SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Steve Beaton, CIA, CISA, CFSA, MsMIT, USAA VP IA
Robert Koehler, CGEIT, PgMP, PMP, MsPM, PwC Director
Slide 2
TOPIC
We will explore the essential elements for preparing an
assurance framework for IT Governance that integrates
leading industry standards and practices ensuring the
governing objectives for assessing strategy, financial
performance, and effective delivery of technology.
Slide 3
KEY BENEFITS TO THE AUDIENCE
• We will highlight the leading IT Governance standards, drawing
comparison between their similarities and differences.
• We will highlight the business areas not adequately addressed
by IT Governance standards.
• We will recommend internal controls that pertain to aligning the
relationships between the business and IT, including
organizational structures for the evaluation and direction of IT.
• We will recommend internal controls that pertain to the
effectiveness of deriving value from IT, including financial
performance and the planning for benefits realization.
• We will recommend internal controls that pertain to the
effectiveness of IT risk and compliance management, including
what can be done to ensure sufficient IT risk information is
factored into investment decision making.
Slide 4
CURRENT STATE OF IT GOVERNANCE
We will highlight the leading IT Governance standards, drawing
comparison between their similarities and differences.
• What are leaders saying about it?
• Whose definition is best?
• How is IA’s role perceived?
• Where are the rabbit holes?
Slide 5
CURRENT STATE OF IT GOVERNANCE
IN THE NEWS
Oversight split between the
Board, Audit Committee, IT/Risk
Committees or no one at all.
- PwC, Insights from the
Boardroom 2012
Only 30% of directors find IT expertise a “very
important” attribute in new directors, and 31%
are not seeking this skill set at all.
- PwC’s 2013 Annual Corporate Directors
Survey
44-50% of Board members meet with
the CIO only once a year or not at all.
- PwC, Insights from the Boardroom
2012
Only 38% of business partners seen
as “very engaged” in IT Governance.
- Forrester, The State Of IT
Governance Q4 2010
The findings of a number of research projects conducted by the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Center for
Information Systems Research (CISR) suggest that firms with
focused strategies and above-average IT governance
capabilities had more than 20 percent higher profits than other
firms following the same strategies.
- Peter Weill and Jeanne W. Ross, It governance, how top
performers manage it decisions for superior results, Harvard
Business School Press
Effective IT governance is the single most
important predictor of the value an organization
generates from IT.
- Peter Weill and Jeanne W. Ross, It
governance, how top performers manage it
decisions for superior results, Harvard Business
School Press
Slide 6
COMPARING IT GOVERNANCE STANDARDS
WHOSE DEFINITION IS BEST?
• ISACA – The responsibility of executives and the board of directors; consists of
the leadership, organizational structures and processes that ensure that the
enterprise’s IT sustains and extends the enterprise’s strategies and objectives.
• ISO – The system by which the current and future use of IT is directed and
controlled. Corporate governance of IT involves evaluating and directing the use of
IT to support the organization and monitoring this use to achieve plans. It includes
the strategy and policies for using IT within an organization.
• Gartner – The set of processes that ensure the effective and efficient use of IT in
enabling an organization to achieve its goals.
• Forrester – A decision-making framework for IT investments that is designed to
maximize the return of benefits while managing risk to acceptable levels.
• MIT CISR – Specifying the decision rights and accountability framework to
encourage desirable behavior in using IT.
Slide 7
ARE STAKEHOLDERS SATISFIED?
AREAS OF LEAST SATISFACTION WITH IA
Slide 8
COMPARING IT GOVERNANCE STANDARDS
STANDARDS OVERLAPPING, EVEN CONFLICTING
The challenge is choosing right and filling in the gaps as many
standards are overlapping, even conflicting – None complete
IT GovernanceProject Management
Process
Centric
Maturity
Centric
PMI/PMBOK
ITIL
IT Management
Val IT 2.0
Risk IT
COBIT 5SEI CMMI
ISO 38500TOGAF
ISO 17998
COBIT 4
ISO 27001/2/5
MoV
ISO 31000
MIT CISR
PRINCE2
Most relevant
standards
Slide 9
COMPARING IT GOVERNANCE STANDARDS
RIGHT SPECTRUM FOR COMPARISON
Five dimensions of comparison used, each having a common focus
on an organizations ability to drive greater value from IT
Strategic Alignment
•The successful alignment between business and IT
•The comprehension of the impacts of IT on business processes and results
•The clarity of priorities for both IT investments and business management focus
Financial Performance
•The effectiveness of deriving value from IT across the first and second lines of defense
•The comprehension of performance as predictors of strategic decision-making
•The comprehension of factors to measure and regulate the effectiveness of controls for risk and compliance
Risk & Compliance
•The establishment or risk, compliance, security and legal authority
•The alignment of risk and compliance decisions with responsibilities for performance
•The level of process integration across IT governance, risk, and compliance
Grow & Transform
•The level IT investments contribute to optimal business value
•The level collaboration occurs between business and IT to realize benefits
•The provision of investment management controls across the economic lives of investments
Delivery Management
•The determination of how types of IT-enabled capabilities are chosen as important for success
•The decision driven actions to set objectives and expectations for the performance of IT
•The position to handle the costs and risk of the service portfolios
Slide 10
COMPARING IT GOVERNANCE STANDARDS
MAPPING TO LEADING PRACTICES
Strategic Alignment
Financial
Performance
Delivery
Risk & Compliance Grow &Transform Delivery Mgmt.
• COBIT APO08
Manage
Relationships
• COBIT EDM01
Ensure Governance
Framework Setting
and Maintenance
• COBIT EDM04
Ensure Resource
Optimization
• ITIL Strategy –
Strategy and
Organization
• ITIL Strategy –
Demand
Management
• IIA GTAG 17 –
Auditing IT
Governance
• ISO/IEC 38500:
2008–Corporate
Governance of
Information
Technology
• COBIT MEA01
Monitor, Evaluate
and Assess
Performance and
Conformance
• EDM05 Ensure
Stakeholder
Transparency
• COBIT APO06
Manage Budget
and Costs
• ITIL Strategy –
Financial
Management
• ITIL Strategy –
Return on
Investment
• ISO/IEC 38500:
2008–Corporate
Governance of
Information
Technology
• COBIT EDM03
Ensure Risk
Optimization
• COBIT MEA03
Monitor, Evaluate
and Assess
Compliance with
External
Requirements
• COBIT DSS05
Manage Security
Services
• ISO/IEC 31000–
Risk Management
• ISO/IEC 27000–
Security Techniques
• Multiple industry
based requirements
such as: HIPPA,
AML, Dodd Frank,
PCI, FISMA,
Sarbanes Oxley and
Safe Harbour
• COBIT APO04
Manage Innovation
• COBIT APO05
Manage Portfolio
• COBIT EDM02
Ensure Benefits
Delivery
• ITIL Strategy –
Service Portfolio
Management
• Project Management
Book of Knowledge
(PMBOK)
• Projects in
Controlled
Environments
(PRINCE 2)
• Portfolio, Program,
and Project
Management
Maturity Model
(P3M3)
• ITIL Strategy–
Strategy, Tactics,
and Operations
• COBIT APO02
Manage Strategy
• COBIT APO03
Manage Enterprise
Architecture
• The Open Group
Architecture
Framework
(TOGAF)
• ISO/IEC 20000–IT
Service
Management
Slide 11
AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED
We will highlight the business areas not adequately addressed
by IT Governance standards.
• Is IT on the boards agenda?
• Does corporate strategy influence IT?
• Is the value gap being closed?
• Does the three lines of defense help IT Governance?
• Is IT Governance, Risk and Compliance combined?
• Are business benefits being realized?
Slide 12
AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED
IT ON THE BOARD’S AGENDA
A structured approach for board’s IT oversight:
• Assessment: Evaluate the company’s current IT situation, while considering
various factors, and conclude how critical IT is to the company’s current and
future success.
• Approach: Agree on the board's IT oversight approach including who is
responsible (the full board, the audit committee, a risk committee, etc.), how
often to discuss IT, and when to talk with the CIO.
• Prioritization: Identify the IT subjects most relevant to the company and focus
oversight efforts on those areas.
• Strategy: "Bake" IT initiatives into the board’s oversight of overall company
strategy based on the importance of IT to the company.
• Risk: Include IT risks as part of the board’s risk management oversight process.
• Monitoring: Adopt a continuous IT oversight process, regularly revisit the
efficacy of that process, and measure results.
Slide 13
AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED
CASCADING CORPORATE STRATEGY
Need to evaluate the IT strategy within the overall strategy
for the business
Business
Strategy
(3-5 yr plan)
IT Strategy
Digital
Business
Model
• Frames how IT & technology enables
business capabilities
• Sets expectations for scalability &
interoperability
• Provides principles & standards that
guide technology decisions
• Prioritizes immediate IT challenges
that need resolution
• Identifies synergies across entities
• Identifies digital business model
capabilities
• Measures effectiveness of digital
content, experience, and platform
• Identifies digital source of competitive
advantage
BusinessDrivenITStrategy
• Develops a target state and future vision
that synchronizes IT investments with
business needs
• Creates a blueprint for maximizing return
on technology investments
• Establish guiding principles that will
drive the technology evolution
Strategy &
business
alignment
Organization
& skills
Technology
& architecture
Management
& Governance
Information
Product
Customer
Experience
Internal
External
The Digital Business Model describes
how content, experience, and platform
