More Related Content
Similar to Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac complaint pdf
Similar to Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac complaint pdf (20)
More from Lyn Goering (20)
Spring 2010 closed memo assignment jellyvision v. aflac complaint pdf
- 1. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 1 of 12
!"!#$%!&"!#%'!(#)#%(!'!(#*!+#!+,&*#!
-,*!#$%!",*#$%*"!'!(#*!+#!,-!!..!",!(!
%)(#%*"!'!/!(!,"!
!
!
0%..1/!(!,"2!!"+32! ! ! ! 4! 0&*1!'%5)"'!
! ! ! ! ! ! 4!
6789:;9<<2! ! ! ! 4!
! ! ! ! ! ! 4!
=3! ! ! ! ! 4! !
! ! ! ! ! ! 4!
)-.)+!!"+,*6,*)#%'2! ! ! 4! !
! ! ! ! ! ! 4!
'><>:?8:;3! ! ! ! 4!
!
!
+,56.)!"#!
"#$%&'%((! )*##+,%-%.&/! 0&12! 34)*##+,%-%.&56/! (.7! %'-! 8.9:#$%&'! $;$%&-'! <*(*&=$&'! >(#$1!
0&1.7:.7$'*=!34>(#$156/!$##*;*-!$-!(.##.?-@!
"8;@A>!,<!)B;9C:!
!2 AB%-!$1'%.&!$7%-*-!(7.9!>(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!%&!
1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!$&!.&#%&*!;$9*2!MD1B!D-*!1.&-'%'D'*-!%&(7%&;*9*&'!.(!)*##+,%-%.&C-!(*=*7$##+!
7*;%-'*7*=!'7$=*9$7N!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J/!?B%1B!)*##+,%-%.&!B$-!D-*=!(.7!9.7*!'B$&!!O!
+*$7-!(.7!;$9*-2!
P2 >-!-*'!(.7'B!9.7*!(D##+!B*7*%&/!>(#$1!B$-!7*1*&'#+!Q*;D&!D-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!
(.7!$!;$9*!$11*--%Q#*!.&!%'-!?*Q-%'*2!>(#$1C-!D-*!%-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&!$&=!7*:7*-*&'-!$&!
*((.7'!'.!'7$=*!.&!'B*!,$#D$Q#*!;..=?%##!$&=!7*:D'$'%.&!$--.1%$'*=!?%'B!)*##+,%-%.&!$&=!%'-!FGH!
<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N2!
!!
- 2. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 2 of 12
R2 >(#$1C-!D-*!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!B$-!1$D-*=/!$&=!%-!#%N*#+!'.!1.&'%&D*!'.!1$D-*/!
1.&(D-%.&!?%'B!7*;$7=!'.!'B*!$((%#%$'%.&!.7!1.&&*1'%.&!Q*'?**&!>(#$1!$&=!)*##+,%-%.&/!$&=!?%'B!
7*;$7=!'.!'B*!-.D71*/!-:.&-.7-B%:/!.7!$::7.,$#!.(!>(#$1C-!;$9*/!7*-D#'%&;!%&!'B*!D&SD-'!
*&7%1B9*&'!.(!>(#$12!!
T2 )*##+,%-%.&!-**N-/!$9.&;!.'B*7!7*9*=%*-/!%&SD&1'%,*!$&=!9.&*'$7+!7*#%*(!(.7!%&SD7%*-!'B$'!
B$,*!Q**&/!$&=!?%##!1.&'%&D*!'.!Q*/!1$D-*=!Q+!>(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!
LH>8J/!%&!,%.#$'%.&!.(!'B*!U$&B$9!>1'!3!O!H2M282!VV!WO!!!"!#!$26!$&=!7*#$'*=!0##%&.%-!#$?-2!
0@A9D?9B;9C:!8:?!/>:@>!
O2 AB%-!8.D7'!B$-!:*7-.&$#!SD7%-=%1'%.&!.,*7!>(#$1!Q*1$D-*!>(#$1!B$-!*&;$;*=!%&!QD-%&*--!
$1'%,%'%*-!%&/!$&=!=%7*1'*=!'./!'B*!M'$'*!.(!0##%&.%-!$&=!?%'B%&!'B%-!)D=%1%$#!<%-'7%1'/!$&=!Q*1$D-*!
>(#$1!B$-!N&.?%&;#+!1.99%''*=!'.7'%.D-!$1'-!$%9*=!$'/!$&=!1$D-%&;!B$79!?%'B%&/!'B*!M'$'*!.(!
0##%&.%-!$&=!'B%-!)D=%1%$#!<%-'7%1'2!!
X2 AB%-!8.D7'!B$-!SD7%-=%1'%.&!.,*7!'B*!1#$%9-!%&!'B%-!8.9:#$%&'!:D7-D$&'!'.!!O!H2M282!V!!P!!
$&=!PY!H2M282!VV!RR!/!!RRY!$&=!!RXZ2!
