Linear balanceable and subcubic balanceable graphs

                              Théophile Trunck

                                  BGW 2012


                              November 2012




Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)     Balanceable graphs   November 2012   1 / 23
Co-authors




Joint work with:
    Pierre Aboulker, LIAFA, Paris
    Marko Radovanović, Union University, Belgrade
    Nicolas Trotignon, CNRS, LIP, Lyon
    Kristina Vušković, Union University, Belgrade and
    Leeds University




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)        Balanceable graphs   November 2012   2 / 23
Motivation

Conjecture (Morris, Spiga and Webb)
If G is cubic and every induced cycle has length divisible by 4, then G has a pair
of twins.




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs              November 2012   3 / 23
Motivation

Conjecture (Morris, Spiga and Webb)
If G is cubic and every induced cycle has length divisible by 4, then G has a pair
of twins.




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs              November 2012   3 / 23
Definitions




Definition
Let G be a bipartite graph, we say that G is balanceable if we can give weights
+1, −1 to edges such that the weight of every induced cycle is divisible by 4.




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)      Balanceable graphs             November 2012    4 / 23
Characterization


Theorem (Truemper)
A bipartite graph is balanceable if and only if it does not contain an odd wheel nor
an odd 3-path configuration.




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs              November 2012   5 / 23
Conjecture

Conjecture (Conforti, Cornuéjols and Vušković)
In a balanceable bipartite graph either every edge belongs to some R10 or there is
an edge that is not the unique chord of a cycle.




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs             November 2012   6 / 23
Main results


Theorem
If G is a 4-hole free balanceable graph on at least two vertices, then G contains at
least two vertices of degree at most 2.

Theorem
If G is a cubic balanceable graph that is not R10 , then G has a pair of twins none
of whose neighbors is a cut vertex of G .

Corollary
The conjecture is true if G does not contain a 4-hole or if ∆(G ) ≤ 3.




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs              November 2012   7 / 23
Decomposition




Theorem (Conforti, Cornuéjols, Kappor and Vušković + Conforti and Rao +
Yannakakis + easy lemma)
Let G be a connected balanceable graph.
    If G is 4-hole free, then G is basic, or has a 2-join, a 6-join or a star cutset.
    If ∆(G ) ≤ 3, then G is basic or is R10 , or has a 2-join, a 6-join or a star
    cutset.




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)        Balanceable graphs               November 2012   8 / 23
The Good


                   B1          B2                        B2




                   C1          C2                        C2




                   A1          A2                        A2

                   X1          X2                        X2

                                    Figure : 2-join


 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)        Balanceable graphs    November 2012   9 / 23
The Bad


                   B1          B2                        B2




                   C1          C2                        C2




                   A1          A2                        A2

                   X1          X2                        X2

                                    Figure : 6-join


 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)        Balanceable graphs    November 2012   10 / 23
The Ugly




Definition
A star cutset in a graph G is a set S of vertices such that:
    G  S is disconnected.
    S contains a vertex v adjacent to all other vertices of S.
We note (x, R) the star cutset.




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs            November 2012   11 / 23
In a perfect world


Theorem
Let G be bipartite 4-hole free with no-star cutset, then {2, 6}-join blocks preserve:

    Being balanceable;
    Having no star cutset;
    Having no 6-join.




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)        Balanceable graphs             November 2012   12 / 23
In a perfect world


Theorem
Let G be bipartite 4-hole free with no-star cutset, then {2, 6}-join blocks preserve:

    Being balanceable;
    Having no star cutset;
    Having no 6-join.

Theorem
Let G be a bipartite 4-hole free graph. Let X1 , X2 be a minimally-sided {2, 6}-join.
If G has no star cutset, then the block of decomposition G1 has no {2, 6}-join.




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)        Balanceable graphs             November 2012   12 / 23
Crossing 2-join




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)   Balanceable graphs   November 2012   13 / 23
Star cutset, again


Definition
A star cutset in a graph G is a set S of vertices such that:
    G  S is disconnected.
    S contains a vertex v adjacent to all other vertices of S.

Definition
A double star cutset in a graph G is a set S of vertices such that:
    G  S has two disconnected components C1 and C2 .
    S contains an edge uv such that every vertex in S is adjacent to u or v .
We call C1 ∪ S and C2 ∪ S the blocks of decomposition, and we note (u, v , U, V )
where U ⊆ N(u) and V ⊆ N(v ) the double star cutset.



