SlideShare a Scribd company logo
IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 136
MAINTENANCE PERFORMANCE METRICS FOR MANUFACTURING
INDUSTRY
Jitendra Kumar1
, V.K. Soni2
, Geeta Agnihotri3
1
PhD Scholar, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, MANIT, Bhopal, jitendra.me@gmail.com
2
Asst. Professor, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, MANIT, Bhopal, soni_vk@rediffmail.com
3
Professor, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, MANIT, Bhopal, dr.gagnihotri@gmail.com
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate various maintenance performance indicators (MPIs) within the perspective of
maintenance metrics conducted by the managerial personnel for achieving the specified production target. In this paper, a conceptual
framework has been developed, that provides guideline for choosing maintenance performance metrics for a typical manufacturing
industry. It seeks to align maintenance objective with the performance indicators and provides a link between the two. Operations and
maintenance of manufacturing system are of great economic importance. The review of literature on maintenance performance
indicators and their measurement has been summarized under the five categories of metrics; functional metrics, equipment
performance metrics, maintenance process metrics, periodicity metrics and OEE metrics. The review indicates that quantitative
metrics for measuring maintenance performance are lacking. To address this gap, maintenance performance metrics has been
proposed.
Keywords: Maintenance performance indicators, Performance metrics, Reactive Maintenance, Periodic maintenance,
OEE
---------------------------------------------------------------------***----------------------------------------------------------------------
1. INTRODUCTION
Effective maintenance is critical to many operations. It extends
equipment life, improves equipment availability and retains
equipment in proper condition without delay of production
schedules. The Maintenance Engineering Society of Australia
(MESA) indicates that maintenance is about achieving the
required asset capabilities within an economic or business
context (MESA, 1995). They define maintenance as the
engineering decision and associated actions, necessary and
sufficient for optimization of specified equipment „capability‟.
The term “capability” indicates the ability to perform a
specified function within a range of performance levels that
may relate to capacity, rate, quality and responsiveness (Tsang,
1998).
The four major factors (Karim, 2011) that cause defects in the
product quality are human negligence, bad quality of raw
material, machine that need maintenance and work procedure.
After analysis it has been concluded that the machine
maintenance from time to time is an important issue in quality
control. To optimize and reduce defects & occurring of
machine damage, the plant managers should focus on the
maintenance of machinery to ensure quality production at a
satisfactory level.
A number of methods have been expressed by Antero Ollila
and Markku (1999) like reactive maintenance, preventive
maintenance, predictive maintenance and proactive
maintenance. Reactive maintenance can be minimized by using
methods like JIT (Just-In-Time), TQM (Total Quality
Maintenance) to repair the machine & to reduce the defects in
produced products. Further, for achieving zero defects, JIT and
TQM method can be used in conjunction with the DPM
(Downtime Due to Preventive Maintenance) methods. While
the methods for preventive maintenance is a routine
maintenance that has been set. Campbell (1995) proposed the
implementation of two highly successful methods for the
continuous improvement – RCM (Reliability centered
Maintenance) and TPM (Total Productive Maintenance).
Pintelon and Van Wassenhove (1992) have provided a
maintenance management tool to evaluate maintenance
performance. The tool consists of a control board and a set of
reports to analyze certain ratios. This tool is applied in five
different domains falling under the control of the maintenance
manager: cost/budget, equipment performance, personnel
performance, material management and work order control.
The outline of this article is as follows. Section 2 treats the
possibility of performance metrics in achieving higher
improvement. Section 3 gives an overview of the maintenance
performance metrics and explains the importance of metrics.
Section 4 describes the different maintenance performance
metrics including functional metrics, equipment performance
metrics, maintenance process metrics, periodicity metrics and
IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 137
OEE metrics. Conclusion and future research scope are
formulated in section 5.
2. PERFORMANCE METRICS
Performance metric is the fundamental instrument of the
management which provides essential link between strategies,
execution and ultimate value creation. Performance metric is a
standard definition of a measurable quantity that indicates some
aspect of performance and it is often viewed as being part of
the infrastructure or environment in which manufacturing
operation must operate. In other words a metric is nothing more
than a standard measure to assess the performance in a
particular area. Manufacturing and management consultant
Oliver Wight almost 40 years ago offered the often repeated
maxim, “you get what you inspect, not what you expect”. All
type of firms, activity, and worker needs metrics to evaluate
fundamental activities of measuring, educating, and directing
the gap for improvement. For the continuous improvement of
plant, it is very essential to evaluate the present status of
maintenance performance with respect to the fundamental,
strategic and maintenance objectives defined by the corporate,
plant and maintenance management. While making
maintenance objectives, performance indicators and key
performance indicators can be defined (Liyange, 2003) in the
manner of either measure past or predict future performance.
Operational performance indicators related to the maintenance
are referred to as maintenance performance indicators (MPIs).
MPIs are evaluated against goals coupled with the objectives by
the company and the plant managers, respectively. Familiar
maintenance metrics can be developed for measuring
performance along the dimension of maintenance function,
process, and equipment at the plant level maintenance activities
which is untouched by the researcher.
3. MAINTENANCE PERFORMANCE METRICS
The European standard for maintenance key performance
indicators (EN: 15341, 2007) provides three main categories of
indicators namely economic indicators, technical indicators and
organizational indicators. A hierarchical manner of key figures
of industrial maintenance has been developed by Komonen
(2002) like external, internal and intermediate objective
variable including the business-oriented indicators.
The managerial aim of indicators is to guide plant operations
and maintenance performance specifically. The different
category of measure shows different areas of interest in
maintenance performance in both literature and practice. The
importance of maintenance performance measurements have
extensively been discussed by many authors (Arts 1998; Tsang
1999; Visser 2003; Weber 2006; Parida 2007). Maintenance
managers require performance information to monitor and
control maintenance processes and results, which provide
indication towards improvement. The measure of maintenance
effectiveness is defined in terms of maintenance performance
indicators (MPIs) for the plant. While, metrics are needed to
evaluate the effectiveness of maintenance strategies and
decisions regarding designing a new maintenance policy or
redesigning an existing one. Such metrics should be simple to
use to facilitate their application in today‟s changeable and
reconfigurable manufacturing environment (wiendahl, 2007). In
other words, there should be a strong dependency between
maintenance performance metrics (MPMs) and the MPIs.
Based on data analysis, this dependency should be reflected in a
strong correlation between the MPMs and MPIs. Parida and
Kumar (2006) identified the various issues and challenges
associated with development and implementation of a
maintenance performance measurement (MPM) system. The
study finds that for successful implementation of MPM, all
employees should be involved and all relevant issues need to be
considered.
A huge numbers of indicators are used in the industrial
maintenance but literature does not provide any methodology
for selection of key performance indicators and usually it has
been derived by the need and experience felt by the industry to
industry. The similar type of indicators can be grouped within a
performance metrics which can evaluate the performance of
maintenance and such type of metrics is a great challenge for
the researcher. In consequence a similar attempt has been made
to develop maintenance performance metrics in the next
section.
4. DEVELOPING A BASIS OF MAINTENANCE
PERFORMANCE METRICS
As explained in previous section it is necessary to identify the
needs of advance in order to maintain the normal functioning of
production systems. Further the analysis of maintenance
function is needed to implement better maintenance policy. For
the same the performance of maintenance must be analyzed
through performance indicators. The similar type of indicators
can be grouped within a metrics for measuring maintenance
performance according to the maintenance function. Moya
(2004) developed a system composed of indicators to control
the setting up predictive maintenance programs which should
facilitate the early detection of anomalies which can appear
during setting up to avoid the failure of maintenance program.
The procedure for detailed metrics development is shown as
follows:
(A). Metrics Collection and Definition: A comprehensive list
of maintenance performance indicators is put together through
extensive literature review including web based information
sources. Each indicator is defined within their metric so that it‟s
meaning and measures are clearly understood.
(B). Metrics Evaluation and Categorization: Each metric is
evaluated based on its characteristics and maintenance work
relevant to it, such as maintenance objective, strategies,
process, and maintenance cost is involved.
IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 138
(C). Relevancy and Repetition Check: Each category is
reviewed to ensure that all the metrics are relevant. Redundant
ones are eliminated.
4.1 FUNCTIONAL METRICS
To ensure that plant operates at the required condition while
meeting its production targets at an optimal cost, maintenance
management has to make conscious decisions regarding the
maintenance objective and strategies that need to be pursued. It
is evident that (Kelly 1989; MESA 1995; Tsang 1999; Visser
2003), maintenance objectives are related to attainment of
production target (through high equipment availability) at
required quality within the constraints of the system condition
and safety, utilizing optimum available maintenance resources
so that the plant achieves its design life, the safety standard are
met, the energy use and raw material consumption are
optimized among the other factors (Dekker, 1996).
Maintenance objective has been summarized under the
following five headings (as shown in Fig. 1): ensuring the
functionality of plant so that plant achieves its design life
within the environmental safety and cost effectiveness with
effective use of resources. It is assumed that the maintenance
objectives pursued at a given plant influences the kind of
performance metrics or indicators used.
Once the maintenance objectives are outlined, maintenance
strategy formulation is necessary to decide which type of
maintenance needs to be done, when to do it and how often it
can be done. According to Pintelon (2006) maintenance
decision making can be broadly explained in terms of
maintenance action, maintenance policies and maintenance
concepts. Maintenance policies are the rules or set of rules
describing the triggering mechanism for the different
maintenance actions. Example of these policies are Failure
based maintenance (FBM), use based or time based
maintenance (UBM/TBM), condition based maintenance
(CBM), design out maintenance (DOM) (Madu, 2000; Pintelon,
2002; savsar, 2006).
When maintenance objectives and strategies have been
established, the success of functional metrics is dependent on
the maintenance work management cycle, as outlined by
Campbell (1995), consists of work identification, planning,
scheduling, execution and closing the job. At the heart of the
maintenance, functions are work planning and scheduling,
which defines what gets done and when.
Organizational
strategies
Manufacturing
Strategies
Maintenance Objective
Be able to operate as & when
required
Operate efficiently, accurately at
the required level
Operate without unscheduled
stoppage
Operate within safety &
environmental limit
1. Operate at minimum maintenance cost
2. Operate at designed speed
3. Product Quality
4. Reliability
Fig. 1 Maintenance Objective for Maintenance Department
IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 139
4.2 EQUIPMENT PERFORMANCE METRICS
The role of the equipment condition in controlling quality and
quantity is well known in the manufacturing industry (Daya,
1995). Equipment must be maintained in top operating
conditions through adequate maintenance activities. From the
analysis of the manufacturing and maintenance environment, it
was found that equipment breakdown is the most important
cause of production disruption among other causes of
disruptions (quality, feedstock, logistics etc). Saxena (2008)
developed algorithmic performance metrics to plan
maintenance in advance to reduce downtime and maximize
availability. Ollila and Malmipuro (1999) observed that the
equipment availability has a major impact on efficiency and
quality of production. An integrated maintenance model using
statistical process control for monitoring quality of product has
been developed by Noorossana (2011) and found that the
quality of product is synonymous to monitoring status of
equipment and as the result an out-of-control signal would
indicate deterioration of the equipment. Huang et al. (2006)
considered a further extension using a preventive maintenance
(PM) that either brings the system to the „as good as new‟
condition or the system will fail immediately because of faulty
maintenance. Equipment performance (Rosqvist et al., 2009)
can be analyzed through proactivity of maintenance task of
equipment (Preventive tasks and actions/Maintenance tasks),
equipment reliability (Number of functional
failures/Operational cycles of equipment) and equipment
availability (Downtime/Operational period of equipment).
Planning of preventive maintenance of technical system is
assessed by the RCM (Reliability centered maintenance)
analysis and it is gaining a solid reputation for successful
method (Selvik, 2011). The analysis of RCM includes all
historical records such as the list of functionality significant
items (FSIA), the failure mode and effect analysis (FMEA),
case based reasoning (CBR) and the basic reliability data
(Cheng et al., 2008).