Z2 [*&D*!%-!:7.:*7!%&!'B%-!)D=%1%$#!<%-'7%1'!D&=*7!PY!H2M282!V!R!3Q6!$&=!316!Q*1$D-*!
)*##+,%-%.&!$&=!>(#$1!7*-%=*!%&!'B%-!<%-'7%1'/!Q*1$D-*!)*##+,%-%.&!$&=!>(#$1!'7$&-$1'!QD-%&*--!%&!'B%-!
<%-'7%1'/!$&=!Q*1$D-*!$!-DQ-'$&'%$#!:$7'!.(!'B*!*,*&'-!;%,%&;!7%-*!'.!)*##+,%-%.&C-!1#$%9-!B$,*!
.11D77*=/!$&=!$7*!.11D77%&;/!?%'B%&!'B%-!<%-'7%1'2!]D7'B*79.7*/!'B*!=$9$;*!'.!)*##+,%-%.&!$&=!%'-!
%&'*##*1'D$#!:7.:*7'+!=*-17%Q*=!B*7*%&!1.&'%&D*-!'.!.11D7!%&!'B%-!<%-'7%1'2!
68A;9>D!
Y2 )*##+,%-%.&!%-!$&!0##%&.%-!1.7:.7$'%.&!?%'B!%'-!:7%&1%:$#!:#$1*!.(!QD-%&*--!%&!8B%1$;./!0##%&.%-2!
P!
- 3. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 3 of 12
2 >(#$1!%-!$!^*.7;%$!1.7:.7$'%.&!?%'B!%'-!:7%&1%:$#!:#$1*!.(!QD-%&*--!%&!8.#D9QD-/!^*.7;%$2!!
0>77E=9D9C:FD!1,&!',"F#!G",H!0)+G!58AI!
!W2 )*##+,%-%.&!17*$'*-!$&=!=*,*#.:-!.7%;%&$#!%&'*7$1'%,*!$&=!&.&"%&'*7$1'%,*!*_:*7%*&1*-2!
G&*!.(!)*##+,%-%.&C-!1.7*!:7.=D1'-!%-!$!;$9*!'B$'!%'!-*##-!D&=*7!'B*!9$7N!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!
)>8J2!AB*!;$9*/!(%7-'!7*#*$-*=!%&!!O/!*&'$%#-!:#$+*7-!$&-?*7%&;!BD9.7.D-!9D#'%:#*"1B.%1*!
`D*-'%.&-2!
!!2 )*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*!B$-!*&S.+*=!*&.79.D-!1.99*71%$#!$&=!
17%'%1$#!-D11*--2!AB*!;$9*!1$&!Q*!:#$+*=!.&!1.9:D'*7-/!%&!*%'B*7!8<"aGb!.7!.&#%&*!(.79$'/!$-!
?*##!$-!.&!'B*!M.&+!"#$+M'$'%.&!-+-'*92!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*!B$-!?.&!
9.7*!'B$&!OW!$?$7=-!(7.9!'B*!%&'*7$1'%,*!%&=D-'7+2!M%&1*!!O/!.,*7!O!9%##%.&!D&%'-!.(!FGH!
<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*-!B$,*!Q**&!-.#=2!0&!'B*!-D99*7!.(!PWW!/!'B*!>c8!'*#*,%-%.&!&*'?.7N!
:7*9%*7*=!$!:7%9*"'%9*!'*#*,%-%.&!-B.?!,*7-%.&!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J/!D&=*7!#%1*&-*!(7.9!
)*##+,%-%.&2!
!P2 AB*!:B7$-*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!%-!D-*=!%&!'B*!;$9*!%'-*#(/!.&!'B*!:$1N$;%&;!.(!'B*!
;$9*/!$&=!%&!$=,*7'%-*9*&'-!(.7!'B*!;$9*2!M%&1*!'B*!%&1*:'%.&!.(!'B*!:7.=D1'!#%&*/!'B*!FGH!
<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!B$-!1.&-%-'*&'#+!'$N*&!'B*!,%-D$#!(.79!.(!'B*!?.7=-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!
-%''%&;!.&!'.:!.(!'B*!?.7N!)>8J/!?B%1B!%-!'?.!'.!'B7**!'%9*-!$-!'$##/!$&=!*`D$##+!$-!?%=*/!$-!FGH!
<GICA!JIGKd!'BD-@!
!
R!
- 4. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 4 of 12
!
!
!R2 )*##+,%-%.&!B$-!:7.9.'*=!%'-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*!'B7.D;B!,$7%.D-!9*=%$/!
%&1#D=%&;!:7%&'/!*#*1'7.&%1/!'*#*,%-%.&/!$&=!7$=%.2!M%&1*!!O/!)*##+,%-%.&!$&=!%'-!#%1*&-**-!B$,*!
-:*&'!9%##%.&-!.(!=.##$7-!:7.9.'%&;!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N/!Q7$&=/!$&=!
