ‘Moodle’ and ‘Zhengfang’ Learning Management System. The uses of
VLE for undergraduate study was mainly for selecting courses and submitting
assignments (e.g., P5; P8). Out of 30 students, 24 reported using Blackboard
frequently for postgraduate study and most students hold positive attitudes towards
Blackboard. Students also show quick uptake for Wikipedia, Google Scholar and
University database. Some students developed knowledge of discipline-based database
during PG study, such as using Lexis to search for news. The majority of students also
motioned about previously they mainly contacted their tutor face to face and they
started to contact their tutor more often through Email during PG study.
Ongoing reliance on the authority of the institution when it comes
to using digital technologies and use web-based resources
34. Students’ digital literacy practices and their decisions on using digital technologies are
shaped in different contexts and influenced by different factors.
Internal
Individual
preferences/Beliefs
Motivation
Expectation of the study
External
Institutions/Departments
Tutor
Technological/Wider
context
Students talked about various
things, such as:
• Political and critical social issues-Internet
censorship
• Difference of institutional cultures,
technological conditions
• Different focus of learning and
assessment
• Different role of their tutors
• Different practices across different
disciplines
35. ‘Most of the time, I asked questions face to face before or after the class time. Sometimes I also sent emails. My tutors
[referring to the undergraduate tutors in Macau] liked sending emails and they also prefer students sending emails to them.
They are very similar to UK tutors (P24, female, age 23, Media and Communication, line 81-85).’
‘I usually went to the office to meet tutors. I feel undergraduate tutors did not have the habits of using email to
communicate with students (P12, male, age 23, Financial Mathematics and Computation, line 63).’
Literacy practice is shaped by context, and understood through people’s networks
‘we were studying hard science, so sometimes verbal explanation online was not adequate and we may need to do
demonstrations or deductions. For example, if I made a mistake when designing a programme and the programme
did not work. I may need to get one classmate to help me with this problem by looking at these codes line by line
(P5, male, age 23, Management, line 67).’
36. ‘I have Facebook and many other accounts. But I often use certain social networks such as WeChat
and Facebook. We often use them for groupwork. You can set up a group on Facebook and use it
for discussion (P15, male, age 25, New media, line 63).’
‘Facebook. It has some educational uses. For example, because it is an international environment, like
we have Japanese, Hungarian students and students from other countries in the group. And they might
not use Wechat, so we use Facebook and Messenger to discuss about the group assignment and arrange
time for group meetings (P10, female, age 23, Public Relation, line 296).’
P15 did undergraduate study in the UK and had previous experience with Facebook:
P10 did undergraduate study in China, when asking whether she began to use any new digital technologies. She
could perceive the educational usefulness of Facebook:
Social media for intercultural communication-different experience
37. ‘I attended a workshop about career seeking and the workshop tutor introduced some social media such as
Linkedin…I build my profile on the Linked in, but the companies that I keep an eye on are mostly Chinese company
because I am going back to China to look for a job after finishing my degree. For the Facebook, we have a group.
Because I did a course ‘academic media’ at the ELTU. There were 14 people in the group. The tutor named it as ‘new
media’, and we used it for discussion. I do not use it very often. There are too many Chinese students now in the
university. So, I still use Wechat for communication as a dominant tool. And even some foreign students have been
influenced by us to start using Wechat (P14, female, age 24, Media, line 172).’
Cultural factors-it is not just about Facebook and Twitter!
And different belief as well as preferences:
Example- P20, female, age 24, Data for Business in Technology.
And language insufficiency, anxiety, stressors that impair intercultural adaptation and communication:
I did not register for any [new] accounts such as Facebook and Twitter [in the UK]. Because I do not think they are
useful for my study and they take up your time. I prefer to communicate face to face (P21, female, age 25, Media and
Advertisement, line 222).
