SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Journal of Visual Arts Practice Volume 7 Number 1 © 2008 Intellect Ltd
Article. English Language. doi: 10.1386/jvap.7.1.75/1
Forming art: making and responding
Harry Jamieson Retired member of staff, University of Liverpool
Abstract
The aim of this article is to present ways of thinking about the visual arts from a
wide perspective. It is a theoretical paper with important implications for those
interested in understanding the deeper processes at work in art creation and art
appreciation. It deals with issues such as complexity and information and goes on
to show how they can be circumscribed under the general concept of relationships.
It is maintained that ‘making’ and ‘reading’ art is essentially a search for relation-
ships, which may be found in the form of the image, or the symbolism for which it
acts as a ‘stand-in’. In dealing with the concept of form, special reference to two
modes of form: the material form of the image, and the mental form of mind that
the image instigates in the viewer. It goes on to show the interrelationship between
sensitivity and skill, and the part they play in art creation and art appreciation. It
ends by pointing out that as an activity given to seeking and resolving relation-
ships, art can therefore be classified as a manifestation of intelligence.
Setting the scene
Visual art as practice and as a discipline within the educational curriculum
has less distinct or less prescribed requirements than other verbal/numerical
based disciplines. Nevertheless, as a ‘form-conceiving’ and ‘form-making’
process it shares common ground with them on the basis that they are also
engaged in the construction of form; for example, in the formation of
sentences, or in the formation of mathematical equations.
The main distinction is that, in the case of the visual, perception plays a
significant role, whereas the demands on perception in the case of the verbal/
numerical are, in most instances, minimal. Having said that, we need to be
reminded that in the formulation of plans and designs, and in the formula-
tion of ideas in the process of execution, visual art as practice is engaged in
conceptualization, thus it can be seen to have a foot in both camps: the
perceptual and conceptual.
The sensory nature of visual art, and the lack of a precise language to
convey the nuances that accompany its making, introduces a specific teaching
and learning problem. But this very problem can be seen as advantageous,
freeing the artist/apprentice/student from the constraints of formalized rules.
This is not to gainsay the fact that art as practice is not without procedures
and tacit knowledge, which are imbibed during the learning process and
further employed in practice. It is here that the role of the teacher/lecturer
is significant. He, or she, is invested with the responsibility for passing on
both formal and informal tacit knowledge, and thus establishing continuity
in the transmission of core or key processes in art education.
75JVAP 7 (1) pp. 75–84 © Intellect Ltd 2008
Keywords
form and forming
complexity
relationships
skill
sensitivity
perception
JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 75
This then leads to the question of what constitutes core or key elements in
the visual arts. And here we leave aside such questions as creativity and
aesthetics, which fall more in the province of value judgements. It takes
careful appraisal and research to uncover the many fundamental cues that lie
at the base of different art practices. When they are subjected to analytical
scrutiny, when questions are asked about the cognitive and ‘decision-making’
aspect of the task in hand, a new and more informed picture emerges of the
sensory/perceptual cues and cognitive demands of the learning process. First
of all, we must recognize that perception itself, the sensory aspect of knowing
and being aware, involves more than mere seeing. It involves judgements and
recognition of differences and similarities of which the learner may not be
initially or consciously aware. Moreover, although perception is always
engaged with presence, with things actually observed by the eye, it draws
upon past experiential knowledge, accessed through memory, when making
current appraisals. It is always a twofold affair, a conjoining of past and
present experience. Thus we can appreciate that, given the same event or
object to perceive, two people can educe different interpretations. Further-
more, decisions of a more openly cognitive kind have to be taken regarding
the appropriateness of the tools and materials that are specific to a particular
task in art production. It is this ‘thinking’ or intellectual aspect of art practice
that is rarely touched upon in any significant way in the debate about the role
of art in the curriculum, or of the artist’s place in society.
Having stressed the cognitive component in relation to the practice of
art-making, we are led to consider other issues, such as complexity and
information. It should be pointed out that throughout this article the term
‘information’ is defined in the sense that it is employed in information and
communication theory, and in contemporary research in neuro-psychology,
where the term is used to refer to two aspects of mental processing, i.e.,
conscious and unconscious.
Form and relationship
What also needs to be brought to the fore and considered in depth is the
connection between the terms form and relationship. All designs are the
product of ‘form-making’, i.e., making specific combinations within a uni-
tary whole. This is so whether the task is the creation of a painting or illus-
trations for print. But of even deeper significance for our interest in the
cognitive aspect of ‘form-making’ is to view the process essentially as a
‘relationship seeking’ and ‘relationship creating’ activity, the practical out-
come being the finished ‘form’. In taking this path, we focus more clearly
upon the active process of ‘art-making’, the arranging or creation of parts in
furtherance of a total form, the finished artwork.
Form as construction is none other than a series of relationships, the
interplay of parts. Seen in this light, we can portray art-making, of whatever
kind, as a forging of relationships. The artist or learner/apprentice is
engaged in juxtaposing parts and thereby establishing relationships
between them. This, we might say, is the active aspect of art creation, which
has cognitive dimensions besides the manipulation of tools and materials,
the physicality of ‘form-making’. Here we refer to the processes of the
mind, where plans are formulated and reformulated according to the exi-
gencies of the task or work in hand.
76 Harry Jamieson
JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 76
What has been said about ‘form’ in terms of the artist as ‘form-maker’,
and in particular the stress placed on the inner mental contribution to
form-making, can also be seen to have a counterpart in the demands made
upon the viewers of artwork. Although their role appears to be passive, in
contrast to the artist’s which is active, it does, in fact, call for participation.
The participation we have in mind here is the active perceptual involvement
of searching or scanning which the observer engages in when faced with a
visual presentation. The work, metaphorically speaking, offers itself, but the
viewer is called upon to participate by carrying out the mental task of join-
ing the parts that make up the whole; it is a task of unification. Seen in this
light, viewing or appreciating artwork is a constructive process, on the sur-
face it appears to be passive, but below, as a process of mind, it is active. In
those instances where the viewer as observer fails to make the connections/
associations created by the artist, this can lead to what we might term a
state of incomprehension. To comprehend always means to see or intuit a
connection with something, be it a word, an idea or a thing. In the case of
the visual arts, this can be extended to include connections between, for
example, colours, shapes or lines, and indeed any symbolic images or rep-
resentations that require decoding or call for exterior reference.
Always it is a personal matter. The form that the mind of the viewer
takes in observing the work will depend not only upon the form offered by
the artist but, additionally, the influence exerted by forms already laid down
in memory as a result of previous learning and experience. Here all kinds of
issues unfold; for example, the motivation to search for connections/
relationships, the availability in memory of the significance of any symbols
which may form part of the visual presentation, and familiarity with the
style/form when the work on view is part of a greater oeuvre. A mind already
prepared, ‘in-formed’ in our terms, to see the significance of the relation-
ships will naturally be ‘more in tune’ with the artist’s intention.
From an aesthetic standpoint, the relationship may, for example, be that
of colour, tone, line or shape, or alternatively of similarity or contrast. The
design, the artwork itself, only offers proximal spatial relationships. The
fusion of the parts takes place in the mind; it is here, metaphorically speak-
ing, that ‘gaps are jumped’, that the mind itself imposes a higher order
than the one given to the visual sense. A good example is that of optical
colour blending. The artist, by putting things (colours, tones, lines or sym-
bols) in juxtaposition, offers opportunity for viewers to respond in a variety
of ways; but he or she can never complete the task of making the mental
closures that seal the unity of the work. The final act takes place in the mind
of the viewer.
The place of skill
It could be argued that art as practice is, at its core, enveloped in the issue
of relationships. They can both be perceived, given to the senses, i.e., by
observation, or conceived, in which case it is a purely mental event. And
here we can introduce the notion of skill, of perceptual skill in particular, the
sensing and awareness of relationships. Such skill relates to the ability to
detect and to be aware of unfolding relationships, which might be by design
or purely coincidental, a matter of serendipity. Here we need to interpret the
term skill not in the pejorative way that art purists often use the term, but in
77Forming art: making and responding
JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 77
the way that it is used by theorists concerned with skills of a perceptual
nature. For those concerned with visual arts where time and movement
are integral parts of the process (e.g. video art and film), perceptual skill
theory is of particular significance. Here concepts such as seriality, cues
and anticipation can be seen to offer very useful ideas for those engaged in
work involving moving images.
Theorists in perceptual skills use the term to refer to competence in
dealing with sensory information. For our concern with the visual, this cen-
tres upon the perception of, amongst other things, colour, tone and line,
and their contribution to the unitary whole, the form. The perception of
form in its own right, without reference or concern for meaning, produces
an aesthetic response. On the other hand, a work of art may include signs
