SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Peer Review Worksheet
The ability to critique someone else’s work is an extremely valuable skill and can provide
insight into the reviewer’s work as well. Briefly write down a few comments for
evaluating the author in each category. Please be as specific as possible.
1. Introduction: Does the author grab your attention in the first sentence? Does the
introduction move smoothly towards the thesis/argument, or is it unclear? Does the
author take a firm stance in his/her thesis, or are they “on the fence”?
2. Body: Does the author use transition sentences? Is their a topic sentence for each
body paragraph? Does the evidence match the topic sentence?
3. Conclusion: Does the author restate the thesis, either directly or indirectly? Does the
author broaden out the significance of the argument presented in relation to world
history?
4. Grammar: run-on sentences, correct spelling, subject-verb agreement, awkward
sentence structure, comma splice, etc. Indicate whether there is a pattern or just a few
cases.
HIS 101-Sp09-Peer Review

More Related Content

What's hot

Paragraph writing
Paragraph writingParagraph writing
Paragraph writing
Safeer Ali
 
Types of paragraphs
Types of paragraphsTypes of paragraphs
Types of paragraphs
rochamaryuri
 
Types of paragraphs
Types of paragraphsTypes of paragraphs
Types of paragraphsMiyi75
 
English Literature Exam Prep Ocr
English Literature Exam Prep OcrEnglish Literature Exam Prep Ocr
English Literature Exam Prep Ocr
Andy Fisher
 
0486 sow unseen
0486 sow unseen0486 sow unseen
0486 sow unseenPato_Ch
 
Ewrt 1 c class 17 writing essay 2 review for exam 1
Ewrt 1 c class 17 writing essay 2 review for exam 1Ewrt 1 c class 17 writing essay 2 review for exam 1
Ewrt 1 c class 17 writing essay 2 review for exam 1
jordanlachance
 
Ewrt 1 c class 18 online
Ewrt 1 c class 18 onlineEwrt 1 c class 18 online
Ewrt 1 c class 18 online
jordanlachance
 
plagiarism
plagiarismplagiarism
Types of paragraphs
Types of paragraphsTypes of paragraphs
Types of paragraphs
andreamora2797
 
Types of paragraphs
Types of paragraphsTypes of paragraphs
Types of paragraphs
Paula Aldana
 
how to write an essay
how to write an essay how to write an essay
how to write an essay
Khadeejah Khan
 
Cautions about paraphrasing
Cautions about paraphrasingCautions about paraphrasing
Cautions about paraphrasingPilgrim Library
 
What is an essay?
What is an essay?What is an essay?
What is an essay?
Faith Mokoena
 
The expository paragraph
The expository paragraphThe expository paragraph
The expository paragraph
Mara Luna
 
Essay and its Type
Essay and its TypeEssay and its Type
Essay and its Type
Azeemaj101
 
Materi PLPG
Materi PLPGMateri PLPG
Materi PLPG
Syarifuddin Achmad
 

What's hot (19)

Paragraph writing
Paragraph writingParagraph writing
Paragraph writing
 
Types of paragraphs
Types of paragraphsTypes of paragraphs
Types of paragraphs
 
Types of paragraphs
Types of paragraphsTypes of paragraphs
Types of paragraphs
 
English Literature Exam Prep Ocr
English Literature Exam Prep OcrEnglish Literature Exam Prep Ocr
English Literature Exam Prep Ocr
 
0486 sow unseen
0486 sow unseen0486 sow unseen
0486 sow unseen
 
Ewrt 1 c class 17 writing essay 2 review for exam 1
Ewrt 1 c class 17 writing essay 2 review for exam 1Ewrt 1 c class 17 writing essay 2 review for exam 1
Ewrt 1 c class 17 writing essay 2 review for exam 1
 
Register
RegisterRegister
Register
 
Ewrt 1 c class 18 online
Ewrt 1 c class 18 onlineEwrt 1 c class 18 online
Ewrt 1 c class 18 online
 
ENG 105 Module 1 PPT
ENG 105 Module 1 PPTENG 105 Module 1 PPT
ENG 105 Module 1 PPT
 
plagiarism
plagiarismplagiarism
plagiarism
 
Types of paragraphs
Types of paragraphsTypes of paragraphs
Types of paragraphs
 
Types of paragraphs
Types of paragraphsTypes of paragraphs
Types of paragraphs
 
how to write an essay
how to write an essay how to write an essay
how to write an essay
 
Cautions about paraphrasing
Cautions about paraphrasingCautions about paraphrasing
Cautions about paraphrasing
 
Paragraphs (1)
Paragraphs (1)Paragraphs (1)
Paragraphs (1)
 
What is an essay?
What is an essay?What is an essay?
What is an essay?
 
