diario de sesiones

1. 7=4E=B 78 F8F=BA8F 78? 6BA;E8FB 78 ?BF 7=CHG47BF
6B@=F=BA8F
AvX& +, - PQ MN]UW PQ *(). CqS& *
FQ MN]Q WM ^Q^UuY M WM^ PUQe d _]QUY_M XUY`_Z^ PQ WM XMtMYM&
CEBCBF=6=BA8F AB 78 ?8K2
f E8?4G=I4 4 ?BF =A68A7=BF FH9E=7BF 8A 4FGHE=4F 8A 8? @8F 78 7=6=8@5E8 78 *()- K
CE=@8EBF 7m4F 78 8A8EB 78 *().& CE8F8AG474 CBE 8? ;EHCB C4E?4@8AG4E=B @=JGB&
"AvXQ]Z PQ Qc[QPUQY_Q ).)'((((()#&
; cU}_b CE8F=78AG82 IU}_b|Qc% fQ]_c Q TQb S_]YU^i_ Q Q cUcY~^% Seh_ _bTU^ TU T|Q S_]_ d_T_c
RYU^ S_^_SU^ S_^cYcdU U^ U TURQdU h Q Q`b_RQSY~^% U^ ce SQc_% TU `b_`_cYSY_^Uc ^_ TU Uh' ;^ `bY^SY`Y_%
cY Uc `QbUSU RYU^% Qe^aeU h_ SbU_ aeU ^_ fQ Q cUb U SQc_% `_Tb|Q]_c VYZQb Q X_bQ TU f_dQSY~^ Q `QbdYb TU
Qc T_SU h ]UTYQ' N_ ce`_^W_ aeU cU bUdbQcQby e^ `_S_% `Ub_ Uc `bUVUbYRU aeUTQb^_c S_bd_c h cY eUW_ XQh
aeU cUWeYb S_^ Q 8_]YcY~^% `eUc cU QQbWQ'
GeYUb_ bUS_bTQb aeU U^ Q bUe^Y~^ TU Q CUcQ h `_bdQf_SUc TU `QcQT_ ,) TU ]Qbi_ cU QS_bT~ aeU _c
dYU]`_c VeUbQ^ TU SY^S_ ]Y^ed_c `QbQ U Wbe`_ Qed_b TU Q `b_`eUcdQ% TU dbUc ]Y^ed_c `QbQ _c Wbe`_c
U^]U^TQ^dUc h TU dbUc ]Y^ed_c `QbQ Q VYZQSY~^ TU `_cYSY~^ TU bUcd_ TU _c Wbe`_c' 6cY]Yc]_% aeYUb_
bUS_bTQbUc aeU Qc `b_`_cYSY~^ ^_ TU Uh cU f_dQ^ U^ ce Y^dUWbYTQT% S_^ Qc U^]YU^TQc QSU`dQTQc% cUQ^
dbQ^cQSSY_^QUc _ ^_' IY cU f_dQ Q `b_`_cYSY~^ ^_ TU Uh U^ cec `b_`Y_c d{b]Y^_c% cY^ U^]YU^TQc% c__
SQRU^ f_dQSY_^Uc cU`QbQTQc TU dUgd_ TU Q FDB% cY ^_ cU _`_^U U Wbe`_ Qed_b TU Q ]Yc]Q'
IY^ ]yc% `QcQ]_c Q TURQdU TU Q `bY]UbQ `b_`_cYSY~^ ^_ TU Uh `bUcU^dQTQ `_b U =be`_ CYgd_% <_b_
6cdebYQc' "8W ^QtZ] FMWaMPZ] 4]XQYPq]Ue [UPQ WM [MWMN]M#& IU}_b IQfQT_b'
; cU}_b F4?I47BE 4E@8A7kE=L2 IU}_b `bUcYTU^dU% Y^dUbfU^W_ `_b e^Q SeUcdY~^ TU _bTU^% `QbQ
c_YSYdQb ce fU^YQ h `QbQ ]Q^YVUcdQb aeU cUby U dYdeQb `b_`_^U^dU TU UcdQ FDB TU^db_ TU =be`_ CYgd_% <_b_
6cdebYQc% aeYU^ Y^dUbfU^Tby U^ UcdU Qce^d_'
=bQSYQc'
; cU}_b CE8F=78AG82 CeSXQc WbQSYQc% cU}_b IQfQT_b' D_ XQh ^Y^W•^ `b_RU]Q'
6 S_^dY^eQSY~^ TURQdYbU]_c Q `b_`_cYSY~^ ^_ TU Uh TU =be`_ CYgd_% `bUcU^dQTQ `_b <_b_ 6cdebYQc h
TUVU^TYTQ `_b ce bU`bUcU^dQ^dU% bUQdYfQ Q _c Y^SU^TY_c ceVbYT_c U^ 6cdebYQc U^ U ]Uc TU TYSYU]RbU
TU +)*. h `bY]Ub_c T|Qc TU U^Ub_ TU +)*/' BUc `UTYb|Q% `_b VQf_b% aeU Q _RZUd_ TU VQSYYdQb U dbQRQZ_ TU
UcdQ CUcQ h UcdQ FbUcYTU^SYQ cU QdU^WQ^ _ ]ygY]_ `_cYRU Q _c dYU]`_c aeU ecdUTUc ]Yc]_c QS_bTQb_^'
8_]_ fQ Q cUb TUVU^TYTQ `_b U bU`bUcU^dQ^dU TU <_b_ 6cdebYQc% dYU^U Q `QQRbQ U cU}_b CQbd|^Ui
ERQ^SQ'
CeSXQc WbQSYQc'
; cU}_b @4EGmA8L B5?4A642 CeSXQc WbQSYQc% cU}_b `bUcYTU^dU'
Ceh ReU^_c T|Qc Q d_T_c' 6cdebYQc ceVbY~ U^dbU U *2 TYSYU]RbU TU `QcQT_ Q}_ +)*. h _c `bY]Ub_c T|Qc
TU +)*/ e^Q Y^ecYdQTQ ceSUcY~^ TU fYbeU^d_c Y^SU^TY_c V_bUcdQUc% aeU QVUSdQb_^ Q .1 TU cec 01 ]e^YSY`Y_c
h SQSY^Qb_^% cUW•^ U RQQ^SU _VYSYQ% ]yc TU *++ [Y~]Udb_c SeQTbQT_c' ;^ e^ c__ T|Q cU UWQb_^ Q
S_^dQRYYiQb *-0 V_S_c cY]edy^U_c TU VeUW_' FUb]|dQ^]U Q`b_fUSXQb ]Y `bUcU^SYQ U^ UcdQ Y]`_bdQ^dU
dbYRe^Q ^QSY_^Q% S_]_ Uc Q 8_]YcY~^ TU ?^dUbY_b% `QbQ ce]Qb e^Q fUi ]yc Q f_i TU <_b_ Q Qc ]eUcdbQc
TU WbQdYdeT XQSYQ d_T_c QaeU_c UVUSdYf_c TU Qc <eUbiQc h 8eUb`_c TU IUWebYTQT% SYfYUc h ]YYdQbUc%
f_e^dQbY_c% fUSY^_c% eWQbU}_c% UdS{dUbQ% aeU `QbdYSY`Qb_^ U^ U S_]RQdU S_^dbQ U VeUW_ U^ QaeUQc
Z_b^QTQc Q^WecdY_cQc U Y^dUb]Y^QRUc% Q fUSUc U^ U^d_b^_c TU WbQ^ bYUcW_' GeYUb_ aeU aeUTU S_^cdQ^SYQ
dQ]RY{^ TU ^eUcdb_ dbYRed_ `~cde]_ Q `Y_d_ T_^ @_c{ 6^d_^Y_ H_Tb|WeUi 7QZ_% aeU VQUSY~ Q _c ]Q^T_c
TU ce XUYS~`dUb_ U^ Qc S_]`UZQc dQbUQc TU UgdY^SY~^ TU Qc Q]Qc TUSQbQTQc U^ U ]e^YSY`Y_ TU FQbbUc'