and/or symbols, which not only have to be perceived, but also decoded. It
is interesting to note that the aesthetic is only ever concerned with pres-
ence, with the properties of the image there before the eye. Whereas, when
symbols are incorporated into the work, there is a requirement for attention
to shift away from the image’s material presence towards something
absent, towards the idea for which it is merely a ‘stand-in’. In such a case
there is presence of a kind, an unobservable presence, but one that can be
raised to consciousness.
The point is that in either case, the perceptual or the conceptual, there
exists a need to search for relationships, which, in the case of aesthetics, is
centred upon the material form, while in the case of the symbolic, the
viewer is called upon to search for relationships which are contained only
in memory. The process of the search could be characterized in two ways:
(a) ‘reading for form’ (aesthetic), and (b) ‘reading for significance’ (meaning).
From the foregoing, we are now in a position to consider the informational
input to the mind from a particular work of art as having its source in either
its form, or its symbolic imagery, or as is often the case, in both.
The skill here lies in the artist’s ability to construct form, and to create or
appropriate symbols which resonate with prospective viewers. Secondly, the
viewer displays skill in his or her ability to be aware of the nuances of form,
and also in the ability to decode the cues or clues provided by symbols.
Additionally, art, as practice, invariably calls upon competence in han-
dling tools and materials, in this we include the whole range of supportive
material and aids that are commonly found in art establishments and
studios. This leads to a consideration of the notion of mastership, a term
with a good pedigree when applied to classical artists, and one that, in
itself, implies competence or skill acquired through practice. Thus we may
say that art as practice, as a learned phenomenon, displays mastership
when its skill base is founded upon a high degree of competence. What
that competence is in any particular instance can only be fully determined
by careful appraisal of all the factors which lie at the core of a particular art
production or procedure. And here we run into the problem of determining
the quality, and indeed quantity, of the sensory inputs which contribute
most to the unfolding of skill, to mastership of a task that may resist
verbalization. In art circles, as previously mentioned, the term skill often
carries negative connotations, and yet, when a careful analysis is made of
its place in artistic creation, it can be shown to be an integral part of the
whole process.
78 Harry Jamieson
JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 78
Sense and sensitivity
Another poorly understood concept in art education and practice is that of
sensitivity. It is invariably expressed as a personality factor, as, for example,
when it is used as a term to describe persons as being ‘sensitive’, of being
disposed to ‘feelings’, to the emotive side of human personality. But when
seen from the perspective of perceptual skill theory, that is, when it is seen
as a means of gathering information, of sensing events in ongoing situa-
tions, it takes on the more robust role of being an essential part of the
whole process. Seen in this light, it relates to a heightening of awareness,
which is a product of experience or learning through practical involvement,
the outcome of which leads to a gain in knowledge or awareness of the sig-
nificant cues surrounding a particular skill. Art as practice by its very nature
demands a keen awareness of visual cues, of being sensitive to certain fea-
tures that are essential to the task at hand. Thus when we, as educators or
instructors, shift our attention from the general to the specific, we are
called upon to define, in detail, the nature and kind of cues and procedures
that are essential to the learning of a particular practice task. To make man-
ifest these issues it is important, and necessary, to make a careful analysis
of the critical elements that combine in a particular practical situation. This
may call upon a research commitment to uncover that which may not have
been consciously appreciated beforehand. A particular problem in art edu-
cation and instruction is that of verbalization, the inability to tell what one
has learnt and knows only tacitly. However, as all those involved in art edu-
cation as practice are fully aware, demonstrations and practical engage-
ment often provide an answer to this kind of problem.
To return to the sensitivity issue, and taking further the issue of skill
which we can now appreciate is sustained by an awareness, conscious or
subconscious, of sensed events, it is apparent that the notion of sensitivity
as a personality trait is too simplistic; as a vital element in the execution of
a perceptual skill, in which we include its role in art production, it can be of
special significance.
Referring back to the discussion on relationships, we can speak about
being sensitized to relationships between, for example, colour and tone.
Furthermore, the ability to discriminate in the visual arts, particularly at the
aesthetic level, invariably requires a person to be sensitive, and here the
word is used in an active way, that of sensing differences, contrasts, simi-
larities, and repetition. In a more general sense it would appear to be more
profitable to think about sensitivity as a heightening of awareness. This
would free the term from its emotive baggage and show it for what it is, i.e.
an indispensable part of learning in the visual arts.
Beyond perception
In the foregoing description of the place of skill and sensitivity in art practice,
the emphasis has been placed on perceptual involvement, and here we note
that tacit learning and consequent understanding plays a significant role.
At this point, we shift attention to a consideration of intellectual issues of a
more formal kind, namely to those of information, complexity and entropy.
Art as design, as the formulation of ideas and the presentation of them
in some significant form, is a central issue in art practice and in art education.
And while the issue of what is significant or insignificant is open to conjecture
79Forming art: making and responding
JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 79
and cultural interpretation, what is not at issue is that the design aspect of
art and the ‘reading’ of art can be complex. In dealing with the interactions
created or observed between, for example, lines, colours, tones (aesthetic
function) and/or between objects, people or settings (representative func-
tion), the artist or student artist is dealing with complexity. For the viewer,
the task becomes one of perceiving order in complexity.
In an article in the art journal Leonardo, the authors Michael Mendes-
France and Alain Henaut (1994) made some interesting observations about
complexity in relation to, in their own words, artistic creation and percep-
tion. They went on to propose that complexity could be bracketed with
‘information’ and ‘entropy’, and that, essentially, they are three facets of the
same reality. In their concluding comments they went on to stress the
necessity of sensitivity and skill in the understanding of art, thus echoing
some of the central tenets in this article.
Here we enlarge upon the complexity, information and entropy factors
that the aforementioned authors raised. They are factors rarely touched
upon in art theorizing and yet, as will be shown, they are quite fundamental
to a fuller understanding of art-making and art appreciation. Firstly we will
focus upon the concept of ‘information’, then go on to that of ‘complexity’,
and then, to complete the trilogy, turn our attention to ‘entropy’. As a term,
entropy will be familiar to those with a knowledge of physics, but less so to
those from other disciplines. However, to lighten the load, it will be explained
more fully a little later.
About information
Information, as the word proclaims, has its roots in ‘form’, as can be seen
when it is taken apart to reveal ‘in-form’, or better still when it is shown in
its active role as ‘in-forming’. We may well view art practice as a mode of
‘in-forming’, of putting something into a form, the ultimate form being the
finished work itself. But what is of special significance is the shift from con-
sidering information as a commodity (for example, letters, notes, etc.), its
quality as noun, to its quality as verb (informing) (Jamieson 2007). This
shift of emphasis is of special importance to an understanding of the vital-
ity of information, enabling us to view it as a process, not simply as a thing.
In doing so, we can speak of the artist as ‘in-forming’ his, or her, work
through the form-ation of ideas and the practical in-forming of materials.
On the other hand, the viewer, as recipient, is called upon to ‘in-form’ his,
or her, mind in a particular way on observing an art production. In both
instances there is work to be done; the artist has the practical task of in-
forming his or her work, and the viewer has the mental task of in-forming
his, or her, mind, which may be done consciously or subconsciously.
From the foregoing it becomes apparent that the usual interpretation of the
term ‘information’ as being a commodity, e.g. a word or letter, fails to take
account of its role as action, although it could be argued that it can be a
prompt for action, i.e. set in motion a particular thought, a patterning of mind.
What has not been mentioned, and is of special significance to an arti-
cle on the visual arts, is that information, whether it is discussed in terms
of its normal usage as a commodity, or, as it has been portrayed here as
verb, as action, has to have a source. The primary source of information in
art is that given to the visual sense, which may be perceived directly without
80 Harry Jamieson
JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 80
any form of mediation, for example, drawing from nature, or indirectly
through mediated forms of communication, for example the whole range of
printed and pictorial forms.
Here we shift to a discussion of some theoretical ideas relevant to
our interest in information, in particular to the notion of ‘information
gain’. It is a term familiar to information and communication theorists
(see the work of Cherry 1961 for a fuller description of information as a
theoretical construct). Our interests centre upon the growth of informa-
tion through selection and discrimination, particularly as it relates to
vision. But we can go a step further and raise an even more fundamental
issue, that of difference. Selection and discrimination both involve an
awareness of difference.
Without the awareness of difference, without the ability to distinguish
one thing from another (in art terms this could be, for example, colour, tone
or proportion), there is little information to be found, and thus little to
engage or hold the attention of the beholder. Difference is not located in
time or space (Geoffrey Bateson 1980), it has to be thought, difference is a
relationship not a thing. However, through learning and experience an indi-
vidual becomes aware of difference(s) not previously noted, and thereby, to
