SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Media & the Politics of
Implementation:
Explaining Geographic Variation in
Local TV Coverage of the ACA
Erika Franklin Fowler & Laura Baum, Wesleyan
Colleen L. Barry, John Hopkins Bloomberg
Jeff Niederdeppe, Cornell
Pinar Karaca-Mandic, Andrew Wilcock & Sarah E. Gollust, UMN
Funding from:
• Robert Wood Johnson Foundation through its State Health Care
Access Reform Evaluation (SHARE), Grant ID# 72179
• Wesleyan University
News as Commodity, not a Mirror
• News is a highly selective version of reality (Lippmann 1922; Gans
1979; Hamilton 2004)
• Much of political science assumes information transmission (see
Althaus et al. 2011)
• Even within communication, news production takes a backseat to
effects
Key Insight: Coverage Unlikely to be Uniform
• Audience characteristics
• Ease of access to story material
• Ownership characteristics
• Geographic proximity to story
• Congruence between media and political boundaries
• In other words, production is variable and complex
Competing Interests Shaping ACA Coverage
• News producers
• Politicians
• Organized interests
Interested here in predicting volume (content focus later)
Data & Measures
• Closed captioned searches of local TV news from 10/1/13-4/15/14
• Key words: “health care,” “healthcare,” “Obama care,” “Obamacare”
and “Affordable Care Act”
• 685 stations in 208 media markets, all evening news (4:30-11:59pm)
• American Community Survey (ACS)
• Wesleyan Media Project political and insurance advertising data
• RWJF insurance market information
• BIA Kelsey Station Ownership Information
Volume of Evening Local TV ACA Hits
Oct 1, 2013 – Apr 15, 2014
Local TV News Hits by Station
02468
FrequencyofStations
0 200 400 600
Number of Closed Captioning Hits
Analytic Approach
• Negative binomial count models
• Clustering by state, robust SEs (robust to hierarchical)
• All results from one model
Factors Shaping News: Audience Interest
Greater interest in the ACA in a market should drive coverage up
• Markets with more uninsured: more coverage
• Markets with more direct purchasers: more coverage
• Markets with high poverty: unclear
• Partisanship: unclear
• Political competition: more coverage
• Controls for news consumer demographics: age, sex, education, race
Factors Shaping News: Audience Interest
Coeff. (S.E.)
Uninsured (% 18-64 NCI population) 1.278** (0.597)
Indiv. health ins. enrollees (% 18-64 NCI pop) -0.206 (1.414)
Poverty (%) -3.093** (1.316)
White (%) -0.227 (0.205)
College grad or more (%) 0.982 (0.734)
Male (%) -17.73*** (3.353)
Ages 20-64 (%) 1.070 (1.684)
Ages 65+ (%) -1.107 (1.032)
Obama vote in DMA (%) 0.175 (0.266)
Margin of victory (50 – abs(Obama vote)) 0.214 (0.415)
Predicted Count by Proportion Uninsured
100150200250
PredictedNumberofACAHits
.04 .08 .12 .16 .2 .24 .28 .32
Proportion of 18-64 CNI Population w/o Health Insurance (ACS 2013 5-Yr Est)
Ease of Access to Sources & Story Materials
Availability of materials for ACA stories should increase coverage
• Accessibility of spokespeople should increase coverage
• Volume of ACA insurance and political ads should increase coverage
• Type of insurance marketplace: state-based should have more stories
Ease of Access to Sources & Story Materials
Coeff. (S.E.)
Consumer assistance funds (per uninsured) -0.00415 (0.00263)
Insurance ad volume (000s) 0.0195** (0.00900)
Political ad volume (000s) 0.0642 (0.0417)
Partnership exchange 0.200*** (0.0665)
State-based exchange 0.162** (0.0711)
Predicted Count by Exchange Type
140160180200220
PredictedNumberofACAHits
Federally-Facilitated Partnership State-Based
Station & Ownership Characteristics
Stations are enabled and constrained by their network affiliates and
ownership groups choices and priorities for programming
• Fox affiliates (more sports, fewer newscasts): less coverage
• Ownership profits: unclear
Station & Ownership Characteristics
Coeff. (S.E.)
CBS affiliate 0.0293 (0.0415)
Fox affiliate -0.228*** (0.0473)
NBC affiliate 0.162*** (0.0417)
Second tier (revenue) -0.114** (0.0490)
Lowest tier (revenue) -0.158*** (0.0483)
Predicted Count by Owner Revenue Tier
150160170180190200
PredictedNumberofACAHits
Largest Profits Mid-Tier Profits Lowest Profits
Structural Factors Affecting Production
Structural set-up of media markets (population served and geographic
congruence) matter
• Number of states within DMA: decrease coverage
• Population of the media market: decrease coverage
• Insurer competition: increase coverage (expect negative sign)
Structural Factors Affecting Production
Coeff. (S.E.)
# of states within DMA 0.0316 (0.0203)
DMA total population (Ms) -0.0321* (0.0174)
HHI (insurance competition) -2.02e-05 (1.28e-05)
Contribution & Future Directions
• Variance in news coverage of the ACA is predictable
• Systematic analysis of local TV across the country
• Future work
• Over time
• Assessing content