BQ _UQTQ TU Y^SU^TY_c VQf_bUSYTQ `_b e^Qc SQeb_cQc S_^TYSY_^Uc SY]ydYSQc UgSU`SY_^QUc U^ U Y^YSY_
TU Y^fYUb^_ VeU dQ^ WU^UbQYiQTQ% dQ^ `b__^WQTQ U^ U dYU]`_ h U^ ^_ `_S_c SQc_c dQ^ QQb]Q^dU aeU TU
XUSX_ Q @e^dQ =U^UbQ TU FbY^SY`QT_ TU 6cdebYQc XQ SbUQT_ e^Q S_]YcY~^ TU Y^fUcdYWQSY~^ `QbQ]U^dQbYQ
aeUS_]U^iQbyceQSdYfYTQT]Q}Q^Q]Yc]_'J_T_U_%`_bce`eUcd_%cY^]U^_cSQR_TUQcS_bbUc`_^TYU^dUc
`UcaeYcQc _VYSYQUc TU Qc <eUbiQc h 8eUb`_c TU IUWebYTQT TU ;cdQT_% aeU Ucdy^ bUQYiQ^T_% h Qc
bUc`_^cQRYYTQTUc aeU ce SQc_ TUdUb]Y^U Qc Qed_bYTQTUc ZeTYSYQUc U^ _c TYVUbU^dUc `b_SUTY]YU^d_c
QRYUbd_c'
IU}_b|Qc% S_^ UcdQ `b_`_cYSY~^ ^_ TU Uh aeUbU]_c Q`UQb Q Qc VQSedQTUc UgdbQ_bTY^QbYQc TU =_RYUb^_
aeU Ucdy^% U^dbU _dbQc U]UbWU^SYQc% `QbQ ]YdYWQb _c WbQfUc TQ}_c SQecQT_c `_b SQdycdb_VUc' F_b Uc_
`b_`_^U]_c aeU UcdQ 8_]YcY~^ TU ?^dUbY_b TU 8_^WbUc_ Y^cdU Q =_RYUb^_ U^ Ve^SY_^Uc Q Q`b_RQb QheTQc
SfU39I89&**&8E&,-

2. 7=4E=B 78 F8F=BA8F 78? 6BA;E8FB 78 ?BF 7=CHG47BF
6B@=F=BA8F
AvX& +, - PQ MN]UW PQ *(). CqS& +
h ]UTYTQc `QYQdYfQc `_b Ucd_c Y^SU^TY_c' ;^ d_T_ SQc_% c_^ ]UTYTQc aeU ^_ `eUTU^ Uc`UbQb `_baeU%
QTU]yc TU _c SeQ^dY_c_c U YbbU`QbQRUc TQ}_c Q `QdbY]_^Y_ ^QdebQ% U VeUW_ dQ]RY{^ cU Uf~ `_b TUQ^dU
fYfYU^TQc% U^cUbUc% Ug`_dQSY_^Uc QWbQbYQc% WQ^QTUbQc% V_bUcdQUc% UdS{dUbQ' ;c TUSYb% cU dbQdQ TU
`b_`_bSY_^Qb bUc`QT_ US_^~]YS_ Q aeYU^Uc hQ TU `_b c| dU^|Q^ e^Qc S_^TYSY_^Uc US_^~]YSQc TYV|SYUc `_b
fYfYb U^ i_^Qc bebQUc h Q`QbdQTQc TU Qc S_]_TYTQTUc TU Qc ebRUc h aeU Q `QbdYb TU _c Y^SU^TY_c cU Uc
XQ QWeTYiQT_ ]eSX_ ]yc% Y^Sec_ `UbTY{^T__ d_T_'
B_ bUSQ]Q]_c Qae| S_^_SUT_bUc TU aeU U 8_^cUZ_ TU =_RYUb^_ Qed_^~]YS_ hQ XQ Ug`bUcQT_ cec
SQbU^SYQc `QbQ QVb_^dQb Q `bUcdQSY~^ TU QheTQc Q _c QVUSdQT_c' ; `b_`Y_ `bUcYTU^dU TU `bY^SY`QT_ SQYVYS~
`•RYSQ]U^dU TU UgYWeQc Qc `_cYRYYTQTUc `bUce`eUcdQbYQc TU ce =_RYUb^_ `QbQ `QYQb Qc ^USUcYTQTUc
TUbYfQTQc TU UcdQ SQdQcdb~VYSQ cUbYU TU ]yc TU ,/) Y^SU^TY_c' DY aeU TUSYb dYU^U aeU ]eSX_c Qhe^dQ]YU^d_c%
cY^WeQb]U^dU _c TU QaeU_c S_^SUZ_c S_^ ]yc UcdbQW_c QSe]eQT_c% SQbUSU^ TU SQ`QSYTQT `QbQ
QVb_^dQb S_^ cec ]_TUcd_c bUSebc_c `b_`Y_c Qc QheTQc Q cec fUSY^_c h Qc dQbUQc TU bUSe`UbQSY~^ TU _c
dUbbYd_bY_c TUfQcdQT_c `_b Qc Q]Qc' BU cU}Q_% U^ UcdU cU^dYT_% aeU _c TQ}_c ]UTY_Q]RYU^dQUc c_^ TU
U^_b]U ]QW^YdeT% `_b _ aeU dQ]RY{^ bU`UbSedYby c_SYQ]U^dU S_^ cUSeUQc ]eh cUfUbQc c_RbU e^Qc
i_^Qc bebQUc U^ Qc aeU Qc Ug`_dQSY_^Uc V_bUcdQUc h QWb_WQ^QTUbQc c_^ SQfU `QbQ U TUcQbb__
US_^~]YS_' I__ U WbQ^ Y^SU^TY_ aeU QVUSd~ Q 7_Q h ; <bQ^S_ ce`_^U `{bTYTQc US_^~]YSQc ce`UbY_bUc
Q _c *) ]Y_^Uc TU Ueb_c'
BQ Y^YSYQdYfQ `QbQ]U^dQbYQ TU <_b_% `bY]UbQ TU Qc bUWYcdbQTQc `QbQ ce TURQdU Q^dU UcdQ 8_]YcY~^ TU
?^dUbY_b% VeU bUQYiQTQ UgQSdQ]U^dU e^ ]Uc TUc`e{c TU aeU QTaeYbY{cU]_c S_]_ bU`bUcU^dQ^dUc `_|dYS_c
Q^dU _c bUcS_T_c Xe]UQ^dUc TU _c `QbQZUc TU HY_R~^% >UbfUTUYbQc% BQ HUR_QTQ h BQ FUbehUYbQ% d_T_c
U^ U ]e^YSY`Y_ TU ; <bQ^S_% U S_]`b_]Yc_ S_^ cec XQRYdQ^dUc `QbQ Y]`ecQb V~b]eQc TU QheTQ Q^dU
QaeU TUcQcdbU' 6e^ Qc|% ^QTQ XQS|Q `bUcQWYQb aeU Q f|c`UbQ TU +) TYSYU]RbU% S_Y^SYTU^dU S_^ Q
SUURbQSY~^ TU Qc UUSSY_^Uc WU^UbQUc% cU UcdQRQ Y^YSYQ^T_ e^Q SQQ]Yd_cQ ceSUcY~^ TU Y^SU^TY_c aeU
cU `b__^WQb|Q XQcdQ U , U^Ub_ `_b WbQ^ `QbdU TU 6cdebYQc'
<Y^Q]U^dU% aeYUb_ cU}QQb aeU TUcTU U bUWYcdb_ TU ^eUcdbQ Y^YSYQdYfQ `QbQ]U^dQbYQ cU XQ^ `eRYSQT_
RQQ^SUc _VYSYQUc h cU XQ^ `_TYT_ `bUSYcQb ]yc _c TQd_c' F_b Uc_% ^_c XU]_c Qed_U^]U^TQT_ h XU]_c
