The advancement of science and technology and subsequent industrial processes such as Industry 4.0 should be perceived as an opportunity to transform society from unsustainable living to more sustainable future. One of the challenging issues is how to engage non-state actors, particularly community at grassroot level. The presentation will share some concerns of the issues based on the lesson learnt in promoting sustaibility agenda in some initiatives in Indonesia.

1. Promoting Sustainability Agenda at Micro Level:
Translating Ideas into Reality
Workshop on Community Empowerment through Waqf Scheme
Bandung, September 6, 2019

2. OUTLINE
My Reflection on Change, Behavior and Design Problems
Climate Change Issues, Sustainability and Knowledge Creation
Translating Ideas on the Ground:
§ 21st Library: Library as Co-sharing Space
§ Media Aggregation through Geve2015.radio
§ #SADAP4Citarum (One Data, and One Map for Citarum Watershed))
§ # GreenPesantren
§ Disability and Inclusive living Community Engagement (#DICE)
§ #Youth Entrepreneurship
Final Thought: Crowd Sourcing Platform
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

3. REFLECTION ON CHANGE, BEHAVIOR AND DESIGN PROBLEMS:
INDONESIA IN 2 DECADES (1998– NOW)
Big Political Economy and
Environmental Events Reformasi (1998),
Decentralization(2002), 1st Presidential direct election
(2004), Tsunami Aceh (2004), Big Forest Fires (2007),
Bali Action Plan (2008), Paris Agreement (2015)
Technology Yahoo Messenger(2002), Soutcast,
YouTube, other social media, Big Data, Artificial
Intelligence(AI), Internet of Things(IoT), Data Science,
Machine Learning, …
Paradoxes at Micro Level inclusiveness,
accountability, engagement, “value” mis-match, lack of
science based analysis, system delay, …
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT
https://youtu.be/LoUHZG7UgNY

4. REFLECTION ON ACCESS TO PUBLIC FACILITIES & DESIGN PROBLEM: A CASE IN POINT
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

5. GREEN VOICE AT GLANCE
PROCEEDINGS. Initially, Green Voice was a multi-stakeholder initiative facilitated by Indonesia Climate Change
Center (ICCC), a program supported by National Council on Climate Change (NCCC) and the US Forest Service (USFS)
with funding support from the US-Indonesia Partnership (2010-2014). In October 2014, this initiative was further
developed as Green Voice Foundation (GVF) by extending its activities to cover broader issues of sustainability
including art, science, technology, and education based on what had been achieved by ICCC. In the last 2 years GVF
had been continuing working with international and key national organizations such as UNDP, UNICEF, International
Labour Organization(ILO), ICLEI-Indonesia, Plan-International/Indonesia, Office of the President’s Special
Envoy(UKPPI), UK-Climate Change Office, Green Economy Caucus of Indonesia Parliament(DPR-RI), Thamrin School of
Climate Change and Sustainability as well as Universities (ITB, UPI). In 2016, GVF in cooperation with Climate Change
Center (PPI) of Bandung Institute of Technology (ITB) initiated Sustainable Investment Talks aims at promoting design
and innovation of “sustainability”. Also, with the same spirit expanded networking activities through the establishment
Green Engagement Network (Indonesia, ASEAN, and Asia-Africa countries) and Online Broadcasting Radio
Geve2015.org.
VISION. Enlightening society towards Greener Indonesia movement by the time of global climate change and related
agreements ratified in 2015 and beyond
MISSION and CORE VALUES. Communicating green vision and mission to outreach society awareness through media
aggregation platform that focus on art, science, technology and education, and its related activities. We believe that
sustainable society can be achieved with strong-inclusive governance and engagement, open-minded and critical
thinking, respect to human being and nature, applying impartiality in everyday life, creating and sharing accessible
knowledge that educates, informs and ignites.
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

6. RELEVANT ACTIVITIES (2014-2019)
#PESANTREN GREEN | ASCODI LABORATORI, GVI
Partnerships
2014 • Green Voice Days (ICCC, UPI, DNPI, MGF)
2015 • #Road2Paris (UNICEF, GVF, Plan International, UKPPI,YFCC)
2016 • Launching Green Investment Talks (GVF, PPI-ITB)
• Launching 21st Library Initiative (GVF, PPI-ITB)
• Green Engagement Network-Indonesia (I-GEN), www.greenengagement.net
• GeVe2015.radio Online Radio/Podcasting, www.geve2015.radio
• #Road2Marrakesch, COP-22 Awareness (GVF, ICCTF and partners)
2017 • #Road2Bonn, COP-23 (Sept-Dec),
2018 • Bandung #Sruput
2019 • #SADAP4Citarum (Satu Data, Satu Peta untuk Citarum)
• #GreenPesantren
• #DICE (Disability and Inclusive Living and Community Engagement)