The expository paragraph
The expository paragraphThe expository paragraph
The expository paragraph
 
Essay and its Type
Essay and its TypeEssay and its Type
Essay and its Type
 
Materi PLPG
Materi PLPGMateri PLPG
Materi PLPG
 

Viewers also liked

Kassierer / Allrounder
Kassierer / AllrounderKassierer / Allrounder
Kassierer / AllrounderPhilippPenelas
 
Paul Mason - Post Capitalism
Paul Mason - Post CapitalismPaul Mason - Post Capitalism
Paul Mason - Post Capitalism
SogetiLabs
 
Tarea unidad-acreditable-2
Tarea unidad-acreditable-2Tarea unidad-acreditable-2
Tarea unidad-acreditable-2
OrianaAraque18
 
Uni bern datenpolitik_20160303
Uni bern datenpolitik_20160303Uni bern datenpolitik_20160303
Uni bern datenpolitik_20160303
Andre Golliez
 
Comercio internacional
Comercio internacionalComercio internacional
Comercio internacionalandresfurlan85
 
Extraordinrio janinealessandraosorioescamilla
Extraordinrio janinealessandraosorioescamillaExtraordinrio janinealessandraosorioescamilla
Extraordinrio janinealessandraosorioescamilla
janine osorio
 
CV Silas Souza (Version in English)
CV Silas Souza (Version in English)CV Silas Souza (Version in English)
CV Silas Souza (Version in English)Silas Souza
 
Erp article1
Erp article1Erp article1
Erp article1infosolz
 
CMS Implementation: Things to do before writing a single line of code
CMS Implementation: Things to do before writing a single line of codeCMS Implementation: Things to do before writing a single line of code
CMS Implementation: Things to do before writing a single line of code
Zoran Nikolovski
 
Account types version1.1
Account types version1.1Account types version1.1
Account types version1.1guestd39354
 
Butter cream frosting
Butter cream frostingButter cream frosting
Butter cream frosting
stilettostigma
 

Viewers also liked (15)

Valentines day
Valentines dayValentines day
Valentines day
 
Trabajo de computacion
Trabajo de computacionTrabajo de computacion
Trabajo de computacion
 
Kassierer / Allrounder
Kassierer / AllrounderKassierer / Allrounder
Kassierer / Allrounder
 
Paul Mason - Post Capitalism
Paul Mason - Post CapitalismPaul Mason - Post Capitalism
Paul Mason - Post Capitalism
 
Tarea unidad-acreditable-2
Tarea unidad-acreditable-2Tarea unidad-acreditable-2
Tarea unidad-acreditable-2
 
Uni bern datenpolitik_20160303
Uni bern datenpolitik_20160303Uni bern datenpolitik_20160303
Uni bern datenpolitik_20160303
 
Comercio internacional
Comercio internacionalComercio internacional
Comercio internacional
 
Extraordinrio janinealessandraosorioescamilla
Extraordinrio janinealessandraosorioescamillaExtraordinrio janinealessandraosorioescamilla
Extraordinrio janinealessandraosorioescamilla
 
Lucia
LuciaLucia
Lucia
 
CV Silas Souza (Version in English)
CV Silas Souza (Version in English)CV Silas Souza (Version in English)
CV Silas Souza (Version in English)
 
Erp article1
Erp article1Erp article1
Erp article1
 
Projeto alfa
Projeto alfaProjeto alfa
Projeto alfa
 
CMS Implementation: Things to do before writing a single line of code
CMS Implementation: Things to do before writing a single line of codeCMS Implementation: Things to do before writing a single line of code
CMS Implementation: Things to do before writing a single line of code
 
Account types version1.1
Account types version1.1Account types version1.1
Account types version1.1
 
Butter cream frosting
Butter cream frostingButter cream frosting
Butter cream frosting
 