Q]`YQT_ U^ T_c `e^d_c Q `b_`_cYSY~^ _bYWY^Q `QbQ TQb bUc`QT_ Q Qc `UdYSY_^Uc bUQYiQTQc Q =_RYUb^_
`_b _c bUc`_^cQRUc TU `bY^SY`QT_ h dQ]RY{^ `QbQ ]Q^TQdQb Q CY^YcdUbY_ TU ?^dUbY_b U^ U S~]`ed_ TU _c
TQ}_c `b_TeSYT_c `_b _c Y^SU^TY_c U^ Qc SeQdb_ S_]e^YTQTUc TU Q S_b^YcQ SQ^dyRbYSQ l;ec[QTY%
8Q^dQRbYQ% 6cdebYQc h =QYSYQl% Q _c UVUSd_c TU aeU ;c`Q}Q `bUcU^dU Q^dU Q K^Y~^ ;eb_`UQ e^Q c_YSYdeT
TU QheTQc S_^ SQbW_ Q <_^T_ TU c_YTQbYTQT% aeU cU UcdQRUSY~ `bUSYcQ]U^dU `QbQ QcYcdYb Q QaeUQc
bUWY_^Uc aeU XQ^ ceVbYT_ SQdycdb_VUc S_^ bU`UbSecY_^Uc WbQfUc U^ cec S_^TYSY_^Uc TU fYTQ% ]UTY_ ^QdebQ
h U^ ce US_^_]|Q% S_]_ Uc U SQc_'
CeSX|cY]Qc WbQSYQc% cU}_b `bUcYTU^dU'
; cU}_b CE8F=78AG82 CeSXQc WbQSYQc% cU}_b|Q% `_b ce Ug`YSQSY~^ h c_RbU d_T_ `_b ce Se]`Y]YU^d_
UcdbYSd_ TU dYU]`_' 9_h `_b U^dU^TYT_ aeU XQ TUVU^TYT_ hQ Q U^]YU^TQ aeU XQ `bUcU^dQT_% u^_5
"4^QY_UXUQY_Z#& =bQSYQc'
6 UcdQ `b_`_cYSY~^ cU XQ^ `bUcU^dQT_ fQbYQc U^]YU^TQc' ;^ `bY]Ub eWQb% `QcQ]_c Q Q U^]YU^TQ
`bUcU^dQTQ `_b U =be`_ I_SYQYcdQ'
BQ cU}_bQ 64AG8E4 78 64FGEB2 =bQSYQc% `bUcYTU^dU'
IU}_b|Qc% Ucd_h Qae| U^ bU`bUcU^dQSY~^ TU =be`_ I_SYQYcdQ aeU ]Q^dYU^U e^Q |^UQ aeU S_^SeSQ S_^
U _RZUdYf_ VY^Q TU Q `b_`_cYSY~^ ^_ TU Uh% U^ SeQ^d_ Q aeU cU dYU^U^ aeU bU`QbQb _c TQ}_c aeU cU XQ^
`b_TeSYT_ TebQ^dU UcdU Y^fYUb^_ `_b Ucd_c Y^SU^TY_c' D_ _RcdQ^dU% `QbQ `b_SUTUb Q Q bU`QbQSY~^ TU Ucd_c
TQ}_c cU TURU UcdQRUSUb e^ ]QbS_ UWYcQdYf_% e^ ]QbS_ fYWU^dU aeU `Ub]YdQ UfQb Q SQR_ TU ]Q^UbQ
QTUSeQTQ h dbQ^c`QbU^dU Q dbQ^cVUbU^SYQ TU UcdQc QheTQc `QbQ Qc| `_TUb bU`QbQb dQ^d_ _c TQ}_c ]_bQUc
S_]_ _c TQ}_c ]QdUbYQUc aeU cU XQhQ^ `b_TeSYT_ U^ Ucd_c Y^SU^TY_c'
IY^ U]RQbW_% aeYUb_ bUS_bTQb Q cec cU}_b|Qc aeU S_^ U HUQ 9USbUd_&Uh *+(+)*.% TU ,) _SdeRbU% cU
Q`b_RQb_^ e^Q cUbYU TU QheTQc `QbQ Qc Y^e^TQSY_^Uc aeU ceVbYUb_^ dQ^d_ Q 8_]e^YTQT 6ed~^_]Q TU
8Q^QbYQc S_]_ U ceb h U UcdU TU Q `U^|^ceQ' ;cdU ]Yc]_ bUQ TUSbUd_ UcdQRUS|Q U^ ce Qbd|Se_ *%
Q`QbdQT_ ,% aeU U `b_`Y_ =_RYUb^_ `_Tb|Q UcdQRUSUb `_cdUbY_b]U^dU ]UTYQ^dU UWYcQSY~^ TU e^ ^eUf_
bUQ TUSbUd_ Q Q]`YQSY~^ TU UcdQc ]UTYTQc Q SeQaeYUb `QbdU TU dUbbYd_bY_ Uc`Q}_ U^ SeQaeYUb dY`_ TU
SQdycdb_VU' ;^ Ucd_ cU RQcQ `bY^SY`Q]U^dU ^eUcdbQ U^]YU^TQ' DeUcdbQ U^]YU^TQ cU RQcQ U^ Y^cdQb Q
=_RYUb^_ Q Q`b_RQb S_^ Q ]ygY]Q ebWU^SYQ% S_]_ RYU^ cU XQ `Q^dUQT_ U^ Q FDB% e^ bUQ TUSbUd_ aeU
SfU39I89&**&8E&,-

3. 7=4E=B 78 F8F=BA8F 78? 6BA;E8FB 78 ?BF 7=CHG47BF
6B@=F=BA8F
AvX& +, - PQ MN]UW PQ *(). CqS& ,
`Ub]YdQ U UcdQRUSY]YU^d_ TU UcU ]QbS_ UWQ `QbQ `b_SUTUb Q UcdQc QheTQc% RYU^ cUQ ]UTYQ^dU Sb{TYd_c%
RYU^ cUQ ]UTYQ^dU bU`_cYSY~^ ]QdUbYQ% RYU^ cUQ ]UTYQ^dU bU`_RQSY~^ V_bUcdQ'
;^ UcdQ |^UQ UcdU bUQ TUSbUd_ UcdQRUS|Q aeU cU `_T|Q Q`YSQb XQcdQ U 2 TU U^Ub_ TU +)*/% U^dbQ^T_
`_b dQ^d_ U^ U ]QbS_ dU]`_bQ aeU U S_]`Q}Ub_ TU <_b_ 6cdebYQc XQ UcdQRUSYT_% `eUcd_ aeU _c Y^SU^TY_c
cU `b_TeZUb_^ XQcdQ U , U^Ub_' 9QT_ Ucd_% _ aeU c| c_YSYdQ ]Y Wbe`_ `QbQ]U^dQbY_ Uc aeU cY cU UfQ Q
SQR_ Q Q`b_RQSY~^ TU e^ bUQ TUSbUd_ TU ebWU^SYQ% S_^ Q QSU`dQSY~^ TU UcdQ U^]YU^TQ% Qc QheTQc aeU
cU Q`YaeU^ cUQ^ S_^ Q ]Qh_b dbQ^c`QbU^SYQ% U^ fYbdeT TU _ aeU U `eUR_ QSdeQ]U^dU Ucdy TU]Q^TQ^T_'
CeSXQc WbQSYQc'
; cU}_b CE8F=78AG82 CeSXQc WbQSYQc% cU}_bQ TY`edQTQ'
>Qh _dbQ U^]YU^TQ aeU XQ cYT_ `bUcU^dQTQ `_b U =be`_ FQbQ]U^dQbY_ F_`eQb h `QbQ ce TUVU^cQ%
dYU^U Q `QQRbQ ce `_bdQf_i'
BQ cU}_bQ ;4E6m4%C8?4KB >HE47B2 =bQSYQc% cU}_b `bUcYTU^dU'
;^ ^_]RbU TU =be`_ FQbQ]U^dQbY_ F_`eQb aeYUb_ S_]U^iQb ]Y `bY]UbQ Y^dUbfU^SY~^ U^ Q 8_]YcY~^