;$9*-2!)*##+,%-%.&C-!*((.7'-!B$,*!7*-D#'*=!%&!9%##%.&-!.(!$D7$#!$&=!,%-D$#!1.&-D9*7!%9:7*--%.&-!.(!
'B*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N/!'BD-!7*%&(.71%&;!'B*!$--.1%$'%.&!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!
;$9*-!?%'B!$!-%&;#*!-.D71*2!
!T2 )*##+,%-%.&C-!D-*!$&=!:7.9.'%.&!.(!'B*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!
;$9*-/!%&!%&'*7-'$'*!1.99*71*/!Q*;$&!%&!!O!$&=!B$-!Q**&!-DQ-'$&'%$##+!1.&'%&D.D-!$&=!
*_1#D-%,*!-%&1*!'B*&2!
T!
- 5. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 5 of 12
!O2 AB7.D;B!%'-!*_:*&=%'D7*!.(!-DQ-'$&'%$#!'%9*/!7*-.D71*-/!$&=!*((.7'!%&!1.&'%&D.D-#+!D-%&;!
$&=!:7.9.'%&;!'B*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!;$9*-/!)*##+,%-%.&!B$-!
17*$'*=!-DQ-'$&'%$#!7*1.;&%'%.&/!;..=?%##/!$&=!-*1.&=$7+!9*$&%&;/!$&=!B$-!$1`D%7*=!-%;&%(%1$&'!
%&'*##*1'D$#!:7.:*7'+!7%;B'-/!%&!%'-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!$-!D-*=!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!
;$9*-2!
!X2 AB*!HM!"$'*&'!$&=!A7$=*9$7N!G((%1*!B$-!$?$7=*=!'.!)*##+,%-%.&!HM!A7$=*9$7N!
a*;%-'7$'%.&!I.2!P/WPZ/RPR!(.7!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!(.7!D-*!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!1.9:D'*7!
;$9*!:7.;7$9-!7*1.7=*=!.&!8<"aGbM!3#!!!e_B%Q%'!>62!
!Z2 AB*!a*;%-'7$'%.&!%-!%&1.&'*-'$Q#*!:D7-D$&'!'.!M*1'%.&!!O!.(!'B*!U$&B$9!>1'!3!O!H2M282!
V!WXO62!>-!$!7*-D#'/!'B*!9$7N!%-!,$#%=/!'B*!a*;%-'7$'%.&!(.7!'B*!9$7N!%-!,$#%=/!)*##+,%-%.&!.?&-!'B*!
9$7N/!$&=!)*##+!B$-!'B*!*_1#D-%,*!7%;B'!'.!D-*!'B*!9$7N!%&!1.99*71*!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!;$9*-!
3!O!H2M282!V!!!O62!
)<78BFD!&:8@;JCA9K>?!&D>!,<!1,&!',"F#!G",H!L&)+G!
!Y2 G&!%&(.79$'%.&!$&=!Q*#%*(/!>(#$1C-!:7%9$7+!QD-%&*--!%-!-D::#*9*&'$#!%&-D7$&1*!
D&=*7?7%'%&;2!>-!:$7'!.(!%'-!:7.9.'%.&$#!*((.7'-!'.!-D::.7'!%'-!QD-%&*--/!>(#$1!B$-!7*1*&'#+!Q*;D&!
.((*7%&;!%'-!1D-'.9*7-!$&=!:.'*&'%$#!1D-'.9*7-!$&!.&#%&*!;$9*2!>(#$1!:7.9.'*-!'B*!;$9*!D&=*7!
'B*!9$7N@!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J2!AB*!9$7N!%-!D-*=!.&!3$9.&;!.'B*7!'B%&;-6!$!?*Q-%'*!
.:*7$'*=!Q+!>(#$1!'B$'!%'-*#(!D-*-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!$-!'B*!*&'%7*'+!.(!'B*!=.9$%&!
&$9*@!???2+.D=.&'N&.?`D$1N21.92!AB*!B.9*!:$;*!.(!'B$'!-%'*!-B.?-!'B*!(.##.?%&;@!
O!
- 6. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 6 of 12
!
3AB*!-$9*!-17**&!-B.?-!D:!$'!$&.'B*7!>(#$1!-%'*/!???2;*'`D$1N21.926!]7.9!'B*7*/!.&*!%-!
:7*-*&'*=!?%'B!$!-*7%*-!.(!'B7**!`D*-'%.&-!?%'B!9D#'%:#*!1B.%1*!7*-:.&-*-!$,$%#$Q#*!'.!'B*!
:#$+*7!.(!'B*!;$9*2!
!2 >(#$1C-!:7.9.'%.&!.(!%'-!;$9*!%-!$#-.!$11*--%Q#*!'B7.D;B!'B%7=!:$7'%*-C!?*Q!-%'*-/!
