This study examined how the relationship between perceived mutual understanding and accuracy of understanding is moderated by media richness. The study involved 51 teams completing a crisis management task either via email (low richness) or face-to-face (high richness). Results showed that in the low richness condition, perceived mutual understanding was not related to accuracy of understanding. However, in the high richness face-to-face condition, perceived high mutual understanding was positively related to accuracy, while perceived low mutual understanding was negatively related to accuracy. The findings suggest that media richness influences whether perceptions of mutual understanding accurately reflect the level of shared understanding within teams.
Relational Development & Interpersonal Communication In Computer Mediated Con...maxbury
This document summarizes research on how computer-mediated communication affects relational development. It discusses how social information processing theory explains that in computer-mediated contexts, verbal cues of affinity and issues of time (chronemics) become especially important for developing relationships due to the lack of in-person nonverbal cues. Some research has found similarities between online and in-person relationship development, but most research cited finds that self-disclosure of meaningful information through text is important for developing relational closeness and attraction when communication is mediated by computers rather than face-to-face. The document provides examples of studies that have examined how factors like depth and breadth of self-disclosure can influence relationship development in online contexts.
E XPLORING T HE S ELF -E NHANCED M ECHANISM OF I NTERACTIVE A DVERTISING...ijma
The document discusses interactive advertising and explores its self-enhanced dissemination mechanism. It analyzes three cases of interactive ads: on official websites, social media, and mobile media. It identifies micro, meso, and macro level mechanisms. At the micro level, core, inner, and outer interaction reveal the process of interacting with content, people, and computers. The meso level shows self-fission-type spread and communication approaches. At the macro level, the communication effect of interactive advertising achieves a spiral increasing effect. The analysis enriches research on the communication effects of interactive advertising.
Delay Tolerant Networking routing as a Game Theory problem – An OverviewCSCJournals
This document discusses modeling delay tolerant networking (DTN) routing as a game theory problem. It provides background on DTN, which aims to enable communication in disrupted networks, and discusses how routing in DTN can be viewed as a strategic interaction between nodes. The document then gives an overview of game theory and different game forms. It proposes analyzing DTN routing as a game with Nash equilibrium, where nodes make forwarding decisions rationally based on beliefs about other nodes' actions.
This document summarizes research on the perception of influential messages related to dating. An analysis of 52 college students revealed confusion between terms like persuasion, manipulation, and coercion when applied to interpersonal relationships. The implications are that better defining these messages could help people understand and respond to them more purposefully. Further research is still needed to better distinguish different types of influence.
Influences of strong tie with opinion leaders in an interconnected network of...Myunggoon Choi
This document describes the research project "Influences of Strong Tie with Opinion Leaders in an Interconnected Network of Korea". The research questions examine the relationship between tie strength with opinion leaders and information exchange, and the relationship between strong ties with opinion leaders and their influence on peripheral network members. The literature review covers topics of information inequality, social network perspectives, opinion leaders hypotheses, tie strength, and influence. The methodology section outlines plans to measure opinion leaders and tie strength, influences of those with strong ties to opinion leaders, information exchange measurement, questionnaire design, sample, and data analysis. Preliminary findings identify four opinion leaders and present descriptive statistics on opinion leader tie strengths.
Influences of strong tie with opinion leaders in an interconnected network of...Myunggoon Choi
The document discusses research on the influence of strong ties with opinion leaders in social networks in Korea. It presents three research questions: 1) the relationship between tie strength with opinion leaders and information exchange, 2) the relationship between strong ties with opinion leaders and influence on peripheral network members, and 3) differences in influence between networks that include opinion leaders versus those that do not. The document reviews literature on information inequality, social networks, opinion leaders, tie strength, and influence. It proposes three hypotheses related to the research questions and describes the planned method of identifying opinion leaders, measuring tie strength, and analyzing network density to test the hypotheses.
This study examined how varying degrees of misalignment between data visualization titles and visualizations impact recall of information and perceptions of bias and credibility.
The researchers created data visualizations on controversial topics with titles that were either slightly misaligned with the visualization's message (miscued) or directly contradictory. They found that greater misalignment led to recall of more general topics rather than specific messages. While most participants did not perceive bias, attitudes inconsistent with titles decreased perceived credibility. The findings suggest confirmation bias can influence how visualizations are interpreted.
Relational Development & Interpersonal Communication In Computer Mediated Con...maxbury
This document summarizes research on how computer-mediated communication affects relational development. It discusses how social information processing theory explains that in computer-mediated contexts, verbal cues of affinity and issues of time (chronemics) become especially important for developing relationships due to the lack of in-person nonverbal cues. Some research has found similarities between online and in-person relationship development, but most research cited finds that self-disclosure of meaningful information through text is important for developing relational closeness and attraction when communication is mediated by computers rather than face-to-face. The document provides examples of studies that have examined how factors like depth and breadth of self-disclosure can influence relationship development in online contexts.
E XPLORING T HE S ELF -E NHANCED M ECHANISM OF I NTERACTIVE A DVERTISING...ijma
The document discusses interactive advertising and explores its self-enhanced dissemination mechanism. It analyzes three cases of interactive ads: on official websites, social media, and mobile media. It identifies micro, meso, and macro level mechanisms. At the micro level, core, inner, and outer interaction reveal the process of interacting with content, people, and computers. The meso level shows self-fission-type spread and communication approaches. At the macro level, the communication effect of interactive advertising achieves a spiral increasing effect. The analysis enriches research on the communication effects of interactive advertising.
Delay Tolerant Networking routing as a Game Theory problem – An OverviewCSCJournals
This document discusses modeling delay tolerant networking (DTN) routing as a game theory problem. It provides background on DTN, which aims to enable communication in disrupted networks, and discusses how routing in DTN can be viewed as a strategic interaction between nodes. The document then gives an overview of game theory and different game forms. It proposes analyzing DTN routing as a game with Nash equilibrium, where nodes make forwarding decisions rationally based on beliefs about other nodes' actions.
This document summarizes research on the perception of influential messages related to dating. An analysis of 52 college students revealed confusion between terms like persuasion, manipulation, and coercion when applied to interpersonal relationships. The implications are that better defining these messages could help people understand and respond to them more purposefully. Further research is still needed to better distinguish different types of influence.
Influences of strong tie with opinion leaders in an interconnected network of...Myunggoon Choi
This document describes the research project "Influences of Strong Tie with Opinion Leaders in an Interconnected Network of Korea". The research questions examine the relationship between tie strength with opinion leaders and information exchange, and the relationship between strong ties with opinion leaders and their influence on peripheral network members. The literature review covers topics of information inequality, social network perspectives, opinion leaders hypotheses, tie strength, and influence. The methodology section outlines plans to measure opinion leaders and tie strength, influences of those with strong ties to opinion leaders, information exchange measurement, questionnaire design, sample, and data analysis. Preliminary findings identify four opinion leaders and present descriptive statistics on opinion leader tie strengths.
Influences of strong tie with opinion leaders in an interconnected network of...Myunggoon Choi
The document discusses research on the influence of strong ties with opinion leaders in social networks in Korea. It presents three research questions: 1) the relationship between tie strength with opinion leaders and information exchange, 2) the relationship between strong ties with opinion leaders and influence on peripheral network members, and 3) differences in influence between networks that include opinion leaders versus those that do not. The document reviews literature on information inequality, social networks, opinion leaders, tie strength, and influence. It proposes three hypotheses related to the research questions and describes the planned method of identifying opinion leaders, measuring tie strength, and analyzing network density to test the hypotheses.
This study examined how varying degrees of misalignment between data visualization titles and visualizations impact recall of information and perceptions of bias and credibility.
The researchers created data visualizations on controversial topics with titles that were either slightly misaligned with the visualization's message (miscued) or directly contradictory. They found that greater misalignment led to recall of more general topics rather than specific messages. While most participants did not perceive bias, attitudes inconsistent with titles decreased perceived credibility. The findings suggest confirmation bias can influence how visualizations are interpreted.
