© House of Lords 2015Tuesday 9 June 2015
Scrutiny of legislation
in the House of Lords
Jake Vaughan, Clerk of Legislation, House
of Lords
© House of Lords 2015
State Opening of Parliament
27 May 2015
© House of Lords 2015
© House of Lords 2015
Different stages of Bill scrutiny
© House of Lords 2015
Main stages of public bills in the House of Lords
• First reading – formal, text is published
• Second reading – debate on principles
• Committee stage – detailed
examination. Debates on amendments
• Report stage – more amendments
• Third Reading – sometimes more
amendments
• “Ping-pong” – resolving differences
between the two Houses
© House of Lords 2015
Similar but not the same:
Lords / Commons procedures
• No formal programming of bills in the
Lords: timetabling is less certain
• Committee stage normally open to all
members. No evidence taking
• No selection of amendments – all
relevant amendments tabled can be
debated
• Third Reading on a separate day
© House of Lords 2015
2015 Government Bills
introduced in the House of Lords
• Charities (Protection and Social
Investment) Bill
• Childcare Bill
• Cities and Local Government
Devolution Bill
• Psychoactive Substances Bill
© House of Lords 2015
Private Members’ Bills
• Same procedures as Government Bills
• Can be introduced by any Member
• 44 entered into the ballot
• More to be introduced later in the
session
• Much lower chance of becoming law
© House of Lords 2015
Draft Bills
•Draft Public Service
Ombudsman Bill
•Proposals for a Draft Bill of
Rights
•Others?
© House of Lords 2015
Committee work
• 2014-15 – e.g. Affordable Childcare
• Permanent committees on e.g. EU
matters
• New ad hoc inquiries:
– Sexual violence in conflicts
– National policy for the build
environment
– Social mobility for school leavers
– Disability provisions of the Equality
Act 2010
© House of Lords 2015
Sources of information about
legislative business in the House
• The Parliamentary website
www.parliament.uk
• The Government Whips Office
website www.lordswhips.org.uk
© House of Lords 2015
© House of Lords 2015
Bill pages
Timetable
Bills
Explanatory
Notes
Amendment
s
Briefing
papers
© House of Lords 2015
Lists of
amendment
s
© House of Lords 2015
www.lordswhips.org.uk
© House of Lords 2015
© House of Lords 2015
Members’
policy
interests

Lords legislation slides june 2015

  • 1.
    © House ofLords 2015Tuesday 9 June 2015 Scrutiny of legislation in the House of Lords Jake Vaughan, Clerk of Legislation, House of Lords
  • 2.
    © House ofLords 2015 State Opening of Parliament 27 May 2015
  • 3.
    © House ofLords 2015
  • 4.
    © House ofLords 2015 Different stages of Bill scrutiny
  • 5.
    © House ofLords 2015 Main stages of public bills in the House of Lords • First reading – formal, text is published • Second reading – debate on principles • Committee stage – detailed examination. Debates on amendments • Report stage – more amendments • Third Reading – sometimes more amendments • “Ping-pong” – resolving differences between the two Houses
  • 6.
    © House ofLords 2015 Similar but not the same: Lords / Commons procedures • No formal programming of bills in the Lords: timetabling is less certain • Committee stage normally open to all members. No evidence taking • No selection of amendments – all relevant amendments tabled can be debated • Third Reading on a separate day
  • 7.
    © House ofLords 2015 2015 Government Bills introduced in the House of Lords • Charities (Protection and Social Investment) Bill • Childcare Bill • Cities and Local Government Devolution Bill • Psychoactive Substances Bill
  • 8.
    © House ofLords 2015 Private Members’ Bills • Same procedures as Government Bills • Can be introduced by any Member • 44 entered into the ballot • More to be introduced later in the session • Much lower chance of becoming law
  • 9.
    © House ofLords 2015 Draft Bills •Draft Public Service Ombudsman Bill •Proposals for a Draft Bill of Rights •Others?
  • 10.
    © House ofLords 2015 Committee work • 2014-15 – e.g. Affordable Childcare • Permanent committees on e.g. EU matters • New ad hoc inquiries: – Sexual violence in conflicts – National policy for the build environment – Social mobility for school leavers – Disability provisions of the Equality Act 2010
  • 11.
    © House ofLords 2015 Sources of information about legislative business in the House • The Parliamentary website www.parliament.uk • The Government Whips Office website www.lordswhips.org.uk
  • 12.
    © House ofLords 2015
  • 13.
    © House ofLords 2015 Bill pages Timetable Bills Explanatory Notes Amendment s Briefing papers
  • 14.
    © House ofLords 2015 Lists of amendment s
  • 15.
    © House ofLords 2015 www.lordswhips.org.uk
  • 16.
    © House ofLords 2015
  • 17.
    © House ofLords 2015 Members’ policy interests

Editor's Notes

  • #4 When the House is in committee, procedures are more relaxed (members can speak as often as they wish) and the Lord in the chair sits on the right of the Table, not on the Woolsack. (Sorry, no recent photo available of the House in committee!)