TU ?^dUbY_b TU 8_^WbUc_ TU _c 9Y`edQT_c ]Q^YVUcdQ^T_ e^Q fUi ]yc% U^ ^_]RbU TU =be`_ FQbQ]U^dQbY_
F_`eQb% ^eUcdbQ c_YTQbYTQT S_^ d_T_ U `eUR_ QcdebYQ^_ aeU `QTUSY~ e^_c XUSX_c aeU VeUb_^ TU U^_b]U
]QW^YdeT h aeU ^_ c_Q]U^dU QVUSdQb_^ Q ce XUb]_c_ `QdbY]_^Y_ ^QdebQ% cY^_ aeU dQ]RY{^ _SQcY_^Qb_^
WbQfUc TQ}_c `Ubc_^QUc% Y^Sec_ Y^SU^TY_c aeU cU UfQb_^ `_b TUQ^dU Q fYTQ TU e^ cUb Xe]Q^_ Seh_
dbQRQZ_ UcdQRQ TUTYSQT_ `bUSYcQ]U^dU Q cQfQb Q fYTQ h U `QdbY]_^Y_ TU _c TU]yc% S_]_ VeU U `Y_d_ TU
XUYS~`dUb_ @_c{ 6^d_^Y_ H_Tb|WeUi% `QbQ U SeQ `_b ce`eUcd_ c_YSYdQ]_c h ^_c ce]Q]_c Q SeQaeYUb
bUS_^_SY]YU^d_ aeU cU XQWQ TUcTU 6cdebYQc U Y^Sec_ dQ]RY{^ TUcTU U `b_`Y_ =_RYUb^_ TU ;c`Q}Q Q
`UdYSY~^ TU =_RYUb^_ QcdebYQ^_' 6cY]Yc]_% aeUbU]_c VUYSYdQb Q Qc <eUbiQc h 8eUb`_c TU IUWebYTQT TU
;cdQT_% Fb_dUSSY~^ 8YfY% R_]RUb_c% `_YS|Qc _SQUc% `_YS|Qc Qed_^~]YSQc% Q d_T_c _c f_e^dQbY_c aeU
WU^Ub_cQ]U^dU dQ]RY{^ cU Y]`YSQb_^ U^ Q UgdY^SY~^ TU Ucd_c Y^SU^TY_c h aeU% `_b _ dQ^d_% XQh aeU
XQSUbUc dQ]RY{^ UcdU TURYT_ bUS_^_SY]YU^d_'
; =be`_ FQbQ]U^dQbY_ F_`eQb aeYUbU ]Q^YVUcdQb _ cYWeYU^dU U^ bUQSY~^ S_^ UcdQ `b_`eUcdQ' ;^
`bY]Ub eWQb% XQh e^Q ^_b]QdYfQ aeU Uc U HUQ 9USbUd_ ,)0(+)*.% *1 ]Qbi_% aeU bUWeQ ^_ c_Q]U^dU
`QbQ UcdU SQc_ cY^_ `QbQ d_T_c _c SQc_c aeU S_]_ UcdU _SebbQ^ U^ ^eUcdb_ dUbbYd_bY_ ^QSY_^Q h S_^ d_dQ
dbQ^c`QbU^SYQ% Q S_^SUcY~^ TU Qc Y^TU]^YiQSY_^Uc% Qc ceRfU^SY_^Uc aeU Y^TU]^YSU^ _c TQ}_c h
`UbZeYSY_c _SQcY_^QT_c `_b QS_^dUSY]YU^d_c TU UcdU dY`_' 6TU]yc% Q QSdYfQSY~^ TU _c `b_SUTY]YU^d_c aeU
cU bUWeQ^ U bUQ TUSbUd_ ^_ bUaeYUbU TU Y^YSYQdYfQ ^Y^We^Q% cY^_ aeU cU QSdYfQ^ _c `b_SUTY]YU^d_c `QbQ
Q S_^SUcY~^ TU UcdQc Y^TU]^YiQSY_^Uc S_^ SQbySdUb Qed_]ydYS_' IU Y^TU]^YiQ^ _c TQ}_c `Ubc_^QUc h
_c TQ}_c ]QdUbYQUc' IU S_]`U^cQ^ dQ]RY{^ _c `QW_c aeU XQhQ aeU XQRUb bUQYiQT_ `_b `QbdU TU _c
]e^YSY`Y_c aeU ^_ `eUTU^ c_`_bdQb TU QWe^Q ]Q^UbQ% `_b cYdeQSY_^Uc TU Y^c_fU^SYQ _ TU S_]`UZYTQT
US_^~]YSQ' IU Y^TU]^YiQ^ dQ]RY{^ _c TQ}_c U^ _c UcdQRUSY]YU^d_c ]UbSQ^dYUc U Y^TecdbYQUc h dQ]RY{^
U^ _c cUbfYSY_c' 6cY]Yc]_% cU Y^TU]^YiQ Q Qc `Ubc_^Qc V|cYSQc _ Zeb|TYSQc aeU XQhQ^ UfQT_ Q SQR_
`bUcdQSY_^Uc `Ubc_^QUc _ TU RYU^Uc Q bUaeUbY]YU^d_ TU Qc Qed_bYTQTUc S_]`UdU^dUc' GeYUb_ TUSYbUc aeU
Q T|Q TU X_h hQ cU XQ^ V_b]QT_ V_b]QYiQT_ /. c_YSYdeTUc TU QheTQ `_b `QbdU TU UcdQc `Ubc_^Qc
`UbZeTYSQTQc h aeU XQ^ cYT_ dbQ]YdQTQc `_b `QbdU TU Q 9UUWQSY~^ TU =_RYUb^_ U^ 6cdebYQc U Y^Sec_ XQ
cYT_ Y^TU]^YiQ^ Q VQ]YYQ TU @_c{ 6^d_^Y_ H_Tb|WeUi aeU% S_]_ XU TYSX_ Q^dUbY_b]U^dU% `UbTY~ Q fYTQ U^
Qc QR_bUc TU UgdY^SY~^ TU Ucd_c Y^SU^TY_c' F_b dQ^d_% U bUQ TUSbUd_ UgYcdU% U bUQ TUSbUd_ Uc dbQ^c`QbU^dU%
U bUQ TUSbUd_ bUS_WU ]UTYTQc `QbQ d_T_ U dUbbYd_bY_ ^QSY_^Q h `QbQ XUSX_c cY]YQbUc Q _SebbYT_ U^ d_T_
U dUbbYd_bY_ ^QSY_^Q' IU QSdYfQ Qed_]ydYSQ]U^dU h QTU]yc Ucdy hQ Ve^SY_^Q^T_'
JQ]RY{^ U^ Q 9UUWQSY~^ TU =_RYUb^_ U^ 6cdebYQc cU XQ SbUQT_ e^Q _VYSY^Q% aeU Uc _ aeU c_YSYdQ U
<_b_ 6cdebYQc U^ U `e^d_ , TU Q `b_`_cYSY~^ ^_ TU Uh% `QbQ QdU^TUb Q d_TQc Qc `Ubc_^Qc QVUSdQTQc h QX|
Uc `bUSYcQ]U^dU T_^TU cU XQ^ UcdQT_ dbQ]YdQ^T_ UcdQc QheTQc' 6cY]Yc]_ aeYUb_ dbQcQTQbUc aeU U
CY^YcdUbY_ TU ?^dUbY_b h d_T_ U =_RYUb^_ TU ;c`Q}Q Ucdef_ QdU^d_% `U^TYU^dU h `bUcU^dU TebQ^dU _c
]UcUc TU TYSYU]RbU h TU U^Ub_ SeQ^T_ cU `b_TeZUb_^ Ucd_c WbQf|cY]_c Y^SU^TY_c% `Ub_ `_cdUbY_b]U^dU U
=_RYUb^_ XQ cUWeYT_ `bUcU^dU h cUWeYby `bUcU^dU XQcdQ aeU d_T_c _c TQ}_c aeU cU `b_TeZUb_^ S_]_
S_^cUSeU^SYQ TU UcU Y^SU^TY_ ^_ aeUTU^ cQfQT_c% dQ^d_ _c `QdbY]_^YQUc S_]_ _c ^QdebQUc% dQ h S_]_