use a colloquial phrase, ‘sees more in it’.
The idea of difference as an informational source places added empha-
sis on the active role of the artist as creator of information, of a person who
first of all perceives and/or creates designs from which difference can be
extracted from the interplay of the parts that make up the whole. By placing
things in juxtaposition within a design we can say that the artist offers
potentials for the observance of difference, but the viewer has the task of
what we might call ‘closing the gaps’. The way that the gaps are closed will
always be an affair of the individual, thus producing the individualism that
art always allows.
While Geoffrey Bateson’s theorizing on difference as an informational
source is significant to our understanding of the fundamentals of human
communication, from an art perspective we could propose a refinement by
including the concept of similarity. This could be placed at the lower end of
a difference continuum but, like difference in general, it is not given, it is
intuited. The important point is that whether we speak about difference or
similarity, they both require the existence of at least two entities. As states,
constructed in mind, they do not inhere in that which is observed, they are
mental constructs.
By juxtaposing elements within a design in certain relationships, the
artist presents opportunities for the observer to intuit differences or simi-
larities of a particular kind. The work itself, we might say, acts as a catalyst
for organizing/in-forming the mind of the observer, but the amount of
information extracted by the recipient is singular to that person. What can
be said is that when neither difference nor similarity is perceived or intu-
ited, there is, in information theory terms, no gain in information. And here
we might observe a connection with the oft used cliché, ‘It is all in the eye
of the beholder’. Here we have given it some deeper significance.
The comments above focus upon perception, the perception of differ-
ence and/or similarity arising from an awareness of impressions given to
vision, and their place as sources of information. But we cannot afford to
81Forming art: making and responding
JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 81
neglect the contribution that symbolism plays as a source of information in
art. Here we shift our attention from dealing with the acquisition of infor-
mation derived from direct perceptual observation to that of conception, a
non-observable faculty. A particularly good example is the use of imagery in
art, which, as icon, is intended to raise in the viewer a particular idea, e.g.
religious imagery. In effect it stands as metaphor, and, as with all metaphors,
the condition requires the existence of two things: the image/icon there
before the eye, and the idea for which it is only a ‘stand-in’. But as with per-
ception there is a gap to be filled, in this case it is between the material
image/icon and the repository of ideas stored in memory. A relationship
has to be established in the mind of the observer, and when no relationship
is found, or none that satisfies the intention behind the icon, its purpose as
metaphor becomes clouded or non-existent.
Thus again we come back to noticing the primacy of the concept of rela-
tionships in our enquiry into information. In the case of perception the
focus is upon observed relationships, which are heightened by the develop-
ment of visual acuity. In the case of conception, the relationships are unob-
servable, being in the mind; the focus here is upon what we might term
conceptual referability. In either case, perceptual and conceptual, relation-
ships have to be found or established.
Complexity
Complexity is related to information, in fact as a statement it conjures up
the idea of something bearing a multiplicity of relationships that are not
easy to resolve. But this begs the question of individual differences: com-
plexity to one person may be simplicity to another. Then again, from an art
perspective, a person viewing a work of art may say, ‘I can see nothing in it’,
implying that there is, to that person, no complexity to resolve in the first
place. The resolution of complexity can be a source of satisfaction, similar
in a way to the satisfaction that one experiences on having successfully
negotiated a route across unknown territory.
Art itself, as a productive activity, opens endless possibilities for the
creation of complexity and its resolution. The artist can create a form
with infinite relationships, which require the viewer to search carefully
for the variety of interconnections that the work offers. But as stated ear-
lier with reference to the concept of difference, there is always a demand
on the observer to ‘close the gaps’, to make the connections that unify
the parts. This involves searching and noting (mentally). In classical art
the work of Hieronymus Bosch provides a good example of complexity,
but it should be understood that non-figurative work can carry complex-
ity of a different order.
Order/disorder/entropy
The concept of entropy, as Colin Cherry (1961) wrote, ‘… is one of consid-
erable difficulty, and of deceptively apparent simplicity’. It has clearly laid
down rules for physicists. That being so, we shall aim to carry its message
and show its relevance to art in terms of everyday language.
In a descriptive sense, entropy is often referred to as a ‘measure of dis-
order’, and it is in this sense that we shall employ the term here. It has been
introduced because, as with information and complexity, it is concerned
82 Harry Jamieson
JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 82
with relationships, but in a negative way, with disorder. Trends in modern
art often seem to exemplify entropy, a lack of established order, but on
inspection, order of a different kind may be found. It is this that we need to
emphasize, and we need to be aware of the fact that artwork is initially cre-
ated on the basis of at least some disorder, that, as a task, it calls upon
things to be ordered, i.e. to in-form (put into form) the un-formed. In dis-
cussing entropy (disorder) in relation to artwork, the notion of chaos (defined
in the OUP dictionary as ‘formless void’) springs to mind, suggesting dis-
order, and yet, on inspection, it becomes evident that at least partial disor-
der is a necessary foundation for all artwork.
This reasoning is based on the fact that such work proceeds on the
basis of having something, an idea or medium, to be put into some form or
order. The finished work is the end of an ordering/forming process. The
process can be described as a search for, or the creation of, relationships, in
which order arises from disorder. The resulting order is given in space, usu-
ally within a frame. It becomes a presentation with a particular order, which
the viewer is called upon to comprehend, or in aesthetic terms, to find sat-
isfaction in its form ‘in its own right’.
The corollary to this is that when the viewer is unable to observe order,
when he or she fails to make the necessary connections that give unity to
the whole, there is an increase in entropy. The amount of entropy/disorder
is determined, not by the work, but by the viewer’s ability to perceive order,
although it must be understood that at any time the viewer can create his or
her own kind of order from the viewing experience, and thereby reduce the
negative effects of entropy.
In drawing attention to information, complexity and entropy as concepts
which have a bearing upon art, its processes and understanding, and return-
ing to the assertion by Mendes-France and Henaut that ‘they are the same
facets of the same reality’, we are now in a position to answer the question
of what is the basis of this reality. From the foregoing descriptions of the
three factors, information, complexity and entropy, it becomes clear that
what is common to them is their fundamental base in the idea of relation-
ships. Information, as a term concerned with form, is constructed on the
basis of relationships. Complexity is also concerned with form, and it is
bound up with multiplicity of relationships. Entropy, as a concept concerned
with disorder, is centred upon relationships, although in a negative way.
In art practice these relationships may be compact, invoking multiple
connections that call for subtle or careful discrimination of, for example,
colour, tone or shape. The artwork may be created to be knowingly dense,
or complex, in which case the viewer as observer is called upon to search
for connections/relationships in many directions. The more connections or
relationships that are found, the greater will be the information to that per-
son. Throughout, information has been emphasized not as a commodity
but as a product of mind that involves a search for relationships, but it is in
the awareness of difference that information has its ultimate source.
Relationships themselves always involve the idea of difference, a kind of
between ‘this and that’, the unity that we perceive is a result of the mental
‘gap jumping’ that we spoke about earlier. In aesthetics the awareness of
difference at subtle levels can be a source of satisfaction and indeed plea-
sure, which we might call an enlightenment provided by the senses.
83Forming art: making and responding
JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 83
Conclusion
What stands out clearly from the various strands that we have dealt with in
pursuing the fundamentals of art practice and art appreciation is the pri-
macy of relationships. Apart from the implications it holds for art theory,
this could be seen to be of special interest to those in the field of education.
In writing about intelligence, Rex Knight (1956) gave perhaps the most suc-
cinct definition of intelligence, which he described as ‘the eduction of cor-
relates’, which in plain English means none other than seeing or adducing
relationships. As the central finding of this article points to the primacy of
the perception and conception of relationships in art, we may conclude that
at its core the practice of art is a manifestation of intelligence.
References
Bateson, G. (1980), Mind and Nature, London: Fontana.
Cherry, C. (1961), On Human Communication, New York: Wiley.
Jamieson, H. (2007), Visual Communication: More Than Meets the Eye, Bristol:
Intellect Books.
Knight, R. (1956), Intelligence and Intelligence Testing, London: Methuen.
Mendes-France, M. and Henaut, A. (1994), ‘Art, Therefore Entropy’, Leonardo, 9:3,
pp. 219–221.
Suggested citation
Jamieson, H. (2008), ‘Forming art: making and responding’, Journal of Visual Arts
Practice 7: 1, pp. 75–84, doi: 10.1386/jvap.7.1.75/1.
Contributor details
The author has been engaged in aspects of the visual throughout his professional
career. After a period in art education, teaching and carrying out research into per-
ceptual aspects of learning, he moved to a full-time research post in the university
sector. He was a co-founder of the Department of Communication Studies at the
University of Liverpool, where he focused upon matters visual.
Contact: 45 Green Lane, Wallasey, Wirral, CH45 8JG.
E-mail: hghjamieson@btinternet.com
84 Harry Jamieson
JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 84
Forming art ; making and responding

