Running head: RESEARCH PAPER 1
RESEARCH PAPER 6
HOSPITAL-ACQUIRED INFECTIONS AMONG PATIENTS in hospitals in florida?
(Qualitative Study)
Dayana Lewandowski
Florida International University
HSA 6977
Dr. Mariceli Comellas
May 17, 2020
Background Information
Explain overall what the problem is? Statistics in the usa, in the usa there are 4574 hospitalizations due to the infections acquired in hospitals, use citations and use government websites. Download research guidelines.
1.The objective of the study is.
2. results of the study
3.connect that study with your study and how ur study fills in the gap of that study
“citation”Hospital-acquired infection, otherwise known as nosocomial diseases are a common problem that affects many healthcare institutions around the world. Such diseases are not only a burden to healthcare institutions but also the patients served. The total costs associated with the management of hospital-acquired infections have constantly been rising despite the implementation of many intervention policies, (Khan, Baig, & Mehboob, 2017). The government has formulated various nursing intervention policies through various federal and state departments to resolve the issues of nosocomial infections. However, many of these interventions have barely led to a permanent solution. Hospitals and patients are still incurring huge costs as a result of hospital-acquired infections. Hospitals are often subjected to expensive litigation procedures whenever patients contract infections while admitted.
On the other hand, patients are sometimes required to spend more on treatment after contracting infections while admitted in various healthcare institutions. In the University of Miami Hospital, for instance, operational costs have been increasing annually mainly because the hospital has to deal with many nosocomial infections annually, (Chang, 2017). A similar scenario is noted among healthcare institutions operating in the Southern Florida region. While this problem has been identified and discussed a lot, not much attention has been directed to dissect the most affected persons. People with pre-existing chronic diseases such as arthritis, diabetes, and asthma are more susceptible to nosocomial infections compared to people who do not have pre-existing chronic illnesses.
Problem Statement
Pre-existing chronic illnesses increase the risk of opportunistic illnesses and infections. For instance, diabetes type I affects immunity hence diabetic people have greater risks, (Casqueiro, Casqueiro, & Alves, 2012). Healthcare practitioners, as well as patients, are at risk of contracting nosocomial infections, especially when they have pre-existing chronic diseases. “Add citations”Past research indicates that the majority of persons who are severely affected by hospital-acquired infections have pre-existing conditions. Many healthcare institutions in the Southern Florida region have high cases of nosocomial infections because p.
1. Running head: RESEARCH PAPER 1
RESEARCH PAPER 6
HOSPITAL-ACQUIRED INFECTIONS AMONG PATIENTS in
hospitals in florida?
(Qualitative Study)
Dayana Lewandowski
Florida International University
HSA 6977
Dr. Mariceli Comellas
May 17, 2020
Background Information
Explain overall what the problem is? Statistics in the usa, in the
usa there are 4574 hospitalizations due to the infections
2. acquired in hospitals, use citations and use government
websites. Download research guidelines.
1.The objective of the study is.
2. results of the study
3.connect that study with your study and how ur study fills in
the gap of that study
“citation”Hospital-acquired infection, otherwise known as
nosocomial diseases are a common problem that affects many
healthcare institutions around the world. Such diseases are not
only a burden to healthcare institutions but also the patients
served. The total costs associated with the management of
hospital-acquired infections have constantly been rising despite
the implementation of many intervention policies, (Khan, Baig,
& Mehboob, 2017). The government has formulated various
nursing intervention policies through various federal and state
departments to resolve the issues of nosocomial infections.
However, many of these interventions have barely led to a
permanent solution. Hospitals and patients are still incurring
huge costs as a result of hospital-acquired infections. Hospitals
are often subjected to expensive litigation procedures whenever
patients contract infections while admitted.
On the other hand, patients are sometimes required to spend
more on treatment after contracting infections while admitted in
various healthcare institutions. In the University of Miami
Hospital, for instance, operational costs have been increasing
annually mainly because the hospital has to deal with many
nosocomial infections annually, (Chang, 2017). A similar
scenario is noted among healthcare institutions operating in the
Southern Florida region. While this problem has been identified
and discussed a lot, not much attention has been directed to
dissect the most affected persons. People with pre-existing
chronic diseases such as arthritis, diabetes, and asthma are more
susceptible to nosocomial infections compared to people who do
not have pre-existing chronic illnesses.
Problem Statement
3. Pre-existing chronic illnesses increase the risk of opportunistic
illnesses and infections. For instance, diabetes type I affects
immunity hence diabetic people have greater risks, (Casqueiro,
Casqueiro, & Alves, 2012). Healthcare practitioners, as well as
patients, are at risk of contracting nosocomial infections,
especially when they have pre-existing chronic diseases. “Add
citations”Past research indicates that the majority of persons
who are severely affected by hospital-acquired infections have
pre-existing conditions. Many healthcare institutions in the
Southern Florida region have high cases of nosocomial
infections because pre-existing conditions among nurses are
often not considered during the hiring and also during the
admission of patients.
Nurse practitioners tasked with extending care services to
patients in various wards including ICUs often contract
nosocomial infections. A nurse practitioner who has a pre-
existing chronic illness such as diabetes type I is more
susceptible to nosocomial infection than other nurses. The same
case applies to patients admitted to hospital with pre-existing
chronic conditions. Similarly, asthmatic people are more
susceptible to infections that affect the respiratory system.
Although people with pre-existing chronic illnesses are more
susceptible to hospital-acquired infections, not much has been
done to develop specific intervention measures for this group of
people, (Klompas, 2017). For this reason, research is needed to
identify the extent to which hospital-acquired infections affect
persons with pre-existing chronic illnesses.
Significance of the study
How the reader, why this program of acquiring infections
research is going to help society?
Significance of the study (cost $$ or loss of life morbidity, loss
of productivity)
“Citations”Nursing research has in the past been used to
develop appropriate interventions to resolve various problems in
the healthcare sector. (Why is it important)Therefore, research
4. on the prevalence of hospital-acquired infections among
patients diagnosed with chronic diseases is important to identify
intervention measures that could be formulated to address the
problem. Also, research on the identified problem will fill
existing knowledge gaps that affect the quality of healthcare
services extended to patients diagnosed with chronic diseases.
More so, the research will help to identify appropriate measures
that could be used to reduce the financial burden among
admitted patients diagnosed with chronic diseases. The
prevalence of nosocomial infections among patients and
healthcare professionals’ diagnosed living with various chronic
illnesses is much higher than the prevalence among patients and
healthcare professionals who do not have pre-existing chronic
conditions. Therefore, it is necessary to undertake research that
focuses on the specific group of people to better understand
which nursing interventions would be most appropriate.
Hospitals acquired infections in hospitals in the US
Review of Literature
Although all patients are exposed to nosocomial infection
during their stay in various healthcare institutions, recent
studies indicate a high prevalence among patients diagnosed
with chronic illnesses. Chronic illnesses often weaken immunity
thus exposing patients to many opportunistic infections and
diseases. For instance, a hyperglycemic environment triggers
immune dysfunction among diabetic patients thus exposing
them to frequent infections that are in some cases very severe,
(Casqueiro, et.al.,2012). In another study, Kirchgesner et.al.,
(2018) found that patients with chronic inflammatory bowel
disease often suffer a great deal due to the high susceptibility to
5. nosocomial infections. For instance, catheters used have been
identified to increase the prevalence of hospital-acquired
infections among IBD patients. Similarly, patients who have
pre-existing asthmatic conditions often contract pneumonia
while admitted to the hospital. However, (continue argument)
very few studies have looked into assessing hospital based
infections among patients in florida.
In a recent study, Klompas (2017) discovered that ventilators
used in ICUs are often the cause of nosocomial infections
among asthmatic patients. Hygiene compliance policies have
been formulated and prevented to reduce the prevalence of
nosocomial infections in the past. However, implementing
hygiene standards as a preventive measure does not alleviate the
problem among persons diagnosed with chronic conditions,
(Smythe, et.al., 2016). A lot of research about hospital-acquired
infections has been conducted in the past but very few studies
have focused exclusively on a population of persons with
chronic illnesses. A knowledge gap is identified from the
literature reviewed, thus research on the topic is necessary.
According to Chang (2017), the University of Miami Hospital is
among the most affected healthcare institutions in the Southern
Florida region. (Add more content)
Methodology
The proposed study will adopt a qualitative research design to
explore the prevalence of hospital-acquired infections among
patients diagnosed with chronic illnesses. An exploratory study
will pave the way for further research on the same topic in the
future, (Creswell & Creswell, 2018). Therefore, a synthesis of
existing literature materials will be conducted to gain
meaningful insights into the topic. The literature sources
selected for the qualitative synthesis must cover main concepts
such as the prevalence of nosocomial infections and chronic
diseases. Focusing on these concepts will ensure that the data
collected can be used to answer research questions and
6. consequently fill the existing knowledge gaps. The sample
population will comprise of patients and nurses admitted and
working, respectively, at Miami University Hospital. Research
participants must have a pre-existing chronic illness and a
history of nosocomial infections in the last 3 years. Also, the
research will mainly rely on secondary data collected in
previous studies. Utilizing secondary data saves time and costs
associated with collecting primary data.
In conclusion, patients diagnosed with chronic illnesses are
more susceptible to nosocomial infections. However, not much
has been done on this topic hence a lack of effective
intervention measures to alleviate the problem. The existing
interventions do not adequately cover the problems endured by
patients who contract nosocomial infections easily due to pre-
existing chronic illnesses. As such, the proposed study is meant
to address this problem.