works together to create a compelling
customer value proposition.
The Business Strategy describes and
interrelates mission, vision, goals, and
strategies with core processes,
constituents, and interactions.
Slide 14
AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED
CLOSING THE VALUE GAP
While many companies fail to deliver business value, top performers deliver
the expected value (+15%), on time (+30%) at or below budget (+30%)
ACTUAL ROI = -4%
Value RealizedPlan Actual Execution
Benefits
Only 38% of programs
delivered 100% of value
Time
Only 36% of programs
are delivered on time
Value
(200)
Cost
(100)
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3
3 Year
Plan
Value
(125)
Extra
Year
4 Year
Actual
Value
Gap
Cost
(130)
Over Cost
PLAN ROI=50% The Value Gap
-$60M
-$15M
+$30M
EXAMPLE:
Time Increase: 30%
Cost Increase: 30%
Value Loss: 30%
($M)
IMPACT
($M)
Slide 15
AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED
THREE LINES OF DEFENSE
Clear delineation between line controls, second-level monitoring
controls and third-line independent assurance for the effective
governance of information technology
Board of Directors / Audit Committee
Business and IT Senior Management
Regulator
1st Line of Defense
ExternalAudit
3rd Line of Defense2nd Line of Defense
Internal Control
Measures
IT Governance
Mechanisms
Financial Controls
Risk Management
Compliance
Portfolio Performance
Program Governance
Security
Internal Audit
Project Assurance
Slide 16
AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED
IT GRC INTEGRATION
IT Governance, risk management and compliance managed in
an integrated manner
IT Compliance
Committee
Audit Committees
Evaluate
Direct
Report
Monitor
IT governance Risk Management Compliance
IT Governance
Committee
IT Steering
Committee
PMO /
Portfolio
Management
Objective Setting
Risk Assessment
Event
Identification
Risk Response
Control Activities
Information &
Communication
Monitoring
Requirement
Analysis
Deviation
Analysis
Deficiency
Management
Reporting /
Documentation
Deviation
Analysis
Enterprise & IT
Risk Committees
Slide 17
AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED
BENEFITS REALIZATION
The benefits expected from IT are unlikely to emerge automatically.
Any benefits sought must be identified along with the changes in
ways of working to bring about and sustain each of the benefits.
Means to Achieve Changes
Evaluate overall vision
for the new digital solution
Ways to Achieve Changes
Evaluate the new ways of doing business
and the benefits this will deliver
Results of Changes
Evaluate how fostering and realizing
business benefits will come through
structured change
Benefits
Identification
Business
Case
Benefits
Planning
Project
Delivery
User
Adoption
Value
Creation
Benefits
Extension
Benefits
Fulfillment
Slide 18
BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK
We will recommend internal controls.
• Where should we focus our attention?
• What IT-related domains should be controlled?
• What controls should comprise each domain?
Slide 19
BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK
EXECUTIVE AGREEMENT ON ROLE OF IT
Align with management’s active design of IT Governance around
the business’ objectives and performance goals.
•Strategic Aims
•Stewardship
•IT Reliance
•Firm Performance
•Economic Life & Reward
•Strategic Aims
•Stewardship
•IT Reliance
•Firm Performance
•Economic Life & Reward
Corporate GovernanceCorporate Governance
•Strategic Aims
•Stewardship
•IT Reliance
•Firm Performance
•Economic Life & Reward
Corporate Governance
•Financial Objectives
•Customer Needs
•Process Improvements
•Organizational Learns
•Financial Objectives
•Customer Needs
•Process Improvements
•Organizational Learns
Performance MgmtPerformance Mgmt
•Financial Objectives
•Customer Needs
•Process Improvements
•Organizational Learns
Performance Mgmt
•Service Levels
•Resource Profiles
•Workforce Planning
•Learning & Development
•Service Levels
•Resource Profiles
•Workforce Planning
•Learning & Development
Resource ManagementResource Management
•Service Levels
•Resource Profiles
•Workforce Planning
•Learning & Development
Resource Management
•Risk Transparency
•Risk Delegation
•Risk Control
•Operational Risk
•Risk Transparency
•Risk Delegation
•Risk Control
•Operational Risk
Risk ManagementRisk Management
•Risk Transparency
•Risk Delegation
•Risk Control
•Operational Risk
Risk Management
•Strategic Importance
•Environmental Context
•Financial Planning
•IT Capabilities
•IT Resources
•Strategic Importance
•Environmental Context
•Financial Planning
•IT Capabilities
•IT Resources
Strategic AlignmentStrategic Alignment
•Strategic Importance
•Environmental Context
•Financial Planning
•IT Capabilities
•IT Resources
Strategic Alignment
•Regulatory Compliance
•Internal Controls
•IT Security
•Compliance Policies
•Regulatory Compliance
•Internal Controls
•IT Security
•Compliance Policies
IT ComplianceIT Compliance
•Regulatory Compliance
•Internal Controls
•IT Security
•Compliance Policies
IT Compliance
IT
Governance
Executive Agreement
on the Role of IT
Slide 20
BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK
TOP-DOWN BOTTOM-UP PROCESS
Proper integration of management and support functions must be
considered when creating the assessment framework
Project Work
and Resource
Authorizations
Change
Requirements
and Risk Mitigates
Performance
Measurements
Corporate
Risk Management
Service Levels
and
Finished Products
Professional and
Operational
Services
Investment
Management
IT Strategy,
Vision, and
Action Plans
Program
Health Updates
Benefits
Realization
Time-Sensitive
Growth / Recovery
Strategies
IT
Governance
IT
Services
Project
Portfolio
Management
Corporate
Governance
Top-Down
Evaluation & Direction
Bottom-Up
Monitoring & Reporting
Slide 21
BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK
HOLISTIC VIEW
Encompassing these arrangements to create a holistic view of the
governance, management, and use of IT
Business
Strategy
Organization
Structures
Digital
Business
Models
IT Asset
Portfolios
Performance
and Change
Metrics
IT Service
Valuation
IT Risk
Management
IT Compliance
Security
Governance
IT Service
Strategy
IT Long-term
Strategy
Portfolio &
Project Delivery
Operations
Benefits
Realization
Architecture
Strategic Alignment
Financial Performance
Risk & Compliance
Grow & Transform
Service Management
Delivery Management
Slide 22
BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK
STRATEGIC ALIGNMENT
Business Strategy Digital Business Models Organization Structures
• Clear alignment is visible
between Corporate and IT
Strategy.
• Business strategy changes
are understood, documented
and approved with their
impact on IT communicated.
• Good relationships and
communication channels
exist between the business
and IT.
• Business stakeholders are
aware of technology-
enabled opportunities.
• Business plans, operating
models and requirements
are understood, documented
and approved with their
impact on IT communicated.
• Impacts of expected future
demand are understood and
built into IT planning.
• Strategic decision-making
model for IT is effective and
aligned with the
organization’s internal and
external environment and
stakeholder requirements.
• The governance system &
bodies for IT are
implemented and operating
effectively.
• Organizational structures
are aligned with strategic
value drivers.
• The resource needs of the
organization are met with
the right capabilities.
• Resources are allocated to
best meet the overall
business priorities within
budget constraints.
• Optimal use of resources is
achieved throughout their
full economic life cycles.
Slide 23
BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK
FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE
IT Service Valuation IT Asset Portfolio
Performance &
Change Metrics
• Processes are measured
against agreed-on goals
and metrics.
• Goals and metrics are
approved by the
stakeholders.
• Owners are assigned and
held accountable.
• Investment decisions are
linked to value that can be
tracked.
• An appropriate investment
mix is defined and aligned
with business strategy.
• Program business cases
are evaluated and
prioritized before funds are
allocated.
• Sources of investment
funding are identified and
available.
• Current accounting
evaluation process for
justifying an IT investment is
sufficient for managing
investment risk.
• Returns are measured
across the economic life of
the investment.
• Performance measures
include profitability,
productivity and
effectiveness.
• Goals and metrics are
integrated within the
organization’s monitoring
systems.
• Process reporting on
performance and
conformance is useful and
timely.
Slide 24
BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK
RISK & COMPLIANCE
IT Risk Management IT Compliance Security Governance
• Risk appetite is defined at
the organizational level and
cascaded to IT.
• Risk thresholds are defined
and communicated while
key IT-related risks are
known.
• The organization is
managing critical IT-related
risk to the business
effectively and efficiently.
• IT-related risk does not
exceed risk appetite and the
impact of IT risk to business
value is identified and
managed.
• All compliance obligations
are identified.
• Compliance obligations are
adequately addressed.
• The organization seeks to
proactively manage
compliance obligations
through the use of
technology.
• Network and
communications security
meet business needs.
• Information processed on,
stored on and transmitted by
endpoint devices is
protected.
• All users are uniquely
identifiable and have access
rights in accordance with
their business role.
• Physical measures have
been implemented to protect
information from
unauthorized access,
damage and interference
when being processed,
stored or transmitted.
• Electronic information is
properly secured when
stored, transmitted or
destroyed.
Slide 25
BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK
GROW & TRANSFORM
IT Long-term Strategy
Portfolio &
Project Delivery
Benefits Realization
• Business value is created
through the qualification and
staging of the most
