The Educational Ecosystem Analysis
Threat of Substitution
• Blended learning solutions
• New Age open education
providers. Khan
Academy, Coursera , EdX
• Wikis & web based resources
Schools creating own content
• New service providers –
Managing employability/Career
advice

Threat of New Entrants

Industry Competitiveness

• Fast moving tech players can
scale rapidly
• Hardware suppliers integrating
content to provide complete
solutions

• Commoditized print products
lead to low margins, forcing
players to innovate
• High funding inflow allowing
rapid scaling
• Innovative add-ons to
traditional products have
become the norm

• Scarcity of high quality teachers
& content creators
• Technology professionals with
understanding of pedagogy hard
to find

• Schools/Distributors have a wide
choice of publishers .
• Largely price sensitive market
• Digital products lead to easier
direct access to consumers

Power of Suppliers

Power of Buyers
Value chain – goimg up the value chain- lets us partner and give the school all that it
wants content, assement, teacher training so that we can create content that is
measurable - “Vertical integration “ -- Later we manage a school “ May it is
horizontal integration
Commoditization of publishing
Power changing to distributor and Author -K 12

Break up of student fee

Teachers /Teacher
Training/Teaching pedagogy
development

Go up the Value chain
Analyse the value chain
Books
10 November 2013

Schools

Assessment

supports

Fees
2
We need to be able to incubate ventures that help us very quickly diversify and build alternate revenue
Streams by JV’s , acquisitions and new incubations
Technology based
personalized learning
solution
• Fast Innovation
• Direct access to
consumers
Print Books
• Distribution,
warehousing &
production
capabilities
• Legacy products

Managing School
• Infrastructure Heavy
• Long gestation
Impact of Technology on Education- Opportunity to
create disruptive offerings

EBooks

Infrastructure

Content

Cheaper Access
Devices

Conferencing
Adaptive Online
Assessments

Open Source
Learning
Digital Learning
Pedagogy

Distance Learning
Pedagogy

Machine Learning
Future Classroom
The Classroom Officially Has No Walls……

Students With Tablet PC’s in 1:1 Setting
Teachers have interactive whiteboard
Everybody collaborates via Tablet PC
Learning happens 24/7
Capability To Interact With Digital Content
and Activities

Confidential

Classroom in an App!
What makes the present book ready for a disruption – A
learning solution
Impact of digital on educational
content

• Content can be consumed in a digital

•

•
•
•

format
Comprehension of content after
consumption can be measured and
hence an immediate feed back is
available
Content can take more forms , be
interactive and engaging – Video,
Audio, games etc
Video based lectures or synchronous
lectures can be created and beamed
across countries
Content can be packaged and
distributed in more customized ways
with ease.

Strictly Private & Confidential. India Proposal

Business Impact

• Digital impact creates opportunity and
challenges to Macmillan. Emergence
of technology companies, digital
aggregators in the value chain

• Emergence of standards in terms of
reader formats, and sticky ness of user
inertia

• Customized courses can be build
and electronically distributed .Creating
a need for digital distribution, royalty
management
Need for innovation
Need to Innovate

Opportunities

• School Textbook business
(even with minor digital
add-ons) becoming
commoditized
• Higher Education growth
without injecting strong
titles almost impossible
• While Macmillan is at a
very early stage of
technological innovation,
the industry itself is
innovating fast.

More Books

This is some thing we
will need to analyze to
see fitment to market,
capability in the team.
As we don’t have a
back list and an
adoption market –this
will be positioned as a
disruptive product !

Digital content
authoring tool/SCP
Assessments: UNSW
JV & PrepU

First priorities
Learning Management
System
• Necessary innovation
to sustain textbook
business and further
build on into other
services

Engineering Courses:
New Market
Macmillan Academics
Homework Solutions:
Sapling

MOOC Add-ons

Employability

Employability !
Help students get aware of the job
market !
Help students reach out for
internships and Jobs !
Help employers reach out to
fresher's
Train and assess fresh graduates to
make them aware of the job
fitment
Opportunities

Disruptive

Innovation

MOOC
Add-ons

Engineering
Courses
Homework
Solutions
Assessments

Incremental
Digital
Content &
Platform

Sustaining

Macmillan
Academics

More
Books
??? Size of bubble
proportional to dollar value

Internal

Partnerships & Joint Ventures

Capability Building

External
The Vision: Learning Cloud

Content

Assessment

New Age Pedagogy

Personalized learning solution – providing a
blended learning platform to schools
Where is the hidden Value lying and why we are in the
best position to create a learning platform….
Content available freely

Think about it:
10 M books sold
Millions of
students
Thousands of
Teachers
What if we could capture
these Millions of
interactions to make our
content richer??
The Products-to-Solutions Transformation:
Business Model Innovation

Product: EBook

Valued
Customer

Solution: Learning Cloud

•

Almost all customers

•

Segment Focus

•

“Better” products with service

•

End-to-end solutions that reduce customer costs
and risks or increase revenues

•
•
•

New technology focus
Stand-alone products
Proprietary products

•
•
•

Customer problem focus
Modular products
Open, standards-based

Operations

•
•

In-house manufacturing of products
Limited supply chain complexity

•
•

Partner with best providers & be product agnostic
Many independent partners requiring high coordination

Service

•

Cost center, bundled free with products

•

Profit center, unbundled from products

Marketing

•
•

•
•

•
•

Cost-plus product pricing
Product sales & Volume based
commissions
Salesperson as order taker
Geographical coverage

