This is the genre research and textual analysis for the films Schindler's List and Saving Private Ryan for our main task, these films were chosen as they are part of the Drama genre that our film opening will be in.

1. Genre Research
By Matthew Haddock

2. Our Genre: Drama
• We have chosen the genre of drama, and so
we have researched the introductions to three
films in the drama genre.
• These three films are Schindler’s List,

3. Schindler’s List: Narrative
• The opening to Schindler’s List shows a Jewish
prayer ceremony, candles are lit and a Jewish
family recites a prayer, then the room is
empty, and the camera focuses on the candles
as they melt, the title “Schindler’s List”
appears between two candles, the scene
gradually loses colour and goes black and
white as the candles burn out.

4. Schindler’s List: Mise-En-Scene And
Props

5. Schindler’s List: Mise-En-Scene And
Props Analysis
• The setting is a small kitchen in the house of a Jewish
family, the candles and drinks are part of a Jewish prayer
ceremony and make the film’s connection to Judaism and
the Holocaust immediately clear to the audience.
• The wooden simple furniture are Germanic and would be
popular in homes in the early 20th century, this is a clear
indicator of the film being set in Germany during World
War II.
• From this we can learn that it is important to convey the
time and setting with the furniture used, as our film is set
in modern day we will use contemporary furniture,
however we will not use modern features that could
become dated such as specific smartphones.

6. Schindler’s List: Editing And Shots

7. Schindler’s List: Editing And Shots
Analysis
• The first shots are close-ups of a hand lighting a candle in the dark, this provokes intrigue in the viewer as, lacking
context, the audience tries to figure out what this relates to, the symbolism is that of the Jewish faith being forced
underground by the Nazis, their prayers being held in the dark, however this is not immediately obvious.
• From this we can learn that a strange, seemingly abstract first shot would make our audience interested in our
film, as we are presenting them with a problem that they will want a logical answer to, and this answer will be
revealed as they watch the rest of the opening titles.
• The next shots show a Jewish family in natural mid-day lighting taking part in a prayer ceremony,, the first a wide
shot of the whole family of 6 people, the next a one shot of a young boy in the family, the change from dark to
light showing a contrast between openly practiced Judaism and the clandestine underground form it was forced
into by the Nazis, it also shows a variety of visuals to the audience and assures them the entire film will not take
place in the dark.
• This tells us that contrast is important, so we could have two subsequent shots that have a vastly different visual
language, be it light or dark, cluttered or minimalist, this would be a dynamic and interesting concept to make our
film look visually rich and entertaining.
• The family is faded out of the scene in the next shot, leaving only the room and props, this holds the audience’s
attention as it is a rare moment in the film that shows an artificial, non-naturalistic editing style, this is jarring and
this break from the film’s style draws attention to the visual symbolism of the Jewish people being killed and
forced into hiding by the Nazis in the holocaust.
• This shows us that the audience’s suspension of disbelief can be controlled through editing, from this we can
decide whether we want a completely naturalistic editing style, one that is more stylised, or employ both for a
disorienting contrast.
• Finally, the last shots show the two candles burning out as the colour gradually fades from the scene, the title
“Schindler’s List” appears between the two candles, and the next shot focuses on only one of the candles, as it
burns out, leaving the purple flame as the last object in the scene that is not in black and white, symbolising the
millions of Jews that had their lives snuffed out in the Holocaust.
• From this we can learn that colour plays an important visual and symbolic role in film, we could apply colour filters
to reflect the mood of the whole film or change them to fit the mood of different scenes.

8. Schindler’s List: Sound Used And
Analysis
• The first sounds are that of a match being struck and candles burning,
these are normally not sounds that are given special attention in films,
rather fading into the background, however they are the focus here to
reflect the hushed nature of Judaism in Germany in the Second World
War.
• For these to be recorded a candle being lit would have had to be recorded
with a very close microphone, this tells us that we can employ very small,
usually ignored sounds to amplify an atmosphere of silence by recording
them with a close microphone and playing them in quiet, intense scenes.
• The next sound lasts throughout the rest of the opening titles, it is the
recitation of a traditional Jewish prayer by an old Orthodox Jewish man,
this exemplifies the traditional Jewish values that the Nazis aimed to
destroy.
• From this we can understand that by using speech in other languages and
accents we can symbolically represent cultural values and ideals, for
example an upper-class Received Pronunciation accent would be
associated with wealth and tradition, this is an example of Barthe’s
cultural code.

