2006 Shell Creek
           W atershed Study

Advisors – Mark Seier & Suzy Goedeken
Researchers – Amanda Gasper, Melissa Gasper,
Heather Schmidt, Tom O’Brien, Laura Johnson, Josh
Kaufman, Tim Wiese, Mandy Anderson, Jessica
Boschen, Sean Farrier, Brittany Julsen, Ann O’Brien,
Sheila O’Brien, Lynzee Pieke, Brett Roberg, Connie
Dohmen, Luke Gasper, Jesse Knust, Alyshia Nelson,
Skye Rosno, Darrek Schmidt & Kelsey Wallin
                                         1
Shell Creek and Loseke-Taylor Creek Watersheds
             (with Township-Range Labels)
     Lower Platte North Natural Resources District




                                 2
Site 1




         3
Site 2




         4
Site 3




         5
Site 4




         6
Site 5




         7
W.Q.I.
• The Water Quality Index was developed by the
  National Sanitation Foundation as a standard
  system to compare different bodies of water.
• To determine the WQI, a series of nine tests
  were performed. These tests were: dissolved
  oxygen, fecal coliform, pH, Biological Oxygen
  Demand (BOD), temperature, total phosphate,
  nitrates, turbidity, and total solids. We also did a
  water discharge test which we use to measure
  the flow of the creek in cubic feet per second.
                                         8
• After the tests are completed, the WQI for each
  section of the creek can be computed.
• To formulate the WQI, we first computed Q-values.
• We multiply this number by a weighting factor, which
  provides a measure of the relative importance of
  each test to overall water quality.
• The water quality index ranges from zero to 100.
     - 0 - 25 is very bad
     - 25 - 50 is bad
     - 50 - 70 is medium
     - 70 - 90 is good
     - 90 - 100 is excellent
• The bio-indicator tests weren’t part of W.Q.I., but did
  give us a water quality rating.
                                           9
Sample W.Q.I. Curve Chart




                    10
Sample W.Q.I. Form
                                     Weighting   T   o   t a   l


                Test Results Q-value  Factor
      DO          % sat.               0.17
Fecal Coliform col/100 mL              0.16
       pH          units               0.11
      BOD          mg/L                0.11
 Temperature change in C               0.1
Total Phosphate    mg/L                0.1
   Nitrates        mg/L                0.1
   Turbidity        JTU                0.08
 Total Solids      mg/L                0.07

              Overall Water Quality Index ___
                                       11
Test       Natural Readings        Cautionary
                                          Readings
Dissolved Oxygen % 90% or higher     Below 90% unless the
                                     waters are supersaturated
Saturation                           due to cultural
                                     eutrophication.

pH                6.5-8.5            Below 6.5
                                     Above 8.5

Nitrates          0.0-1.0 ppm        Consistent readings
                                     above 3.5 ppm
Change in                            The higher the change,
                                     the worse the water
Temperature                          quality.


Turbidity         0-8 JTU’s          Increasing trends in
                                     turbidity measurements.
                                          12
Test      Natural Readings        Cautionary
                                         Readings
5 Day B.O.D                         The higher the difference
                                    between the original and
                                    the 5 day reading, the
                                    worse the water.




Phosphates       Less than 1 mg/L More than 1 mg/L


Total Solids                        The higher the
                                    concentration, the
                                    worse the water.

Fecal Coliform                      Over 200 colonies/100
                                    mL of water
                                        13
pH      Change in  Total Solids     Fecal    Discharge
                          Water Temp.   (mg/ L)      Coliform     (cubic
                           (Degrees                  (Col./
                                                          100    ft./
                                                                    sec.)
                            Celsius)                   mL)


May 27    Site 1   7.8        1.4         270          150        2.62

          Site 2   7.7        -1.3        420          100        1.22

          Site 3   7.9         0          590          750        2.65

          Site 4   8.2        -0.5        510          200        4.53

          Site 5   7.9        0.9         410          400        13.1

June 12
          Site 1   7.75      1.55         390          125       2.575
 & 13
          Site 2   7.7        -0.6        460          175        1.08

          Site 3   6.95       0.2         370          150        2.86

          Site 4   7.85       -0.4        600          700        2.96
                                                     14
          Site 5    8         0.7         510          550        12.2
Turbidity    Dissolved    Dissolved   5 Day     Nitrates   Phosphates
                  (JTU’s)    Oxygen (%      Oxygen     B.O.D.                 (ppm)
                                                                  (ppm)
                             Saturation)    (ppm)

May 27    S 1
           ite      23          60%          5.4        2.6       1.408       0.54

          S 2
           ite      41          41%          3.8        2.6       12.848      0.37

          S 3
           ite      51          53%          4.7        3.6       10.384      0.28

          S 4
           ite     139          9%           1.9         0        10.472      0.76

          S 5
           ite      36          25%          2.4         0        3.476       0.46

June 12
          S 1
           ite    13.5         69.5%         6.35       2.6       13.597       0.5
 & 13

          S 2
           ite    39.5         31.5%         3.1        0.7       2.748       1.725

          S 3
           ite      23         68.5%         6.3        2.2       1.342       0.37

          S 4
           ite     125         27.5%         2.8        0.2         0         3.84

          S 5
           ite      55         43.5%         4.1        2.5     15 7.59       0.44
pH      Change in  Total Solids    Fecal     Discharge
                            Water Temp.    mg/ L      Coliform      cubic
                              Degrees                Col./
                                                         100 mL    ft./
                                                                      sec.
                              Celsius


July 17 &
            Site 1   7.6        1.6         340         300        1.565
   18
            Site 2   7.25      -0.35        270         400         0.61
            Site 3   7.7       0.55         630         600        1.1105
            Site 4   8.15      -1.35        640         550         3.25
            Site 5   7.85      1.55         510        2200        9.505

August 8    Site 1   7.5        0.9         980        85100         NA

            Site 2   7.7        0.3         230         300         2.08

            Site 3   7.9       -0.1         300         1 00       2.382

            Site 4   7.9       -0.3         470         216          3.9
                                                      16
            Site 5   7.9        0          2760        68100         NA
Turbidity   Dissolved    Dissolved   5 Day     Nitrates    Phosphates
                    JTU’s      Oxygen %      Oxygen     B.O.D.                  (mg/L)
                                                                   (ppm)
                               Saturation     ppm

July 17
          Site 1      19         19.5         1.65      1.15      13.024        4.54
 & 18