7. #GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT
“Acknowledging that climate change is a common concern of
humankind, Parties should, when taking action to address climate change,
respect, promote and consider their respective obligations on human rights, the
right to health, the rights of indigenous peoples, local communities,
migrants, children, persons with disabilities and people in vulnerable
situations and the right to development, as well as gender equality,
empowerment of women and intergenerational equity”.
Paris Agreement, 2015

8. SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT GOALS(SDGS) & CLIMATE CHANGE
Global Initiatives:
•1.5 degree Synthesis Report (IPCC, 2018)
• Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs, 2015)
• Paris Agreement (UNFCC, 2015)
• Global Initiatives on Green Economy
• Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) (UN, 2015)
National Responses (government and non-government)
• Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC), 29% and 41% CO2 emission target
• Low Carbon Development Scenarios (Bappenas, 2019)
• National Mid-term Development Plan 2020-2024: Technocratic Scenarios
(Bappenas, 2019)
• SDGs Indonesia
•Means of Implementation (finance, technology, capacity building)
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT
Source: UN (2015)

9. CLIMATE CHANGE ISSUES & KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT
Climate Change Issues:
system dynamic issues (social/human,
space, time)
Knowledge Management to use
data science approach by integrating
extensive digital data acquisition,
thematic knowledge and computing
capability.
Knowledge Creation and
Public Literacy through new
media platform for inclusive
information exchange and
transparency.
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

10. CLIMATE CHANGE, SUSTAINABILITY AGENDA & NATIONAL RESPONSES
Global Initiatives:
•1.5 degree Synthesis Report (IPCC, 2018)
•Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs, 2015)
•Paris Agreement (UNFCC, 2015)
• Global Initiatives on Green Economy (WAVES, New Climate Economy, Page,
etc.)
National Responses (government and non-government)
•Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC), 29% and 41% CO2 emission
target
•Low Carbon Development Scenarios (Bappenas, 2019)
•National Mid-term Development Plan 2020-2024: Technocratic Scenarios
(Bappenas, 2019)
•Means of Implementation (finance, technology, capacity building)
Source: Global Warming of 1.5 C, IPCC Special Report, 2018
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

11. MITIGATION OPTIONS, SDGS, TRANSFORMATIONAL ISSUES
Mitigation options deployed in each sector can be associated with potential
positive effects (synergies) or negative effects (trade-offs) with the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). The degree to which this potential is
realized will depend on the selected portfolio of mitigation options,
mitigation policy design, and local circumstances and context. Particularly in
the energy-demand sector, the potential for synergies is larger than for trade-
offs. The bars group individually assessed options by level of confidence and
take into account the relative strength of the assessed mitigation-SDG
connections.
Some Findings
D1. Estimates of the global emissions outcome of current nationally stated
mitigation ambitions as submitted under the Paris Agreement would lead to
global greenhouse gas emissions18 in 2030 of 52–58 GtCO2eq yr-1 (medium
confidence). Pathways reflecting these ambitions would not limit global warming
to 1.5°C, even if supplemented by very challenging increases in the scale and
ambition of emissions reductions after 2030 (high confidence). Avoiding
overshoot and reliance on future large-scale deployment of carbon dioxide
removal(CDR) can only be achieved if global CO2 emissions start to decline
well before 2030
SouClimate Change Issues: system dynamic issues (social/human, space, time)
rce: Global Warming of 1.5 C, IPCC Special Report, 2018
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

12. MITIGATION OPTIONS, SDGS, TRANSFORMATIONAL ISSUES (CONT’D)
D2. The avoided climate change impacts on sustainable development, eradication of poverty
and reducing inequalities would be greater if global warming were limited to 1.5°C rather
than 2°C, if mitigation and adaptation synergies are maximized while trade-offs are minimized
(high confidence).
D3. Adaptation options specific to national contexts, if carefully selected together with
enabling conditions, will have benefits for sustainable development and poverty reduction with
global warming of 1.5°C, although trade-offs are possible (high confidence)
D4. Mitigation options consistent with 1.5°C pathways are associated with multiple synergies
and trade-offs across the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) While the total number of
possible synergies exceeds the number of trade-offs, their net effect will depend on the pace
and magnitude of changes, the composition of the mitigation portfolio and the management of
the transition.
D5. Limiting the risks from global warming of 1.5°C in the context of sustainable development
and poverty eradication implies system transitions that can be enabled by an increase of
adaptation and mitigation investments, policy instruments, the acceleration of technological
innovation and behaviour changes (high confidence).
D7. Strengthening the capacities for climate action of national and sub-national authorities,
civil society, the private sector, indigenous peoples and local communities can support the
implementation of ambitious actions implied by limiting global warming to 1.5°C (high
confidence). International cooperation can provide an enabling environment for this to be
achieved in all countries and for all people, in the context of sustainable development.
International cooperation is a critical enabler for developing countries and vulnerable regions
(high confidence).
Source: Global Warming of 1.5 C, IPCC Special Report, 2018
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