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Discussing Artwork
Discussing ArtworkDiscussing Artwork
Discussing Artwork
Emily Valenza
 
7 how do you interpret an artwork
7 how do you interpret an artwork7 how do you interpret an artwork
7 how do you interpret an artworkcharlottefrost
 
Photography Analysis Support Sheet
Photography Analysis Support SheetPhotography Analysis Support Sheet
Photography Analysis Support Sheet
Z Hoeben
 
What is Art?
What is Art?What is Art?
What is Art?
Janet Ellis
 
What is Art?
What is Art?What is Art?
What is Art?
Gary Freeman
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Discussing Artwork
Discussing ArtworkDiscussing Artwork
Discussing Artwork
 
7 how do you interpret an artwork
7 how do you interpret an artwork7 how do you interpret an artwork
7 how do you interpret an artwork
 
Photography Analysis Support Sheet
Photography Analysis Support SheetPhotography Analysis Support Sheet
Photography Analysis Support Sheet
 
How to Formally Critique Art
How to Formally Critique ArtHow to Formally Critique Art
How to Formally Critique Art
 
What is Art?
What is Art?What is Art?
What is Art?
 
What is Art?
What is Art?What is Art?
What is Art?
 

Similar to Forming art ; making and responding

Essay Abstract
Essay AbstractEssay Abstract
Pro questdocuments 2015-04-05
Pro questdocuments 2015-04-05Pro questdocuments 2015-04-05
Pro questdocuments 2015-04-05arewull88
 
Theory of knowledge essay
Theory of knowledge essayTheory of knowledge essay
Theory of knowledge essay
Writers Per Hour
 
Essay About A Picture.pdf
Essay About A Picture.pdfEssay About A Picture.pdf
Essay About A Picture.pdf
Cheryl Barry
 
Investigating cognitive prosesses within a practical art context
Investigating cognitive prosesses within a practical art contextInvestigating cognitive prosesses within a practical art context
Investigating cognitive prosesses within a practical art context
ekinrashid
 
Agnostic Thinking Creative Writing As Practice-Led Research
Agnostic  Thinking  Creative Writing As Practice-Led ResearchAgnostic  Thinking  Creative Writing As Practice-Led Research
Agnostic Thinking Creative Writing As Practice-Led Research
Jim Webb
 
Art Exhibition Essay. Anderson University, SC
Art Exhibition Essay. Anderson University, SCArt Exhibition Essay. Anderson University, SC
Art Exhibition Essay. Anderson University, SC
Cierra Leigh
 
Visual Analysis Essay Sample. University of Arkansas Hope-Texarkana
Visual Analysis Essay Sample. University of Arkansas Hope-TexarkanaVisual Analysis Essay Sample. University of Arkansas Hope-Texarkana
Visual Analysis Essay Sample. University of Arkansas Hope-Texarkana
Leahona Lovato
 
Gestalt Final Thesis
Gestalt Final ThesisGestalt Final Thesis
Gestalt Final Thesis
Rede Ballard
 
Art & Aesthetics power point presentation
Art & Aesthetics power point presentationArt & Aesthetics power point presentation
Art & Aesthetics power point presentation
AkashVerma639361
 
Lewitt paragraphs on conceptual art
Lewitt paragraphs on conceptual artLewitt paragraphs on conceptual art
Lewitt paragraphs on conceptual artCCricket
 
Infographics aesthetic literacy
Infographics aesthetic literacyInfographics aesthetic literacy
Infographics aesthetic literacyPekka Ihanainen
 
Research proposal
Research proposalResearch proposal
Research proposaliekaamin
 
Design thinking
Design thinkingDesign thinking
Design thinkinglaldevyani
 
Visual Arts Education - its important role in Shaping Personality by Theodora...
Visual Arts Education - its important role in Shaping Personality by Theodora...Visual Arts Education - its important role in Shaping Personality by Theodora...
Visual Arts Education - its important role in Shaping Personality by Theodora...
Theodora Chandrinou
 
Art Appreciation Course
Art Appreciation CourseArt Appreciation Course
Art Appreciation Course
Scott Donald
 
Be prepared for the future
Be prepared for the futureBe prepared for the future
Be prepared for the future
beshirova
 

Similar to Forming art ; making and responding (20)

Essay Abstract
Essay AbstractEssay Abstract
Essay Abstract
 
Pro questdocuments 2015-04-05
Pro questdocuments 2015-04-05Pro questdocuments 2015-04-05
Pro questdocuments 2015-04-05
 
Theory of knowledge essay
Theory of knowledge essayTheory of knowledge essay
Theory of knowledge essay
 
Essay About A Picture.pdf
Essay About A Picture.pdfEssay About A Picture.pdf
Essay About A Picture.pdf
 
Investigating cognitive prosesses within a practical art context
Investigating cognitive prosesses within a practical art contextInvestigating cognitive prosesses within a practical art context
Investigating cognitive prosesses within a practical art context
 
Agnostic Thinking Creative Writing As Practice-Led Research
Agnostic  Thinking  Creative Writing As Practice-Led ResearchAgnostic  Thinking  Creative Writing As Practice-Led Research
Agnostic Thinking Creative Writing As Practice-Led Research
 
Art Exhibition Essay. Anderson University, SC
Art Exhibition Essay. Anderson University, SCArt Exhibition Essay. Anderson University, SC
Art Exhibition Essay. Anderson University, SC
 
Visual Analysis Essay Sample. University of Arkansas Hope-Texarkana
Visual Analysis Essay Sample. University of Arkansas Hope-TexarkanaVisual Analysis Essay Sample. University of Arkansas Hope-Texarkana
Visual Analysis Essay Sample. University of Arkansas Hope-Texarkana
 
Gestalt Final Thesis
Gestalt Final ThesisGestalt Final Thesis
Gestalt Final Thesis
 
Visual Literacy
Visual LiteracyVisual Literacy
Visual Literacy
 
Art & Aesthetics power point presentation
Art & Aesthetics power point presentationArt & Aesthetics power point presentation
Art & Aesthetics power point presentation
 
Lewitt paragraphs on conceptual art
Lewitt paragraphs on conceptual artLewitt paragraphs on conceptual art
Lewitt paragraphs on conceptual art
 
Infographics aesthetic literacy
Infographics aesthetic literacyInfographics aesthetic literacy
Infographics aesthetic literacy
 
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
 
Research proposal
Research proposalResearch proposal
Research proposal
 
Design thinking
Design thinkingDesign thinking
Design thinking
 
Visual Arts Education - its important role in Shaping Personality by Theodora...
Visual Arts Education - its important role in Shaping Personality by Theodora...Visual Arts Education - its important role in Shaping Personality by Theodora...
Visual Arts Education - its important role in Shaping Personality by Theodora...
 
