The document discusses a framework for the co-evolution of prototypes and clones within the context of AutomationML, particularly addressing challenges faced by engineers in diverse domains. It introduces a generic metamodel for prototype-based languages, detailing various levels of consistency and repair operations needed to maintain prototype/clone consistency. The document emphasizes ongoing and future work, including enhanced AutomationML support and versioning.

1. Business Informatics Group
Institute of Software Technology and Interactive Systems
Vienna University of Technology
Favoritenstraße 9-11/188-3, 1040 Vienna, Austria
phone: +43 (1) 58801-18804 (secretary), fax: +43 (1) 58801-18896
office@big.tuwien.ac.at, www.big.tuwien.ac.at
Model-Based Co-Evolution of Production Systems
and their Libraries with AutomationML
20th IEEE International Conference on Emerging Technologies and
Factory Automation (ETFA) 2015
Luca Berardinelli, Stefan Biffl, Emanuel Maetzler,
Tanja Mayerhofer, Manuel Wimmer

2. Emerging Technology in Factory Automation 2015
2Best Paper Award

3. Introduction: AutomationML
3
 AutomationML (AML) standard for tool
data exchange
 AML docs are XML-based artifacts
 AML as pivotal language: Tool-
specific docs can be transformed in
AML docs
= domain = tool = doc
XML-based
artifacts
CAEX.xsd
overall system design
mechanical
engineering
electrical
engineering
software
engineering
Industry 4.0

4. Introduction: AutomationML Example
4
Lab-sized Production System
“Equipment Center for Distributed Systems,”
http://www.iafbg.ovgu.de/en/technische ausstattung cvs.html, Institute of
Ergonomics, Manufacturing Systems and Automation at Otto-v.-Guericke
University Magdeburg.

5. 5
Turntable Conveyor
PI Controller
Introduction: AutomationML Example::Model Overview
AML Artifact
Wooden Block
Conveyor
Inductive
Sensor
Turntable
.plc
PLC Program
«conformsTo»
 Reusable model elements
collected in Libraries. Its
elements represents
prototypes.
 The model is obtained by
cloning elements from
libraries in hierarchies of
connected elements.
Its elements are cloned
from prototypes
«model»
mCLONES
Motor
∈
PROTOTYPES «library»
L∈
PI Controller

6. Introduction: (some) AutomationML Concepts
System Unit Class
• Reusable Modeling Elements as
System Unit Class Library
• Set of reusable modeling elements Wooden Block
Conveyor
PI Controller
Inductive
Sensor
Turntable
.plc
PLC Program
Motor
are
s
External Interface
• Elements’ connection points as
Internal Link
• Elements’ connection as
• Attributes
nominal speed = 9000
AML Artifact
PROTOTYPES «library»
L∈
name = value
AML concepts for representing L:
66

7. Introduction: (some) AutomationML Concepts
Inductive
Sensor
Motor
nominal speed = 9000
AML Artifact
Wooden Block
Conveyor
PI Controller
Inductive
Sensor
Turntable
.plc
PLC Program
Motor
nominal speed = 9000
Instance Hierarchy
• Main model container:
Internal Element
• Its constituting elements as
External Interface
• Elements’ connection points as
Internal Link
• Elements’ connection as
• Attributes
name = value
AML concepts for representing m:
«model»
mCLONES ∈
are
s
«clones»
6

8. Problem Description: Challenges
 Challenge: Evolution of engineering data has to be managed
 Engineers from diverse domains working in parallel
 Challenge: Co-evolution of prototypes and clones has to be managed
CLONES
PROTOTYPESPROTOTYPES
CLONES
Engineer
Evolution
Co-evolution 7

9. Contribution: Framework for prototype/clone co-evolution
1. Generic metamodel for prototype-based languages
2. Levels of consistency rigor between and
3. Change types on and their impact on prototype/clone
consistency
4. Repair operations to re-establish prototype/clone consistency
PROTOTYPES CLONES
PROTOTYPES
CLONES
PROTOTYPESPROTOTYPES
CLONES
Engineer
Evolution
Co-evolution 8