References
Casqueiro, J., Casqueiro, J., & Alves, C. (2012). Infections in
patients with diabetes mellitus: A review of
pathogenesis. Indian journal of endocrinology and
metabolism, 16(Suppl1), S27. DOI: 10.4103/2230-8210.94253
Chang, D. (2017). UM Hospital can’t stop bleeding money as
costs soar and admissions drop. Miami Herald. Retrieved from
https://www.miamiherald.com/news/health-
care/article186714813.html
Creswell, J. W., & Creswell, J. D. (2018). Research design
qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approach. Los
Angeles: SAGE.
Kirchgesner, J., Lemaitre, M., Carrat, F., Zureik, M.,
Carbonnel, F., & Dray-Spira, R. (2018). Risk of serious and
opportunistic infections associated with the treatment of
inflammatory bowel diseases. Gastroenterology, 155(2), 337-
346. https://doi.org/10.1053/j.gastro.2018.04.012
Klompas, M. (2017). What is new in the prevention of
nosocomial pneumonia in the ICU?. Current opinion in critical
care, 23(5), 378-384. DOI: 10.1097/MCC.0000000000000443
7. Khan, H. A., Baig, F. K., & Mehboob, R. (2017). Nosocomial
infections: Epidemiology, prevention, control, and
surveillance. Asian Pacific Journal of Tropical
Biomedicine, 7(5), 478-482.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apjtb.2017.01.019
Smythe, W., Engelbrecht, H., Morris, V., Patel, B., &
McDonald, H. (2016). A multifaceted hospital-wide intervention
increases hand hygiene compliance: in practice. African Journal
of Health Professions Education, 106(4), 335-341.
Statistical Techniques Used for Exploring Relationships:
1) Correlation: Explores relationship among two continuous
variables (e.g. age and depression scale).
a. Partial correlation: Controls for one continuous variable
while explores for a relationship among two continuous
variables.
Example: After controlling for the effects of socially desirable
responding, is there still a significant relationship between
optimism and life satisfaction scores (three continuous
variables)
2) Multiple regression: Predicts. One continuous dependent
variable & 2 or more continuous independent variable. It can
be seen as an extension of correlation and is used when you
want to explore the predictive ability of a set of independent
variables on one continuous dependent measure.
Example: How much variance in life satisfaction scores can be
explained by the following set of variables: self-esteem,
optimism and perceived control? Which variables is a better
predictor of life satisfaction. All variables here are continuous.
3) Chi Square: Explores relationships among two categorical
8. variables (e.g. sex and exercise—exercise is categorized as
either (Yes or No).
Example: Is there a relationship between sex (Males and
Females) and exercise (Yes vs. No)?
4) Spearman’s Rank Order correlation: two variables that are
either ordinal, interval or ratio.
Exploring Differences Between Groups (interval scales):
Parametric tests: the data is required to fit a normal
distribution.
5) T-tests are used when you have 2 groups or two set of data
(before & after) and when you wish to compare the mean scores
on some continuous variable.
Example: Are males more optimistic than females?
One categorical independent variables with two groups and one
continuous dependent variable.
a) Independent sample t-test: Used when there are 2 different
independent groups and you want to compare their scores. One
categorical independent variable with only 2 groups & one
continuous dependent variable.
b) Paired sample t-test: Sameparticipants are tested on 2
separate occasions. One categorical independent variable (e.g.
Time 1 & Time 2) & one continuous dependent variable.
Example: Does ten weeks of meditation training result in a
9. decrease in participant level of anxiety? Is there a change in
anxiety levels from Time 1 (pre intervention) to time 2 (post
intervention)? One categorical independent (Time 1/Time 2) &
One continuous dependent variable (anxiety score).
6) One sample between groups analyses (ANOVA): Used to
compare 2 or more groups and compare their mean scores on a
continuous variable. One categorical independent variables with
2 or more groups & one continuous dependent variable.
Example: Is there a difference in optimism scores for people
who are under 30, between 31-49 and 50 years and over.
7) Two way between groups ANOVA: Test the impact of two
categorical independent variables and one continuous dependent
variable. This test allows the possibility of testing for
interaction effect. This is when the effect of one independent
variable is influenced by another.
Example: What is the effect of age on optimism scores for
males and females.
8) Mixed between-within ANOVA: One between groups
independent variable (intervention such as math skills and
confidence building) and one within group’s independent
variable (Time 1, Time 2, Time 3) & one continuous dependent
variable.
9) Multivariate ANOVA: One categorical independent variable
& ≥ 2 continuous dependent variables.
10) ANCOVA: One categorical independent variable & one
continuousdependent variable & one or more continuous
covariates.
Nonparametric tests: the data is not required to fit a normal
distribution. Data that is often ordinal, meaning it does not rely
10. on numbers, rather a ranking or order of categories.
11) Wilcoxon Signed-Rank test: is the nonparametric test
equivalent to the repeated measures t-test. *Converts scores to
ranks and compares these at Time 1 and at Time 2.
12) Mann-Whitney U: Non parametric measure; tests difference
between 2 independent groups.
13) Kruskal–Wallis one-way analysis of variance: The non-
parametric option for one-way ANOVA. It is used for
comparing two or more independent samples of equal or
different sample sizes. It extends the Mann–Whitney U test
when there are more than two groups.
a. Post hoc analyses are conducted to find out which groups are
significantly different from one another.
14) McNemar’s Test: Tests 2 variables, the first recorded at
time 1 and the second recorded at time 2. Both of these
variables are categorical.
a. E.g. Question: Is there a change in the proportion of the
sample diagnosed with clinical depression prior to and
following intervention.
15) Cochran’s Q Test: If you have 3 or more time points. All
three are categorical variables measuring the same
characteristics at 3 points in time.
a. Example: Is there a proportion of participants diagnosed with
clinical depression across the three time points (a) prior to the
program (b) three months’ post program.
Research Objective
Type of DV
Type of IV
11. Covariates
Test
Analysis Goal
Test associations or relationships
Explore associations
nominal (categorical) variables
nominal (categorical) variables
Chi Square
Is there an association between the IV+DV
Explore associations and strengths
Continuous
Continuous
Correlation
Is there an association between the IV+DV
Explore associations and strengths
Continuous
Continuous
one or more
Partial correlation
Is there an association between the IV+DV controlling for 1 or
more variables
Explore associations and strength between two ranked variables
Continuous
Continuous
Spearman Rank Order correlation
(non-parametric)
Is there an association between the IV+DV
Differences between groups tests:
Explore differences between groups (Before or After) AND
Compare the mean scores on some continuous variable
Continuous
One nominal (categorical) variables with 2 groups
12. T-tests
(Parametric)
Do differences exist between groups.
Explore the differences between independent groups to compare
their scores
Continuous
One nominal (categorical) variable with only 2 groups
Independent sample T-test
(Parametric)
Do differences exist between these two groups.
Explore the differences between the same participants on two
separate occasions to compare their scores
Continuous
One nominal (categorical) variable (Time 1 & Time 2)
Paired Sample t-test (Parametric)
Test the same participants on two separate occasions (Time 1 &
Time 2)
Research Objective
# and type of DV
# and type of IV
Covariates
Test
Analysis Goal
Explore the differences between ≥2 groups and compare their
mean scores on a continuous variable
Continuous
Categorical with ≥2 groups
ANOVA
Do differences exist between ≥2 groups on one DV
Test the main and interaction effects of categorical variables on
a continuous dependent variable, controlling for the effects of
selected other continuous variables, which co-vary with the
13. dependent.
One continuous
Categorical with ≥2 groups
one or more additional
ANCOVA
Do differences exist between ≥2 groups on one DV after
controlling for the covariates
Explore the differences between ≥2 groups on multiple DVs
≥2 groups (continuous)
Categorical with ≥2 groups
one or more additional
MANOVA
Do differences exist between ≥2 groups on multiple DVs
Explanation or prediction tests:
How much variance in the DV is accounted for by linear
combination of the IVs
1 continuous
≥2 Dichotomous Continuous
Multiple regression
How strongly related to the DV is the beta coefficient for each
IV
What is the odds or the probability of the DV occurring as the
values of the IVs change?
1 dichotomous
1 or more Categorical or continuous
Logistic regression
What are the odds or the probability of the DV occurring as the
values of the IVs change
Practice exercise
Research Objective
# and type of DV
# and type of IV
Covariates
15. G U I D E L I N E S F O R T H E A D V A N C E D
H E A L T H S E R V I C E S M A N A G E M E N T A N D
R E S E A R C H S E M I N A R
M A S T E R O F H E A L T H S E R V I C E S
A D M I N I S T R A T I O N
1
Guidelines
...............................................................................................
............... 2
Part I: Advanced Research Seminar 6717 Research Overview
............................. 3
Advanced Health Services Management Research Seminar HSA
6717 Overview.4
Part II: 6977 Masters Research Project
Overview….…………………………………………..5
Organization of the Research Proposal
16. .................................................................. 6
Introduction/Background
................................................................................... 6
Statement of Problem
......................................................................................... 6
Significance of Study
........................................................................................... 7
Literature Review
...............................................................................................
8
Research Methods
............................................................................... .............
10
Part II: 6977 Masters Research
Project…………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………17
Data
Analysis………………………………………………………………
………………………………….18
Results………………………………………………….……………
…………………………………………..19
Discussion, Recommendations, and
Conclusions………………………………………….………………
…………………………………………22
17. References………………………………………….…………………
……………………………………….24
CONTENTS
2
A Masters degree contributes to the professional mastery of an
administrative career in
health services administration. The Masters in Health Services
Administration prepares
students with hands-on experience in conducting research and
interacting with leaders while
working in an administrative residency in health service
administration. The student
conducts a research project on a specific healthcare management
problem or enrolls in the
Administrative Residency. At some point in the program, the
student may choose enrollment
in research or the residency based on their interest.