DUHRING1
DUHRING1DUHRING1
DUHRING1
 
Art Appreciation Course
Art Appreciation CourseArt Appreciation Course
Art Appreciation Course
 
Be prepared for the future
Be prepared for the futureBe prepared for the future
Be prepared for the future
 

More from Ahmad Faizul

Rubric for creative thinkink
Rubric for creative thinkinkRubric for creative thinkink
Rubric for creative thinkinkAhmad Faizul
 
Rubrik pemarkahan dan penilaian pendidikan seni visual tahun 4
Rubrik pemarkahan dan penilaian pendidikan seni visual tahun 4Rubrik pemarkahan dan penilaian pendidikan seni visual tahun 4
Rubrik pemarkahan dan penilaian pendidikan seni visual tahun 4Ahmad Faizul
 
Uitm soal selidik disertasi
Uitm soal selidik disertasiUitm soal selidik disertasi
Uitm soal selidik disertasiAhmad Faizul
 
Research method chapter1,2,3 last
Research method chapter1,2,3 lastResearch method chapter1,2,3 last
Research method chapter1,2,3 lastAhmad Faizul
 
The importance of art viewing experiences in early childhood visual arts the...
The importance of art viewing experiences in early childhood visual arts  the...The importance of art viewing experiences in early childhood visual arts  the...
The importance of art viewing experiences in early childhood visual arts the...Ahmad Faizul
 
Forming art ; making and responding
Forming art ; making and respondingForming art ; making and responding
Forming art ; making and respondingAhmad Faizul
 
Pupillary responses in art appreciation effects of aesthetic emotions
Pupillary responses in art appreciation  effects of aesthetic emotionsPupillary responses in art appreciation  effects of aesthetic emotions
Pupillary responses in art appreciation effects of aesthetic emotionsAhmad Faizul
 
Art criticism through story telling
Art criticism through story tellingArt criticism through story telling
Art criticism through story tellingAhmad Faizul
 
Assessment practices in elementary visual art classrooms
Assessment practices in elementary visual art classroomsAssessment practices in elementary visual art classrooms
Assessment practices in elementary visual art classroomsAhmad Faizul
 
What if they believed us? how well prepared are art educators to deliver on t...
What if they believed us? how well prepared are art educators to deliver on t...What if they believed us? how well prepared are art educators to deliver on t...
What if they believed us? how well prepared are art educators to deliver on t...Ahmad Faizul
 
Art Education Just Like A Day At The Beach
Art Education Just Like A Day At The BeachArt Education Just Like A Day At The Beach
Art Education Just Like A Day At The BeachAhmad Faizul
 
Connections to the world ; visual art in urban schools
Connections to the world ; visual art in urban schools Connections to the world ; visual art in urban schools
Connections to the world ; visual art in urban schools Ahmad Faizul
 

More from Ahmad Faizul (16)

Ttct test
Ttct testTtct test
Ttct test
 
Rubric for creative thinkink
Rubric for creative thinkinkRubric for creative thinkink
Rubric for creative thinkink
 
Rubrik pemarkahan dan penilaian pendidikan seni visual tahun 4
Rubrik pemarkahan dan penilaian pendidikan seni visual tahun 4Rubrik pemarkahan dan penilaian pendidikan seni visual tahun 4
Rubrik pemarkahan dan penilaian pendidikan seni visual tahun 4
 
Uitm soal selidik disertasi
Uitm soal selidik disertasiUitm soal selidik disertasi
Uitm soal selidik disertasi
 
Research method chapter1,2,3 last
Research method chapter1,2,3 lastResearch method chapter1,2,3 last
Research method chapter1,2,3 last
 
Ed772
Ed772Ed772
Ed772
 
Proposal
ProposalProposal
Proposal
 
Article review
Article reviewArticle review
Article review
 
The importance of art viewing experiences in early childhood visual arts the...
The importance of art viewing experiences in early childhood visual arts  the...The importance of art viewing experiences in early childhood visual arts  the...
The importance of art viewing experiences in early childhood visual arts the...
 
Forming art ; making and responding
Forming art ; making and respondingForming art ; making and responding
Forming art ; making and responding
 
Pupillary responses in art appreciation effects of aesthetic emotions
Pupillary responses in art appreciation  effects of aesthetic emotionsPupillary responses in art appreciation  effects of aesthetic emotions
Pupillary responses in art appreciation effects of aesthetic emotions
 
Art criticism through story telling
Art criticism through story tellingArt criticism through story telling
Art criticism through story telling
 
Assessment practices in elementary visual art classrooms
Assessment practices in elementary visual art classroomsAssessment practices in elementary visual art classrooms
Assessment practices in elementary visual art classrooms
 
What if they believed us? how well prepared are art educators to deliver on t...
What if they believed us? how well prepared are art educators to deliver on t...What if they believed us? how well prepared are art educators to deliver on t...
What if they believed us? how well prepared are art educators to deliver on t...
 
Art Education Just Like A Day At The Beach
Art Education Just Like A Day At The BeachArt Education Just Like A Day At The Beach
Art Education Just Like A Day At The Beach
 
Connections to the world ; visual art in urban schools
Connections to the world ; visual art in urban schools Connections to the world ; visual art in urban schools
Connections to the world ; visual art in urban schools
 

Recently uploaded

Model Attribute Check Company Auto Property
Model Attribute  Check Company Auto PropertyModel Attribute  Check Company Auto Property
Model Attribute Check Company Auto Property
Celine George
 
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
rosedainty
 
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with MechanismOverview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
DeeptiGupta154
 
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumersBasic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
PedroFerreira53928
 
Language Across the Curriculm LAC B.Ed.
Language Across the  Curriculm LAC B.Ed.Language Across the  Curriculm LAC B.Ed.
Language Across the Curriculm LAC B.Ed.
Atul Kumar Singh
 
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdf
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdfThe Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdf
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdf
kaushalkr1407
 
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
Celine George
 
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdfSectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Vivekanand Anglo Vedic Academy
 
1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx
1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx
1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx
JosvitaDsouza2
 
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
Welcome to TechSoup   New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdfWelcome to TechSoup   New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
TechSoup
 
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free downloadThe French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
Vivekanand Anglo Vedic Academy
 
How to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
How to Break the cycle of negative ThoughtsHow to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
How to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
Col Mukteshwar Prasad
 
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdfHome assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Tamralipta Mahavidyalaya
 
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideasThe geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
GeoBlogs
 
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCECLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
BhavyaRajput3
 
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official PublicationThe Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
Delapenabediema
 
Fish and Chips - have they had their chips
Fish and Chips - have they had their chipsFish and Chips - have they had their chips
Fish and Chips - have they had their chips
GeoBlogs
 
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and ResearchDigital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Vikramjit Singh
 
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement EssentialsIntroduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Excellence Foundation for South Sudan
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Model Attribute Check Company Auto Property
Model Attribute  Check Company Auto PropertyModel Attribute  Check Company Auto Property
Model Attribute Check Company Auto Property
 
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
 
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
 
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with MechanismOverview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
 
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumersBasic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
 
Language Across the Curriculm LAC B.Ed.
Language Across the  Curriculm LAC B.Ed.Language Across the  Curriculm LAC B.Ed.
Language Across the Curriculm LAC B.Ed.
 