appropriate advances and
innovations in technology, IT
methods and solutions.
• Business objectives are met
with improved quality
benefits and/or reduced cost
as a result of the
identification and
implementation of innovative
solutions.
• Innovation is promoted and
enabled and forms part of
the business culture.
• As solutions are developed
the business case is
updated to reflect any
changes.
• A comprehensive and
accurate view of the
investment portfolio(s)
performance exists.
• Investment program
changes are reflected in the
relevant IT service, asset
and resource portfolios.
• Robust project and program
management practices.
• Transparency into project
and program progress.
• The business is securing
optimal value from its
portfolio of approved IT-
enabled initiatives, services
and assets.
• Optimal value is derived
from IT investment through
effective value management
practices in the business.
• Individual IT-enabled
investments contribute
optimal value.
• Benefits have been realized
due to benefits
management.
Slide 26
BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK
SERVICE MANAGEMENT
IT Service Strategy IT Operations IT Architecture
• All aspects of the service
strategy are aligned with the
broader corporate strategy.
• The IT strategy is cost-
effective, appropriate,
realistic, achievable,
business-focused and
balanced.
• Clear and concrete short-
term goals can be derived
from, and traced back to,
specific long-term initiatives,
and can then be translated
into operational plans.
• IT is a value driver for the
business.
• There is awareness of the
service strategy and a clear
assignment of accountability
for delivery.
• Achieve effectiveness and
efficiency in the delivery and
support of services.
• Strategic objectives are
ultimately realized through
service operations.
• Stability in service
operations is maintained,
allowing for changes in
design, scale, scope, and
service levels.
• The architecture and
standards are effective in
supporting the business.
• A portfolio of business
architecture services
supports agile business
change.
• Appropriate and up-to-date
domain and/or federated
architectures exist that
provide reliable architecture
information.
• A common business
architecture framework and
methodology as well as an
integrated architecture
repository are used to
enable re-use efficiencies
across the business.
Slide 27
EXECUTING THE AUDIT
• Is your audit approach risk-based?
• What is the workflow for the audit?
• How should risks be classified?
• Who should participate in the audit?
• What information should be requested?
Slide 28
EXECUTING THE AUDIT
AUDIT APPROACH
Take a consultative approach to assuring IT Governance.
Assess
Assess your capability
and maturity with a
wide range of industry
standards and best
practice frameworks
Evaluate
Measure your
performance in order
to establish your
current baseline
Benchmark
Compare your direction
with that of your peers
using extensive global
benchmarking data
• Alignment
• Value
• Risk
• Resource
• Performance
• Evaluate execution
management
• Organizational
structures
• Governing
processes
• Relational
mechanisms
• Maturity models
• IT strategies
• Digital business
designs
• IT investment
areas and levels
Recommend
Provide practical
recommendations for
your consideration and
selection for making
improvements
• Decision rights &
accountability
• Process maturity
• Performance
ratios
• Priorities
Slide 29
EXECUTING THE AUDIT
AUDIT APPROACH, CONTINUED
Step 1 – Assess
Conduct an assessment through
executive and senior
management and business leader
interviews, roundtables, and
surveys and examine
documentation to compare IT
practices against the framework
in the areas of alignment, value,
risk, resource, and performance.
Analyse critical IT practices and
prioritize risk to communicate the
risk exposure based on stated
objectives.
The key to assuring IT is to
understand the culture and
priorities in both the business and
IT; this will ensure that IT is
aligned with the overall business
strategy, and that the IT strategy
drives controls, policies, budgets,
risk tolerance, and service levels.
Step 2 – Evaluate/Compare
Leverage the results of Step 1 to
evaluate and define the current
condition of IT practice indicators
that will be used to assess
achievement of the expectations
expressed in the IT Governance
framework.
Continue this evaluation by
comparing your direction with that
of your peers using extensive
global benchmarking data.
[Optional]
Step 3 – Recommend
Through the analysis of strengths
and weaknesses, the prior steps
provide the information to prepare
practical recommendations and
actions to improve the outcomes
and performance of enterprise IT.
Throughout the assessment,
provide improvement
recommendations based on the
evaluation documentation and
discussions with executive and
senior management. At any time
you identify an item that requires
immediate attention by
management, communicate such
item.
Slide 30
EXECUTING THE AUDIT
AUDIT WORKFLOW
Tasks / Milestones Duration
Project Start-up / Finalize Statement of Work Week 1 – Week 2
1. Kick-off Meeting
2. Begin Scheduling Interviews
3. Publish Initial Information Request
4. Establish Goals, Objectives, and Drivers for Assessment
5. Determine Comparison Baselines from Past IT Audits / Changes
6. Propose Custom Framework for Assessment
7. Obtain Approval for Proposal, Timeline, and Initial Resources
8. Establish Assessment Infrastructure to Coordinate Activities
9. Publish Goals and Guiding Principles of Assessment
10. Update Interview Calendar
11. Launch Assessment
Slide 31
EXECUTING THE AUDIT
AUDIT WORKFLOW, CONTINUED
Tasks / Milestones Duration
Perform Assessment Week 3 – Week 4
1. Finalize Categories / Process Areas for Custom Framework
2. Build Custom Framework
3. Publish Updated Information Request
4. Conduct Assessment and Characterize Current Practice
5. Develop Audit Themes and Begin Socializing with Senior Management
6. Develop Recommendations and Document Results
7. Identify Improvement Strategy and Priorities
Prepare / Deliver Draft Report Week 5 – Week 5
Prepare / Deliver Final Report Week 6 – Week 6
Plan Improvement (Optional) Week 7 – Week 8
1. Understand Short-/Long-Term Planned Improvement Efforts
2. Identify Roles/Responsibilities of Improvement/Audit Programs
3. Reconcile Existing/Planned Improvements with the Assessment Baseline
4. Prepare Performance Measurement Plan
5. Create Strategic Improvement Program
Slide 32
EXECUTING THE AUDIT
CLASSIFY IT RISK
Factor IT Risk within the ERM process to help ensure IT decision-
makers know how much IT Risk is acceptable.
Significance
Likelihood
10
98
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
11
12
13
14
15
1. Enterprise IT Strategy
2. Digital Business Designs
3. Organizational Structures
4. Enterprise Architecture
5. IT Service Valuation
6. IT Investment Portfolios
7. IT Performance
8. IT Risk Management
9. IT Compliance
10. Security Governance
11. Service Strategy
12. Project Delivery
13. Benefits Realization
14. IT Operations
15. Price Performance
Slide 33
EXECUTING THE AUDIT
IDENTIFYING PARTICIPANTS
Technology
• Heads IT Operations
• Heads IT Development
• Chief Technology Officer
• Chief Architect
• Chief Information Officer
• Chief Information Security Officer
• Heads IT PMOs
Business
• Chief Risk Officer
• Business Leaders
• Chief Financial Officer
• IT Spokesperson on the Board
• Heads Enterprise PMO
Survey
• Frontline and Middle Management
The audit involves executives, senior management, and business
leader interviews and possibly surveying frontline and business
management.
Slide 34
EXECUTING THE AUDIT
INFORMATION REQUESTS
• IT strategy documentation
• IT scorecards
• IT policies
• IT financial management documentation, including: financing and budgeting,
asset management, contract management, and resource plans
• Service level agreements (SLAs)
• Any utilized governance or maturity frameworks and models
• IT compliance and training requirements
• Governance processes documentation
The following information should be requested to understand IT
Governance practices:
Slide 35
QUESTIONS & ANSWERS
Slide 36
YOUR SPEAKERS
Steve Beaton
Vice President
Bank Audit Services
Robert Koehler
Director
Risk Assurance Services
Steve is Vice President of Bank Audit Services at
USAA, where he leads audit coverage of bank
operations. Previously he led IT/Security Audit
Services, supporting the full range of engagements
specific to IT/Security. Prior to joining USAA, Steve
was Vice President of IT Audit at Freddie Mac.
Steve is a seasoned internal audit and risk
management executive with diverse leadership
experience within financial services including TD
BankNorth, Fifth Third Bank, Sunlife Financial, and
Bank of Ireland.
Steve holds a bachelor of business administration
from Merrimack College in Massachusetts and a
master’s degree in management of information
technology from the McIntire School of Commerce
at the University of Virginia. He is a Certified Internal
Auditor (CIA), Certified Information Systems Auditor
(CISA) and Certified Financial Services Auditor
(CFSA).
Robert is a Director at PwC. Over the last 30 years, as
a consulting executive and provider, he has purchased,
sold, managed, and delivered extensive global IT
consulting services involving Oracle, SAP, and
Microsoft enterprise software suites. He has led
numerous global business transformations, and the
PMOs, IT asset portfolios, and project management
practices of leading firms. His specialties are in
assuming responsibility for and leading client services
in need of performance gains, improved client relations,
and growth across numerous industries and the
Government.
Robert has earned a M.S. in Management, Project
Management Specialty from Boston University and a
B.S. in Administration and Management from La Roche
College. He holds the professional certifications of
Program Management Professional (PgMP), Project
Management Professional (PMP), and Certified in the
Governance of Enterprise IT (CGEIT).
steven.beaton@usaa.com
(210) 249-1309
robert.j.koehler@us.pwc.com
(505) 417-7689