This document summarizes a research article that explores the role of informants in interpretive case study research in information systems. The article reviews literature on involving informants in case study research and discusses different perspectives, ranging from simply verifying facts to viewing informants as co-researchers who can provide feedback and help interpret findings. It then presents a case study where informants were extensively involved in providing feedback during different phases of an 18-month case study. The article analyzes the case using the "ladder of analytical abstraction" framework and discusses challenges of informant involvement, as well as implications for interpretive case study research.
Study: Creating Buzz: The Neural Correlates of Effective Message PropagationDaniel Honigman
The document discusses a study that examined the neural correlates of effective message propagation. Specifically:
- Participants ("interns") viewed descriptions of TV show ideas in an fMRI scanner and rated their willingness to recommend each idea.
- Interns later discussed each idea on video, which were shown to other participants ("producers") who rated their willingness to further spread each idea.
- Ideas that were more successfully spread to producers exhibited greater neural activity in the interns' mentalizing and reward systems during initial viewing, suggesting these systems enable effective influence.
- Individual differences in ability to influence others' ratings were linked to greater mentalizing activity, supporting its role in predicting others' interests.
A communications goals model of online persuasionKrishna De
This document presents a theoretical model for predicting outcomes of online persuasion based on the goals of message senders and receivers. It discusses influence goals from interpersonal communication research, including instrumental, interpersonal, and identity goals. It also discusses Dillard's expansion of these into a bi-level Goals-Planning-Action model, distinguishing primary goals that define communication from secondary goals like identity, interaction, relational resource, and arousal management goals. Research supports the model's predictions about message production. The model may provide insights into how senders apply communication technologies and how receivers interpret messages based on their own benefit and cost goals.
This document discusses how rumors spread quickly through social networks. It simulates a simple rumor spreading process on real-world social networks like Twitter and Orkut as well as theoretical network models. The results show that rumors spread much faster in the structures of actual social networks and preferential attachment networks than in random or complete networks. Specifically, a rumor reaching 45.6 million Twitter users within 8 rounds of communication.
A ROUTING MECHANISM BASED ON SOCIAL NETWORKS AND BETWEENNESS CENTRALITY IN DE...ijcsit
With the growing popularity of mobile smart devices, the existing networks are unable to meet the requirement of many complex scenarios; current network architectures and protocols do not work well with the network with high latency and frequent disconnections. To improve the performance of these networks some scholars opened up a new research field, delay-tolerant networks, in which one of the important
research subjects is the forwarding and routing mechanism of data packets. This paper presents a routing
scheme based on social networks owing to the fact that nodes in computer networks and social networks
have high behavioural similarity. To further improve efficiency this paper also suggests a mechanism,which is the improved version of an existing betweenness centrality based routing algorithm [1]. The experiments showed that the proposed scheme has better performance than the existing friendship routing algorithms.
A bayesian abduction model for extracting most probable evidence to support s...ijaia
In this paper, we discuss the development of a Bayesian Abduction Model of Sensemaking Support (BAMSS) as a tool for information fusion to support prospective sensemaking. Currently, BAMSS can identify the Most Probable Explanation from a Bayesian Belief Network (BBN) and extract the prevalent conditional probability values to help the sensemaking analysts to understand the cause-effect of the adversary information. Actual vignettes from databases of modern insurgencies and asymmetry warfare are used to validate the performance of BAMSS. BAMSS computes the posterior probability of the network
edges and performs information fusion using a clustering algorithm. In the model, the friendly force commander uses the adversary information to prospectively make sense of the enemy’s intent. Sensitivity
analyses were used to confirm the robustness of BAMSS in generating the Most Probable Explanations from a BBN through abductive inference. The simulation results demonstrate the utility of BAMSS as a computational tool to support sense making
This study examines how Facebook users manage their privacy and personal information disclosure based on Communication Privacy Management theory. A survey and content analysis were conducted to understand the relationship between perceptions of Facebook privacy and efforts to stay updated on privacy settings. The introduction provides background on social networking sites and how they have changed communication. Hypotheses are presented that Facebook users who use the site daily will be more concerned about privacy and more likely to hide or restrict information from coworkers than family.
This document discusses using vague language to present quantitative data in a way that is appropriate to the level of uncertainty or inconsistency in the data. It argues that expressing information at a suitable level of precision makes it more accessible and relevant to users. A probabilistic approach to vagueness is proposed, which utilizes uncertainty measures on propositions defined over three-valued truth models to capture blurred category boundaries and borderline cases. The project aims to develop an implementable model of imprecise assertion strategies to derive posterior probabilities over descriptive terms based on data and assertability conventions.
An AI assistant to help answer questions about cPanel.
FTP Accounts:
Create FTP accounts to allow file uploads.
Mail:
Manage email accounts, aliases, autoresponders, etc.
MySQL Databases:
Create and manage MySQL databases.
PHPMyAdmin:
A web-based MySQL administration interface.
Software:
Install and manage software like PHP, Perl, Python, etc.
Statistics:
View web server statistics like bandwidth usage.
Subdomains:
Create subdomains for your domain name.
Webmail:
Access your email via a web-based interface.
Websites:
Manage your domain name's website settings.
WHM
The document summarizes the features and specifications of the Sokkia CX series of total stations. The CX series features long battery life of up to 36 hours, advanced angle measurement systems, RED-tech reflectorless distance measurement up to 500 meters, and rugged and waterproof construction. It also offers Bluetooth connectivity, advanced security with TSshield technology, and long range measurement capabilities with prism targets.
Oleg Antonov has been active in sports since childhood, enjoying running, swimming, yoga and keeping a healthy diet free of meat. He and his wife often exercise together, such as walking, running, swimming and winter sports. Oleg believes in maintaining a healthy mind and body through daily exercise. Both Oleg and his uncle, who is a sports trainer at 65 years old, emphasize healthy living and fitness as important values they share with their family.
This document provides information about tours in and around Sapa, Vietnam. It describes several 2-4 day tour options that involve trekking to visit various ethnic minority villages. The tours allow visitors to learn about the local cultures and lifestyles through activities like homestays. The document also lists hotels in Sapa and provides general travel information about the area, including details on the climate, best times to visit, cultural attractions, and major landmarks like Fansipan mountain.
This document provides instructions for installing and configuring Nagios network monitoring software on CentOS 4.x/5.x. It discusses installing required packages, configuring Apache as the web server, setting up authentication, editing configuration files, and starting Nagios services. The summary focuses on the high-level steps:
1. Install Nagios and related packages using yum.
2. Configure Apache and enable authentication using htpasswd.
3. Edit configuration files such as nagios.cfg, cgi.cfg and object files to define monitoring configurations.
4. Restart services and access the Nagios web interface.
Email Marketing – it’s more than just sending a message Paul Segreto
This generic presentation was the basis for a presentation for a client's franchisees about email marketing and how it can be used to drive sales, create brand awareness, and much more.
F. Fouad Saleep(1), I. Fayek(1), I. Farahat(2)
(1)National Cancer Institute - Cairo University, Surgical Oncology Department, Cairo, Egypt.
(2)National Cancer Institute - Cairo University, Pathology Department, Cairo, Egypt.
Poster presentation No.3224 at the 17th European Cancer Organization conference ECCO 17, Amsterdam-Netherlands, September 2013
Presentatie over de verbouwingsplannen van de sportschool in Gentbrugge, gegeven door
- schepen van onderwijs Rudy Coddens,
- Tom Marlier van Nero
- Miranda De Laet van AG SOB
- directeur Rony Troch van de school
This document summarizes a research article that explores the role of informants in interpretive case study research in information systems. The article reviews literature on involving informants in case study research and discusses different perspectives, ranging from simply verifying facts to viewing informants as co-researchers who can provide feedback and help interpret findings. It then presents a case study where informants were extensively involved in providing feedback during different phases of an 18-month case study. The article analyzes the case using the "ladder of analytical abstraction" framework and discusses challenges of informant involvement, as well as implications for interpretive case study research.
Study: Creating Buzz: The Neural Correlates of Effective Message PropagationDaniel Honigman
The document discusses a study that examined the neural correlates of effective message propagation. Specifically:
- Participants ("interns") viewed descriptions of TV show ideas in an fMRI scanner and rated their willingness to recommend each idea.
