1. Feed the Future MEL Webinar Series:
Feed the Future’s
Agrometeorological
Context Indicators
Interpreting Agriculture-Related
Outcomes through the Lens of
Rainfall, Vegetation Greenness,
and Temperature
30 May 2019
2. 2018-19 Feed the Future MEL Webinar Series
• Introduction to the MEL System (link)
• Standard Indicator Overview (link)
• New Indicators: Application of improved practices & technologies
(link)
• New Indicators: Sales, finance & investment (link)
• Annual FTFMS user’s webinar (link)
• Nutrition, sanitation & hygiene indicators (link)
• New Indicators: Gender (link)
• Reporting on policy change (link)
• New Indicators: Yield Revealed! (link)
• New Indicators: Agrometeorological context indicators
2
4. Webinar objective #1
• Introduce new agrometeorological context
indicators that will allow us to interpret
agriculture-related outcomes through the lens of:
Rainfall
Greenness
Temperature
4
5. Webinar objective #2 and #3
• Discuss how the new indicators will be
calculated
• Discuss how these indicators can be used to
interpret agricultural measures
– yield
– other measures (e.g., levels of input use)
5
6. New Context Indicators
Rainfall:
FTF Context-12: Average Standard Precipitation Index score
during the main growing seasons (p203-4 of the Feed the Future
Indicator Handbook)
Greenness:
FTF Context-13: Average deviation from 10-year average NDVI
during the main growing season (p205-7 of the Feed the Future
Indicator Handbook)
Temperature:
FTF Context-14: Total number of heat stress days above 30°C
during the main growing season (p208-09 of the Feed the Future
Indicator Handbook)
6
7. Rationale for adding these indicators
• In places where rainfed agriculture is predominant,
the weather is a key factor in determining yields (as
well as some practices, like how much area to plant)
• Without having a sense of weather-related variables
from year to year, it is not possible to interpret trends
and performance in yields
– Did el Niño negatively impact farmers’ production in the
Zone of Influence this year? Or were our programs slow to
get started?
– Was there a bumper crop for everyone this year because
of perfect weather, or were our programs especially
effective in the ZOI?
7
8. What each indicator tells us individually…
8
Near Normal
Moderately Wet
Very Wet
Extremely Wet
Moderately Dry
Severely Dry
Extremely Dry
Data Source: Climate Hazards Group InfraRed Precipitation
with Station (CHIRPS) datasets. CHIRPS is a 30+ year quasi-global
rainfall dataset spanning 50°S-50°N (and all longitudes), starting
in 1981 to near-present.
Rainfall:
Maize from the Upper West region of Ghana
9. What each indicator tells us individually…
9
Normal
Above Normal
Bellow Normal
Data Source: NASA MODIS
Greenness:
Maize from the Upper West region of Ghana
10. What each indicator tells us individually…
10
Data Source: Modern-Era Retrospective analysis for Research
and Applications version 2 (MERRA-2), NASA’s atmospheric
reanalysis for the satellite era using the Goddard Earth
Observing System Model, Version 5 (GEOS-5) with its
Atmospheric Data Assimilation System (ADAS), version 5.12.4
Temperature:
Maize from the Upper West region of Ghana
11. …and taken together.
11
Maize
• A wet start to the season followed by a
moderately dry period during the main
vegetative period.
• Above average NDVI values during
the season showing healthy crops.
• Average number of heat stress days
during the season.
• Despite the reduced rainfall during the
main vegetative period, extremely wet
to moderately wet conditions earlier in
the season combined with normal
temperatures allowed for soil moisture
to carry a healthy crop until harvest.
• Overall the season was above
average with final yields of the season
above the 10-yr average.
12. How these indicators will be calculated
• USAID/BFS and Feed the Future are building the
capacity to use the remotely-sensed data that inform
these indicators.
• We are currently being supported in these efforts by
the NASA Harvest Consortium as well as
FFP/FEWS NET colleagues.