4.3 MAINTENANCE PROCESS METRICS
Marquez (2006) have defined maintenance process as the series
of action at different stages which need to follow. The
maintenance Process include assessing the feasibility and effort
required to fulfill the need of maintenance for system change
and scoping the work accordingly; planning, designing and
implementing the changes to the system and accompanying
documentation; testing the amended system at the unit, system,
integration, and acceptance levels; and transitioning the
amended system into production with minimal disruption of
normal production level. At large the assessment of
maintenance process has two parts effective analysis and
efficiency analysis. The first part helps to detect the most
important problems and locate their potential solution. The
second part identifies the suitable procedure. The researcher
define eight phases to accomplish this comprehensive
assessment as: (1) determination of current factory performance
(2) quality and downtime (3) effectiveness analysis of
alternative solution (4) efficiency analysis of maintenance
procedure (5) plan action (6) implementing action and
gathering of data (7) monitoring action and processing data (8)
adaption of plans.
Lam (2007) introduced a special monotone process applied to a
replacement model in which the operating times of system from
a non-increasing geometric process and consecutive repair
times constitute a non-decreasing geometric process. Chen
(2010) identified Geometric process modeling as a useful tool
to study repairable deteriorating system in maintenance
problems. While maintenance Error Decision Aid (MEDA)
process was developed (Rankin, 2000) based on the philosophy
that maintenance technician do not make errors on the purpose,
that errors result from a series of related contributing factors,
and that these factors are largely under management control
and, therefore, can be changed. The process was tested by the
employees of airline and one repair centre. Grall (2010)
discussed maintenance policies for stochastically deteriorating
systems which are subject to sudden change in their
degradation processes. From a maintenance decision making
point of view two condition based maintenance policies are
considered and compared through a numerical example and
show that the time distribution of the change of deterioration
rate and the difference between the two possible deterioration
rates strongly influence the choice of the best decision rule
structure.
4.3.1 PLANNED MAINTENANCE PROCESS
Planned Maintenance has two loops: Planning, scheduling,
Execution and Follow up make up the first loop while second
loop consists of work identification and performance analysis
elements. Planned maintenance process is measured by
schedule compliance i.e. the percentage of work orders
completed during the scheduled period before the late finish or
required by date. World class maintenance should achieve more
than 90% during execution. An integrated model developed by
Daya (2002) for the joint determination of economic production
quantity and preventive maintenance (PM) level for an
imperfect process having a general deterioration distribution
with increasing hazard rate.
4.3.2 ASSET RELIABILITY PROCESS
The analysis of typical asset could include costs of planning,
research and development, production, operation, maintenance
and disposal. So a life cycle cost analysis calculates the cost of
an asset for its entire life span whereas reliability analysis such
as failure rate cost of spares, repair times, and component costs.
In many maintenance problems, it is convenient to assume that
repairs are either equivalent or less beneficial than the
replacement and the system are brought back into an as good as
new state after each repair and for the same Kallen (2011) used
to model the effect of imperfect maintenance through the use of
superposition of renewal process. This model can be
IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 140
extensively used to determine an approximate probability
distribution of the time between repairs. Failed component are
not repaired until a predefined fraction of the total number has
failed.
4.4 PERIODICITY METRICS
The planned maintenance process is targeted to achieve
required performance asset performance. For the better periodic
maintenance activities, must be a better planning and
scheduling. As planning develops procedure for maintenance
work while scheduling evaluates the availability of all
resources required for maintenance work “due” in a specified
time frame.
Maintenance strategy is a structured combination of two
maintenance action (Dekker, 1996) corrective and preventive
which describes the events (e.g. failure, machine condition,
etc.) and the type of action they trigger (i.e. inspection, repair,
maintenance or replacement). Corrective maintenance which
includes all actions performed as a result of a failure to restore
an item to a specified working condition, while preventive
maintenance includes all actions performed on operating
equipment to restore them to a better condition.
Meselhy (2010) introduced two independent source of
periodicity due to maintenance programs; the failure repair and
pre-planned Preventive maintenance. Therefore, for the given
maintenance policy parameter repair level (RL), periodicity
extent expressed by the level of PM (PMLi), preventive
maintenance frequency (PMFi) and the machine failure rate E
(λ), the total system periodicity can be expressed as:
Periodicity =
E(λ)
2
RL
− 1
+
PMFi
2
PMLi
− 1
n
i=1
The above calculated periodicity is a measure of the relative
ability of the maintenance strategy to resets the machine‟s
functionality.
We may conclude that equipment performance are measured on
a shorter time interval (daily and weekly basis), probably to
facilitate quicker corrective actions. Rosqvist et al. (2009)
discussed Periodic preventive maintenance task related to
preventive maintenance strategies which are either condition-
based (periodic functional testing, periodic inspection,
condition monitoring, operation supervision) or predetermined
(periodic restoration, periodic servicing, Modification work).
4.5 OEE METRICS
The total productive maintenance (TPM) concept launched by
Nakajima (1988) provides a quantitative metric called Overall
Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) for measuring productivity of
manufacturing equipments. OEE metric and its variants came
out as the most popular equipment performance indicator
capable of measuring different production losses, of which
maintenance related losses are important. The important
maintenance indicators in the OEE have shown in the fig 2.
OEE
Availability
Rate
Performance
Rate
Quality Rate
Planned
Downtime
Unplanned
Downtime
1. Preventive Maintenance time
2. No. f preventive Maintenance
1. Failure (MTBF)
2. Failure Frequency
3. Mean Time To Repair
Fig. 2 Maintenance Indicator in the OEE Metrics
IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 141
The OEE concept has become increasingly popular and has
been widely used as a quantitative tool essential for
measurement equipments‟ performance in industries (Huang
2003; Muchiri 2008).
OEE = Availability A X Performance P X Quality (Q)
A =
calender time − Downtime
calender time
X 100
P =
Processed amount
operating time
X100
Q =
processed amount − Defective amount
processed amount
X100
This metric has become widely accepted as a quantitative tool
essential for measurement of productivity in manufacturing
operations (Samuel et al., 2002). One of the most critical
success factors influencing survival, profitability, and
competitive advantage of manufacturing organization is to
select proper maintenance policy. OEE is mostly used in one of
the policies, i.e. total productive maintenance and it helps in
decision making (Shahin, 2011) to improve the overall
performance of organizations.
Using OEE metrics and establishing a disciplined reporting
system help an organization to focus on the parameters critical
to its success. Analyzing OEE categories can reveal the greatest
limits to success.
CONCLUSIONS
In this paper, a conceptual framework has been developed that
provide the overview of maintenance performance metrics
aligning various maintenance performance indicators according
to the maintenance objective of the plant. The maintenance
performance metrics are summarized under the five categories:
functional metrics, equipment performance metrics,
maintenance process metrics, periodicity metrics and OEE
metrics. The aim is to ensure that the key indicators must be
measured within the metrics to evaluate the maintenance
performance.
This research demonstrates that the performance indicators can
be grouped within a metric so that the maintenance
performance analysis will be easy to review. Further research
work is recommended on the maintenance diagnostic metrics
and maintenance cost metrics which plays key role in the
operation and maintenance department to evaluate the
performance and further improvement. Since the availability of
maintenance metrics may not necessarily guarantee low
maintenance cost, hence a maintenance cost metrics may be
derived for the low cost repair, replacement and maintenance in
practice.
REFERENCES
[1] Arts, R.H.P.M., Knapp, G.M., Mann, L. (1998), “Some
aspects of measuring maintenance performance in
process industry”, Journal of Quality in Maintenance
Engineering, 4 (1), 6–11.
[2] Campbell J. D., Uptime. (1995), “Strategies in
excellence in maintenance management”, Portland:
Productivity Press; 1995.
[3] Chen J. et al. (2010), “Bayesian computation for
geometric process in maintenance problem”,
Mathematics and computers in simulation, 81:771-781.
[4] Cheng et al. (2008), “A framework for intelligent
reliability centered maintenance analysis”, Reliability
engineering and system safety 93:784-792.
[5] Christer AH, Wang W, Sharp JM., (1997), “A state
space condition monitoring model for furnace erosion
prediction and replacement”, European Journal of
Operation Research, 101:1-14.
[6] Daya, B., Duffuaa, S., (1995), “Maintenance and quality:
The missing link”, Journal of Quality in Maintenance
Engineering, 1 (1), 20–26.
[7] Dekker, R., (1996), “Application of maintenance
optimization models: a review and analysis”, Reliability
Engineering and System Safety, 51, 229–240.
[8] EN: 15341, (2007), “Maintenance Key Performance
Indicators”, European Committee for Standardization
(CEN), Brussels, Belgium.
[9] Grall, A., et al. (2010) “assessment of a maintenance
model for a multi-deteriorating mode system”,
Reliability Engineering and system safety, 95:1244-
1254.
[10] Kallen, MJ., (2011) “Modeling imperfect maintenance
and the reliability of complex system using superposed
renewal processes”, Reliability Engineering and
system safety, 96: 636-641.
[11] Karim, K. and Talib, A., (2011), “total productive
maintenance application to reduce Defects of product”,
Journal of applied science research, 7(1):11-17.
[12] Kelly, A., 1989. Maintenance and its Management.
Conference communication London.
[13] Komonen, K., (2002) “A cost model of industrial
maintenance for profitability analysis and
benchmarking”, International Journal of Production
Economics, 79, 15-31.
[14] Lam, Y., (1991) “An optimal repairable replacement
model for deteriorating systems”, J. Appl. Prob., 28:
843–851.
[15] Lam, Y., (2007) “A geometric process maintenance
model with preventive repair”, European Journal of
Operational Research, 182:806-819.
[16] Liyange JP, Kumar U., (2003) “Towards a value based
view on operations and maintenance performance
management” Journal of Quality & Maintenance
Engineering, (9): 333-350.
IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 142
[17] Lupinucci M, Perej J, Davila G., (2000) “Improving
sheet metal quality and product throughput with Bently‟s
Machinery Management system”, orbit. Bently Nevada;
21 (3), 37-41.
[18] Madu, C., (2000) “Competing through maintenance
strategies”, International Journal of Quality & Reliability
Management, 17 (9), 937–948.
[19] Marquez A.C., and Gupta, J.N.D., (2006) “contemporary
maintenance management: process, framework and
supporting pillars” Omega 34:313-326.
[20] Meselhy, K.T., et al. (2010) “A periodicity metric for
assessing maintenance strategies”, CIRP Journal of
Manufacturing Science and Technology. (3), 135-141.
[21] MESA, (1995) “Maintenance Engineering Society of
Australia capability Assurance: A Generic Model of
Maintenance”, Maintenance Engineering Society of
Australia (MESA), Australia.
[22] Muchiri, P.N., Pintelon, L., (2008), “Performance
measurement using overall equipment effectiveness
(OEE): Literature review and practical application”,
International Journal of Production Research, 46 (13),
3517–3535.
[23] Nakajima, S., (1988), “Introduction to TPM: Total
Productive Maintenance”, Productivity Press,
Cambridge, MA.
[24] Ollila, A., M. dan Malmipuro, (1999), “Maintenance Has
a Role in Quality”, The TQM Magazine, 11(1): 17- 22.
[25] Pintelon LM, Van Wassenhove (1992) “A maintenance
management tool”, Omega; 18(1):59-70.
[26] Parida, A., Chattopadhyay, G., (2007), “Development of
a multi-criteria hierarchical framework for maintenance
performance measurement (MPM)”, Journal of Quality
in Maintenance Engineering, 13 (3), 241–258.
[27] Pintelon, L., VanPuyvelde, F., (2006), “Maintenance
Decision Making”, Leuven, Belgium, Acco.
[28] Rosqvist, T. et al., (2009) “Value-driven maintenance
planning for a production plant”, Reliability Engineering
and system safety 94: 97-110.
[29] Savsar, M., (2006), “Effects of maintenance policies on
the productivity of flexible manufacturing cells”, Omega
International Journal of management Science, 34, 274–
282.
[30] Shahin, A., (2011), “Developing Decision making grid
for maintenance policy making based on estimated
range of OEE”, Modern applied science, 5 (6)
[31] Tsang, A.H.C., (1998), “A strategic approach to
managing maintenance performance”, Journal of Quality
in Maintenance Engineering, 4 (2), 87–94 (8).
[32] Tsang, A.H.C., (1999), “Measuring maintenance
performance: a holistic approach”, International Journal
of Operations and Production management 19 (7), 691–
715.
[33] Tsang, A.H.C., (1998), “A strategic approach to
managing maintenance performance”, Journal of Quality
in Maintenance Engineering, 4 (2), 87-94 (8).
[34] Villar JM, Masson LO, Gomes JA., (2003) “Proactive
maintenance – A successful history”, orbit, Bently
Nevada; 21(3):33-41.
[35] Visser, J.K., Pretorious, M.W., (2003), “The
development of a performance measurement system for
maintenance, SA Journal of Industrial Engineering, 14
(1), 83–97.
[36] Wiendahl, H.P., et al. (2007), “changeable
Manufacturing- Classification, design and operation",
CIRP Annals-Manufacturing Technology, 56 (2), 783-
809.
[37] Weber, A., Thomas, R., (2006), “Key Performance
Indicators: Measuring & Managing the Maintenance
Function”, Ivara Corporation.
BIOGRAPHIES:
Jitendra Kumar holds a Bachelor‟s
Degree in Mechanical Engineering and M.
Tech in Industrial Design from LNCT,
Bhopal. Presently, he is pursuing PhD in
the Dept. of Mechanical Engineering,
M.A.National Institute of Technology,
Bhopal. His main research area is
Industrial Engineering & Management.
Jitendra Kumar is the corresponding author and can be
contacted at: jitendra.me@gmail.com