39. video
editing
designing/editing
poster/picture
animation
modelling
web
editing
Discipline difference-Students from media and communication mentioned more about
editing posters using Photoshop (e.g. P13, P17,
P18)
making, editing and remixing videos using
Adobe Premiere (e.g. P15, P17, P18, P21),
Abode After Effects (e.g. P14, P15, P21)
producing animations using ‘Dreamworks’
(http://www.dreamworksanimation.com/) and
Maya 3D max (e.g. P14, P21)
making electronic magazines using iebook
(Chinese electronic journal platform,
http://www.iebook.cn/) (e.g. P14);
designing graphics using Adobe Illustrator (e.g.,
P18);
using Procreate to draw digital paintings (e.g.,
P16).
40. Discipline difference-students from computer science and mathematic discipline mentioned more about
• Using software for
programme making
(e.g., 23)
• Statistical analysis and
modelling (e.g., P12)
• Looking for open
source code (e.g., P5)
41. Discipline difference-students from business discipline mentioned more about
‘I had experience with ERP (Enterprise resource planning) software. It is like a simulation, and it is very
similar to the Monopoly. You have the factory houses and so on. It was quite useful and helpful (P7,
female, age 23, Management Finance and Accounting, line 201).’
‘We used a simulation…that is the assignment for marketing. The tutor divide the class into different
groups…each group would be formed by around three people and they run a company virtually together. We
need to consider...for example…we decided to sell backpack bags…we need to consider how many bags to
produce and whom would be the targeted consumers. It is like a competition. We compare to see who sell
the most of the products then that group would win. Each group has an account for the company. We discuss
about the strategy together and operate the company together. We discussed questions like: what to produce?
what to sell? How to design the products? how to advertise? and so on. We would be warned by tips of the
game. On every class for every week, the tutor would report all the situation of different companies during
the class like the rankings of different companies. And the tutor would use some companies as good
examples to explain what are the strategies that they have used, and also provide some feedback for other
companies which are not in good situations (P5, male, age 23, Management, line 164).’
And discursive difficulties….
42. Discursive difficulties
‘I still do not know how to insert table of contents. Because I did not have to do it often before. For
undergraduate study, I only had to insert a table of contents for the dissertation. Actually, many of us in the
class did not know how to insert a table of content. We went to the print shop. We paid some money to the
staff in the print shop and asked their help to insert a table of contents for us. Now I am experimenting with it
and if I do not know any functions I ask my peers (P10, female, age 23, Public Relations, line 156).’
In another case, during the observation, P3 demonstrated that he had difficulty in writing financial models in a piece of an
essay. For the purpose of demonstrating the problem, he took some contents from his essay. The first example is ‘Cost of
liquidation (normal market) = ∑Si α i/2= 1.438*3343.25*0.0004487/2=1.0785’. While showing this example, P3
described that he did not know how to insert an ‘α (alpha)’ or ‘β (beta)’. Sometimes, he typed an ‘a’ in the word document
then put an Italic so that it became an ‘a’, which looks like an ‘α (alpha)’. Also, he said that he could only type, for
example a ‘√10’ in the word document, which does not look quite right. He was not aware that when inserting an
equation ‘√’, it can be formatted through chosing the ‘professional’ icon to make it into a ‘ 10’. He then describe how he
cope with this with the help of his peers and learnt to use scientific Word and LaTex.
46. ‘Once I decided the topic for my essay, I search for the literature using different approaches. Google Scholar I use it
definitely, and I still like Chinese database CNKI because it is the biggest and the most comprehensive Chinese
database. Together with the University library database. And we also had specific database for translation studies. I
normally use these approaches to look for literature (P1, male, age 23, Translation, line 133).’
‘I use both Chinese and Western recourses. But I will turn to Chinese resources if I read something in English and I feel I
do not understand it. Because Chinese literature is in Chinese normally (P2, female, age 23, Translation, line 166).’
Meaning-making inside and outside of education institutions
‘I was writing the essay outline about tourism translation [during postgraduate study]. I needed the data about
tourists who travelling from aboard to China. I search it on Baidu and I found some official websites to look for
and validate data (P1, male, age 23, Translation, line 151).’
47. ‘I knew about Bloomberg (a website that delivers business and markets news, data and analysis,
https://www.bloomberg.com) during postgraduate study. For undergraduate study, we mainly used Chinese database. Now
sometimes I need to find information using Bloomberg when doing project (P12, male, age 23, Financial Mathematics
and Computation, line 232).’