fYU^U bUS_WYT_ U^ U bUQ TUSbUd_'
6c|% XU TU TUSYbUc aeU U - VURbUb_ U ceRcUSbUdQbY_ TU CY^YcdUbY_ TU ?^dUbY_b Ucdef_ U^ U FbY^SY`QT_
TU 6cdebYQc h ]Q^def_ e^Q bUe^Y~^ U^ Q 9UUWQSY~^ TU =_RYUb^_ S_^ U TUUWQT_% U S_^cUZUb_ TU
FbUcYTU^SYQ% U S_^cUZUb_ TU FQbdYSY`QSY~^ 8YeTQTQ^Q% U TYbUSd_b WU^UbQ TU @ecdYSYQ U ?^dUbY_b h e^
bU`bUcU^dQ^dU TU Q <UTUbQSY~^ 6cdebYQ^Q TU 8_^SUZ_c% T_^TU UcdefYUb_^ `_^Y{^T_cU TU QSeUbT_ U^
SfU39I89&**&8E&,-

4. 7=4E=B 78 F8F=BA8F 78? 6BA;E8FB 78 ?BF 7=CHG47BF
6B@=F=BA8F
AvX& +, - PQ MN]UW PQ *(). CqS& -
bUQSY~^ S_^ Q S_]`U^cQSY~^ TU _c TQ}_c `b_TeSYT_c `_b _c Y^SU^TY_c' ; *2 VURbUb_ cU XQ feUd_ Q
`b_TeSYb _dbQ bUe^Y~^ TU S__bTY^QSY~^% U^ UcdU SQc_ hQ U^ CQTbYT% U^ Q cUTU TU Q 9YbUSSY~^ =U^UbQ TU
Fb_dUSSY~^ 8YfY h ;]UbWU^SYQ S_^ bU`bUcU^dQSY~^ TU TYcdY^d_c TU`QbdQ]U^d_c ]Y^YcdUbYQUc h Ucd_ ]U
WecdQb|Q TUcdQSQb_' J_T_ U =_RYUb^_ Ucdy Y]`YSQT_3 U CY^YcdUbY_ TU ?^dUbY_b% U CY^YcdUbY_ TU >QSYU^TQ h
6T]Y^YcdbQSY_^Uc F•RYSQc% U CY^YcdUbY_ TU 6WbYSedebQ% 6Y]U^dQSY~^ h CUTY_ 6]RYU^dU% U CY^YcdUbY_ TU
<_]U^d_ U Y^Sec_ U CY^YcdUbY_ TU FbUcYTU^SYQ aeU Uc Ucdy S__bTY^Q^T_ Qc QSdeQSY_^Uc% Ze^d_ S_^ _c
TUUWQT_c TU =_RYUb^_ U^6cdebYQc h 8Q^dQRbYQ h _c bU`bUcU^dQ^dUc TU Qc QT]Y^YcdbQSY_^Uc Qed_^~]YSQc'
;_c XQ^ aeUTQT_ U^ fQ_bQb Qc TYcdY^dQc QdUb^QdYfQc aeU cU TURU^ `_^Ub U^SY]Q TU Q ]UcQ `QbQ Q
S_]`U^cQSY~^ QTUSeQTQ TU _c TQ}_c' GeYUb_ dbQcQTQbUc% `_b _ dQ^d_% aeU UgYcdU e^Q ^_b]QdYfQ h aeU
UcdQ ^_b]QdYfQ Ve^SY_^Q'
;^ bUQSY~^ S_^ Q U^]YU^TQ TU =be`_ I_SYQYcdQ c| ]U WecdQb|Q dbQcQTQbUc aeU Uc dQbTU% U^ UcdU
SQc_% `QbQ ]_TYVYSQb Q ^_b]QdYfQ' ;cQ ]_TYVYSQSY~^ c__ UbQ `_cYRU Q^dUc TU Q U^dbQTQ U^ fYW_b TU Q
^eUfQ BUh TU Fb_dUSSY~^ 8YfY% `Ub_ Q U^dbQTQ U^ fYW_b cU `b_TeZ_ U 2 TU U^Ub_ TU UcdU Q}_' IY^ U]RQbW_%
Uc_ ^_ aeYUbU TUSYb aeU ^_ cU fQhQ Q dbQRQZQb ^Y aeU ^_ cU fQhQ cUWeYb dbQRQZQ^T_% aeU ^_ fQhQ]_c Q
cUWeYb UcdQ^T_ S_^ U `eUR_ QcdebYQ^_ S_]_ U_c ]UbUSU^ h S_]_ U_c ^USUcYdQ^' F_b dQ^d_% cU Yby
Se]`YU^T_ S_^ d_T_c _c S_]`b_]Yc_c aeU cU fQhQ Qce]YU^T_ Ze^d_ S_^ _c bU`bUcU^dQ^dUc TU _c
SYeTQTQ^_c TU 6cdebYQc'
CeSXQc WbQSYQc' "4[WM`^Z^#&
; cU}_b CE8F=78AG82 =bQSYQc% cU}_b|Q'
BQ •dY]Q U^]YU^TQ `bUcU^dQTQ S_bbUc`_^TU Q =be`_ FQbQ]U^dQbY_ 8YeTQTQ^_c'
; cU}_b CE=8GB EB@8EB2 =bQSYQc% cU}_b `bUcYTU^dU'
IU}_b|Qc% ^eUcdbQ `bY]UbQ U^]YU^TQ Q Q`QbdQT_ * `bUdU^TU QcUWebQb Q UgdU^cY~^ TU _c UVUSd_c TU
HUQ 9USbUd_&Uh *+(+)*.% Q aeU XQS|Q bUVUbU^SYQ Q `_bdQf_i TU =be`_ I_SYQYcdQ% dbQc Qc Y^e^TQSY_^Uc
U^ Q i_^Q TU 8Q^QbYQc% Uc TUSYb% Q`YSQb UcdU bUQ TUSbUd_ Q Qc SQdycdb_VUc TUbYfQTQc TU _c Y^SU^TY_c
V_bUcdQUc aeU TebQ^dU U `QcQT_ ]Uc TU TYSYU]RbU Qc_Qb_^ 6cdebYQc h _dbQc S_]e^YTQTUc TU ^_bdU TU
;c`Q}Q' ;cdQ `QbUSU cUb Q f|Q ]yc by`YTQ `QbQ TQb bUc`eUcdQ Q Qc ^USUcYTQTUc Xe]Q^Qc h ]QdUbYQUc
TU d_T_ dY`_ aeU cU XQ^ WU^UbQT_ Q _c QVUSdQT_c% aeU TURU^ cUb `bY_bYdQbYQc h aeU ^_ QT]YdU^ TU]_bQ'
6c| _ U^dYU^TU Q 6R_WQS|Q TU ;cdQT_ aeU% cUW•^ ^_dYSYQc TU `QcQT_ ]Uc TU U^Ub_% `b_`_^|Q UcdU
]USQ^Yc]_ `QbQ QSdeQb S_^ ebWU^SYQ h c_fU^dQb Qc| _c _RcdySe_c TUbYfQT_c TU Q cYdeQSY~^ TU e^
=_RYUb^_ U^ Ve^SY_^Uc h Q TYQdQSY~^ aeU `_Tb|Q ce`_^Ub dbQ]YdQb e^ bUQ TUSbUd_&Uh' 6e^aeU dQ]RY{^
TURU]_c U^dU^TUb aeU UcdQ]_c QR_bTQ^T_ cYdeQSY_^Uc TU UgdbQ_bTY^QbYQ h ebWU^dU ^USUcYTQT% aeU U^
^Y^W•^ SQc_ ZecdYVYSQ^ Q Y^QSdYfYTQT TU =_RYUb^_ TebQ^dU d_T_ UcdU dYU]`_% Ucd{ _ ^_ U^ Ve^SY_^Uc' 6
`UcQb TU aeU `QbUSU cUb aeU UgYcd|Q e^ S_]`b_]Yc_ TU =_RYUb^_% TU ;cdQT_% `QbQ QSdeQb U^ UcdQ |^UQ