More Related Content

What's hot

IRJET- Plant Evaluation using OEE & ORE
IRJET-  	  Plant Evaluation using OEE & OREIRJET-  	  Plant Evaluation using OEE & ORE
IRJET- Plant Evaluation using OEE & ORE
IRJET Journal
 
Design and fabrication of modular fixture for cmm inspection
Design and fabrication of modular fixture for cmm inspectionDesign and fabrication of modular fixture for cmm inspection
Design and fabrication of modular fixture for cmm inspection
eSAT Journals
 
Road map of development for pull system in thailand small and medium automoti...
Road map of development for pull system in thailand small and medium automoti...Road map of development for pull system in thailand small and medium automoti...
Road map of development for pull system in thailand small and medium automoti...
eSAT Publishing House
 
IRJET- A General Framework of Computerized Maintenance Management System ...
IRJET-  	  A General Framework of Computerized Maintenance Management System ...IRJET-  	  A General Framework of Computerized Maintenance Management System ...
IRJET- A General Framework of Computerized Maintenance Management System ...
IRJET Journal
 
F04943847
F04943847F04943847
F04943847
IOSR-JEN
 
Interweaving Knowledge Acquisition and Product Functionality
Interweaving Knowledge Acquisition and Product FunctionalityInterweaving Knowledge Acquisition and Product Functionality
Interweaving Knowledge Acquisition and Product Functionality
Editor IJCATR
 
Cost Implication of Inventory Management in Organised Systems
Cost Implication of Inventory Management in Organised SystemsCost Implication of Inventory Management in Organised Systems
Cost Implication of Inventory Management in Organised Systems
Dr. Amarjeet Singh
 
Purchasing functions and mrp in foodservice firms
Purchasing functions and mrp in foodservice firmsPurchasing functions and mrp in foodservice firms
Purchasing functions and mrp in foodservice firms
Alexander Decker
 
Implementation of Single Minute Exchange of Die in Motor Manufacturing Unit
Implementation of Single Minute Exchange of Die in Motor Manufacturing UnitImplementation of Single Minute Exchange of Die in Motor Manufacturing Unit
Implementation of Single Minute Exchange of Die in Motor Manufacturing Unit
IRJET Journal
 
Impact of total productive maintenance methodology on the performance
Impact of total productive maintenance methodology on the performanceImpact of total productive maintenance methodology on the performance
Impact of total productive maintenance methodology on the performance
eSAT Journals
 
Study on Factors for Improving The Effectiveness Of ERP Within Korea Agricult...
Study on Factors for Improving The Effectiveness Of ERP Within Korea Agricult...Study on Factors for Improving The Effectiveness Of ERP Within Korea Agricult...
Study on Factors for Improving The Effectiveness Of ERP Within Korea Agricult...
QUESTJOURNAL
 
IRJET- Study to Condense Expenditure through Engineering Management of Wood P...
IRJET- Study to Condense Expenditure through Engineering Management of Wood P...IRJET- Study to Condense Expenditure through Engineering Management of Wood P...
IRJET- Study to Condense Expenditure through Engineering Management of Wood P...
IRJET Journal
 
I04402058062
I04402058062I04402058062
I04402058062
ijceronline
 
Introduction to Production Engineering Department
Introduction to Production Engineering DepartmentIntroduction to Production Engineering Department
Introduction to Production Engineering Department
Amr El-Ganainy
 
Improving overall equipment effectiveness by Implementing Total Productive Ma...
Improving overall equipment effectiveness by Implementing Total Productive Ma...Improving overall equipment effectiveness by Implementing Total Productive Ma...
Improving overall equipment effectiveness by Implementing Total Productive Ma...
IJMER
 
Y4201162171
Y4201162171Y4201162171
Y4201162171
IJERA Editor
 
Chapter 1 introduction to agricultural machinery design
Chapter 1   introduction to agricultural machinery designChapter 1   introduction to agricultural machinery design
Chapter 1 introduction to agricultural machinery design
ElmanTorres5
 
IRJET- Study and Analysis of Time Factor in the Utilization Process
IRJET- Study and Analysis of Time Factor in the Utilization ProcessIRJET- Study and Analysis of Time Factor in the Utilization Process
IRJET- Study and Analysis of Time Factor in the Utilization Process
IRJET Journal
 

What's hot (18)

IRJET- Plant Evaluation using OEE & ORE
IRJET-  	  Plant Evaluation using OEE & OREIRJET-  	  Plant Evaluation using OEE & ORE
IRJET- Plant Evaluation using OEE & ORE
 
Design and fabrication of modular fixture for cmm inspection
Design and fabrication of modular fixture for cmm inspectionDesign and fabrication of modular fixture for cmm inspection
Design and fabrication of modular fixture for cmm inspection
 
Road map of development for pull system in thailand small and medium automoti...
Road map of development for pull system in thailand small and medium automoti...Road map of development for pull system in thailand small and medium automoti...
Road map of development for pull system in thailand small and medium automoti...
 
IRJET- A General Framework of Computerized Maintenance Management System ...
IRJET-  	  A General Framework of Computerized Maintenance Management System ...IRJET-  	  A General Framework of Computerized Maintenance Management System ...
IRJET- A General Framework of Computerized Maintenance Management System ...
 
