Laura Mulvey



   Feminist Film Theory and
       ‘The Male Gaze’


                              
Pleasurable Spectatorship


 Laura Mulvey analysed the way men and
  women were represented in films, and
  speculated about how this would appeal to a
  spectator.
 She mixed psychoanalytic film theory (the ideas
  of Freud and Lacan) for a ‘politically feminist’
  end.
 She said that ‘spectatorship’ and the act of
  looking itself provided a form of sexual
  gratification
Scopophilia and Voyeurism


 Scopophilia = Freud’s phrase for when
 we get sexual pleasure from looking at
 other people
 but Mulvey also noted that Freud said
 people feel guilty when getting
 pleasure in this way.
Scopophilic pleasure
 Mulvey suggested that cinema was the
   ideal place to get ‘scopophilic’ pleasure
   because
1. the people in the film aren’t aware the
   spectator is watching
2. no-one else can see the spectator getting
   pleasure because the theatre is in
   darkness, plus everyone else is watching
   the screen.
 Mulvey said the cinema provides
 voyeuristic pleasure: pleasure achieved
 through watching others who don’t know
 they’re being observed
‘Mirror Stage’


 Jacques Lacan was a psychoanalyst who expanded and
   developed Freudian ideas.
 Lacan said this is a stage in child’s development where they
   recognise themselves in other people with similar features.
 Child develops sense of ‘self’ and ‘Other’ that influence it’s
   thinking for the rest of its life.
Link back to Mulvey

 Mulvey used Lacan’s idea
  about the importance of
  seeing your self ‘visually
  reflected’ to explain why
  people like films.
 When we see a character on
  the screen like us, we identify
  with it – and this helps
  reinforce our sense of self.
Mulvey’s Conclusions


 Most mainstream films are made by male
  filmmakers for male spectators
 This results in ACTIVE (Hero) male characters
  and PASSIVE (Object) Female characters
How do these appeal to the (male)
           spectator?


 Mulvey said that mainstream films appeal to the
  ‘Male Gaze’
 Women are presented as something pleasurable
  for the male spectator to look at;
 In her own words, popular films “are obsessively
  subordinated to the neurotic needs of the male
  ego”.
Narcissistic identification


 Narcissus was a figure in Greek mythology, a boy who
  was so attractive he fell in love with his own reflection
 Narcissism = loving your own image

 Narcissistic identification = male spectator sees male
  hero on screen and gets pleasure by both feeling similar
  to the hero and admiring/loving the idealised image of
  masculinity
Voyeuristic Objectification


 Voyeuristic objectification =
  when the male spectator gets
  pleasure by desiring the
  female character, and feeling
  he owns her because she is
  passive (like an object) and
  because he can look at her
  with out guilt (because she
  doesn’t know she is being
  watched)
Fetishisation

 Mulvey also noted that sometimes there were active female
  characters, especially those portrayed by a female star.
 However, she said that these weren’t characters that were
  presented for the female spectator to identify with..
 … instead their power seemed to be based around their
  beauty.
Fetishisation cont’d


 She said that female beauty was fetishised
 A fetish is when a source of fear becomes a source of
  pleasure.
 Humans don’t like feeling scared and anxious – so,
  psychologically, they sometimes turn a source of fear
  into something that gives pleasure
 So… a male spectator, made anxious by a female
  characters empowered actions, can turn her into a
  source of visual pleasure by concentrating on her beauty
  and sexiness.
Problems with Mulvey



One main problem is that she didn’t do any audience research, she
based all her ideas on her own analysis of films.
Completely disregards female audience

No reference to gay/lesbian couples (narcissistic identification)

out-dated because there are more videos promoting female
empowerment and gay relationships.

Mulvey and the gaze

  • 1.
    Laura Mulvey Feminist Film Theory and ‘The Male Gaze’ 
  • 2.
    Pleasurable Spectatorship  LauraMulvey analysed the way men and women were represented in films, and speculated about how this would appeal to a spectator.  She mixed psychoanalytic film theory (the ideas of Freud and Lacan) for a ‘politically feminist’ end.  She said that ‘spectatorship’ and the act of looking itself provided a form of sexual gratification
  • 3.
    Scopophilia and Voyeurism Scopophilia = Freud’s phrase for when we get sexual pleasure from looking at other people  but Mulvey also noted that Freud said people feel guilty when getting pleasure in this way.
  • 4.
    Scopophilic pleasure  Mulveysuggested that cinema was the ideal place to get ‘scopophilic’ pleasure because 1. the people in the film aren’t aware the spectator is watching 2. no-one else can see the spectator getting pleasure because the theatre is in darkness, plus everyone else is watching the screen.
  • 5.
     Mulvey saidthe cinema provides voyeuristic pleasure: pleasure achieved through watching others who don’t know they’re being observed
  • 6.
    ‘Mirror Stage’  JacquesLacan was a psychoanalyst who expanded and developed Freudian ideas.  Lacan said this is a stage in child’s development where they recognise themselves in other people with similar features.  Child develops sense of ‘self’ and ‘Other’ that influence it’s thinking for the rest of its life.
  • 7.
    Link back toMulvey  Mulvey used Lacan’s idea about the importance of seeing your self ‘visually reflected’ to explain why people like films.  When we see a character on the screen like us, we identify with it – and this helps reinforce our sense of self.
  • 8.
    Mulvey’s Conclusions  Mostmainstream films are made by male filmmakers for male spectators  This results in ACTIVE (Hero) male characters and PASSIVE (Object) Female characters
  • 9.
    How do theseappeal to the (male) spectator?  Mulvey said that mainstream films appeal to the ‘Male Gaze’  Women are presented as something pleasurable for the male spectator to look at;  In her own words, popular films “are obsessively subordinated to the neurotic needs of the male ego”.
  • 10.
    Narcissistic identification  Narcissuswas a figure in Greek mythology, a boy who was so attractive he fell in love with his own reflection  Narcissism = loving your own image  Narcissistic identification = male spectator sees male hero on screen and gets pleasure by both feeling similar to the hero and admiring/loving the idealised image of masculinity
  • 11.
    Voyeuristic Objectification  Voyeuristicobjectification = when the male spectator gets pleasure by desiring the female character, and feeling he owns her because she is passive (like an object) and because he can look at her with out guilt (because she doesn’t know she is being watched)
  • 12.
    Fetishisation  Mulvey alsonoted that sometimes there were active female characters, especially those portrayed by a female star.  However, she said that these weren’t characters that were presented for the female spectator to identify with..  … instead their power seemed to be based around their beauty.
  • 13.
    Fetishisation cont’d  Shesaid that female beauty was fetishised  A fetish is when a source of fear becomes a source of pleasure.  Humans don’t like feeling scared and anxious – so, psychologically, they sometimes turn a source of fear into something that gives pleasure  So… a male spectator, made anxious by a female characters empowered actions, can turn her into a source of visual pleasure by concentrating on her beauty and sexiness.
  • 14.
    Problems with Mulvey Onemain problem is that she didn’t do any audience research, she based all her ideas on her own analysis of films. Completely disregards female audience No reference to gay/lesbian couples (narcissistic identification) out-dated because there are more videos promoting female empowerment and gay relationships.