More Related Content

What's hot

What Is It Governance Introduction
What Is It Governance   IntroductionWhat Is It Governance   Introduction
What Is It Governance Introduction
nicxenos
 
IT Governance Introduction
IT Governance  IntroductionIT Governance  Introduction
IT Governance Introduction
Keith Rackley
 
IT Governances
IT GovernancesIT Governances
IT Governances
Jerald Burget
 
EFFECTIVE IT GOVERNANCE presentation
EFFECTIVE IT GOVERNANCE presentationEFFECTIVE IT GOVERNANCE presentation
EFFECTIVE IT GOVERNANCE presentation
S L
 
Executive's Handbook on IT Strategy and Governance
Executive's Handbook on IT Strategy and GovernanceExecutive's Handbook on IT Strategy and Governance
Executive's Handbook on IT Strategy and Governance
Kuda Musundire CA (Z), RPA
 
What Every Executive Needs To Know About IT Governance
What Every Executive Needs To Know About IT GovernanceWhat Every Executive Needs To Know About IT Governance
What Every Executive Needs To Know About IT Governance
Bill Lisse
 
IT Governance Concept
IT Governance ConceptIT Governance Concept
IT Governance Concept
itgproduct
 
Understanding IT Governance and Risk Management
Understanding IT Governance and Risk ManagementUnderstanding IT Governance and Risk Management
Understanding IT Governance and Risk Management
jiricejka
 
IT Governance Overview
IT Governance OverviewIT Governance Overview
IT Governance Overview
Jim Sutter
 
IT Governance Presentation
IT Governance PresentationIT Governance Presentation
IT Governance Presentation
jmcarden
 
IT Governance
IT GovernanceIT Governance
IT Governance
Carlos Chalico
 
[MU630] 002. IT Strategic Planning
[MU630] 002. IT Strategic Planning[MU630] 002. IT Strategic Planning
[MU630] 002. IT Strategic Planning
AriantoMuditomo
 
IT Governance Vs IT Management Presentation V0.1
IT Governance Vs IT Management   Presentation V0.1IT Governance Vs IT Management   Presentation V0.1
IT Governance Vs IT Management Presentation V0.1
Richard Willis
 
IT Strategic Planning Guide
IT Strategic Planning GuideIT Strategic Planning Guide
IT Strategic Planning Guide
Mary Patry
 
What is IT Governance?
What is IT Governance?What is IT Governance?
What is IT Governance?
Mansoor Adenwala
 
Stateofthecio2008 1210987739793979 8
Stateofthecio2008 1210987739793979 8Stateofthecio2008 1210987739793979 8
Stateofthecio2008 1210987739793979 8
Balaji Balasubramanian
 
IT Governance - OpenThinking Day
IT Governance - OpenThinking DayIT Governance - OpenThinking Day
IT Governance - OpenThinking Day
Iyad Mourtada, CMA, CIA, CFE, CCSA, CRMA, CPLP
 
2 -governanca_de_tic_-_uma_visao_do_mercado_gartner_-_claudio_chauke
2  -governanca_de_tic_-_uma_visao_do_mercado_gartner_-_claudio_chauke2  -governanca_de_tic_-_uma_visao_do_mercado_gartner_-_claudio_chauke
2 -governanca_de_tic_-_uma_visao_do_mercado_gartner_-_claudio_chauke
Mayk Campelo
 
PECB Webinar: Aligning COBIT 5.0 and ISO/IEC 38500
PECB Webinar: Aligning COBIT 5.0 and ISO/IEC 38500PECB Webinar: Aligning COBIT 5.0 and ISO/IEC 38500
PECB Webinar: Aligning COBIT 5.0 and ISO/IEC 38500
PECB
 
It governance
It governanceIt governance

What's hot (20)

What Is It Governance Introduction
What Is It Governance   IntroductionWhat Is It Governance   Introduction
What Is It Governance Introduction
 
IT Governance Introduction
IT Governance  IntroductionIT Governance  Introduction
IT Governance Introduction
 
IT Governances
IT GovernancesIT Governances
IT Governances
 
EFFECTIVE IT GOVERNANCE presentation
EFFECTIVE IT GOVERNANCE presentationEFFECTIVE IT GOVERNANCE presentation
EFFECTIVE IT GOVERNANCE presentation
 
Executive's Handbook on IT Strategy and Governance
Executive's Handbook on IT Strategy and GovernanceExecutive's Handbook on IT Strategy and Governance
Executive's Handbook on IT Strategy and Governance
 
What Every Executive Needs To Know About IT Governance
What Every Executive Needs To Know About IT GovernanceWhat Every Executive Needs To Know About IT Governance
What Every Executive Needs To Know About IT Governance
 
IT Governance Concept
IT Governance ConceptIT Governance Concept
IT Governance Concept
 
Understanding IT Governance and Risk Management
Understanding IT Governance and Risk ManagementUnderstanding IT Governance and Risk Management
Understanding IT Governance and Risk Management
 
IT Governance Overview
IT Governance OverviewIT Governance Overview
IT Governance Overview
 
IT Governance Presentation
IT Governance PresentationIT Governance Presentation
IT Governance Presentation
 
IT Governance
IT GovernanceIT Governance
IT Governance
 
[MU630] 002. IT Strategic Planning
[MU630] 002. IT Strategic Planning[MU630] 002. IT Strategic Planning
[MU630] 002. IT Strategic Planning
 
IT Governance Vs IT Management Presentation V0.1
IT Governance Vs IT Management   Presentation V0.1IT Governance Vs IT Management   Presentation V0.1
IT Governance Vs IT Management Presentation V0.1
 
IT Strategic Planning Guide
IT Strategic Planning GuideIT Strategic Planning Guide
IT Strategic Planning Guide
 
What is IT Governance?
What is IT Governance?What is IT Governance?
What is IT Governance?
 