- Interns later discussed each idea on video, which were shown to other participants ("producers") who rated their willingness to further spread each idea.
- Ideas that were more successfully spread to producers exhibited greater neural activity in the interns' mentalizing and reward systems during initial viewing, suggesting these systems enable effective influence.
- Individual differences in ability to influence others' ratings were linked to greater mentalizing activity, supporting its role in predicting others' interests.
A communications goals model of online persuasionKrishna De
This document presents a theoretical model for predicting outcomes of online persuasion based on the goals of message senders and receivers. It discusses influence goals from interpersonal communication research, including instrumental, interpersonal, and identity goals. It also discusses Dillard's expansion of these into a bi-level Goals-Planning-Action model, distinguishing primary goals that define communication from secondary goals like identity, interaction, relational resource, and arousal management goals. Research supports the model's predictions about message production. The model may provide insights into how senders apply communication technologies and how receivers interpret messages based on their own benefit and cost goals.
This document discusses how rumors spread quickly through social networks. It simulates a simple rumor spreading process on real-world social networks like Twitter and Orkut as well as theoretical network models. The results show that rumors spread much faster in the structures of actual social networks and preferential attachment networks than in random or complete networks. Specifically, a rumor reaching 45.6 million Twitter users within 8 rounds of communication.
A ROUTING MECHANISM BASED ON SOCIAL NETWORKS AND BETWEENNESS CENTRALITY IN DE...ijcsit
With the growing popularity of mobile smart devices, the existing networks are unable to meet the requirement of many complex scenarios; current network architectures and protocols do not work well with the network with high latency and frequent disconnections. To improve the performance of these networks some scholars opened up a new research field, delay-tolerant networks, in which one of the important
research subjects is the forwarding and routing mechanism of data packets. This paper presents a routing
scheme based on social networks owing to the fact that nodes in computer networks and social networks
have high behavioural similarity. To further improve efficiency this paper also suggests a mechanism,which is the improved version of an existing betweenness centrality based routing algorithm [1]. The experiments showed that the proposed scheme has better performance than the existing friendship routing algorithms.
A bayesian abduction model for extracting most probable evidence to support s...ijaia
In this paper, we discuss the development of a Bayesian Abduction Model of Sensemaking Support (BAMSS) as a tool for information fusion to support prospective sensemaking. Currently, BAMSS can identify the Most Probable Explanation from a Bayesian Belief Network (BBN) and extract the prevalent conditional probability values to help the sensemaking analysts to understand the cause-effect of the adversary information. Actual vignettes from databases of modern insurgencies and asymmetry warfare are used to validate the performance of BAMSS. BAMSS computes the posterior probability of the network
edges and performs information fusion using a clustering algorithm. In the model, the friendly force commander uses the adversary information to prospectively make sense of the enemy’s intent. Sensitivity
analyses were used to confirm the robustness of BAMSS in generating the Most Probable Explanations from a BBN through abductive inference. The simulation results demonstrate the utility of BAMSS as a computational tool to support sense making
This study examines how Facebook users manage their privacy and personal information disclosure based on Communication Privacy Management theory. A survey and content analysis were conducted to understand the relationship between perceptions of Facebook privacy and efforts to stay updated on privacy settings. The introduction provides background on social networking sites and how they have changed communication. Hypotheses are presented that Facebook users who use the site daily will be more concerned about privacy and more likely to hide or restrict information from coworkers than family.
This document discusses using vague language to present quantitative data in a way that is appropriate to the level of uncertainty or inconsistency in the data. It argues that expressing information at a suitable level of precision makes it more accessible and relevant to users. A probabilistic approach to vagueness is proposed, which utilizes uncertainty measures on propositions defined over three-valued truth models to capture blurred category boundaries and borderline cases. The project aims to develop an implementable model of imprecise assertion strategies to derive posterior probabilities over descriptive terms based on data and assertability conventions.
An AI assistant to help answer questions about cPanel.
FTP Accounts:
Create FTP accounts to allow file uploads.
Mail:
Manage email accounts, aliases, autoresponders, etc.
MySQL Databases:
Create and manage MySQL databases.
PHPMyAdmin:
A web-based MySQL administration interface.
Software:
Install and manage software like PHP, Perl, Python, etc.
Statistics:
View web server statistics like bandwidth usage.
Subdomains:
Create subdomains for your domain name.
Webmail:
Access your email via a web-based interface.
Websites:
Manage your domain name's website settings.
WHM
The document summarizes the features and specifications of the Sokkia CX series of total stations. The CX series features long battery life of up to 36 hours, advanced angle measurement systems, RED-tech reflectorless distance measurement up to 500 meters, and rugged and waterproof construction. It also offers Bluetooth connectivity, advanced security with TSshield technology, and long range measurement capabilities with prism targets.
Oleg Antonov has been active in sports since childhood, enjoying running, swimming, yoga and keeping a healthy diet free of meat. He and his wife often exercise together, such as walking, running, swimming and winter sports. Oleg believes in maintaining a healthy mind and body through daily exercise. Both Oleg and his uncle, who is a sports trainer at 65 years old, emphasize healthy living and fitness as important values they share with their family.
This document provides information about tours in and around Sapa, Vietnam. It describes several 2-4 day tour options that involve trekking to visit various ethnic minority villages. The tours allow visitors to learn about the local cultures and lifestyles through activities like homestays. The document also lists hotels in Sapa and provides general travel information about the area, including details on the climate, best times to visit, cultural attractions, and major landmarks like Fansipan mountain.
This document provides instructions for installing and configuring Nagios network monitoring software on CentOS 4.x/5.x. It discusses installing required packages, configuring Apache as the web server, setting up authentication, editing configuration files, and starting Nagios services. The summary focuses on the high-level steps:
1. Install Nagios and related packages using yum.
2. Configure Apache and enable authentication using htpasswd.
3. Edit configuration files such as nagios.cfg, cgi.cfg and object files to define monitoring configurations.
4. Restart services and access the Nagios web interface.
Email Marketing – it’s more than just sending a message Paul Segreto
This generic presentation was the basis for a presentation for a client's franchisees about email marketing and how it can be used to drive sales, create brand awareness, and much more.
F. Fouad Saleep(1), I. Fayek(1), I. Farahat(2)
(1)National Cancer Institute - Cairo University, Surgical Oncology Department, Cairo, Egypt.
(2)National Cancer Institute - Cairo University, Pathology Department, Cairo, Egypt.
Poster presentation No.3224 at the 17th European Cancer Organization conference ECCO 17, Amsterdam-Netherlands, September 2013
Presentatie over de verbouwingsplannen van de sportschool in Gentbrugge, gegeven door
- schepen van onderwijs Rudy Coddens,
- Tom Marlier van Nero
- Miranda De Laet van AG SOB
- directeur Rony Troch van de school
Executives throughout the world have never felt more time pressured. This presentation examines what a day looks like, and what it should look like, for the world’s business leaders.
The document summarizes public outreach activities from October 1, 2012 through March 31, 2013 conducted by an organization involved in chemical weapons disposal. During this period, the organization interacted with over 7,000 people through various outreach events including networking events, information booths, public meetings, briefings for new employees, and site tours. An educational outreach program reached over 2,500 students at local schools. Social media, particularly Twitter, was the most effective means of distributing information to over 600,000 people during this period.
1) The document discusses several studies that examine how political elites use framing to influence public opinion. Druckman and Nelson (2003) found that elite framing persists when discussions only include common perspectives, but conflicting perspectives eliminate elite influence.
2) Druckman (2002) also studied framing effects and found that citizens base preferences on systematic information rather than arbitrary frames, though using only students in experiments limits conclusions.
3) Berinsky and Kinder (2006) manipulated frames on Kosovo and found they influenced views, though more research on diverse populations and mediums could provide more insights.