10. Contribution: Framework for prototype/clone co-evolution
1. Generic metamodel for prototype-based languages
2. Levels of consistency rigor between and
3. Change types on and their impact on prototype/clone
consistency
4. Repair operations to re-establish prototype/clone consistency
PROTOTYPES CLONES
PROTOTYPES
CLONES
PROTOTYPESPROTOTYPES
CLONES
Engineer
Evolution
Co-evolution 9

11. Contribution: Framework for prototype/clone co-evolution
1. Generic metamodel for prototype-based languages
2. Levels of consistency rigor between and
3. Change types on and their impact on prototype/clone
consistency
4. Repair operations to re-establish prototype/clone consistency
PROTOTYPES CLONES
PROTOTYPES
Engineer
Evolution
Co-evolution
CLONESCLONES
PROTOTYPESPROTOTYPES
10

12. Contribution: Framework for prototype/clone co-evolution
1. Generic metamodel for prototype-based languages
2. Levels of consistency rigor between and
3. Change types on and their impact on prototype/clone
consistency
4. Repair operations to re-establish prototype/clone consistency
PROTOTYPES CLONES
PROTOTYPES
CLONES
PROTOTYPESPROTOTYPES
CLONES
Co-evolution
Engineer
Evolution
11

13. 1. Generic Metamodel for Prototype-Based Languages
 A general metamodel for prototypes
and clones (prototype clone metamodel,
PCMM) whose concepts can be
adopted for several modeling languages.
PROTOTYPES CLONES and as roles
 A Object can play different roles,
depending on its current relationships
ObjectStore
+ createObject() :Object
+ deleteObject() :void
Slot
- name :String
- Value :Object[*]
+objects
+slots
Object
- id :int
- name :String
+ createClone():Object
+ addSlot() :Slot
+ deleteSlot() :void
+ modifySlot() :void
+prototype 0..1+clones *
*
*
12
PCMM

14. 1. Generic Metamodel for Prototype-Based Languages
ObjectStore
+ createObject() :Object
+ deleteObject() :void
Slot
- name :String
- Value :Object[*]
+objects
+slots
Object
- id :int
- name :String
+ createClone():Object
+ addSlot() :Slot
+ deleteSlot() :void
+ modifySlot() :void
+prototype 0..1+clones *
*
*
Generic Artifact based on PCMM
objstore1:ObjectStore
obj1: Object
- id = 1
- name = "Motor"
s1: Slot
- name = "nominal speed"
- value = 9000
obj2: Object
- id = 2
- name = “Motor"
s2: Slot
- name = "nominal speed"
- value = 9000
+prototype
+clones
PROTOTYPES
CLONES
Attr
Attr
13
PCMM

15. 2. Levels of Consistency Rigor between Prototypes and Clones
Generic Artifact based on PCMM
objstore1:ObjectStore
obj1: Object
- id = 1
- name = "Motor"
s1: Slot
- name = "nominal speed"
- value = 9000
obj2: Object
- id = 2
- name = “Motor"
s2: Slot
- name = "nominal speed"
- value = 9000
+prototype
+clones
PROTOTYPES
«conforms to»
«library»
L
«model»
m
 Clones and prototypes
may evolve
independently
 Different levels of
consistency between
clones and prototypes
may apply
CLONES
14

16. 2. Levels of Consistency Rigor between Prototypes and Clones
Level 0: Uncontrolled Compliance
 Clones may evolve completely
independent from Prototypes
 Prototypes are solely used as templates
or classification mechanism
Level 1: Substantial Compliance
 Evolution of clones is partially restricted
Level 1a: Extension: all or more slots
Level 1b: Restriction: at most all the slots
Level 1c: Redefinition: the same but values
Level 2: Full Compliance
 Clones may not evolve independently of
prototypes
PROTOTYPES
«conforms to»
«library»
L
«model»
m
 Clones and prototypes
may evolve
independently
 Different levels of
consistency between
clones and prototypes
may apply
CLONES
15