9. Researching Roland Barthes And The
Five Codes Of Narrative

10. Roland Barthe’s 5 Codes Of Narrative
• Proairetic Code: This dictates that any action that is shown to begin
must be completed, and that suspense can be created by leaving
actions without a conclusion for an extended period of time or
indefinitely.
• Hermeneutic Code: This is a way to create suspense by leaving
questions unanswered for the audience to wonder about.
• Connotative Code: This dictates that the sequential thoughts of a
character build up to create a fleshed-out characterisation.
• Cultural Code: This is the use of plot elements that take advantage
of things that the audience already knows, communicating without
explaining, as the audience is aware of the connotations of what is
being shown.
• Symbolic Code: This is the use of binary opposites in reinforcing a
theme, comparing and contrasting images and ideas.

11. Saving Private Ryan: Scene Analysis
• The first shot is of the film’s titles and credits being
listed in white text over a black background, this
emphasises the solemn nature of the following scene,
this uses Barthe’s Cultural Code as the audience will be
familiar with the black and white plain text that is
commonly employed at funerals, and this links to the
cemetery setting. From this we can understand that a
reverent mood can be conveyed through the use of
slow and monochrome text titles, this can be applied
to the film we are making as the mood we are trying to
convey is a somewhat melancholy one,

12. • The next shot shows a United States Of America flag waving in the wind,
its colour washed out, this also uses Barthe’s Cultural Code, in that the
film is mainly about the events during the Second World War, the washed-
out colour symbolising the passage of time since the War, this would make
the audience understand that this film is exploring the events of the past
from an American perspective, this tells us that flags can be used to
communicate the national identity of a film, however our film will not be
set in a specific country, so this will not be used in ours.
• The following shot is a tracking shot of the back of the elderly man's legs
as he walks down the path towards the ceremony, the camera follows his
pace and pans up to show only his head and shoulders from behind, while
still keeping up with him. The effect on the audience here is one that first
communicates motion by showing the legs of the elderly man as he walks,
and then focuses primarily on his character by showing the back of his
head, this also reveals his grey hair, showing his age. This tells us that not
only can panning be used effectively in conjunction with tracking, but that
panning can be used to reveal aspects of a character, while our character
is the main focus of the film, his appearance is not something we intend to
withhold and reveal, so we will not use this aspect in our film.

13. • The next shot is a tracking shot, facing towards the elderly man's family, an adult
man and woman, an elderly woman and three young women, the camera moves
away from them at the same pace that they walk towards it, following the elderly
man. This makes it clear to the audience that the man has lived an eventful life
and raised a family, this also shows him as a respected man, as his family are going
with him to visit the military cemetery, a task that would not be very enjoyable,
but shows that they understand him and will provide him with support. This shot
teaches us that many things about a character can be inferred from their relation
to other characters, another example of Barthe's Cultural Code, we will employ
this in our film by showing the main character's loneliness through a photograph
of an absent love interest.
• The next two shots show the adult man of the family about to take a picture, the
camera facing towards his face and continuing the tracking pace, the next shot is
from behind the family and shows the adult woman, implied to be his wife,
shaking her head at him as if to say it would be disrespectful to take a picture,
notably the elderly man is kept in focus in the centre of the frame, however the
exchange between the presumed husband and wife is the main event of the shot,
this tells us that the focus of the shot and the main action in a shot do not always
have to be the same, we will employ this by focusing on a still tin of beans in one
shot, while a picture is turned face-down out of the shot's focus. The following
shot is faced towards the elderly woman, tracking away from her as she walks
towards the cemetery, revealing a small boy holding the adult woman's hand, this
shot does not provide anything new of note that we can learn from.