Typically students enroll in the Professional Seminar (HSA
18. 6930) and the Advanced
Research Seminar (HSA 6717), where all students develop a
research proposal by the end of
the semester.
The student has the choice to enroll in either the
Administrative Residency (HSA 6875)
or the Masters Research Project (HSA 6977). If the student
chooses to enroll in the HSA
6977 instead of the HSA 6875, then the student advances in
their research project. Students
who completed their research proposal during the Advanced
Research Seminar may
continue to work in the final portion of the research project to
fulfill the requirements for
HSA 6977. Page 4 of this guide describes the research project
structure in detail.
The student who chooses to conduct a research project will
finalize the research project
within two semesters— during the Advanced Research Seminar
(HSA 6717) and the
Advanced Health Services Management and Research Seminar
(HSA 6977) course. Below
19. there is a description of the Masters Program structure with
either of these choices.
Guidelines
3
The first objective of these guidelines is to provide a roadmap
for the student on both the
Advanced Research Seminar and the Masters Research Project.
Students should know in
advance about the program research expectations. If a student
decides to continue on the
research project path, they have the opportunity to continue to
20. work on the research project
in their interest area. To ensure the student's success, follow
these guidelines in preparation
for your research project.
The second objective of this guide is to show students the
components for conducting
quantitative and/or qualitative studies, depending on the type of
research design as
applicable.
Students are responsible for ensuring the research paper is free
of errors in form, style,
spelling, and grammar. Students should follow the American
Psychological Association
(APA) writing format. For more information on the APA writing
style, consult the 7th
edition manual.
4
Advanced Research Seminar 6717 Overview
21. WEEK 1-2: Topic Selection
o Students enrolled in the Advanced Research Seminar 6717
who are interested in research,
discuss a research topic with the course instructor.
o Meet the course instructor to discuss potential topics (within
the first three weeks).
o Search the literature to narrow down a topic of interest.
o Develop an annotated bibliography.
o Select a feasible research topic within the first three (3)
weeks.
Note: Students who do not meet the topic selection deadline
will be offered the opportunity to
register in the Administrative Residency HSA 6875.
WEEK 3-7: Develop Research Question and Purpose of Study
o Meet with the course instructor to discuss the research
progress and proposed topic.
o Discuss a research proposal structure/plan
o Develop a research question
22. o Develop Introduction/Background, Statement of Problem,
Purpose, and Significance of
Research
WEEK 8-11
o Start the Literature Review: Continue to research and annotate
sources
o Start the methods section
WEEK 12-14
o Turn in a comprehensive research proposal including a list of
references
5
Advanced Health Services Management Seminar
HSA 6977 Overview
23. WEEK 1-3: Data collection
o Meet with the course instructor to discuss the research
progress and recruitment progress.
o Continue data collection process.
WEEK 4-5: Preliminary Analyses
o Meet with the course instructor to discuss a data analysis plan
and conduct analyses.
o Report and discuss preliminary analyses with the course
instructor
WEEK 6-7: Report participant demographics and other statistics
o Finalize analyses and reporting
WEEK 8-10: Write recommendations and conclusions
o Finalize the discussion, recommendations limitations and
conclusions write up
WEEK 11-12 Prepare research project presentation
24. o Final research project presentation
o Turn in final research paper
6
Organization of the Research Proposal
The research proposal allows the student to write a formal
written plan put forward for
consideration in the Professional Seminar.
When the student is writing the research proposal, it is written
in the future tense, since
the research has not been conducted.
Example: 'This research will explore…'
Title Page
The title page should include several sections: Project title,
25. name, name of the institution
name of the course instructor, and date the proposal is
submitted. Do not include a running head
on the title page.
The title should be brief yet informative, providing the reader
with a description of the
proposed topic of the research study. The title should reflect the
identification of the problem the
research assesses.
Introduction/Background
The first section must capture the reader's interest, provide a
rationale for the study as a whole,
and inform the reader about the research content and scope.
First, explain the research background starting from a broad
perspective (e.g., what is known
about the problem globally? What is the prevalence of the
problem nationwide? Second, describe
the problem at the local/state level.) Third, describe what is
known about the research topic.
26. This section includes relevant references to support the
statements part of the background. The
references should be from reliable sources of information, and
these should be accurate.
References can be found in the peer-reviewed literature (i.e.,
scholarly journals), books, and other
reliable sources.
Statement of Problem
The statement of the problem lays the foundation for the issues
being explored in the research
project. This section details why the problem requires research.
The statement of the problem
section usually starts by addressing why the student is pursuing
this research topic. Is it severe
enough to warrant the study? Next, place the problem and
research question in perspective,
develop a narrative on the demographics (introducing the
population of interest), and location of
the problem (setting/geographical location) or situation leading
to the applied research. It is
essential to provide compelling evidence the problem exists.
This section should also be supported
27. 7
by evidence-based references/citations. Cite relevant literature
to support the topic of interest and
the variables of the study.
Significance of the Study
This section narrates why the proposed research study is
relevant or meaningful and why
the study might be necessary. The use of literature is highly
recommended to describe the gaps in
the published literature, insufficient knowledge in the subject
area, or the need to validate the
findings of previous studies. Explain what the benefit or
contribution to new knowledge is.
Example: "This research is important to understand barriers to
access health care services
for South Florida residents with cardiovascular diseases. This
study is relevant to
understand better what the specific barriers are so that
28. intervention tailored to this
population are implemented."
Qualitative studies are exploratory in nature. An example of
qualitative research is Interviews
of clinical practitioners about the types of policies on a specific
health program or available
therapies to treat a disease. This type of research is
recommended when a researcher wants to
understand the population or area of interest from a behavioral
or analytical perspective.
Interpretations of the answers are required.
In qualitative studies, there is a guide to topics/themes. Through
this design, there is some
flexibility to explore the participant's responses through a
structured interview process.
If a student decides to use a qualitative study as the design of
their research, he/she shows the
study findings' using the research participants' direct narrative
quotes that should support the study
conclusions.
Qualitative research question example: "What are the relevant
29. barriers for access to
healthcare are for South Florida residents with cardiovascular
diseases."
Quantitative Research
Quantitative studies use a structured variable-specific survey
questionnaire or secondary data
collection. When using this type of research design, the student
uses a representative sample of the
population of interest. The student should be cautious about the
type of questions when using
questionnaires and should consult with the course instructor if
they are planning to use surveys to
collect data. The survey question (s) should follow the research
question objectives.
In these types of studies, the student should be able to speak
about the data that supports the
conclusions. In quantitative research, it is not possible to
subjectively interpret any results, as is the
case of qualitative research.
30. 8
Quantitative research question example: "What are the most
prevalent barriers to access
health care services identified by South Florida residents with
cardiovascular diseases?"
Literature Review
The purpose of the literature review is to describe the related
and existent evidence about the
topic of interest. Creswell (2014) suggests that the literature
review shares with the reader the
results of previous studies, related to the one being
proposed/conducted.
The literature review is a critical review and assessment of
current as well as previous research
studies or evidence in the field of study. This section compares
and contrasts previous studies
related to the topic chosen, combining, and summarizing related
studies.
The reader should be able to find a roadmap and a narrative
describing many aspects of the
31. literature on what is known about the topic. Start by explaining
the problem worldwide,
nationwide, and explain the varying results documented in the
literature.
Provide a logical structure to the reader, guiding them through
previous research studies and
theories supporting the proposed research, establishing the
importance of the topic.
Be critical and consistent. Provide an assessment of the
strengths and weaknesses of previous
and current studies.
Cooper (2010) & Creswell (2014) recognized four aspects of
literature reviews described below:
1) Integrate research/evidence that others have done or said
2) Criticize scholarly work
3) Build bridges between related topics
4) Identify the principal issues in a field
Example of a research question for the example below: "What
are the barriers to access
health care services identified by South Florida residents with
cardiovascular diseases?"
32. Literature Example: "Access to health care seems to be
improving in the United States
(Clooney, 2017). However, some research has found significant
increases in chronic diseases
such as cardiovascular diseases in the state of Florida (Jones-
Who, 2018). Therefore, more
research is needed to understand barriers for access to health
care services identified by South
Florida residents with cardiovascular diseases, since the
prevalence is rising. A recent study
found positive effects on access to health care and
cardiovascular disease outcomes (Clooney &
Comellas, 2018). Clooney and Comellas (2018) argued there is
an increasingly aging population
9
in South Florida identifying significant transportation barriers
to access preventive care
services."
33. According to Creswell (2014) (in quantitative research), the
literature review starts with a
(1) introduction section, followed by (2) topic 1 (the
independent variable) (3) topic 2 (the
dependent variable) and (4) topic 3 (studies that address both
the dependent and independent
variable) and (5) a summary highlighting the most important
studies (Creswell, 2014, p. 47).
The literature review for a qualitative and quantitative study is
written as part of the research
proposal.
Note: Use current literature / evidence. Seek the input from
your course instructor.
Literature Review: Step by Step
Creswell (2014) suggests several different ways to work on a
literature review:
1) Identify keywords to locate different materials in a library.
The keywords may emerge
from the literature, and it may allow for the identification of a
topic.
2) Search journals, books, databases (e.g., FIU computer
databases: ProQuest, EBSCO,
PubMed, etc.).
34. 3) Gather as many reports as possible that are related to the
research topic.
4) Skim through the articles. Creswell (2014) suggests that
throughout this process, it is
essential to try to gain a sense as to whether the research will
make a useful
contribution to the understanding of the literature.