          Site 2      18         21.5         1.9         1           0.836     0.365

          Site 3      73          32          2.6         .7          2.156     0.69

          Site 4    135.5        19.5         1.7         .1           0         3.18

          Site 5      55         57.5         4.85      2.25          9.878     1.275

August
          Site 1     794           0           0          0            0        4.48
  8

          Site 2      58          25          2.3        1.2          1.408     0.92

          Site 3      62          54          4.6        1.7          1.188      1.04

          Site 4     108          46           4          3           0.09      0.69
                                                                 17
          Site 5    2096           0           0          0           3.036      1.58
May 27 Site 1
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            57           0.17          9.69
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        40           0.16          6.4
pH             Units             90           0.11          9.9
B.O.D.         Mg/L              70           0.11          7.7
Temp.          Change in o C     90           0.10          9.0
Phosphates     Mg/L              60           0.10           6.0
Nitrates       Mg/L              94           0.10           9.4
Turbidity      JTU               56           0.08          4.48
Total Solids   Mg/L              63           0.07          4.41
                                                     18
     Overall Water Quality Index 66.98 (medium)
May 27 Site 2
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            31           0.17          5.27
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        44           0.16          7.04
pH             Units             91           0.11          10.01
B.O.D.         Mg/L              70           0.11           7.7
Temp.          Change in o C     90           0.10           9.0
Phosphates     Mg/L              96           0.10           9.6
Nitrates       Mg/L              45           0.10           4.5
Turbidity      JTU               44           0.08          3.52
Total Solids   Mg/L              45           0.07          3.15
            Overall Water Quality Index 59.79 (medium)
                                               19
May 27 Site 3
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total
D.O.           % Sat.            45           0.17          7.65
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        23           0.16          3.68
pH             Units             86           0.11          9.46
B.O.D.         Mg/L              70           0.11           7.7
Temp.          Change in o C     93           0.10           9.3
Phosphates     Mg/L              93           0.10           9.3
Nitrates       Mg/L              50           0.10           5.0
Turbidity      JTU               37           0.08          2.96
Total Solids   Mg/L              20           0.07           1.4
            Overall Water Quality Index 56.45 (medium)
                                               20
May 27 Site 4
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            5            0.17           .85
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        35           0.16           5.6
pH             Units             75           0.11           8.25
B.O.D.         Mg/L              96           0.11          10.56
Temp.          Change in o C     91           0.10            9.1
Phosphates     Mg/L              50           0.10           5.0
Nitrates       Mg/L              50           0.10           5.0
Turbidity      JTU                5           0.08            .4
Total Solids   Mg/L              20           0.07           1.4
            Overall Water Quality Index 46.16 (bad)
                                                21
May 27 Site 5
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            14           0.17          2.38
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        27           0.16          4.32
pH             Units             85           0.11           9.35
B.O.D.         Mg/L              96           0.11          10.56
Temp.          Change in o C     92           0.10            9.2
Phosphates     Mg/L               6           0.10           6.1
Nitrates       Mg/L              91           0.10           9.1
Turbidity      JTU               47           0.08          3.76
Total Solids   Mg/L              46       0.07              3.22
            Overall Water Quality Index 57.99 (medium)
                                               22
June 12 & 13 Site 1
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            75           0.17          12.75
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        43           0.16          6.88
pH             Units             90           0.11           9.9
B.O.D.         Mg/L              70           0.11           7.7
Temp.          Change in o C     90           0.10           9.0
Phosphates     Mg/L              60           0.10           6.0
Nitrates       Mg/L              48           0.10           4.8
Turbidity      JTU               71           0.08          5.68
Total Solids   Mg/L              48        0.07
                                                23
                                                     3.36
            Overall Water Quality Index 66.07 (medium)
June 12 & 13 Site 2
                Test Results   Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            20           0.17          3.4
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        38           0.16          6.08
pH             Units             88           0.11          9.68
B.O.D.         Mg/L              90           0.11           9.9
Temp.          Change in o C     90           0.10           9.0
Phosphates     Mg/L              29           0.10           2.9
Nitrates       Mg/L              90           0.10           9.0
Turbidity      JTU               46           0.08          3.68
Total Solids   Mg/L              39           0.07          2.73
            Overall Water Quality Index 56.37 (medium)
                                                24
June 12 & 13 Site 3
                Test Results   Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            74           0.17          12.58
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        40           0.16           6.4
pH             Units             90           0.11           9.9
B.O.D.         Mg/L              70           0.11           7.7
Temp.          Change in o C     91           0.10           9.1
Phosphates     Mg/L              90           0.10           9.0
Nitrates       Mg/L              94           0.10           9.4
Turbidity      JTU               59           0.08          4.72
Total Solids   Mg/L              50           0.07           3.5
            Overall Water Quality Index 72.3 (good)
                                                25
June 12 & 13 Site 4
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            18           0.17          3.06
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        23           0.16          3.68
pH             Units             88           0.11           9.68
B.O.D.         Mg/L              95           0.11          10.45
Temp.          Change in o C     90           0.10            9.0
Phosphates     Mg/L              18           0.10           1.8
Nitrates       Mg/L              97           0.10           9.7
Turbidity      JTU                5           0.08           0.4
Total Solids   Mg/L              20           0.07           1.4
            Overall Water Quality Index 49.17 (bad)
                                                26
June 12 & 13 Site 5
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            40           0.17          6.8
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        24           0.16          3.84
pH             Units             82           0.11          9.02
B.O.D.         Mg/L              70           0.11           7.7
Temp.          Change in o C     90           0.10           9.0
Phosphates     Mg/L              65           0.10           6.5
Nitrates       Mg/L              57           0.10           5.7
Turbidity      JTU               36           0.08          2.88
Total Solids   Mg/L              20           0.07           1.4
            Overall Water Quality Index 52.84 (medium)
                                               27
July 17 & 18 Site 1
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            10           0.17          1.7
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        30           0.16          4.8
pH             Units             89           0.11          9.79
B.O.D.         Mg/L              90           0.11           9.9
Temp.          Change in o C     88           0.10           8.8
Phosphates     Mg/L              16           0.10           1.6
Nitrates       Mg/L              45           0.10           4.5
Turbidity      JTU               61           0.08          4.88
Total Solids   Mg/L              53           0.07          3.71
            Overall Water Quality Index 49.68 (bad)
                                               28
July 17 & 18 Site 2
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            12           0.17          2.04
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        27           0.16          4.32
pH             Units             91           0.11          10.01
B.O.D.         Mg/L              90           0.11           9.9
Temp.          Change in o C     88           0.10           8.8
Phosphates     Mg/L              90           0.10            9
Nitrates       Mg/L              54           0.10           5.4
Turbidity      JTU               63           0.08          5.04
Total Solids   Mg/L              61           0.07          4.27
            Overall Water Quality Index 58.78 (medium)
                                               29
July 17 & 18 Site 3
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            20           0.17           3.4
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        25           0.16           4
pH             Units             88           0.11           9.68
B.O.D.         Mg/L              92           0.11          10.12
Temp.          Change in o C     92           0.10            9.2
Phosphates     Mg/L              61           0.10           6.1
Nitrates       Mg/L              90           0.10           9.0
Turbidity      JTU               28           0.08          2.24
Total Solids   Mg/L              20           0.07           1.4
            Overall Water Quality Index 55.14 (medium)
                                               30
July 17 & 18 Site 4
                 Test Results   Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.            % Sat.            9            0.17          1.53
Fecal
Coliform        Col./100mL        26           0.16          4.16
pH              Units             76           0.11           8.37
B.O.D.          Mg/L              99           0.11          10.89
Temp.           Change in o C     89           0.10            8.9
Phosphates      Mg/L              20           0.10            2
Nitrates        Mg/L              97           0.10           9.7
Turbidity       JTU                5           0.08           0.4
Total Solids    Mg/L              20           0.07           1.4
               Overall Water Quality Index 47.35 (bad)
                                                31
July 17 & 18 Site 5
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            48           0.17          8.16
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        18           0.16          2.88
pH             Units             89           0.11          9.79
B.O.D.         Mg/L              70           0.11           7.7
Temp.          Change in o C     88           0.10           8.8
Phosphates     Mg/L              33           0.10           3.3
Nitrates       Mg/L              51           0.10           5.1
Turbidity      JTU               37           0.08          2.96
Total Solids   Mg/L              20           0.07           1.4
            Overall Water Quality Index 50.0932
                                              (medium)
August 8 Site 1
                Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.            % Sat.            0            0.17           0
Fecal
Coliform        Col./100mL        20           0.16          0.32
pH              Units             93           0.11          10.23
B.O.D.          Mg/L              97           0.11          1.067
Temp.           Change in o C     91           0.10           9.1
Phosphates      Mg/L             15            0.10           1.5
Nitrates        Mg/L             96            0.10           9.6
Turbidity       JTU              0.5           0.08          0.04
Total Solids    Mg/L             20            0.07           1.4
                                                    33
               Overall Water Quality Index 33.257 (bad)
August 8 Site 2
                Test Results   Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            17           0.17          2.89
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        32           0.16          5.12
pH             Units             90           0.11           9.9
B.O.D.         Mg/L              94           0.11          10.34
Temp.          Change in o C     92           0.10           9.2
Phosphates     Mg/L              42           0.10           4.2
Nitrates       Mg/L              92           0.10           9.2
Turbidity      JTU               35           0.08           2.2
Total Solids   Mg/L              67           0.07          4.69
                                                   34
               Overall Water Quality Index 57.74 (medium)
August 8 Site 3
                Test Results   Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            43           0.17          7.31
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        45           0.16          7.2
pH             Units             86           0.11          9.46
B.O.D.         Mg/L              89           0.11          9.79
Temp.          Change in o C     90           0.10            9
Phosphates     Mg/L              38           0.10           3.8
Nitrates       Mg/L              95           0.10           9.5
Turbidity      JTU               32           0.08          2.56
Total Solids   Mg/L              59           0.07          4.13
                                                   35
               Overall Water Quality Index 62.75 (medium)
August 8 Site 4
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            39           0.17          6.63
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        34           0.16          5.44
pH             Units             86           0.11          9.46
B.O.D.         Mg/L              63           0.11          6.93
Temp.          Change in o C     89           0.10           8.9
Phosphates     Mg/L              57           0.10           5.7
Nitrates       Mg/L              96           0.10           9.6
Turbidity      JTU               50           0.08           0.4
Total Solids   Mg/L              32           0.07          2.24
                                                   36
               Overall Water Quality Index 55.3 (medium)
August 8 Site 5
               Test Results    Q-Value   Weighting Factor   Total