F04943847
F04943847F04943847
F04943847
 
Interweaving Knowledge Acquisition and Product Functionality
Interweaving Knowledge Acquisition and Product FunctionalityInterweaving Knowledge Acquisition and Product Functionality
Interweaving Knowledge Acquisition and Product Functionality
 
Cost Implication of Inventory Management in Organised Systems
Cost Implication of Inventory Management in Organised SystemsCost Implication of Inventory Management in Organised Systems
Cost Implication of Inventory Management in Organised Systems
 
Purchasing functions and mrp in foodservice firms
Purchasing functions and mrp in foodservice firmsPurchasing functions and mrp in foodservice firms
Purchasing functions and mrp in foodservice firms
 
Implementation of Single Minute Exchange of Die in Motor Manufacturing Unit
Implementation of Single Minute Exchange of Die in Motor Manufacturing UnitImplementation of Single Minute Exchange of Die in Motor Manufacturing Unit
Implementation of Single Minute Exchange of Die in Motor Manufacturing Unit
 
Impact of total productive maintenance methodology on the performance
Impact of total productive maintenance methodology on the performanceImpact of total productive maintenance methodology on the performance
Impact of total productive maintenance methodology on the performance
 
Study on Factors for Improving The Effectiveness Of ERP Within Korea Agricult...
Study on Factors for Improving The Effectiveness Of ERP Within Korea Agricult...Study on Factors for Improving The Effectiveness Of ERP Within Korea Agricult...
Study on Factors for Improving The Effectiveness Of ERP Within Korea Agricult...
 
IRJET- Study to Condense Expenditure through Engineering Management of Wood P...
IRJET- Study to Condense Expenditure through Engineering Management of Wood P...IRJET- Study to Condense Expenditure through Engineering Management of Wood P...
IRJET- Study to Condense Expenditure through Engineering Management of Wood P...
 
I04402058062
I04402058062I04402058062
I04402058062
 
Introduction to Production Engineering Department
Introduction to Production Engineering DepartmentIntroduction to Production Engineering Department
Introduction to Production Engineering Department
 
Improving overall equipment effectiveness by Implementing Total Productive Ma...
Improving overall equipment effectiveness by Implementing Total Productive Ma...Improving overall equipment effectiveness by Implementing Total Productive Ma...
Improving overall equipment effectiveness by Implementing Total Productive Ma...
 
Y4201162171
Y4201162171Y4201162171
Y4201162171
 
Chapter 1 introduction to agricultural machinery design
Chapter 1   introduction to agricultural machinery designChapter 1   introduction to agricultural machinery design
Chapter 1 introduction to agricultural machinery design
 
IRJET- Study and Analysis of Time Factor in the Utilization Process
IRJET- Study and Analysis of Time Factor in the Utilization ProcessIRJET- Study and Analysis of Time Factor in the Utilization Process
IRJET- Study and Analysis of Time Factor in the Utilization Process
 

Similar to Maintenance performance metrics for manufacturing industry

Technical maintenance of world class increase the availability of equipment
Technical maintenance of world class increase the availability of equipmentTechnical maintenance of world class increase the availability of equipment
Technical maintenance of world class increase the availability of equipmentIAEME Publication
 
Implementation Of TPM with Case study
Implementation Of TPM with Case studyImplementation Of TPM with Case study
Implementation Of TPM with Case study
IJESM JOURNAL
 
IRJET- Evaluating the Performance of Plant by Overall Equipment Effectiveness...
IRJET- Evaluating the Performance of Plant by Overall Equipment Effectiveness...IRJET- Evaluating the Performance of Plant by Overall Equipment Effectiveness...
IRJET- Evaluating the Performance of Plant by Overall Equipment Effectiveness...
IRJET Journal
 
Enhancement of the performance of an industry by the application of tqm concepts
Enhancement of the performance of an industry by the application of tqm conceptsEnhancement of the performance of an industry by the application of tqm concepts
Enhancement of the performance of an industry by the application of tqm concepts
eSAT Journals
 
Enhancement of the performance of an industry by the
Enhancement of the performance of an industry by theEnhancement of the performance of an industry by the
Enhancement of the performance of an industry by the
eSAT Publishing House
 
Phd literature review sample pdf
Phd literature review sample pdfPhd literature review sample pdf
Phd literature review sample pdf
PhD Assistance
 
Multi criteria Decision model (MCDM) for the evaluation of maintenance practi...
Multi criteria Decision model (MCDM) for the evaluation of maintenance practi...Multi criteria Decision model (MCDM) for the evaluation of maintenance practi...
Multi criteria Decision model (MCDM) for the evaluation of maintenance practi...
IJERA Editor
 
ARTICULO DE INVESTIGACION
ARTICULO DE INVESTIGACIONARTICULO DE INVESTIGACION
ARTICULO DE INVESTIGACION
Fabrizio Antonio Bautista Incio
 
IRJET- Effective Implementation of Planned Maintenance in a Gas Producing Pla...
IRJET- Effective Implementation of Planned Maintenance in a Gas Producing Pla...IRJET- Effective Implementation of Planned Maintenance in a Gas Producing Pla...
IRJET- Effective Implementation of Planned Maintenance in a Gas Producing Pla...
IRJET Journal
 
Failure Mode Effect Analysis and Total Productive Maintenance: A Review
Failure Mode Effect Analysis and Total Productive Maintenance: A ReviewFailure Mode Effect Analysis and Total Productive Maintenance: A Review
Failure Mode Effect Analysis and Total Productive Maintenance: A Review
AM Publications
 
Maintenance Leading and Lagging Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
Maintenance Leading and Lagging Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)Maintenance Leading and Lagging Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
Maintenance Leading and Lagging Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
Ricky Smith CMRP
 
5.an integrated
5.an integrated5.an integrated
5.an integratedlibfsb
 
Development Of An Effective Industrial Maintenance Practice For Plant Optimum...
Development Of An Effective Industrial Maintenance Practice For Plant Optimum...Development Of An Effective Industrial Maintenance Practice For Plant Optimum...
Development Of An Effective Industrial Maintenance Practice For Plant Optimum...
IJERA Editor
 
Overall Equipment Effectiveness in Construction Equipments
Overall Equipment Effectiveness in Construction EquipmentsOverall Equipment Effectiveness in Construction Equipments
Overall Equipment Effectiveness in Construction Equipments
IRJET Journal
 
Study of Total Productive Maintenance & It’s Implementation Approach in Steel...
Study of Total Productive Maintenance & It’s Implementation Approach in Steel...Study of Total Productive Maintenance & It’s Implementation Approach in Steel...
Study of Total Productive Maintenance & It’s Implementation Approach in Steel...
IRJET Journal
 
Reliability centered maintenance planning based on computer-aided fmea
Reliability centered maintenance planning based on computer-aided fmeaReliability centered maintenance planning based on computer-aided fmea
Reliability centered maintenance planning based on computer-aided fmeaNgoc Dep
 
OVERALL EQUIPMENT EFFECTIVENESS OF CRITICAL MACHINES IN MANUFACTURING INDUSTR...
OVERALL EQUIPMENT EFFECTIVENESS OF CRITICAL MACHINES IN MANUFACTURING INDUSTR...OVERALL EQUIPMENT EFFECTIVENESS OF CRITICAL MACHINES IN MANUFACTURING INDUSTR...
OVERALL EQUIPMENT EFFECTIVENESS OF CRITICAL MACHINES IN MANUFACTURING INDUSTR...
IAEME Publication
 

Similar to Maintenance performance metrics for manufacturing industry (20)

30720130101004
3072013010100430720130101004
30720130101004
 
Technical maintenance of world class increase the availability of equipment
Technical maintenance of world class increase the availability of equipmentTechnical maintenance of world class increase the availability of equipment
Technical maintenance of world class increase the availability of equipment
 
Implementation Of TPM with Case study
Implementation Of TPM with Case studyImplementation Of TPM with Case study
Implementation Of TPM with Case study
 
IRJET- Evaluating the Performance of Plant by Overall Equipment Effectiveness...
IRJET- Evaluating the Performance of Plant by Overall Equipment Effectiveness...IRJET- Evaluating the Performance of Plant by Overall Equipment Effectiveness...
IRJET- Evaluating the Performance of Plant by Overall Equipment Effectiveness...
 
Enhancement of the performance of an industry by the application of tqm concepts
Enhancement of the performance of an industry by the application of tqm conceptsEnhancement of the performance of an industry by the application of tqm concepts
Enhancement of the performance of an industry by the application of tqm concepts
 
Enhancement of the performance of an industry by the
Enhancement of the performance of an industry by theEnhancement of the performance of an industry by the
Enhancement of the performance of an industry by the
 
Phd literature review sample pdf
Phd literature review sample pdfPhd literature review sample pdf
Phd literature review sample pdf
 
Multi criteria Decision model (MCDM) for the evaluation of maintenance practi...
Multi criteria Decision model (MCDM) for the evaluation of maintenance practi...Multi criteria Decision model (MCDM) for the evaluation of maintenance practi...
Multi criteria Decision model (MCDM) for the evaluation of maintenance practi...
 
ARTICULO DE INVESTIGACION
ARTICULO DE INVESTIGACIONARTICULO DE INVESTIGACION
ARTICULO DE INVESTIGACION
 
IRJET- Effective Implementation of Planned Maintenance in a Gas Producing Pla...
IRJET- Effective Implementation of Planned Maintenance in a Gas Producing Pla...IRJET- Effective Implementation of Planned Maintenance in a Gas Producing Pla...
IRJET- Effective Implementation of Planned Maintenance in a Gas Producing Pla...
 
Failure Mode Effect Analysis and Total Productive Maintenance: A Review
Failure Mode Effect Analysis and Total Productive Maintenance: A ReviewFailure Mode Effect Analysis and Total Productive Maintenance: A Review
Failure Mode Effect Analysis and Total Productive Maintenance: A Review
 
Maintenance Leading and Lagging Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
Maintenance Leading and Lagging Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)Maintenance Leading and Lagging Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
Maintenance Leading and Lagging Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
 
18 implementation
18 implementation18 implementation
18 implementation
 
5.an integrated
5.an integrated5.an integrated
5.an integrated
 
Development Of An Effective Industrial Maintenance Practice For Plant Optimum...
Development Of An Effective Industrial Maintenance Practice For Plant Optimum...Development Of An Effective Industrial Maintenance Practice For Plant Optimum...
Development Of An Effective Industrial Maintenance Practice For Plant Optimum...
 
