WHAT IS THE
PROBLEM OF EVIL?
Aims:
  • Describe what the problem of evil and suffering
 • Explain why there is evil and suffering is a problem
                 for religious believers
HOW IS EVIL UNDERSTOOD?

• Wickedness! The worst kind of badness or
  nastiness which causes people to suffer pain
  and sorrow both physical and non-physical.
WHAT TYPES OF SUFFERING ARE THERE?


   war        terrorism      poverty      crime


 sickness    bereavement     Illness     rejection


depression    Holocaust    Twin Towers   Tsunami
TWO TYPES OF EVIL
• Moral evil – evil actions deliberately carried out by
  people that brings suffering to others e.g.
  murder, rape, war, theft
• Natural evil – suffering beyond people’s
  control, caused by nature, e.g. famine, disease, natural
  disasters


• Sometimes these overlap, or they do not fit into these
  categories
SOME EXAMPLES:
• War (a moral evil) may lead to famine because the
  agricultural system breaks down (a natural evil)
• Cancer (a natural evil) can be caused by smoking or poor
  diet, which is an individual choice, so is it actually a moral
  evil?
• Is death an evil? If people never died would that be worse
  than death?
• If animals are abused by people, that must be a moral
  evil, but what about the suffering of an animal killed by a
  lion?
LOOKING AT TODAYS PAPERS
1. Have a look at one of today's papers and list all of the
   news stories that involve suffering
2. Identify whether that are examples of moral or natural
   evil
3. What caused each event and how it might have been
   prevented
DIAGRAM OF THE PROBLEM OF EVIL
God is thought to be omni-benevolent, omnipotent and omniscient

  If God is omni-     If God is omniscient he   If God is omnipotent he
benevolent he would     would know how to           would be able to
want to remove evil       remove evil and           remove evil and
   and suffering              suffering                 suffering

                      Therefore, both God
                      and evil cannot exist

                      Evil and suffering do
                              exist

                        Therefore, God
                         cannot exist
QUESTIONS
1. Does evil always lead to suffering?
2. Is suffering always wrong?
3. Imagine that you were having a conversation with God
   a) What questions would you like to ask God about the
      problem of evil?
   b) What answers do you think that God would give?
SUMMARY
• Evil and suffering occur in many forms and
  can cause serious problems for those who
  believe in an all-loving, all-powerful and all-
  knowing God

Lesson 5 the problem of evil

  • 1.
    WHAT IS THE PROBLEMOF EVIL? Aims: • Describe what the problem of evil and suffering • Explain why there is evil and suffering is a problem for religious believers
  • 2.
    HOW IS EVILUNDERSTOOD? • Wickedness! The worst kind of badness or nastiness which causes people to suffer pain and sorrow both physical and non-physical.
  • 3.
    WHAT TYPES OFSUFFERING ARE THERE? war terrorism poverty crime sickness bereavement Illness rejection depression Holocaust Twin Towers Tsunami
  • 4.
    TWO TYPES OFEVIL • Moral evil – evil actions deliberately carried out by people that brings suffering to others e.g. murder, rape, war, theft • Natural evil – suffering beyond people’s control, caused by nature, e.g. famine, disease, natural disasters • Sometimes these overlap, or they do not fit into these categories
  • 5.
    SOME EXAMPLES: • War(a moral evil) may lead to famine because the agricultural system breaks down (a natural evil) • Cancer (a natural evil) can be caused by smoking or poor diet, which is an individual choice, so is it actually a moral evil? • Is death an evil? If people never died would that be worse than death? • If animals are abused by people, that must be a moral evil, but what about the suffering of an animal killed by a lion?
  • 6.
    LOOKING AT TODAYSPAPERS 1. Have a look at one of today's papers and list all of the news stories that involve suffering 2. Identify whether that are examples of moral or natural evil 3. What caused each event and how it might have been prevented
  • 7.
    DIAGRAM OF THEPROBLEM OF EVIL God is thought to be omni-benevolent, omnipotent and omniscient If God is omni- If God is omniscient he If God is omnipotent he benevolent he would would know how to would be able to want to remove evil remove evil and remove evil and and suffering suffering suffering Therefore, both God and evil cannot exist Evil and suffering do exist Therefore, God cannot exist
  • 8.
    QUESTIONS 1. Does evilalways lead to suffering? 2. Is suffering always wrong? 3. Imagine that you were having a conversation with God a) What questions would you like to ask God about the problem of evil? b) What answers do you think that God would give?
  • 9.
    SUMMARY • Evil andsuffering occur in many forms and can cause serious problems for those who believe in an all-loving, all-powerful and all- knowing God