• Implementing partners will not need to calculate
these context indicators.
• All of us need to learn how to interpret our
performance indicators in the context of these
indicators.
12
13. How to interpret trends in production in light
of rainfall, greenness & temperature: Ghana
13
Above Average Year
Below Average Year Average Year
Maize
14. How to interpret trends in production in light
of rainfall, greenness & temperature: Ghana
14
On the ground example of
below average conditions:
Below Average Year
15. How to interpret trends in production in light
of rainfall, greenness & temperature: Ghana
15
Average Year
On the ground example of
average conditions:
16. How to interpret trends in production in light
of rainfall, greenness & temperature: Ghana
16
On the ground example of
above average conditions:
Above Average Year
17. How to interpret trends in production in light
of rainfall, greenness & temperature: Senegal
17
Average Year Above Average Year
Below Average Year
Rice
18. How to interpret trends in production in light
of rainfall, greenness & temperature: Senegal
18
On the ground example of
below average conditions:
Below Average Year
19. How to interpret trends in production in light
of rainfall, greenness & temperature: Senegal
19
On the ground example of
average conditions:
Average Year
20. How to interpret trends in production in light
of rainfall, greenness & temperature: Senegal
20
On the ground example of
above average conditions:
Above Average Year
21. An examination over time
21
Maize in northern Ghana:
Maize
• A comparison of the indicators
over time along with the final
yields from implementing
partners.
3.00
3.25
3.50
3.75
4.00
2015 2016 2017
Yield
(MT/Ha)
Year
Average Final Yields
22. What other trends might we better
understand in light of rain, temp & NDVI?
• If there is no rain,
– farmers might not purchase seeds, fertilizer
– planted area might be reduced
• Currently in the process of assessing whether data
are available that allow us to look at this
– implementing partners may be able to assess their own
data on input use and area under cultivation through the
lens of rainfall, temperature and NDVI
– if available data allow, we may organize a future webinar
to go into more depth on this topic
22
Rainfall is one of the primary factors affecting crop productivity, especially for rainfed agriculture. This is especially true during the main growing season in semiarid conditions, where most of the GFSS countries are located. Lower or less than optimum crop yields are usually associated with lower than normal (or higher than normal) rainfall conditions. The indicator will help in analyzing conditions that led to observed crop yields. It will also help to understand the rainfall context that best suits a given crop (for example, it could provide insights leading to recommendations to shift planting times or select a crop type that fits the rainfall context better).
Earth observation data, and the NDVI measure derived therefrom, are spatially explicit, broad in extent, uniform for the entire area covered, repeatable over time, and capable of appraising entire landscapes. Satellite-derived estimates of net primary production in plants – which are correlated with yield – are calculated using vegetation indices like NDVI. NDVI is correlated with plant biomass, crop yield, plant nitrogen, plant chlorophyll, water stress, plant disease, and pest damage.
Air temperature influences plant growth through photosynthesis and respiration, affects soil temperature, and impacts the amount of available water in the soil. When temperatures exceed 30°C, especially during certain growth phases (e.g. flowering and seed development), crop yields can be negatively impacted. Assessing the number of days on which temperatures exceed 30°C during the main growing season in conjunction with precipitation data can help determine if temperature was a factor affecting crop yield.
Rainfall is one of the primary factors affecting crop productivity, especially for rainfed agriculture. This is especially true during the main growing season in semiarid conditions, where most of the GFSS countries are located. Lower or less than optimum crop yields are usually associated with lower than normal (or higher than normal) rainfall conditions. The indicator will help in analyzing conditions that led to observed crop yields. It will also help to understand the rainfall context that best suits a given crop (for example, it could provide insights leading to recommendations to shift planting times or select a crop type that fits the rainfall context better).
