Ecodesign	
  meets	
  the	
  Built	
  Environment	
  




 An	
  EDC	
  and	
  CEW	
  Collaboration	
  
 Eoin	
  Bailey	
  
 Project	
  Coordinator	
  
Ecodesign	
  meets	
  the	
  Built	
  Environment	
  



Designing	
  a	
  ‘Towards	
  Zero	
  Waste’	
  Wales	
  
	
  
An	
  EDC	
  and	
  CEW	
  Collaboration	
  
	
  
Tuesday	
  November	
  29th	
  2011	
  	
  
Future	
  Inn,	
  Cardiff	
  Bay	
  
	
  
www.ecodesigncentre.org	
  
www.cewales.org.uk	
  
	
  
Facilitated	
  workshop	
  


 Question	
  1:	
  	
  	
  

 ‘What	
  issues	
  result	
  with	
  waste	
  in	
  
 construction?’	
  	
  
 	
  
Delegate	
  Responses	
  


 •  Poor	
  Design	
  
 •  Poor	
  Operations	
  
 •  Client	
  Pressure	
  
 	
  

 Q1:	
  ‘What	
  issues	
  result	
  with	
  waste	
  in	
  construction?’	
  	
  
Delegate	
  Responses	
  
 Poor	
  Design	
  
•    Bad	
  design	
  management	
  
•    Site	
  modiMications	
  due	
  to	
  poor	
  design	
  	
  
•    Bad	
  design	
  
•    InefMicient	
  designer	
  	
  
•    Material	
  selection	
  	
  




 Q1:	
  ‘What	
  issues	
  result	
  with	
  waste	
  in	
  construction?’	
  	
  
Delegate	
  Responses	
  
 Poor	
  Operations	
  
•    Fragile	
  building	
  products	
  	
  
•    Lack	
  of	
  recycling	
  /	
  reuse	
  solutions	
  	
  
•    Waste	
  removal	
  
•    Changing	
  Regs	
  
•    Problematic	
  waste	
  
•    Recycling	
  can	
  create	
  more	
  waste	
  
•    Bias	
  in	
  existing	
  systems	
  
•    Workforce	
  quality	
  

 Q1:	
  ‘What	
  issues	
  result	
  with	
  waste	
  in	
  construction?’	
  	
  
Delegate	
  Responses	
  
 Client	
  Pressure	
  
•    Time	
  Constraints	
  
•    Investment	
  cost	
  v	
  pain	
  
•    High	
  expectations	
  
•    Money,	
  lowest	
  cost	
  ethos	
  
•    Cost	
  pressure	
  
•    Low	
  cost	
  of	
  poor	
  quality	
  materials	
  




 Q1:	
  ‘What	
  issues	
  result	
  with	
  waste	
  in	
  construction?’	
  	
  
Facilitated	
  workshop	
  


 Question	
  2:	
  	
  	
  

 ‘What	
  is	
  needed	
  to	
  move	
  
 Towards	
  Zero	
  Waste?’	
  	
  
 	
  
Delegate	
  Responses	
  


 •  Design	
  
 •  Advice	
  &	
  Collaboration	
  
 •  Legislation	
  &	
  Direction	
  
 	
  

 Q2:	
  ‘What	
  is	
  needed	
  to	
  move	
  Towards	
  Zero	
  Waste?’	
  	
  
Delegate	
  Responses	
  
 Design	
  
•    Separation	
  of	
  materials	
  
•    Increased	
  recycled	
  content	
  
•    Modular	
  components	
  	
  
•    Off-­‐site	
  construction	
  
•    Design	
  for	
  recycling	
  
•    Design	
  for	
  demolition	
  –	
  deconstruction	
  
•    Standardisation	
  of	
  design	
  and	
  products	
  
•    Logistics	
  /	
  management	
  

 Q2:	
  ‘What	
  is	
  needed	
  to	
  move	
  Towards	
  Zero	
  Waste?’	
  	