D.O.           % Sat.            0            0.17           0
Fecal
Coliform       Col./100mL        20           0.16          0.32
pH             Units             86           0.11           9.46
B.O.D.         Mg/L              97           0.11          10.67
Temp.          Change in o C     92           0.10            9.2
Phosphates     Mg/L              28           0.10           2.8
Nitrates       Mg/L              68           0.10           6.8
Turbidity      JTU               50           0.08           0.4
Total Solids   Mg/L              20           0.07           1.4
            Overall Water Quality Index 41.05 (bad)
                                                37
2006 Precipitation

         10

         8

         6
Inches




         4

         2

         0
              May        June        July   August

                          Rainfall


                                            38
pH



              8.4

              8.1
              7.8                                                   Site   1
p H Le ve l




                                                                    Site   2
              7.5                                                   Site   3
              7.2                                                   Site   4
                                                                    Site   5
              6.9
              6.6

              6.3
                    Ma y 27   Jun e 12 &    July 17 &   Aug ust 8
                                  13            18
                                      Da te

                                                            39
Ch a nge in Wa te r Te mpe ra ture

                          2

                        1.5

                          1
De g re e s Ce lcius




                                                                              Site   1
                        0.5                                                   Site   2
                                                                              Site   3
                          0                                                   Site   4
                               Ma y 27   Jun e 12 &   July 17 &   Aug ust 8   Site   5
                       - 0.5                 13           18

                         -1

                       - 1.5
                                                  Da te

                                                                     40
Tota l Solid s

        3000

        2500

        2000                                                  Site   1
                                                              Site   2
mg/ L




        1500                                                  Site   3
                                                              Site   4
        1000                                                  Site   5

         500

           0
               Ma y 27   Jun e 12 &   July 17 &   Aug ust 8
                             13           18
                                 Da te

                                                      41
Fe ca l Coliform

                      2500


                      2000
colon ie s/ 100 m L




                                                                            Site   1
                      1500                                                  Site   2
                                                                            Site   3
                      1000                                                  Site   4
                                                                            Site   5
                       500


                         0
                             Ma y 27   Jun e 12 &   July 17 &   Aug ust 8
                                           13           18
                                               Da te