5) Begin a literature map.
a. This is a visual picture or groupings of the literature on the
topic illustrating
how the study will contribute to the literature.
b. Position the study within the larger body of research.
6) Begin to draft summaries of the most relevant articles. Start
critiquing the previous
literature and point out deficiencies and issues with the
methods.
7) Assemble the literature review. Structure of the literature
thematically (use headings).
The literature review conclusion should suggest how the
proposed research may contribute
to the current literature and could address gaps in the current
literature.
35. 10
Research Methods
This section describes participant selection, the data collection
of the research procedures,
and data analysis.
This section starts with a description of the study design (i.e.,
qualitative and/or quantitative
design). The methods section includes the following:
1. Introduction. This section includes a reiteration of the
statement of the problem and the
research question.
2. Participants. This section includes the study population and
sample selection
(quantitative) or a description of study participants (e.g., males
and/or females, age range,
ethnicity, or other demographical characteristics). Describe how
the participants will be
chosen (qualitative), recruitment procedures, the estimated
number of participants, and
36. reimbursement or monetary compensations are given to
participants (if any) should be
specified.
3. Procedures for data collection. This section includes detailed
descriptions of procedures
(quantitative or qualitative) used/to be used to collect the data.
Anticipate how data will be
collected. Explain why each procedure was chosen. It is also
essential to describe how the
procedure will address the research questions.
4. Data Collection. In this course, data collection will be done
mainly through secondary
data (data collected by others, not the principal investigator).
Provide a rationale for the
procedures, using arguments based on its strengths and
weaknesses, costs, data availability
and/or convenience.
5. Ethical Considerations. This section should describe
foreseeable risks or discomforts
related to participation (if any). Everyone who decides to
participate in the study should receive
an informed consent form. The researcher should provide their
contact information in case the
participants request additional research-related information.
Qualitative and Quantitative Content
37. Qualitative Research
When conducting qualitative research, the aim is to address
people's experiences, needs, and
different perspectives. Qualitative research aims at
understanding and observing attitudes, life
circumstances, beliefs, opinions, behaviors, and processes in
depth.
Data is collected by interviewing people and recording the
responses as well as observing and
documenting participant body language. The conventional
approaches for facilitating interviews
are:
11
a. In-depth interviews: These are one on one interviews.
Researchers are interested in
understanding individual experiences or opinions.
b. Focus group interviews: The researcher attempts to discuss or
explore participants'
38. opinions in a group setting.
c. Telephone mediated interviews: The researcher interviews
participants by phone.
d. Online mediated interviews: These are one on one interviews
conducted online.
e. Observation: This is an approach often used as a supplement
to recording
participant's responses.
Quantitative Research
When conducting quantitative research, data is often gathered
using surveys either in person
or through the Internet. If the information is collected through a
survey questionnaire, it usually has
three sections: (a) inclusion/exclusion criteria, (b) demographic
information, and (c) the questions
assessing the study variable (s) of interest.
Participants
Qualitative Research
39. In qualitative research designs, the researcher purposely
identifies the individuals (usually
between 5 to 10 study participants) for the proposed study
(Creswell, 2014). He/she should have
in mind the research problem and which population (s) are
affected by the problem.
This section of the paper describes the selection of study
participants, explains the
characteristics of the participants, and describes the proposed
number of participants. It also
includes the inclusion and the exclusion criteria for including
the research population.
Quantitative Research
As is the case with qualitative research designs, this section
describes the selection of
participants (e.g., data), explaining the demographic
characteristics, and describing the proposed
number in the sample being studied. It also includes the
inclusion and exclusion criteria for
selecting the research sample. Sample sizes may vary based
upon the research aim/question (s).
Large sample sizes (e.g., ≥ 100), often leads to increased
40. accuracy in estimates about the
population.
Note: Students are encouraged to ask their course instructor for
recommendations on sample
sizes.
12
Procedures
Qualitative Research
This section describes the participant's recruitment process as
well as the methods used while
conducting the interviews (e.g., notes, audiotape recording, and
videotape recording). Discuss how
the group (if a focus group) will discuss a quiet, comfortable
place to ensure everyone
speaks/participate. Describe the development of a topic guide.
41. A topic guide is used in the
interview process to guide and discuss critical questions the
interviewer would like to cover,
including useful prompts to encourage discussion.
Include an explanation about transcribing the interview once the
participant's
interviews/discussions have ended. After transcribing, the
student reads the interviews (i.e., the
data) and start coding it.
Note: Coding is an approach used to organize the data by
grouping pieces (categorizing
the data) and writing a word representing a category (Rossman
& Rallis, 2012;
Creswell, 2014, p. 198). In qualitative research, data is
primarily in the form of
words derived from the participant's expressions on a subject
matter.
The data should be organized into categories of themes.
Describe how validity occurs in the
research process to validate the findings of the proposed study.
42. Describe one or more strategies for establishing the
accurateness of the findings. Some of the
commonly used strategies are described below:
a) Triangulation: Search for different data sources and use these
to build the justification of
themes (Creswell, 2014). If the researcher finds that the themes
are established based on
converging several sources of data or participant perspectives,
then this would add to the
validity of the study.
b) Member checking: Taking the emergent themes back to the
participants and asking them
if they feel the themes are correct.
Note: To check the reliability, researchers may cross-check the
results with an
independent person who can check the codes used by the
researcher. Consult the
course instructor for more information on these methods.
43. 13
Quantitative Research
In this section, the student documents the participant's
recruitment process (e.g., consecutively,
using a snowball approach, randomly, or other procedure that is
free from bias). The student must
always provide informed consent and specify the research is
voluntary to all participants before
starting the data collection process. Therefore, the student must
describe the informed consent
process in the methods section (if administering a survey).
This section describes the processes used while collecting the
research data. It documents all
the processes for gathering data, selecting participants (or
sites), providing copies of the consent
form (if applicable).
Describe the study variables, the parameters established for the
variable (s) of study (e.g.,
optimal health risk scores are defined as ≥10"), and how these
data collected was collected.
44. Data Collection
Qualitative Research
It is common to develop structured and semi-structured
questions and record each
participant's responses. The interview research question should
map to the main research
question.
When conducting qualitative research, an interview/discussion
guide is developed to conduct
the interviews. These questions address the main research
problem. Other data collected during
the interviews could include participant demographics (e.g.,
age, sex, race/ethnicity, income for
descriptive statistics).
Note: The student interviewer informs the research participant
of the location, day, and
time of the interview. The interviewer ensures the participants
have the interviewer
contact information in case they get lost, are delayed, or have
45. other problems before the
interview.
During and before the interview:
a) Provide an informed consent form indicating the research is
voluntary
b) Remind the research participants that they will be recorded
c) Remind the research participants that there are no right or
wrong answers during the
interview session (promote open and honest communication)
d) State name and the goal of meeting with the participants
e) Ask each participant to introduce themselves, state their
names or initials so that you
can later distinguish each participant responses
14
f) Do not redirect or interpret the respondent answers, or judge
g) Know the interview guide and questions
46. h) Do not bring any knowledge to the table
i) Be comfortable with silence
Note: Use probes as needed. For example – be silent, repeat the
statement they said, and
then continue neutrally ("I see, uh…"), direct ("Tell me more"),
and clarify (what,
where, when, what).
Quantitative Research
This section describes how many questions are going to be used
(even if it is secondary data
collection) and how the survey that led to the data collection
was developed.
Example: "The data used in this research is from the
cardiovascular diseases questionnaire used
in research conducted by the National Center for Health
Statistics of the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention. This is a national cross-sectional
research study representative of the
U.S. population. The interviewers were elderly persons and
minorities to provide a full
representation of the U.S population.
Note: If the student plans to use a survey or other form of data
collection, consult the
47. course instructor for guidance.
Sample Population (Participants)
Qualitative Research
In qualitative research designs, the researcher purposely
identifies the individuals (usually
between 5 to 10 study participants) for the proposed study
(Creswell, 2014). The student should
have in mind the research problem and which population (s) are
affected by the problem.
This section describes the selection of study participants,
explains the characteristics of the
participants, and describes the number of participants the
student plans to recruit. To determine
the sample size, consult the course instructor for guidance. This
section includes the inclusion
and exclusion criteria for study participation. The inclusion
criteria describe which participants
should be included in the research (e.g., individuals with
diabetes and/or people who had an HPV
vaccination, ages 18yrs and over).
48. Conversely, the exclusion criteria disqualify those individuals
(potential participants) who do
not meet the described characteristics the researcher is looking
for.
Quantitative Research
15
As is the case with qualitative research designs, this section of
the paper also describes the
selection of research participants, explains the characteristics of
the participants, and describes
the proposed number of participants. It also includes the
inclusion and exclusion criteria for
study participation (as described above). Samples sizes may
vary based upon the research
aim/question (s). Large sample sizes (e.g., ≥ 100), often leads to
increased accuracy in estimates
about the population. Students are encouraged to ask their
49. course instructor for recommendations
on sample sizes. The requirements for sample sizes may vary by
study design.
Instrumentation
Qualitative Research
This section describes the qualitative research approach to
open-ended questions. In
qualitative research, the …
Research Paper Checklist & Assessment for MHSA Students
The research paper information should be discussed with the
course instructor throughout all stages of the writing process.
Title
1
Fifteen (15) words or less. APA capitalization rules should be
followed.