  
Delegate	
  Responses	
  
 Advice	
  &	
  Collaboration	
  
•    Education	
  and	
  discussion	
  throughout	
  supply	
  chain	
  
•    Collaboration	
  between	
  life-­‐cycle	
  brief	
  client	
  
•    Guidance	
  for	
  actual	
  material	
  environmental	
  impact	
  	
  
•    Waste,	
  detrimental	
  to	
  the	
  environment	
  -­‐	
  deMine	
  clearly	
  
•    Communication	
  of	
  true	
  value	
  –	
  Greenwash	
  
•    Identify	
  true	
  environmental	
  properties	
  of	
  materials	
  
•    Finding	
  a	
  partner	
  –	
  symbiosis	
  
•    Integrated	
  supply	
  chain	
  

 Q2:	
  ‘What	
  is	
  needed	
  to	
  move	
  Towards	
  Zero	
  Waste?’	
  	
  
Delegate	
  Responses	
  
 Legislation	
  &	
  Direction	
  
•    End	
  of	
  life	
  /	
  use	
  
•    Polluter	
  pays	
  =	
  client	
  
•    E-­‐tagging	
  –	
  reuse	
  
•    Planning	
  to	
  include	
  reuse	
  requirements	
  
•    LandMill	
  Tax	
  
•    Assumed	
  usage	
  –	
  EOL	
  
•    Producer	
  responsibility	
  
•    Enforcement	
  /	
  incentive	
  
 Q2:	
  ‘What	
  is	
  needed	
  to	
  move	
  Towards	
  Zero	
  Waste?’	
  	
  
Facilitated	
  workshop	
  


 Statement	
  Answer	
  to:	
  	
  	
  

 ‘How	
  does	
  Construction	
  in	
  Wales	
  
 move	
  Towards	
  Zero	
  Waste?’	
  	
  
 	
  
Delegate	
  Responses	
  
 Group	
  1	
  Statement:	
  

“There	
  is	
  a	
  need	
  for	
  a	
  variety	
  of	
  drivers,	
  	
  
enforcement,	
  education	
  and	
  guidance	
  for	
  	
  
clients	
  to	
  design	
  out	
  waste”.	
  



 Q2:	
  ‘How	
  does	
  Construction	
  in	
  Wales	
  move	
  Towards	
  Zero	
  Waste?’	
  	
  
Delegate	
  Responses	
  
 Group	
  2	
  Statement:	
  

“There	
  is	
  a	
  need	
  for	
  responsibility	
  to	
  be	
  allocated	
  	
  
at	
  every	
  stage	
  of	
  the	
  process.	
  This	
  should	
  	
  
be	
  achieved	
  through	
  legislation	
  and	
  education,	
  	
  
effective	
  collaboration	
  and	
  integration”.	
  


 Q2:	
  ‘How	
  does	
  Construction	
  in	
  Wales	
  move	
  Towards	
  Zero	
  Waste?’	
  	
  
Delegate	
  Opinions	
  


 Invitation	
  to	
  respond:	
  	
  	
  

 ‘How	
  do	
  you	
  feel	
  Construction	
  
 in	
  Wales	
  could	
  move	
  Towards	
  
 Zero	
  Waste?’	
  	
  
 	
  Please	
  contact	
  Eoin	
  
 eoin@edcw.org	
  
www.ecodesigncentre.org	
  
	
  




Eoin	
  Bailey:	
  eoin@edcw.org	
  
Blog:	
  www.edcshare.org	
  
	
  

