In this webinar, Dr. Thao Nguyen discusses the exciting discoveries that her research team has made, debunks some common myths, and shares best-practices for data acquisition, analysis, and interpretation. Her in vivo studies of adult zebrafish cardiac electrophysiology rely on single-lead and multi-lead surface ECG in live anesthetized adult zebrafish.
Zebrafish is a popular high-throughput vertebrate model to study human cardiac electrophysiology, arrhythmias, and myopathies. One reason for this popularity is the purported striking similarities between zebrafish and human electrocardiograms (ECGs). While human ECG, discovered 120 years ago, remains a standard technique in routine clinical practice, establishing similar standards for routine adult zebrafish cardiac research faces unique challenges. Yet, in vivo surface ECG offers the single most practical, economical, if not unique, solution to study adult zebrafish in vivo cardiac electrophysiology and arrhythmias.
Fishing for Insights from Single-Lead and Multi-Lead ECG of Live Adult Zebrafish
1. Fishing for Insights from
Single-Lead and Multi-Lead
ECG of Live Adult Zebrafish
Thao P. Nguyen, MD, PhD
Associate Professor of Medicine,
David Geffen School of Medicine
University of California, Los Angeles
2. Dr. Thao P. Nguyen discusses the exciting
discoveries that her research team has made,
debunks some common myths, and shares
best-practices for data acquisition, analysis,
and interpretation.
Fishing for Insights from
Single-Lead and Multi-Lead
ECG of Live Adult Zebrafish
3. Fishing for Insights from
Single-Lead and Multi-Lead
ECG of Live Adult Zebrafish
Thao P. Nguyen, MD, PhD
Associate Professor of Medicine,
David Geffen School of Medicine
University of California, Los Angeles
Copyright 2021 T. Nguyen and InsideScientific. All Rights Reserved. @ThaoNguyenMDPhD
4. Can we really use zebrafish to study
human cardiac electrophysiology and arrhythmias?
4
5. Compared to human ECG,
zebrafish ECG looks strikingly similar
Human Zebrafish
Nguyen Lab, Cardiovasc Res 2020
Yan J et al, PLoS One 2020
Millan DJ et al, AJP Heart Circ Phys 2006
P
QRS
T
P
QRS
T
P
QRS
T
P
QRS
T
P
QRS
T
P
QRS
T
5
11. right arm left arm
left leg
-
+ +
lead I +
-
-
Einthoven’s triangle
Einthoven’s Law
II = I + III
Human Einthoven’s (bipolar) leads,
Einthoven’s triangle, and Einthoven’s law
Historical Perspective
11
12. right arm left arm
lead I
left leg
+
-
right arm left arm
left leg
-
+ +
-
12
Frontal electrical activity along the heart
short axis (lead I) vs long axis (leads II-III)
Historical Perspective
13. right arm left arm
left leg
+
lead I
Einthoven’s triangle
Human unipolar augmented limb leads
aVR, aVL, and aVF
Historical Perspective
aVR aVL
aVF
13
14. The Cabrera system is
a hexaxial reference system
Historical Perspective
+
lead I
aVR aVL
aVF
Cabrera system
0°
60°
180°
90°
-90°
lead I
120°
-30°
-150° aVR aVL
aVF
aVF
Q II Q I
Q III Q IV
14
15. Human Einthoven’s triangle defines
the main heart axis in Quadrant I (QI)
Right axis
Q II Q I
NORMAL AXIS
Q III
Extreme axis
Q IV
Left axis
-
+ +
lead I +
-
-
Historical Perspective
180°
90°
-90°
lead I
0°
15
16. A scientific preview
Perspectives
Understand the historical perspective
Appreciate the anatomical perspective
ECG Recording
Describe the four steps of ECG recording
Single-lead vs. dual-lead ECG recording
ECG Interpretation
Critique ECG recording quality
Interpret single-lead vs. dual-lead ECG
Applications
Diagnose arrhythmias and conduction blocks
Diagnose drug-induced cardiotoxicities 16
17. Zebrafish
Human 4-chambered heart vs.
