Chapter 2 Network Theory

                                                  patterns within small groups, studies of
An Introduction                                   business communities and sexual patterns,
This chapter will introduce you to the field of   statistical physics community, etc.
science known as Network Theory and tell
you about the major researches that took          Network Models
place since its conceptualization. Since the      Networks are designed rigorously based on
course in question is social computing the        their mathematical modeling. Some of the
chapter is written in a way to give examples      most discussed network models are: Random
                                                  graphs, Small world networks, Scale-free
and illustrations which mostly relate to social
                                                  networks, etc.
computing. It also contains theories and
information which are mostly related to           Network Theory
network theory and have some or no relation
                                                  “Network theory is an area of applied
to social computing. But the basic purpose of
                                                  mathematics, network science and a part of
this chapter is to explain Network theory and
                                                  graph theory. It is concerned with the study of
its applications in the field of social
                                                  graphs as a representation of either
computing.
                                                  symmetric relations or, more generally, of
                                                  asymmetric relations between discrete
What is a Network
                                                  objects”.
A network is a set of relationships comprised
of two objects, viz. vertices and nodes pair-     REF: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_theory
wise connected with each other. Network
systems are scattered around us such as:          The concept of network theory came into
social networks, World Wide Web, Internet,        being during the 1930’s.This was the work of
airport networks, etc. In networking              an informal group of German psychologists
terminology, nodes are represented by
                                                  who specialized in “Gestalt Psychology”. At
people, items, computer servers, airports, and
the links are represented by friendships,         that time it was considered more of a social
flights, physical connections.                    science tool. During 1950 this changed when
                                                  Cartwright and Harary connected network
                                                  theory with graph theory and other
Social Networks                                   mathematical applications. After that two
“A social network is a social structure made      threads were now researching network
up of individuals (or organizations) called       theory. One thought of it as a study of social
"nodes", which are tied (connected) by one or     groups and their relations and the other
more specific types of interdependency, , such    thought of it as a structural science which lead
as friendship, kinship, common interest,
                                                  to the creation of different mathematical
financial exchange, dislike, sexual
relationships, or relationships of beliefs,       models of network structure and other
knowledge or prestige”. (Ref:                     interesting phenomenon examples of which
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_network)      include small world phenomenon, strength of
                                                  weak ties etc.
Social science is one of many other disciplines
where quantitative study of real world            Major Research in Network
networks has been carried out extensively.        Theory
The topics that have been explored at length
                                                  The concept of network theory after it’s
in social networks research includes: early
                                                  recognition as a mathematical application
studies of Jacob Moreno (1920s) on friendship
                                                  grew at a steady pace. Although it has
                                                                                                     4
Chapter 2 Network Theory

become more and more complex due to               could now be described using quantitative
complex networks in the modern world still it     graph theory descriptions. An example of this
has become very popular and grown its             would be the social balance theory which
branches into diversified fields such as          states that:
computer networks, biological ecosystems,
                                                  “Social balance theory is a class of theories
business management, particle physics,
computer science, economics, operations           within social network theory which attempts
                                                  to describe how individual desires to reduce
research and other domains such as sociology.
But the major contributions in the Network        affective cognitive dissonance influence in a
                                                  group of network structures, and that
theory field were made by a few scientists
which are as followed:                            individual expect to be exposed to balanced
                                                  social situations. Social balance theory is a tool to
                                                  observe a social group evolving to a balanced”
Moreno’s Sociograms
                                                  (Cartwright and Harary, 1956)
In 1937 one of the German psychologists
“Moreno” created a model based on the
                                                  The Small World
study that the psychological state of an
individual within a group is affected by the
                                                  “In mathematics, physics and sociology a
relations within a group. The model depicted      small-world network is a type of
the individuals as dots, which later came to be   mathematical graph in which most nodes are
known as nodes and the relation between the       not neighbors of one another, but most nodes
various members as lines or in more scientific    can be reached from every other by a small
terms links. Example                              number of hops or steps. (Ref:
                                                  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small-
                                                  world_network)

                                                  If the personal networks of people don’t
                                                  overlap, then s/he can reach to entire world
                                                  in two or three steps. Suppose a person in
                                                  Pakistan know 1000 unique people that his
                                                  siblings don’t know, then, each of those 1000
This model gave rise to one of the most           people may know 100 other unique people,
widely researched fields known as social          and so on (Pool and Kochen 1978). Then, the
network analysis. This became known as a          1000 people you know each know 1000
tool for measuring and analyzing social           unique others and they each know 1000
networks.                                         others, and so on (Kadushin, 2004).