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Media and politics gv311 2016
Media and politics gv311 2016Media and politics gv311 2016
Media and politics gv311 2016
POLIS LSE
 
Politics and media
Politics and mediaPolitics and media
Politics and media
dunianyamaya
 
Political Communication In Digital Age – Social Media Analysis
Political Communication In Digital Age – Social Media AnalysisPolitical Communication In Digital Age – Social Media Analysis
Political Communication In Digital Age – Social Media Analysis
Vijaykumar Meti
 
Pros and cons of mass media in politic
Pros and cons of mass media in politicPros and cons of mass media in politic
Pros and cons of mass media in politicAiaulym Kz
 
Duygu Basaran Sahin Social Media and Politics in Turkey: A Mysterious Relatio...
Duygu Basaran Sahin Social Media and Politics in Turkey: A Mysterious Relatio...Duygu Basaran Sahin Social Media and Politics in Turkey: A Mysterious Relatio...
Duygu Basaran Sahin Social Media and Politics in Turkey: A Mysterious Relatio...
Digital Sociology Mini-Conference
 
The Media and American Politics
The Media and American PoliticsThe Media and American Politics
The Media and American Politics
Christopher Rice
 
Graham Davis - Social Media in Politics
Graham Davis - Social Media in PoliticsGraham Davis - Social Media in Politics
Graham Davis - Social Media in Politics
SMCgreatlakes
 
Social media, politics and elections
Social media, politics and electionsSocial media, politics and elections
Social media, politics and elections
Stephen Dann
 
Indonesia's Politics & The Media
Indonesia's Politics & The Media Indonesia's Politics & The Media
Indonesia's Politics & The Media
sonyambudi
 
Relevance of Social Media in Politics
Relevance of Social Media in PoliticsRelevance of Social Media in Politics
Relevance of Social Media in PoliticsDezine Brainz
 
Social Media And Politics
Social Media And PoliticsSocial Media And Politics
Social Media And Politics
Philippe Bossin
 
Media and Politics
Media and PoliticsMedia and Politics
Media and Politics
brianbelen
 
Effect of social media on political campaigns
Effect of social media on political campaignsEffect of social media on political campaigns
Effect of social media on political campaignsbev052185
 
Role of social media in politics
Role of social media in politicsRole of social media in politics
Role of social media in politicsDhruva Trivedy
 

Viewers also liked (16)

Media and politics gv311 2016
Media and politics gv311 2016Media and politics gv311 2016
Media and politics gv311 2016
 
Politics and media
Politics and mediaPolitics and media
Politics and media
 
Political Communication In Digital Age – Social Media Analysis
Political Communication In Digital Age – Social Media AnalysisPolitical Communication In Digital Age – Social Media Analysis
Political Communication In Digital Age – Social Media Analysis
 
Pros and cons of mass media in politic
Pros and cons of mass media in politicPros and cons of mass media in politic
Pros and cons of mass media in politic
 
Duygu Basaran Sahin Social Media and Politics in Turkey: A Mysterious Relatio...
Duygu Basaran Sahin Social Media and Politics in Turkey: A Mysterious Relatio...Duygu Basaran Sahin Social Media and Politics in Turkey: A Mysterious Relatio...
Duygu Basaran Sahin Social Media and Politics in Turkey: A Mysterious Relatio...
 
The Media and American Politics
The Media and American PoliticsThe Media and American Politics
The Media and American Politics
 
Social Media & Politics
Social Media & PoliticsSocial Media & Politics
Social Media & Politics
 
Graham Davis - Social Media in Politics
Graham Davis - Social Media in PoliticsGraham Davis - Social Media in Politics
Graham Davis - Social Media in Politics
 
Social media, politics and elections
Social media, politics and electionsSocial media, politics and elections
Social media, politics and elections
 
Indonesia's Politics & The Media
Indonesia's Politics & The Media Indonesia's Politics & The Media
Indonesia's Politics & The Media
 
Relevance of Social Media in Politics
Relevance of Social Media in PoliticsRelevance of Social Media in Politics
Relevance of Social Media in Politics
 
Social Media And Politics
Social Media And PoliticsSocial Media And Politics
Social Media And Politics
 
Media and Politics
Media and PoliticsMedia and Politics
Media and Politics
 
Effect of social media on political campaigns
Effect of social media on political campaignsEffect of social media on political campaigns
Effect of social media on political campaigns
 
Role of social media in politics
Role of social media in politicsRole of social media in politics
Role of social media in politics
 
Social Media and Politics
Social Media and PoliticsSocial Media and Politics
Social Media and Politics
 

Similar to Media & the Politics of Implementation: Explaining Geographic Variation in Local TV Coverage of the ACA

Comparing Health Insurance Measurement Error (CHIME) in the ACS & CPS
Comparing Health Insurance Measurement Error (CHIME) in the ACS & CPSComparing Health Insurance Measurement Error (CHIME) in the ACS & CPS
Comparing Health Insurance Measurement Error (CHIME) in the ACS & CPS
soder145
 
The Partisan Divide and American Elections
The Partisan Divide and American ElectionsThe Partisan Divide and American Elections
The Partisan Divide and American Elections
PSCIProject
 
