New Right Theory
1990s and the New Right The New Right perspective developed in response to changes in the world that started in the 1960s and 1970s but continued into the 1980s and 1990s. These changes included: The decline in usefulness of the  concept of First, Second and Third world due to the increased diversity between countries in developing world The decline of Marxism in sociology The collapse of Soviet Union
Key Names and arguments in the New Right Milton  Friedman  and Peter  Bauer  influenced economic policy of  Thatcherism This emphasised  laissez-faire  (leave economic forces to do what they will or the economy will be damaged) and  Reaganism
Government interference in the market place will distort the balance of supply and demand.  (E.g. the regular giving of aid upsets the price of goods and supply of labour) The New Right say that:
Friedman argues that: Governments should not be involved in the economy except four main functions: Defence Law and Order The provision of the necessary public works that private enterprise does not find profitable to provide Protection from members of the community who ‘cannot be regarded as ‘responsible individuals’
Peter Bauer (British  development economist)  Bauer advocates a wider range of functions for governments: The basic provision for health and education The management of the monetary and fiscal (taxation/spending) system
Friedman and Bauer argue that: The production, distribution and trade of goods and services are best left to private (profit making) rather than public (government owned and regulated) organisations The free market will regulate itself and lead to increased economic growth e.g. as in Hong Kong.  Government central planning fails to raise living standards But critics say this is not the case with Sweden and former Soviet Union which have been successful
New Right say that regular aid does  not  assist development as it distorts the free market process because:  if a development project is economically viable then private enterprise would be willing to invest in it on a commercial basis. If not then the project should not be undertaken. regular aid often end up up in the wrong hands and benefits the wealthy rather than the country’s needy
Impact of Friedman and Bauer Their approach has had little support even by conservatives, as regular aid is still given However : It is increasingly linked to the acceptance of democratic and free market reforms.  EG. Multi-lateral and lateral aid providers link aid in return for certain economic conditions such as ‘structural adjustments’ Aid in return for certain conditions is known as conditionality
Chomsky (1999) argues that - “The neo liberal (New Right) global order is concerned with minimising the role of the state” by doing this: Power is transferred from democratically elected representatives towards financial and business elites The conditionality of aid could be seen as morally unacceptable as well as counterproductive

Sociology - The New Right

  • 1.
  • 2.
    1990s and theNew Right The New Right perspective developed in response to changes in the world that started in the 1960s and 1970s but continued into the 1980s and 1990s. These changes included: The decline in usefulness of the concept of First, Second and Third world due to the increased diversity between countries in developing world The decline of Marxism in sociology The collapse of Soviet Union
  • 3.
    Key Names andarguments in the New Right Milton Friedman and Peter Bauer influenced economic policy of Thatcherism This emphasised laissez-faire (leave economic forces to do what they will or the economy will be damaged) and Reaganism
  • 4.
    Government interference inthe market place will distort the balance of supply and demand. (E.g. the regular giving of aid upsets the price of goods and supply of labour) The New Right say that:
  • 5.
    Friedman argues that:Governments should not be involved in the economy except four main functions: Defence Law and Order The provision of the necessary public works that private enterprise does not find profitable to provide Protection from members of the community who ‘cannot be regarded as ‘responsible individuals’
  • 6.
    Peter Bauer (British development economist) Bauer advocates a wider range of functions for governments: The basic provision for health and education The management of the monetary and fiscal (taxation/spending) system
  • 7.
    Friedman and Bauerargue that: The production, distribution and trade of goods and services are best left to private (profit making) rather than public (government owned and regulated) organisations The free market will regulate itself and lead to increased economic growth e.g. as in Hong Kong. Government central planning fails to raise living standards But critics say this is not the case with Sweden and former Soviet Union which have been successful
  • 8.
    New Right saythat regular aid does not assist development as it distorts the free market process because: if a development project is economically viable then private enterprise would be willing to invest in it on a commercial basis. If not then the project should not be undertaken. regular aid often end up up in the wrong hands and benefits the wealthy rather than the country’s needy
  • 9.
    Impact of Friedmanand Bauer Their approach has had little support even by conservatives, as regular aid is still given However : It is increasingly linked to the acceptance of democratic and free market reforms. EG. Multi-lateral and lateral aid providers link aid in return for certain economic conditions such as ‘structural adjustments’ Aid in return for certain conditions is known as conditionality
  • 10.
    Chomsky (1999) arguesthat - “The neo liberal (New Right) global order is concerned with minimising the role of the state” by doing this: Power is transferred from democratically elected representatives towards financial and business elites The conditionality of aid could be seen as morally unacceptable as well as counterproductive