4) Overall, the readings represent early work on how frames shape public views, but more diverse experiments are needed to fully
Cognitive Biases and Communication Strength in Social Networks.pdfssuser1867b7
Media stories often reach citizens via a two-step process, transmitted to them indirectly via their social
networks. Why are some media stories strongly transmitted and impact opinions powerfully in this twostep flow while others quickly perish? Integrating classical research on the two-step flow of political
communication and novel theories from cognitive psychology, this article outlines a model for
understanding the strength of political frames in the two-step flow. It argues that frames that resonate
with cognitive biases (that is, deep-seated psychological decision rules) will be transmitted more and have
a stronger influence on opinion when citizens recollect media frames in their social networks. Focusing on
the case of episodic and thematic frames, the study tests this model. It introduces a novel research design:
implementing the children’s game ‘Telephone’ in consecutive experimental online surveys fielded to
nationally representative samples. This design helps gauge the reliability of transmission and the degree of
persuasiveness in actual chains of transmission.
Communication is the lifeblood of all organizations, so Zappos and.docxmonicafrancis71118
This document discusses communication in organizations and teams. It outlines the communication process model involving encoding, transmitting, receiving and decoding messages. Effective communication depends on factors like shared codebooks, mental models and experience communicating messages. Key communication channels discussed are email and emerging social media technologies. While email is widely used, it can contribute to information overload and lacks emotional and social context. Social media allow more interactive sharing of information but their impact on organizations is still emerging. The document examines issues with email and advantages of other channels like face-to-face communication for complex topics.
This document discusses various perspectives on the concept of information in communication studies. It addresses how information is defined, the role it plays in reducing uncertainty, and how it impacts individuals, relationships, organizations, and media. Specifically, it explores how information helps people understand themselves and their environment, how it both actively and passively influences understanding, and how factors like cognitive involvement impact how information is received and interpreted.
Chapter 8: Theories of Media Cognition and Information Processing (final vers...Toby Zhu
This document discusses various theories of how people process information from media and communications. It covers information processing theory, which views people as complex information processors. Schema theory explains how people organize information into mental frameworks. The elaboration likelihood model describes central and peripheral routes to persuasion. Transportation theory discusses how narratives can engage audiences. Neuroscience perspectives view information processing as biological and social.
JSAI paper on Collaborative Innovation ToolsJohn Thomas
This document discusses the importance of collaboration and some challenges to effective collaboration. It notes that while natural language evolved for small groups, new tools are needed for large, diverse collaborations. Specifically, it argues that expressive communication like storytelling can help build trust and shared understanding between collaborators. The document also suggests that perceptual experiences could be enhanced to make systemic problems more salient and motivate collaborative thinking and knowledge sharing.
Efficacy of learning digital sources versus printAlexander Decker
1. The document summarizes a study that compares long-term memory recall between learning from digital sources versus print sources.
2. The study involved 76 female students divided into two groups - one that learned from print and one from digital. It measured variables like memory recall grading and item repetition frequency.
3. Contrary to previous evidence, the results found no statistically significant differences between the two groups in terms of the shift from episodic to semantic memory when accounting for confounding factors. The shift from random guessing to remembering occurred faster with digital learning.
Journal of Organizational BehaviorJ. Organiz. Behav. 25, 5.docxpriestmanmable
Journal of Organizational Behavior
J. Organiz. Behav. 25, 547–587 (2004)
Published online in Wiley InterScience (www.interscience.wiley.com). DOI: 10.1002/job.259
The contexts of knowing: natural history
of a globally distributed team
MARIETTA L. BABA
1
*, JULIA GLUESING
2
, HILARY RATNER
3
AND
KIMBERLY H. WAGNER
4
1
College of Social Science, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan, U.S.A.
2
Institute for Information Technology and Culture, Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan, U.S.A.
3
The Graduate School, Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan, U.S.A.
4
Human Resources and Organizational Behavior Area, Anderson Graduate School of Management,
UCLA, Los Angeles, California, U.S.A.
Summary The focus of this paper is cognitive convergence in a globally distributed team (GDT), defined
as the process by which cognitive structures of distributed team members gradually become
more similar over time. To explore the convergence process, we employed a longitudinal, eth-
nographic research strategy that allowed us to follow a naturally occurring GDT over a
14-month period, producing a rich case study portraying factors and processes that influence
convergence. Confirming previous studies, we find that increases in shared cognition alone are
not sufficient to account for performance gains on a GDT. Rather, it may be necessary not only
to increase the sharing of cognition, but also to reverse a pattern of increasing divergence that
can result from rejection of key knowledge domains. We also found that several factors influ-
ence the process of cognitive convergence beyond direct knowledge sharing. These include:
separate but parallel or similar learning experiences in a common context; the surfacing of hid-
den knowledge at remote sites by third-party mediators or knowledge brokers; and shifts in
agent self-interest that motivate collaboration and trigger the negotiation of task interdepen-
dence. Also relevant to cognitive convergence on a GDT is the geographical distribution pattern
of people and resources on the ground, and the different ways in which leaders exploit the his-
torical, cultural and linguistic dimensions of such distribution to further their own political
agendas. Several propositions related to these observations are suggested. We conclude that
GDTs can be effective in bringing together divergent points of view to yield new organizational
capabilities, but such benefits require that leaders and members recognize early and explicitly
the existence and validity of their differences. Copyright # 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Introduction
Two general questions have prompted the inquiry reported in this paper. First, we are interested in
the efficacy of globally distributed teams (GDTs) as vehicles for knowledge sharing in global
Received 15 February 2002
Copyright # 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Revised 11 November 2003
Accepted 27 January 2004
* Correspondence to: Marietta L. Baba, College of Social Scie ...
This document discusses a study examining how the speed of an organization's response on social media during a crisis affects outcomes. It will analyze case studies to understand how response time and messaging frequency impacted public perception. The literature review found that communicating via Twitter during a crisis leads to better reputation management than blogs or newspapers. However, more research is needed on how quickly information must flow on social media and how response frequency influences effectiveness. The study aims to provide crisis communicators a better sense of the time available before messaging in social media.
dependency theory and Uuses and gratificationCHSGmedia
The document discusses two media theories: Uses and Gratifications Approach and Dependency Theory. The Uses and Gratifications Approach, introduced in the 1970s, views audiences as active users who seek out specific media and content to fulfill personal needs and gratifications. Dependency Theory, developed in 1976, proposes that people in modern societies rely on mass media for information needed to make daily decisions, and dependence increases as media serves more needs. Both theories are evaluated based on criteria like logic, consistency, testability, and simplicity.
The document discusses two media theories: Uses and Gratifications Approach and Dependency Theory. The Uses and Gratifications Approach, introduced in the 1970s, views audiences as active users who seek out specific media and content to fulfill personal needs and gratifications. Dependency Theory, developed in 1976, proposes that people in modern societies rely on mass media for information needed to make daily decisions, and dependence increases as media provides more central functions. Both theories are evaluated based on criteria like logic, consistency, testability, and simplicity, though they have also received some criticism for assuming audiences are completely active without media influence.
A Brief Exploration Of Modern Persuasion TheoriesWendy Hager
The document provides an overview of modern persuasion theories, summarizing five key theories:
1) The five canons of rhetoric which focus on message and source characteristics.
2) Elaboration likelihood model which examines central and peripheral routes of persuasion.
3) Cultivation analysis which explores how media shapes worldviews through storytelling.
4) Theory of planned behavior which analyzes cognitive processes and how attitudes influence behaviors.
5) Agenda setting theory which discusses how media guides public and policy agendas.
This document discusses effective electronic communication between disputing parties. It outlines two models of communication: the transmission model which views communication as a process of encoding and decoding messages, and the constructionist model which sees communication as a joint, dynamic process where meaning is negotiated between parties. The document then examines some problems with electronic communication (EC), how these impact mediators, and characteristics of EC like isolation and ambiguity that can affect how parties communicate and negotiate.
This document presents an analysis of the concept of mutuality. It aims to clarify the meaning of mutuality and examine its application to nursing practice and research. Mutuality is defined as the quality or condition of being interdependent or mutually reliant on each other. Key attributes that define mutuality include mutualism, teamwork, alliance, and correlation. The analysis presents a model case example and alternative cases to demonstrate attributes of mutuality. It also discusses antecedents, consequences, and empirical referents of the concept.
