Jon Cohn Exton PA - Rationalizing Application Portfolios
1. JonCohn ExtonPA - RationalizingApplicationPortfolios
The pressure ismountingforCIOsand otherIT leaderstohelpthe businessenable newdisruptive
technologieslikemobile,social,cloudandbigdata,butmany CIOsare strugglingtodo sobecause
maintainingandsupportinglegacyapplicationsconsumesthe lion'sshare of the budget.Here are
five recommendationsforrationalizingyourapplicationportfolio.
In manyorganizations,the complexityof the applicationlandscape isbecomingamajorchallenge
for the CIO.Maintainingandsupportinglegacyapplicationsconsumesthe lion'sshare of the budget,
leavinglittleroomforinnovation.Andyet,disruptivenext-generationtechnologieslike mobile,
social,cloudandbig data promise tantalizingbenefitstothe businessif itcanleverage them.
Andthere'sthe rub: Evenas the businessisbeginningtolookatIT as a strategicenablerthatcan
helpitgetits arms aroundthese newtechnologies,ITisstrugglingtodeal withanapplication
landscape thatismore complex thaneverbefore.
"There'sa strikingdifferencefrom2011: IT isconsideredmuchmore,particularlybythe business
side,assomethingthathelpstheminnovateandinformthemselves,"saysRonTolido,seniorvice
president,ApplicationServices,atconsulting,technologyandoutsourcingservicesprovider
Capgemini.
Tolidoisalsothe author of Capgemini'srecentlyreleasedApplicationLandscapeReport2014, a
follow-uptoa 2011 reporton the same subject.
"In 2011, IT was much more lookedatfor cost reduction,"Tolidoadds."Now it'sseenasastrategic
enabler.Itputsa lot of the CIOs that we've beensurveyingunderalotof additional pressure."
Evenback in2011, CIOsclearlyfeltthe pressure torationalize the applicationlandscape,Tolidosays.
"Despite theirworries — andclearrecognitionof the needforaction — many CIOsindicatedthat
theyfounditdifficulttoactuallystartrationalizingtheirportfolio,"Tolidowritesinthe report."The
impedimentsof complexity,costconstraintsandthe inabilitytodefine aconvincingbusinesscase
were simplytoobigtotake on."
Now,he says,the needisbecomingcritical.He hasfive recommendationstohelpCIOsget
rationalizationprogramsunderway.
1. Industrialize andStandardize First
Nearlyone-half(48percent) of respondentstoCapgemini'sstudyreportedtheyhave more
applicationsintheirportfoliothanthe businessactuallyrequires.That'salarge jumpfrom2011,
when34 percentof organizationsreportedthe same.
"Most CIOswill admitthattheyhave far too manyapplications,"Tolidosays."It'sa clearincrease
comparedto 2011. Despite the ambitionsCIOshada few yearsagoto simplifytheirITlandscape,in
practice theyhaven'treallybeenable todoit."
2. One of the bigcontributingfactorstothe growingnumberof applicationsinthe portfolioisthatfew
businessesare willingtodecommissionapplications,evenasindividual businessunitsturnto
software-as-a-service (SaaS) solutionstomeettheirneeds,eitherwith IT'sapproval orinthe formof
shadowIT. These SaaSsolutionsaddtothe complexityaswell.
Capgemini recommendsstartingbytakingafreshlookat yourapplicationlandscape,seekingways
to applyindustrializationandstandardizationtorationalize itsfoundation.Fully70percentof
respondentstoCapgemini'sstudybelieve thatatleastone-fifthof theirapplicationscouldbe
consolidatedbyeliminatingredundantfunctionality.
"Look foropportunitiestomutualize resources,improve documentation,refactorsoftware,
consolidate overlappingapplications,eliminateredundantapplications,replace agingandhigh-risk
technologies,getridof excessive customizationandtoimprove developmentandapplication
managementproductivity,"Tolidowritesinthe report.
2. ConsiderMore Radical RationalizationScenarios
Despite effortsoverthe pastfewyearsto streamlinethe applicationlandscape,Tolidosaysthat,in
manyorganizations,the problemhasreachedthe pointthatCIOsneedtoconsider"extreme"
strategies.He pointstotwosuch rationalizationstrategiesthatmore andmore organizations
surveyedbyCapgeminihave begunadopting:"enhancement"and"rip-and-replace."