                       *August 8-Site 1- 85,100 colonies/100 mL
                              Site 5-68,100 colonies/100 mL         42
Fecal Coliform




                 43
Flow

                               14

                               12
Cub ic fe e t p e r se con d




                               10                                                  Site   1
                                8                                                  Site   2
                                                                                   Site   3
                                6                                                  Site   4
                                4                                                  Site   5

                                2

                                0
                                    Ma y 27   Jun e 12 &   July 17 &   Aug ust 8
                                                  13           18
                                                      Da te

                                                                             44
Turbid ity

        160
        140
        120
                                                             Site   1
        100
                                                             Site   2
JTU's




         80                                                  Site   3
         60                                                  Site   4
                                                             Site   5
         40
         20
          0
              Ma y 27   Jun e 12 &   July 17 &   Aug ust 8
                            13           18
                                Da te

          *Augst 8-Site 1 794 JTU’s
                 Site 5 2,096 JTU’s                   45
Dissolve d O xyge n

      7

      6

      5                                                   Site   1
      4                                                   Site   2
ppm




                                                          Site   3
      3                                                   Site   4
      2                                                   Site   5

      1

      0
          Ma y 27   Jun e 12 & July 17 & 18   Aug ust 8
                        13
                            Da te

                                                    46
Dissolve d O xyge n

                 100
                  90
                  80
                  70                                                  Site   1
% Sa tura tion




                  60                                                  Site   2
                  50                                                  Site   3
                  40                                                  Site   4
                  30                                                  Site   5
                  20
                  10
                   0
                       Ma y 27   Jun e 12 &   July 17 &   Aug ust 8
                                     13           18
                                         Da te

                                                               47
5 Da y Biologica l O xyge n De ma n d

      6

      5

      4                                                   Site   1
                                                          Site   2
ppm




      3                                                   Site   3
                                                          Site   4
      2                                                   Site   5

      1

      0
          Ma y 27   Jun e 12 & July 17 & 18   Aug ust 8
                        13
                            Da te

                                                    48
N itra te s

      16
      14
      12
                                                          Site   1
      10
                                                          Site   2
ppm




       8                                                  Site   3
       6                                                  Site   4
                                                          Site   5
       4
       2
       0
           Ma y 27   Jun e 12 &   July 17 &   Aug ust 8
                         13           18
                             Da te

                                                    49
Phosph a te s

        5
      4.5
        4
      3.5                                                  Site   1
        3                                                  Site   2
ppm




      2.5                                                  Site   3
        2                                                  Site   4
      1.5                                                  Site   5
        1
      0.5
        0
            Ma y 27   Jun e 12 &   July 17 &   Aug ust 8
                          13           18
                              Da te

                                                    50
Chemical Test Conclusion
• pH consistent
• D.O. consistently low
• Fecal coliform is increasing
• Phosphates are increasing
• May WQI averages consistent since 2003
• By site WQI averages are consistent within 5
  points
• Each year from 2003-2005 WQI increased over
  the summer
                                   51
WQI Averages by Site
Site 1                    54
Site 2                    58
Site 3                    62
Site 4                    49
Site 5                    50
         WQI Averages by Date
May 27                    57
June 12 & 13              59
July 17 & 18              52
August 8                  50
                                52
WQI Averages by Site

70

60

50

40
                                                         2003 Averages
30                                                       2004 Averages
                                                         2005 Averages
20                                                       2006 Averages

10

 0
     Site 1   Site 2     Site 3   Site 4   Site 5
                         Site
                                                    53
WQI Averages by Date

80

70

60

50                                             2003 Averages
                                               2004 Averages
40
                                               2005 Averages
30                                             2006 Averages
20

10

 0
     May   June           July   August
                  Month                   54
2003 to 2005 Chemical Test Average
                         Comparisons

12

10

8
                                                                  2003 Averages
6
                                                                  2004 Averages
4                                                                 2005 Averages
                                                                  2006 Averages
2

0
              pH




                                                .
         ge




                        es




                                     es




                                                          p.
                                              .D




                                                         m
                     at




                                  at
       ar




                                          .O




                                                        Te
                    itr




                                ph
    ch




                                          B
                   N




                              os
  is




                                                    in
 D




                             Ph




                                                    e
                                                  ng
                                                ha

                          Chemical Test
                                               C



                                                             55
2003 to 2005 Chemical Test Average Comparisons


1200
                 *2006 Fecal Coliform
1000             Average 8,058 col/100 mL

800
                                                                  2003 Averages
600                                                               2004 Averages
                                                                  2005 Averages
400
                                                                  2006 Averages

200

  0
        D.O. % Sat.   Turbidity   Fecal Coliform   Total Solids
                                                             56
                          Chemical Test
Macro Invertebrates

Sensitive         Somewhat Sensitive        Tolerant




                                       57
Sample Bio-Indicator Data Form




                      58
Bio-Indicator Comparison Chart
            2002 & 2004-2006
20
18
16
14
12                                                     Summer 2002
10                                                     Summer 2004
8                                                      Summer 2005
6                                                      Summer 2006
4
2
0
     Site 1   Site 2   Site 3   Site 4   Site 5
                                                  59
Bio-Indicator Ratings
          14
                                                 si te 1
          12
                                                 si te 2
          10
                                                 si te 3
           8
 atings




                                                 si te 4
           6                                     si te 5
R




           4
           2
           0
               M
               ay   Jn e
                     u            Jl y
                                   u     Agu
                                          u st
                           M th
                           on


                                           60
Bio-Indicators Test Conclusions
• Average water quality-poor
• Water quality is poor-making macro
  invertebrates hard to find
• Improvement from 2005
• Lower ratings than 2002 & 2004




                                 61
Fish Study
              1939 1972 1985 1989 1991 1992 1995 2006
Black                    X    X   X          X    X
Bullhead
Carp                X    X        X     X    X
Fathead        X    X    X    X   X     X    X    X
Minnow
Sand Shiner         X    X        X     X    X    X
Red Shiner     X    X    X        X     X         X
Bigmouth            X
Shiner
Brassy              X
Minnow
                                        62
Fish Study
             1939 1972 1985 1989 1991 1992 1995 2006
Channel            X    X        X
Catfish
Emerald                          X
Shiner
Flathead                X
Chub
Freshwater
Drum
Plains             X
Minnow
Quilback           X    X
                                       63
Fish Study
                1939 1972 1985 1989 1991 1992 1995 2006
River                       X
Carpsucker
Shortnose gar               X
Shorthead             X     X
redhorse
Western Silvery       X
Minnow
Silver Chub                 X
Flathead Catfish                     X
Speckled Chub                            X
Green Sunfish                            X            X
Yellow Bullhead                                       X
Total Fish Diversity 2 11   12   2   8   6   64   4   6
Black Bullhead
A e riurus m e la s
 m