Cartwright and Harary                             Distance between any Two Nodes
1956 Cartwright a sociologist and Harary a        The issue of distance between any two nodes
mathematician wrote a publication which           was raised by Milgram (Milgram 1967) that
claimed that the sociograms like the one          can be applied to all levels of network
                                                  analysis. The distance between two nodes is
Moreno built could be analyzed using graph
                                                  determined by following four parameters: (1)
theory (Davis, 1970). Till now the sociologists   the size of the first order zone of nodes in the
were describing social networks in qualitative    network; (2) the extent to which nodes in the
terms, but with the contribution of Cartwright    network have overlapping members in their
and Harary these qualitative descriptions         first order zones; (3) barriers between nodes;
                                                  (4) agency exercised by the nodes.
                                                                                                          4
Chapter 2 Network Theory


                                                    Strength of Weak Ties
                                                    In 1973, Mark Garnovetter (1973) published a
The Effective Distance between
                                                    very famous theory known as “Strength of
Nodes
                                                    weak Ties”. This theory was based upon the
This principle says that the impact of a zone       small world theory and states that in cases of
on an individual node declines exponentially,       job searching weak relations are more
when there can be an infinite number of             effective than the strong ones. Meaning that
zones, in principle. That is, whatever is being     family friends and relatives might not be as
studied, nodes have relatively small effects on     much help in finding jobs as acquaintances
the focal individual or structure (Poulin et al.,   since these acquaintances belong to a
2000).                                              completely different social group than yours.

The Size of the Interpersonal                       These were some of the theories which
Environment                                         revolutionized the Network theory field and
According to this principal, the number of          there are still more like the Watts and
people in an average size of 300 to 5000            Strongatz (1998) small world theory which
interpersonal individuals environment varies        have left a mark in the history of Network
depends on how this environment is
                                                    theory.
measured and society in which focal person is
embodied (Bernard, Johnsen, Killworth, and
Robinson 1989).                                     Let me tell you how and when you can use
                                                    network theory. Given an already existing
Six Degrees of Separation                           network, network theory can be used to
1960s Stanley Milgram experimented and              analyze and optimize that given network and
confirmed the authenticity of very popular          also understand the flow of information
still unproven hypothesis. The hypothesis           throughout the network. Since we are
states that everyone in the world is connected      studying network theory in order to
by six degrees of separation. This means that       understand Social Computing we will be using
if a sociogram of the relations between the         examples of social network for analysis.
people of the world could be made then the          Whereas optimization is mostly used in
difference between any two nodes (taking the        logistical problems and network load
shortest route possible) would not be more          problems in business thus we will not be
than 6 nodes on average. This hypothesis was        going into much depth about the optimization
tested by Milgram through an experiment in          part of Network theory.
which he distributed letters throughout the
nation addressed to a single person along           Weak Ties Help to Integrate social
with a letter which told the receiver to send       Systems
the letter to either the person to whom the         “The macroscopic side of this communication
letter was addressed to (given they knew him)       argument is that social systems lacking in
or just send it to someone they thought             weak ties will be fragmented and incoherent.
would know him. Not all the letters reached         New ideas will spread slowly, scientific
its destination but those that did took an          endeavours will be handicapped, and
average 6 people to find their way to the           subgroups that are separated by race,
person.                                             ethnicity, geography or other characteristics
                                                                                                     4
Chapter 2 Network Theory

will have difficulty reaching a modus Vivendi”     theoretical models on 742 sociograms.
(Garnovetter 1982, p. 106).                        American Sociological Review. 35, 843-852.