Similar to HIS 101-Sp09-Peer Review

AP Exam Prep - Essays
AP Exam Prep  - EssaysAP Exam Prep  - Essays
AP Exam Prep - Essaysmrsfason
 
Essay #3 Argument Paper Proposal In this 2-3 page paper.docx
Essay #3 Argument Paper Proposal    In this 2-3 page paper.docxEssay #3 Argument Paper Proposal    In this 2-3 page paper.docx
Essay #3 Argument Paper Proposal In this 2-3 page paper.docx
russelldayna
 
Advice on academic writing
Advice on academic writingAdvice on academic writing
Advice on academic writing
vanesalonghi
 
Essay
EssayEssay
Comparative essay
Comparative essayComparative essay
Comparative essay
m1sterka1
 
Comparative essay
Comparative essayComparative essay
Comparative essay
m1sterka1
 
ENG 115ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAYDue Week 3 and worth 10.docx
ENG 115ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAYDue Week 3 and worth 10.docxENG 115ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAYDue Week 3 and worth 10.docx
ENG 115ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAYDue Week 3 and worth 10.docx
SALU18
 
ENG 115 ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAY DRAFT Due W.docx
ENG 115  ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAY DRAFT  Due W.docxENG 115  ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAY DRAFT  Due W.docx
ENG 115 ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAY DRAFT Due W.docx
gidmanmary
 
Animal farm essayWriting the introductionThe question .docx
Animal farm essayWriting the introductionThe question .docxAnimal farm essayWriting the introductionThe question .docx
Animal farm essayWriting the introductionThe question .docx
daniahendric
 
How To Write A Reaction Response Paper
How To Write A Reaction Response PaperHow To Write A Reaction Response Paper
How To Write A Reaction Response Paper
Ufuk Solmazlar
 
Academic Essay Writing
Academic Essay WritingAcademic Essay Writing
Academic Essay Writing
Robin Beregovska
 
1. Essay-writing  Essay The word Essay is defined in The Concise O.docx
1. Essay-writing  Essay The word Essay is defined in The Concise O.docx1. Essay-writing  Essay The word Essay is defined in The Concise O.docx
1. Essay-writing  Essay The word Essay is defined in The Concise O.docx
ambersalomon88660
 
Essay Character ComparisonYou are to choose one character fro.docx
Essay Character ComparisonYou are to choose one character fro.docxEssay Character ComparisonYou are to choose one character fro.docx
Essay Character ComparisonYou are to choose one character fro.docx
YASHU40
 
1 Outline Structure for Literary Analysis Essay I. .docx
 1 Outline Structure for Literary Analysis Essay I. .docx 1 Outline Structure for Literary Analysis Essay I. .docx
1 Outline Structure for Literary Analysis Essay I. .docx
ShiraPrater50
 
Unit 3 success criteria
Unit 3 success criteriaUnit 3 success criteria
Unit 3 success criteriaalexgreen196
 
Text analysis
Text analysisText analysis
Text analysis
Emagister
 
Week 10 class 2 ewrt211
Week 10 class 2 ewrt211Week 10 class 2 ewrt211
Week 10 class 2 ewrt211jordanlachance
 
Comparative Literature 203 The European Novel Whats in an (Auth.docx
Comparative Literature 203 The European Novel Whats in an (Auth.docxComparative Literature 203 The European Novel Whats in an (Auth.docx
Comparative Literature 203 The European Novel Whats in an (Auth.docx
monicafrancis71118
 

Similar to HIS 101-Sp09-Peer Review (20)

AP Exam Prep - Essays
AP Exam Prep  - EssaysAP Exam Prep  - Essays
AP Exam Prep - Essays
 
Presentation4
Presentation4Presentation4
Presentation4
 
Essay #3 Argument Paper Proposal In this 2-3 page paper.docx
Essay #3 Argument Paper Proposal    In this 2-3 page paper.docxEssay #3 Argument Paper Proposal    In this 2-3 page paper.docx
Essay #3 Argument Paper Proposal In this 2-3 page paper.docx
 
Advice on academic writing
Advice on academic writingAdvice on academic writing
Advice on academic writing
 