Earth observation data, and the NDVI measure derived therefrom, are spatially explicit, broad in extent, uniform for the entire area covered, repeatable over time, and capable of appraising entire landscapes. Satellite-derived estimates of net primary production in plants – which are correlated with yield – are calculated using vegetation indices like NDVI. NDVI is correlated with plant biomass, crop yield, plant nitrogen, plant chlorophyll, water stress, plant disease, and pest damage.
Air temperature influences plant growth through photosynthesis and respiration, affects soil temperature, and impacts the amount of available water in the soil. When temperatures exceed 30°C, especially during certain growth phases (e.g. flowering and seed development), crop yields can be negatively impacted. Assessing the number of days on which temperatures exceed 30°C during the main growing season in conjunction with precipitation data can help determine if temperature was a factor affecting crop yield.
Rainfall is one of the primary factors affecting crop productivity, especially for rainfed agriculture. This is especially true during the main growing season in semiarid conditions, where most of the GFSS countries are located. Lower or less than optimum crop yields are usually associated with lower than normal (or higher than normal) rainfall conditions. The indicator will help in analyzing conditions that led to observed crop yields. It will also help to understand the rainfall context that best suits a given crop (for example, it could provide insights leading to recommendations to shift planting times or select a crop type that fits the rainfall context better).
Earth observation data, and the NDVI measure derived therefrom, are spatially explicit, broad in extent, uniform for the entire area covered, repeatable over time, and capable of appraising entire landscapes. Satellite-derived estimates of net primary production in plants – which are correlated with yield – are calculated using vegetation indices like NDVI. NDVI is correlated with plant biomass, crop yield, plant nitrogen, plant chlorophyll, water stress, plant disease, and pest damage.
Air temperature influences plant growth through photosynthesis and respiration, affects soil temperature, and impacts the amount of available water in the soil. When temperatures exceed 30°C, especially during certain growth phases (e.g. flowering and seed development), crop yields can be negatively impacted. Assessing the number of days on which temperatures exceed 30°C during the main growing season in conjunction with precipitation data can help determine if temperature was a factor affecting crop yield.
When analyzing combined temperature and precipitation data with Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) data, the degree of impact on crop productivity and yield that Feed the Future interventions have contributed to can be more clearly understood. Agricultural yield is critical to achieving the Feed the Future goal to Sustainably Reduce Global Poverty and Hunger. This indicator is linked to IR.4: Increased sustainable productivity, particularly through climate-smart approaches in the GFSS Results Framework.
USAID/BFS and Feed the Future are in the process of building the capacity to access and use the remotely-sensed data that inform these indicators.
We are currently being supported in these efforts by the NASA Harvest Consortium, a NASA-funded program that has partner capacity building as a core mission.
Implementing partners will not need to calculate these indicators.
All of us need to learn how to interpret our performance indicators in the context of these context indicators
Rainfall is one of the primary factors affecting crop productivity, especially for rainfed agriculture. This is especially true during the main growing season in semiarid conditions, where most of the GFSS countries are located. Lower or less than optimum crop yields are usually associated with lower than normal (or higher than normal) rainfall conditions. The indicator will help in analyzing conditions that led to observed crop yields. It will also help to understand the rainfall context that best suits a given crop (for example, it could provide insights leading to recommendations to shift planting times or select a crop type that fits the rainfall context better).
Earth observation data, and the NDVI measure derived therefrom, are spatially explicit, broad in extent, uniform for the entire area covered, repeatable over time, and capable of appraising entire landscapes. Satellite-derived estimates of net primary production in plants – which are correlated with yield – are calculated using vegetation indices like NDVI. NDVI is correlated with plant biomass, crop yield, plant nitrogen, plant chlorophyll, water stress, plant disease, and pest damage.
Air temperature influences plant growth through photosynthesis and respiration, affects soil temperature, and impacts the amount of available water in the soil. When temperatures exceed 30°C, especially during certain growth phases (e.g. flowering and seed development), crop yields can be negatively impacted. Assessing the number of days on which temperatures exceed 30°C during the main growing season in conjunction with precipitation data can help determine if temperature was a factor affecting crop yield.