%&1#D=%&;!3$9.&;!.'B*7-6!-D1B!B*$,%#+"'7$((%1N*=!-%'*-!$-!'B.-*!.:*7$'*=!Q+!'B*!I*?!F.7N!A%9*-!
$&=!8II2!>!-17**&!-B.'!(7.9!'B*!I*?!F.7N!A%9*-C!B.9*!:$;*/!$-!$11*--*=!.&!)$&D$7+!!W/!PW!W/!
%-!$''$1B*=!$'!e_B%Q%'!c2!
PW2 AB*!?.7=-!D-*=!Q+!>(#$1!=%((*7!(7.9!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!.&#+!Q+!
'B*!-DQ-'%'D'%.&!.(!'B*!#*''*7!4`5!(.7!'B*!#*''*7-!4S$52!AB*!-DQ-'%'D'%.&!:7.=D1*-!'B*!?.7=!
4`D$1N/5!?B%1B!%-!,*7+!-%9%#$7!'.!'B*!?.7=!4S$1N25!>&=!'B*!,%-D$#!:7*-*&'$'%.&!.(!'B*!?.7=-!D-*=!
Q+!>(#$1!9%9%1-!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!%&!%'-!-'$1N%&;!$&=!:7.:.7'%.&$#!
'7*$'9*&'!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!%&!7*#$'%.&!'.!LH>8J2!
P!2 AB*!;$9*!.((*7*=!Q+!>(#$1!D&=*7!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!%-!$'!#*$-'!7*#$'*=!%&!&$'D7*!
$&=!N%&=!'.!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*2!
PP2 >(#$1!B$-!$::#%*=!'.!7*;%-'*7!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!$-!$!'7$=*9$7N!?%'B!'B*!HM!
"$'*&'!$&=!A7$=*9$7N!G((%1*!(.7!D-*!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!%&-D7$&1*!D&=*7?7%'%&;!%&!'B*!(%*#=!.(!
B*$#'B!%&-D7$&1*2!AB*!$::#%1$'%.&/!M*7%$#!ID9Q*7!ZZYWOY!/!%-!:*&=%&;2!
X!
- 7. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 7 of 12
PR2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(/!$&=!$''*9:'!'.!7*;%-'*7/!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!(.7!$!
;$9*!$7*!?%##(D#!$&=!%&'*&'%.&$#!$1'-!$&=!$7*!%&'*&=*=!'.!'7$=*!.&!'B*!7*:D'$'%.&!$&=!;..=?%##!
.(!)*##+,%-%.&/!'.!1.&(D-*!$&=!=*1*%,*!1.&-D9*7-/!$&=!'.!D&($%7#+!1.9:*'*!?%'B!)*##+,%-%.&2!
PT2 !G&!%&(.79$'%.&!$&=!Q*#%*(/!Q*(.7*!>(#$1!Q*;$&!D-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J/!>(#$1!
B$=!$1'D$#!N&.?#*=;*!.(!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!$&=f.7!a*;%-'7$'%.&2!
PO2 M%&1*!>(#$1!Q*;$&!D-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J/!QD'!Q*(.7*!)$&D$7+!P!/!PW!W/!>(#$1!
B$=!$1'D$#!N&.?#*=;*!.(!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N!$&=f.7!a*;%-'7$'%.&2!
PX2 c*(.7*!>(#$1!Q*;$&!D-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J/!>(#$1!B$=!1.&-'7D1'%,*!&.'%1*!.(!
)*##+,%-%.&C-!1#$%9!.(!.?&*7-B%:!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!(.7!1.9:D'*7!;$9*!:7.;7$9-!
7*1.7=*=!.&!8<"aGb-/!:D7-D$&'!'.!!O!H2M282!V!WZP2!!
PZ2 G&!%&(.79$'%.&!$&=!Q*#%*(/!>(#$1!%-!=*#%Q*7$'*#+!$&=!?%##(D##+!D-%&;/!%&!%&'*7-'$'*!
1.99*71*/!'B*!9$7N!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!$!;$9*!%&!$&!$''*9:'!'.!
'7$=*!.&!'B*!;..=?%##/!7*:D'$'%.&/!$&=!9$7N*'%&;!:.?*7!17*$'*=!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&!D&=*7!%'-!FGH!
<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N2!
PY2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!=*:7%,*-!)*##+,%-%.&!.(!'B*!$Q%#%'+!
'.!1.&'7.#!1.&-D9*7!:*71*:'%.&!.(!'B*!`D$#%'+!.(!;..=-!.((*7*=!D&=*7!9$7N-!'B$'!$7*!%=*&'%1$#!
.7!1.&(D-%&;#+!-%9%#$7!'.!)*##+,%-%.&C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!9$7N2!AB%-!:#$1*-!)*##+,%-%.&C-!
,$#D$Q#*!7*:D'$'%.&!$&=!;..=?%##!%&!'B*!B$&=-!.(!>(#$1/!.,*7!?B.9!)*##+,%-%.&!B$-!&.!1.&'7.#2!!