                      65
Fathead Minnow
Pim e p ha le s p ro m e la s




                          66
Sand Shiner
N tro p is s tra m ine us
 o




                       67
Red Shiner
Ly p rine lla lutre us is




                        68
Green Sunfish
Le p o m is c y a ne llus




                        69
Yellow Bullhead
A e riurus na ta lis
 m




                   70
Fish Study Conclusion
• Fish vary greatly over years
• With the information from Phil Chvala at
  the Nebraska Game and Parks
  Commision
  – Fish diversity is a lot worse
  – Better than in 1995
  – 2006 study same diversity as 1992 study
• Can’t make any conclusions at this point
                                    71
Using the
Equipment




72
Bio-Indicators



                 73
Lab Work




    74
75
Website
• http://newman.esu8.org/project.html
                 OR
      • http://newman.esu8.org/
         • Click “Our Students”
       • Click “Student Projects”
     • Click “Watershed Project”
 • You can see our data and further
  information concerning this project,
            including pictures. 76
Thank You To:
  • Lower Platte North Natural
       Resource District

     • PrairieLand RC&D

• Natural Resource Conservation
             Service

   • Nebraska Department of
      Environmental Quality

   • Shell Creek Watershed    77
      Improvement Group
Special Thanks



• Dedicated
  to Brittany
  Julsen

                       78

NG Shell Creek Data Powerpoint 2006

  • 1.
    2006 Shell Creek W atershed Study Advisors – Mark Seier & Suzy Goedeken Researchers – Amanda Gasper, Melissa Gasper, Heather Schmidt, Tom O’Brien, Laura Johnson, Josh Kaufman, Tim Wiese, Mandy Anderson, Jessica Boschen, Sean Farrier, Brittany Julsen, Ann O’Brien, Sheila O’Brien, Lynzee Pieke, Brett Roberg, Connie Dohmen, Luke Gasper, Jesse Knust, Alyshia Nelson, Skye Rosno, Darrek Schmidt & Kelsey Wallin 1
  • 2.
    Shell Creek andLoseke-Taylor Creek Watersheds (with Township-Range Labels) Lower Platte North Natural Resources District 2
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
    W.Q.I. • The WaterQuality Index was developed by the National Sanitation Foundation as a standard system to compare different bodies of water. • To determine the WQI, a series of nine tests were performed. These tests were: dissolved oxygen, fecal coliform, pH, Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD), temperature, total phosphate, nitrates, turbidity, and total solids. We also did a water discharge test which we use to measure the flow of the creek in cubic feet per second. 8
  • 9.
    • After thetests are completed, the WQI for each section of the creek can be computed. • To formulate the WQI, we first computed Q-values. • We multiply this number by a weighting factor, which provides a measure of the relative importance of each test to overall water quality. • The water quality index ranges from zero to 100. - 0 - 25 is very bad - 25 - 50 is bad - 50 - 70 is medium - 70 - 90 is good - 90 - 100 is excellent • The bio-indicator tests weren’t part of W.Q.I., but did give us a water quality rating. 9
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Sample W.Q.I. Form Weighting T o t a l Test Results Q-value Factor DO % sat. 0.17 Fecal Coliform col/100 mL 0.16 pH units 0.11 BOD mg/L 0.11 Temperature change in C 0.1 Total Phosphate mg/L 0.1 Nitrates mg/L 0.1 Turbidity JTU 0.08 Total Solids mg/L 0.07 Overall Water Quality Index ___ 11
  • 12.
    Test Natural Readings Cautionary Readings Dissolved Oxygen % 90% or higher Below 90% unless the waters are supersaturated Saturation due to cultural eutrophication. pH 6.5-8.5 Below 6.5 Above 8.5 Nitrates 0.0-1.0 ppm Consistent readings above 3.5 ppm Change in The higher the change, the worse the water Temperature quality. Turbidity 0-8 JTU’s Increasing trends in turbidity measurements. 12
  • 13.
    Test Natural Readings Cautionary Readings 5 Day B.O.D The higher the difference between the original and the 5 day reading, the worse the water. Phosphates Less than 1 mg/L More than 1 mg/L Total Solids The higher the concentration, the worse the water. Fecal Coliform Over 200 colonies/100 mL of water 13
  • 14.
    pH Change in Total Solids Fecal Discharge Water Temp. (mg/ L) Coliform (cubic (Degrees (Col./ 100 ft./ sec.) Celsius) mL) May 27 Site 1 7.8 1.4 270 150 2.62 Site 2 7.7 -1.3 420 100 1.22 Site 3 7.9 0 590 750 2.65 Site 4 8.2 -0.5 510 200 4.53 Site 5 7.9 0.9 410 400 13.1 June 12 Site 1 7.75 1.55 390 125 2.575 & 13 Site 2 7.7 -0.6 460 175 1.08 Site 3 6.95 0.2 370 150 2.86 Site 4 7.85 -0.4 600 700 2.96 14 Site 5 8 0.7 510 550 12.2
  • 15.