Complete the University of Phoenix Material Communication Theorie.docxdonnajames55
Complete the University of Phoenix Material: Communication Theories and Application Worksheet.
Format your assignment according to appropriate course-level APA guidelines.
Submit your assignment to the Assignment Files tab.
Hi All --
Sometimes, if a student presents the wrong theory in response to the initial clue, it throws off all the rest of the boxes. The theory name will earn zero; the other boxes may earn partial credit, depending on how accurately they portray the actual theory that was named.
Examples should be brief, concrete and specific, and -- of course -- accurate and clear. Please do not write an essay for each.
STUDENT NAME
Comment
Theory
Identification 2
Theorists 2
Context 2
Application 3.4
Credit
2
2
2
3.4
9.40
2
2
2
3.4
9.40
2
2
2
3.4
9.40
2
2
2
3.4
9.40
2
2
2
3.4
9.40
2
2
2
3.4
9.40
2
2
2
3.4
9.40
2
2
2
3.4
9.40
2
2
2
3.4
9.40
2
2
2
3.4
9.40
Matching (1 ea)
6.00
TOTAL
100.00
Example: You earned 97.75% = 9.78 points
This mini spreadsheet shows how I evaluate the boxes.
Title
ABC/123 Version X
1
Communication Theories and Application Worksheet
BSCOM/336 Version 5
1
University of Phoenix MaterialCommunication Theories and Application Worksheet
Fill out the different cells with regard to each theory definition. You are to identify the name of the theory the example represents, who developed the theory (theorist), note the context of the theory (interpersonal, intrapersonal, group, etc.), and then provide your own brief personal or professional application example of the theory. Remember to use APA citation rules if you integrate information from your text or other sources.
Theory Definition
Identify the Theory
Theorist(s)
Context of Theory
(Intrapersonal, Interpersonal, Organizational, Public, Mass)
Application Example from your Personal or Professional Life
Theory explains why as relationships develop, communication moves from less intimate levels to more intimate, more personal levels.
Theory explains how people hold expectations about the nonverbal behaviors of others. Violations of these expectations may trigger a change in the perception of exchange either positively or negatively, depending on the relationship.
Theory explains the process that people use to manage the relationship between concealing and revealing private information.
Theory explains how people experience a limited effect from media. Individuals are thought to be actively seeking specific types of media to generate specific needs. However, some theorists working within this model study how effects, such as attitudes and perceptions of social reality, can and do happen.
Theory explains why parties to communication experience conflicting pulls causing relationships to be in a constant state of flux. The closer individuals become to one another, the more conflict will arise to pull them apart.
Theory explains meanings for routine organizational events, thereby reducing the amount of cognitive.
Item 1In the case below, the original source material is given alo.pdfjaronkyleigh59760
Item 1
In the case below, the original source material is given along with a sample of student work.
Determine the type of plagiarism by clicking the appropriate radio button.
Original Source Material
Student Version
While solitary negative reactions or unjustified suggestions for change have the potential to
dissipate discourse rather than build it, the pattern analysis shows that the anonymous condition
seemed to provide a safe explorative space for learners to try out more reasons for their multiple
solutions. Teachers will rarely give anonymous feedback, but the experience of giving
anonymous feedback may open a social space where learners can try out the reasons for their
suggestions.
References:
Howard, C. D., Barrett, A. F., & Frick, T. W. (2010). Anonymity to promote peer feedback: Pre-
service teachers\' comments in asynchronous computer-mediated communication. Journal of
Educational Computing Research, 43(1), 89-112.
Teachers don\'t often provide feedback anonymously, but the ability to provide feedback
anonymously may create a context where the rationale associated with specific suggestions can
be more safely explored (Howard, Barrett, & Frick, 2010). However, we cannot assume that all
anonymous online spaces will serve as safe social spaces.
Which of the following is true for the Student Version above?
Word-for-Word plagiarism
Paraphrasing plagiarism
This is not plagiarism
Hints
Item 2
In the case below, the original source material is given along with a sample of student work.
Determine the type of plagiarism by clicking the appropriate radio button.
Original Source Material
Student Version
But what are reasonable outcomes of the influence of global processes on education? While the
question of how global processes influence all aspects of education (and who controls these
forces) is multidimensional and not completely testable, there appear to be some theories of
globalization as it relates to education that can be empirically examined.
References:
Rutkowski, L., & Rutkowski, D. (2009). Trends in TIMSS responses over time: Evidence of
global forces in education? Educational Research and Evaluation, 15(2), 137-152.
The authors are not alone in asking “what are reasonable outcomes of the influence of global
processes on education?” (p. 138). In fact, this same question provides the basis for the
discussion that follows.
Which of the following is true for the Student Version above?
Word-for-Word plagiarism
Paraphrasing plagiarism
This is not plagiarism
Hints
Item 3
In the case below, the original source material is given along with a sample of student work.
Determine the type of plagiarism by clicking the appropriate radio button.
Original Source Material
Student Version
Merck, in fact, epitomizes the ideological nature--the pragmatic idealism--of highly visionary
companies. Our research showed that a fundamental element in the \"ticking clock\" of a
visionary company is a core ideology--core values and a sense of purpose beyond ju.
Hospitality Supervision And Management
We Also Provide SYNOPSIS AND PROJECT.
Contact www.kimsharma.co.in for best and lowest cost solution or
Email: amitymbaassignment@gmail.com
Call: 9971223030
We documented and illustrated the use of a data collection and analysis suite, SenseMaker, that was designed to collect and work with narrative fragments. The approach presented adds a new and inherently mixed tool to the mixed methods toolbox. Despite its novelty and potential utility, little has been written in the academic literature on the application of SenseMaker to complex problems. To the best of our knowledge, the approach has not been used in relation to climate change or climate change adaptation and has not been presented in the mixed methods literature. We sought to contribute to filling this gap through describing the approach used to generate the data that underpin the articles in this special feature. Our purpose was to illustrate some of the potential and most notable challenges of using the SenseMaker data collection and analysis process in a complex domain through examining adaptation to climate change. Our overview was not exhaustive but rather sought to highlight capabilities and challenges through examining experiences of adaptation from a stages of change perspective. SenseMaker provides a remarkably powerful tool for the capture of micronarratives of complex phenomena such as climate change. The capacity to have respondents interpret, i.e., make sense of, their own narratives is an important innovation that provides one plausible solution to the problem of analysts coding narratives.
Little research has been done on the benefit of empathy for socialMerrileeDelvalle969
- The study explored the relationship between empathy and decision-making in social work students. Two cohorts of students reflected on a social work case scenario and proposed interventions.
- The results showed that higher levels of perspective taking, fantasy, and empathic concern were associated with prioritizing direct assistance for the person most in need. Higher personal distress was not related to helpful interventions.
- The findings provide preliminary evidence that empathy, especially cognitive and emotional aspects, underpins effective case management in social work students. Further research is needed to deepen understanding of this relationship.
Similar to Paper 17504 updated version 2014 07-30 (20)
Little research has been done on the benefit of empathy for social
Paper 17504 updated version 2014 07-30
1. 1
Perceived Mutual Understanding and Accuracy of Understanding:
The Moderating Role of Media Richness
Authors: Sigmund Valaker, Thorvald Hærem & Dominique Kost
An earlier version of this article was accepted for presentation at the Academy of management
conference 2014
2. 2
ABSTRACT
In this article we examined empirically, whether the congruence between perceived mutual
understanding and accuracy of understanding others information depends on the level of
media richness. We explored this research question by performing an experiment in which 51
three-member teams, 27 in a low media rich condition, email, and 24 in a high media rich
condition, face to face, engaged in a complex crisis management task. Results indicated that
perception of high mutual understanding is related to high accuracy of understanding in face
to face, but not in email. Perceived low mutual understanding is related to low accuracy of
understanding, in both media conditions. Theoretical and practical implications, limitations
and future directions for research are discussed.