 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs             November 2012   14 / 23
Extreme double star cutset




Theorem
Let G be a 2-connected 4-hole free bipartite graph that has a star cutset. Let G1
be a minimal side of a minimally-sided double star cutset of G . Then G1 does not
have a star cutset.




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)      Balanceable graphs            November 2012   15 / 23
Extreme double star cutset




           u                   v
                                             G1 is 2-connected.
           U                   V




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs             November 2012   16 / 23
Extreme double star cutset




                                             G1 is 2-connected.
                                             (x, R) a star cutset in G1 .
        x u                    v
                                             |R ∩ S| ≤ 1.
                                             If R ∩ {u, v } = ∅ then
            U                  V             (x, y ∈ R, R  {y }, ∅) is a double
                                             star cutset in G .




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs                November 2012   17 / 23
Extreme double star cutset




                                             G1 is 2-connected.
                                             C component in G1  ({x} ∪ R)
        x u                    v
                                             with C ∩ ({v } ∪ V ) = ∅.
                                             C U =∅
            U                  V             (x, u, R  {u}, U) is a double
                                             star cutset in G .




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs               November 2012   18 / 23
Extreme double star cutset




                                             If a component of G1  ({x} ∪ R)
        x=u                    v             contains a vertex from U or V ,
                                             it contains vertex from G1  S.
           U                   V             (x, v , U ∪ R  {v }, V ) is a
                                             double star cutset in G .




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs                  November 2012   19 / 23
Extreme double star cutset




                                             {v } ∪ V are in the same
                                             component in G1  ({x} ∪ R)
           u                   v             If a component of G1  ({x} ∪ R)
                                             contains a vertex from U, it
                                             contains vertex from G1  S.
        x∈U                    V
                                             (x, u, R  {u}, U  {x}) is a
                                             double star cutset in G .




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs                November 2012   20 / 23
Sketch of the proof

Theorem
If G is a 4-hole free balanceable graph on at least two vertices, then G contains at
least two vertices of degree at most 2.

Proof.
    If we have a cut vertex it is easy.
    Assume there is a star cutset.
    Take a double star cutset such that the block G has no star cutset.
    G is basic or has {2, 6}-join.
    If G is basic find two vertices of degree 2.
    Take (X1 , X2 ) a minimally-sided {2, 6}-join with small intersection with the
    double star cutset.
    Now G1 is basic, find good vertices in it.


 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)         Balanceable graphs           November 2012   21 / 23
Open questions




Question
How to build every cubic graph such that every induced cycle has length divisible
by 4 ?

Conjecture (Conforti, Cornuéjols and Vušković)
In a balanceable bipartite graph either every edge belongs to some R10 or there is
an edge that is not the unique chord of a cycle.




 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)       Balanceable graphs            November 2012   22 / 23
Thanks for you attention.




Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012)   Balanceable graphs   November 2012   23 / 23