SHADAC: Overview and Evaluation
SHADAC:  Overview and EvaluationSHADAC:  Overview and Evaluation
SHADAC: Overview and Evaluation
soder145
 
Rural Implications of ACA Medicaid Expansions
Rural Implications of ACA Medicaid ExpansionsRural Implications of ACA Medicaid Expansions
Rural Implications of ACA Medicaid Expansionssoder145
 
475 2015 democracy and the news media, part ii up
475 2015 democracy and the news media, part ii up475 2015 democracy and the news media, part ii up
475 2015 democracy and the news media, part ii up
mpeffl
 
Contemporary and Alternative Medicine Powerpoint
Contemporary and Alternative Medicine PowerpointContemporary and Alternative Medicine Powerpoint
Contemporary and Alternative Medicine Powerpoint
mariamontroni
 
Shadac oregon churnwebinar_fullslidedeck
Shadac oregon churnwebinar_fullslidedeckShadac oregon churnwebinar_fullslidedeck
Shadac oregon churnwebinar_fullslidedeck
soder145
 
Tania
TaniaTania
Informed Citizen Akron #2: Improving Candidate-Focused Media Coverage in the ...
Informed Citizen Akron #2: Improving Candidate-Focused Media Coverage in the ...Informed Citizen Akron #2: Improving Candidate-Focused Media Coverage in the ...
Informed Citizen Akron #2: Improving Candidate-Focused Media Coverage in the ...
Jefferson Center
 
Ziller_AcademyHealth2014
Ziller_AcademyHealth2014Ziller_AcademyHealth2014
Ziller_AcademyHealth2014
soder145
 
Fcsm turner
Fcsm turnerFcsm turner
Fcsm turnersoder145
 
cost of caring health.pptx
cost of caring health.pptxcost of caring health.pptx
cost of caring health.pptx
ZuneraTariq2
 
After Campaign 2016, Can Consumer Advertisers Learn Anything From Political C...
After Campaign 2016, Can Consumer Advertisers Learn Anything From Political C...After Campaign 2016, Can Consumer Advertisers Learn Anything From Political C...
After Campaign 2016, Can Consumer Advertisers Learn Anything From Political C...
MediaPost
 
Early Impacts of the ACA on Health Insurance Coverage in Minnesota
Early Impacts of the ACA on Health Insurance Coverage in MinnesotaEarly Impacts of the ACA on Health Insurance Coverage in Minnesota
Early Impacts of the ACA on Health Insurance Coverage in Minnesota
soder145
 
The Health Care Cost Institute’s National Transparency Initiative
The Health Care Cost Institute’sNational Transparency InitiativeThe Health Care Cost Institute’sNational Transparency Initiative
The Health Care Cost Institute’s National Transparency Initiative
Health Data Consortium
 
Individual and Small-Group Healthcare Markets
Individual and Small-Group Healthcare MarketsIndividual and Small-Group Healthcare Markets
Individual and Small-Group Healthcare Markets
Mile High Healthcare Analytics
 
State-Level Estimates for Tracking Health Reform Impact: Opportunities and Ch...
State-Level Estimates for Tracking Health Reform Impact: Opportunities and Ch...State-Level Estimates for Tracking Health Reform Impact: Opportunities and Ch...
State-Level Estimates for Tracking Health Reform Impact: Opportunities and Ch...soder145
 
APO Korea Health System Review (Health in Transition)
APO Korea Health System Review (Health in Transition)APO Korea Health System Review (Health in Transition)
APO Korea Health System Review (Health in Transition)
Asia Pacific Observatory on Health Systems and Policies (APO)
 
Secondary Research: Fast and Cost-Effective
Secondary Research: Fast and Cost-EffectiveSecondary Research: Fast and Cost-Effective
Secondary Research: Fast and Cost-Effective
Kevin Brett, M.A.
 

Similar to Media & the Politics of Implementation: Explaining Geographic Variation in Local TV Coverage of the ACA (20)

Comparing Health Insurance Measurement Error (CHIME) in the ACS & CPS
Comparing Health Insurance Measurement Error (CHIME) in the ACS & CPSComparing Health Insurance Measurement Error (CHIME) in the ACS & CPS
Comparing Health Insurance Measurement Error (CHIME) in the ACS & CPS
 
The Partisan Divide and American Elections
The Partisan Divide and American ElectionsThe Partisan Divide and American Elections
The Partisan Divide and American Elections
 
SHADAC: Overview and Evaluation
SHADAC:  Overview and EvaluationSHADAC:  Overview and Evaluation
SHADAC: Overview and Evaluation
 
Rural Implications of ACA Medicaid Expansions
Rural Implications of ACA Medicaid ExpansionsRural Implications of ACA Medicaid Expansions
Rural Implications of ACA Medicaid Expansions
 
475 2015 democracy and the news media, part ii up
475 2015 democracy and the news media, part ii up475 2015 democracy and the news media, part ii up
475 2015 democracy and the news media, part ii up
 
Contemporary and Alternative Medicine Powerpoint
Contemporary and Alternative Medicine PowerpointContemporary and Alternative Medicine Powerpoint
Contemporary and Alternative Medicine Powerpoint
 
Shadac oregon churnwebinar_fullslidedeck
Shadac oregon churnwebinar_fullslidedeckShadac oregon churnwebinar_fullslidedeck
Shadac oregon churnwebinar_fullslidedeck
 
Tania
TaniaTania
Tania
 
Informed Citizen Akron #2: Improving Candidate-Focused Media Coverage in the ...
Informed Citizen Akron #2: Improving Candidate-Focused Media Coverage in the ...Informed Citizen Akron #2: Improving Candidate-Focused Media Coverage in the ...
Informed Citizen Akron #2: Improving Candidate-Focused Media Coverage in the ...
 