P2 )*##+,%-%.&!B$-!Q**&/!%-!&.?/!$&=!?%##!Q*!%77*:$7$Q#+!B$79*=!Q+!>(#$1C-!$(.7*9*&'%.&*=!
$1'-!$&=/!D&#*--!*&S.%&*=!Q+!'B*!8.D7'/!>(#$1!?%##!1.&'%&D*!'.!*&;$;*!%&!%'-!D&#$?(D#!$1'-2!AB*7*!
%-!&.!$=*`D$'*!7*9*=+!$'!#$?!(.7!'B*!B$79!1$D-*=!Q+!>(#$1C-!D&#$?(D#!$1'-!$##*;*=!B*7*%&2!
Z!
- 8. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 8 of 12
+,&"#!!!
#A8?>M8AI!!:<A9:N>M>:;!9:!/9C78;9C:!C<!
(>B;9C:!OPQR4!C<!;J>!.8:J8M!)B;2!RS!&3(3+3!TRRRUQR4!
RW2 )*##+,%-%.&!%&1.7:.7$'*-!Q+!7*(*7*&1*!"$7$;7$:B-!!!'B7.D;B!P/!$Q.,*/!$-!'B.D;B!(D##+!-*'!
(.7'B!B*7*%&2!!
R!2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(!FGH!<GIgA!JIGK!LH>8J!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!$!;$9*!%-!
#%N*#+!'.!1$D-*!1.&(D-%.&/!9%-'$N*/!$&=f.7!=*1*:'%.&2!!
RP2 AB*!$(.7*9*&'%.&*=!$1'-!.(!>(#$1!1.&-'%'D'*!%&(7%&;*9*&'!.(!$!(*=*7$##+!7*;%-'*7*=!9$7N/!
%&!,%.#$'%.&!.(!!O!H2M282!V!!!T2!!
+,&"#!!!!
&:<89A!+CMV>;9;9C:!9:!/9C78;9C:!C<!
(>B;9C:!UOQ84!C<!;J>!.8:J8M!)B;2!RS!&3(3+3!TRRPSQ84!
RR2 )*##+,%-%.&!%&1.7:.7$'*-!Q+!7*(*7*&1*!"$7$;7$:B-!!!'B7.D;B!RP/!$Q.,*/!$-!'B.D;B!(D##+!-*'!
(.7'B!B*7*%&2!
RT2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!%&!1.99*71*!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!1.&-'%'D'*-!$!($#-*!
=*-%;&$'%.&!.(!.7%;%&!'B$'!%-!#%N*#+!'.!1$D-*!1.&(D-%.&/!9%-'$N*/!.7!=*1*:'%.&!$-!'.!'B*!$((%#%$'%.&/!
1.&&*1'%.&/!.7!$--.1%$'%.&!Q*'?**&!>(#$1!$&=!)*##+,%-%.&/!.7!$-!'.!'B*!.7%;%&/!-:.&-.7-B%:/!.7!
$::7.,$#!.(!>(#$1C-!;$9*!.7!1.99*71%$#!$1'%,%'%*-!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&/!%&!,%.#$'%.&!.(!M*1'%.&!TR3$6!.(!
'B*!U$&B$9!>1'/!!O!H2M282!V!!PO3$62!
Y!
- 9. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 9 of 12
+,&"#!!!!!
/9C78;9C:!C<!;J>!!779:C9D!&:9<CAM!
'>B>V;9=>!#A8?>!6A8B;9B>D!)B;2!WRS!!.+(!SRXYR"Z!
RO2 )*##+,%-%.&!%&1.7:.7$'*-!Q+!7*(*7*&1*!"$7$;7$:B-!!!'B7.D;B!RT/!$Q.,*/!$-!'B.D;B!(D##+!-*'!
(.7'B!B*7*%&2!
RX2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!%-!#%N*#+!'.!1$D-*!1.&(D-%.&!.7!
9%-D&=*7-'$&=%&;!$-!'.!'B*!-.D71*/!-:.&-.7-B%:/!$::7.,$#/!.7!1*7'%(%1$'%.&!.(!>(#$1C-!;$9*/!
$&=f.7!.'B*7?%-*!17*$'*-!$!#%N*#%B..=!.(!1.&(D-%.&!.7!9%-D&=*7-'$&=%&;2!
+,&"#!!/!
/9C78;9C:!C<!;J>!!779:C9D!+C:D@M>A!-A8@?!
8:?!'>B>V;9=>![@D9:>DD!6A8B;9B>D!)B;2!WRS!!.+(!SXSYR"RP!
RZ2 !)*##+,%-%.&!%&1.7:.7$'*-!Q+!7*(*7*&1*!"$7$;7$:B-!!!'B7.D;B!RX/!$Q.,*/!$-!'B.D;B!(D##+!
-*'!(.7'B!B*7*%&2!