In the enhancementscenario,Tolidosays,ITleaveslegacyapplicationsinplace but doesn'ttouch
themor spendtime addingnewfeatures.Instead,ITwrapsnext-generationtechnology — likea
mobile front-endorcloud-basedAPI — aroundthem.
In the rip-and-replace scenario,ITsimplyjettisonsthe oldapplicationsandreplacesthemwith new,
standardapplications,oftencloud-basedapplications.
"Thoughthe firststrategyis a pragmatic,relativelylow-riskone thatdeliversquickresultswithout
massive change,it'sradical inthe sense thatit movesthe focusawayfromrebuildingcore
applicationstothe outerlayersof the applicationestate,"Tolidowritesinthe report."The second
strategyismuch more radical though,and islikelytobe ignitedbythe impatience of the business,
frustrationbyearlierrationalizationattemptsandthe availabilityof anew generationof relatively
low-cost,easy-to-implementcloud-basedsolutions."
While Tolidonotesthatthese strategieswouldhave beenunthinkablebymostCIOsjusta few short
yearsago, the pressure fromthe businessismountingthese daysandCIOsthatare strugglingto
make progressinapplicationrationalizationneedtoconsidermore radical solutions.
3. Leverage Next-GenerationSolutions
"In mostcases,the single biggestreasonnottobe able to rationalize isthe inabilityto create a
businesscase,"Tolidosays."Thissimplyhastodo witha lackof metrics."
But here,Tolidosays,the businesslandscape hasbeguntiltinginfavorof CIOs.Social,mobility,big
data and cloudsolutionsare bigdriversof the needforapplicationrationalization,andCIOscanuse
the perceivedhighbusinessvalue of these solutionstobuildcompellingbusinesscasesfor
improvementstothe underlyingcore applications.
3. "There'smuchmore pressure fromthe businessside torationalize the applicationlandscape
because theywantto dothese innovativethings,"Tolidosays.
"Also,the newwave of applicationstypicallycomeswithadvanced(cloud-based) platformsthat
provide alternative waystounlocklegacyapplicationsandlinkthemtothe new frontends,"Tolido
writesinthe report."Done inthe right way,the applicationportfoliowouldbe aconvincingmix of
new,high-value solutionsandcritical changestothe underlyingfoundation."
4. EmbedInnovationinthe ApplicationLifecycle
Most CIOs are familiarwiththe old80-20 rule:80 percentof yourtime and resourcesare spent
"keepingthe lightson"—runningandoperatingexistingapplications.Thatleavesonly20percentfor
innovation.The waytoslaythat bugbear,Capgemini says,istoembedinnovationwithinthe
applicationlifecycle (andintoanyapplicationmanagementorsupportcontract,if applicable).
"For example,thiscanbe done throughorganizingperiodical trendworkshops,the obligationto
dedicate awell-definedpartof the projectportfoliotoinnovative solutionsormore organizational
measuressuchas establishinganinnovationgovernance element(like a"value office")orsimply
crowdsourcingsuggestionsforimprovement,"Tolidowritesinthe report.
5. SystematicallyUse FactsandMetrics to Create More Mutual Understanding
Underlyingitall,the keytosucceedinginrationalizationandinnovationeffortsisasolidbase of
agreementbetweenbusinessandITon the currentstate of the applicationlandscape andthe
priorities forimprovement.Withboththe businessandITon the same page,you can create a
forward-looking,collaborativeatmosphere thatcanenable digital transformationsuccess.
"Considertoolsforapplicationmappingandassessment,andforapplicationportfolio
management,"Tolidowritesinthe report."Use these tools —amongotherthings—torelate
applicationstobusinessprocessessothatthe businessimpactandvalue of applicationsbecome
clearerand more tangible.Thishelpstomake rationalizationdecisionsandestablishprioritiesbased
on businesscriticality.Also,paymore attentiontobusinesscase development,businessoutcome-
drivendashboardsandeven"value engineering,"astheyprovide powerful,objectivemeansfor
communicationbetweenthe variousstakeholders.
Source : cio.com
Recommendedby:
JonCohn ,CTO, VP IT Architecture
https://www.linkedin.com/in/jonacohn
joncohn@comcast.net