zebrafish 2-chambered heart
Anatomical Perspective
Human
Frank Netter
Zhao et al, JoVE 2019
Two atria
Two ventricles
17
18. Human heart normal compaction vs.
zebrafish heart normal non-compaction
Two ventricles
Fishbein, G for Nguyen Lab
Human abnormal
non-compaction (NC)
C
NC
Zebrafish normal
non-compaction (NC)
Nguyen Lab
Bulbus
arteriosus
Atrium
Ventricle
C
NC
Human normal
Compaction (C)
Frank Netter
Ramnani D, WebPathology.com
C
NC
Anatomical Perspective
18
19. Zebrafish pacemaker activity starts in
the SA node at the sinus venosus (SV)
Sedmera et al, AJP Heart 284(4) 2003
SA node
Anatomical Perspective
19
20. Zebrafish atrioventricular (AV) ring
acts like the human AV node
Sedmera et al, AJP Heart 284(4) 2003
SA node AV node
Anatomical Perspective
20
21. Sedmera et al, AJP Heart 284(4) 2003
SA node AV node
Zebrafish two main trabecular bands
act like the human His-Purkinje system
Anatomical Perspective
Two main trabecular bands
(~His-Purkinje system)
AV node
Apex
21
22. A scientific preview
Perspectives
Understand the historical perspective
Appreciate the anatomical perspective
ECG Recording
Describe the four steps of ECG recording
Single-lead vs. dual-lead ECG recording
ECG Interpretation
Critique ECG recording quality
Interpret single-lead vs. dual-lead ECG
Applications
Diagnose arrhythmias and conduction blocks
Diagnose drug-induced cardiotoxicities 22
23. Human Zebrafish
Nguyen Lab, Cardiovasc Res 2020
P
QRS
T
Human & zebrafish ECGs look strikingly similar
but they were recorded from opposite leads!
P
QRS
T
rII
ECG Recording
23
24. Human lead II axis goes from right arm to left leg
at a +60o angle of orientation
right arm
left leg
-
+
Cabrera system
0°
60°
180°
+90°
-90°
Q IV
Q I
Q II
Q III
ECG Recording
24
25. Standard zebrafish ECG is recorded from lead
reverse II (rII) at a -120o angle of orientation
ADI Single-lead Bio Amp FE136
-
+
+
-
Cabrera system
0°
+60°
-120°
180°
+90°
-90°
Q IV
Q I
Q II
Q III
ECG Recording
25
26. The 4 basic steps of ECG recording ECG Recording
1. Setting up
2. Anesthesia Induction
3. ECG Lead Placement
4. ECG Recording
26
27. The 4 (+ 1) steps of single-lead ECG recording ECG Recording
27
29. ECG Recording
STEP 1b: Setting up the equipment
https://www.adinstruments.com/research/animal/autonomic/ecg
PowerLab
Data acquisition
LabChart
Software
SINGLE Bio Amp FE 136
Amplifier
DUAL Bio Amp FE 232
OR
29
30. ECG Recording
STEP 2: Anesthesia induction
Choose the appropriate anesthetics
Only tricaine (MS-222) is FDA-approved
Determine the minimal concentration needed
Capitalize on synergistic potency
Know anesthesia goals (level 4 of anesthesia)
Consult IACUC veterinarian for additional
guidance
Determine the route of administration
30
32. ECG Recording
The more leads, the better
if the test subject can afford chest real-estate
32
33. 33
ECG Recording
STEP 3b: Dual-lead placement (e.g., I & II)
to construct the 1st zebrafish Einthoven’s triangle
Zebrafish
lead I
+
-
-
+
tail
right left
Human
right arm left arm
lead I
left leg
-
+
+
+
-
-
Einthoven’s Law
II = I + III
34. 34
ECG Recording
A 6-leads for 2 deal!