RY2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!%-!$!=*1*:'%,*!$1'!.7!:7$1'%1*/!.&!
?B%1B!%'!%&'*&=-!1.&-D9*7-!'.!7*#+/!$&=!%-!%&!'B*!1.D7-*!.(!1.&=D1'!%&,.#,%&;!'7$=*!.7!
1.99*71*2!!
R2 >(#$1C-!1.&=D1'!%&,.#,*-!'7$=*!:7$1'%1*-!'B$'!$7*!=%7*1'*=!'.!'B*!9$7N*'!;*&*7$##+!$&=!
'B$'!%9:#%1$'*!1.&-D9*7!:7.'*1'%.&!1.&1*7&-2!
!
!
- 10. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 10 of 12
+,&"#!/!
+CMMC:!.8!&:<89A!+CMV>;9;9C:!
8:?!#A8?>M8AI!!:<A9:N>M>:;!
TW2 )*##+,%-%.&!7*:*$'-!$&=!7*$##*;*-!'B*!$##*;$'%.&-!.(!:$7$;7$:B-!!!'B7.D;B!R/!$Q.,*/!$-!
'B.D;B!(D##+!-*'!(.7'B!B*7*%&2!
T!2 >(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!1.&-'%'D'*-!1.99.&!#$?!D&($%7!
1.9:*'%'%.&!$&=!'7$=*9$7N!%&(7%&;*9*&'!Q*1$D-*!-D1B!D-*!%-!#%N*#+!'.!1$D-*!1.&(D-%.&/!9%-'$N*/!
.7!=*1*:'%.&!$-!'.!'B*!-.D71*/!-:.&-.7-B%:/!.7!$::7.,$#!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&!.(!>(#$1C-!;$9*2!AB*!
:DQ#%1!%-/!(.7!*_$9:#*/!#%N*#+!'.!Q*#%*,*!'B$'!>(#$1C-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!;$9*!.7%;%&$'*-!
?%'B!)*##+,%-%.&/!%-!#%1*&-*=!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&/!$&=f.7!%-!-:.&-.7*=!Q+/!1.&&*1'*=!?%'B/!.7!7*#$'*=!'.!
)*##+,%-%.&2!
!
Kheae]Gae/!)*##+,%-%.&!:7$+-@!
>2! AB$'!>(#$1/!%'-!.((%1*7-/!$;*&'-/!-*7,$&'-/!*9:#.+**-!$&=!$''.7&*+-/!$&=!$##!'B.-*!
%&!$1'%,*!1.&1*7'!.7!:$7'%1%:$'%.&!?%'B!'B*9!3B*7*%&$('*7!1.##*1'%,*#+!4>(#$156/!Q*!
:7*#%9%&$7%#+!$&=!:*79$&*&'#+!*&S.%&*=!$&=!7*-'7$%&*=!(7.9@!
!2! H-%&;!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!$-/!.7!$-!:$7'!.(/!$&+!9$7N!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!
?%'B!$!;$9*d!!
!
P2! H-%&;!$&+!.'B*7!'*79!.7!:B7$-*!$-/!.7!$-!:$7'!.(/!$!9$7N!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!
?%'B!$!;$9*/!?B*7*!-D1B!D-*!%-!#%N*#+!'.!7*-D#'!%&!'B*!9%-'$N*&!Q*#%*(!'B$'!
>(#$1!.7!%'-!;$9*!%-!%&!$&+!?$+!$((%#%$'*=/!1.&&*1'*=!.7!$--.1%$'*=!?%'B!
)*##+,%-%.&!.7!%'-!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!)>8J!;$9*d!$&=!
!
R2! G'B*7?%-*!D&($%7#+!1.9:*'%&;!?%'B!)*##+,%-%.&!%&!$&+!9$&&*7!?B$'-.*,*72!
!
!W!
- 11. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 11 of 12
c2! AB$'!>(#$1!Q*!7*`D%7*=!'.!*_:7*--#+!$Q$&=.&!%'-!(*=*7$#!'7$=*9$7N!$::#%1$'%.&!(.7!
FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J/!M*7%$#!I.2!ZZYWOY!/!:D7-D$&'!'.!RZ!82]2a2!VP2XY2!
82! AB$'!>(#$1!Q*!7*`D%7*=!'.!$--%;&!'.!)*##+,%-%.&!$##!.(!>(#$1C-!7%;B'/!'%'#*/!$&=!%&'*7*-'!
%&!$&=!'.!'B*!=.9$%&!&$9*!???2+.D=.&'N&.?`D$1N21.92!!
<2! AB$'/!:D7-D$&'!'.!!O!H2M282!V!!!Y/!>(#$1!Q*!7*`D%7*=!'.!=*#%,*7!'.!'B*!8.D7'!.7!'.!
)*##+,%-%.&!(.7!=*-'7D1'%.&!$##!#$Q*#-/!:$1N$;*-/!Q7.1BD7*-/!?7$::*7-/!