Keywords: Perceived Mutual understanding, Accuracy of understanding, Media richness
3. 3
INTRODUCTION
When teams work together, it is often a problem that team members believe they know
what is going on, when they don’t. This problem may be accentuated in settings with virtual
teams and distributed problem solving (Cramton, 2001). This article aims to shed light on the
relation between what teams believe about their mutual understanding and what they actually
know about it. Specifically we study the relation between team’s perceived mutual
understanding and wheter the team actually understands others information, and whether this
relation is moderated by the use of different communication media. The distinction between
what team members believe they know and what they actually know is important both
theoretically and methodologically. Much research assumes what team believes about their
knowledge is a good proxy for what they actually know (e.g. Katz & Te’eni, 2007), but when
team members believe they have a good mutual understanding, they may actually hold
different understandings.
Congruence between perceived mutual understanding and accurate understanding is
important from a practical point of view as well. Shared accurate understanding of
information is important for achieving coordinated action. Handover of patient information
among medical doctors, or interagency antiterrorism collaboration, exemplify situations were
sharing an accurate understanding of each others` information is important (Blatt,
Christianson, Sutcliffe & Rosenthal, 2006; Weick, 2005). By knowing what information other
team members hold, it can be possible to develop a mutual understanding of the task which
can then aid performance (Krauss & Fussell, 1990). This is corroborated by recent meta-
analysis indicating that shared mental models increase team performance (DeChurch &
Mesmer-Magnus, 2010).
Other research, such as Cramton (2001), has suggested that people have problems
identifying what they know in a less rich media, yet to our knowledge this assumption has not
been empirically tested. Studies do suggest that people are less able to achieve accurate
communication when they have fewer cues for communicating (Brennan, 2004). Kruger,
Epley, Parker & Ng, (2005) tested the hypothesis that people were more prone to overestimate
the accuracy of their communication in email versus face to face communication and their
results indicated support for this hypothesis. Our study aim to extend this current research in
the following ways: Firstly it specifically look at the construct of mutual understanding
which means that it takes into account knowledge of not only the message has been properly
understand but also whether this is shared knowledge among the communication partners. We
4. 4
look at the degree of congruence between mutual understanding and accurate understanding at
the group level.
We draw media richness theory as well as theories of common ground to theorize on
the degree to which people develop an accurate understanding of others information (Daft &
Lengel, 1986; Weick & Meader, 1993; Cramton, 2001). Media that provide more cues and
faster feedback, characteristics of rich media, are thought to lead to more accurate
understanding of others information because they make it possible to have a shared reference
or common ground (Clark & Brennan, 1991). Specifically we argue that perception of mutual
understanding and accurately understanding others information are more congruent in a rich
media than in less rich media and ask the question: To what extent is the relationship between
perceived mutual understanding and accuracy of understanding moderated by media richness?
Our article intends to contribute to the discussion of what factors influence the relation
between media characteristics and organizational communication (Dennis et al., 2008). By
investigating the relation between perceived mutual understanding, media richness and
accuracy of understanding we seek to respond to a call for research on how media
characteristics affect mutual knowledge seen as a combination of accurate understanding and
knowledge that the information is shared (Krauss & Fussell, 1990; Cramton, 2007, Katz and
Te’eni, 2007). By investigating accuracy and perceived mutual understanding, a more
nuanced insight could be gained into the phenomenon of mutual knowledge.
This article is structured in the following way: We first hypothesize how perceived
mutual understanding influence accuracy of understanding, and then hypothesize how media
richness may moderate this relation. We then present the method and results from an
experimental study, and finally discuss our findings with respect to theoretical implications,
limitations, future research directions and practical implications.
----------------------------------
Insert Figure 1 about here
----------------------------------
THEORY AND HYPOTHESES
The relation between perceived mutual understanding and accuracy of understanding
Perception of mutual understanding refers to perceiving that the speaker is aware that the
listener has understood it and the listener knows that the speaker knows this (based on Katz &
5. 5
Te ’ eni, 2007). Perceived mutual understanding could lead to better accuracy of
understanding as people acknowledge the information received by others by perceiving it as
understood (Huber & Lewis, 2010). On the other hand the theory of common ground suggest
that if people do not have a reference that is readily available perception of mutual
understanding may not relate to actual high accuracy of understanding (Clark, 1996). One
example that illustrate this is the use of nonstandard phraseology during collaboration.
Although people believe they use words in similar ways they may actually be using it
differently (Weick, 1990). Such problems of lack of reference suggest that breakdowns in
accuracy can occur despite of perceived mutual understanding (Clark, 1996). Thus it could be
argued that whether there is a congruence between perception and accuracy may not be
guaranteed by perceiving their to be a mutual understanding alone and we hypothesize:
Hypothesis 1: Perceived mutual understanding is not significantly related to more
accurate understanding of others information.
The influence of perceived mutual understanding on accuracy of understanding
moderated by media richness.
Although there may not be a significant relationship between perceived mutual understanding
and accuracy of understanding this may depend on the degree of media richness of the
communication media used. Using a media-richness and sense-making perspective, it can be
suggested that multiplicities of cues could lead to better accuracy in understanding other
messages (Daft & Lengel, 1986; Weick & Sutcliffe, 2001; Byron, 2008). One explanation
offered for why media richness, i.e., a medium’s ability to affect change of understanding in a
time interval, positively affects accuracy of understanding, is that the communication partners
are able to understand more of the sender’s intended meaning due to the presence of
nonverbal cues, such as facial expressions. This in turn enables the confirming or
disconfirming of whether one has a correct understanding (Weick & Sutcliffe, 2001).
Similarly Te`eni (2001) suggest that richness of media impact the ability to convey accurately
information to others through the possibilities for richer descriptions of core content.
Furthermore, the availability of feedback in rich media could allow for checking whether a
message is understood more rapidly than in a less-rich communication medium (Cramton,
2001). This should lead to the possibility that varieties in availability of cues and rapid
feedback would positively impact accuracy of understanding by allowing a more rapid
turntaking among communication partners (Clark, 1996).
Specifically richer media may imply more shared common ground which
communication partners can relate to in order to achieve correct communication (Clark &
6. 6
Brennan, 1991). Visual references can be made to a larger extent if one is collocated or see
what the other team member sees, which could aid in tailoring ones message to the specific
situation of the ones interlocutors (Kraut, Fussell, Siegel, 2003). It can thus be grounds to
believe that people will not be accurate in judging whether there is a high versus low mutual
understanding in a less rich media, in particular when people are not used to working on a
task (Hollingshead, Brandon, Yoon & Gupta, 2011). On the other hand in a rich media
condition, perception of mutual understanding may be an indicator of a better communication
because there are available cues and information that could lead to a more accurate
perception. Based on this reasoning we hypothesize:
Hypothesis 2: Perceived low mutual understanding is related to low accuracy in high
and low media rich conditions. The perception of high mutual understanding is related
to low accuracy in a low rich medium, while perception of high mutual understanding
is related to high accuracy in a high rich media condition.
METHOD
Participants and procedure
The study participants were 153 students at a business school who were placed in 51
teams consisting of three members each and played a system-dynamic command-and-control
simulation. 27 groups were placed in a low media rich condition, and 24 teams were placed in
a high media rich condition.The participants were 49 percent female and 51 percent male with
an age range from 19–53 years and a mean age of 24 years. After listening to instructions and
playing a test scenario, the teams solved three tasks lasting 20 minutes each. For the purpose
of another study, three tasks were played, but for this study, only the last task was analyzed.
After the task, the participants answered a survey on their background, perceived mutual
understanding, and measures of their knowledge of what the content of each others
intelligence updates was as well as a control measure of whether they knew the other team
members.
The participants played a simulation through a map and email interface. See Figure 2
for a screenshot of the graphical user interface in the simulation game. The task in the
simulation was to protect oil rigs in the North Sea from possible attacks from terrorists. The
terrorists operated from commercial fishing vessels. In order to hinder the attack, the team had
to accomplish the following: make fishing vessels visually appear (detection), search fishing
7. 7
vessels for information that could confirm whether they were friend or foe (infosearch), and
intercept the fishing vessel if they were confirmed as being a foe (attack). Each team member
was specialized in either detection, infosearch or attack. In order to find the hostile object the
team members needed to share information about its location. We provided the three team
members with differing information about the location of the terrorists: “Intelligence
updates”. In order to solve the task more efficiently the team members needed to integrate this
information. This resembled an established way of inducing differences in the information
provided to each participant so as to investigate how the team solves communication
problems (Schober & Brennan, 2003; Katz & Teeni, 2007).