13. COMMUNITY BASED INITIATIVES: THEORITICAL FOUNDATION
Community based is other alternative in managing
“Commons”/Common Pool Resources (CPR), such as collective
forest, collective space outside State and Market (Ostrom, 1990)
8 Principles of successful self-governance:
• The CPR has clearly-defined boundaries (effective exclusion of external unentitled parties)
• There is congruence between the resource environment and its governance structure or rules
• Decisions are made through collective-choice arrangements that allow most resource
appropriators to participate
• Rules are enforced through effective monitoring by monitors who are part of or accountable
to the appropriators
• Violations are punished with graduated sanctions
• Conflicts and issues are addressed with low-cost and easy-to-access conflict resolution
mechanisms
• Higher-level authorities recognize the right of the resource appropriators to self-govern
In the case of larger common-pool resources: rules are organized and enforced through
multiple layers of nested enterprises
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

14. 3 FOUNDATIONS IN TRANSLATING IDEAS AT MICRO LEVEL
Community Center
• Training Center
• Digital/Knowledge Production House
• SME Incubation
“Proof of Concept”
§ 21st Library: Library as Co-sharing Space
§ Media Aggregation through Geve2015.radio
§ #SADAP4Citarum (One Data, and One Map for Citarum Watershed))
§ # GreenPesantren
§ Disability and Inclusive living Community Engagement (#DICE)
§ #Youth Entrepreneurship
Information Network
• Digitalization
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT
Source: ESRI-Indonesia (2018)

15. (0). LIBRARY AS CO-SHARING SPACE (2016)
We realized that there is to a lesser and greater extent a worry, as we
see as of now, that data and information flooding, aka infobesity, drives
the individuals and organizations into misleading behavior and
responses. It seems there is a delay and misconceived in responding to a
digital revolution, “old treatments” to counter to new dynamics.
At individual level, it is also important to understand and apply the value
of “diversity in unity” as one of shared values as the nature teach us.
Sustainable society will be materialized if we treat human being and
nature respectfully regardless their background.
In 2016, Green Voice Foundation, Climate Change Research Center(PPI)
and Central Library of Bandung Institute of Technology(ITB) initiated 21st
Library initiative, an initiative aims at reinventing a new library role
as a place not only as a ”book store” but also as a meeting point to
exchange ideas, experiences, knowledge as well as collaborative
engagement.
As part of continual engagement, we seek to expand the following
activities to the youth entities:
­ 21st Library at Senior High School and University
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

16. (1). TRANSLATING IDEAS: MEDIA AGGREGATION (2014 – UP TO DATE)
WWW.GEVE2015.RADIO
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

17. (2). TRANSLATING IDEAS: CITARUM WATERSHED (2018 – NOW)
The Dynamics: 1.1 million hectares, more than 18
million inhabitants, 1500 industries, land use
change, disaster and resilience, complicated
hierarchical governance (national, provincial,
districts)
Knowledge Management:
• scatter, quality and quality diverse, lack of time-series,
untraceable hard copy, no data clearing house at micro
level (data)
• more than 6000 researches already (thematic)
• Computing capacity (?)
Initiative: One Data and One Map 4 Citarum
(#SADAP4Citarum)
• Open and crowd sourcing platform based on ESRI and
other open source software (QGIS, R-STATS, ISSUU, etc)
• Facilitate by Green Voice Indonesia, Center for Remote
Sensing ITB and ESRI-Indonesia
• www.sadap4citarum.net (under development)
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

18. (2). TRANSLATING IDEAS: CITARUM WATERSHED (CONT’D)
Platform #SADAP4Citarum
• Database and Data Exchange
• Clearing House
• Data Story Telling
Thematic Collaboration
• Policy, governance and conflict resolution
• Spatial dynamics
• Sustainable economic development
• Science, technology and culture od watershed management
• Education and advocacy
Progress(as of April 2019)
• https://citarum-smartcommunity.opendata.arcgis.com/
• www.sadap4citarum.net
• Digitalization
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT
Source: ESRI-Indonesia (2018)

19. (3). TRANSLATING IDEAS: #GREENPESANTREN (2018 – NOW)
Community Center Development
• Library as a data sources and exchanges of data,
information and knowledge
• crowd sourcing based incubator
• Training Center for Green Entreuprenership (On/Off-
line)
• Community/Internet Radio, including podcasting.
Show Cases
• Small and Medium Enterprises (UMKM)
Information Network
• www.greenpesantren.net
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