Overall Equipment Effectiveness in Construction Equipments
Overall Equipment Effectiveness in Construction EquipmentsOverall Equipment Effectiveness in Construction Equipments
Overall Equipment Effectiveness in Construction Equipments
 
Study of Total Productive Maintenance & It’s Implementation Approach in Steel...
Study of Total Productive Maintenance & It’s Implementation Approach in Steel...Study of Total Productive Maintenance & It’s Implementation Approach in Steel...
Study of Total Productive Maintenance & It’s Implementation Approach in Steel...
 
Reliability centered maintenance planning based on computer-aided fmea
Reliability centered maintenance planning based on computer-aided fmeaReliability centered maintenance planning based on computer-aided fmea
Reliability centered maintenance planning based on computer-aided fmea
 
OVERALL EQUIPMENT EFFECTIVENESS OF CRITICAL MACHINES IN MANUFACTURING INDUSTR...
OVERALL EQUIPMENT EFFECTIVENESS OF CRITICAL MACHINES IN MANUFACTURING INDUSTR...OVERALL EQUIPMENT EFFECTIVENESS OF CRITICAL MACHINES IN MANUFACTURING INDUSTR...
OVERALL EQUIPMENT EFFECTIVENESS OF CRITICAL MACHINES IN MANUFACTURING INDUSTR...
 
Ijetcas14 340
Ijetcas14 340Ijetcas14 340
Ijetcas14 340
 

More from eSAT Publishing House

Likely impacts of hudhud on the environment of visakhapatnam
Likely impacts of hudhud on the environment of visakhapatnamLikely impacts of hudhud on the environment of visakhapatnam
Likely impacts of hudhud on the environment of visakhapatnam
eSAT Publishing House
 
Impact of flood disaster in a drought prone area – case study of alampur vill...
Impact of flood disaster in a drought prone area – case study of alampur vill...Impact of flood disaster in a drought prone area – case study of alampur vill...
Impact of flood disaster in a drought prone area – case study of alampur vill...
eSAT Publishing House
 
Hudhud cyclone – a severe disaster in visakhapatnam
Hudhud cyclone – a severe disaster in visakhapatnamHudhud cyclone – a severe disaster in visakhapatnam
Hudhud cyclone – a severe disaster in visakhapatnam
eSAT Publishing House
 
Groundwater investigation using geophysical methods a case study of pydibhim...
Groundwater investigation using geophysical methods  a case study of pydibhim...Groundwater investigation using geophysical methods  a case study of pydibhim...
Groundwater investigation using geophysical methods a case study of pydibhim...
eSAT Publishing House
 
Flood related disasters concerned to urban flooding in bangalore, india
Flood related disasters concerned to urban flooding in bangalore, indiaFlood related disasters concerned to urban flooding in bangalore, india
Flood related disasters concerned to urban flooding in bangalore, india
eSAT Publishing House
 
Enhancing post disaster recovery by optimal infrastructure capacity building
Enhancing post disaster recovery by optimal infrastructure capacity buildingEnhancing post disaster recovery by optimal infrastructure capacity building
Enhancing post disaster recovery by optimal infrastructure capacity building
eSAT Publishing House
 
Effect of lintel and lintel band on the global performance of reinforced conc...
Effect of lintel and lintel band on the global performance of reinforced conc...Effect of lintel and lintel band on the global performance of reinforced conc...
Effect of lintel and lintel band on the global performance of reinforced conc...
eSAT Publishing House
 
Wind damage to trees in the gitam university campus at visakhapatnam by cyclo...
Wind damage to trees in the gitam university campus at visakhapatnam by cyclo...Wind damage to trees in the gitam university campus at visakhapatnam by cyclo...
Wind damage to trees in the gitam university campus at visakhapatnam by cyclo...
eSAT Publishing House
 
Wind damage to buildings, infrastrucuture and landscape elements along the be...
Wind damage to buildings, infrastrucuture and landscape elements along the be...Wind damage to buildings, infrastrucuture and landscape elements along the be...
Wind damage to buildings, infrastrucuture and landscape elements along the be...
eSAT Publishing House
 
Shear strength of rc deep beam panels – a review
Shear strength of rc deep beam panels – a reviewShear strength of rc deep beam panels – a review
Shear strength of rc deep beam panels – a review
eSAT Publishing House
 
Role of voluntary teams of professional engineers in dissater management – ex...
Role of voluntary teams of professional engineers in dissater management – ex...Role of voluntary teams of professional engineers in dissater management – ex...
Role of voluntary teams of professional engineers in dissater management – ex...
eSAT Publishing House
 
Risk analysis and environmental hazard management
Risk analysis and environmental hazard managementRisk analysis and environmental hazard management
Risk analysis and environmental hazard management
eSAT Publishing House
 
Review study on performance of seismically tested repaired shear walls
Review study on performance of seismically tested repaired shear wallsReview study on performance of seismically tested repaired shear walls
Review study on performance of seismically tested repaired shear walls
eSAT Publishing House
 
Monitoring and assessment of air quality with reference to dust particles (pm...
Monitoring and assessment of air quality with reference to dust particles (pm...Monitoring and assessment of air quality with reference to dust particles (pm...
Monitoring and assessment of air quality with reference to dust particles (pm...
eSAT Publishing House
 
Low cost wireless sensor networks and smartphone applications for disaster ma...
Low cost wireless sensor networks and smartphone applications for disaster ma...Low cost wireless sensor networks and smartphone applications for disaster ma...
Low cost wireless sensor networks and smartphone applications for disaster ma...
eSAT Publishing House
 
Coastal zones – seismic vulnerability an analysis from east coast of india
Coastal zones – seismic vulnerability an analysis from east coast of indiaCoastal zones – seismic vulnerability an analysis from east coast of india
Coastal zones – seismic vulnerability an analysis from east coast of india
eSAT Publishing House
 
Can fracture mechanics predict damage due disaster of structures
Can fracture mechanics predict damage due disaster of structuresCan fracture mechanics predict damage due disaster of structures
Can fracture mechanics predict damage due disaster of structures
eSAT Publishing House
 
Assessment of seismic susceptibility of rc buildings
Assessment of seismic susceptibility of rc buildingsAssessment of seismic susceptibility of rc buildings
Assessment of seismic susceptibility of rc buildings
eSAT Publishing House
 
A geophysical insight of earthquake occurred on 21 st may 2014 off paradip, b...
A geophysical insight of earthquake occurred on 21 st may 2014 off paradip, b...A geophysical insight of earthquake occurred on 21 st may 2014 off paradip, b...
A geophysical insight of earthquake occurred on 21 st may 2014 off paradip, b...
eSAT Publishing House
 
Effect of hudhud cyclone on the development of visakhapatnam as smart and gre...
Effect of hudhud cyclone on the development of visakhapatnam as smart and gre...Effect of hudhud cyclone on the development of visakhapatnam as smart and gre...
Effect of hudhud cyclone on the development of visakhapatnam as smart and gre...
eSAT Publishing House
 

More from eSAT Publishing House (20)

Likely impacts of hudhud on the environment of visakhapatnam
Likely impacts of hudhud on the environment of visakhapatnamLikely impacts of hudhud on the environment of visakhapatnam
Likely impacts of hudhud on the environment of visakhapatnam
 
Impact of flood disaster in a drought prone area – case study of alampur vill...
Impact of flood disaster in a drought prone area – case study of alampur vill...Impact of flood disaster in a drought prone area – case study of alampur vill...
Impact of flood disaster in a drought prone area – case study of alampur vill...
 
Hudhud cyclone – a severe disaster in visakhapatnam
Hudhud cyclone – a severe disaster in visakhapatnamHudhud cyclone – a severe disaster in visakhapatnam
Hudhud cyclone – a severe disaster in visakhapatnam
 
Groundwater investigation using geophysical methods a case study of pydibhim...
Groundwater investigation using geophysical methods  a case study of pydibhim...Groundwater investigation using geophysical methods  a case study of pydibhim...
Groundwater investigation using geophysical methods a case study of pydibhim...
 
Flood related disasters concerned to urban flooding in bangalore, india
Flood related disasters concerned to urban flooding in bangalore, indiaFlood related disasters concerned to urban flooding in bangalore, india
Flood related disasters concerned to urban flooding in bangalore, india
 
Enhancing post disaster recovery by optimal infrastructure capacity building
Enhancing post disaster recovery by optimal infrastructure capacity buildingEnhancing post disaster recovery by optimal infrastructure capacity building
Enhancing post disaster recovery by optimal infrastructure capacity building
 
Effect of lintel and lintel band on the global performance of reinforced conc...
Effect of lintel and lintel band on the global performance of reinforced conc...Effect of lintel and lintel band on the global performance of reinforced conc...
Effect of lintel and lintel band on the global performance of reinforced conc...
 
Wind damage to trees in the gitam university campus at visakhapatnam by cyclo...
Wind damage to trees in the gitam university campus at visakhapatnam by cyclo...Wind damage to trees in the gitam university campus at visakhapatnam by cyclo...
Wind damage to trees in the gitam university campus at visakhapatnam by cyclo...
 
Wind damage to buildings, infrastrucuture and landscape elements along the be...
Wind damage to buildings, infrastrucuture and landscape elements along the be...Wind damage to buildings, infrastrucuture and landscape elements along the be...
Wind damage to buildings, infrastrucuture and landscape elements along the be...
 
Shear strength of rc deep beam panels – a review
Shear strength of rc deep beam panels – a reviewShear strength of rc deep beam panels – a review
Shear strength of rc deep beam panels – a review
 
Role of voluntary teams of professional engineers in dissater management – ex...
Role of voluntary teams of professional engineers in dissater management – ex...Role of voluntary teams of professional engineers in dissater management – ex...
Role of voluntary teams of professional engineers in dissater management – ex...
 
Risk analysis and environmental hazard management
Risk analysis and environmental hazard managementRisk analysis and environmental hazard management
Risk analysis and environmental hazard management
 
Review study on performance of seismically tested repaired shear walls
Review study on performance of seismically tested repaired shear wallsReview study on performance of seismically tested repaired shear walls
Review study on performance of seismically tested repaired shear walls
 
Monitoring and assessment of air quality with reference to dust particles (pm...
Monitoring and assessment of air quality with reference to dust particles (pm...Monitoring and assessment of air quality with reference to dust particles (pm...
Monitoring and assessment of air quality with reference to dust particles (pm...
 