----------------------------------
Insert Figure 2 about here
-----------------------------------
Manipulations and Measures
Accuracy of understanding. This measure is constructed as a measure of whether one
correctly recalls the content of each others’ “Intelligence updates”. This operationalization
draws on the one used by Stewart and Stasser, (1995) to measure whether people accurately
recall what kind of information were connected to a specific expertise. See Appendix A for an
example item were the three first alternatives reflect the three different team members
intelligence updates so that only one alternative is correct for one role. We gave each team
member three items, one concerning its own messages, and two for the two other roles.
During the task the team members in both email and face to face condition were free to
exchange and talk about the intelligence updates to other team members.
Mutual understanding. We adapted Katz and Te’eni (2007) measure of perceived
mutual understanding to a setting with three member teams. Items 1, 2, 3, 5, and 7 loaded
above 0.5 on one factor and had an alpha reliability of 0.91 (Hair et al., 2010). These five
items formed the perceived mutual-understanding scale in this study. See Appendix B for a
presentation of the items.
Media richness. In the email condition, participants were only allowed to
communicate through email. In the face-to-face condition, the teams were collocated and
could talk to each other as well as use email. For a separate sample we checked the
effectiveness of this manipulation with a perceived media richness scale (Dennis and Kinney,
1998, items are presented in Appendix B). There was a significant difference (p <.001)
8. 8
between the mean of the two conditions with a mean of 4.18 and 3.37 for face to face and
email respectively.
Control variables. We controlled for team member role and the degree to which one
knew other team members personally and professionally. Whether a particular team role were
less engaged in the task could inflict on information sharing and hence the degree to which his
or hers messages were understood. Knowing other team members could also motivate people
to be more open with the kind of information they received and hence lead to better accuracy.
By four items we asked how well they knew the two other persons in their team personally
and professionally. We retained four items loaded above 0.5 on one factor (varimax rotation)
and had an alpha reliability of 0.70 (Hair et al, 2010). These four items formed the knowing
team members scale.
RESULTS
In Table 1, the descriptive statistics and correlations of the study and the control
variable for knowing other team members are reported. We conducted a multilevel analysis
using hierarchical linear modelling in SPSS version 20, as the responses for each individual
were nested in groups (Hox, 2010). The group-level variance of mutual understanding was
moderately strong (ICC(1)=.26, p<.05). In order to avoid multicollinearity problems the
variables were mean centered before creating the interaction term. The results of the
regression analysis are presented in table 2. As shown none of the control variables were
significantly related to accuracy.
----------------------------------------------
Insert Table 1 and Table 2 about here
---------------------------------------------
The media richness accuracy relation
As suggested by the nonsignificant effect of perceived mutual understanding on
accuracy of understanding, see Table 2, our results indicated support for hypothesis 1.
Perceived mutual understanding as a moderator of the media richness accuracy relation
As shown in Table 2, the effect from the interaction between perceived mutual
understanding and media richness on accuracy of understanding was significant. To probe the
interaction, we plotted the slopes for values one standard deviation above and one standard
deviation below the mean, as recommended by Aiken and West (1991). The slopes in Figure 3
9. 9
suggest a more positive relationship between perceived mutual understanding and accuracy of
understanding for participants who were in a media rich condition (slope gradient=0.40,
p<0.10) when compared to participants who were in a low media rich condition (slope
gradient=-0.41, p>0.10). The slopes were significantly different from each other
(t=1.97,p<0.05). Additionally the difference between perceived high and perceived low
mutual understanding was not significantly different in the low rich media condition, whereas
it was significantly different in the high rich media condition (p<0.05). This indicated support
for hypothesis 2.
----------------------------------------------
Insert Figure 3 about here
---------------------------------------------
DISCUSSION
To elucidate whether perceptions of mutual understanding influence accuracy of
understanding we asked the following research question: To what extent is the relationship
between perceived mutual understanding and accuracy of understanding moderated by media
richness? Our findings indicate that media richness moderate the relationship between
perceived mutual understanding and accuracy of understanding. Specifically in a low media
rich context both high and low perceived mutual understanding was related to low accuracy.
However, in a high media rich condition high perceived mutual understanding reflected high
accuracy and low perceived mutual understanding reflected low accuracy.
Implications for theory
The theories of mutual knowledge suggest that both actually sharing knowledge and knowing
that one share the knowledge are important aspects of this construct, and that these factors
could be affected by media characteristics (Krauss & Fussell, 1990; Cramton, 2001). On this
basis research has called for empirical investigations that examine the influence from media
on mutual knowledge (Cramton, 2001; Katz & Te’eni, 2007).
Our findings indicate that the effect of perceived mutual understanding on accuracy of
understanding is conditioned by the level of media richness. This finding support previous
suggestions in theorizing on mutual understanding which claim that understanding others in
team collaboration consist of both knowing the information other possess as well as
10. 10
perceiving this information to be shared and that media could affect this relation (Cramton,
2001). One way to explain this is that although people perceive their mutual understanding to
be high in a less rich context they are exposed to less of the uncertainty with respect to
whether team members hold different information. As a consequence people may develop less
congruence between what they think they understand and what they actually understand in a
less rich media.
Limitations and directions for future research
Our findings may not fully capture the extent to which current distributed
communication aids may enable convergence on a mutual knowledge (Dennis et al., 2008).
Specifically we did not look into contextualization support as a factor that could enhance the
degree to which people develop accurate understanding. Contextualization are one of the
crucial ways that people enable understanding of messages by linking a content to a shared
reference (Weick & Meader, 1993). Research has suggested that this can be crucial for mutual
knowledge in a distributed media (Katz & Te’eni, 2007). However, research has not
investigated the link between various supports for contextualization in distributed media,
accuracy and perceptions of mutual understanding and so this could be an interesting avenue
for future research. A longer duration of the task may have made those in a less rich context
more able to learn how to achieve accurate understanding. Additionally meta-analysis
indicates that media effects are less prominent over time, and this can also apply to our
findings (de Guinea, Webster, & Staples, 2012).
This study was conducted with the intention of studying the relationship between
perception of mutual understanding, accuracy of understanding and media richness. We
deliberately focused on investigating the influence of one particular type of information. This
was information that we induced as different in order to constitute a challenge in terms of
developing accurate understanding. A potential limitation and direction for future research is
whether we would have similar findings for other kinds of information, for example whether
the information is more or less salient to the role people have in a group (Cramton & Orvis,
Wilson, 2007). In addition examining other influences, such as overconfidence, on the
congruence between perceived mutual understanding and understanding of others messages
could be interesting.
One potential threat to our design is the degree to which people know each other
before going in to the simulation. However by controlling for knowledge of others we sought
to minimize the influence from this potential threat. As shown in the results none of the
11. 11
control variables were significantly related to accuracy. On the other hand future research
could probe the degree to which our findings are similar for teams where the participants
know each other versus teams were members are strangers to each other. Furthermore, with
respect to participants we used students from a business school as our sample. Our research
could therefore be extended further by investigating expert decision makers. This could
enhance the generalizability of our findings as we investigated our research question in
simulated crisis management setting.
Finally our research specifically concerned the effect on accuracy of understanding.
Substantiating the findings in this study with an analysis of the effects of accuracy on
performance could thus be a valuable.
Managerial Implications
Collaboration in teams is increasingly performed through distributed communication.
One challenge is that of having less access to cues of what information other holds which can
lead to misunderstandings (Cramton 2001; Byron, 2008). Our research suggest that for ad hoc
teams collaborating in a short time interval there is a particular challenge involved in peoples
monitoring of whether the information is accurate or not when working distributed. Indicators
of whether information is shared may enhance the ability of collaborators in a distributed
setting to achieve mutual knowledge, as well as contextualization of messages.