Stateofthecio2008 1210987739793979 8
Stateofthecio2008 1210987739793979 8Stateofthecio2008 1210987739793979 8
Stateofthecio2008 1210987739793979 8
 
IT Governance - OpenThinking Day
IT Governance - OpenThinking DayIT Governance - OpenThinking Day
IT Governance - OpenThinking Day
 
2 -governanca_de_tic_-_uma_visao_do_mercado_gartner_-_claudio_chauke
2  -governanca_de_tic_-_uma_visao_do_mercado_gartner_-_claudio_chauke2  -governanca_de_tic_-_uma_visao_do_mercado_gartner_-_claudio_chauke
2 -governanca_de_tic_-_uma_visao_do_mercado_gartner_-_claudio_chauke
 
PECB Webinar: Aligning COBIT 5.0 and ISO/IEC 38500
PECB Webinar: Aligning COBIT 5.0 and ISO/IEC 38500PECB Webinar: Aligning COBIT 5.0 and ISO/IEC 38500
PECB Webinar: Aligning COBIT 5.0 and ISO/IEC 38500
 
It governance
It governanceIt governance
It governance
 

Similar to Sharpening the Lens

IT Governance Presentation by omaha 2008
IT Governance Presentation by  omaha 2008IT Governance Presentation by  omaha 2008
IT Governance Presentation by omaha 2008
ssusera19f45
 
MAKING SENSE OF IT GOVERNANCE
MAKING SENSE OF IT GOVERNANCEMAKING SENSE OF IT GOVERNANCE
MAKING SENSE OF IT GOVERNANCE
Rudy Shoushany
 
Gaining and Maintaining IT & Business Alignment.pptx
Gaining and Maintaining IT & Business Alignment.pptxGaining and Maintaining IT & Business Alignment.pptx
Gaining and Maintaining IT & Business Alignment.pptx
Robert Sheesley, CBA, CPHIMS
 
Critical Success Factors (CSFs) for Effective IT Governance Implementations
Critical Success Factors (CSFs) for Effective IT Governance ImplementationsCritical Success Factors (CSFs) for Effective IT Governance Implementations
Critical Success Factors (CSFs) for Effective IT Governance Implementations
Rachid Meziani, PhD, CGEIT, PMP
 
Understanding IT Strategy, Sourcing and Vendor Relationships
Understanding IT Strategy, Sourcing and Vendor RelationshipsUnderstanding IT Strategy, Sourcing and Vendor Relationships
Understanding IT Strategy, Sourcing and Vendor Relationships
Goutama Bachtiar
 
IT Governance - COBIT Perspective
IT Governance - COBIT PerspectiveIT Governance - COBIT Perspective
IT Governance - COBIT Perspective
Sayyed Zakir Ali Rizwe
 
CIT 3122 IS Governance Lecture 3.pptx
CIT 3122 IS Governance Lecture 3.pptxCIT 3122 IS Governance Lecture 3.pptx
CIT 3122 IS Governance Lecture 3.pptx
anthonywanjohi5
 
IT Govenence.pptx
IT Govenence.pptxIT Govenence.pptx
IT Govenence.pptx
PeterOwenje1
 
IT Strategy Framework
IT Strategy FrameworkIT Strategy Framework
IT Strategy Framework
Vishal Sharma
 
IT Governance - Core Concepts for Business Managers
IT Governance - Core Concepts for Business ManagersIT Governance - Core Concepts for Business Managers
IT Governance - Core Concepts for Business Managers
Walter Adamson
 
Strategic Business IT alignment
Strategic Business IT alignmentStrategic Business IT alignment
Strategic Business IT alignment
Julen Mohanty
 
Governance and Management of Enterprise IT with COBIT 5 Framework
Governance and Management of Enterprise IT with COBIT 5 FrameworkGovernance and Management of Enterprise IT with COBIT 5 Framework
Governance and Management of Enterprise IT with COBIT 5 Framework
Goutama Bachtiar
 
IT Governance in Banks, May, 2014
IT Governance in Banks, May, 2014IT Governance in Banks, May, 2014
IT Governance in Banks, May, 2014
ArmeniaFED
 
The Value of Portfolio Management
The Value of Portfolio ManagementThe Value of Portfolio Management
The Value of Portfolio Management
Productivity Intelligence Institute
 
Ivi external briefing_pack_v.aim
Ivi external briefing_pack_v.aimIvi external briefing_pack_v.aim
Ivi external briefing_pack_v.aim
AIMIreland
 
IT Governance Framework
IT Governance FrameworkIT Governance Framework
IT Governance Framework
Sherri Booher
 
01 intro-cobit
01 intro-cobit01 intro-cobit
01 intro-cobit
yusrizalmukhtar
 
CoBIT 5 (A brief Description)
CoBIT 5 (A brief Description)CoBIT 5 (A brief Description)
CoBIT 5 (A brief Description)
Sam Mandebvu
 
IT Governance.ppt
IT Governance.pptIT Governance.ppt
IT Governance.ppt
Insta13
 
It Governance OC CIO Nov,2013
It Governance OC CIO Nov,2013It Governance OC CIO Nov,2013
It Governance OC CIO Nov,2013
James Sutter
 

Similar to Sharpening the Lens (20)

IT Governance Presentation by omaha 2008
IT Governance Presentation by  omaha 2008IT Governance Presentation by  omaha 2008
IT Governance Presentation by omaha 2008
 
MAKING SENSE OF IT GOVERNANCE
MAKING SENSE OF IT GOVERNANCEMAKING SENSE OF IT GOVERNANCE
MAKING SENSE OF IT GOVERNANCE
 
Gaining and Maintaining IT & Business Alignment.pptx
Gaining and Maintaining IT & Business Alignment.pptxGaining and Maintaining IT & Business Alignment.pptx
Gaining and Maintaining IT & Business Alignment.pptx
 
Critical Success Factors (CSFs) for Effective IT Governance Implementations
Critical Success Factors (CSFs) for Effective IT Governance ImplementationsCritical Success Factors (CSFs) for Effective IT Governance Implementations
Critical Success Factors (CSFs) for Effective IT Governance Implementations
 
Understanding IT Strategy, Sourcing and Vendor Relationships
Understanding IT Strategy, Sourcing and Vendor RelationshipsUnderstanding IT Strategy, Sourcing and Vendor Relationships
Understanding IT Strategy, Sourcing and Vendor Relationships
 
IT Governance - COBIT Perspective
IT Governance - COBIT PerspectiveIT Governance - COBIT Perspective
IT Governance - COBIT Perspective
 
CIT 3122 IS Governance Lecture 3.pptx
CIT 3122 IS Governance Lecture 3.pptxCIT 3122 IS Governance Lecture 3.pptx
CIT 3122 IS Governance Lecture 3.pptx
 
IT Govenence.pptx
IT Govenence.pptxIT Govenence.pptx
IT Govenence.pptx
 
IT Strategy Framework
IT Strategy FrameworkIT Strategy Framework
IT Strategy Framework
 
IT Governance - Core Concepts for Business Managers
IT Governance - Core Concepts for Business ManagersIT Governance - Core Concepts for Business Managers
IT Governance - Core Concepts for Business Managers
 
Strategic Business IT alignment
Strategic Business IT alignmentStrategic Business IT alignment
Strategic Business IT alignment
 
Governance and Management of Enterprise IT with COBIT 5 Framework
Governance and Management of Enterprise IT with COBIT 5 FrameworkGovernance and Management of Enterprise IT with COBIT 5 Framework
Governance and Management of Enterprise IT with COBIT 5 Framework
 
IT Governance in Banks, May, 2014
IT Governance in Banks, May, 2014IT Governance in Banks, May, 2014
IT Governance in Banks, May, 2014
 
The Value of Portfolio Management
The Value of Portfolio ManagementThe Value of Portfolio Management
The Value of Portfolio Management
 
Ivi external briefing_pack_v.aim
Ivi external briefing_pack_v.aimIvi external briefing_pack_v.aim
Ivi external briefing_pack_v.aim
 
IT Governance Framework
IT Governance FrameworkIT Governance Framework
IT Governance Framework
 
01 intro-cobit
01 intro-cobit01 intro-cobit
01 intro-cobit
 
CoBIT 5 (A brief Description)
CoBIT 5 (A brief Description)CoBIT 5 (A brief Description)
CoBIT 5 (A brief Description)
 
IT Governance.ppt
IT Governance.pptIT Governance.ppt
IT Governance.ppt
 
It Governance OC CIO Nov,2013
It Governance OC CIO Nov,2013It Governance OC CIO Nov,2013
It Governance OC CIO Nov,2013
 