14. • The following shot is a long tracking shot, showing the elderly man
walking down the path to the cemetery, the camera following him
as he walks, slowly zooming in so his family are out of frame, until
he gets to the entrance of the cemetery, faces the towards the
camera, and his family gather behind him. This shows us that a long
shot can be rendered more dynamic with elements of a reveal by
using a combination of tracking and zooming. We could employ this
for some outdoor scenes in our film, however it may end up
betraying the staid atmosphere we are attempting.
• The next shot again shows the United States of America's flag
waving, however this time it is in full colour at the top of a pole and
shot from a low angle, a POV shot from the elderly man's
perspective. This is another reminder of the film's American setting
and perspective. This is followed by a shot of a French flag in the
exact same state, a Culturally Coded reference to the battle at
Omaha Beach that takes place in the film, an attempted American
invasion of Nazi-occupied France.

15. • There is a brief shot of the elderly man beginning to walk towards the graves, followed by a
long tracking shot of him walking amongst the graves that sees the camera move from facing
towards him, to facing towards his left side, and then behind him, pulling back to reveal the
hundreds of gravestones. this is to emphasise the loss of human life that comes as a result of
war, and from this we can learn a pull-back-and-reveal technique that means that the
audience has a different viewpoint from that of the characters, the elderly man would clearly
be able to see the gravestones for a long time before this shot, however it is the first time the
audience would see them, this is something we could employ for dramatic effect by having
an object relevant to the plot hinted at, and acknowledged by the main character, but not
looked at clearly until when it would be most dramatically effective, we will use this with a
photograph of a woman in our film.
• The elderly man then collapses in front of a gravestone and his family surround him to
support him. The next two shots clearly show the names of the gravestones in front of him,
focusing on nothing else, this tells the audience that the names of these men are relevant,
and probably have some emotional significance to the elderly man. From this we can learn
that the written word can be an effective tool for visual communication, and that by giving
the audience clear shots of text they can have a good vantage point to read them, however
as the film we are making focuses more on action than language, it is unlikely we will employ
this technique.

16. • The camera then zooms into the elderly man's
crying eyes in the next shot until they fill the
frame, concluding the opening sequence, this
conveys to the audience the emotional nature
of the film, and teaches us that intensity can
be generated by slowly zooming in on the face
of an emotional person, however our film will
be somewhat emotionally detached, so we
will most likely not use this technique.

17. Saving Private Ryan: Mise-En-Scene
• This setting is in modern day while the rest of
the film takes place during the Second World
War, the message here is that war results in a
catastrophic loss of human life, this teaches us
that changing the time of the mise-en-scene
can be used to powerful dramatic effect to
display change, however we will not employ
this technique as our film will be set in an
ambiguously modern time.

18. Saving Private Ryan: Audio Analysis
• The only audio in the scene besides low ambient noises such as birds chirping, footsteps and
wind is an original score, it starts off as solely mournful brass instrumentation, most likely a
cultural reference to military music such as Taps and The Last Post that are brass pieces,
linking with the film's story of the American military in the Second World War. As the elderly
man walks towards the graves cellos are added to the instrumentation, conveying movement
and dramatic progression,violins come in soon after, and the piece takes a more uplifting
turn, as the elderly man begins to cry the instrumentation becomes more quiet, mournful
and brass-focused, reflecting his sadness towards his fallen comrades, the last instrumental
phrase is an ominous brass tune that becomes overpowered by the sound of crashing waves
as the film switches to the Battle of Omaha Beach and the narrative is set in motion. The
score here works with the onscreen events to telegraph to the audience how they should be
feeling at different points of the film.
• This tells us that the mood and movement of an original instrumental piece can be used as a
fitting companion to onscreen action, however as we are likely going to use an existing song
as the soundtrack to our film, we will not follow this technique exactly but the editing will be
done in tandem with the song's movements.
• Only one word is spoken in this opening, as the elderly man collapses and cries the adult man
runs up to him and says "Dad!" an obvious exposition of the character's relation to the
elderly man, this makes the audience aware that the man is his son and that the people
behind the elderly man are almost certainly his family.
• From this we can learn that sparing words can be used to convey necessary plot information
without dialogue taking over the film, however we intend for our film to have no spoken
words besides those in an existing song used as a soundtrack, this also seems too obvious of
a method of exposition, we would prefer to show instead of tell where possible in our film
opening.