Ziller_AcademyHealth2014
Ziller_AcademyHealth2014Ziller_AcademyHealth2014
Ziller_AcademyHealth2014
 
Fcsm turner
Fcsm turnerFcsm turner
Fcsm turner
 
cost of caring health.pptx
cost of caring health.pptxcost of caring health.pptx
cost of caring health.pptx
 
After Campaign 2016, Can Consumer Advertisers Learn Anything From Political C...
After Campaign 2016, Can Consumer Advertisers Learn Anything From Political C...After Campaign 2016, Can Consumer Advertisers Learn Anything From Political C...
After Campaign 2016, Can Consumer Advertisers Learn Anything From Political C...
 
Early Impacts of the ACA on Health Insurance Coverage in Minnesota
Early Impacts of the ACA on Health Insurance Coverage in MinnesotaEarly Impacts of the ACA on Health Insurance Coverage in Minnesota
Early Impacts of the ACA on Health Insurance Coverage in Minnesota
 
The Health Care Cost Institute’s National Transparency Initiative
The Health Care Cost Institute’sNational Transparency InitiativeThe Health Care Cost Institute’sNational Transparency Initiative
The Health Care Cost Institute’s National Transparency Initiative
 
Individual and Small-Group Healthcare Markets
Individual and Small-Group Healthcare MarketsIndividual and Small-Group Healthcare Markets
Individual and Small-Group Healthcare Markets
 
State-Level Estimates for Tracking Health Reform Impact: Opportunities and Ch...
State-Level Estimates for Tracking Health Reform Impact: Opportunities and Ch...State-Level Estimates for Tracking Health Reform Impact: Opportunities and Ch...
State-Level Estimates for Tracking Health Reform Impact: Opportunities and Ch...
 
APO Korea Health System Review (Health in Transition)
APO Korea Health System Review (Health in Transition)APO Korea Health System Review (Health in Transition)
APO Korea Health System Review (Health in Transition)
 
Marketing analytics final
Marketing analytics finalMarketing analytics final
Marketing analytics final
 
Secondary Research: Fast and Cost-Effective
Secondary Research: Fast and Cost-EffectiveSecondary Research: Fast and Cost-Effective
Secondary Research: Fast and Cost-Effective
 

More from soder145

Trends and Disparities in Children's Health Insurance: New Data and the Impli...
Trends and Disparities in Children's Health Insurance: New Data and the Impli...Trends and Disparities in Children's Health Insurance: New Data and the Impli...
Trends and Disparities in Children's Health Insurance: New Data and the Impli...
soder145
 
Exploring Disparities Using New and Updated MEasures on SHADAC's State Health...
Exploring Disparities Using New and Updated MEasures on SHADAC's State Health...Exploring Disparities Using New and Updated MEasures on SHADAC's State Health...
Exploring Disparities Using New and Updated MEasures on SHADAC's State Health...
soder145
 
Leveraging 1332 State Innovation Waivers to Stabilize Individual Health Insur...
Leveraging 1332 State Innovation Waivers to Stabilize Individual Health Insur...Leveraging 1332 State Innovation Waivers to Stabilize Individual Health Insur...
Leveraging 1332 State Innovation Waivers to Stabilize Individual Health Insur...
soder145
 
Modeling State-based Reinsurance: One Option for Stabilization of the Individ...
Modeling State-based Reinsurance: One Option for Stabilization of the Individ...Modeling State-based Reinsurance: One Option for Stabilization of the Individ...
Modeling State-based Reinsurance: One Option for Stabilization of the Individ...
soder145
 
2017 Health Insurance Coverage Estimates: SHADAC Webinar Featuring U.S. Censu...
2017 Health Insurance Coverage Estimates: SHADAC Webinar Featuring U.S. Censu...2017 Health Insurance Coverage Estimates: SHADAC Webinar Featuring U.S. Censu...
2017 Health Insurance Coverage Estimates: SHADAC Webinar Featuring U.S. Censu...
soder145
 
Exploring the New State-Level Opioid Data On SHADAC's State Health Compare
Exploring the New State-Level Opioid Data On SHADAC's State Health CompareExploring the New State-Level Opioid Data On SHADAC's State Health Compare
Exploring the New State-Level Opioid Data On SHADAC's State Health Compare
soder145
 
Ibd intersectionality
Ibd intersectionalityIbd intersectionality
Ibd intersectionality
soder145
 
Who gets it right
Who gets it rightWho gets it right
Who gets it right
soder145
 
Mn ltss projection model
Mn ltss projection modelMn ltss projection model
Mn ltss projection model
soder145
 