Essay
EssayEssay
Essay
 
Comparative essay
Comparative essayComparative essay
Comparative essay
 
Comparative essay
Comparative essayComparative essay
Comparative essay
 
ENG 115ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAYDue Week 3 and worth 10.docx
ENG 115ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAYDue Week 3 and worth 10.docxENG 115ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAYDue Week 3 and worth 10.docx
ENG 115ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAYDue Week 3 and worth 10.docx
 
ENG 115 ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAY DRAFT Due W.docx
ENG 115  ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAY DRAFT  Due W.docxENG 115  ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAY DRAFT  Due W.docx
ENG 115 ASSIGNMENT 1 PERSONAL ESSAY DRAFT Due W.docx
 
Animal farm essayWriting the introductionThe question .docx
Animal farm essayWriting the introductionThe question .docxAnimal farm essayWriting the introductionThe question .docx
Animal farm essayWriting the introductionThe question .docx
 
How To Write A Reaction Response Paper
How To Write A Reaction Response PaperHow To Write A Reaction Response Paper
How To Write A Reaction Response Paper
 
Academic Essay Writing
Academic Essay WritingAcademic Essay Writing
Academic Essay Writing
 
1. Essay-writing  Essay The word Essay is defined in The Concise O.docx
1. Essay-writing  Essay The word Essay is defined in The Concise O.docx1. Essay-writing  Essay The word Essay is defined in The Concise O.docx
1. Essay-writing  Essay The word Essay is defined in The Concise O.docx
 
Essay Character ComparisonYou are to choose one character fro.docx
Essay Character ComparisonYou are to choose one character fro.docxEssay Character ComparisonYou are to choose one character fro.docx
Essay Character ComparisonYou are to choose one character fro.docx
 
Classification essay jadg
Classification essay jadgClassification essay jadg
Classification essay jadg
 
1 Outline Structure for Literary Analysis Essay I. .docx
 1 Outline Structure for Literary Analysis Essay I. .docx 1 Outline Structure for Literary Analysis Essay I. .docx
1 Outline Structure for Literary Analysis Essay I. .docx
 
Unit 3 success criteria
Unit 3 success criteriaUnit 3 success criteria
Unit 3 success criteria
 
Text analysis
Text analysisText analysis
Text analysis
 
Week 10 class 2 ewrt211
Week 10 class 2 ewrt211Week 10 class 2 ewrt211
Week 10 class 2 ewrt211
 
Comparative Literature 203 The European Novel Whats in an (Auth.docx
Comparative Literature 203 The European Novel Whats in an (Auth.docxComparative Literature 203 The European Novel Whats in an (Auth.docx
Comparative Literature 203 The European Novel Whats in an (Auth.docx
 

More from Scott Wagner

Scott Wagner's Professional Portfolio
Scott Wagner's Professional PortfolioScott Wagner's Professional Portfolio
Scott Wagner's Professional PortfolioScott Wagner
 
UMUC Teacher Evaluation
UMUC Teacher EvaluationUMUC Teacher Evaluation
UMUC Teacher EvaluationScott Wagner
 
Signal Planning Considerations and Network Designs
Signal Planning Considerations and Network DesignsSignal Planning Considerations and Network Designs
Signal Planning Considerations and Network DesignsScott Wagner
 
Strategic Vision for the U.S. Army Signal Corps
Strategic Vision for the U.S. Army Signal CorpsStrategic Vision for the U.S. Army Signal Corps
Strategic Vision for the U.S. Army Signal CorpsScott Wagner
 
HIS 156 Lecture 2- The Bonds of Empire
HIS 156 Lecture 2- The Bonds of EmpireHIS 156 Lecture 2- The Bonds of Empire
HIS 156 Lecture 2- The Bonds of EmpireScott Wagner
 
scott wagner- research- kickapoo bibliography spring 2007
scott wagner- research- kickapoo bibliography spring 2007scott wagner- research- kickapoo bibliography spring 2007
scott wagner- research- kickapoo bibliography spring 2007Scott Wagner
 
Teaching Philosophy
Teaching PhilosophyTeaching Philosophy
Teaching PhilosophyScott Wagner
 
Teaching Philosophy
Teaching PhilosophyTeaching Philosophy
Teaching PhilosophyScott Wagner
 
HIS 665-Prospectus
HIS 665-ProspectusHIS 665-Prospectus
HIS 665-ProspectusScott Wagner
 
