A woman in her 70s presented with chest pain. Her ECG showed atrial fibrillation and intermittent native complexes among predominantly paced complexes. Application of the Sgarbossa criteria to the ECG did not meet STEMI criteria. Serial ECGs showed ST changes in native complexes indicative of ischemia. Coronary angiography revealed a thrombus causing 95% occlusion, which was treated with stenting. This case highlights the challenges of diagnosing ischemia in paced rhythms and emphasizes the importance of evaluating native complexes, as the Sgarbossa criteria have limitations in paced rhythms.