Abstract (10pts)
2
The abstract should be written last. However, it is usually
placed after the Cover Page; not after the reference or anywhere
else. The abstract should be no more than 250 words. It includes
the following succinct parts:
Introduce the research topic (no citations)
The objective(s) of the study
Describe the participants characteristics (brief of results)
State the type of methodology (quantitative, qualitative, or
mixed method)
Include only key results of the study
50. Ex. Quantitative: use p-values to show significance and strength
of association
Ex. Qualitative: discuss major themes
Recommendations and Conclusions
Upon completion of the research, change the future tense to past
tense and include the results of the study.
Pagination and document format (10pts)
Use Microsoft Word. You may watch several YouTube videos
and choose one that you are comfortable with to guide you in
this process. This will require you to change the headings
throughout the document, which is totally fine. It will be in
accordance with APA format. Change/add more headings and
subheadings and update the work. Finally, include page
numbers.
Paper I: Introduction
This information should stimulate the interest of the reader.
Explain why this research is so important in the health
field/health services administration.
Background
Provide a rationale for the study
Discuss the variables
Have one or two sentences that introduce the other headings in
this paper
Last sentence is the purpose statement
This information should give an overview of the current
importance of the topic.
51. Problem Statement
Briefly highlight major actions that have been taken in regards
to the topic (use several citations). Include prevalence / relevant
statistics pertaining to the variables under study.
Write a paragraph describing the problem. The problem
statement should be supported by current literature.
Who is affected by this problem?
Where is the problem taking place?
Why is it important for the problem to be fixed?
What steps should be taken (possible solutions) to correct the
problem. For this, use the current literature (not older than 6yrs
from today). Use recent literature unless the information
pertains to a seminal/historic discovery paper/publication.
Research Aim/Question(s)
At the end of the study, what overall question will be answered?
Hypothesis
Quantitative Research (only):
If you are doing a quantitative study, a hypothesis should be
provided. Back up the hypothesis with literature.
The hypothesis clearly aligned with the purpose statement.
Each research aim/question should be followed by the research
hypothesis (Ha), then the null hypothesis (Ho).
Purpose of the Study
The purpose state is usually one or two sentences (not more
than two sentences). It should reflect the research aim/question.
Ask “Why is this study conducted?” Be sure not to confuse the
purpose with the problem. The purpose of the study should
include the following:
52. Describe the characteristics of the target participants
Significance of the Study
For this section, the researcher uses information from the
literature to justify the need for the research.
Definitions
Define important terms used in thestudy (very important).
Citation is needed for each definition.
Delimitations
Informs the reader the study is limited in scope. Examples:
Describe the specific aspects of the data, sample size,
participants’ characteristics, geographical location of the study,
and other factors to define the limits of the study.
Assumptions: Assumptions are primarily derived from the
literature. Researchers assume that the participants answer the
questions honestly and correctly; that they are able to read and
understand the survey questions; that they follow the
instructions carefully; that the test instrument is valid and
reliable.
This section tells the reader why the study is needed. Who will
benefit? What contribution does this research bring to society?
Gaps in the literature and/or insufficient knowledge in the
subject area is clearly stated
Literature Review
Use peer review journal article topics are related to the research
aim/question.
Begin writing this section with a statement that describes the
purpose of the research.
Discuss how the literature is organized. You might have to
53. revise this statement as you add or subtract information from
Paper2. Use subheadings to separate various parts of the
Literature Review. Check the APA Manual for different levels
of headings (for example, when to use Level 1, 2 or 3 headings).
Provide information that explains the search terms that you used
and describe the databases that were used to obtain the
information. Only include the search terms that helped you to
find information about the study.
After reading several published literature of the variables of
interest, you will need to synthesize them. Synthesizing
involves taking similar studies and looking at topics that they
have in common, (or different) to make themes. Write your
literature review in past tense. For example, Brown and
Forrester (2013) conducted a research on ….
As you are writing this section you should cite information from
the sources and build your reference list using APA format.
Methodology
This paper describes in details the data collection plan. This
section is called the “cookbook” or “recipe” portion of the
study. Therefore, the “ingredients” to bake the “cake” should be
listed, and a step-by step procedure explained. This includes
collecting and analyzing the data.
Restate the purpose of the study
Describe how the methodology is organized
Describe the Study design – cross-sectional, correlational,
descriptive, and others.
Characteristics of the participants
54. Selection of participants – how did you choose the research
participants? Include the inclusion and exclusion criteria for
choosing the participants.
Development and Selection of the instrumentation – give a
general description of the survey. For example, how many
questions and what the question will attempt to answer.
Is the instrument valid? Reliable? Provide such evidence
Ensure that the instrument answers the research aim/question(s)
Data collection procedures – how did you collect the data?
Data Analysis Procedures – How will you analyze the data? Ex.
SPSS, Excel, NVivo, etc.
Describe how you will analyze the independent and dependent
variables
Restate the research aim/question(s) and write the research and
null hypotheses for each research aim/question.
Ethical considerations – How did you protect the privacy and
confidentiality of the participants? How did you store the data?
**Did you analyzed the data collected? If yes, continue. If not,
consult your course instructor.
Part II
Data analysis and Results (10pts)
Results
After analyzing the data, you will need to report the results of
the study. This is the section that you will display the charts,
diagrams, frequencies etc.). Use / draw Microsoft Word tables
to depict the data accordingly.
55. This section includes the demographic information of the
research participants; descriptive information about the various
measures, and the results of the data analysis. Start with the
descriptive statistics, then go to the analytical data.
Discussion, Conclusions and Recommendations (10pts)
The purpose of the study is restated and important findings
should be summarized here. (No need to go into details).
The paper should include a summary of the research,
interpretation the results, the limitations of the study, and the
researcher makes recommendations based on the outcome of the
research.
As you discuss the implications, state how the research may
impact the individuals, family or society. Only materials
mentioned earlier should be included in the summary.
The conclusion should be the last one or two paragraphs of the
thesis. Provide a strong take-home message by bringing all the
main points together. Avoid saying exactly what you have said
before.
Limitations refer to weaknesses in the study. These weaknesses
often relate to the following:
a. sampling errors – ex. Small sample size limits generalization
of the study
b. uncontrolled variables
c. faulty instrumentation
d. representativeness of the data
e. compromises to internal and external validity
References (10pts)
References should be properly cited and typed according to the
APA Manual, 6th edition. The references go on a separate page.
All references used in-text must be typed in the reference
56. section. Similarly, all the references in this section should also
be in the text. References should be placed in alphabetical
order.
Appendix (10pts)
Documents that must be included in the appendix are:
1. Sample of informed consent letter
2. Permission letter to conduct research from stakeholders
3. Copy of the instrument (survey, questionnaire, interview
questions etc.)
**This section
Comments: _________________________________________
4 | Page
57. G U I D E L I N E S F O R T H E A D V A N C E D
H E A L T H S E R V I C E S M A N A G E M E N T A N D
R E S E A R C H S E M I N A R
M A S T E R O F H E A L T H S E R V I C E S
A D M I N I S T R A T I O N
1
Guidelines
...............................................................................................
............... 2
Part I: Advanced Research Seminar 6717 Research Overview
............................. 3
Advanced Health Services Management Research Seminar HSA
6717 Overview.4
Part II: 6977 Masters Research Project
58. Overview….…………………………………………..5
Organization of the Research Proposal
.................................................................. 6
Introduction/Background
................................................................................... 6
Statement of Problem
......................................................................................... 6
Significance of Study
........................................................................................... 7
Literature Review
...............................................................................................
8
Research Methods
............................................................................................
10
Part II: 6977 Masters Research
Project…………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………17
Data
Analysis………………………………………………………………
………………………………….18
Results………………………………………………….……………
…………………………………………..19
Discussion, Recommendations, and
59. Conclusions………………………………………….………………
…………………………………………22
References………………………………………….…………………
……………………………………….24
CONTENTS
2
A Masters degree contributes to the professional mastery of an
administrative career in
health services administration. The Masters in Health Services
Administration prepares
students with hands-on experience in conducting research and
interacting with leaders while
working in an administrative residency in health service
administration. The student
conducts a research project on a specific healthcare management
problem or enrolls in the
Administrative Residency. At some point in the program, the
student may choose enrollment
in research or the residency based on their interest.
60. Typically students enroll in the Professional Seminar (HSA
6930) and the Advanced
Research Seminar (HSA 6717), where all students develop a
research proposal by the end of
the semester.
The student has the choice to enroll in either the
Administrative Residency (HSA 6875)
or the Masters Research Project (HSA 6977). If the student
chooses to enroll in the HSA
6977 instead of the HSA 6875, then the student advances in
their research project. Students
who completed their research proposal during the Advanced
Research Seminar may
continue to work in the final portion of the research project to
fulfill the requirements for
HSA 6977. Page 4 of this guide describes the research project
structure in detail.
The student who chooses to conduct a research project will
finalize the research project
within two semesters— during the Advanced Research Seminar
(HSA 6717) and the
61. Advanced Health Services Management and Research Seminar
(HSA 6977) course. Below
there is a description of the Masters Program structure with
either of these choices.
Guidelines
3
The first objective of these guidelines is to provide a roadmap
for the student on both the
Advanced Research Seminar and the Masters Research Project.
Students should know in
advance about the program research expectations. If a student
62. decides to continue on the
research project path, they have the opportunity to continue to
work on the research project
in their interest area. To ensure the student's success, follow
these guidelines in preparation
for your research project.
The second objective of this guide is to show students the
components for conducting
quantitative and/or qualitative studies, depending on the type of
research design as
applicable.
Students are responsible for ensuring the research paper is free
of errors in form, style,
spelling, and grammar. Students should follow the American
Psychological Association
(APA) writing format. For more information on the APA writing
style, consult the 7th
edition manual.