Modeling financial eligibility, ltss
Modeling financial eligibility, ltssModeling financial eligibility, ltss
Modeling financial eligibility, ltss
soder145
 
Poster, advancements in care coordination mn sim
Poster, advancements in care coordination mn simPoster, advancements in care coordination mn sim
Poster, advancements in care coordination mn sim
soder145
 
Poster, section 1115 waivers
Poster, section 1115 waiversPoster, section 1115 waivers
Poster, section 1115 waivers
soder145
 
Modeling state based reinsurance
Modeling state based reinsuranceModeling state based reinsurance
Modeling state based reinsurance
soder145
 
Who Gets It Right? Characteristics Associated with Accurate Reporting of Heal...
Who Gets It Right? Characteristics Associated with Accurate Reporting of Heal...Who Gets It Right? Characteristics Associated with Accurate Reporting of Heal...
Who Gets It Right? Characteristics Associated with Accurate Reporting of Heal...
soder145
 
Medicaid vs. Marketplace Coverage for Near-Poor Adults: Impact on Out-of-Pock...
Medicaid vs. Marketplace Coverage for Near-Poor Adults: Impact on Out-of-Pock...Medicaid vs. Marketplace Coverage for Near-Poor Adults: Impact on Out-of-Pock...
Medicaid vs. Marketplace Coverage for Near-Poor Adults: Impact on Out-of-Pock...
soder145
 
The Impact of Medicaid Expansion on Employer Provision of Health Insurance
The Impact of Medicaid Expansion on Employer Provision of Health InsuranceThe Impact of Medicaid Expansion on Employer Provision of Health Insurance
The Impact of Medicaid Expansion on Employer Provision of Health Insurance
soder145
 
Physician Participation in Medi-Cal: Is Supply Meeting Demand?
Physician Participation in Medi-Cal: Is Supply Meeting Demand? Physician Participation in Medi-Cal: Is Supply Meeting Demand?
Physician Participation in Medi-Cal: Is Supply Meeting Demand?
soder145
 
Shadac acs cps-webinar 2016-final_sept21
Shadac acs cps-webinar 2016-final_sept21Shadac acs cps-webinar 2016-final_sept21
Shadac acs cps-webinar 2016-final_sept21
soder145
 
2014 SAHIE: Overview with Census Experts
2014 SAHIE: Overview with Census Experts2014 SAHIE: Overview with Census Experts
2014 SAHIE: Overview with Census Experts
soder145
 
Adding complexity to an already difficult task: Monitoring the impact of the ...
Adding complexity to an already difficult task: Monitoring the impact of the ...Adding complexity to an already difficult task: Monitoring the impact of the ...
Adding complexity to an already difficult task: Monitoring the impact of the ...
soder145
 

More from soder145 (20)

Trends and Disparities in Children's Health Insurance: New Data and the Impli...
Trends and Disparities in Children's Health Insurance: New Data and the Impli...Trends and Disparities in Children's Health Insurance: New Data and the Impli...
Trends and Disparities in Children's Health Insurance: New Data and the Impli...
 
Exploring Disparities Using New and Updated MEasures on SHADAC's State Health...
Exploring Disparities Using New and Updated MEasures on SHADAC's State Health...Exploring Disparities Using New and Updated MEasures on SHADAC's State Health...
Exploring Disparities Using New and Updated MEasures on SHADAC's State Health...
 
Leveraging 1332 State Innovation Waivers to Stabilize Individual Health Insur...
Leveraging 1332 State Innovation Waivers to Stabilize Individual Health Insur...Leveraging 1332 State Innovation Waivers to Stabilize Individual Health Insur...
Leveraging 1332 State Innovation Waivers to Stabilize Individual Health Insur...
 
Modeling State-based Reinsurance: One Option for Stabilization of the Individ...
Modeling State-based Reinsurance: One Option for Stabilization of the Individ...Modeling State-based Reinsurance: One Option for Stabilization of the Individ...
Modeling State-based Reinsurance: One Option for Stabilization of the Individ...
 
2017 Health Insurance Coverage Estimates: SHADAC Webinar Featuring U.S. Censu...
2017 Health Insurance Coverage Estimates: SHADAC Webinar Featuring U.S. Censu...2017 Health Insurance Coverage Estimates: SHADAC Webinar Featuring U.S. Censu...
2017 Health Insurance Coverage Estimates: SHADAC Webinar Featuring U.S. Censu...
 