    Turbidity Dissolved Dissolved 5 Day Nitrates Phosphates (JTU’s) Oxygen (% Oxygen B.O.D. (ppm) (ppm) Saturation) (ppm) May 27 S 1 ite 23 60% 5.4 2.6 1.408 0.54 S 2 ite 41 41% 3.8 2.6 12.848 0.37 S 3 ite 51 53% 4.7 3.6 10.384 0.28 S 4 ite 139 9% 1.9 0 10.472 0.76 S 5 ite 36 25% 2.4 0 3.476 0.46 June 12 S 1 ite 13.5 69.5% 6.35 2.6 13.597 0.5 & 13 S 2 ite 39.5 31.5% 3.1 0.7 2.748 1.725 S 3 ite 23 68.5% 6.3 2.2 1.342 0.37 S 4 ite 125 27.5% 2.8 0.2 0 3.84 S 5 ite 55 43.5% 4.1 2.5 15 7.59 0.44
  • 16.
    pH Change in Total Solids Fecal Discharge Water Temp. mg/ L Coliform cubic Degrees Col./ 100 mL ft./ sec. Celsius July 17 & Site 1 7.6 1.6 340 300 1.565 18 Site 2 7.25 -0.35 270 400 0.61 Site 3 7.7 0.55 630 600 1.1105 Site 4 8.15 -1.35 640 550 3.25 Site 5 7.85 1.55 510 2200 9.505 August 8 Site 1 7.5 0.9 980 85100 NA Site 2 7.7 0.3 230 300 2.08 Site 3 7.9 -0.1 300 1 00 2.382 Site 4 7.9 -0.3 470 216 3.9 16 Site 5 7.9 0 2760 68100 NA
  • 17.
    Turbidity Dissolved Dissolved 5 Day Nitrates Phosphates JTU’s Oxygen % Oxygen B.O.D. (mg/L) (ppm) Saturation ppm July 17 Site 1 19 19.5 1.65 1.15 13.024 4.54 & 18 Site 2 18 21.5 1.9 1 0.836 0.365 Site 3 73 32 2.6 .7 2.156 0.69 Site 4 135.5 19.5 1.7 .1 0 3.18 Site 5 55 57.5 4.85 2.25 9.878 1.275 August Site 1 794 0 0 0 0 4.48 8 Site 2 58 25 2.3 1.2 1.408 0.92 Site 3 62 54 4.6 1.7 1.188 1.04 Site 4 108 46 4 3 0.09 0.69 17 Site 5 2096 0 0 0 3.036 1.58
  • 18.
    May 27 Site1 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 57 0.17 9.69 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 40 0.16 6.4 pH Units 90 0.11 9.9 B.O.D. Mg/L 70 0.11 7.7 Temp. Change in o C 90 0.10 9.0 Phosphates Mg/L 60 0.10 6.0 Nitrates Mg/L 94 0.10 9.4 Turbidity JTU 56 0.08 4.48 Total Solids Mg/L 63 0.07 4.41 18 Overall Water Quality Index 66.98 (medium)
  • 19.
    May 27 Site2 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 31 0.17 5.27 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 44 0.16 7.04 pH Units 91 0.11 10.01 B.O.D. Mg/L 70 0.11 7.7 Temp. Change in o C 90 0.10 9.0 Phosphates Mg/L 96 0.10 9.6 Nitrates Mg/L 45 0.10 4.5 Turbidity JTU 44 0.08 3.52 Total Solids Mg/L 45 0.07 3.15 Overall Water Quality Index 59.79 (medium) 19
  • 20.
    May 27 Site3 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 45 0.17 7.65 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 23 0.16 3.68 pH Units 86 0.11 9.46 B.O.D. Mg/L 70 0.11 7.7 Temp. Change in o C 93 0.10 9.3 Phosphates Mg/L 93 0.10 9.3 Nitrates Mg/L 50 0.10 5.0 Turbidity JTU 37 0.08 2.96 Total Solids Mg/L 20 0.07 1.4 Overall Water Quality Index 56.45 (medium) 20
  • 21.
    May 27 Site4 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 5 0.17 .85 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 35 0.16 5.6 pH Units 75 0.11 8.25 B.O.D. Mg/L 96 0.11 10.56 Temp. Change in o C 91 0.10 9.1 Phosphates Mg/L 50 0.10 5.0 Nitrates Mg/L 50 0.10 5.0 Turbidity JTU 5 0.08 .4 Total Solids Mg/L 20 0.07 1.4 Overall Water Quality Index 46.16 (bad) 21
  • 22.
    May 27 Site5 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 14 0.17 2.38 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 27 0.16 4.32 pH Units 85 0.11 9.35 B.O.D. Mg/L 96 0.11 10.56 Temp. Change in o C 92 0.10 9.2 Phosphates Mg/L 6 0.10 6.1 Nitrates Mg/L 91 0.10 9.1 Turbidity JTU 47 0.08 3.76 Total Solids Mg/L 46 0.07 3.22 Overall Water Quality Index 57.99 (medium) 22
  • 23.
    June 12 &13 Site 1 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 75 0.17 12.75 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 43 0.16 6.88 pH Units 90 0.11 9.9 B.O.D. Mg/L 70 0.11 7.7 Temp. Change in o C 90 0.10 9.0 Phosphates Mg/L 60 0.10 6.0 Nitrates Mg/L 48 0.10 4.8 Turbidity JTU 71 0.08 5.68 Total Solids Mg/L 48 0.07 23 3.36 Overall Water Quality Index 66.07 (medium)
  • 24.
    June 12 &13 Site 2 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 20 0.17 3.4 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 38 0.16 6.08 pH Units 88 0.11 9.68 B.O.D. Mg/L 90 0.11 9.9 Temp. Change in o C 90 0.10 9.0 Phosphates Mg/L 29 0.10 2.9 Nitrates Mg/L 90 0.10 9.0 Turbidity JTU 46 0.08 3.68 Total Solids Mg/L 39 0.07 2.73 Overall Water Quality Index 56.37 (medium) 24
  • 25.
    June 12 &13 Site 3 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 74 0.17 12.58 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 40 0.16 6.4 pH Units 90 0.11 9.9 B.O.D. Mg/L 70 0.11 7.7 Temp. Change in o C 91 0.10 9.1 Phosphates Mg/L 90 0.10 9.0 Nitrates Mg/L 94 0.10 9.4 Turbidity JTU 59 0.08 4.72 Total Solids Mg/L 50 0.07 3.5 Overall Water Quality Index 72.3 (good) 25
  • 26.
    June 12 &13 Site 4 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 18 0.17 3.06 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 23 0.16 3.68 pH Units 88 0.11 9.68 B.O.D. Mg/L 95 0.11 10.45 Temp. Change in o C 90 0.10 9.0 Phosphates Mg/L 18 0.10 1.8 Nitrates Mg/L 97 0.10 9.7 Turbidity JTU 5 0.08 0.4 Total Solids Mg/L 20 0.07 1.4 Overall Water Quality Index 49.17 (bad) 26
  • 27.
