COST & BENEFIT FACTORS of REGIONAL
 SDI INFRASTRUCTURES of WESTERN,
   CENTRAL and EASTERN PART OF
              EUROPE




        Robert LACH & Slawomir ANUSZ
IGPIM / ISEH = Institute of Spatial Economy & Housing, Warsaw
 Secretary of National Contact Point of PLAN4ALL Project (PL)
There is well known and constantly being repeated boring – MANTRA, that :

„It is much easier to determine costs associated with SDIs implementaions,
than the benefits. Costs are much more better documented than benefits”

If I would accept that – talking on this subject would be boring.
So I have tried another approach.

Regardless of frequent repetition of this mantra, progress of SDI implementation proceeds, costs seem to
grow, and what about the benefits ?

How does it all relates to Information Society „Buzzword” ?
What are other important trends and dependancies ?
How all this is connected to Global, European, National & Regional Economies ?
Does it all matters in view of coming second wave of Global Finacnial Crisis ?
Regardless of the answers each of us needs to have her/his own answer…

But let us start from the beginning…. from facts & figures….
Data sources for presentations...

DEAD CAPITAL in REAL ESTATES WORLDWIDE, De Soto,                             1997 - 2001

MARKET DATA on POLISH CADASTRAL & SDI ACTIVITIES                             1999 - 2005

DG JRC COST/BENEFITS ESTIMATES                                                   2006

DG JRC CATALAN SDI REPORT                                                        2008

DG JRC ADVANCED REGIONAL SPATIAL DATA INFRASTRUCTURES                            2009

SDI STATE OF PLAY REPORT                                                         2010

NATIONAL COSTS DATA FROM POLISH LAW ON NATIONAL SDI                               2010

REPORTS, FEASIBULITY STUDIES of REGIONAL SDIs from POLAND                    2009 – 2011
data source : regional governments and departmetns
              of structural funds („RPO projects”)

SUMMARY TABLE on LINKS BETWEEN SDI, CADASTER,                               2003 - 2011
MORTGAGE MARKETS,
EUROGEOGRAPHICS, NATIONAL SURVEYS, European Mortgage Federation, R & D reports

around 300 data sources, study is under way
WHAT ABOUT THE COSTS ESTIMATES OF INSPIRE (not quite complete image)
       AT REGIONAL LEVEL on the EXAMPLE data of a few 2010-2012
                        POLISH PROJECTS ?




11-5-21
ADVANCED REGIONAL SPATIAL DATA INFRASTRUCTURES, DG JRC
                         2009




 11-5-21
ADVANCED REGIONAL SPATIAL DATA INFRASTRUCTURES, DG JRC
                         2009




 11-5-21
ADVANCED REGIONAL SPATIAL DATA INFRASTRUCTURES, DG JRC
                         2009




 11-5-21
11-5-21
11-5-21
AN EFFORT of INTEGRATION of CENTRALIZED GUGIK
          APPROACH
          WITH SELF-GOVERNING REGIONS & CITIES

          2010 – 2011 – TIME OF CONSTANT EFFORTS...

          BRIEF REPORT




11-5-21
Actors of NSDI in Poland



         European            Minister of Administration
         Commission              & Internal Affairs
                                                                          CENTRAL LEVEL
            General Survey
                                                                            Leadership
                                           Council for Infrastructure
              of Poland                     of Spatial Information          in INSPIRE




                                                                            CENTRAL
                                                                          GOVERNMENT
                                                                           MINISTRIES
                                                                           & AGENCIES




SELF-
GOVERNMENTAL
UNITS
  11-5-21
ROLE & TASKS of GUGIK AS INSPIRE COORDINATOR in POLAND

               Cooperate with E.C.



                     Maintain                            E.C.
                     geoportal         Take opinions under
                                       consideration

                 Lead inventory
                 of files & services      Promote        NSDI
                                                        Council

                                           Monitor
               Co-
               ordinate
               SDI in                     Plan
               Poland                                  Leading
                                                      Gov't organ

                                          Co - act

11-5-21                                          Administrative organ
Organize trainings                   LEADING ORGAN
                                               TASKS




            Promote

                           Monitor
                                       Coordinator
            Coordinate
Leading      activities     Plan
 organ      within the
              theme



          Identify
          data-sets

                            Co - act


 11-5-21
Organ of administration
1 : 4.06 – 4.21 : 6,53 - 8,88

NATIONAL LEVEL EXPENDITURES in POLAND : cross-check of 2011

  How does 2006 DJ JRC 2006 Cost & Benefits report
  fits into 2011 PL figures ?

  Polish Law on National Infrastructure of Spatial Information
  of March 4th, 2010, acting from June 7th, 2010 estimates
  expenditures of c.a. 650 million PLN in time frame of 2010-2019

  650 million PLN = 165,78 m euro / 10 years = 16, 58 meuro / year

  so purely at national level estimated annual cost in 16,58 meuro.
REGIONAL LEVEL COSTS of INSPIRE cross check 2011
      YET a NON – COMPLETE, a SAMPLE DATA REALLY....




11-5-21
IS HYPERINFLATION COMING BACK WITH THE US DOLLAR FUNERAL ?




11-5-21
11-5-21
11-5-21
11-5-21
THANK YOU FOR ATTENTION !
  I WOULD LIKE TO ASK YOU TO CONTRIBUTE JOINTLY
  FOR FURTHER AND MORE COMPLETE ANALYSIS

  MAYBE PROPOSING FOR DG JRC EXTENSION OF EXISTING STUDIES, of
  LAUNCHING a NEW ONE TAKING INTO ACCOUNT
  TODAY'S STATUS AND TRENDS
  IN EUROPEAN & WORLDWIDE ECONOMY


  If interested, please contact me...