Network Optimization                               Granovetter, Mark S. 1973. "The Strength of
                                                   Weak Ties." American Journal of Sociology
In simple terms network optimization is the        781360-1380.
use of network theory mathematics to
identify the current network and find the          Granovetter, Mark S. 1982. "The Strength of
optimum path for optimizing the working            Weak Ties: a Network Theory Revisited." Pp.
within the network. For example in a given         105-30 in Social Structure and Network
                                                   Analysis, eds. Peter Marsden and Nan Linn.
network for transportation given some
                                                   Beverly Hills, Ca: Sage.
constraints, the optimum path for transferring
goods from one place to another can be             Kadushin, C., 2004. Introduction to Social
derived using the network optimization             Network Theory. Available at:
techniques, thus lowering cost. Likewise other     http://home.earthlink.net/~ckadushin/Texts/
network can be optimized for high efficiency       Basic%20Network%20Concepts.pdf, draft
and effectiveness.                                 version of chapter 2, accessed 23 May 2011

                                                   Milgram, Stanley. 1967. "The Small-World
Network Analysis
                                                   Problem." Psychology Today 1(1):62-67.
In network analysis there is a similar finding     Moreno, Jacob L. 1953. Who Shall Survive?
that relationships are not necessarily             Foundations of Sociometry, Group
articulated, spoken about, or conceptualized       Psychotherapy and Sociodrama. New York:
by the participants in a network. Degree           Beacon House
analysis technique helps analyze social
                                                   Pool, Ithiel d. S. and Manfred Kochen. 1978.
network’s strength and other Characteristics.
                                                   "Contacts and Influence." Social Networks
It should be remembered that the network
                                                   1(1):5-51.
does not end here. It is very essential to
understand what a network is and based on
                                                   Poulin, R., M.-C. Boily, and B. R. M ‫ג‬sse. 2000.
the findings presented in the chapter, one can
                                                   "Dynamical Systems to Define Centrality in
hope to relate the facets of social computing
                                                   Social Networks." Social Networks
with.
                                                   22(3):187-220.

References
                                                   Watts, Duncan J. and Stephen H. Strogatz.
Bernard, H. R., Eugene C. Johnsen, Peter D.        1998. "Collective Dynamics of 'Small-World'
Killworth, and Scott Robinson. 1989.               Networks." Nature 393440-442.
"Estimating the Size of an Average Personal
Network and of an Event Subpopulation." Pp.
159-75 in The Small World, ed. Manfred
Kochen. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Co.

Cartwright, D., and Harary, F. 1956). Structural
balance: A generalization of Heider’s theory.
Psychological Review. 63, 277-292.

Davis, J.A. (1970). Clustering and hierarchy in
interpersonal relations: Testing two
                                                                                                      4

