This document discusses various aspects of performance reviews and feedback. It begins by providing a brief historical context of performance reviews dating back to ancient China. It then discusses some of the common problems with traditional performance review systems, noting that many employees dread the process. The document advocates focusing reviews on future goals and plans rather than just past performance. It also suggests that while praise is good for newcomers, more experienced workers may prefer and benefit from more constructive criticism as it can help them improve and feel challenged. Overall, the key idea discussed is that the purpose of reviews and feedback should be to foster continued growth and goal pursuit, not just judgements of past performance.