Zebrafish concurrent recording
from leads I-II
DUAL Bio Amp FE 232 III
II
aVR
aVL
aVF
I
35. Human lead II
right arm
left leg
-
+
35
ECG Recording
STEP 3b: Dual-lead placement for lead II, then…
Zebrafish lead II
-
+
right
tail
ADI Dual Bio Amp FE 232
Zebrafish lead rII
ADI Single Bio Amp FE 136
36. Zebrafish
ADI Dual Bio Amp FE 232
lead I
+
-
right left
Human
right arm left arm
lead I +
-
36
ECG Recording
STEP 3b: Dual-lead placement for lead I
44. 44
ECG Interpretation
Fishing for insights from heart rate:
Heart rate variability (HRV)
Zhao Y, James N, et al. Cardiovasc Res. 2020 Jul 31
Lead rII
46. 46
ECG Interpretation
Fishing for insights from polarized amplitudes:
Direction of wave propagation
Zhao Y, James N, et al. Cardiovasc Res. 2020 Jul 31
Lead rII
47. 47
ECG Interpretation
ECG predictions based on polarized amplitudes
were confirmed by voltage optical mapping
Baseline
Basoapical repolarization
P
R
S
T
base
apex
Apicobasal activation
Zhao Y et al. Cardiovasc Res. 2020 Jul
31
H2O2-mediated Oxidative Stress
Late QRS inversion
Apicobasal repolarization
Early T wave inversion
Basoapical activation
Zhao Y, James N, et al. Cardiovasc Res. 2020 Jul 31
48. 48
ECG Interpretation
Zhao Y, James N, et al. Cardiovasc Res. 2020 Jul 31
Fishing for insights from durations:
Perturbation of wave propagation
Lead rII
49. 49
ECG Interpretation
QRS prolongation predicts
impaired ventricular activation in optical maps
Zhao Y, James N, et al. Cardiovasc Res. 2020 Jul 31
Baseline H2O2
Activation
Map
50. 50
ECG Interpretation
Zhao Y, James N, et al. Cardiovasc Res. 2020 Jul 31
Baseline H2O2
Repolarization
Map
QTc prolongation predicts
impaired ventricular repolarization on optical maps
Apex
Base
51. 51
ECG Interpretation
ST prolongation predicts
APD prolongation in optical maps
Baseline H2O2
APD
Map
Apex
Base
Zhao Y, James N, et al. Cardiovasc Res. 2020 Jul 31
52. Comparing human and zebrafish
Einthoven limb leads I-III
Zebrafish
ADI Dual Bio Amp FE232
Human
52
ECG Interpretation
P T
QRS
P T
QRS
P
T
QRS
P T
QRS
I
P T
QRS
P T
QRS
II
III
53. I
Like humans,
zebrafish manifests intra-lead polarity concordance
Human Zebrafish
+
+
+
+
+
II
III
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
- -
-
- -
53
ECG Interpretation
+
54. Like humans,
zebrafish show positive concordance in lead I
+
-
isoelectric
54
ECG Interpretation
+
+
+
I
+
+
+
P T
QRS P T
QRS
100
0
(%)
100
0
(%)
Human lead I (n = 24) Zebrafish lead I (n = 30)
55. The concordance in leads II and III is
positive for humans, but negative for zebrafish
Human Zebrafish
55
ECG Interpretation
II
III
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
- -
-
- -
56. What is the implication of human and zebrafish
opposite concordance in leads II and III?
+
-
isoelectric
56
ECG Interpretation
+
+
+
II
-
- -
P T
QRS P T
QRS
100
0
(%)
100
0
(%)
Human lead II (n = 24) Zebrafish lead II (n = 30)
57. 57
ECG Interpretation
Fishing for insights from dual-lead ECG:
Prediction of the three frontal axes between 0 and -120o
0°
-120°
lead I
58. 58
ECG Interpretation
Fishing for insights from dual-lead ECG:
Accurate determination of the main heart (QRS) axis in Q IV
I
II
III
aVR
aVL
aVF
Main heart axis
in Q IV
I
II
III
aVR aVL
aVF
59. In healthy adult humans,
all three heart axes are in Q I
Humans (n =24)
P axis
+46o
Q I
T axis
+39o
Q I
QRS axis
+51o
Q I 59
ECG Interpretation
60. Q I Q I
Q I
In healthy adult humans,
all three heart axes are in Q I
Humans (n =24) Zebrafish (n = 30)
P axis T axis