Exploring the New State-Level Opioid Data On SHADAC's State Health Compare
Exploring the New State-Level Opioid Data On SHADAC's State Health CompareExploring the New State-Level Opioid Data On SHADAC's State Health Compare
Exploring the New State-Level Opioid Data On SHADAC's State Health Compare
 
Ibd intersectionality
Ibd intersectionalityIbd intersectionality
Ibd intersectionality
 
Who gets it right
Who gets it rightWho gets it right
Who gets it right
 
Mn ltss projection model
Mn ltss projection modelMn ltss projection model
Mn ltss projection model
 
Modeling financial eligibility, ltss
Modeling financial eligibility, ltssModeling financial eligibility, ltss
Modeling financial eligibility, ltss
 
Poster, advancements in care coordination mn sim
Poster, advancements in care coordination mn simPoster, advancements in care coordination mn sim
Poster, advancements in care coordination mn sim
 
Poster, section 1115 waivers
Poster, section 1115 waiversPoster, section 1115 waivers
Poster, section 1115 waivers
 
Modeling state based reinsurance
Modeling state based reinsuranceModeling state based reinsurance
Modeling state based reinsurance
 
Who Gets It Right? Characteristics Associated with Accurate Reporting of Heal...
Who Gets It Right? Characteristics Associated with Accurate Reporting of Heal...Who Gets It Right? Characteristics Associated with Accurate Reporting of Heal...
Who Gets It Right? Characteristics Associated with Accurate Reporting of Heal...
 
Medicaid vs. Marketplace Coverage for Near-Poor Adults: Impact on Out-of-Pock...
Medicaid vs. Marketplace Coverage for Near-Poor Adults: Impact on Out-of-Pock...Medicaid vs. Marketplace Coverage for Near-Poor Adults: Impact on Out-of-Pock...
Medicaid vs. Marketplace Coverage for Near-Poor Adults: Impact on Out-of-Pock...
 
The Impact of Medicaid Expansion on Employer Provision of Health Insurance
The Impact of Medicaid Expansion on Employer Provision of Health InsuranceThe Impact of Medicaid Expansion on Employer Provision of Health Insurance
The Impact of Medicaid Expansion on Employer Provision of Health Insurance
 
Physician Participation in Medi-Cal: Is Supply Meeting Demand?
Physician Participation in Medi-Cal: Is Supply Meeting Demand? Physician Participation in Medi-Cal: Is Supply Meeting Demand?
Physician Participation in Medi-Cal: Is Supply Meeting Demand?
 
Shadac acs cps-webinar 2016-final_sept21
Shadac acs cps-webinar 2016-final_sept21Shadac acs cps-webinar 2016-final_sept21
Shadac acs cps-webinar 2016-final_sept21
 
2014 SAHIE: Overview with Census Experts
2014 SAHIE: Overview with Census Experts2014 SAHIE: Overview with Census Experts
2014 SAHIE: Overview with Census Experts
 
Adding complexity to an already difficult task: Monitoring the impact of the ...
Adding complexity to an already difficult task: Monitoring the impact of the ...Adding complexity to an already difficult task: Monitoring the impact of the ...
Adding complexity to an already difficult task: Monitoring the impact of the ...
 

Recently uploaded

Surgery-Mini-OSCE-All-Past-Years-Questions-Modified.
Surgery-Mini-OSCE-All-Past-Years-Questions-Modified.Surgery-Mini-OSCE-All-Past-Years-Questions-Modified.
Surgery-Mini-OSCE-All-Past-Years-Questions-Modified.
preciousstephanie75
 
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
Ameena Kadar
 
The Docs PPG - 30.05.2024.pptx..........
The Docs PPG - 30.05.2024.pptx..........The Docs PPG - 30.05.2024.pptx..........
The Docs PPG - 30.05.2024.pptx..........
TheDocs
 
Immunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentation
Immunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentationImmunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentation
Immunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentation
BeshedaWedajo
 
Demystifying-Gene-Editing-The-Promise-and-Peril-of-CRISPR.pdf
Demystifying-Gene-Editing-The-Promise-and-Peril-of-CRISPR.pdfDemystifying-Gene-Editing-The-Promise-and-Peril-of-CRISPR.pdf
Demystifying-Gene-Editing-The-Promise-and-Peril-of-CRISPR.pdf
SasikiranMarri
 
Preventing Pickleball Injuries & Treatment
Preventing Pickleball Injuries & TreatmentPreventing Pickleball Injuries & Treatment
Preventing Pickleball Injuries & Treatment
LAB Sports Therapy
 
💘Ludhiana ℂall Girls 📞]][89011★83002][[ 📱 ❤ESCORTS service in Ludhiana💃💦Ludhi...
💘Ludhiana ℂall Girls 📞]][89011★83002][[ 📱 ❤ESCORTS service in Ludhiana💃💦Ludhi...💘Ludhiana ℂall Girls 📞]][89011★83002][[ 📱 ❤ESCORTS service in Ludhiana💃💦Ludhi...
💘Ludhiana ℂall Girls 📞]][89011★83002][[ 📱 ❤ESCORTS service in Ludhiana💃💦Ludhi...
ranishasharma67
 
Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...
Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...
Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...
Dr. David Greene Arizona
 
HEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptx
HEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptxHEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptx
HEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptx
priyabhojwani1200
 
Secret Tantric VIP Erotic Massage London
Secret Tantric VIP Erotic Massage LondonSecret Tantric VIP Erotic Massage London
Secret Tantric VIP Erotic Massage London
Secret Tantric - VIP Erotic Massage London
 
Navigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and Beyond
Navigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and BeyondNavigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and Beyond
Navigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and Beyond
Aboud Health Group
 
Navigating Healthcare with Telemedicine
Navigating Healthcare with  TelemedicineNavigating Healthcare with  Telemedicine
Navigating Healthcare with Telemedicine
Iris Thiele Isip-Tan
 