Low cost wireless sensor networks and smartphone applications for disaster ma...
Low cost wireless sensor networks and smartphone applications for disaster ma...Low cost wireless sensor networks and smartphone applications for disaster ma...
Low cost wireless sensor networks and smartphone applications for disaster ma...
 
Coastal zones – seismic vulnerability an analysis from east coast of india
Coastal zones – seismic vulnerability an analysis from east coast of indiaCoastal zones – seismic vulnerability an analysis from east coast of india
Coastal zones – seismic vulnerability an analysis from east coast of india
 
Can fracture mechanics predict damage due disaster of structures
Can fracture mechanics predict damage due disaster of structuresCan fracture mechanics predict damage due disaster of structures
Can fracture mechanics predict damage due disaster of structures
 
Assessment of seismic susceptibility of rc buildings
Assessment of seismic susceptibility of rc buildingsAssessment of seismic susceptibility of rc buildings
Assessment of seismic susceptibility of rc buildings
 
A geophysical insight of earthquake occurred on 21 st may 2014 off paradip, b...
A geophysical insight of earthquake occurred on 21 st may 2014 off paradip, b...A geophysical insight of earthquake occurred on 21 st may 2014 off paradip, b...
A geophysical insight of earthquake occurred on 21 st may 2014 off paradip, b...
 
Effect of hudhud cyclone on the development of visakhapatnam as smart and gre...
Effect of hudhud cyclone on the development of visakhapatnam as smart and gre...Effect of hudhud cyclone on the development of visakhapatnam as smart and gre...
Effect of hudhud cyclone on the development of visakhapatnam as smart and gre...
 

Recently uploaded

ML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptx
ML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptxML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptx
ML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptx
Vijay Dialani, PhD
 
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptxInvestor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
AmarGB2
 
一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
bakpo1
 
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary AttacksImmunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
gerogepatton
 
Architectural Portfolio Sean Lockwood
Architectural Portfolio Sean LockwoodArchitectural Portfolio Sean Lockwood
Architectural Portfolio Sean Lockwood
seandesed
 
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptxFundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
manasideore6
 
Railway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdf
Railway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdfRailway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdf
Railway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdf
TeeVichai
 
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
thanhdowork
 
weather web application report.pdf
weather web application report.pdfweather web application report.pdf
weather web application report.pdf
Pratik Pawar
 
AP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specific
AP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specificAP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specific
AP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specific
BrazilAccount1
 
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdfWater Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation & Control
 
CFD Simulation of By-pass Flow in a HRSG module by R&R Consult.pptx
CFD Simulation of By-pass Flow in a HRSG module by R&R Consult.pptxCFD Simulation of By-pass Flow in a HRSG module by R&R Consult.pptx
CFD Simulation of By-pass Flow in a HRSG module by R&R Consult.pptx
R&R Consult
 
Student information management system project report ii.pdf
Student information management system project report ii.pdfStudent information management system project report ii.pdf
Student information management system project report ii.pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
road safety engineering r s e unit 3.pdf
road safety engineering  r s e unit 3.pdfroad safety engineering  r s e unit 3.pdf
road safety engineering r s e unit 3.pdf
VENKATESHvenky89705
 
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
MdTanvirMahtab2
 
Top 10 Oil and Gas Projects in Saudi Arabia 2024.pdf
Top 10 Oil and Gas Projects in Saudi Arabia 2024.pdfTop 10 Oil and Gas Projects in Saudi Arabia 2024.pdf
Top 10 Oil and Gas Projects in Saudi Arabia 2024.pdf
Teleport Manpower Consultant
 
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdfEnglish lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
BrazilAccount1
 
Standard Reomte Control Interface - Neometrix
Standard Reomte Control Interface - NeometrixStandard Reomte Control Interface - Neometrix
Standard Reomte Control Interface - Neometrix
Neometrix_Engineering_Pvt_Ltd
 
DESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docx
DESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docxDESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docx
DESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docx
FluxPrime1
 
block diagram and signal flow graph representation
block diagram and signal flow graph representationblock diagram and signal flow graph representation
block diagram and signal flow graph representation
Divya Somashekar
 

Recently uploaded (20)

ML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptx
ML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptxML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptx
ML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptx
 
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptxInvestor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
 
一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(SFU毕业证)西蒙菲莎大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
 
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary AttacksImmunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
 
Architectural Portfolio Sean Lockwood
Architectural Portfolio Sean LockwoodArchitectural Portfolio Sean Lockwood
Architectural Portfolio Sean Lockwood
 
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptxFundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
 
Railway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdf
Railway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdfRailway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdf
Railway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdf
 
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
 
weather web application report.pdf
weather web application report.pdfweather web application report.pdf
weather web application report.pdf
 
AP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specific
AP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specificAP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specific
AP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specific
 
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdfWater Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
 
CFD Simulation of By-pass Flow in a HRSG module by R&R Consult.pptx
CFD Simulation of By-pass Flow in a HRSG module by R&R Consult.pptxCFD Simulation of By-pass Flow in a HRSG module by R&R Consult.pptx
CFD Simulation of By-pass Flow in a HRSG module by R&R Consult.pptx
 
Student information management system project report ii.pdf
Student information management system project report ii.pdfStudent information management system project report ii.pdf
Student information management system project report ii.pdf
 
road safety engineering r s e unit 3.pdf
road safety engineering  r s e unit 3.pdfroad safety engineering  r s e unit 3.pdf
road safety engineering r s e unit 3.pdf
 
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
 
Top 10 Oil and Gas Projects in Saudi Arabia 2024.pdf
Top 10 Oil and Gas Projects in Saudi Arabia 2024.pdfTop 10 Oil and Gas Projects in Saudi Arabia 2024.pdf
Top 10 Oil and Gas Projects in Saudi Arabia 2024.pdf
 
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdfEnglish lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
 
Standard Reomte Control Interface - Neometrix
Standard Reomte Control Interface - NeometrixStandard Reomte Control Interface - Neometrix
Standard Reomte Control Interface - Neometrix
 
DESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docx
DESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docxDESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docx
DESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docx
 
block diagram and signal flow graph representation
block diagram and signal flow graph representationblock diagram and signal flow graph representation
block diagram and signal flow graph representation
 