ceWUbYTQ `_b Q 6R_WQS|Q TU ;cdQT_% S_^Ze^dQ]U^dU S_^ U =_RYUb^_ TU 6cdebYQc% ^_ ^_c S_^cdQ aeU cU
XQhQ XUSX_ ^QTQ bUc`USd_'
F_b _dbQ `QbdU% `Q^dUQ]_c dQ]RY{^ U^ UcdQ U^]YU^TQ aeU Qe^aeU XQhQ cYT_ 6cdebYQc Q S_]e^YTQT
]yc QVUSdQTQ% Q aeU XQ fYcd_ ceSe]RYb e^ ]Qh_b ^•]Ub_ TU XUSdybUQc RQZ_ U VeUW_ h `_b dQ^d_ T_^TU
]yc TQ}_c cU XQ^ `b_TeSYT_% ^_ `_TU]_c TUcS_^_SUb aeU dQ]RY{^ cU XQ^ `b_TeSYT_ TQ}_c% TU ]eSXQ
WbQfUTQT% U^ _dbQc S_]e^YTQTUc TU ^_bdU% `bY^SY`Q]U^dU U^ 8Q^dQRbYQ h FQ|c LQcS_% aeU ^_ `eUTU^
aeUTQb Q ]QbWU^ TU Qc QheTQc' ;c Q =_RYUb^_ TU ;c`Q}Q Q aeYU^ U S_bbUc`_^TU TUY]YdQb% hQ aeU
TYc`_^U TU Q Y^V_b]QSY~^ S_^SbUdQ% _c S_^SbUd_c ]e^YSY`Y_c QVUSdQT_c U^ SQTQ S_]e^YTQT Qed~^_]Q'
F_b Uc_% Y^db_TeSY]_c U^ UcdU `e^d_ * Q ]U^SY~^ Q bUcd_ TU Qc S_]e^YTQTUc QVUSdQTQc'
<Y^Q]U^dU% Q U^]YU^TQ Q `e^d_ , cU ZecdYVYSQ `_b U XUSX_ TU aeU cY XQh e^ ybUQ `bUSYcQ]U^dU T_^TU
Q S__bTY^QSY~^ U^dbU QT]Y^YcdbQSY_^Uc Uc QRc_edQ]U^dU Y]`bUcSY^TYRU% Uc U aeU XQSU bUVUbU^SYQ Q Q
QSdeQSY~^ U^ cYdeQSY_^Uc TU U]UbWU^SYQc h SQdycdb_VUc' ;cU `bY^SY`Y_ TU S__bTY^QSY~^ QT]Y^YcdbQdYfQ
QdbQfYUcQ d_TQ Q BUh *0(+)*.% TU IYcdU]Q DQSY_^Q TU Fb_dUSSY~^ 8YfY% aeU U^db~ U^ fYW_b U `QcQT_ *) TU
U^Ub_' F_b U_% U^dU^TU]_c aeU UcQ _VYSY^Q TU QdU^SY~^ Q _c QVUSdQT_c% aeU QTUSeQTQ]U^dU cU `Q^dUQ
^_ `eUTU TUcS_^_SUb Qc _RYWQSY_^Uc h S_]`UdU^SYQc TU _c =_RYUb^_c Qed_^~]YS_c% aeU QTU]yc `_b
dU^Ub e^ ]UZ_b S_^_SY]YU^d_ TU dUbbU^_ `eUTU^ T_dQb TU ]Qh_b UVYSQSYQ h bQ`YTUi Q cYcdU]Q TU QheTQc
aeU cU TUcQbb_U^'
CeSXQc WbQSYQc'
; cU}_b CE8F=78AG82 CeSXQc WbQSYQc% cU}_b|Q'
SfU39I89&**&8E&,-

5. 7=4E=B 78 F8F=BA8F 78? 6BA;E8FB 78 ?BF 7=CHG47BF
6B@=F=BA8F
AvX& +, - PQ MN]UW PQ *(). CqS& .
;^dbQ]_c U^ U deb^_ TU VYZQSY~^ TU `_cYSY_^Uc' u>Qh QWe^Q Y^dUbfU^SY~^ `_b U =be`_ CYgd_5 "CM`^M#&
uF_b U =be`_ LQcS_% FDL5 "CM`^M#&
F_b U =be`_ FQbQ]U^dQbY_ 8QdQy^ #9U]_SbxSYQ Y BYRUbdQd$% cU}_bQ HYRUbQ'
BQ cU}_bQ E=58E4 = ;4E=>B2 IU}_b `bUcYTU^dU% Y^dUbfU^W_ `QbQ `_cYSY_^Qb^_c Q VQf_b TU QdU^TUb _c
WbQfUc TQ}_c ceVbYT_c% Qc| S_]_ TU Qc `{bTYTQc TU fYTQc Xe]Q^Qc% h Q cYdeQSY~^ TU UgdbQ_bTY^QbYQ h
ebWU^dU ^USUcYTQT' 6TU]yc% SUURbQ]_c Q `bUcU^dQSY~^ TU Q Y^YSYQdYfQ'
; cU}_b CE8F=78AG82 u=be`_ TU ;caeUbbQ HU`eRYSQ^Q5
; cU}_b EH9=kA EB@8EB2 CY Wbe`_ dQ]RY{^ Ucdy Q VQf_b h SUURbQ Q Y^YSYQdYfQ'
; cU}_b CE8F=78AG82 CeSXQc WbQSYQc% cU}_b HeVYy^'
uF_b U =be`_ F_TU]_c5
; cU}_b 5EHLBF <=;H8EB2 CeSXQc WbQSYQc% cU}_b `bUcYTU^dU' FUb]|dQ]U aeU XQWQ e^ `bUfY_% U
^_]RbU _VYSYQ TU ]Y Wbe`_ Uc =be`_ F_TU]_c&;^ 8_]• F_TU]&;^ CQbUQ h UcdQb|Q RYU^ aeU Qc| cU
bUS_WYUbQ'
LQ]_c Q f_dQb Q VQf_b TU UcQ Y^YSYQdYfQ `bUcU^dQTQ `_b U =be`_ CYgd_% h Uc`USYQ]U^dU `_b <_b_
6cdebYQc' IY^ U]RQbW_% aeUbU]_c bUcQdQb aeU Q cYdeQSY~^ aeU cU fYfU U^ _c ]_^dUc TU S_^Ze^d_ TU
;cdQT_ h Uc`USYQ]U^dU TU 6cdebYQc% aeU U^ UcdU SQc_ Uc U dUbbYd_bY_ TU aeU cU dbQdQ% `Ub_ dQ]RY{^ TU
=QYSYQ% 8Q^dQRbYQ h ;ec[QTY% bUc`_^TU Q e^Q cUbYU TU TUSYcY_^Uc `_|dYSQc aeU XQSU^ aeU fYfQ]_c _c
TUcQcdbUc aeU fYfY]_c Q}_ dbQc Q}_'
;^ UcU cU^dYT_% aeUbU]_c UZU]`YVYSQb Q `_|dYSQ aeU UfQ U^ S_^SbUd_ U FQbdYT_ F_`eQb U^ Q Q^dUbY_b
UWYcQdebQ S_^ Q ]_TYVYSQSY~^ TU Q BUh TU C_^dUc' ;^ Q Q^dUbY_b UWYcQdebQ cU ]_TYVYS~ e^Q Uh aeU fU^|Q
TU e^ TYy_W_ `b_Ve^T_ U^dbU QWU^dUc V_bUcdQUc h _bWQ^YiQSY_^Uc US__WYcdQc% TebQ^dU e^Q UdQ`Q TU
TYy_W_ aeU VeU TUcTU U Q}_ *22/ XQcdQ U Q}_ +)),' ;cQ Uh cU ]_TYVYS~ `_cdUbY_b]U^dU% dQ]RY{^ S_^
TYy_W_' IY^ U]RQbW_% UcU TYy_W_ cU b_]`Y~ U^ Q Q^dUbY_b UWYcQdebQ S_^ Q Q`b_RQSY~^ TU e^Q Uh% TU