$=,*7'%-*9*&'-/!:7.9.'%.&-/!#*''*7B*$=/!$&=!$##!.'B*7!:B+-%1$#!9$'*7%$#-!%&!'B*!
1D-'.=+!.7!D&=*7!'B*!1.&'7.#!.(!>(#$1!Q*$7%&;!'B*!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!
9$7N/!$-!D-*=!%&!1.&&*1'%.&!?%'B!$!;$9*2!AB%-!%&1#D=*-!'B*!=*#*'%.&!.(!$&+!$&=!
$##!*#*1'7.&%1!=$'$/!%&(.79$'%.&/!$&=f.7!1.9:D'*7!(%#*-!Q*$7%&;!$&+!(.79!.(!'B*!
FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!9$7N!%&!$&+!9$&&*7/!%&1#D=%&;!$&+!-D1B!(%#*-!.&!
?*Q-%'*-/!1.9:D'*7-/!B$7=!=7%,*-/!.7!.'B*7!-'.7$;*!9*=%$!'B$'!$7*!.:*7$'*=!Q+/!
.7!D&=*7!'B*!1.&'7.#!.(/!>(#$1!$&=!%'-!$;*&'-!$&=!1.&'7$1'.7-2!
e2! AB$'/!:D7-D$&'!'.!!O!H2M282!V!!!X/!>(#$1!Q*!=%7*1'*=!'.!(%#*!?%'B!'B*!8.D7'!$&=!
-*7,*!D:.&!)*##+,%-%.&!?%'B%&!'B%7'+!3RW6!=$+-!$('*7!%--D$&1*!.(!$&!%&SD&1'%.&!'B$'!
%&1.7:.7$'*-!'B*!$(.7*9*&'%.&*=!7*#%*(!3$-!?*##!$-!$&+!.'B*7!%&SD&1'%,*!7*#%*(6!$!
7*:.7'!%&!?7%'%&;!$&=!D&=*7!.$'B!-*''%&;!(.7'B!%&!=*'$%#!'B*!9$&&*7!$&=!(.79!%&!
?B%1B!>(#$1!B$-!1.9:#%*=!?%'B!'B*!%&SD&1'%.&2!
!!!
- 12. Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 12 of 12
!
]2! AB$'!)*##+,%-%.&!Q*!$?$7=*=!9.&*'$7+!7*#%*(!%&!$&!$9.D&'!'.!Q*!(%_*=!Q+!'B*!
8.D7'!%&!%'-!=%-17*'%.&/!%&1#D=%&;!3QD'!&.'!#%9%'*=!'.6@!
!2! >##!:7.(%'-!7*1*%,*=!Q+!>(#$1!$-!$!7*-D#'!.(!%'-!D&#$?(D#!$1'%.&-/!-$%=!
$9.D&'!'.!Q*!'7*Q#*=!=D*!'.!>(#$1C-!?%##(D#!9%-1.&=D1'd!$&=!
!
P2! >##!=$9$;*-!-D-'$%&*=!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&!$-!$!7*-D#'!.(!>(#$1C-!D&#$?(D#!$1'-/!
-$%=!$9.D&'!'.!Q*!'7*Q#*=!=D*!'.!>(#$1C-!?%##(D#!$1'%.&-d!$&=f.7!
!
R2! "D&%'%,*!=$9$;*-2!
!
^2! AB$'!'B*!8.D7'!$?$7=!'.!)*##+,%-%.&!$##!7*$-.&$Q#*!$''.7&*+-C!(**-/!1.-'-!$&=!
=%-QD7-*9*&'-!%&1D77*=!Q+!)*##+,%-%.&!$-!$!7*-D#'!.(!'B%-!$1'%.&2!
h2! AB$'!'B*!8.D7'!7*`D%7*!>(#$1!'.!:$+!:7*SD=;9*&'!%&'*7*-'!.&!$&+!$&=!$##!
9.&*'$7+!$?$7=-!3%&!?B$'*,*7!(.796!'.!?B%1B!)*##+,%-%.&!%-!*&'%'#*=2!
02! AB$'!'B*!8.D7'!.7=*7!$##!.'B*7!$&=!(D7'B*7!7*#%*(!'B$'!%'!=**9-!:7.:*7!$&=!SD-'2!
)*##+,%-%.&!=*9$&=-!$!'7%$#!Q+!SD7+!.&!$##!%--D*-!-.!'7%$Q#*2!
!
<>Ae<@!!i)$&D$7+!P!/!PW!Wiiiiiii! a*-:*1'(D##+!-DQ9%''*=/!
! !
! 0%..1/!(!,"2!!"+32!;JAC@NJ!9;D!);;CA:>ED!
! !
! !
! if-f!).-BD$!M2!]7%1Niiiiiiiiii! !