Maintenance performance metrics for manufacturing industry

  • 1. IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163 __________________________________________________________________________________________ Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 136 MAINTENANCE PERFORMANCE METRICS FOR MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY Jitendra Kumar1 , V.K. Soni2 , Geeta Agnihotri3 1 PhD Scholar, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, MANIT, Bhopal, jitendra.me@gmail.com 2 Asst. Professor, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, MANIT, Bhopal, soni_vk@rediffmail.com 3 Professor, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, MANIT, Bhopal, dr.gagnihotri@gmail.com Abstract The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate various maintenance performance indicators (MPIs) within the perspective of maintenance metrics conducted by the managerial personnel for achieving the specified production target. In this paper, a conceptual framework has been developed, that provides guideline for choosing maintenance performance metrics for a typical manufacturing industry. It seeks to align maintenance objective with the performance indicators and provides a link between the two. Operations and maintenance of manufacturing system are of great economic importance. The review of literature on maintenance performance indicators and their measurement has been summarized under the five categories of metrics; functional metrics, equipment performance metrics, maintenance process metrics, periodicity metrics and OEE metrics. The review indicates that quantitative metrics for measuring maintenance performance are lacking. To address this gap, maintenance performance metrics has been proposed. Keywords: Maintenance performance indicators, Performance metrics, Reactive Maintenance, Periodic maintenance, OEE ---------------------------------------------------------------------***---------------------------------------------------------------------- 1. INTRODUCTION Effective maintenance is critical to many operations. It extends equipment life, improves equipment availability and retains equipment in proper condition without delay of production schedules. The Maintenance Engineering Society of Australia (MESA) indicates that maintenance is about achieving the required asset capabilities within an economic or business context (MESA, 1995). They define maintenance as the engineering decision and associated actions, necessary and sufficient for optimization of specified equipment „capability‟. The term “capability” indicates the ability to perform a specified function within a range of performance levels that may relate to capacity, rate, quality and responsiveness (Tsang, 1998). The four major factors (Karim, 2011) that cause defects in the product quality are human negligence, bad quality of raw material, machine that need maintenance and work procedure. After analysis it has been concluded that the machine maintenance from time to time is an important issue in quality control. To optimize and reduce defects & occurring of machine damage, the plant managers should focus on the maintenance of machinery to ensure quality production at a satisfactory level. A number of methods have been expressed by Antero Ollila and Markku (1999) like reactive maintenance, preventive maintenance, predictive maintenance and proactive maintenance. Reactive maintenance can be minimized by using methods like JIT (Just-In-Time), TQM (Total Quality Maintenance) to repair the machine & to reduce the defects in produced products. Further, for achieving zero defects, JIT and TQM method can be used in conjunction with the DPM (Downtime Due to Preventive Maintenance) methods. While the methods for preventive maintenance is a routine maintenance that has been set. Campbell (1995) proposed the implementation of two highly successful methods for the continuous improvement – RCM (Reliability centered Maintenance) and TPM (Total Productive Maintenance). Pintelon and Van Wassenhove (1992) have provided a maintenance management tool to evaluate maintenance performance. The tool consists of a control board and a set of reports to analyze certain ratios. This tool is applied in five different domains falling under the control of the maintenance manager: cost/budget, equipment performance, personnel performance, material management and work order control. The outline of this article is as follows. Section 2 treats the possibility of performance metrics in achieving higher improvement. Section 3 gives an overview of the maintenance performance metrics and explains the importance of metrics. Section 4 describes the different maintenance performance metrics including functional metrics, equipment performance metrics, maintenance process metrics, periodicity metrics and
  • 2. IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163 __________________________________________________________________________________________ Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 137 OEE metrics. Conclusion and future research scope are formulated in section 5. 2. PERFORMANCE METRICS Performance metric is the fundamental instrument of the management which provides essential link between strategies, execution and ultimate value creation. Performance metric is a standard definition of a measurable quantity that indicates some aspect of performance and it is often viewed as being part of the infrastructure or environment in which manufacturing operation must operate. In other words a metric is nothing more than a standard measure to assess the performance in a particular area. Manufacturing and management consultant Oliver Wight almost 40 years ago offered the often repeated maxim, “you get what you inspect, not what you expect”. All type of firms, activity, and worker needs metrics to evaluate fundamental activities of measuring, educating, and directing the gap for improvement. For the continuous improvement of plant, it is very essential to evaluate the present status of maintenance performance with respect to the fundamental, strategic and maintenance objectives defined by the corporate, plant and maintenance management. While making maintenance objectives, performance indicators and key performance indicators can be defined (Liyange, 2003) in the manner of either measure past or predict future performance. Operational performance indicators related to the maintenance are referred to as maintenance performance indicators (MPIs). MPIs are evaluated against goals coupled with the objectives by the company and the plant managers, respectively. Familiar maintenance metrics can be developed for measuring performance along the dimension of maintenance function, process, and equipment at the plant level maintenance activities which is untouched by the researcher. 3. MAINTENANCE PERFORMANCE METRICS The European standard for maintenance key performance indicators (EN: 15341, 2007) provides three main categories of indicators namely economic indicators, technical indicators and organizational indicators. A hierarchical manner of key figures of industrial maintenance has been developed by Komonen (2002) like external, internal and intermediate objective variable including the business-oriented indicators. The managerial aim of indicators is to guide plant operations and maintenance performance specifically. The different category of measure shows different areas of interest in maintenance performance in both literature and practice. The importance of maintenance performance measurements have extensively been discussed by many authors (Arts 1998; Tsang 1999; Visser 2003; Weber 2006; Parida 2007). Maintenance managers require performance information to monitor and control maintenance processes and results, which provide indication towards improvement. The measure of maintenance effectiveness is defined in terms of maintenance performance indicators (MPIs) for the plant. While, metrics are needed to evaluate the effectiveness of maintenance strategies and decisions regarding designing a new maintenance policy or redesigning an existing one. Such metrics should be simple to use to facilitate their application in today‟s changeable and reconfigurable manufacturing environment (wiendahl, 2007). In other words, there should be a strong dependency between maintenance performance metrics (MPMs) and the MPIs. Based on data analysis, this dependency should be reflected in a strong correlation between the MPMs and MPIs. Parida and Kumar (2006) identified the various issues and challenges associated with development and implementation of a maintenance performance measurement (MPM) system. The study finds that for successful implementation of MPM, all employees should be involved and all relevant issues need to be considered. A huge numbers of indicators are used in the industrial maintenance but literature does not provide any methodology for selection of key performance indicators and usually it has been derived by the need and experience felt by the industry to industry. The similar type of indicators can be grouped within a performance metrics which can evaluate the performance of maintenance and such type of metrics is a great challenge for the researcher. In consequence a similar attempt has been made to develop maintenance performance metrics in the next section. 4. DEVELOPING A BASIS OF MAINTENANCE PERFORMANCE METRICS As explained in previous section it is necessary to identify the needs of advance in order to maintain the normal functioning of production systems. Further the analysis of maintenance function is needed to implement better maintenance policy. For the same the performance of maintenance must be analyzed through performance indicators. The similar type of indicators can be grouped within a metrics for measuring maintenance performance according to the maintenance function. Moya (2004) developed a system composed of indicators to control the setting up predictive maintenance programs which should facilitate the early detection of anomalies which can appear during setting up to avoid the failure of maintenance program. The procedure for detailed metrics development is shown as follows: (A). Metrics Collection and Definition: A comprehensive list of maintenance performance indicators is put together through extensive literature review including web based information sources. Each indicator is defined within their metric so that it‟s meaning and measures are clearly understood. (B). Metrics Evaluation and Categorization: Each metric is evaluated based on its characteristics and maintenance work relevant to it, such as maintenance objective, strategies, process, and maintenance cost is involved.
  • 3. IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163 __________________________________________________________________________________________ Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 138 (C). Relevancy and Repetition Check: Each category is reviewed to ensure that all the metrics are relevant. Redundant ones are eliminated. 4.1 FUNCTIONAL METRICS To ensure that plant operates at the required condition while meeting its production targets at an optimal cost, maintenance management has to make conscious decisions regarding the maintenance objective and strategies that need to be pursued. It is evident that (Kelly 1989; MESA 1995; Tsang 1999; Visser 2003), maintenance objectives are related to attainment of production target (through high equipment availability) at required quality within the constraints of the system condition and safety, utilizing optimum available maintenance resources so that the plant achieves its design life, the safety standard are met, the energy use and raw material consumption are optimized among the other factors (Dekker, 1996). Maintenance objective has been summarized under the following five headings (as shown in Fig. 1): ensuring the functionality of plant so that plant achieves its design life within the environmental safety and cost effectiveness with effective use of resources. It is assumed that the maintenance objectives pursued at a given plant influences the kind of performance metrics or indicators used. Once the maintenance objectives are outlined, maintenance strategy formulation is necessary to decide which type of maintenance needs to be done, when to do it and how often it can be done. According to Pintelon (2006) maintenance decision making can be broadly explained in terms of maintenance action, maintenance policies and maintenance concepts. Maintenance policies are the rules or set of rules describing the triggering mechanism for the different maintenance actions. Example of these policies are Failure based maintenance (FBM), use based or time based maintenance (UBM/TBM), condition based maintenance (CBM), design out maintenance (DOM) (Madu, 2000; Pintelon, 2002; savsar, 2006). When maintenance objectives and strategies have been established, the success of functional metrics is dependent on the maintenance work management cycle, as outlined by Campbell (1995), consists of work identification, planning, scheduling, execution and closing the job. At the heart of the maintenance, functions are work planning and scheduling, which defines what gets done and when. Organizational strategies Manufacturing Strategies Maintenance Objective Be able to operate as & when required Operate efficiently, accurately at the required level Operate without unscheduled stoppage Operate within safety & environmental limit 1. Operate at minimum maintenance cost 2. Operate at designed speed 3. Product Quality 4. Reliability Fig. 1 Maintenance Objective for Maintenance Department