Uc`QTQc S_]`UdQ]U^dU dQ^d_ Q _bWQ^YiQSY_^Uc US__WYcdQc% QWU^dUc c_SYQUc h TU]yc' ;^ UcdU cU^dYT_%
aeUbU]_c bUcQdQb T_c Qc`USd_c dbU]U^TQ]U^dU UcYf_c S_]_ c_^ U ^Y^We^U_ QRc_ed_ TU _c QWU^dUc
V_bUcdQUc h Q UY]Y^QSY~^ TU Q `b_dUSSY~^ TU ceU_ aeU]QT_% hQ aeU Q^dUc ^_ `_T|Q cUb bUSQYVYSQT_ U
dUbbU^_ TUcTU aeU cU aeU]QRQ XQcdQ ,) Q}_c `_cdUbY_bUc% `Ub_ U^ Q QSdeQYTQT cU XQ UY]Y^QT_ UcQ
`b_dUSSY~^' 9U V_b]Q WU^UbQ TUSY]_c aeU ^_ cU Ucdy bUQYiQ^T_ e^Q WUcdY~^ UVYSQi h UVYSYU^dU TU ]_^dU'
D_ UgYcdU e^Q `_|dYSQ V_bUcdQ% ^_ UgYcdU e^Q `_|dYSQ QWb|S_Q ^Y WQ^QTUbQ% ^_ UgYcdU e^Q `_|dYSQ TU
_bTU^QSY~^ TU dUbbYd_bY_ h ^_ UgYcdU e^Q `_|dYSQ TU VYZQSY~^ TU Q `_RQSY~^% aeU QheTU `bUSYcQ]U^dU Q
Q`b_fUSXQ]YU^d_ c_cdU^YRU TU ]_^dU' F_b dQ^d_% ^_ cU TUcdY^Q ^Y^W•^ UcVeUbi_ `_|dYS_ Q ^Y^W•^ dY`_ TU
`_|dYSQ TU SeYTQT_ TU _c ]_^dUc h c__ cU TUTYSQ Q Q UgdY^SY~^' ; 2)" TU Q Y^fUbcY~^ cU fQ `bUSYcQ]U^dU
Q UgdY^SY~^ h c__ XQh e^ *)" `QbQ U bUcd_ TU `_|dYSQc V_bUcdQUc' F_b Uc_% aeUbU]_c bUQYiQb UcQ Sb|dYSQ'
D_c `QbUSU QTUSeQT_ aeU U^ UcdQ Y^YSYQdYfQ% aeU fQ]_c Q f_dQb Q VQf_b `_baeU Uc Y]`_bdQ^dU aeU cU
Y^TU]^YSU Q aeYU^ dQ^d_ XQ `UbTYT_ S_^ Q QSbQ TU _c Y^SU^TY_c V_bUcdQUc% ^_ cU _fYTU aeU Uc ^USUcQbYQ
Q Y^fUbcY~^ `•RYSQ% aeU XQh aeU QSQRQb S_^ U ^UW_SY_ TU Qc U]`bUcQc `bYfQTQc TU UgdY^SY~^% aeU XQh
aeU QSQRQb S_^ Q `bUSQbYiQSY~^ TU Qc S_^TYSY_^Uc QR_bQUc TU _c dbQRQZQT_bUc TU UgdY^SY~^ `_baeU UcQc
`_|dYSQc c_^ Qc aeU UfQ^ Q QRQ^T_^_ TU _c ]_^dUc% Q Q TUc`_RQSY~^ h Q Q TUcUbdYiQSY~^'
CeSXQc WbQSYQc'
; cU}_b CE8F=78AG82 CeSXQc WbQSYQc'
9YcS•`U]U% `Ub_ Uc aeU dU^|Q U ^_]RbU TU ce Wbe`_ U^ QRbUfYQdebQ' F_b Uc_ ^_ XU TYSX_ U ^_]RbU
S_]`Ud_% `Ub_ `b_SebQb{ TUSYb_ Q `QbdYb TU QX_bQ'
F_b U Wbe`_ `b_`_^U^dU% dYU^U Q `QQRbQ `QbQ VYZQb `_cYSY~^ c_RbU Q U^]YU^TQ'
; cU}_b @4EGmA8L B5?4A642 CeSXQc WbQSYQc% cU}_b `bUcYTU^dU'
FUb]|dQ]U U^ UcdU RbUfU deb^_ bUQSY_^QT_ S_^ Qc U^]YU^TQc Q ^eUcdbQ `b_`_cYSY~^ ^_ TU Uh aeU
QWbQTUiSQ U Q`_h_ Q^e^SYQT_ Q ^eUcdbQ Y^YSYQdYfQ h Qc Q`_bdQSY_^Uc TU _c TYVUbU^dUc Wbe`_c% `Ub_
Uc`USYQ]U^dU U UcVeUbi_ aeU XQ XUSX_ U =be`_ F_`eQb `QbQ RecSQb e^ `e^d_ TU U^SeU^db_ aeU VQSYYdU
ce Q`_h_ Q UcdQ Y^YSYQdYfQ' 9UcS_^_iS_ VY^Q]U^dU Sey cUby U cU^dYT_ TU ce f_d_% `Ub_% U^ d_T_ SQc_%
aeYUb_ TUZQb S_^cdQ^SYQ TU UcVeUbi_ aeU XQ bUQYiQT_ `QbQ QSQ^iQb UcU UcVeUbi_'
SfU39I89&**&8E&,-

6. 7=4E=B 78 F8F=BA8F 78? 6BA;E8FB 78 ?BF 7=CHG47BF
6B@=F=BA8F
AvX& +, - PQ MN]UW PQ *(). CqS& /
9U d_TQc Qc U^]YU^TQc `bUcU^dQTQc QSU`d_ Q Y^SecY~^ TU Qc T_c U^]YU^TQc TU =be`_ CYgd_% aeU
h_ ]Yc]_ V_b]e{ dbQc Q QSdeQYiQSY~^ TU _c TQd_c _VYSYQUc c_RbU _c Y^SU^TY_c% TQd_c aeU VeUb_^
S_^_SYT_c `_cdUbY_b]U^dU Q Q `bUcU^dQSY~^ TU UcdQ Y^YSYQdYfQ `QbQ]U^dQbYQ' JQ]RY{^ QSU`d_ Q U^]YU^TQ
TU QTYSY~^ TU =be`_ F_`eQb% S_^ ^•]Ub_ TU bUWYcdb_ 1--% aeU XQSU bUVUbU^SYQ Q ]Q^dU^Y]YU^d_ TU _c
cUWeb_c QWbQbY_c S_]RY^QT_c `QbQ QVb_^dQb Q fYQRYYTQT TU Qc Ug`_dQSY_^Uc QWb_WQ^QTUbQc Q^dU TQ}_c
SQecQT_c `_b Q SY]Qd__W|Q' ?WeQ]U^dU QSU`d_ Q U^]YU^TQ bUWYcdbQTQ S_^ U ^•]Ub_ 1+/% TU =be`_
I_SYQYcdQ% TUVU^TYTQ `_b Q TY`edQTQ T_}Q OQYTQ 8Q^dUbQ h aeU `_^U {^VQcYc U^ U HUQ 9USbUd_&
Uh *+(+)*.% TU ,) TU _SdeRbU% aeU cY RYU^ cU UQR_b~ U^d_^SUc S_^ ]_dYf_ TU Qc Y^e^TQSY_^Uc U^ Qc YcQc
8Q^QbYQc `bUf{ Q `_cYRYYTQT TU aeU U =_RYUb^_ dQ]RY{^ ]UTYQ^dU bUQ TUSbUd_ `eUTQ TUSQbQb Q
Q`YSQSY~^ TU ]UTYTQc Q _dbQc cYdeQSY_^Uc TU U]UbWU^SYQ aeU `eUTQ^ QSQUSUb Q SeQaeYUb `QbdU TU
dUbbYd_bY_ ^QSY_^Q TUcTU ce U^dbQTQ U^ fYW_b XQcdQ U 2 TU U^Ub_ TU +)*/% S_^ TUY]YdQSY~^ TU _c ]e^YSY`Y_c