4
63. Advanced Research Seminar 6717 Overview
WEEK 1-2: Topic Selection
o Students enrolled in the Advanced Research Seminar 6717
who are interested in research,
discuss a research topic with the course instructor.
o Meet the course instructor to discuss potential topics (within
the first three weeks).
o Search the literature to narrow down a topic of interest.
o Develop an annotated bibliography.
o Select a feasible research topic within the first three (3)
weeks.
Note: Students who do not meet the topic selection deadline
will be offered the opportunity to
register in the Administrative Residency HSA 6875.
WEEK 3-7: Develop Research Question and Purpose of Study
o Meet with the course instructor to discuss the research
progress and proposed topic.
o Discuss a research proposal structure/plan
64. o Develop a research question
o Develop Introduction/Background, Statement of Problem,
Purpose, and Significance of
Research
WEEK 8-11
o Start the Literature Review: Continue to research and annotate
sources
o Start the methods section
WEEK 12-14
o Turn in a comprehensive research proposal including a list of
references
5
Advanced Health Services Management Seminar
65. HSA 6977 Overview
WEEK 1-3: Data collection
o Meet with the course instructor to discuss the research
progress and recruitment progress.
o Continue data collection process.
WEEK 4-5: Preliminary Analyses
o Meet with the course instructor to discuss a data analysis plan
and conduct analyses.
o Report and discuss preliminary analyses with the course
instructor
WEEK 6-7: Report participant demographics and other statistics
o Finalize analyses and reporting
WEEK 8-10: Write recommendations and conclusions
o Finalize the discussion, recommendations limitations and
conclusions write up
66. WEEK 11-12 Prepare research project presentation
o Final research project presentation
o Turn in final research paper
6
Organization of the Research Proposal
The research proposal allows the student to write a formal
written plan put forward for
consideration in the Professional Seminar.
When the student is writing the research proposal, it is written
in the future tense, since
the research has not been conducted.
Example: 'This research will explore…'
67. Title Page
The title page should include several sections: Project title,
name, name of the institution
name of the course instructor, and date the proposal is
submitted. Do not include a running head
on the title page.
The title should be brief yet informative, providing the reader
with a description of the
proposed topic of the research study. The title should reflect the
identification of the problem the
research assesses.
Introduction/Background
The first section must capture the reader's interest, provide a
rationale for the study as a whole,
and inform the reader about the research content and scope.
First, explain the research background starting from a broad
perspective (e.g., what is known
about the problem globally? What is the prevalence of the
problem nationwide? Second, describe
the problem at the local/state level.) Third, describe what is
68. known about the research topic.
This section includes relevant references to support the
statements part of the background. The
references should be from reliable sources of information, and
these should be accurate.
References can be found in the peer-reviewed literature (i.e.,
scholarly journals), books, and other
reliable sources.
Statement of Problem
The statement of the problem lays the foundation for the issues
being explored in the research
project. This section details why the problem requires research.
The statement of the problem
section usually starts by addressing why the student is pursuing
this research topic. Is it severe
enough to warrant the study? Next, place the problem and
research question in perspective,
develop a narrative on the demographics (introducing the
population of interest), and location of
the problem (setting/geographical location) or situation leading
to the applied research. It is
69. essential to provide compelling evidence the problem exists.
This section should also be supported
7
by evidence-based references/citations. Cite relevant literature
to support the topic of interest and
the variables of the study.
Significance of the Study
This section narrates why the proposed research study is
relevant or meaningful and why
the study might be necessary. The use of literature is highly
recommended to describe the gaps in
the published literature, insufficient knowledge in the subject
area, or the need to validate the
findings of previous studies. Explain what the benefit or
contribution to new knowledge is.
Example: "This research is important to understand barriers to
access health care services
for South Florida residents with cardiovascular diseases. This
70. study is relevant to
understand better what the specific barriers are so that
intervention tailored to this
population are implemented."
Qualitative studies are exploratory in nature. An example of
qualitative research is Interviews
of clinical practitioners about the types of policies on a specific
health program or available
therapies to treat a disease. This type of research is
recommended when a researcher wants to
understand the population or area of interest from a behavioral
or analytical perspective.
Interpretations of the answers are required.
In qualitative studies, there is a guide to topics/themes. Through
this design, there is some
flexibility to explore the participant's responses through a
structured interview process.
If a student decides to use a qualitative study as the design of
their research, he/she shows the
study findings' using the research participants' direct narrative
quotes that should support the study
conclusions.
71. Qualitative research question example: "What are the relevant
barriers for access to
healthcare are for South Florida residents with cardiovascular
diseases."
Quantitative Research
Quantitative studies use a structured variable-specific survey
questionnaire or secondary data
collection. When using this type of research design, the student
uses a representative sample of the
population of interest. The student should be cautious about the
type of questions when using
questionnaires and should consult with the course instructor if
they are planning to use surveys to
collect data. The survey question (s) should follow the research
question objectives.
In these types of studies, the student should be able to speak
about the data that supports the
conclusions. In quantitative research, it is not possible to
subjectively interpret any results, as is the
case of qualitative research.
72. 8
Quantitative research question example: "What are the most
prevalent barriers to access
health care services identified by South Florida residents with
cardiovascular diseases?"
Literature Review
The purpose of the literature review is to describe the related
and existent evidence about the
topic of interest. Creswell (2014) suggests that the literature
review shares with the reader the
results of previous studies, related to the one being
proposed/conducted.
The literature review is a critical review and assessment of
current as well as previous research
studies or evidence in the field of study. This section compares
and contrasts previous studies
related to the topic chosen, combining, and summarizing related
studies.
73. The reader should be able to find a roadmap and a narrative
describing many aspects of the
literature on what is known about the topic. Start by explaining
the problem worldwide,
nationwide, and explain the varying results documented in the
literature.
Provide a logical structure to the reader, guiding them through
previous research studies and
theories supporting the proposed research, establishing the
importance of the topic.
Be critical and consistent. Provide an assessment of the
strengths and weaknesses of previous
and current studies.
Cooper (2010) & Creswell (2014) recognized four aspects of
literature reviews described below:
1) Integrate research/evidence that others have done or said
2) Criticize scholarly work
3) Build bridges between related topics
4) Identify the principal issues in a field
Example of a research question for the example below: "What
are the barriers to access
74. health care services identified by South Florida residents with
cardiovascular diseases?"
Literature Example: "Access to health care seems to be
improving in the United States
(Clooney, 2017). However, some research has found significant
increases in chronic diseases
such as cardiovascular diseases in the state of Florida (Jones-
Who, 2018). Therefore, more
research is needed to understand barriers for access to health
care services identified by South
Florida residents with cardiovascular diseases, since the
prevalence is rising. A recent study
found positive effects on access to health care and
cardiovascular disease outcomes (Clooney &
Comellas, 2018). Clooney and Comellas (2018) argued there is
an increasingly aging population
9
in South Florida identifying significant transportation barriers
to access preventive care
services."
75. According to Creswell (2014) (in quantitative research), the
literature review starts with a
(1) introduction section, followed by (2) topic 1 (the
independent variable) (3) topic 2 (the
dependent variable) and (4) topic 3 (studies that address both
the dependent and independent
variable) and (5) a summary highlighting the most important
studies (Creswell, 2014, p. 47).
The literature review for a qualitative and quantitative study is
written as part of the research
proposal.
Note: Use current literature / evidence. Seek the input from
your course instructor.
Literature Review: Step by Step
Creswell (2014) suggests several different ways to work on a
literature review:
1) Identify keywords to locate different materials in a library.
The keywords may emerge
from the literature, and it may allow for the identification of a
topic.
76. 2) Search journals, books, databases (e.g., FIU computer
databases: ProQuest, EBSCO,
PubMed, etc.).
3) Gather as many reports as possible that are related to the
research topic.
4) Skim through the articles. Creswell (2014) suggests that
throughout this process, it is
essential to try to gain a sense as to whether the research will
make a useful
contribution to the understanding of the literature.
5) Begin a literature map.
a. This is a visual picture or groupings of the literature on the
topic illustrating
how the study will contribute to the literature.
b. Position the study within the larger body of research.
6) Begin to draft summaries of the most relevant articles. Start
critiquing the previous
literature and point out deficiencies and issues with the
methods.
7) Assemble the literature review. Structure of the literature
thematically (use headings).
The literature review conclusion should suggest how the
proposed research may contribute
to the current literature and could address gaps in the current
literature.
77. 10
Research Methods
This section describes participant selection, the data collection
of the research procedures,
and data analysis.
This section starts with a description of the study design (i.e.,
qualitative and/or quantitative
design). The methods section includes the following:
1. Introduction. This section includes a reiteration of the
statement of the problem and the
research question.
2. Participants. This section includes the study population and
sample selection
(quantitative) or a description of study participants (e.g., males
and/or females, age range,
ethnicity, or other demographical characteristics). Describe how
78. the participants will be
chosen (qualitative), recruitment procedures, the estimated
number of participants, and
reimbursement or monetary compensations are given to
participants (if any) should be
specified.
3. Procedures for data collection. This section includes detailed
descriptions of procedures
(quantitative or qualitative) used/to be used to collect the data.
Anticipate how data will be
collected. Explain why each procedure was chosen. It is also
essential to describe how the
procedure will address the research questions.
4. Data Collection. In this course, data collection will be done
mainly through secondary
data (data collected by others, not the principal investigator).
Provide a rationale for the
procedures, using arguments based on its strengths and
weaknesses, costs, data availability
and/or convenience.
5. Ethical Considerations. This section should describe
foreseeable risks or discomforts
related to participation (if any). Everyone who decides to
participate in the study should receive
an informed consent form. The researcher should provide their
contact information in case the
participants request additional research-related information.