Battle Analysis Paper
Battle Analysis PaperBattle Analysis Paper
Battle Analysis PaperScott Wagner
 
S6 Duties and Responsibilities Memo
S6 Duties and Responsibilities MemoS6 Duties and Responsibilities Memo
S6 Duties and Responsibilities MemoScott Wagner
 
kickapoo digital copy
kickapoo digital copykickapoo digital copy
kickapoo digital copyScott Wagner
 
HIS 101-Syllabus Spring 2009
HIS 101-Syllabus Spring 2009HIS 101-Syllabus Spring 2009
HIS 101-Syllabus Spring 2009Scott Wagner
 
WH101 Sp 09'-Elements of Critical Analysis
WH101 Sp 09'-Elements of Critical AnalysisWH101 Sp 09'-Elements of Critical Analysis
WH101 Sp 09'-Elements of Critical AnalysisScott Wagner
 

More from Scott Wagner (16)

Scott Wagner's Professional Portfolio
Scott Wagner's Professional PortfolioScott Wagner's Professional Portfolio
Scott Wagner's Professional Portfolio
 
UMUC Teacher Evaluation
UMUC Teacher EvaluationUMUC Teacher Evaluation
UMUC Teacher Evaluation
 
Signal Planning Considerations and Network Designs
Signal Planning Considerations and Network DesignsSignal Planning Considerations and Network Designs
Signal Planning Considerations and Network Designs
 
Strategic Vision for the U.S. Army Signal Corps
Strategic Vision for the U.S. Army Signal CorpsStrategic Vision for the U.S. Army Signal Corps
Strategic Vision for the U.S. Army Signal Corps
 
HIS 156 Lecture 2- The Bonds of Empire
HIS 156 Lecture 2- The Bonds of EmpireHIS 156 Lecture 2- The Bonds of Empire
HIS 156 Lecture 2- The Bonds of Empire
 
scott wagner- research- kickapoo bibliography spring 2007
scott wagner- research- kickapoo bibliography spring 2007scott wagner- research- kickapoo bibliography spring 2007
scott wagner- research- kickapoo bibliography spring 2007
 
Teaching Philosophy
Teaching PhilosophyTeaching Philosophy
Teaching Philosophy
 
Task Organization
Task OrganizationTask Organization
Task Organization
 
Teaching Philosophy
Teaching PhilosophyTeaching Philosophy
Teaching Philosophy
 
HIS 665-Prospectus
HIS 665-ProspectusHIS 665-Prospectus
HIS 665-Prospectus
 
Battle Analysis Paper
Battle Analysis PaperBattle Analysis Paper
Battle Analysis Paper
 
S6 Duties and Responsibilities Memo
S6 Duties and Responsibilities MemoS6 Duties and Responsibilities Memo
S6 Duties and Responsibilities Memo
 
RETRANS SOP
RETRANS SOPRETRANS SOP
RETRANS SOP
 
kickapoo digital copy
kickapoo digital copykickapoo digital copy
kickapoo digital copy
 
HIS 101-Syllabus Spring 2009
HIS 101-Syllabus Spring 2009HIS 101-Syllabus Spring 2009
HIS 101-Syllabus Spring 2009
 
WH101 Sp 09'-Elements of Critical Analysis
WH101 Sp 09'-Elements of Critical AnalysisWH101 Sp 09'-Elements of Critical Analysis
WH101 Sp 09'-Elements of Critical Analysis
 

HIS 101-Sp09-Peer Review

  • 1. Peer Review Worksheet The ability to critique someone else’s work is an extremely valuable skill and can provide insight into the reviewer’s work as well. Briefly write down a few comments for evaluating the author in each category. Please be as specific as possible. 1. Introduction: Does the author grab your attention in the first sentence? Does the introduction move smoothly towards the thesis/argument, or is it unclear? Does the author take a firm stance in his/her thesis, or are they “on the fence”? 2. Body: Does the author use transition sentences? Is their a topic sentence for each body paragraph? Does the evidence match the topic sentence? 3. Conclusion: Does the author restate the thesis, either directly or indirectly? Does the author broaden out the significance of the argument presented in relation to world history? 4. Grammar: run-on sentences, correct spelling, subject-verb agreement, awkward sentence structure, comma splice, etc. Indicate whether there is a pattern or just a few cases.