h ^•SU_c TU `_RQSY~^ QVUSdQT_c' ;c TUSYb% aeU _c ]e^YSY`Y_c TU d_TQ Q S_b^YcQ SQ^dyRbYSQ QVUSdQT_c `_b
_c Y^SU^TY_c aeU VY^QYiQb_^ Q `bY]UbQ cU]Q^Q TU ]Uc TU U^Ub_ `eUTQ^ RU^UVYSYQbcU TU UcdU S_^Ze^d_
TU ]UTYTQc'
F_b •dY]_% cU}_b `bUcYTU^dU% aeYUb_ cU}QQb aeU QSU`d_ `QbSYQ]U^dU Q U^]YU^TQ TU ]_TYVYSQSY~^
`bUcU^dQTQ `_b U =be`_ 8YeTQTQ^_c S_^ ^•]Ub_ TU bUWYcdb_ 1-1' 8_^SbUdQ]U^dU QSU`d_ Q U^]YU^TQ
aeU ]_TYVYSQ U `e^d_ , TU Q `b_`_cYSY~^% aeU XQ TUVU^TYT_ U TY`edQT_ T_^ <YTU FbYUd_' FQbQ VQSYYdQb Qc
S_cQc `QcQb{ Q Q VYb]Q TU _c `_bdQf_SUc e^ dUgd_ dbQ^cQSSY_^Q aeU XQb{ UWQb Q Q CUcQ TU Q 8_]YcY~^'
CeSXQc WbQSYQc'
; cU}_b CE8F=78AG82 CeSXQc WbQSYQc% cU}_b|Q'
f FB5E8 ?4 78EB;46=oA 78 ?4 ?8K BE;kA=64 78 CEBG866=oA 78 ?4 F8;HE=747
6=H7474A4& CE8F8AG474 CBE 8? ;EHCB C4E?4@8AG4E=B 78 8FDH8EE4 E8CH5?=64A4&
"AvXQ]Z PQ Qc[QPUQY_Q ).)'((()/*#&
; cU}_b CE8F=78AG82 ;^dbQ]_c U^ U `e^d_ +'s TU _bTU^ TU T|Q3 `b_`_cYSY~^ ^_ TU Uh c_RbU Q
TUb_WQSY~^ TU Q BUh EbWy^YSQ TU Fb_dUSSY~^ TU Q IUWebYTQT 8YeTQTQ^Q% `bUcU^dQTQ `_b U =be`_
FQbQ]U^dQbY_ TU ;caeUbbQ HU`eRYSQ^Q' FQbQ ce `bUcU^dQSY~^ dYU^U Q `QQRbQ U `_bdQf_i TU Wbe`_
`b_`_^U^dU'
; cU}_b EH9=kA EB@8EB2 CeSXQc WbQSYQc% `bUcYTU^dU'
IU}_b|Qc% S_]_ cQRU^% U `QcQT_ +/ TU ]Qbi_ TU +)*. cU Q`b_R~ U^ cUTU `QbQ]U^dQbYQ Q TU^_]Y^QTQ
BUh EbWy^YSQ TU Fb_dUSSY~^ TU IUWebYTQT 8YeTQTQ^Q% S_]•^ h QSUbdQTQ]U^dU bURQedYiQTQ U^ Q SQU
S_]_ Uh ]_bTQiQ' Fb_RQRU]U^dU Ze^d_ Q Q bUV_b]Q TU 8~TYW_ FU^Q% cUQ Q ]yc Y^TYW^Q h bUQSSY_^QbYQ
TU SeQ^dQc Y^YSYQdYfQc UWYcQdYfQc XQ YTUQT_ h XQ Q`b_RQT_ UcU b_TY_ `_|dYS_ UWYcQdYf_% bUQSSY_^QbY_ h
QRc_edYcdQ% TU^_]Y^QT_ =_RYUb^_ TU FQbdYT_ F_`eQb U^ _c •dY]_c SeQdb_ Q}_c' K^Q Uh aeU XQSU ReU^_
Q e^_ TU _c ]yc bUcdbYSdYf_c ]Y^Ycdb_c TU ?^dUbY_b TU Q XYcd_bYQ TU UcdU `Q|c% S_^ U `Ub]Yc_ TU Y^UVQRU
@_bWU <Ub^y^TUi 9|Qi% `_b ce`eUcd_% U dbYcdU]U^dU bUS_bTQT_ @_c{ BeYc 8_bSeUbQ 8eUcdQ% Q]QT_ B_c
Ug`UbY]U^d_c cU XQSU^ U^ SQcQ S_^ WQcU_cQ h c_RbU d_T_ Q ce Q•^ ]yc dbYcdU h bUcdbYSdYfQ Uh 8_bSeUbQ%
Q]QTQ Uh TU `QdQTQ U^ Q `eUbdQ% SQYVYSQdYf_c aeU SbU_ aeU TUVY^U^ ]eh RYU^ TU _ aeU UcdQ]_c
XQRQ^T_% Q^dUcQQ TU UcdU Qed{^dYS_ QdQaeU Q _c TUbUSX_c ]yc Ve^TQ]U^dQUc TU Q SYeTQTQ^|Q
TU^_]Y^QTQ Uh ]_bTQiQ'
K^Q Uh aeU UcSQ^TQYiQ Q6]^Ycd|Q ?^dUb^QSY_^Q% Q DQSY_^Uc K^YTQc h Q ]yc TU cUdU^dQ _bWQ^YiQSY_^Uc
^QSY_^QUc U Y^dUb^QSY_^QUc `b_TUbUSX_c Xe]Q^_c h aeU ^_c cYd•Q U^ U dUbSUb]e^TYc]_ TU _c TUbUSX_c
SYfYUc' K^Q Uh aeU UWQYiQ bUSYRYb Q `Q_c h Q `U_dQi_c Q SU^dU^QbUc TU `Ubc_^Qc aeU cU U^SQbQ]Q^
SQTQ T|Q Q e^Q fQQ S_^ SeSXYQc U^ 8UedQ h CUYQ% Seh_ •^YS_ TUYd_ Uc Q ]YcUbYQ aeU Uc XYi_ ]QbSXQb
TU cec `Q|cUc' K^Q Uh aeU `Ub]YdU `UbcUWeYb h SbY]Y^QYiQb Q Q 6cQ]RUQ DQSY_^Q 8QdQQ^Q% Q Q `Qb aeU
d_UbQ U YW^_bQ Q Q VQcSYcdQ <e^TQSY~^ <bQ^SYcS_ <bQ^S_% e^Q Qed{^dYSQ Q^_]Q|Q TU^db_ TU ;eb_`Q' K^Q
Uh aeU `Ub]YdU TUdU^Ub h ZeiWQb Q QSdYfYcdQc `_b U TUbUSX_ Q e^Q fYfYU^TQ TYW^Q h S_^dbQ _c TUcQXeSY_c%
]YU^dbQc `b_dUWU Q Y^cYW^Uc `UbY_TYcdQc aeU cU fQ^QW_bYQ^ `•RYSQ U Y]`e^U]U^dU TU _ aeU XQb|Q^ S_^
e^Q UcS_`UdQ VbU^dU Q cUW•^ ae{ `_|dYS_c ^_ QVY^Uc' K^Q Uh aeU bUcdbY^WU SeQaeYUb `b_dUcdQ VbU^dU Q UcdQ
SQcQ% VbU^dU Q 8_^WbUc_ TU _c 9Y`edQT_c% Y^cdYdeSY~^ aeU bUSeUbT_ Uc TU `eUR_% `_b h `QbQ U `eUR_%
]YU^dbQc d_UbQ U YW^_bQ fUbW_^iQ^dUc ]Q^YVUcdQSY_^Uc `b_W_`YcdQc U^ U Q•^ ]yc fUbW_^iQ^dU ]Qec_U_
VQcSYcdQ `QWQT_ `_b d_T_c Q]QT_ LQU TU _c 8Q|T_c% `_b SYUbd_% U^ U SeQ ]UTYdQ U QSdeQ ]Y^Ycdb_ TU
SfU39I89&**&8E&,-