    June 12 &13 Site 5 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 40 0.17 6.8 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 24 0.16 3.84 pH Units 82 0.11 9.02 B.O.D. Mg/L 70 0.11 7.7 Temp. Change in o C 90 0.10 9.0 Phosphates Mg/L 65 0.10 6.5 Nitrates Mg/L 57 0.10 5.7 Turbidity JTU 36 0.08 2.88 Total Solids Mg/L 20 0.07 1.4 Overall Water Quality Index 52.84 (medium) 27
  • 28.
    July 17 &18 Site 1 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 10 0.17 1.7 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 30 0.16 4.8 pH Units 89 0.11 9.79 B.O.D. Mg/L 90 0.11 9.9 Temp. Change in o C 88 0.10 8.8 Phosphates Mg/L 16 0.10 1.6 Nitrates Mg/L 45 0.10 4.5 Turbidity JTU 61 0.08 4.88 Total Solids Mg/L 53 0.07 3.71 Overall Water Quality Index 49.68 (bad) 28
  • 29.
    July 17 &18 Site 2 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 12 0.17 2.04 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 27 0.16 4.32 pH Units 91 0.11 10.01 B.O.D. Mg/L 90 0.11 9.9 Temp. Change in o C 88 0.10 8.8 Phosphates Mg/L 90 0.10 9 Nitrates Mg/L 54 0.10 5.4 Turbidity JTU 63 0.08 5.04 Total Solids Mg/L 61 0.07 4.27 Overall Water Quality Index 58.78 (medium) 29
  • 30.
    July 17 &18 Site 3 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 20 0.17 3.4 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 25 0.16 4 pH Units 88 0.11 9.68 B.O.D. Mg/L 92 0.11 10.12 Temp. Change in o C 92 0.10 9.2 Phosphates Mg/L 61 0.10 6.1 Nitrates Mg/L 90 0.10 9.0 Turbidity JTU 28 0.08 2.24 Total Solids Mg/L 20 0.07 1.4 Overall Water Quality Index 55.14 (medium) 30
  • 31.
    July 17 &18 Site 4 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 9 0.17 1.53 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 26 0.16 4.16 pH Units 76 0.11 8.37 B.O.D. Mg/L 99 0.11 10.89 Temp. Change in o C 89 0.10 8.9 Phosphates Mg/L 20 0.10 2 Nitrates Mg/L 97 0.10 9.7 Turbidity JTU 5 0.08 0.4 Total Solids Mg/L 20 0.07 1.4 Overall Water Quality Index 47.35 (bad) 31
  • 32.
    July 17 &18 Site 5 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 48 0.17 8.16 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 18 0.16 2.88 pH Units 89 0.11 9.79 B.O.D. Mg/L 70 0.11 7.7 Temp. Change in o C 88 0.10 8.8 Phosphates Mg/L 33 0.10 3.3 Nitrates Mg/L 51 0.10 5.1 Turbidity JTU 37 0.08 2.96 Total Solids Mg/L 20 0.07 1.4 Overall Water Quality Index 50.0932 (medium)
  • 33.
    August 8 Site1 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 0 0.17 0 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 20 0.16 0.32 pH Units 93 0.11 10.23 B.O.D. Mg/L 97 0.11 1.067 Temp. Change in o C 91 0.10 9.1 Phosphates Mg/L 15 0.10 1.5 Nitrates Mg/L 96 0.10 9.6 Turbidity JTU 0.5 0.08 0.04 Total Solids Mg/L 20 0.07 1.4 33 Overall Water Quality Index 33.257 (bad)
  • 34.
    August 8 Site2 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 17 0.17 2.89 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 32 0.16 5.12 pH Units 90 0.11 9.9 B.O.D. Mg/L 94 0.11 10.34 Temp. Change in o C 92 0.10 9.2 Phosphates Mg/L 42 0.10 4.2 Nitrates Mg/L 92 0.10 9.2 Turbidity JTU 35 0.08 2.2 Total Solids Mg/L 67 0.07 4.69 34 Overall Water Quality Index 57.74 (medium)
  • 35.
    August 8 Site3 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 43 0.17 7.31 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 45 0.16 7.2 pH Units 86 0.11 9.46 B.O.D. Mg/L 89 0.11 9.79 Temp. Change in o C 90 0.10 9 Phosphates Mg/L 38 0.10 3.8 Nitrates Mg/L 95 0.10 9.5 Turbidity JTU 32 0.08 2.56 Total Solids Mg/L 59 0.07 4.13 35 Overall Water Quality Index 62.75 (medium)
  • 36.
    August 8 Site4 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 39 0.17 6.63 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 34 0.16 5.44 pH Units 86 0.11 9.46 B.O.D. Mg/L 63 0.11 6.93 Temp. Change in o C 89 0.10 8.9 Phosphates Mg/L 57 0.10 5.7 Nitrates Mg/L 96 0.10 9.6 Turbidity JTU 50 0.08 0.4 Total Solids Mg/L 32 0.07 2.24 36 Overall Water Quality Index 55.3 (medium)
  • 37.
    August 8 Site5 Test Results Q-Value Weighting Factor Total D.O. % Sat. 0 0.17 0 Fecal Coliform Col./100mL 20 0.16 0.32 pH Units 86 0.11 9.46 B.O.D. Mg/L 97 0.11 10.67 Temp. Change in o C 92 0.10 9.2 Phosphates Mg/L 28 0.10 2.8 Nitrates Mg/L 68 0.10 6.8 Turbidity JTU 50 0.08 0.4 Total Solids Mg/L 20 0.07 1.4 Overall Water Quality Index 41.05 (bad) 37
  • 38.
    2006 Precipitation 10 8 6 Inches 4 2 0 May June July August Rainfall 38
  • 39.
    pH 8.4 8.1 7.8 Site 1 p H Le ve l Site 2 7.5 Site 3 7.2 Site 4 Site 5 6.9 6.6 6.3 Ma y 27 Jun e 12 & July 17 & Aug ust 8 13 18 Da te 39
  • 40.
    Ch a ngein Wa te r Te mpe ra ture 2 1.5 1 De g re e s Ce lcius Site 1 0.5 Site 2 Site 3 0 Site 4 Ma y 27 Jun e 12 & July 17 & Aug ust 8 Site 5 - 0.5 13 18 -1 - 1.5 Da te 40
  • 41.
    Tota l Solids 3000 2500 2000 Site 1 Site 2 mg/ L 1500 Site 3 Site 4 1000 Site 5 500 0 Ma y 27 Jun e 12 & July 17 & Aug ust 8 13 18 Da te 41
  • 42.
    Fe ca lColiform 2500 2000 colon ie s/ 100 m L Site 1 1500 Site 2 Site 3 1000 Site 4 Site 5 500 0 Ma y 27 Jun e 12 & July 17 & Aug ust 8 13 18 Da te *August 8-Site 1- 85,100 colonies/100 mL Site 5-68,100 colonies/100 mL 42