Network Theory

  • 1.
    Chapter 2 NetworkTheory patterns within small groups, studies of An Introduction business communities and sexual patterns, This chapter will introduce you to the field of statistical physics community, etc. science known as Network Theory and tell you about the major researches that took Network Models place since its conceptualization. Since the Networks are designed rigorously based on course in question is social computing the their mathematical modeling. Some of the chapter is written in a way to give examples most discussed network models are: Random graphs, Small world networks, Scale-free and illustrations which mostly relate to social networks, etc. computing. It also contains theories and information which are mostly related to Network Theory network theory and have some or no relation “Network theory is an area of applied to social computing. But the basic purpose of mathematics, network science and a part of this chapter is to explain Network theory and graph theory. It is concerned with the study of its applications in the field of social graphs as a representation of either computing. symmetric relations or, more generally, of asymmetric relations between discrete What is a Network objects”. A network is a set of relationships comprised of two objects, viz. vertices and nodes pair- REF: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_theory wise connected with each other. Network systems are scattered around us such as: The concept of network theory came into social networks, World Wide Web, Internet, being during the 1930’s.This was the work of airport networks, etc. In networking an informal group of German psychologists terminology, nodes are represented by who specialized in “Gestalt Psychology”. At people, items, computer servers, airports, and the links are represented by friendships, that time it was considered more of a social flights, physical connections. science tool. During 1950 this changed when Cartwright and Harary connected network theory with graph theory and other Social Networks mathematical applications. After that two “A social network is a social structure made threads were now researching network up of individuals (or organizations) called theory. One thought of it as a study of social "nodes", which are tied (connected) by one or groups and their relations and the other more specific types of interdependency, , such thought of it as a structural science which lead as friendship, kinship, common interest, to the creation of different mathematical financial exchange, dislike, sexual relationships, or relationships of beliefs, models of network structure and other knowledge or prestige”. (Ref: interesting phenomenon examples of which http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_network) include small world phenomenon, strength of weak ties etc. Social science is one of many other disciplines where quantitative study of real world Major Research in Network networks has been carried out extensively. Theory The topics that have been explored at length The concept of network theory after it’s in social networks research includes: early recognition as a mathematical application studies of Jacob Moreno (1920s) on friendship grew at a steady pace. Although it has 4
  • 2.
    Chapter 2 NetworkTheory become more and more complex due to could now be described using quantitative complex networks in the modern world still it graph theory descriptions. An example of this has become very popular and grown its would be the social balance theory which branches into diversified fields such as states that: computer networks, biological ecosystems, “Social balance theory is a class of theories business management, particle physics, computer science, economics, operations within social network theory which attempts to describe how individual desires to reduce research and other domains such as sociology. But the major contributions in the Network affective cognitive dissonance influence in a group of network structures, and that theory field were made by a few scientists which are as followed: individual expect to be exposed to balanced social situations. Social balance theory is a tool to observe a social group evolving to a balanced” Moreno’s Sociograms (Cartwright and Harary, 1956) In 1937 one of the German psychologists “Moreno” created a model based on the The Small World study that the psychological state of an individual within a group is affected by the “In mathematics, physics and sociology a relations within a group. The model depicted small-world network is a type of the individuals as dots, which later came to be mathematical graph in which most nodes are known as nodes and the relation between the not neighbors of one another, but most nodes various members as lines or in more scientific can be reached from every other by a small terms links. Example number of hops or steps. (Ref: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small- world_network) If the personal networks of people don’t overlap, then s/he can reach to entire world in two or three steps. Suppose a person in Pakistan know 1000 unique people that his siblings don’t know, then, each of those 1000 This model gave rise to one of the most people may know 100 other unique people, widely researched fields known as social and so on (Pool and Kochen 1978). Then, the network analysis. This became known as a 1000 people you know each know 1000 tool for measuring and analyzing social unique others and they each know 1000 networks. others, and so on (Kadushin, 2004). Cartwright and Harary Distance between any Two Nodes 1956 Cartwright a sociologist and Harary a The issue of distance between any two nodes mathematician wrote a publication which was raised by Milgram (Milgram 1967) that claimed that the sociograms like the one can be applied to all levels of network analysis. The distance between two nodes is Moreno built could be analyzed using graph determined by following four parameters: (1) theory (Davis, 1970). Till now the sociologists the size of the first order zone of nodes in the were describing social networks in qualitative network; (2) the extent to which nodes in the terms, but with the contribution of Cartwright network have overlapping members in their and Harary these qualitative descriptions first order zones; (3) barriers between nodes; (4) agency exercised by the nodes. 4