79. Qualitative and Quantitative Content
Qualitative Research
When conducting qualitative research, the aim is to address
people's experiences, needs, and
different perspectives. Qualitative research aims at
understanding and observing attitudes, life
circumstances, beliefs, opinions, behaviors, and processes in
depth.
Data is collected by interviewing people and recording the
responses as well as observing and
documenting participant body language. The conventional
approaches for facilitating interviews
are:
11
a. In-depth interviews: These are one on one interviews.
Researchers are interested in
understanding individual experiences or opinions.
80. b. Focus group interviews: The researcher attempts to discuss or
explore participants'
opinions in a group setting.
c. Telephone mediated interviews: The researcher interviews
participants by phone.
d. Online mediated interviews: These are one on one interviews
conducted online.
e. Observation: This is an approach often used as a supplement
to recording
participant's responses.
Quantitative Research
When conducting quantitative research, data is often gathered
using surveys either in person
or through the Internet. If the information is collected through a
survey questionnaire, it usually has
three sections: (a) inclusion/exclusion criteria, (b) demographic
information, and (c) the questions
assessing the study variable (s) of interest.
Participants
81. Qualitative Research
In qualitative research designs, the researcher purposely
identifies the individuals (usually
between 5 to 10 study participants) for the proposed study
(Creswell, 2014). He/she should have
in mind the research problem and which population (s) are
affected by the problem.
This section of the paper describes the selection of study
participants, explains the
characteristics of the participants, and describes the proposed
number of participants. It also
includes the inclusion and the exclusion criteria for including
the research population.
Quantitative Research
As is the case with qualitative research designs, this section
describes the selection of
participants (e.g., data), explaining the demographic
characteristics, and describing the proposed
number in the sample being studied. It also includes the
inclusion and exclusion criteria for
selecting the research sample. Sample sizes may vary based
82. upon the research aim/question (s).
Large sample sizes (e.g., ≥ 100), often leads to increased
accuracy in estimates about the
population.
Note: Students are encouraged to ask their course instructor for
recommendations on sample
sizes.
12
Procedures
Qualitative Research
This section describes the participant's recruitment process as
well as the methods used while
conducting the interviews (e.g., notes, audiotape recording, and
videotape recording). Discuss how
the group (if a focus group) will discuss a quiet, comfortable
83. place to ensure everyone
speaks/participate. Describe the development of a topic guide.
A topic guide is used in the
interview process to guide and discuss critical questions the
interviewer would like to cover,
including useful prompts to encourage discussion.
Include an explanation about transcribing the interview once the
participant's
interviews/discussions have ended. After transcribing, the
student reads the interviews (i.e., the
data) and start coding it.
Note: Coding is an approach used to organize the data by
grouping pieces (categorizing
the data) and writing a word representing a category (Rossman
& Rallis, 2012;
Creswell, 2014, p. 198). In qualitative research, data is
primarily in the form of
words derived from the participant's expressions on a subject
matter.
The data should be organized into categories of themes.
Describe how validity occurs in the
84. research process to validate the findings of the proposed study.
Describe one or more strategies for establishing the
accurateness of the findings. Some of the
commonly used strategies are described below:
a) Triangulation: Search for different data sources and use these
to build the justification of
themes (Creswell, 2014). If the researcher finds that the themes
are established based on
converging several sources of data or participant perspectives,
then this would add to the
validity of the study.
b) Member checking: Taking the emergent themes back to the
participants and asking them
if they feel the themes are correct.
Note: To check the reliability, researchers may cross-check the
results with an
independent person who can check the codes used by the
researcher. Consult the
course instructor for more information on these methods.
85. 13
Quantitative Research
In this section, the student documents the participant's
recruitment process (e.g., consecutively,
using a snowball approach, randomly, or other procedure that is
free from bias). The student must
always provide informed consent and specify the research is
voluntary to all participants before
starting the data collection process. Therefore, the student must
describe the informed consent
process in the methods section (if administering a survey).
This section describes the processes used while collecting the
research data. It documents all
the processes for gathering data, selecting participants (or
sites), providing copies of the consent
form (if applicable).
Describe the study variables, the parameters established for the
variable (s) of study (e.g.,
86. optimal health risk scores are defined as ≥10"), and how these
data collected was collected.
Data Collection
Qualitative Research
It is common to develop structured and semi-structured
questions and record each
participant's responses. The interview research question should
map to the main research
question.
When conducting qualitative research, an interview/discussion
guide is developed to conduct
the interviews. These questions address the main research
problem. Other data collected during
the interviews could include participant demographics (e.g.,
age, sex, race/ethnicity, income for
descriptive statistics).
Note: The student interviewer informs the research participant
of the location, day, and
time of the interview. The interviewer ensures the participants
87. have the interviewer
contact information in case they get lost, are delayed, or have
other problems before the
interview.
During and before the interview:
a) Provide an informed consent form indicating the research is
voluntary
b) Remind the research participants that they will be recorded
c) Remind the research participants that there are no right or
wrong answers during the
interview session (promote open and honest communication)
d) State name and the goal of meeting with the participants
e) Ask each participant to introduce themselves, state their
names or initials so that you
can later distinguish each participant responses
14
f) Do not redirect or interpret the respondent answers, or judge
88. g) Know the interview guide and questions
h) Do not bring any knowledge to the table
i) Be comfortable with silence
Note: Use probes as needed. For example – be silent, repeat the
statement they said, and
then continue neutrally ("I see, uh…"), direct ("Tell me more"),
and clarify (what,
where, when, what).
Quantitative Research
This section describes how many questions are going to be used
(even if it is secondary data
collection) and how the survey that led to the data collection
was developed.
Example: "The data used in this research is from the
cardiovascular diseases questionnaire used
in research conducted by the National Center for Health
Statistics of the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention. This is a national cross-sectional
research study representative of the
U.S. population. The interviewers were elderly persons and
minorities to provide a full
representation of the U.S population.
89. Note: If the student plans to use a survey or other form of data
collection, consult the
course instructor for guidance.
Sample Population (Participants)
Qualitative Research
In qualitative research designs, the researcher purposely
identifies the individuals (usually
between 5 to 10 study participants) for the proposed study
(Creswell, 2014). The student should
have in mind the research problem and which population (s) are
affected by the problem.
This section describes the selection of study participants,
explains the characteristics of the
participants, and describes the number of participants the
student plans to recruit. To determine
the sample size, consult the course instructor for guidance. This
section includes the inclusion
and exclusion criteria for study participation. The inclusion
criteria describe which participants
should be included in the research (e.g., individuals with
diabetes and/or people who had an HPV
90. vaccination, ages 18yrs and over).
Conversely, the exclusion criteria disqualify those individuals
(potential participants) who do
not meet the described characteristics the researcher is looking
for.
Quantitative Research
15
As is the case with qualitative research designs, this section of
the paper also describes the
selection of research participants, explains the characteristics of
the participants, and describes
the proposed number of participants. It also includes the
inclusion and exclusion criteria for
study participation (as described above). Samples sizes may
vary based upon the research
aim/question (s). Large sample sizes (e.g., ≥ 100), often leads to
91. increased accuracy in estimates
about the population. Students are encouraged to ask their
course instructor for recommendations
on sample sizes. The requirements for sample sizes may vary by
study design.
Instrumentation
Qualitative Research
This section describes the qualitative research approach to
open-ended questions. In
qualitative research, the …
92. G U I D E L I N E S F O R T H E A D V A N C E D
H E A L T H S E R V I C E S M A N A G E M E N T A N D
R E S E A R C H S E M I N A R
M A S T E R O F H E A L T H S E R V I C E S
A D M I N I S T R A T I O N
1
Guidelines
...............................................................................................
............... 2
Part I: Advanced Research Seminar 6717 Research Overview
............................. 3
Advanced Health Services Management Research Seminar HSA
6717 Overview.4
93. Part II: 6977 Masters Research Project
Overview….…………………………………………..5
Organization of the Research Proposal
.................................................................. 6
Introduction/Background
................................................................................... 6
Statement of Problem
......................................................................................... 6
Significance of Study
........................................................................................... 7
Literature Review
...............................................................................................
8
Research Methods
............................................................................................
10
Part II: 6977 Masters Research
Project…………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………17
Data
Analysis………………………………………………………………
………………………………….18
Results………………………………………………….……………
…………………………………………..19
94. Discussion, Recommendations, and
Conclusions………………………………………….………………
…………………………………………22
References………………………………………….…………………
……………………………………….24
CONTENTS
2
A Masters degree contributes to the professional mastery of an
administrative career in
health services administration. The Masters in Health Services
Administration prepares
students with hands-on experience in conducting research and
interacting with leaders while
working in an administrative residency in health service
administration. The student
conducts a research project on a specific healthcare management
problem or enrolls in the
Administrative Residency. At some point in the program, the
student may choose enrollment
95. in research or the residency based on their interest.
Typically students enroll in the Professional Seminar (HSA
6930) and the Advanced
Research Seminar (HSA 6717), where all students develop a
research proposal by the end of
the semester.
The student has the choice to enroll in either the
Administrative Residency (HSA 6875)
or the Masters Research Project (HSA 6977). If the student
chooses to enroll in the HSA
6977 instead of the HSA 6875, then the student advances in
their research project. Students
who completed their research proposal during the Advanced
Research Seminar may
continue to work in the final portion of the research project to
fulfill the requirements for
HSA 6977. Page 4 of this guide describes the research project
structure in detail.