  Robert Lach
  Skype ID : robert_j_lach
  e-mail : robertlach@igpim.pl
  e-mail : robertlach00@gmail.com (for bigger attachements)
  Twitter : Robert_Lach
11-5-21

GI2011 Lach cost+benefit factors of regio_sdi

  • 1.
    COST & BENEFITFACTORS of REGIONAL SDI INFRASTRUCTURES of WESTERN, CENTRAL and EASTERN PART OF EUROPE Robert LACH & Slawomir ANUSZ IGPIM / ISEH = Institute of Spatial Economy & Housing, Warsaw Secretary of National Contact Point of PLAN4ALL Project (PL)
  • 2.
    There is wellknown and constantly being repeated boring – MANTRA, that : „It is much easier to determine costs associated with SDIs implementaions, than the benefits. Costs are much more better documented than benefits” If I would accept that – talking on this subject would be boring. So I have tried another approach. Regardless of frequent repetition of this mantra, progress of SDI implementation proceeds, costs seem to grow, and what about the benefits ? How does it all relates to Information Society „Buzzword” ? What are other important trends and dependancies ? How all this is connected to Global, European, National & Regional Economies ? Does it all matters in view of coming second wave of Global Finacnial Crisis ? Regardless of the answers each of us needs to have her/his own answer… But let us start from the beginning…. from facts & figures….
  • 3.
    Data sources forpresentations... DEAD CAPITAL in REAL ESTATES WORLDWIDE, De Soto, 1997 - 2001 MARKET DATA on POLISH CADASTRAL & SDI ACTIVITIES 1999 - 2005 DG JRC COST/BENEFITS ESTIMATES 2006 DG JRC CATALAN SDI REPORT 2008 DG JRC ADVANCED REGIONAL SPATIAL DATA INFRASTRUCTURES 2009 SDI STATE OF PLAY REPORT 2010 NATIONAL COSTS DATA FROM POLISH LAW ON NATIONAL SDI 2010 REPORTS, FEASIBULITY STUDIES of REGIONAL SDIs from POLAND 2009 – 2011 data source : regional governments and departmetns of structural funds („RPO projects”) SUMMARY TABLE on LINKS BETWEEN SDI, CADASTER, 2003 - 2011 MORTGAGE MARKETS, EUROGEOGRAPHICS, NATIONAL SURVEYS, European Mortgage Federation, R & D reports around 300 data sources, study is under way
  • 7.
    WHAT ABOUT THECOSTS ESTIMATES OF INSPIRE (not quite complete image) AT REGIONAL LEVEL on the EXAMPLE data of a few 2010-2012 POLISH PROJECTS ? 11-5-21
  • 8.
    ADVANCED REGIONAL SPATIALDATA INFRASTRUCTURES, DG JRC 2009 11-5-21
  • 9.
    ADVANCED REGIONAL SPATIALDATA INFRASTRUCTURES, DG JRC 2009 11-5-21
  • 10.
    ADVANCED REGIONAL SPATIALDATA INFRASTRUCTURES, DG JRC 2009 11-5-21
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
    AN EFFORT ofINTEGRATION of CENTRALIZED GUGIK APPROACH WITH SELF-GOVERNING REGIONS & CITIES 2010 – 2011 – TIME OF CONSTANT EFFORTS... BRIEF REPORT 11-5-21
  • 14.
    Actors of NSDIin Poland European Minister of Administration Commission & Internal Affairs CENTRAL LEVEL General Survey Leadership Council for Infrastructure of Poland of Spatial Information in INSPIRE CENTRAL GOVERNMENT MINISTRIES & AGENCIES SELF- GOVERNMENTAL UNITS 11-5-21
  • 15.
    ROLE & TASKSof GUGIK AS INSPIRE COORDINATOR in POLAND Cooperate with E.C. Maintain E.C. geoportal Take opinions under consideration Lead inventory of files & services Promote NSDI Council Monitor Co- ordinate SDI in Plan Poland Leading Gov't organ Co - act 11-5-21 Administrative organ
  • 16.
    Organize trainings LEADING ORGAN TASKS Promote Monitor Coordinator Coordinate Leading activities Plan organ within the theme Identify data-sets Co - act 11-5-21 Organ of administration
  • 17.
    1 : 4.06– 4.21 : 6,53 - 8,88 NATIONAL LEVEL EXPENDITURES in POLAND : cross-check of 2011 How does 2006 DJ JRC 2006 Cost & Benefits report fits into 2011 PL figures ? Polish Law on National Infrastructure of Spatial Information of March 4th, 2010, acting from June 7th, 2010 estimates expenditures of c.a. 650 million PLN in time frame of 2010-2019 650 million PLN = 165,78 m euro / 10 years = 16, 58 meuro / year so purely at national level estimated annual cost in 16,58 meuro.
  • 18.
    REGIONAL LEVEL COSTSof INSPIRE cross check 2011 YET a NON – COMPLETE, a SAMPLE DATA REALLY.... 11-5-21
  • 19.
    IS HYPERINFLATION COMINGBACK WITH THE US DOLLAR FUNERAL ? 11-5-21
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
    THANK YOU FORATTENTION ! I WOULD LIKE TO ASK YOU TO CONTRIBUTE JOINTLY FOR FURTHER AND MORE COMPLETE ANALYSIS MAYBE PROPOSING FOR DG JRC EXTENSION OF EXISTING STUDIES, of LAUNCHING a NEW ONE TAKING INTO ACCOUNT TODAY'S STATUS AND TRENDS IN EUROPEAN & WORLDWIDE ECONOMY If interested, please contact me... Robert Lach Skype ID : robert_j_lach e-mail : robertlach@igpim.pl e-mail : robertlach00@gmail.com (for bigger attachements) Twitter : Robert_Lach 11-5-21