QRS axis
-70o -69o -51o
Q IV Q IV
Q IV
P axis
+46o
T axis
+39o
QRS axis
+51o
In healthy adult zebrafish,
all three heart axes are in Q IV
60
ECG Interpretation
Fishing for insights from dual-lead ECG:
First determination of zebrafish three frontal axes in Q IV
61. A scientific preview
Perspectives
Understand the historical perspective
Appreciate the anatomical perspective
ECG Recording
Describe the four steps of ECG recording
Single-lead vs. dual-lead ECG recording
ECG Interpretation
Critique ECG recording quality
Interpret single-lead vs. dual-lead ECG
Applications
Diagnose arrhythmias and conduction blocks
Diagnose drug-induced cardiotoxicities 61
62. Clinical relevance of zebrafish in the
diagnosis of arrhythmias
62
Applications
Sinus tachy-bradyarrhythmia
Zhao Y, James N, et al. Cardiovasc Res. 2020 Jul 31
Sinus bradyarrhythmia
Sinus arrest rescued by
ventricular escape rhythm
63. P
Clinical relevance of zebrafish in the
diagnosis of conduction blocks
63
Applications
Second-degree AV block type I
(Mobitz I)
Zhao Y, James N, et al. Cardiovasc Res. 2020 Jul 31
First-degree AV block
Third-degree AV block
(complete heart block)
Second-degree AV block type II
(Mobitz II)
P
R
R
R
R
R
R
P P
P P P P P
P
P
R
P
R
P
P
P
P
R R
R R R R
R
P P P P P P P
64. Source: Arthur Haines
Digitalis (Foxglove) plant
Clinical relevance of zebrafish Einthoven triangle for
in-vivo screening of ‘digitalis effect’ & toxicities
Source: wikipedia 64
Applications
65. Zebrafish recapitulates human ‘digitalis effect’
Sagging ST depression
Lead II
Lead I
Zebrafish
https://litfl.com/digoxin-effect-ecg-library
Baseline
STD
STE
Digitoxin
Human
Lead II
STD
65
Applications
67. Zebrafish recapitulates human ‘digitalis effect’
PR prolongation (first-degree AV block)
Lead II
Lead I
Digoxin levels of 4.7 mg/L
(therapeutic range 1–2 mg/L)
Lead II
Lead I
67
Applications
Zebrafish
Baseline
Digitoxin
Human
68. STD STD STD
Q
Q
R
Q
STE STD STD
Lead II
Lead I
S
Dual-lead beats single-lead zebrafish ECG,
such as in screening for ‘digitalis effect’
68
Applications
69. 69
Applications
Zebrafish recapitulates human
suppressant ‘digitalis cardiotoxicities’
Mobitz I
Complete
heart block
Mobitz II
P P P P P P P P P P P P P
P P P P P P P P P P P P
R R R
R R R
R R
P P
P
8:20 8:25
R R R R R R R R
R R R R
P P
P
71. 71
Zebrafish recapitulates human
hyperkalemic ‘digitalis cardiotoxicities’
Petrov DB. N Engl J Med 2012; 366:1824
Wide complex rhythm with sine wave morphology
(loss of P waves, QRS widening, and fused T waves)
Zebrafish
Human
I I
II
II
Ko 9.4 mmol/L
Applications
72. A scientific preview
Perspectives
Understand the historical perspective
Appreciate the anatomical perspective
ECG Recording
Describe the four steps of ECG recording
Single-lead vs. dual-lead ECG recording
ECG Interpretation
Critique ECG recording quality
Interpret single-lead vs. dual-lead ECG
Applications
Diagnose arrhythmias and conduction blocks
Diagnose drug-induced cardiotoxicities 72
73. Acknowledgements
NGUYEN LAB
Zebrafish Project
Yali Zhao, PhD
Binh Nguyen, MD
Nicholas James
Ashraf Beshay
Connie Chen
Morgan Yun
Andrew Lin
Thomas Issa
Michelle Tran
Faiza Bashar
Abram Wassily
Francia Lopez
Francia
Lopez
Morgan
Yun
Yali
Zhao
Michelle
Tran
Nicholas
James
Ashraf
Beshay
Faiza
Bashar
Abram
Wassily
73
74. Thao P. Nguyen, MD, PhD
Associate Professor of Medicine,
David Geffen School of Medicine
University of California, Los Angeles
Thank you for participating!
CLICK HERE to learn more and
watch the webinar