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdf
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdfThe Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdf
The Roman Empire A Historical Colossus.pdf
 
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
 
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdfSectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
 
1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx
1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx
1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx
 
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
Welcome to TechSoup   New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdfWelcome to TechSoup   New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
 
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free downloadThe French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
 
How to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
How to Break the cycle of negative ThoughtsHow to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
How to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
 
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdfHome assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
 
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideasThe geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
 
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCECLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
 
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official PublicationThe Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
 
Fish and Chips - have they had their chips
Fish and Chips - have they had their chipsFish and Chips - have they had their chips
Fish and Chips - have they had their chips
 
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and ResearchDigital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
 
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement EssentialsIntroduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
 

Forming art ; making and responding

  • 1. Journal of Visual Arts Practice Volume 7 Number 1 © 2008 Intellect Ltd Article. English Language. doi: 10.1386/jvap.7.1.75/1 Forming art: making and responding Harry Jamieson Retired member of staff, University of Liverpool Abstract The aim of this article is to present ways of thinking about the visual arts from a wide perspective. It is a theoretical paper with important implications for those interested in understanding the deeper processes at work in art creation and art appreciation. It deals with issues such as complexity and information and goes on to show how they can be circumscribed under the general concept of relationships. It is maintained that ‘making’ and ‘reading’ art is essentially a search for relation- ships, which may be found in the form of the image, or the symbolism for which it acts as a ‘stand-in’. In dealing with the concept of form, special reference to two modes of form: the material form of the image, and the mental form of mind that the image instigates in the viewer. It goes on to show the interrelationship between sensitivity and skill, and the part they play in art creation and art appreciation. It ends by pointing out that as an activity given to seeking and resolving relation- ships, art can therefore be classified as a manifestation of intelligence. Setting the scene Visual art as practice and as a discipline within the educational curriculum has less distinct or less prescribed requirements than other verbal/numerical based disciplines. Nevertheless, as a ‘form-conceiving’ and ‘form-making’ process it shares common ground with them on the basis that they are also engaged in the construction of form; for example, in the formation of sentences, or in the formation of mathematical equations. The main distinction is that, in the case of the visual, perception plays a significant role, whereas the demands on perception in the case of the verbal/ numerical are, in most instances, minimal. Having said that, we need to be reminded that in the formulation of plans and designs, and in the formula- tion of ideas in the process of execution, visual art as practice is engaged in conceptualization, thus it can be seen to have a foot in both camps: the perceptual and conceptual. The sensory nature of visual art, and the lack of a precise language to convey the nuances that accompany its making, introduces a specific teaching and learning problem. But this very problem can be seen as advantageous, freeing the artist/apprentice/student from the constraints of formalized rules. This is not to gainsay the fact that art as practice is not without procedures and tacit knowledge, which are imbibed during the learning process and further employed in practice. It is here that the role of the teacher/lecturer is significant. He, or she, is invested with the responsibility for passing on both formal and informal tacit knowledge, and thus establishing continuity in the transmission of core or key processes in art education. 75JVAP 7 (1) pp. 75–84 © Intellect Ltd 2008 Keywords form and forming complexity relationships skill sensitivity perception JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 75
  • 2. This then leads to the question of what constitutes core or key elements in the visual arts. And here we leave aside such questions as creativity and aesthetics, which fall more in the province of value judgements. It takes careful appraisal and research to uncover the many fundamental cues that lie at the base of different art practices. When they are subjected to analytical scrutiny, when questions are asked about the cognitive and ‘decision-making’ aspect of the task in hand, a new and more informed picture emerges of the sensory/perceptual cues and cognitive demands of the learning process. First of all, we must recognize that perception itself, the sensory aspect of knowing and being aware, involves more than mere seeing. It involves judgements and recognition of differences and similarities of which the learner may not be initially or consciously aware. Moreover, although perception is always engaged with presence, with things actually observed by the eye, it draws upon past experiential knowledge, accessed through memory, when making current appraisals. It is always a twofold affair, a conjoining of past and present experience. Thus we can appreciate that, given the same event or object to perceive, two people can educe different interpretations. Further- more, decisions of a more openly cognitive kind have to be taken regarding the appropriateness of the tools and materials that are specific to a particular task in art production. It is this ‘thinking’ or intellectual aspect of art practice that is rarely touched upon in any significant way in the debate about the role of art in the curriculum, or of the artist’s place in society. Having stressed the cognitive component in relation to the practice of art-making, we are led to consider other issues, such as complexity and information. It should be pointed out that throughout this article the term ‘information’ is defined in the sense that it is employed in information and communication theory, and in contemporary research in neuro-psychology, where the term is used to refer to two aspects of mental processing, i.e., conscious and unconscious. Form and relationship What also needs to be brought to the fore and considered in depth is the connection between the terms form and relationship. All designs are the product of ‘form-making’, i.e., making specific combinations within a uni- tary whole. This is so whether the task is the creation of a painting or illus- trations for print. But of even deeper significance for our interest in the cognitive aspect of ‘form-making’ is to view the process essentially as a ‘relationship seeking’ and ‘relationship creating’ activity, the practical out- come being the finished ‘form’. In taking this path, we focus more clearly upon the active process of ‘art-making’, the arranging or creation of parts in furtherance of a total form, the finished artwork. Form as construction is none other than a series of relationships, the interplay of parts. Seen in this light, we can portray art-making, of whatever kind, as a forging of relationships. The artist or learner/apprentice is engaged in juxtaposing parts and thereby establishing relationships between them. This, we might say, is the active aspect of art creation, which has cognitive dimensions besides the manipulation of tools and materials, the physicality of ‘form-making’. Here we refer to the processes of the mind, where plans are formulated and reformulated according to the exi- gencies of the task or work in hand. 76 Harry Jamieson JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 76
  • 3. What has been said about ‘form’ in terms of the artist as ‘form-maker’, and in particular the stress placed on the inner mental contribution to form-making, can also be seen to have a counterpart in the demands made upon the viewers of artwork. Although their role appears to be passive, in contrast to the artist’s which is active, it does, in fact, call for participation. The participation we have in mind here is the active perceptual involvement of searching or scanning which the observer engages in when faced with a visual presentation. The work, metaphorically speaking, offers itself, but the viewer is called upon to participate by carrying out the mental task of join- ing the parts that make up the whole; it is a task of unification. Seen in this light, viewing or appreciating artwork is a constructive process, on the sur- face it appears to be passive, but below, as a process of mind, it is active. In those instances where the viewer as observer fails to make the connections/ associations created by the artist, this can lead to what we might term a state of incomprehension. To comprehend always means to see or intuit a connection with something, be it a word, an idea or a thing. In the case of the visual arts, this can be extended to include connections between, for example, colours, shapes or lines, and indeed any symbolic images or rep- resentations that require decoding or call for exterior reference. Always it is a personal matter. The form that the mind of the viewer takes in observing the work will depend not only upon the form offered by the artist but, additionally, the influence exerted by forms already laid down in memory as a result of previous learning and experience. Here all kinds of issues unfold; for example, the motivation to search for connections/ relationships, the availability in memory of the significance of any symbols which may form part of the visual presentation, and familiarity with the style/form when the work on view is part of a greater oeuvre. A mind already prepared, ‘in-formed’ in our terms, to see the significance of the relation- ships will naturally be ‘more in tune’ with the artist’s intention. From an aesthetic standpoint, the relationship may, for example, be that of colour, tone, line or shape, or alternatively of similarity or contrast. The design, the artwork itself, only offers proximal spatial relationships. The fusion of the parts takes place in the mind; it is here, metaphorically speak- ing, that ‘gaps are jumped’, that the mind itself imposes a higher order than the one given to the visual sense. A good example is that of optical colour blending. The artist, by putting things (colours, tones, lines or sym- bols) in juxtaposition, offers opportunity for viewers to respond in a variety of ways; but he or she can never complete the task of making the mental closures that seal the unity of the work. The final act takes place in the mind of the viewer. The place of skill It could be argued that art as practice is, at its core, enveloped in the issue of relationships. They can both be perceived, given to the senses, i.e., by observation, or conceived, in which case it is a purely mental event. And here we can introduce the notion of skill, of perceptual skill in particular, the sensing and awareness of relationships. Such skill relates to the ability to detect and to be aware of unfolding relationships, which might be by design or purely coincidental, a matter of serendipity. Here we need to interpret the term skill not in the pejorative way that art purists often use the term, but in 77Forming art: making and responding JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 77