‘I had a class called ‘the politics of digital media.’ Because I have seldom experienced Western media when I was in
China but we must use case studies for that class. But I feel I know nothing about the Western politics so I could not
come up with any cases. I could only use Chinese cases. Fortunately, one of my tutors is doing Asian related studies and
he encourages me to use cases in my own country as he thinks I know better about the domestic cases. But again, the
problem is that many political cases have not been reported by the Western media so I had to translate many content
from the Chinese media (P14, female, age 23, New Media, line 137).
Meaning-making inside and outside of education institutions
‘I found there are many useful answers provided by people on Zhihu. On Zhihu, people ask questions and then there are
other people who provide answers below these question. It is a real network of Q&A community. It enjoys a friendly
atmosphere. It connects elite people from all areas of life. They are sharing their expertise, experience and insights, and
contributing to a high-quality platform (P28, female, age 22, TESOL, line 54).’
48. Wider contexts and cultural factors: students’ digital literacy
practices are shaped in different contexts and influenced by social
and cultural factors
Textuality, convergence
49. ‘two bottles of water, two calculators, I
am not fighting alone. Working hard for
exams!-to cheer each other up’ .
‘reading papers for my dissertation at home
alone, with a phone at hand to look up terms’
‘working on an assignment with my
classmate in the café. We discuss things but
it is a little bit difficult to concentrate on
writing’
‘I am in the library reading journals. I feel my brain
has not been accustomed to the fact that I am already
a postgraduate student. It is so much efforts to read
academic journals’.
‘exam time, the library is so full. I am thinking
to use this picture to take up a seat’
‘I was writing my essay to meet the deadline. It is
so late now, I feel tired and hungry’
50. Challenges- Not just digital (the majority of students mentioned concerns about academic writing)
‘My tutor say that there is something wrong with my reference. For translation, sometimes there are original text.
I only provide reference for original text, which I quoted directly. But the university has a system called ‘Turnitin’
to check the repetition of the content of your work, so I don’t want to use too much direct quotation as it will
increase the repetition rate. I seldom use direct quotation; therefore, I think I don’t need to put references (P2,
female, age 23, Translation, line 137).’
‘It is hard to search for literature. Most of the cases, I found the literature [referring to English literature] I searched
are not relevant to my research topic. For literature about the theoretical concepts. I only search for Chinese
resources. I can understand better if they are in Chinese. I often search for Chinese articles and then translate the
main idea into English when writing essays (P24, female, age 23, Media and Communication, line 133).’
51. ‘I had some sessions at the English Language Teaching Unit (ELTU), the tutor taught us how to deconstruct the
keywords for a topic for literature search. How to filter the resources and so on. The tutor taught us in details. In
China, we only had supervisor and students; and the supervisor only told us what you should write and what
should you not write. They did not offer much practical help. It is useful to know how to conduct literature search.
For example, like the topic ‘the influence of financial opening upon the national economy in Vietnam’, the tutor
taught us how to deconstruct the sentence and use the key words for searching. we search from big scope to small
scope. For Vietnam, I searched southeast Asian first…financial opening is related to the government control and
financial freedom. These are alternative keywords. Maybe not only deconstruct the sentence but also use some
interconnected words as the replacements and you may get some useful articles (P4, male, age 26, Management,
line 206).’
Supporting…
53. ‘I found it is not very useful to read the conclusion first for the English journals, but it is the best to read the abstract in
the first place. Before when reading Chinese literature, I think the conclusion contains more useful arguments and
summary, so it is useful to read the conclusion first. But for English journals, the abstract summaries what did the
researchers found out but the conclusion is very short. The abstract use the very simple words to display the key points
of the articles, including its methodology and the major findings. (P9, female, age 23, TESOL, line 94).’
Reflecting…
‘Before [referring to undergraduate study in China], I thought what I read is right and I just used the ideas. Now when I
am reading I read with question. And consider different people’s viewpoints (P28, female, age 22, TESOL, line 120).’