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdfCHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdf
Sachin Sharma
 
How many patients does case series should have In comparison to case reports.pdf
How many patients does case series should have In comparison to case reports.pdfHow many patients does case series should have In comparison to case reports.pdf
How many patients does case series should have In comparison to case reports.pdf
pubrica101
 
Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility TestingPerformance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
Nguyễn Thị Vân Anh
 
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdfCHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
Sachin Sharma
 
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...
Guillermo Rivera
 
Dimensions of Healthcare Quality
Dimensions of Healthcare QualityDimensions of Healthcare Quality
Dimensions of Healthcare Quality
Naeemshahzad51
 
Artificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular Therapy
Artificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular TherapyArtificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular Therapy
Artificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular Therapy
Iris Thiele Isip-Tan
 
Contact Now 89011**83002 Dehradun ℂall Girls By Full Service ℂall Girl In De...
Contact Now  89011**83002 Dehradun ℂall Girls By Full Service ℂall Girl In De...Contact Now  89011**83002 Dehradun ℂall Girls By Full Service ℂall Girl In De...
Contact Now 89011**83002 Dehradun ℂall Girls By Full Service ℂall Girl In De...
aunty1x2
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Surgery-Mini-OSCE-All-Past-Years-Questions-Modified.
Surgery-Mini-OSCE-All-Past-Years-Questions-Modified.Surgery-Mini-OSCE-All-Past-Years-Questions-Modified.
Surgery-Mini-OSCE-All-Past-Years-Questions-Modified.
 
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
POLYCYSTIC OVARIAN SYNDROME (PCOS)......
 
The Docs PPG - 30.05.2024.pptx..........
The Docs PPG - 30.05.2024.pptx..........The Docs PPG - 30.05.2024.pptx..........
The Docs PPG - 30.05.2024.pptx..........
 
Immunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentation
Immunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentationImmunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentation
Immunity to Veterinary parasitic infections power point presentation
 
Demystifying-Gene-Editing-The-Promise-and-Peril-of-CRISPR.pdf
Demystifying-Gene-Editing-The-Promise-and-Peril-of-CRISPR.pdfDemystifying-Gene-Editing-The-Promise-and-Peril-of-CRISPR.pdf
Demystifying-Gene-Editing-The-Promise-and-Peril-of-CRISPR.pdf
 
Preventing Pickleball Injuries & Treatment
Preventing Pickleball Injuries & TreatmentPreventing Pickleball Injuries & Treatment
Preventing Pickleball Injuries & Treatment
 
💘Ludhiana ℂall Girls 📞]][89011★83002][[ 📱 ❤ESCORTS service in Ludhiana💃💦Ludhi...
💘Ludhiana ℂall Girls 📞]][89011★83002][[ 📱 ❤ESCORTS service in Ludhiana💃💦Ludhi...💘Ludhiana ℂall Girls 📞]][89011★83002][[ 📱 ❤ESCORTS service in Ludhiana💃💦Ludhi...
💘Ludhiana ℂall Girls 📞]][89011★83002][[ 📱 ❤ESCORTS service in Ludhiana💃💦Ludhi...
 
Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...
Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...
Leading the Way in Nephrology: Dr. David Greene's Work with Stem Cells for Ki...
 
HEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptx
HEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptxHEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptx
HEAT WAVE presented by priya bhojwani..pptx
 
Secret Tantric VIP Erotic Massage London
Secret Tantric VIP Erotic Massage LondonSecret Tantric VIP Erotic Massage London
Secret Tantric VIP Erotic Massage London
 
Navigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and Beyond
Navigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and BeyondNavigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and Beyond
Navigating Women's Health: Understanding Prenatal Care and Beyond
 
Navigating Healthcare with Telemedicine
Navigating Healthcare with  TelemedicineNavigating Healthcare with  Telemedicine
Navigating Healthcare with Telemedicine
 
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdfCHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V - ROLE OF PEADIATRIC NURSE.pdf
 
How many patients does case series should have In comparison to case reports.pdf
How many patients does case series should have In comparison to case reports.pdfHow many patients does case series should have In comparison to case reports.pdf
How many patients does case series should have In comparison to case reports.pdf
 
Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility TestingPerformance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
 
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdfCHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdf
 
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...
 
Dimensions of Healthcare Quality
Dimensions of Healthcare QualityDimensions of Healthcare Quality
Dimensions of Healthcare Quality
 
Artificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular Therapy
Artificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular TherapyArtificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular Therapy
Artificial Intelligence to Optimize Cardiovascular Therapy
 
Contact Now 89011**83002 Dehradun ℂall Girls By Full Service ℂall Girl In De...
Contact Now  89011**83002 Dehradun ℂall Girls By Full Service ℂall Girl In De...Contact Now  89011**83002 Dehradun ℂall Girls By Full Service ℂall Girl In De...
Contact Now 89011**83002 Dehradun ℂall Girls By Full Service ℂall Girl In De...
 