  • 4. the way that it is used by theorists concerned with skills of a perceptual nature. For those concerned with visual arts where time and movement are integral parts of the process (e.g. video art and film), perceptual skill theory is of particular significance. Here concepts such as seriality, cues and anticipation can be seen to offer very useful ideas for those engaged in work involving moving images. Theorists in perceptual skills use the term to refer to competence in dealing with sensory information. For our concern with the visual, this cen- tres upon the perception of, amongst other things, colour, tone and line, and their contribution to the unitary whole, the form. The perception of form in its own right, without reference or concern for meaning, produces an aesthetic response. On the other hand, a work of art may include signs and/or symbols, which not only have to be perceived, but also decoded. It is interesting to note that the aesthetic is only ever concerned with pres- ence, with the properties of the image there before the eye. Whereas, when symbols are incorporated into the work, there is a requirement for attention to shift away from the image’s material presence towards something absent, towards the idea for which it is merely a ‘stand-in’. In such a case there is presence of a kind, an unobservable presence, but one that can be raised to consciousness. The point is that in either case, the perceptual or the conceptual, there exists a need to search for relationships, which, in the case of aesthetics, is centred upon the material form, while in the case of the symbolic, the viewer is called upon to search for relationships which are contained only in memory. The process of the search could be characterized in two ways: (a) ‘reading for form’ (aesthetic), and (b) ‘reading for significance’ (meaning). From the foregoing, we are now in a position to consider the informational input to the mind from a particular work of art as having its source in either its form, or its symbolic imagery, or as is often the case, in both. The skill here lies in the artist’s ability to construct form, and to create or appropriate symbols which resonate with prospective viewers. Secondly, the viewer displays skill in his or her ability to be aware of the nuances of form, and also in the ability to decode the cues or clues provided by symbols. Additionally, art, as practice, invariably calls upon competence in han- dling tools and materials, in this we include the whole range of supportive material and aids that are commonly found in art establishments and studios. This leads to a consideration of the notion of mastership, a term with a good pedigree when applied to classical artists, and one that, in itself, implies competence or skill acquired through practice. Thus we may say that art as practice, as a learned phenomenon, displays mastership when its skill base is founded upon a high degree of competence. What that competence is in any particular instance can only be fully determined by careful appraisal of all the factors which lie at the core of a particular art production or procedure. And here we run into the problem of determining the quality, and indeed quantity, of the sensory inputs which contribute most to the unfolding of skill, to mastership of a task that may resist verbalization. In art circles, as previously mentioned, the term skill often carries negative connotations, and yet, when a careful analysis is made of its place in artistic creation, it can be shown to be an integral part of the whole process. 78 Harry Jamieson JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 78
  • 5. Sense and sensitivity Another poorly understood concept in art education and practice is that of sensitivity. It is invariably expressed as a personality factor, as, for example, when it is used as a term to describe persons as being ‘sensitive’, of being disposed to ‘feelings’, to the emotive side of human personality. But when seen from the perspective of perceptual skill theory, that is, when it is seen as a means of gathering information, of sensing events in ongoing situa- tions, it takes on the more robust role of being an essential part of the whole process. Seen in this light, it relates to a heightening of awareness, which is a product of experience or learning through practical involvement, the outcome of which leads to a gain in knowledge or awareness of the sig- nificant cues surrounding a particular skill. Art as practice by its very nature demands a keen awareness of visual cues, of being sensitive to certain fea- tures that are essential to the task at hand. Thus when we, as educators or instructors, shift our attention from the general to the specific, we are called upon to define, in detail, the nature and kind of cues and procedures that are essential to the learning of a particular practice task. To make man- ifest these issues it is important, and necessary, to make a careful analysis of the critical elements that combine in a particular practical situation. This may call upon a research commitment to uncover that which may not have been consciously appreciated beforehand. A particular problem in art edu- cation and instruction is that of verbalization, the inability to tell what one has learnt and knows only tacitly. However, as all those involved in art edu- cation as practice are fully aware, demonstrations and practical engage- ment often provide an answer to this kind of problem. To return to the sensitivity issue, and taking further the issue of skill which we can now appreciate is sustained by an awareness, conscious or subconscious, of sensed events, it is apparent that the notion of sensitivity as a personality trait is too simplistic; as a vital element in the execution of a perceptual skill, in which we include its role in art production, it can be of special significance. Referring back to the discussion on relationships, we can speak about being sensitized to relationships between, for example, colour and tone. Furthermore, the ability to discriminate in the visual arts, particularly at the aesthetic level, invariably requires a person to be sensitive, and here the word is used in an active way, that of sensing differences, contrasts, simi- larities, and repetition. In a more general sense it would appear to be more profitable to think about sensitivity as a heightening of awareness. This would free the term from its emotive baggage and show it for what it is, i.e. an indispensable part of learning in the visual arts. Beyond perception In the foregoing description of the place of skill and sensitivity in art practice, the emphasis has been placed on perceptual involvement, and here we note that tacit learning and consequent understanding plays a significant role. At this point, we shift attention to a consideration of intellectual issues of a more formal kind, namely to those of information, complexity and entropy. Art as design, as the formulation of ideas and the presentation of them in some significant form, is a central issue in art practice and in art education. And while the issue of what is significant or insignificant is open to conjecture 79Forming art: making and responding JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 79
  • 6. and cultural interpretation, what is not at issue is that the design aspect of art and the ‘reading’ of art can be complex. In dealing with the interactions created or observed between, for example, lines, colours, tones (aesthetic function) and/or between objects, people or settings (representative func- tion), the artist or student artist is dealing with complexity. For the viewer, the task becomes one of perceiving order in complexity. In an article in the art journal Leonardo, the authors Michael Mendes- France and Alain Henaut (1994) made some interesting observations about complexity in relation to, in their own words, artistic creation and percep- tion. They went on to propose that complexity could be bracketed with ‘information’ and ‘entropy’, and that, essentially, they are three facets of the same reality. In their concluding comments they went on to stress the necessity of sensitivity and skill in the understanding of art, thus echoing some of the central tenets in this article. Here we enlarge upon the complexity, information and entropy factors that the aforementioned authors raised. They are factors rarely touched upon in art theorizing and yet, as will be shown, they are quite fundamental to a fuller understanding of art-making and art appreciation. Firstly we will focus upon the concept of ‘information’, then go on to that of ‘complexity’, and then, to complete the trilogy, turn our attention to ‘entropy’. As a term, entropy will be familiar to those with a knowledge of physics, but less so to those from other disciplines. However, to lighten the load, it will be explained more fully a little later. About information Information, as the word proclaims, has its roots in ‘form’, as can be seen when it is taken apart to reveal ‘in-form’, or better still when it is shown in its active role as ‘in-forming’. We may well view art practice as a mode of ‘in-forming’, of putting something into a form, the ultimate form being the finished work itself. But what is of special significance is the shift from con- sidering information as a commodity (for example, letters, notes, etc.), its quality as noun, to its quality as verb (informing) (Jamieson 2007). This shift of emphasis is of special importance to an understanding of the vital- ity of information, enabling us to view it as a process, not simply as a thing. In doing so, we can speak of the artist as ‘in-forming’ his, or her, work through the form-ation of ideas and the practical in-forming of materials. On the other hand, the viewer, as recipient, is called upon to ‘in-form’ his, or her, mind in a particular way on observing an art production. In both instances there is work to be done; the artist has the practical task of in- forming his or her work, and the viewer has the mental task of in-forming his, or her, mind, which may be done consciously or subconsciously. From the foregoing it becomes apparent that the usual interpretation of the term ‘information’ as being a commodity, e.g. a word or letter, fails to take account of its role as action, although it could be argued that it can be a prompt for action, i.e. set in motion a particular thought, a patterning of mind. What has not been mentioned, and is of special significance to an arti- cle on the visual arts, is that information, whether it is discussed in terms of its normal usage as a commodity, or, as it has been portrayed here as verb, as action, has to have a source. The primary source of information in art is that given to the visual sense, which may be perceived directly without 80 Harry Jamieson JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 80