12. 12
References
Blatt, R., Christianson, M. K., Sutcliffe, K. M., & Rosenthal, M. M. 2006. A sensemaking lens
on Reliability. Journal of Organizatonal Behavior, 27, 897-917.
Brennan, S. E. 2004. How conversation is shaped by visual and spoken evidence. In Trueswell
J., Tanenhaus M. (Eds.) Approaches to Studying world-situated language use: Bridging the
language as-product and language-action traditions (pp. 95-129). Cambridge, MA: MIT
Press.
Byron, K. 2008. Carrying too Heavy a Load? The Communication and Miscommunication
by Email. Academy of Management Review, 33(2): 309-327.
Carlson J. R., and Zmud, R. W. 1999. Channel Expansion Theory and the Experiential Nature
of Media Richness Perceptions,Academy of Management Journal 42(2), 153-170.
Clark, H. H. 1996. Using Language. Stanford: Cambridge University Press
Clark, H. H., Brennan, S.E. 1991. Grounding in Communication. In Perspectives on socially
shared cognition. Resnick, L. B., Levine, J. M., Teasley, S. D. (eds.). Washington, American
Psychological Association, 127-149.
Clark, H. H. 1995. Using Language, New York, Cambridge University Press
Cramton, C. D. 2001. The Mutual Knowledge Problem and Its Consequences for Dispersed
Collaboration. Organization Science, 12(3), 346-371.
Cramton, C. D., Orvis, Wilson, K. L., Wilson, J. M. 2007. Situation Invisibility and
Attribution in Distributed Collaborations. Journal of Management, 33(4), 525-546
Daft, R. L., & Lengel, R. H. 1986. Organizational Information Requirements, Media Richness
and Structural Design. Management Science, 32(5), 554-571.
DeChurch, L.A., & Mesmer-Magnus, J.R. 2010. The cognitive underpinnings of team
effectiveness: A meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 95, 1, 32-53.
DeChurch, L.A., & Mesmer-Magnus, J.R. 2010. Measuring Shared Team Mental Models: A
Meta-Analysis. Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice, 14, 1: 1-14
deGuniea, A. O., Webster, J., Staples, D. 2012. A meta-analysis of the consequences of
virtualness on team functioning. Information & Management 49, 301-308
Dennis A. R., Fuller R. M. & Valacich J. S., 2008. Media, Tasks, and Communication
Processes. A Theory of Media Synchronicity. MIS Quarterly, 32, 3, 575-600
Hollingshead, A.B., Brandon, D.P., Yoon, K. & Gupta, N., 2010. Communication and
Knowledge sharing Errors in Groups: A Transactive Memory Perspective. In H. E. Canary
and R. D. McPhee (Eds.), Communication and Organizational Knowledge: Contemporary
Issues for Theory and Practice. New York, NY: Taylor Francis/Routledge.
Hollingshead, A.B., & Fraidin, S.N. 2002. Gender stereotypes and assumptions about
expertise in transactive memory. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 39, 355 – 363.
Hox, J. 2010. Multilevel Analysis. Techniques and Application. London: Routledge
Huber, George P., & Lewis, Kyle. 2010. Cross - Understanding: Implications for group
cognition and performance. Academy of Management Review, 35(1): 6-26.
Katz, A., Te ́eni, D. 2007. The Contingent Impact of Contextualization on Computer-Mediated
Collaboration. Organization Science, 18(2), 261-279.
Kraut, R. E., Fussell, S. R., & Siegel, J. 2003. Visual information as a conversational resource
in collaborative physical tasks. Human-Computer Interaction, 18, 13-49.
Krauss, R., S. Fussell. 1990. Mutual knowledge and communicative effectiveness. In J.
Galegher, R. Kraut, C. Egido, (Eds.) Intellectual Teamwork: Social and Technological
13. 13
Foundations of Cooperative Work. Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ 111–146.
Kruger, J., Epley, N., Parker, J., & Ng, Z. W. 2005. Egocentrism over e-mail: Can we
communicate as well as we think? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 89(6): 925-
936.
Lind, M.R. & Zmud, A.W. 1991. The Influence of a Convergence in Understanding Between
Technology Providers and Users on Information Technology Innovativeness, Organization
Science (2)2: 195-217.
Schober & Brennan, 2003. Processes of interactive spoken discourse: The role of the partner.
In Graesser, A. C., Gernsbacher, M. A., Goldman, S. R. (Eds.) Handbook of discourse
processes (pp. 123-164). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Sproull, L., & Kiesler, S. 1986. Reducing social-context cues: Electronic mail in
organizational communication. Management Science, 32(11): 1492-1512.
Stewart, D.D., Stasser, G., Expert role assignment and information sampling during collective
recall and decision making. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 69, 4, 619-628
Te'eni D. (2001). A Cognitive-Affective Model of Organizational Communication for
Designing IT. MIS Quarterly 25 (2), 251-312
Weick, K. E. 1990. The vulnerable system: An analysis of the Tenerife air disaster. Journal of
Management, 16(3): 571-593.
Weick, K. E., & Meader, D. K. (1993). Sensemaking support systems. In L. M. Jessup & J. S.
Valecich (Eds.), Group support systems: New perspectives (pp. 230-252). New York:
Macmillan.
Weick, K., Sutcliffe, K. M. (2001). Managing the unexpected: assuring high performance
in an age of complexity. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Meser-Magnus, L. A., Mesmer-Magnus, J. R. 2010. Measuring Shared Team Mental Models:
A Meta-Analysis. Group Dynamics, 14(1):1-14
Weick, K. E., Sutcliffe, K. M., Obstfeld, D. (2005). Organizing and the process of
sensemaking, Organization Science, 16(4): 409-421
14. 14
APPENDIX A
Items
Accuracy of understanding (example item)
What was the content of the intelligence update received by the Frigate? Answer alternatives:
-We have unverified information that the terrorists are operating from commercial fishing vessels. These vessels
can be located near Faraoe Islands (1)
-We have unverified information that the terrorists use commercial fishing vessels. These vessels can be located
near the westcoast of Denmark (2)
-We have verified informaiton that the terrorists operate from commercial fishing vessels. These vessels are
located in the Barents Sea between the northern part of Norway and Svalbard. (3)
-We have unverified information that the terrorists operate from commercial fishing vessels. These vessels are
located at the northern part of (4)
-None of the answers (5)
Perceived Mutual understanding a)
-I understood my partner’s messages.
-I successfully monitored incoming messages during the task.
-My partner’s actions indicated that they understood my messages.
-I knew when my communication partners understood my messages and when they did not.
-My communication partners and I understood each other.
a) Scored on a likert type scale from 1-7 strongly disagree to strongly agree.
TABLE 1
Descriptive Statistics and Intercorrelations
Variables Mean s.d. Max. Min. 1. 2. 3.
1. Mutual understanding 5.03 1.00 6.00 1.40
2.Accuracyof understanding 0 1 6.00 -1.40 0.15†
3. Media richnessa
0.47 0.50 1.00 1 0.30**
0.22**
4. Knowing team members 1.8 1.14 5.50 1 0.10 -0.01 0.16*
Note. N=153.
†p<.10
*p<.05
**p<.01
A) Media richness: email = ”0”, face-to-face = “1”
15. 15
TABLE 2
Regression Analyses
Accuracy of understanding
Variables Model 1 Model 2 Model 3
Intercept 0.03 -0.11 -0.12
Orion 0.21 0.27 0.28
Patrol -0.20 -0.13 -0.12
Frigatte 0.00 0.00 0.00
Knowing team members -0.02 -0.06 -0.06
Mutual understanding 0.13 -0.00
Media richness 0.37* 0.30†
Mutual understanding X Media richness 0.40*
Deviance (AIC) 447.30 433.25 431.42
Pseudo-R2
0.02 0.09 0.10
∆Pseudo-R2
0.07 0.01
Note.Unstandardized regression coefficients are shown.
†p<.10
*p<.05
**p<.01
***p<.001
Figure 1
Research model