Media & the Politics of Implementation: Explaining Geographic Variation in Local TV Coverage of the ACA

  • 1. Media & the Politics of Implementation: Explaining Geographic Variation in Local TV Coverage of the ACA Erika Franklin Fowler & Laura Baum, Wesleyan Colleen L. Barry, John Hopkins Bloomberg Jeff Niederdeppe, Cornell Pinar Karaca-Mandic, Andrew Wilcock & Sarah E. Gollust, UMN
  • 2. Funding from: • Robert Wood Johnson Foundation through its State Health Care Access Reform Evaluation (SHARE), Grant ID# 72179 • Wesleyan University
  • 3. News as Commodity, not a Mirror • News is a highly selective version of reality (Lippmann 1922; Gans 1979; Hamilton 2004) • Much of political science assumes information transmission (see Althaus et al. 2011) • Even within communication, news production takes a backseat to effects
  • 4. Key Insight: Coverage Unlikely to be Uniform • Audience characteristics • Ease of access to story material • Ownership characteristics • Geographic proximity to story • Congruence between media and political boundaries • In other words, production is variable and complex
  • 5. Competing Interests Shaping ACA Coverage • News producers • Politicians • Organized interests Interested here in predicting volume (content focus later)
  • 6. Data & Measures • Closed captioned searches of local TV news from 10/1/13-4/15/14 • Key words: “health care,” “healthcare,” “Obama care,” “Obamacare” and “Affordable Care Act” • 685 stations in 208 media markets, all evening news (4:30-11:59pm) • American Community Survey (ACS) • Wesleyan Media Project political and insurance advertising data • RWJF insurance market information • BIA Kelsey Station Ownership Information
  • 7. Volume of Evening Local TV ACA Hits Oct 1, 2013 – Apr 15, 2014
  • 8. Local TV News Hits by Station 02468 FrequencyofStations 0 200 400 600 Number of Closed Captioning Hits
  • 9. Analytic Approach • Negative binomial count models • Clustering by state, robust SEs (robust to hierarchical) • All results from one model
  • 10. Factors Shaping News: Audience Interest Greater interest in the ACA in a market should drive coverage up • Markets with more uninsured: more coverage • Markets with more direct purchasers: more coverage • Markets with high poverty: unclear • Partisanship: unclear • Political competition: more coverage • Controls for news consumer demographics: age, sex, education, race
  • 11. Factors Shaping News: Audience Interest Coeff. (S.E.) Uninsured (% 18-64 NCI population) 1.278** (0.597) Indiv. health ins. enrollees (% 18-64 NCI pop) -0.206 (1.414) Poverty (%) -3.093** (1.316) White (%) -0.227 (0.205) College grad or more (%) 0.982 (0.734) Male (%) -17.73*** (3.353) Ages 20-64 (%) 1.070 (1.684) Ages 65+ (%) -1.107 (1.032) Obama vote in DMA (%) 0.175 (0.266) Margin of victory (50 – abs(Obama vote)) 0.214 (0.415)
  • 12. Predicted Count by Proportion Uninsured 100150200250 PredictedNumberofACAHits .04 .08 .12 .16 .2 .24 .28 .32 Proportion of 18-64 CNI Population w/o Health Insurance (ACS 2013 5-Yr Est)
  • 13. Ease of Access to Sources & Story Materials Availability of materials for ACA stories should increase coverage • Accessibility of spokespeople should increase coverage • Volume of ACA insurance and political ads should increase coverage • Type of insurance marketplace: state-based should have more stories
  • 14. Ease of Access to Sources & Story Materials Coeff. (S.E.) Consumer assistance funds (per uninsured) -0.00415 (0.00263) Insurance ad volume (000s) 0.0195** (0.00900) Political ad volume (000s) 0.0642 (0.0417) Partnership exchange 0.200*** (0.0665) State-based exchange 0.162** (0.0711)
  • 15. Predicted Count by Exchange Type 140160180200220 PredictedNumberofACAHits Federally-Facilitated Partnership State-Based
  • 16. Station & Ownership Characteristics Stations are enabled and constrained by their network affiliates and ownership groups choices and priorities for programming • Fox affiliates (more sports, fewer newscasts): less coverage • Ownership profits: unclear
  • 17. Station & Ownership Characteristics Coeff. (S.E.) CBS affiliate 0.0293 (0.0415) Fox affiliate -0.228*** (0.0473) NBC affiliate 0.162*** (0.0417) Second tier (revenue) -0.114** (0.0490) Lowest tier (revenue) -0.158*** (0.0483)
  • 18. Predicted Count by Owner Revenue Tier 150160170180190200 PredictedNumberofACAHits Largest Profits Mid-Tier Profits Lowest Profits
  • 19. Structural Factors Affecting Production Structural set-up of media markets (population served and geographic congruence) matter • Number of states within DMA: decrease coverage • Population of the media market: decrease coverage • Insurer competition: increase coverage (expect negative sign)
  • 20. Structural Factors Affecting Production Coeff. (S.E.) # of states within DMA 0.0316 (0.0203) DMA total population (Ms) -0.0321* (0.0174) HHI (insurance competition) -2.02e-05 (1.28e-05)
  • 21. Contribution & Future Directions • Variance in news coverage of the ACA is predictable • Systematic analysis of local TV across the country • Future work • Over time • Assessing content