•
•

Value -based pricing
Multiyear service contracts, service-based
commissions
Salesperson as consultant
Industry Experts

•

Products sold through many channels

•

Become a value-added reseller (VAR)

Value
Proposition

Value Network

R&D

Distribution

Digital k12 stratgey amitabh nagpal

  • 1.
    The Educational EcosystemAnalysis Threat of Substitution • Blended learning solutions • New Age open education providers. Khan Academy, Coursera , EdX • Wikis & web based resources Schools creating own content • New service providers – Managing employability/Career advice Threat of New Entrants Industry Competitiveness • Fast moving tech players can scale rapidly • Hardware suppliers integrating content to provide complete solutions • Commoditized print products lead to low margins, forcing players to innovate • High funding inflow allowing rapid scaling • Innovative add-ons to traditional products have become the norm • Scarcity of high quality teachers & content creators • Technology professionals with understanding of pedagogy hard to find • Schools/Distributors have a wide choice of publishers . • Largely price sensitive market • Digital products lead to easier direct access to consumers Power of Suppliers Power of Buyers
  • 2.
    Value chain –goimg up the value chain- lets us partner and give the school all that it wants content, assement, teacher training so that we can create content that is measurable - “Vertical integration “ -- Later we manage a school “ May it is horizontal integration Commoditization of publishing Power changing to distributor and Author -K 12 Break up of student fee Teachers /Teacher Training/Teaching pedagogy development Go up the Value chain Analyse the value chain Books 10 November 2013 Schools Assessment supports Fees 2
  • 3.
    We need tobe able to incubate ventures that help us very quickly diversify and build alternate revenue Streams by JV’s , acquisitions and new incubations Technology based personalized learning solution • Fast Innovation • Direct access to consumers Print Books • Distribution, warehousing & production capabilities • Legacy products Managing School • Infrastructure Heavy • Long gestation
  • 4.
    Impact of Technologyon Education- Opportunity to create disruptive offerings EBooks Infrastructure Content Cheaper Access Devices Conferencing Adaptive Online Assessments Open Source Learning Digital Learning Pedagogy Distance Learning Pedagogy Machine Learning
  • 5.
    Future Classroom The ClassroomOfficially Has No Walls…… Students With Tablet PC’s in 1:1 Setting Teachers have interactive whiteboard Everybody collaborates via Tablet PC Learning happens 24/7 Capability To Interact With Digital Content and Activities Confidential Classroom in an App!
  • 6.
    What makes thepresent book ready for a disruption – A learning solution Impact of digital on educational content • Content can be consumed in a digital • • • • format Comprehension of content after consumption can be measured and hence an immediate feed back is available Content can take more forms , be interactive and engaging – Video, Audio, games etc Video based lectures or synchronous lectures can be created and beamed across countries Content can be packaged and distributed in more customized ways with ease. Strictly Private & Confidential. India Proposal Business Impact • Digital impact creates opportunity and challenges to Macmillan. Emergence of technology companies, digital aggregators in the value chain • Emergence of standards in terms of reader formats, and sticky ness of user inertia • Customized courses can be build and electronically distributed .Creating a need for digital distribution, royalty management
  • 7.
    Need for innovation Needto Innovate Opportunities • School Textbook business (even with minor digital add-ons) becoming commoditized • Higher Education growth without injecting strong titles almost impossible • While Macmillan is at a very early stage of technological innovation, the industry itself is innovating fast. More Books This is some thing we will need to analyze to see fitment to market, capability in the team. As we don’t have a back list and an adoption market –this will be positioned as a disruptive product ! Digital content authoring tool/SCP Assessments: UNSW JV & PrepU First priorities Learning Management System • Necessary innovation to sustain textbook business and further build on into other services Engineering Courses: New Market Macmillan Academics Homework Solutions: Sapling MOOC Add-ons Employability Employability ! Help students get aware of the job market ! Help students reach out for internships and Jobs ! Help employers reach out to fresher's Train and assess fresh graduates to make them aware of the job fitment
  • 8.
  • 10.
    The Vision: LearningCloud Content Assessment New Age Pedagogy Personalized learning solution – providing a blended learning platform to schools
  • 11.
    Where is thehidden Value lying and why we are in the best position to create a learning platform…. Content available freely Think about it: 10 M books sold Millions of students Thousands of Teachers What if we could capture these Millions of interactions to make our content richer??
  • 12.
    The Products-to-Solutions Transformation: BusinessModel Innovation Product: EBook Valued Customer Solution: Learning Cloud • Almost all customers • Segment Focus • “Better” products with service • End-to-end solutions that reduce customer costs and risks or increase revenues • • • New technology focus Stand-alone products Proprietary products • • • Customer problem focus Modular products Open, standards-based Operations • • In-house manufacturing of products Limited supply chain complexity • • Partner with best providers & be product agnostic Many independent partners requiring high coordination Service • Cost center, bundled free with products • Profit center, unbundled from products Marketing • • • • • • Cost-plus product pricing Product sales & Volume based commissions Salesperson as order taker Geographical coverage • • Value -based pricing Multiyear service contracts, service-based commissions Salesperson as consultant Industry Experts • Products sold through many channels • Become a value-added reseller (VAR) Value Proposition Value Network R&D Distribution

Editor's Notes

  • #19 This is one way and in my experience this would give us a good chance of success but what do you think?There is no quick fix it will take time, a lot of time, to transform into a world class technology and digital product company