54. At the beginning of the course of ‘the politics of digital media’, many Chinese students often felt
unpleasant when the tutor was critiquing about China. This offended Chinese students as they are feeling
great about China. For instance, when the tutor was talking about the Fa Lung Gong [often understood as a
spiritual practice in the Western context], he thinks the Chinese government is controlling the freedom of a
normal organization. But some students argued that Fa Lung organization is an evil threat because some
members did many destructive things. I think it is because we have different mind-set. For them, they may
think people have the free rights to do things to court others’ attention. But for us Chinese people, we think
social order should not be disturbed. But because that course, I read many Western comments about the
Chinese politics which make me feel it is difficult to say which one is real and I started to be critical about
the Chinese politics. The Chinese media always say something in a different way compared to the Western
media. I think maybe media is propaganda which serves the purposes of a government (P14, female, age
23, New Media, line 137).
Conflicts and tensions…
55. There are something missing from most accounts of digital literacies which are capability
or competence based models, such as :
• Learning contexts in which technology uses is shaped
• Cultural and social factors, and lack of address on engagement
• Students’ agency
• Explanations on how literate practice is achieved and enacted
While, the danger is
‘Removing the agency of texts and tools in formalising movements risks romanticising the
practices as well as the humans in them; focusing uniquely on the texts and tools lapses into
naïve formalism or techno-centrism. (Leander and Lovvorn 2006: 301)’
56. What does the data say?
‘How learners interpret their experience is highly influenced by prior experiences
of learning, and the interpretations that have arising from those. Digital literacies
cannot be bolted onto existing practices and prior conception: these must be
recognised, incorporated and (if necessary) reconceptualised. (Goodyear & Ellis,
2008).
Most accounts of literature on affordances of digital technologies that described technology
can be used for certain educational purpose are framed on Western perspectives with a
focus on Western Web technologies, while it overlooked cultural factors such as linguistic
aspects, and international students’ own capacity to make informed choices. Developing
literacy pedagogy needs to research learner’s experience, and look at the funds of
knowledge that learners bring to education to inform pedagogies.
57. ‘Literacy is not and never has been a personal attribute or ideologically inert ‘skills’
simply to be ‘acquired’ by individual person…It is ideologically and inert ‘skills’
simply to be acquired by individual persons…It is ideologically and politically
charged-it can be used as a means of social control or regulation.’ (Hartley, 2002)
Developing literacy pedagogy among international students need to move beyond the cognitive model
at individual levels. Focusing on generic skills hides the complexity of the tensions occurs when
sojourners move from a familiarised place (which could be home) to a unfamiliarised place (when
studying aboard). In this sense, digital literacy constitutes identities and learning. Educators ought to
observe discursive conflicts that take place during the classroom, understanding different worldviews
and negotiating them with students (for example, try not to take a stance when discussing sensitive
topics in the classroom, but providing students with resources that offer different interpretations on the
topics, and help students to reflect and become more open-minded to multiple perspectives.)
58. Reconceptualising digital literacies for the present study:
• Context-specific, unstable, in flux
• Emergent from situated social and cultural practices of meaning-making
Digital literacies are emergent through networks of human and
nonhuman actors. It is constitutive of ‘context’, space and place. It is
locally negotiated and created. It relies on resilience and creativity.
(Lesley and Martin, 2014).
We see themes in terms of:
59. Implication for further research
Understanding students’ digital literacy practices through tracing their socialmaterial uses
Trace ‘the multifarious struggles, negotiations and accommodations whose effects constitute the ‘thing’ in education:
students, teachers, learning activities, spaces, knowledge representations such as texts, pedagogy, curriculum, content and so
forth. Rather than take such concepts as foundational categories, or objects with properties (Fenwick et al., 2011, p.2 ).’
‘Humans, and what they take to be their learning and social process, do not float, distinct, in container-like contexts of
education, such as a classroom or community sites, that can be conceptualised and dismissed simply as a wash of
material stuff and spaces. The things that assemble these contexts, and incidentally the actions and bodies including
human ones that are part o these assemblages, are continuously acting upon each other to bring forth and distribute, as
well as to obscure and deny, knowledge (Fenwick et al., 2011, vii).’
More longitudinal and ethnographic research, and also have a take on identity