20. (3). TRANSLATING IDEAS: #GREENPESANTREN (2018 – NOW)
Community Center Development
• Library as a data sources and exchanges of data,
information and knowledge
• crowd sourcing based incubator
• Training Center for Green Entreuprenership (On/Off-
line)
• Community/Internet Radio, including podcasting.
Show Cases
• Small and Medium Enterprises (UMKM)
Information Network
• www.greenpesantren.net
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

21. (3). TRANSLATING IDEAS: #GREENPESANTREN (CONT’D)
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

22. (3). TRANSLATING IDEAS: #GREENPESANTREN (CONT’D)
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

23. (4). TRANSLATING IDEAS: #DICE (2019 – NOW)
DISABILITY AND INCLUSIVE LIVING COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
Community Center Development
• Library as a data sources and exchanges of data,
information and knowledge
• crowd sourcing based incubator
• Training Center for Green Entreuprenership (On/Off-
line)
• Community/Internet Radio, including podcasting.
Show Cases
• Small and Medium Enterprises (UMKM)
Information Network
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

24. (5). TRANSLATING IDEAS: #YOUTH-ENTREUPRENEURSHIP(2017)
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

25. FINAL THOUGHT– CROWD SOURCING PLATFORM
Given the reality that Capacity Building requires a large amount of resources and
the need of consistent and continual implementation, crowd sourcing would be the
feasible option. Three strategic approaches are proposed:
• Shared Resource Mobilization. We are expecting interested individuals, organizations
share their resources in many kinds, it does not always necessarily mean a financial
resources. It could be an expertise, in-kind facilities for gathering as well as other support
to make the activities happened.
• Library and Community Center as a Hub. In the past library can be seen as huge store for
searching data, information and references. As of ICT progressively developed, the
traditional role of library is no longer applied as people easily accesses a huge piece of
information from around the world, even with just simply using smart phone. However, still
there is a big issues on how to facilitate information and knowledge exchange with this new
realm. The library can also be adjusted as a venue for crowdsourced gathering to solve the
emerging issues of the society.
• Platform as a basis for scaling up movement. The power of platform has been
recognized as an alternative business model that use technology to connect people,
organization and resources in interactive ecosystem in which amazing amount of value can
be created and exchanged (Parker, Geofrey G. et.al, 2015). As a growing ecosystem,
Youth engagement is also expected to grow in the coming years. Looking forward to this
potentials, we would like to use this model to expand the activities.
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

26. #GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT
Terimakasih
Thank You

27. ASCODI LAB PRINCIPAL DEVELOPER
M. FARHAN HELMY. A scientifically-trained independent professional of natural resource and
environmental policy analysis, with special interests and extensive experiences in forestry governance,
land use and land use change and forestry (LULUCF), disaster risk reduction, urban low emission
development strategies (Urban LEDS), green investment and innovations and the use of open-platform
and open-source based tools, such as Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and related analytical
tools. In 2014, Farhan was appointed as a Chairperson of Thamrin School of Climate Change and
Sustainability. He is also Founder and CEO of Advanced Systems COmputing, Design and Innovation
(ASCODI) Laboratory affiliated with Green Voice Foundation. Part of his concern on sustainble
production and consumption, and fair supply chain values on agriculture products, he joined the
Indonesia Sustainable Coffee Cooperatives (ISCC), System Dynamic Society, Internasional Society for
Ecological Economics(ISEE)
AVI S. TJOKRO. Educational Consultant, Curriculum Developers for manufacturing management,
managerial skills and environment with more than 20 years experienced in national and Asean. Project
Management for human resource development activities. Her speciality is a comprehensive and
effective management of activities using Total Quality Management. Currently Avi is Secretary of
Thamrin School of Climate Change and Sustainability. Her role at Green Voice Foundation is to manage
day to day activities.
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT

28. ON-LINE REFERENCES & INFORMATION INQUIRY
Official Website
• www.greenvoice.id & www.ascodilab.id (under new development)
• Facebook: @greenvoiceID, @ascodilab
• Twitter: @gvid_media, @ascodilab
Online Broadcasting/Podcasting GeVe2015.radio
• www.geve2015.radio
• Facebook: @geve2015dotorg
• Twitter: @geve2015
• You Tube Channel: geve2015dotorg
• Tunein: GeVe2015.org
Green Engagement Network (GENet)
• Facebook: @indonesiagenet
• Twitter: @indonesia_genet (Indonesia), @aseangenet (ASEAN countries), @asiaafricagenet
(Asia-Africa countries) @globalgenet (Global Network)
• ISSUU: greenengagementnetwork
#GVCOMMUNITYBASEDMOVEMENT