The student who chooses to conduct a research project will
finalize the research project
within two semesters— during the Advanced Research Seminar
96. (HSA 6717) and the
Advanced Health Services Management and Research Seminar
(HSA 6977) course. Below
there is a description of the Masters Program structure with
either of these choices.
Guidelines
3
The first objective of these guidelines is to provide a roadmap
for the student on both the
Advanced Research Seminar and the Masters Research Project.
Students should know in
97. advance about the program research expectations. If a student
decides to continue on the
research project path, they have the opportunity to continue to
work on the research project
in their interest area. To ensure the student's success, follow
these guidelines in preparation
for your research project.
The second objective of this guide is to show students the
components for conducting
quantitative and/or qualitative studies, depending on the type of
research design as
applicable.
Students are responsible for ensuring the research paper is free
of errors in form, style,
spelling, and grammar. Students should follow the American
Psychological Association
(APA) writing format. For more information on the APA writing
style, consult the 7th
edition manual.
98. 4
Advanced Research Seminar 6717 Overview
WEEK 1-2: Topic Selection
o Students enrolled in the Advanced Research Seminar 6717
who are interested in research,
discuss a research topic with the course instructor.
o Meet the course instructor to discuss potential topics (within
the first three weeks).
o Search the literature to narrow down a topic of interest.
o Develop an annotated bibliography.
o Select a feasible research topic within the first three (3)
weeks.
Note: Students who do not meet the topic selection deadline
will be offered the opportunity to
register in the Administrative Residency HSA 6875.
WEEK 3-7: Develop Research Question and Purpose of Study
o Meet with the course instructor to discuss the research
progress and proposed topic.
99. o Discuss a research proposal structure/plan
o Develop a research question
o Develop Introduction/Background, Statement of Problem,
Purpose, and Significance of
Research
WEEK 8-11
o Start the Literature Review: Continue to research and annotate
sources
o Start the methods section
WEEK 12-14
o Turn in a comprehensive research proposal including a list of
references
5
100. Advanced Health Services Management Seminar
HSA 6977 Overview
WEEK 1-3: Data collection
o Meet with the course instructor to discuss the research
progress and recruitment progress.
o Continue data collection process.
WEEK 4-5: Preliminary Analyses
o Meet with the course instructor to discuss a data analysis plan
and conduct analyses.
o Report and discuss preliminary analyses with the course
instructor
WEEK 6-7: Report participant demographics and other statistics
o Finalize analyses and reporting
WEEK 8-10: Write recommendations and conclusions
101. o Finalize the discussion, recommendations limitations and
conclusions write up
WEEK 11-12 Prepare research project presentation
o Final research project presentation
o Turn in final research paper
6
Organization of the Research Proposal
The research proposal allows the student to write a formal
written plan put forward for
consideration in the Professional Seminar.
When the student is writing the research proposal, it is written
in the future tense, since
the research has not been conducted.
Example: 'This research will explore…'
102. Title Page
The title page should include several sections: Project title,
name, name of the institution
name of the course instructor, and date the proposal is
submitted. Do not include a running head
on the title page.
The title should be brief yet informative, providing the reader
with a description of the
proposed topic of the research study. The title should reflect the
identification of the problem the
research assesses.
Introduction/Background
The first section must capture the reader's interest, provide a
rationale for the study as a whole,
and inform the reader about the research content and scope.
First, explain the research background starting from a broad
perspective (e.g., what is known
about the problem globally? What is the prevalence of the
problem nationwide? Second, describe
103. the problem at the local/state level.) Third, describe what is
known about the research topic.
This section includes relevant references to support the
statements part of the background. The
references should be from reliable sources of information, and
these should be accurate.
References can be found in the peer-reviewed literature (i.e.,
scholarly journals), books, and other
reliable sources.
Statement of Problem
The statement of the problem lays the foundation for the issues
being explored in the research
project. This section details why the problem requires research.
The statement of the problem
section usually starts by addressing why the student is pursuing
this research topic. Is it severe
enough to warrant the study? Next, place the problem and
research question in perspective,
develop a narrative on the demographics (introducing the
population of interest), and location of
the problem (setting/geographical location) or situation leading
104. to the applied research. It is
essential to provide compelling evidence the problem exists.
This section should also be supported
7
by evidence-based references/citations. Cite relevant literature
to support the topic of interest and
the variables of the study.
Significance of the Study
This section narrates why the proposed research study is
relevant or meaningful and why
the study might be necessary. The use of literature is highly
recommended to describe the gaps in
the published literature, insufficient knowledge in the subject
area, or the need to validate the
findings of previous studies. Explain what the benefit or
contribution to new knowledge is.
Example: "This research is important to understand barriers to
access health care services
105. for South Florida residents with cardiovascular diseases. This
study is relevant to
understand better what the specific barriers are so that
intervention tailored to this
population are implemented."
Qualitative studies are exploratory in nature. An example of
qualitative research is Interviews
of clinical practitioners about the types of policies on a specific
health program or available
therapies to treat a disease. This type of research is
recommended when a researcher wants to
understand the population or area of interest from a behavioral
or analytical perspective.
Interpretations of the answers are required.
In qualitative studies, there is a guide to topics/themes. Through
this design, there is some
flexibility to explore the participant's responses through a
structured interview process.
If a student decides to use a qualitative study as the design of
their research, he/she shows the
study findings' using the research participants' direct narrative
quotes that should support the study
106. conclusions.
Qualitative research question example: "What are the relevant
barriers for access to
healthcare are for South Florida residents with cardiovascular
diseases."
Quantitative Research
Quantitative studies use a structured variable-specific survey
questionnaire or secondary data
collection. When using this type of research design, the student
uses a representative sample of the
population of interest. The student should be cautious about the
type of questions when using
questionnaires and should consult with the course instructor if
they are planning to use surveys to
collect data. The survey question (s) should follow the research
question objectives.
In these types of studies, the student should be able to speak
about the data that supports the
conclusions. In quantitative research, it is not possible to
subjectively interpret any results, as is the
107. case of qualitative research.
8
Quantitative research question example: "What are the most
prevalent barriers to access
health care services identified by South Florida residents with
cardiovascular diseases?"
Literature Review
The purpose of the literature review is to describe the related
and existent evidence about the
topic of interest. Creswell (2014) suggests that the literature
review shares with the reader the
results of previous studies, related to the one being
proposed/conducted.
The literature review is a critical review and assessment of
current as well as previous research
studies or evidence in the field of study. This section compares
and contrasts previous studies
related to the topic chosen, combining, and summarizing related
108. studies.
The reader should be able to find a roadmap and a narrative
describing many aspects of the
literature on what is known about the topic. Start by explaining
the problem worldwide,
nationwide, and explain the varying results documented in the
literature.
Provide a logical structure to the reader, guiding them through
previous research studies and
theories supporting the proposed research, establishing the
importance of the topic.
Be critical and consistent. Provide an assessment of the
strengths and weaknesses of previous
and current studies.
Cooper (2010) & Creswell (2014) recognized four aspects of
literature reviews described below:
1) Integrate research/evidence that others have done or said
2) Criticize scholarly work
3) Build bridges between related topics
4) Identify the principal issues in a field
109. Example of a research question for the example below: "What
are the barriers to access
health care services identified by South Florida residents with
cardiovascular diseases?"
Literature Example: "Access to health care seems to be
improving in the United States
(Clooney, 2017). However, some research has found significant
increases in chronic diseases
such as cardiovascular diseases in the state of Florida (Jones-
Who, 2018). Therefore, more
research is needed to understand barriers for access to health
care services identified by South
Florida residents with cardiovascular diseases, since the
prevalence is rising. A recent study
found positive effects on access to health care and
cardiovascular disease outcomes (Clooney &
Comellas, 2018). Clooney and Comellas (2018) argued there is
an increasingly aging population
9
in South Florida identifying significant transportation barriers
to access preventive care
110. services."
According to Creswell (2014) (in quantitative research), the
literature review starts with a
(1) introduction section, followed by (2) topic 1 (the
independent variable) (3) topic 2 (the
dependent variable) and (4) topic 3 (studies that address both
the dependent and independent
variable) and (5) a summary highlighting the most important
studies (Creswell, 2014, p. 47).
The literature review for a qualitative and quantitative study is
written as part of the research
proposal.
Note: Use current literature / evidence. Seek the input from
your course instructor.
Literature Review: Step by Step
Creswell (2014) suggests several different ways to work on a
literature review:
1) Identify keywords to locate different materials in a library.
The keywords may emerge
from the literature, and it may allow for the identification of a
111. topic.
2) Search journals, books, databases (e.g., FIU computer
databases: ProQuest, EBSCO,
PubMed, etc.).
3) Gather as many reports as possible that are related to the
research topic.
4) Skim through the articles. Creswell (2014) suggests that
throughout this process, it is
essential to try to gain a sense as to whether the research will
make a useful
contribution to the understanding of the literature.
5) Begin a literature map.
a. This is a visual picture or groupings of the literature on the
topic illustrating
how the study will contribute to the literature.
b. Position the study within the larger body of research.
6) Begin to draft summaries of the most relevant articles. Start
critiquing the previous
literature and point out deficiencies and issues with the
methods.
7) Assemble the literature review. Structure of the literature
thematically (use headings).
The literature review conclusion should suggest how the
proposed research may contribute
112. to the current literature and could address gaps in the current
literature.
10
Research Methods
This section describes participant selection, the data collection
of the research procedures,
and data analysis.
This section starts with a description of the study design (i.e.,
qualitative and/or quantitative
design). The methods section includes the following:
1. Introduction. This section includes a reiteration of the
statement of the problem and the
research question.
2. Participants. This section includes the study population and
sample selection
(quantitative) or a description of study participants (e.g., males