17. 3. Change Types on Prototypes and their Impact on
Prototype/Clone Consistency
17
Operation L0 L1a L1b L1c L2
ObjectStore::createObject ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑
ObjectStore::deleteObject ≠ ≠ ≠ ≠ ≠
Object::addSlot ↑ ≠ ↑ ≠ ≠
Object::deleteSlot ↑ ↑ ≠ ≠ ≠
Object::modifySlot ↑ ≠ ≠ ↑ ≠
ObjectStore
+ createObject() :Object
+ deleteObject() :void
Slot
- name :String
- Value :Object[*]
+objects
+slots
Object
- id :int
- name :String
+ createClone():Object
+ addSlot() :Slot
+ deleteSlot() :void
+ modifySlot() :void
+prototype 0..1+clones *
*
*
PROTOTYPES
«conforms to»
«library»
L‘
«model»
m‘
CLONES
Engineer
↑ = non-breaking
≠ =breaking
are
s
are
s
PCMM

18. Generic Artifact based on PCMM
4. Repair Operations to Re-Establish Prototype/Clone
Consistency
18
Example
Desired
consistency level:
L1a Extension
«conforms to»
«library»
L‘
«model»
m‘

obj1: Object
- id = 1
- name = "Motor"
s1: Slot
- name = "nominal speed"
- value = 9000
obj2: Object
- id = 2
- name = “Motor"
s2: Slot
- name = "nominal speed"
- value = 9000
+prototype
+clones

PROTOTYPES
CLONES

19. Generic Artifact based on PCMM
4. Repair Operations to Re-Establish Prototype/Clone
Consistency
19
Example
Desired
consistency level:
L1a Extension
«conforms to»
«library»
L‘
«model»
m‘
obj1: Object
- id = 1
- name = "Motor"
s1: Slot
- name = "nominal speed"
- value = 9000
obj2 : Object
- id = 2
- name = “Motor"
s2: Slot
- name = "nominal speed"
- value = 9000
+prototype
+clones
PROTOTYPES
CLONES
s3: Slot
- name = "min rotation speed"
- value = 5800
addSlot()


Engineer
Evolution

20. Generic Artifact based on PCMM
4. Repair Operations to Re-Establish Prototype/Clone
Consistency
20
Example
Desired
consistency level:
L1a Extension
«conforms to»
«library»
L‘
«model»
m‘
obj1: Object
- id = 1
- name = "Motor"
s1: Slot
- name = "nominal speed"
- value = 9000
obj2: Object
- id = 2
- name = "M1"
s2: Slot
- name = "nominal speed"
- value = 9000
+prototype
+clones
PROTOTYPES
CLONES
s3: Slot
- name = "min rotation speed"
- value = 5800
addSlot()
Engineer
Evolution
s4: Slot
- name = "min rotation speed"
- value = 5800
addSlot()


Co-evolution

21. Case Study: AutomationML
21
 Tool support
Object
Constraint
Language
- Metamodeling
- Modeling (Editor)
- Validation
- Co-evolution (fixing rules)

22. Conclusion
22
 Presented an approach for dealing with evolving libraries and co-
evolving system models
 Introduced a general metamodel to characterize prototype-based
languages
 Adapted the general metamodel for AutomationML
 Deduced a minimal change model and classified changes w.r.t.
consistency levels
 Showed possible tool support for consistency checks and (semi-)
automated fixing
 Ongoing and Future work:
 Define nesting and inheritance for prototypes in PCMM
 Full AutomationML support (e.g., interfaces and roles)
 Versioning support

23. Business Informatics Group
Institute of Software Technology and Interactive Systems
Vienna University of Technology
Favoritenstraße 9-11/188-3, 1040 Vienna, Austria
phone: +43 (1) 58801-18804 (secretary), fax: +43 (1) 58801-18896
office@big.tuwien.ac.at, www.big.tuwien.ac.at
Model-Based Co-Evolution of Production Systems
and their Libraries with AutomationML
20th IEEE International Conference on Emerging Technologies and
Factory Automation (ETFA) 2015
Luca Berardinelli, Stefan Biffl, Emanuel Maetzler,
Tanja Mayerhofer, Manuel Wimmer