JD7'!)2!h%7-1B!30##%&.%-!c$7!I.2!XPZXPYR6! ).B&!A2!^$Q7%*#%=*-!30##%&.%-!c$7!I.2!X!YRPR6!
)*##+,%-%.&/!0&12! "B%#%:!>2!).&*-!30##%&.%-!c$7!I.2!XP!ZP!R6!
YTY!K!e$-'9$&!M'7**'/!MD%'*!!WT! ).-BD$!M2!]7%1N!30##%&.%-!c$7!I.2!XPPYTR6!
8B%1$;./!0U!XWXPP! c7%&N-!h.(*7!^%#-.&!j!U%.&*!
3R!P6!PXX"WXWX! TOO!I2!8%'+(7.&'!"#$E$!<7%,*/!MD%'*!RXWW!
! 8B%1$;./!0U!XWX!!!
3R!P6!RP!"TPWW!
! !
!P!
![Case 1:10-cv-00426 Document 1 Filed 01/21/2010 Page 2 of 12
R2 >(#$1C-!D-*!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!LH>8J!B$-!1$D-*=/!$&=!%-!#%N*#+!'.!1.&'%&D*!'.!1$D-*/!
1.&(D-%.&!?%'B!7*;$7=!'.!'B*!$((%#%$'%.&!.7!1.&&*1'%.&!Q*'?**&!>(#$1!$&=!)*##+,%-%.&/!$&=!?%'B!
7*;$7=!'.!'B*!-.D71*/!-:.&-.7-B%:/!.7!$::7.,$#!.(!>(#$1C-!;$9*/!7*-D#'%&;!%&!'B*!D&SD-'!
*&7%1B9*&'!.(!>(#$12!!
T2 )*##+,%-%.&!-**N-/!$9.&;!.'B*7!7*9*=%*-/!%&SD&1'%,*!$&=!9.&*'$7+!7*#%*(!(.7!%&SD7%*-!'B$'!
B$,*!Q**&/!$&=!?%##!1.&'%&D*!'.!Q*/!1$D-*=!Q+!>(#$1C-!D&$D'B.7%E*=!D-*!.(!FGH!<GICA!JIGK!
LH>8J/!%&!,%.#$'%.&!.(!'B*!U$&B$9!>1'!3!O!H2M282!VV!WO!!!"!#!$26!$&=!7*#$'*=!0##%&.%-!#$?-2!
0@A9D?9B;9C:!8:?!/>:@>!
O2 AB%-!8.D7'!B$-!:*7-.&$#!SD7%-=%1'%.&!.,*7!>(#$1!Q*1$D-*!>(#$1!B$-!*&;$;*=!%&!QD-%&*--!
$1'%,%'%*-!%&/!$&=!=%7*1'*=!'./!'B*!M'$'*!.(!0##%&.%-!$&=!?%'B%&!'B%-!)D=%1%$#!<%-'7%1'/!$&=!Q*1$D-*!
>(#$1!B$-!N&.?%&;#+!1.99%''*=!'.7'%.D-!$1'-!$%9*=!$'/!$&=!1$D-%&;!B$79!?%'B%&/!'B*!M'$'*!.(!
0##%&.%-!$&=!'B%-!)D=%1%$#!<%-'7%1'2!!
X2 AB%-!8.D7'!B$-!SD7%-=%1'%.&!.,*7!'B*!1#$%9-!%&!'B%-!8.9:#$%&'!:D7-D$&'!'.!!O!H2M282!V!!P!!
$&=!PY!H2M282!VV!RR!/!!RRY!$&=!!RXZ2!
Z2 [*&D*!%-!:7.:*7!%&!'B%-!)D=%1%$#!<%-'7%1'!D&=*7!PY!H2M282!V!R!3Q6!$&=!316!Q*1$D-*!
)*##+,%-%.&!$&=!>(#$1!7*-%=*!%&!'B%-!<%-'7%1'/!Q*1$D-*!)*##+,%-%.&!$&=!>(#$1!'7$&-$1'!QD-%&*--!%&!'B%-!
<%-'7%1'/!$&=!Q*1$D-*!$!-DQ-'$&'%$#!:$7'!.(!'B*!*,*&'-!;%,%&;!7%-*!'.!)*##+,%-%.&C-!1#$%9-!B$,*!
.11D77*=/!$&=!$7*!.11D77%&;/!?%'B%&!'B%-!<%-'7%1'2!]D7'B*79.7*/!'B*!=$9$;*!'.!)*##+,%-%.&!$&=!%'-!
%&'*##*1'D$#!:7.:*7'+!=*-17%Q*=!B*7*%&!1.&'%&D*-!'.!.11D7!%&!'B%-!<%-'7%1'2!
68A;9>D!
Y2 )*##+,%-%.&!%-!$&!0##%&.%-!1.7:.7$'%.&!?%'B!%'-!:7%&1%:$#!:#$1*!.(!QD-%&*--!%&!8B%1$;./!0##%&.%-2!
P!]()