Sharpening the Lens

  • 1. Steve Beaton, CIA, CISA, CFSA, MsMIT, USAA VP IA Robert Koehler, CGEIT, PgMP, PMP, MsPM, PwC Director
  • 2. Slide 2 TOPIC We will explore the essential elements for preparing an assurance framework for IT Governance that integrates leading industry standards and practices ensuring the governing objectives for assessing strategy, financial performance, and effective delivery of technology.
  • 3. Slide 3 KEY BENEFITS TO THE AUDIENCE • We will highlight the leading IT Governance standards, drawing comparison between their similarities and differences. • We will highlight the business areas not adequately addressed by IT Governance standards. • We will recommend internal controls that pertain to aligning the relationships between the business and IT, including organizational structures for the evaluation and direction of IT. • We will recommend internal controls that pertain to the effectiveness of deriving value from IT, including financial performance and the planning for benefits realization. • We will recommend internal controls that pertain to the effectiveness of IT risk and compliance management, including what can be done to ensure sufficient IT risk information is factored into investment decision making.
  • 4. Slide 4 CURRENT STATE OF IT GOVERNANCE We will highlight the leading IT Governance standards, drawing comparison between their similarities and differences. • What are leaders saying about it? • Whose definition is best? • How is IA’s role perceived? • Where are the rabbit holes?
  • 5. Slide 5 CURRENT STATE OF IT GOVERNANCE IN THE NEWS Oversight split between the Board, Audit Committee, IT/Risk Committees or no one at all. - PwC, Insights from the Boardroom 2012 Only 30% of directors find IT expertise a “very important” attribute in new directors, and 31% are not seeking this skill set at all. - PwC’s 2013 Annual Corporate Directors Survey 44-50% of Board members meet with the CIO only once a year or not at all. - PwC, Insights from the Boardroom 2012 Only 38% of business partners seen as “very engaged” in IT Governance. - Forrester, The State Of IT Governance Q4 2010 The findings of a number of research projects conducted by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Center for Information Systems Research (CISR) suggest that firms with focused strategies and above-average IT governance capabilities had more than 20 percent higher profits than other firms following the same strategies. - Peter Weill and Jeanne W. Ross, It governance, how top performers manage it decisions for superior results, Harvard Business School Press Effective IT governance is the single most important predictor of the value an organization generates from IT. - Peter Weill and Jeanne W. Ross, It governance, how top performers manage it decisions for superior results, Harvard Business School Press
  • 6. Slide 6 COMPARING IT GOVERNANCE STANDARDS WHOSE DEFINITION IS BEST? • ISACA – The responsibility of executives and the board of directors; consists of the leadership, organizational structures and processes that ensure that the enterprise’s IT sustains and extends the enterprise’s strategies and objectives. • ISO – The system by which the current and future use of IT is directed and controlled. Corporate governance of IT involves evaluating and directing the use of IT to support the organization and monitoring this use to achieve plans. It includes the strategy and policies for using IT within an organization. • Gartner – The set of processes that ensure the effective and efficient use of IT in enabling an organization to achieve its goals. • Forrester – A decision-making framework for IT investments that is designed to maximize the return of benefits while managing risk to acceptable levels. • MIT CISR – Specifying the decision rights and accountability framework to encourage desirable behavior in using IT.
  • 7. Slide 7 ARE STAKEHOLDERS SATISFIED? AREAS OF LEAST SATISFACTION WITH IA
  • 8. Slide 8 COMPARING IT GOVERNANCE STANDARDS STANDARDS OVERLAPPING, EVEN CONFLICTING The challenge is choosing right and filling in the gaps as many standards are overlapping, even conflicting – None complete IT GovernanceProject Management Process Centric Maturity Centric PMI/PMBOK ITIL IT Management Val IT 2.0 Risk IT COBIT 5SEI CMMI ISO 38500TOGAF ISO 17998 COBIT 4 ISO 27001/2/5 MoV ISO 31000 MIT CISR PRINCE2 Most relevant standards
  • 9. Slide 9 COMPARING IT GOVERNANCE STANDARDS RIGHT SPECTRUM FOR COMPARISON Five dimensions of comparison used, each having a common focus on an organizations ability to drive greater value from IT Strategic Alignment •The successful alignment between business and IT •The comprehension of the impacts of IT on business processes and results •The clarity of priorities for both IT investments and business management focus Financial Performance •The effectiveness of deriving value from IT across the first and second lines of defense •The comprehension of performance as predictors of strategic decision-making •The comprehension of factors to measure and regulate the effectiveness of controls for risk and compliance Risk & Compliance •The establishment or risk, compliance, security and legal authority •The alignment of risk and compliance decisions with responsibilities for performance •The level of process integration across IT governance, risk, and compliance Grow & Transform •The level IT investments contribute to optimal business value •The level collaboration occurs between business and IT to realize benefits •The provision of investment management controls across the economic lives of investments Delivery Management •The determination of how types of IT-enabled capabilities are chosen as important for success •The decision driven actions to set objectives and expectations for the performance of IT •The position to handle the costs and risk of the service portfolios
  • 10. Slide 10 COMPARING IT GOVERNANCE STANDARDS MAPPING TO LEADING PRACTICES Strategic Alignment Financial Performance Delivery Risk & Compliance Grow &Transform Delivery Mgmt. • COBIT APO08 Manage Relationships • COBIT EDM01 Ensure Governance Framework Setting and Maintenance • COBIT EDM04 Ensure Resource Optimization • ITIL Strategy – Strategy and Organization • ITIL Strategy – Demand Management • IIA GTAG 17 – Auditing IT Governance • ISO/IEC 38500: 2008–Corporate Governance of Information Technology • COBIT MEA01 Monitor, Evaluate and Assess Performance and Conformance • EDM05 Ensure Stakeholder Transparency • COBIT APO06 Manage Budget and Costs • ITIL Strategy – Financial Management • ITIL Strategy – Return on Investment • ISO/IEC 38500: 2008–Corporate Governance of Information Technology • COBIT EDM03 Ensure Risk Optimization • COBIT MEA03 Monitor, Evaluate and Assess Compliance with External Requirements • COBIT DSS05 Manage Security Services • ISO/IEC 31000– Risk Management • ISO/IEC 27000– Security Techniques • Multiple industry based requirements such as: HIPPA, AML, Dodd Frank, PCI, FISMA, Sarbanes Oxley and Safe Harbour • COBIT APO04 Manage Innovation • COBIT APO05 Manage Portfolio • COBIT EDM02 Ensure Benefits Delivery • ITIL Strategy – Service Portfolio Management • Project Management Book of Knowledge (PMBOK) • Projects in Controlled Environments (PRINCE 2) • Portfolio, Program, and Project Management Maturity Model (P3M3) • ITIL Strategy– Strategy, Tactics, and Operations • COBIT APO02 Manage Strategy • COBIT APO03 Manage Enterprise Architecture • The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF) • ISO/IEC 20000–IT Service Management
  • 11. Slide 11 AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED We will highlight the business areas not adequately addressed by IT Governance standards. • Is IT on the boards agenda? • Does corporate strategy influence IT? • Is the value gap being closed? • Does the three lines of defense help IT Governance? • Is IT Governance, Risk and Compliance combined? • Are business benefits being realized?
  • 12. Slide 12 AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED IT ON THE BOARD’S AGENDA A structured approach for board’s IT oversight: • Assessment: Evaluate the company’s current IT situation, while considering various factors, and conclude how critical IT is to the company’s current and future success. • Approach: Agree on the board's IT oversight approach including who is responsible (the full board, the audit committee, a risk committee, etc.), how often to discuss IT, and when to talk with the CIO. • Prioritization: Identify the IT subjects most relevant to the company and focus oversight efforts on those areas. • Strategy: "Bake" IT initiatives into the board’s oversight of overall company strategy based on the importance of IT to the company. • Risk: Include IT risks as part of the board’s risk management oversight process. • Monitoring: Adopt a continuous IT oversight process, regularly revisit the efficacy of that process, and measure results.
  • 13. Slide 13 AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED CASCADING CORPORATE STRATEGY Need to evaluate the IT strategy within the overall strategy for the business Business Strategy (3-5 yr plan) IT Strategy Digital Business Model • Frames how IT & technology enables business capabilities • Sets expectations for scalability & interoperability • Provides principles & standards that guide technology decisions • Prioritizes immediate IT challenges that need resolution • Identifies synergies across entities • Identifies digital business model capabilities • Measures effectiveness of digital content, experience, and platform • Identifies digital source of competitive advantage BusinessDrivenITStrategy • Develops a target state and future vision that synchronizes IT investments with business needs • Creates a blueprint for maximizing return on technology investments • Establish guiding principles that will drive the technology evolution Strategy & business alignment Organization & skills Technology & architecture Management & Governance Information Product Customer Experience Internal External The Digital Business Model describes how content, experience, and platform works together to create a compelling customer value proposition. The Business Strategy describes and interrelates mission, vision, goals, and strategies with core processes, constituents, and interactions.