  • 3.
    Chapter 2 NetworkTheory Strength of Weak Ties In 1973, Mark Garnovetter (1973) published a The Effective Distance between very famous theory known as “Strength of Nodes weak Ties”. This theory was based upon the This principle says that the impact of a zone small world theory and states that in cases of on an individual node declines exponentially, job searching weak relations are more when there can be an infinite number of effective than the strong ones. Meaning that zones, in principle. That is, whatever is being family friends and relatives might not be as studied, nodes have relatively small effects on much help in finding jobs as acquaintances the focal individual or structure (Poulin et al., since these acquaintances belong to a 2000). completely different social group than yours. The Size of the Interpersonal These were some of the theories which Environment revolutionized the Network theory field and According to this principal, the number of there are still more like the Watts and people in an average size of 300 to 5000 Strongatz (1998) small world theory which interpersonal individuals environment varies have left a mark in the history of Network depends on how this environment is theory. measured and society in which focal person is embodied (Bernard, Johnsen, Killworth, and Robinson 1989). Let me tell you how and when you can use network theory. Given an already existing Six Degrees of Separation network, network theory can be used to 1960s Stanley Milgram experimented and analyze and optimize that given network and confirmed the authenticity of very popular also understand the flow of information still unproven hypothesis. The hypothesis throughout the network. Since we are states that everyone in the world is connected studying network theory in order to by six degrees of separation. This means that understand Social Computing we will be using if a sociogram of the relations between the examples of social network for analysis. people of the world could be made then the Whereas optimization is mostly used in difference between any two nodes (taking the logistical problems and network load shortest route possible) would not be more problems in business thus we will not be than 6 nodes on average. This hypothesis was going into much depth about the optimization tested by Milgram through an experiment in part of Network theory. which he distributed letters throughout the nation addressed to a single person along Weak Ties Help to Integrate social with a letter which told the receiver to send Systems the letter to either the person to whom the “The macroscopic side of this communication letter was addressed to (given they knew him) argument is that social systems lacking in or just send it to someone they thought weak ties will be fragmented and incoherent. would know him. Not all the letters reached New ideas will spread slowly, scientific its destination but those that did took an endeavours will be handicapped, and average 6 people to find their way to the subgroups that are separated by race, person. ethnicity, geography or other characteristics 4
  • 4.
    Chapter 2 NetworkTheory will have difficulty reaching a modus Vivendi” theoretical models on 742 sociograms. (Garnovetter 1982, p. 106). American Sociological Review. 35, 843-852. Network Optimization Granovetter, Mark S. 1973. "The Strength of Weak Ties." American Journal of Sociology In simple terms network optimization is the 781360-1380. use of network theory mathematics to identify the current network and find the Granovetter, Mark S. 1982. "The Strength of optimum path for optimizing the working Weak Ties: a Network Theory Revisited." Pp. within the network. For example in a given 105-30 in Social Structure and Network Analysis, eds. Peter Marsden and Nan Linn. network for transportation given some Beverly Hills, Ca: Sage. constraints, the optimum path for transferring goods from one place to another can be Kadushin, C., 2004. Introduction to Social derived using the network optimization Network Theory. Available at: techniques, thus lowering cost. Likewise other http://home.earthlink.net/~ckadushin/Texts/ network can be optimized for high efficiency Basic%20Network%20Concepts.pdf, draft and effectiveness. version of chapter 2, accessed 23 May 2011 Milgram, Stanley. 1967. "The Small-World Network Analysis Problem." Psychology Today 1(1):62-67. In network analysis there is a similar finding Moreno, Jacob L. 1953. Who Shall Survive? that relationships are not necessarily Foundations of Sociometry, Group articulated, spoken about, or conceptualized Psychotherapy and Sociodrama. New York: by the participants in a network. Degree Beacon House analysis technique helps analyze social Pool, Ithiel d. S. and Manfred Kochen. 1978. network’s strength and other Characteristics. "Contacts and Influence." Social Networks It should be remembered that the network 1(1):5-51. does not end here. It is very essential to understand what a network is and based on Poulin, R., M.-C. Boily, and B. R. M ‫ג‬sse. 2000. the findings presented in the chapter, one can "Dynamical Systems to Define Centrality in hope to relate the facets of social computing Social Networks." Social Networks with. 22(3):187-220. References Watts, Duncan J. and Stephen H. Strogatz. Bernard, H. R., Eugene C. Johnsen, Peter D. 1998. "Collective Dynamics of 'Small-World' Killworth, and Scott Robinson. 1989. Networks." Nature 393440-442. "Estimating the Size of an Average Personal Network and of an Event Subpopulation." Pp. 159-75 in The Small World, ed. Manfred Kochen. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Co. Cartwright, D., and Harary, F. 1956). Structural balance: A generalization of Heider’s theory. Psychological Review. 63, 277-292. Davis, J.A. (1970). Clustering and hierarchy in interpersonal relations: Testing two 4