  • 7. any form of mediation, for example, drawing from nature, or indirectly through mediated forms of communication, for example the whole range of printed and pictorial forms. Here we shift to a discussion of some theoretical ideas relevant to our interest in information, in particular to the notion of ‘information gain’. It is a term familiar to information and communication theorists (see the work of Cherry 1961 for a fuller description of information as a theoretical construct). Our interests centre upon the growth of informa- tion through selection and discrimination, particularly as it relates to vision. But we can go a step further and raise an even more fundamental issue, that of difference. Selection and discrimination both involve an awareness of difference. Without the awareness of difference, without the ability to distinguish one thing from another (in art terms this could be, for example, colour, tone or proportion), there is little information to be found, and thus little to engage or hold the attention of the beholder. Difference is not located in time or space (Geoffrey Bateson 1980), it has to be thought, difference is a relationship not a thing. However, through learning and experience an indi- vidual becomes aware of difference(s) not previously noted, and thereby, to use a colloquial phrase, ‘sees more in it’. The idea of difference as an informational source places added empha- sis on the active role of the artist as creator of information, of a person who first of all perceives and/or creates designs from which difference can be extracted from the interplay of the parts that make up the whole. By placing things in juxtaposition within a design we can say that the artist offers potentials for the observance of difference, but the viewer has the task of what we might call ‘closing the gaps’. The way that the gaps are closed will always be an affair of the individual, thus producing the individualism that art always allows. While Geoffrey Bateson’s theorizing on difference as an informational source is significant to our understanding of the fundamentals of human communication, from an art perspective we could propose a refinement by including the concept of similarity. This could be placed at the lower end of a difference continuum but, like difference in general, it is not given, it is intuited. The important point is that whether we speak about difference or similarity, they both require the existence of at least two entities. As states, constructed in mind, they do not inhere in that which is observed, they are mental constructs. By juxtaposing elements within a design in certain relationships, the artist presents opportunities for the observer to intuit differences or simi- larities of a particular kind. The work itself, we might say, acts as a catalyst for organizing/in-forming the mind of the observer, but the amount of information extracted by the recipient is singular to that person. What can be said is that when neither difference nor similarity is perceived or intu- ited, there is, in information theory terms, no gain in information. And here we might observe a connection with the oft used cliché, ‘It is all in the eye of the beholder’. Here we have given it some deeper significance. The comments above focus upon perception, the perception of differ- ence and/or similarity arising from an awareness of impressions given to vision, and their place as sources of information. But we cannot afford to 81Forming art: making and responding JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 81
  • 8. neglect the contribution that symbolism plays as a source of information in art. Here we shift our attention from dealing with the acquisition of infor- mation derived from direct perceptual observation to that of conception, a non-observable faculty. A particularly good example is the use of imagery in art, which, as icon, is intended to raise in the viewer a particular idea, e.g. religious imagery. In effect it stands as metaphor, and, as with all metaphors, the condition requires the existence of two things: the image/icon there before the eye, and the idea for which it is only a ‘stand-in’. But as with per- ception there is a gap to be filled, in this case it is between the material image/icon and the repository of ideas stored in memory. A relationship has to be established in the mind of the observer, and when no relationship is found, or none that satisfies the intention behind the icon, its purpose as metaphor becomes clouded or non-existent. Thus again we come back to noticing the primacy of the concept of rela- tionships in our enquiry into information. In the case of perception the focus is upon observed relationships, which are heightened by the develop- ment of visual acuity. In the case of conception, the relationships are unob- servable, being in the mind; the focus here is upon what we might term conceptual referability. In either case, perceptual and conceptual, relation- ships have to be found or established. Complexity Complexity is related to information, in fact as a statement it conjures up the idea of something bearing a multiplicity of relationships that are not easy to resolve. But this begs the question of individual differences: com- plexity to one person may be simplicity to another. Then again, from an art perspective, a person viewing a work of art may say, ‘I can see nothing in it’, implying that there is, to that person, no complexity to resolve in the first place. The resolution of complexity can be a source of satisfaction, similar in a way to the satisfaction that one experiences on having successfully negotiated a route across unknown territory. Art itself, as a productive activity, opens endless possibilities for the creation of complexity and its resolution. The artist can create a form with infinite relationships, which require the viewer to search carefully for the variety of interconnections that the work offers. But as stated ear- lier with reference to the concept of difference, there is always a demand on the observer to ‘close the gaps’, to make the connections that unify the parts. This involves searching and noting (mentally). In classical art the work of Hieronymus Bosch provides a good example of complexity, but it should be understood that non-figurative work can carry complex- ity of a different order. Order/disorder/entropy The concept of entropy, as Colin Cherry (1961) wrote, ‘… is one of consid- erable difficulty, and of deceptively apparent simplicity’. It has clearly laid down rules for physicists. That being so, we shall aim to carry its message and show its relevance to art in terms of everyday language. In a descriptive sense, entropy is often referred to as a ‘measure of dis- order’, and it is in this sense that we shall employ the term here. It has been introduced because, as with information and complexity, it is concerned 82 Harry Jamieson JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 82
  • 9. with relationships, but in a negative way, with disorder. Trends in modern art often seem to exemplify entropy, a lack of established order, but on inspection, order of a different kind may be found. It is this that we need to emphasize, and we need to be aware of the fact that artwork is initially cre- ated on the basis of at least some disorder, that, as a task, it calls upon things to be ordered, i.e. to in-form (put into form) the un-formed. In dis- cussing entropy (disorder) in relation to artwork, the notion of chaos (defined in the OUP dictionary as ‘formless void’) springs to mind, suggesting dis- order, and yet, on inspection, it becomes evident that at least partial disor- der is a necessary foundation for all artwork. This reasoning is based on the fact that such work proceeds on the basis of having something, an idea or medium, to be put into some form or order. The finished work is the end of an ordering/forming process. The process can be described as a search for, or the creation of, relationships, in which order arises from disorder. The resulting order is given in space, usu- ally within a frame. It becomes a presentation with a particular order, which the viewer is called upon to comprehend, or in aesthetic terms, to find sat- isfaction in its form ‘in its own right’. The corollary to this is that when the viewer is unable to observe order, when he or she fails to make the necessary connections that give unity to the whole, there is an increase in entropy. The amount of entropy/disorder is determined, not by the work, but by the viewer’s ability to perceive order, although it must be understood that at any time the viewer can create his or her own kind of order from the viewing experience, and thereby reduce the negative effects of entropy. In drawing attention to information, complexity and entropy as concepts which have a bearing upon art, its processes and understanding, and return- ing to the assertion by Mendes-France and Henaut that ‘they are the same facets of the same reality’, we are now in a position to answer the question of what is the basis of this reality. From the foregoing descriptions of the three factors, information, complexity and entropy, it becomes clear that what is common to them is their fundamental base in the idea of relation- ships. Information, as a term concerned with form, is constructed on the basis of relationships. Complexity is also concerned with form, and it is bound up with multiplicity of relationships. Entropy, as a concept concerned with disorder, is centred upon relationships, although in a negative way. In art practice these relationships may be compact, invoking multiple connections that call for subtle or careful discrimination of, for example, colour, tone or shape. The artwork may be created to be knowingly dense, or complex, in which case the viewer as observer is called upon to search for connections/relationships in many directions. The more connections or relationships that are found, the greater will be the information to that per- son. Throughout, information has been emphasized not as a commodity but as a product of mind that involves a search for relationships, but it is in the awareness of difference that information has its ultimate source. Relationships themselves always involve the idea of difference, a kind of between ‘this and that’, the unity that we perceive is a result of the mental ‘gap jumping’ that we spoke about earlier. In aesthetics the awareness of difference at subtle levels can be a source of satisfaction and indeed plea- sure, which we might call an enlightenment provided by the senses. 83Forming art: making and responding JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 83
  • 10. Conclusion What stands out clearly from the various strands that we have dealt with in pursuing the fundamentals of art practice and art appreciation is the pri- macy of relationships. Apart from the implications it holds for art theory, this could be seen to be of special interest to those in the field of education. In writing about intelligence, Rex Knight (1956) gave perhaps the most suc- cinct definition of intelligence, which he described as ‘the eduction of cor- relates’, which in plain English means none other than seeing or adducing relationships. As the central finding of this article points to the primacy of the perception and conception of relationships in art, we may conclude that at its core the practice of art is a manifestation of intelligence. References Bateson, G. (1980), Mind and Nature, London: Fontana. Cherry, C. (1961), On Human Communication, New York: Wiley. Jamieson, H. (2007), Visual Communication: More Than Meets the Eye, Bristol: Intellect Books. Knight, R. (1956), Intelligence and Intelligence Testing, London: Methuen. Mendes-France, M. and Henaut, A. (1994), ‘Art, Therefore Entropy’, Leonardo, 9:3, pp. 219–221. Suggested citation Jamieson, H. (2008), ‘Forming art: making and responding’, Journal of Visual Arts Practice 7: 1, pp. 75–84, doi: 10.1386/jvap.7.1.75/1. Contributor details The author has been engaged in aspects of the visual throughout his professional career. After a period in art education, teaching and carrying out research into per- ceptual aspects of learning, he moved to a full-time research post in the university sector. He was a co-founder of the Department of Communication Studies at the University of Liverpool, where he focused upon matters visual. Contact: 45 Green Lane, Wallasey, Wirral, CH45 8JG. E-mail: hghjamieson@btinternet.com 84 Harry Jamieson JVAP_7.1_07_art_Jamieson 6/26/08 8:19 PM Page 84