  • 14. Slide 14 AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED CLOSING THE VALUE GAP While many companies fail to deliver business value, top performers deliver the expected value (+15%), on time (+30%) at or below budget (+30%) ACTUAL ROI = -4% Value RealizedPlan Actual Execution Benefits Only 38% of programs delivered 100% of value Time Only 36% of programs are delivered on time Value (200) Cost (100) Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 3 Year Plan Value (125) Extra Year 4 Year Actual Value Gap Cost (130) Over Cost PLAN ROI=50% The Value Gap -$60M -$15M +$30M EXAMPLE: Time Increase: 30% Cost Increase: 30% Value Loss: 30% ($M) IMPACT ($M)
  • 15. Slide 15 AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED THREE LINES OF DEFENSE Clear delineation between line controls, second-level monitoring controls and third-line independent assurance for the effective governance of information technology Board of Directors / Audit Committee Business and IT Senior Management Regulator 1st Line of Defense ExternalAudit 3rd Line of Defense2nd Line of Defense Internal Control Measures IT Governance Mechanisms Financial Controls Risk Management Compliance Portfolio Performance Program Governance Security Internal Audit Project Assurance
  • 16. Slide 16 AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED IT GRC INTEGRATION IT Governance, risk management and compliance managed in an integrated manner IT Compliance Committee Audit Committees Evaluate Direct Report Monitor IT governance Risk Management Compliance IT Governance Committee IT Steering Committee PMO / Portfolio Management Objective Setting Risk Assessment Event Identification Risk Response Control Activities Information & Communication Monitoring Requirement Analysis Deviation Analysis Deficiency Management Reporting / Documentation Deviation Analysis Enterprise & IT Risk Committees
  • 17. Slide 17 AREAS NOT ADEQUATELY COVERED BENEFITS REALIZATION The benefits expected from IT are unlikely to emerge automatically. Any benefits sought must be identified along with the changes in ways of working to bring about and sustain each of the benefits. Means to Achieve Changes Evaluate overall vision for the new digital solution Ways to Achieve Changes Evaluate the new ways of doing business and the benefits this will deliver Results of Changes Evaluate how fostering and realizing business benefits will come through structured change Benefits Identification Business Case Benefits Planning Project Delivery User Adoption Value Creation Benefits Extension Benefits Fulfillment
  • 18. Slide 18 BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK We will recommend internal controls. • Where should we focus our attention? • What IT-related domains should be controlled? • What controls should comprise each domain?
  • 19. Slide 19 BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK EXECUTIVE AGREEMENT ON ROLE OF IT Align with management’s active design of IT Governance around the business’ objectives and performance goals. •Strategic Aims •Stewardship •IT Reliance •Firm Performance •Economic Life & Reward •Strategic Aims •Stewardship •IT Reliance •Firm Performance •Economic Life & Reward Corporate GovernanceCorporate Governance •Strategic Aims •Stewardship •IT Reliance •Firm Performance •Economic Life & Reward Corporate Governance •Financial Objectives •Customer Needs •Process Improvements •Organizational Learns •Financial Objectives •Customer Needs •Process Improvements •Organizational Learns Performance MgmtPerformance Mgmt •Financial Objectives •Customer Needs •Process Improvements •Organizational Learns Performance Mgmt •Service Levels •Resource Profiles •Workforce Planning •Learning & Development •Service Levels •Resource Profiles •Workforce Planning •Learning & Development Resource ManagementResource Management •Service Levels •Resource Profiles •Workforce Planning •Learning & Development Resource Management •Risk Transparency •Risk Delegation •Risk Control •Operational Risk •Risk Transparency •Risk Delegation •Risk Control •Operational Risk Risk ManagementRisk Management •Risk Transparency •Risk Delegation •Risk Control •Operational Risk Risk Management •Strategic Importance •Environmental Context •Financial Planning •IT Capabilities •IT Resources •Strategic Importance •Environmental Context •Financial Planning •IT Capabilities •IT Resources Strategic AlignmentStrategic Alignment •Strategic Importance •Environmental Context •Financial Planning •IT Capabilities •IT Resources Strategic Alignment •Regulatory Compliance •Internal Controls •IT Security •Compliance Policies •Regulatory Compliance •Internal Controls •IT Security •Compliance Policies IT ComplianceIT Compliance •Regulatory Compliance •Internal Controls •IT Security •Compliance Policies IT Compliance IT Governance Executive Agreement on the Role of IT
  • 20. Slide 20 BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK TOP-DOWN BOTTOM-UP PROCESS Proper integration of management and support functions must be considered when creating the assessment framework Project Work and Resource Authorizations Change Requirements and Risk Mitigates Performance Measurements Corporate Risk Management Service Levels and Finished Products Professional and Operational Services Investment Management IT Strategy, Vision, and Action Plans Program Health Updates Benefits Realization Time-Sensitive Growth / Recovery Strategies IT Governance IT Services Project Portfolio Management Corporate Governance Top-Down Evaluation & Direction Bottom-Up Monitoring & Reporting
  • 21. Slide 21 BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK HOLISTIC VIEW Encompassing these arrangements to create a holistic view of the governance, management, and use of IT Business Strategy Organization Structures Digital Business Models IT Asset Portfolios Performance and Change Metrics IT Service Valuation IT Risk Management IT Compliance Security Governance IT Service Strategy IT Long-term Strategy Portfolio & Project Delivery Operations Benefits Realization Architecture Strategic Alignment Financial Performance Risk & Compliance Grow & Transform Service Management Delivery Management
  • 22. Slide 22 BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK STRATEGIC ALIGNMENT Business Strategy Digital Business Models Organization Structures • Clear alignment is visible between Corporate and IT Strategy. • Business strategy changes are understood, documented and approved with their impact on IT communicated. • Good relationships and communication channels exist between the business and IT. • Business stakeholders are aware of technology- enabled opportunities. • Business plans, operating models and requirements are understood, documented and approved with their impact on IT communicated. • Impacts of expected future demand are understood and built into IT planning. • Strategic decision-making model for IT is effective and aligned with the organization’s internal and external environment and stakeholder requirements. • The governance system & bodies for IT are implemented and operating effectively. • Organizational structures are aligned with strategic value drivers. • The resource needs of the organization are met with the right capabilities. • Resources are allocated to best meet the overall business priorities within budget constraints. • Optimal use of resources is achieved throughout their full economic life cycles.
  • 23. Slide 23 BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE IT Service Valuation IT Asset Portfolio Performance & Change Metrics • Processes are measured against agreed-on goals and metrics. • Goals and metrics are approved by the stakeholders. • Owners are assigned and held accountable. • Investment decisions are linked to value that can be tracked. • An appropriate investment mix is defined and aligned with business strategy. • Program business cases are evaluated and prioritized before funds are allocated. • Sources of investment funding are identified and available. • Current accounting evaluation process for justifying an IT investment is sufficient for managing investment risk. • Returns are measured across the economic life of the investment. • Performance measures include profitability, productivity and effectiveness. • Goals and metrics are integrated within the organization’s monitoring systems. • Process reporting on performance and conformance is useful and timely.
  • 24. Slide 24 BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK RISK & COMPLIANCE IT Risk Management IT Compliance Security Governance • Risk appetite is defined at the organizational level and cascaded to IT. • Risk thresholds are defined and communicated while key IT-related risks are known. • The organization is managing critical IT-related risk to the business effectively and efficiently. • IT-related risk does not exceed risk appetite and the impact of IT risk to business value is identified and managed. • All compliance obligations are identified. • Compliance obligations are adequately addressed. • The organization seeks to proactively manage compliance obligations through the use of technology. • Network and communications security meet business needs. • Information processed on, stored on and transmitted by endpoint devices is protected. • All users are uniquely identifiable and have access rights in accordance with their business role. • Physical measures have been implemented to protect information from unauthorized access, damage and interference when being processed, stored or transmitted. • Electronic information is properly secured when stored, transmitted or destroyed.