  • 4. IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163 __________________________________________________________________________________________ Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 139 4.2 EQUIPMENT PERFORMANCE METRICS The role of the equipment condition in controlling quality and quantity is well known in the manufacturing industry (Daya, 1995). Equipment must be maintained in top operating conditions through adequate maintenance activities. From the analysis of the manufacturing and maintenance environment, it was found that equipment breakdown is the most important cause of production disruption among other causes of disruptions (quality, feedstock, logistics etc). Saxena (2008) developed algorithmic performance metrics to plan maintenance in advance to reduce downtime and maximize availability. Ollila and Malmipuro (1999) observed that the equipment availability has a major impact on efficiency and quality of production. An integrated maintenance model using statistical process control for monitoring quality of product has been developed by Noorossana (2011) and found that the quality of product is synonymous to monitoring status of equipment and as the result an out-of-control signal would indicate deterioration of the equipment. Huang et al. (2006) considered a further extension using a preventive maintenance (PM) that either brings the system to the „as good as new‟ condition or the system will fail immediately because of faulty maintenance. Equipment performance (Rosqvist et al., 2009) can be analyzed through proactivity of maintenance task of equipment (Preventive tasks and actions/Maintenance tasks), equipment reliability (Number of functional failures/Operational cycles of equipment) and equipment availability (Downtime/Operational period of equipment). Planning of preventive maintenance of technical system is assessed by the RCM (Reliability centered maintenance) analysis and it is gaining a solid reputation for successful method (Selvik, 2011). The analysis of RCM includes all historical records such as the list of functionality significant items (FSIA), the failure mode and effect analysis (FMEA), case based reasoning (CBR) and the basic reliability data (Cheng et al., 2008). 4.3 MAINTENANCE PROCESS METRICS Marquez (2006) have defined maintenance process as the series of action at different stages which need to follow. The maintenance Process include assessing the feasibility and effort required to fulfill the need of maintenance for system change and scoping the work accordingly; planning, designing and implementing the changes to the system and accompanying documentation; testing the amended system at the unit, system, integration, and acceptance levels; and transitioning the amended system into production with minimal disruption of normal production level. At large the assessment of maintenance process has two parts effective analysis and efficiency analysis. The first part helps to detect the most important problems and locate their potential solution. The second part identifies the suitable procedure. The researcher define eight phases to accomplish this comprehensive assessment as: (1) determination of current factory performance (2) quality and downtime (3) effectiveness analysis of alternative solution (4) efficiency analysis of maintenance procedure (5) plan action (6) implementing action and gathering of data (7) monitoring action and processing data (8) adaption of plans. Lam (2007) introduced a special monotone process applied to a replacement model in which the operating times of system from a non-increasing geometric process and consecutive repair times constitute a non-decreasing geometric process. Chen (2010) identified Geometric process modeling as a useful tool to study repairable deteriorating system in maintenance problems. While maintenance Error Decision Aid (MEDA) process was developed (Rankin, 2000) based on the philosophy that maintenance technician do not make errors on the purpose, that errors result from a series of related contributing factors, and that these factors are largely under management control and, therefore, can be changed. The process was tested by the employees of airline and one repair centre. Grall (2010) discussed maintenance policies for stochastically deteriorating systems which are subject to sudden change in their degradation processes. From a maintenance decision making point of view two condition based maintenance policies are considered and compared through a numerical example and show that the time distribution of the change of deterioration rate and the difference between the two possible deterioration rates strongly influence the choice of the best decision rule structure. 4.3.1 PLANNED MAINTENANCE PROCESS Planned Maintenance has two loops: Planning, scheduling, Execution and Follow up make up the first loop while second loop consists of work identification and performance analysis elements. Planned maintenance process is measured by schedule compliance i.e. the percentage of work orders completed during the scheduled period before the late finish or required by date. World class maintenance should achieve more than 90% during execution. An integrated model developed by Daya (2002) for the joint determination of economic production quantity and preventive maintenance (PM) level for an imperfect process having a general deterioration distribution with increasing hazard rate. 4.3.2 ASSET RELIABILITY PROCESS The analysis of typical asset could include costs of planning, research and development, production, operation, maintenance and disposal. So a life cycle cost analysis calculates the cost of an asset for its entire life span whereas reliability analysis such as failure rate cost of spares, repair times, and component costs. In many maintenance problems, it is convenient to assume that repairs are either equivalent or less beneficial than the replacement and the system are brought back into an as good as new state after each repair and for the same Kallen (2011) used to model the effect of imperfect maintenance through the use of superposition of renewal process. This model can be
  • 5. IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163 __________________________________________________________________________________________ Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 140 extensively used to determine an approximate probability distribution of the time between repairs. Failed component are not repaired until a predefined fraction of the total number has failed. 4.4 PERIODICITY METRICS The planned maintenance process is targeted to achieve required performance asset performance. For the better periodic maintenance activities, must be a better planning and scheduling. As planning develops procedure for maintenance work while scheduling evaluates the availability of all resources required for maintenance work “due” in a specified time frame. Maintenance strategy is a structured combination of two maintenance action (Dekker, 1996) corrective and preventive which describes the events (e.g. failure, machine condition, etc.) and the type of action they trigger (i.e. inspection, repair, maintenance or replacement). Corrective maintenance which includes all actions performed as a result of a failure to restore an item to a specified working condition, while preventive maintenance includes all actions performed on operating equipment to restore them to a better condition. Meselhy (2010) introduced two independent source of periodicity due to maintenance programs; the failure repair and pre-planned Preventive maintenance. Therefore, for the given maintenance policy parameter repair level (RL), periodicity extent expressed by the level of PM (PMLi), preventive maintenance frequency (PMFi) and the machine failure rate E (λ), the total system periodicity can be expressed as: Periodicity = E(λ) 2 RL − 1 + PMFi 2 PMLi − 1 n i=1 The above calculated periodicity is a measure of the relative ability of the maintenance strategy to resets the machine‟s functionality. We may conclude that equipment performance are measured on a shorter time interval (daily and weekly basis), probably to facilitate quicker corrective actions. Rosqvist et al. (2009) discussed Periodic preventive maintenance task related to preventive maintenance strategies which are either condition- based (periodic functional testing, periodic inspection, condition monitoring, operation supervision) or predetermined (periodic restoration, periodic servicing, Modification work). 4.5 OEE METRICS The total productive maintenance (TPM) concept launched by Nakajima (1988) provides a quantitative metric called Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) for measuring productivity of manufacturing equipments. OEE metric and its variants came out as the most popular equipment performance indicator capable of measuring different production losses, of which maintenance related losses are important. The important maintenance indicators in the OEE have shown in the fig 2. OEE Availability Rate Performance Rate Quality Rate Planned Downtime Unplanned Downtime 1. Preventive Maintenance time 2. No. f preventive Maintenance 1. Failure (MTBF) 2. Failure Frequency 3. Mean Time To Repair Fig. 2 Maintenance Indicator in the OEE Metrics
  • 6. IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163 __________________________________________________________________________________________ Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 141 The OEE concept has become increasingly popular and has been widely used as a quantitative tool essential for measurement equipments‟ performance in industries (Huang 2003; Muchiri 2008). OEE = Availability A X Performance P X Quality (Q) A = calender time − Downtime calender time X 100 P = Processed amount operating time X100 Q = processed amount − Defective amount processed amount X100 This metric has become widely accepted as a quantitative tool essential for measurement of productivity in manufacturing operations (Samuel et al., 2002). One of the most critical success factors influencing survival, profitability, and competitive advantage of manufacturing organization is to select proper maintenance policy. OEE is mostly used in one of the policies, i.e. total productive maintenance and it helps in decision making (Shahin, 2011) to improve the overall performance of organizations. Using OEE metrics and establishing a disciplined reporting system help an organization to focus on the parameters critical to its success. Analyzing OEE categories can reveal the greatest limits to success. CONCLUSIONS In this paper, a conceptual framework has been developed that provide the overview of maintenance performance metrics aligning various maintenance performance indicators according to the maintenance objective of the plant. The maintenance performance metrics are summarized under the five categories: functional metrics, equipment performance metrics, maintenance process metrics, periodicity metrics and OEE metrics. The aim is to ensure that the key indicators must be measured within the metrics to evaluate the maintenance performance. This research demonstrates that the performance indicators can be grouped within a metric so that the maintenance performance analysis will be easy to review. Further research work is recommended on the maintenance diagnostic metrics and maintenance cost metrics which plays key role in the operation and maintenance department to evaluate the performance and further improvement. Since the availability of maintenance metrics may not necessarily guarantee low maintenance cost, hence a maintenance cost metrics may be derived for the low cost repair, replacement and maintenance in practice. REFERENCES [1] Arts, R.H.P.M., Knapp, G.M., Mann, L. (1998), “Some aspects of measuring maintenance performance in process industry”, Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 4 (1), 6–11. [2] Campbell J. D., Uptime. (1995), “Strategies in excellence in maintenance management”, Portland: Productivity Press; 1995. [3] Chen J. et al. (2010), “Bayesian computation for geometric process in maintenance problem”, Mathematics and computers in simulation, 81:771-781. [4] Cheng et al. (2008), “A framework for intelligent reliability centered maintenance analysis”, Reliability engineering and system safety 93:784-792. [5] Christer AH, Wang W, Sharp JM., (1997), “A state space condition monitoring model for furnace erosion prediction and replacement”, European Journal of Operation Research, 101:1-14. [6] Daya, B., Duffuaa, S., (1995), “Maintenance and quality: The missing link”, Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 1 (1), 20–26. [7] Dekker, R., (1996), “Application of maintenance optimization models: a review and analysis”, Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 51, 229–240. [8] EN: 15341, (2007), “Maintenance Key Performance Indicators”, European Committee for Standardization (CEN), Brussels, Belgium. [9] Grall, A., et al. (2010) “assessment of a maintenance model for a multi-deteriorating mode system”, Reliability Engineering and system safety, 95:1244- 1254. [10] Kallen, MJ., (2011) “Modeling imperfect maintenance and the reliability of complex system using superposed renewal processes”, Reliability Engineering and system safety, 96: 636-641. [11] Karim, K. and Talib, A., (2011), “total productive maintenance application to reduce Defects of product”, Journal of applied science research, 7(1):11-17. [12] Kelly, A., 1989. Maintenance and its Management. Conference communication London. [13] Komonen, K., (2002) “A cost model of industrial maintenance for profitability analysis and benchmarking”, International Journal of Production Economics, 79, 15-31. [14] Lam, Y., (1991) “An optimal repairable replacement model for deteriorating systems”, J. Appl. Prob., 28: 843–851. [15] Lam, Y., (2007) “A geometric process maintenance model with preventive repair”, European Journal of Operational Research, 182:806-819. [16] Liyange JP, Kumar U., (2003) “Towards a value based view on operations and maintenance performance management” Journal of Quality & Maintenance Engineering, (9): 333-350.
  • 7. IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology ISSN: 2319-1163 __________________________________________________________________________________________ Volume: 02 Issue: 02 | Feb-2013, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 142 [17] Lupinucci M, Perej J, Davila G., (2000) “Improving sheet metal quality and product throughput with Bently‟s Machinery Management system”, orbit. Bently Nevada; 21 (3), 37-41. [18] Madu, C., (2000) “Competing through maintenance strategies”, International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, 17 (9), 937–948. [19] Marquez A.C., and Gupta, J.N.D., (2006) “contemporary maintenance management: process, framework and supporting pillars” Omega 34:313-326. [20] Meselhy, K.T., et al. (2010) “A periodicity metric for assessing maintenance strategies”, CIRP Journal of Manufacturing Science and Technology. (3), 135-141. [21] MESA, (1995) “Maintenance Engineering Society of Australia capability Assurance: A Generic Model of Maintenance”, Maintenance Engineering Society of Australia (MESA), Australia. [22] Muchiri, P.N., Pintelon, L., (2008), “Performance measurement using overall equipment effectiveness (OEE): Literature review and practical application”, International Journal of Production Research, 46 (13), 3517–3535. [23] Nakajima, S., (1988), “Introduction to TPM: Total Productive Maintenance”, Productivity Press, Cambridge, MA. [24] Ollila, A., M. dan Malmipuro, (1999), “Maintenance Has a Role in Quality”, The TQM Magazine, 11(1): 17- 22. [25] Pintelon LM, Van Wassenhove (1992) “A maintenance management tool”, Omega; 18(1):59-70. [26] Parida, A., Chattopadhyay, G., (2007), “Development of a multi-criteria hierarchical framework for maintenance performance measurement (MPM)”, Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 13 (3), 241–258. [27] Pintelon, L., VanPuyvelde, F., (2006), “Maintenance Decision Making”, Leuven, Belgium, Acco. [28] Rosqvist, T. et al., (2009) “Value-driven maintenance planning for a production plant”, Reliability Engineering and system safety 94: 97-110. [29] Savsar, M., (2006), “Effects of maintenance policies on the productivity of flexible manufacturing cells”, Omega International Journal of management Science, 34, 274– 282. [30] Shahin, A., (2011), “Developing Decision making grid for maintenance policy making based on estimated range of OEE”, Modern applied science, 5 (6) [31] Tsang, A.H.C., (1998), “A strategic approach to managing maintenance performance”, Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 4 (2), 87–94 (8). [32] Tsang, A.H.C., (1999), “Measuring maintenance performance: a holistic approach”, International Journal of Operations and Production management 19 (7), 691– 715. [33] Tsang, A.H.C., (1998), “A strategic approach to managing maintenance performance”, Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 4 (2), 87-94 (8). [34] Villar JM, Masson LO, Gomes JA., (2003) “Proactive maintenance – A successful history”, orbit, Bently Nevada; 21(3):33-41. [35] Visser, J.K., Pretorious, M.W., (2003), “The development of a performance measurement system for maintenance, SA Journal of Industrial Engineering, 14 (1), 83–97. [36] Wiendahl, H.P., et al. (2007), “changeable Manufacturing- Classification, design and operation", CIRP Annals-Manufacturing Technology, 56 (2), 783- 809. [37] Weber, A., Thomas, R., (2006), “Key Performance Indicators: Measuring & Managing the Maintenance Function”, Ivara Corporation. BIOGRAPHIES: Jitendra Kumar holds a Bachelor‟s Degree in Mechanical Engineering and M. Tech in Industrial Design from LNCT, Bhopal. Presently, he is pursuing PhD in the Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, M.A.National Institute of Technology, Bhopal. His main research area is Industrial Engineering & Management. Jitendra Kumar is the corresponding author and can be contacted at: jitendra.me@gmail.com