  • 43.
  • 44.
    Flow 14 12 Cub ic fe e t p e r se con d 10 Site 1 8 Site 2 Site 3 6 Site 4 4 Site 5 2 0 Ma y 27 Jun e 12 & July 17 & Aug ust 8 13 18 Da te 44
  • 45.
    Turbid ity 160 140 120 Site 1 100 Site 2 JTU's 80 Site 3 60 Site 4 Site 5 40 20 0 Ma y 27 Jun e 12 & July 17 & Aug ust 8 13 18 Da te *Augst 8-Site 1 794 JTU’s Site 5 2,096 JTU’s 45
  • 46.
    Dissolve d Oxyge n 7 6 5 Site 1 4 Site 2 ppm Site 3 3 Site 4 2 Site 5 1 0 Ma y 27 Jun e 12 & July 17 & 18 Aug ust 8 13 Da te 46
  • 47.
    Dissolve d Oxyge n 100 90 80 70 Site 1 % Sa tura tion 60 Site 2 50 Site 3 40 Site 4 30 Site 5 20 10 0 Ma y 27 Jun e 12 & July 17 & Aug ust 8 13 18 Da te 47
  • 48.
    5 Da yBiologica l O xyge n De ma n d 6 5 4 Site 1 Site 2 ppm 3 Site 3 Site 4 2 Site 5 1 0 Ma y 27 Jun e 12 & July 17 & 18 Aug ust 8 13 Da te 48
  • 49.
    N itra tes 16 14 12 Site 1 10 Site 2 ppm 8 Site 3 6 Site 4 Site 5 4 2 0 Ma y 27 Jun e 12 & July 17 & Aug ust 8 13 18 Da te 49
  • 50.
    Phosph a tes 5 4.5 4 3.5 Site 1 3 Site 2 ppm 2.5 Site 3 2 Site 4 1.5 Site 5 1 0.5 0 Ma y 27 Jun e 12 & July 17 & Aug ust 8 13 18 Da te 50
  • 51.
    Chemical Test Conclusion •pH consistent • D.O. consistently low • Fecal coliform is increasing • Phosphates are increasing • May WQI averages consistent since 2003 • By site WQI averages are consistent within 5 points • Each year from 2003-2005 WQI increased over the summer 51
  • 52.
    WQI Averages bySite Site 1 54 Site 2 58 Site 3 62 Site 4 49 Site 5 50 WQI Averages by Date May 27 57 June 12 & 13 59 July 17 & 18 52 August 8 50 52
  • 53.
    WQI Averages bySite 70 60 50 40 2003 Averages 30 2004 Averages 2005 Averages 20 2006 Averages 10 0 Site 1 Site 2 Site 3 Site 4 Site 5 Site 53
  • 54.
    WQI Averages byDate 80 70 60 50 2003 Averages 2004 Averages 40 2005 Averages 30 2006 Averages 20 10 0 May June July August Month 54
  • 55.
    2003 to 2005Chemical Test Average Comparisons 12 10 8 2003 Averages 6 2004 Averages 4 2005 Averages 2006 Averages 2 0 pH . ge es es p. .D m at at ar .O Te itr ph ch B N os is in D Ph e ng ha Chemical Test C 55
  • 56.
    2003 to 2005Chemical Test Average Comparisons 1200 *2006 Fecal Coliform 1000 Average 8,058 col/100 mL 800 2003 Averages 600 2004 Averages 2005 Averages 400 2006 Averages 200 0 D.O. % Sat. Turbidity Fecal Coliform Total Solids 56 Chemical Test
  • 57.
    Macro Invertebrates Sensitive Somewhat Sensitive Tolerant 57
  • 58.
  • 59.
    Bio-Indicator Comparison Chart 2002 & 2004-2006 20 18 16 14 12 Summer 2002 10 Summer 2004 8 Summer 2005 6 Summer 2006 4 2 0 Site 1 Site 2 Site 3 Site 4 Site 5 59
  • 60.
    Bio-Indicator Ratings 14 si te 1 12 si te 2 10 si te 3 8 atings si te 4 6 si te 5 R 4 2 0 M ay Jn e u Jl y u Agu u st M th on 60
  • 61.
    Bio-Indicators Test Conclusions •Average water quality-poor • Water quality is poor-making macro invertebrates hard to find • Improvement from 2005 • Lower ratings than 2002 & 2004 61
  • 62.
    Fish Study 1939 1972 1985 1989 1991 1992 1995 2006 Black X X X X X Bullhead Carp X X X X X Fathead X X X X X X X X Minnow Sand Shiner X X X X X X Red Shiner X X X X X X Bigmouth X Shiner Brassy X Minnow 62
  • 63.
    Fish Study 1939 1972 1985 1989 1991 1992 1995 2006 Channel X X X Catfish Emerald X Shiner Flathead X Chub Freshwater Drum Plains X Minnow Quilback X X 63
  • 64.
    Fish Study 1939 1972 1985 1989 1991 1992 1995 2006 River X Carpsucker Shortnose gar X Shorthead X X redhorse Western Silvery X Minnow Silver Chub X Flathead Catfish X Speckled Chub X Green Sunfish X X Yellow Bullhead X Total Fish Diversity 2 11 12 2 8 6 64 4 6
  • 65.
    Black Bullhead A eriurus m e la s m 65
  • 66.
    Fathead Minnow Pim ep ha le s p ro m e la s 66
  • 67.
    Sand Shiner N trop is s tra m ine us o 67
  • 68.
    Red Shiner Ly prine lla lutre us is 68
  • 69.
    Green Sunfish Le po m is c y a ne llus 69
  • 70.
    Yellow Bullhead A eriurus na ta lis m 70
  • 71.
    Fish Study Conclusion •Fish vary greatly over years • With the information from Phil Chvala at the Nebraska Game and Parks Commision – Fish diversity is a lot worse – Better than in 1995 – 2006 study same diversity as 1992 study • Can’t make any conclusions at this point 71
  • 72.
  • 73.
  • 74.
  • 75.
  • 76.
    Website • http://newman.esu8.org/project.html OR • http://newman.esu8.org/ • Click “Our Students” • Click “Student Projects” • Click “Watershed Project” • You can see our data and further information concerning this project, including pictures. 76
  • 77.
    Thank You To: • Lower Platte North Natural Resource District • PrairieLand RC&D • Natural Resource Conservation Service • Nebraska Department of Environmental Quality • Shell Creek Watershed 77 Improvement Group
  • 78.
    Special Thanks • Dedicated to Brittany Julsen 78