  • 25. Slide 25 BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK GROW & TRANSFORM IT Long-term Strategy Portfolio & Project Delivery Benefits Realization • Business value is created through the qualification and staging of the most appropriate advances and innovations in technology, IT methods and solutions. • Business objectives are met with improved quality benefits and/or reduced cost as a result of the identification and implementation of innovative solutions. • Innovation is promoted and enabled and forms part of the business culture. • As solutions are developed the business case is updated to reflect any changes. • A comprehensive and accurate view of the investment portfolio(s) performance exists. • Investment program changes are reflected in the relevant IT service, asset and resource portfolios. • Robust project and program management practices. • Transparency into project and program progress. • The business is securing optimal value from its portfolio of approved IT- enabled initiatives, services and assets. • Optimal value is derived from IT investment through effective value management practices in the business. • Individual IT-enabled investments contribute optimal value. • Benefits have been realized due to benefits management.
  • 26. Slide 26 BUILDING INTERNAL CONTROL FRAMEWORK SERVICE MANAGEMENT IT Service Strategy IT Operations IT Architecture • All aspects of the service strategy are aligned with the broader corporate strategy. • The IT strategy is cost- effective, appropriate, realistic, achievable, business-focused and balanced. • Clear and concrete short- term goals can be derived from, and traced back to, specific long-term initiatives, and can then be translated into operational plans. • IT is a value driver for the business. • There is awareness of the service strategy and a clear assignment of accountability for delivery. • Achieve effectiveness and efficiency in the delivery and support of services. • Strategic objectives are ultimately realized through service operations. • Stability in service operations is maintained, allowing for changes in design, scale, scope, and service levels. • The architecture and standards are effective in supporting the business. • A portfolio of business architecture services supports agile business change. • Appropriate and up-to-date domain and/or federated architectures exist that provide reliable architecture information. • A common business architecture framework and methodology as well as an integrated architecture repository are used to enable re-use efficiencies across the business.
  • 27. Slide 27 EXECUTING THE AUDIT • Is your audit approach risk-based? • What is the workflow for the audit? • How should risks be classified? • Who should participate in the audit? • What information should be requested?
  • 28. Slide 28 EXECUTING THE AUDIT AUDIT APPROACH Take a consultative approach to assuring IT Governance. Assess Assess your capability and maturity with a wide range of industry standards and best practice frameworks Evaluate Measure your performance in order to establish your current baseline Benchmark Compare your direction with that of your peers using extensive global benchmarking data • Alignment • Value • Risk • Resource • Performance • Evaluate execution management • Organizational structures • Governing processes • Relational mechanisms • Maturity models • IT strategies • Digital business designs • IT investment areas and levels Recommend Provide practical recommendations for your consideration and selection for making improvements • Decision rights & accountability • Process maturity • Performance ratios • Priorities
  • 29. Slide 29 EXECUTING THE AUDIT AUDIT APPROACH, CONTINUED Step 1 – Assess Conduct an assessment through executive and senior management and business leader interviews, roundtables, and surveys and examine documentation to compare IT practices against the framework in the areas of alignment, value, risk, resource, and performance. Analyse critical IT practices and prioritize risk to communicate the risk exposure based on stated objectives. The key to assuring IT is to understand the culture and priorities in both the business and IT; this will ensure that IT is aligned with the overall business strategy, and that the IT strategy drives controls, policies, budgets, risk tolerance, and service levels. Step 2 – Evaluate/Compare Leverage the results of Step 1 to evaluate and define the current condition of IT practice indicators that will be used to assess achievement of the expectations expressed in the IT Governance framework. Continue this evaluation by comparing your direction with that of your peers using extensive global benchmarking data. [Optional] Step 3 – Recommend Through the analysis of strengths and weaknesses, the prior steps provide the information to prepare practical recommendations and actions to improve the outcomes and performance of enterprise IT. Throughout the assessment, provide improvement recommendations based on the evaluation documentation and discussions with executive and senior management. At any time you identify an item that requires immediate attention by management, communicate such item.
  • 30. Slide 30 EXECUTING THE AUDIT AUDIT WORKFLOW Tasks / Milestones Duration Project Start-up / Finalize Statement of Work Week 1 – Week 2 1. Kick-off Meeting 2. Begin Scheduling Interviews 3. Publish Initial Information Request 4. Establish Goals, Objectives, and Drivers for Assessment 5. Determine Comparison Baselines from Past IT Audits / Changes 6. Propose Custom Framework for Assessment 7. Obtain Approval for Proposal, Timeline, and Initial Resources 8. Establish Assessment Infrastructure to Coordinate Activities 9. Publish Goals and Guiding Principles of Assessment 10. Update Interview Calendar 11. Launch Assessment
  • 31. Slide 31 EXECUTING THE AUDIT AUDIT WORKFLOW, CONTINUED Tasks / Milestones Duration Perform Assessment Week 3 – Week 4 1. Finalize Categories / Process Areas for Custom Framework 2. Build Custom Framework 3. Publish Updated Information Request 4. Conduct Assessment and Characterize Current Practice 5. Develop Audit Themes and Begin Socializing with Senior Management 6. Develop Recommendations and Document Results 7. Identify Improvement Strategy and Priorities Prepare / Deliver Draft Report Week 5 – Week 5 Prepare / Deliver Final Report Week 6 – Week 6 Plan Improvement (Optional) Week 7 – Week 8 1. Understand Short-/Long-Term Planned Improvement Efforts 2. Identify Roles/Responsibilities of Improvement/Audit Programs 3. Reconcile Existing/Planned Improvements with the Assessment Baseline 4. Prepare Performance Measurement Plan 5. Create Strategic Improvement Program
  • 32. Slide 32 EXECUTING THE AUDIT CLASSIFY IT RISK Factor IT Risk within the ERM process to help ensure IT decision- makers know how much IT Risk is acceptable. Significance Likelihood 10 98 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 11 12 13 14 15 1. Enterprise IT Strategy 2. Digital Business Designs 3. Organizational Structures 4. Enterprise Architecture 5. IT Service Valuation 6. IT Investment Portfolios 7. IT Performance 8. IT Risk Management 9. IT Compliance 10. Security Governance 11. Service Strategy 12. Project Delivery 13. Benefits Realization 14. IT Operations 15. Price Performance
  • 33. Slide 33 EXECUTING THE AUDIT IDENTIFYING PARTICIPANTS Technology • Heads IT Operations • Heads IT Development • Chief Technology Officer • Chief Architect • Chief Information Officer • Chief Information Security Officer • Heads IT PMOs Business • Chief Risk Officer • Business Leaders • Chief Financial Officer • IT Spokesperson on the Board • Heads Enterprise PMO Survey • Frontline and Middle Management The audit involves executives, senior management, and business leader interviews and possibly surveying frontline and business management.
  • 34. Slide 34 EXECUTING THE AUDIT INFORMATION REQUESTS • IT strategy documentation • IT scorecards • IT policies • IT financial management documentation, including: financing and budgeting, asset management, contract management, and resource plans • Service level agreements (SLAs) • Any utilized governance or maturity frameworks and models • IT compliance and training requirements • Governance processes documentation The following information should be requested to understand IT Governance practices:
  • 36. Slide 36 YOUR SPEAKERS Steve Beaton Vice President Bank Audit Services Robert Koehler Director Risk Assurance Services Steve is Vice President of Bank Audit Services at USAA, where he leads audit coverage of bank operations. Previously he led IT/Security Audit Services, supporting the full range of engagements specific to IT/Security. Prior to joining USAA, Steve was Vice President of IT Audit at Freddie Mac. Steve is a seasoned internal audit and risk management executive with diverse leadership experience within financial services including TD BankNorth, Fifth Third Bank, Sunlife Financial, and Bank of Ireland. Steve holds a bachelor of business administration from Merrimack College in Massachusetts and a master’s degree in management of information technology from the McIntire School of Commerce at the University of Virginia. He is a Certified Internal Auditor (CIA), Certified Information Systems Auditor (CISA) and Certified Financial Services Auditor (CFSA). Robert is a Director at PwC. Over the last 30 years, as a consulting executive and provider, he has purchased, sold, managed, and delivered extensive global IT consulting services involving Oracle, SAP, and Microsoft enterprise software suites. He has led numerous global business transformations, and the PMOs, IT asset portfolios, and project management practices of leading firms. His specialties are in assuming responsibility for and leading client services in need of performance gains, improved client relations, and growth across numerous industries and the Government. Robert has earned a M.S. in Management, Project Management Specialty from Boston University and a B.S. in Administration and Management from La Roche College. He holds the professional certifications of Program Management Professional (PgMP), Project Management Professional (PMP), and Certified in the Governance of Enterprise IT (CGEIT). steven.beaton@usaa.com (210) 249-1309 robert.j.koehler@us.pwc.com (505) 417-7689