EDC meets the Built Environment Event Summary

  • 1.
    Ecodesign  meets  the  Built  Environment   An  EDC  and  CEW  Collaboration   Eoin  Bailey   Project  Coordinator  
  • 2.
    Ecodesign  meets  the  Built  Environment   Designing  a  ‘Towards  Zero  Waste’  Wales     An  EDC  and  CEW  Collaboration     Tuesday  November  29th  2011     Future  Inn,  Cardiff  Bay     www.ecodesigncentre.org   www.cewales.org.uk    
  • 3.
    Facilitated  workshop   Question  1:       ‘What  issues  result  with  waste  in   construction?’      
  • 4.
    Delegate  Responses   •  Poor  Design   •  Poor  Operations   •  Client  Pressure     Q1:  ‘What  issues  result  with  waste  in  construction?’    
  • 5.
    Delegate  Responses   Poor  Design   •  Bad  design  management   •  Site  modiMications  due  to  poor  design     •  Bad  design   •  InefMicient  designer     •  Material  selection     Q1:  ‘What  issues  result  with  waste  in  construction?’    
  • 6.
    Delegate  Responses   Poor  Operations   •  Fragile  building  products     •  Lack  of  recycling  /  reuse  solutions     •  Waste  removal   •  Changing  Regs   •  Problematic  waste   •  Recycling  can  create  more  waste   •  Bias  in  existing  systems   •  Workforce  quality   Q1:  ‘What  issues  result  with  waste  in  construction?’    
  • 7.
    Delegate  Responses   Client  Pressure   •  Time  Constraints   •  Investment  cost  v  pain   •  High  expectations   •  Money,  lowest  cost  ethos   •  Cost  pressure   •  Low  cost  of  poor  quality  materials   Q1:  ‘What  issues  result  with  waste  in  construction?’    
  • 8.
    Facilitated  workshop   Question  2:       ‘What  is  needed  to  move   Towards  Zero  Waste?’      
  • 9.
    Delegate  Responses   •  Design   •  Advice  &  Collaboration   •  Legislation  &  Direction     Q2:  ‘What  is  needed  to  move  Towards  Zero  Waste?’    
  • 10.
    Delegate  Responses   Design   •  Separation  of  materials   •  Increased  recycled  content   •  Modular  components     •  Off-­‐site  construction   •  Design  for  recycling   •  Design  for  demolition  –  deconstruction   •  Standardisation  of  design  and  products   •  Logistics  /  management   Q2:  ‘What  is  needed  to  move  Towards  Zero  Waste?’    
  • 11.
    Delegate  Responses   Advice  &  Collaboration   •  Education  and  discussion  throughout  supply  chain   •  Collaboration  between  life-­‐cycle  brief  client   •  Guidance  for  actual  material  environmental  impact     •  Waste,  detrimental  to  the  environment  -­‐  deMine  clearly   •  Communication  of  true  value  –  Greenwash   •  Identify  true  environmental  properties  of  materials   •  Finding  a  partner  –  symbiosis   •  Integrated  supply  chain   Q2:  ‘What  is  needed  to  move  Towards  Zero  Waste?’    
  • 12.
    Delegate  Responses   Legislation  &  Direction   •  End  of  life  /  use   •  Polluter  pays  =  client   •  E-­‐tagging  –  reuse   •  Planning  to  include  reuse  requirements   •  LandMill  Tax   •  Assumed  usage  –  EOL   •  Producer  responsibility   •  Enforcement  /  incentive   Q2:  ‘What  is  needed  to  move  Towards  Zero  Waste?’    
  • 13.
    Facilitated  workshop   Statement  Answer  to:       ‘How  does  Construction  in  Wales   move  Towards  Zero  Waste?’      
  • 14.
    Delegate  Responses   Group  1  Statement:   “There  is  a  need  for  a  variety  of  drivers,     enforcement,  education  and  guidance  for     clients  to  design  out  waste”.   Q2:  ‘How  does  Construction  in  Wales  move  Towards  Zero  Waste?’    
  • 15.
    Delegate  Responses   Group  2  Statement:   “There  is  a  need  for  responsibility  to  be  allocated     at  every  stage  of  the  process.  This  should     be  achieved  through  legislation  and  education,     effective  collaboration  and  integration”.   Q2:  ‘How  does  Construction  in  Wales  move  Towards  Zero  Waste?’    
  • 16.
    Delegate  Opinions   Invitation  to  respond:       ‘How  do  you  feel  Construction   in  Wales  could  move  Towards   Zero  Waste?’      Please  contact  Eoin   eoin@edcw.org  
  • 17.
    www.ecodesigncentre.org     Eoin  Bailey:  eoin@edcw.org   Blog:  www.edcshare.org