BGW2012 - Linear balanceable and subcubic balanceable graphs

  • 1.
    Linear balanceable andsubcubic balanceable graphs Théophile Trunck BGW 2012 November 2012 Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 1 / 23
  • 2.
    Co-authors Joint work with: Pierre Aboulker, LIAFA, Paris Marko Radovanović, Union University, Belgrade Nicolas Trotignon, CNRS, LIP, Lyon Kristina Vušković, Union University, Belgrade and Leeds University Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 2 / 23
  • 3.
    Motivation Conjecture (Morris, Spigaand Webb) If G is cubic and every induced cycle has length divisible by 4, then G has a pair of twins. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 3 / 23
  • 4.
    Motivation Conjecture (Morris, Spigaand Webb) If G is cubic and every induced cycle has length divisible by 4, then G has a pair of twins. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 3 / 23
  • 5.
    Definitions Definition Let G bea bipartite graph, we say that G is balanceable if we can give weights +1, −1 to edges such that the weight of every induced cycle is divisible by 4. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 4 / 23
  • 6.
    Characterization Theorem (Truemper) A bipartitegraph is balanceable if and only if it does not contain an odd wheel nor an odd 3-path configuration. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 5 / 23
  • 7.
    Conjecture Conjecture (Conforti, Cornuéjolsand Vušković) In a balanceable bipartite graph either every edge belongs to some R10 or there is an edge that is not the unique chord of a cycle. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 6 / 23
  • 8.
    Main results Theorem If Gis a 4-hole free balanceable graph on at least two vertices, then G contains at least two vertices of degree at most 2. Theorem If G is a cubic balanceable graph that is not R10 , then G has a pair of twins none of whose neighbors is a cut vertex of G . Corollary The conjecture is true if G does not contain a 4-hole or if ∆(G ) ≤ 3. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 7 / 23
  • 9.
    Decomposition Theorem (Conforti, Cornuéjols,Kappor and Vušković + Conforti and Rao + Yannakakis + easy lemma) Let G be a connected balanceable graph. If G is 4-hole free, then G is basic, or has a 2-join, a 6-join or a star cutset. If ∆(G ) ≤ 3, then G is basic or is R10 , or has a 2-join, a 6-join or a star cutset. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 8 / 23
  • 10.
    The Good B1 B2 B2 C1 C2 C2 A1 A2 A2 X1 X2 X2 Figure : 2-join Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 9 / 23
  • 11.
    The Bad B1 B2 B2 C1 C2 C2 A1 A2 A2 X1 X2 X2 Figure : 6-join Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 10 / 23
  • 12.
    The Ugly Definition A starcutset in a graph G is a set S of vertices such that: G S is disconnected. S contains a vertex v adjacent to all other vertices of S. We note (x, R) the star cutset. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 11 / 23
  • 13.
    In a perfectworld Theorem Let G be bipartite 4-hole free with no-star cutset, then {2, 6}-join blocks preserve: Being balanceable; Having no star cutset; Having no 6-join. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 12 / 23
  • 14.
    In a perfectworld Theorem Let G be bipartite 4-hole free with no-star cutset, then {2, 6}-join blocks preserve: Being balanceable; Having no star cutset; Having no 6-join. Theorem Let G be a bipartite 4-hole free graph. Let X1 , X2 be a minimally-sided {2, 6}-join. If G has no star cutset, then the block of decomposition G1 has no {2, 6}-join. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 12 / 23
  • 15.
    Crossing 2-join ThéophileTrunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 13 / 23
  • 16.
    Star cutset, again Definition Astar cutset in a graph G is a set S of vertices such that: G S is disconnected. S contains a vertex v adjacent to all other vertices of S. Definition A double star cutset in a graph G is a set S of vertices such that: G S has two disconnected components C1 and C2 . S contains an edge uv such that every vertex in S is adjacent to u or v . We call C1 ∪ S and C2 ∪ S the blocks of decomposition, and we note (u, v , U, V ) where U ⊆ N(u) and V ⊆ N(v ) the double star cutset. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 14 / 23
  • 17.
    Extreme double starcutset Theorem Let G be a 2-connected 4-hole free bipartite graph that has a star cutset. Let G1 be a minimal side of a minimally-sided double star cutset of G . Then G1 does not have a star cutset. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 15 / 23
  • 18.
    Extreme double starcutset u v G1 is 2-connected. U V Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 16 / 23
  • 19.
    Extreme double starcutset G1 is 2-connected. (x, R) a star cutset in G1 . x u v |R ∩ S| ≤ 1. If R ∩ {u, v } = ∅ then U V (x, y ∈ R, R {y }, ∅) is a double star cutset in G . Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 17 / 23
  • 20.
    Extreme double starcutset G1 is 2-connected. C component in G1 ({x} ∪ R) x u v with C ∩ ({v } ∪ V ) = ∅. C U =∅ U V (x, u, R {u}, U) is a double star cutset in G . Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 18 / 23
  • 21.
    Extreme double starcutset If a component of G1 ({x} ∪ R) x=u v contains a vertex from U or V , it contains vertex from G1 S. U V (x, v , U ∪ R {v }, V ) is a double star cutset in G . Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 19 / 23
  • 22.
    Extreme double starcutset {v } ∪ V are in the same component in G1 ({x} ∪ R) u v If a component of G1 ({x} ∪ R) contains a vertex from U, it contains vertex from G1 S. x∈U V (x, u, R {u}, U {x}) is a double star cutset in G . Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 20 / 23
  • 23.
    Sketch of theproof Theorem If G is a 4-hole free balanceable graph on at least two vertices, then G contains at least two vertices of degree at most 2. Proof. If we have a cut vertex it is easy. Assume there is a star cutset. Take a double star cutset such that the block G has no star cutset. G is basic or has {2, 6}-join. If G is basic find two vertices of degree 2. Take (X1 , X2 ) a minimally-sided {2, 6}-join with small intersection with the double star cutset. Now G1 is basic, find good vertices in it. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 21 / 23
  • 24.
    Open questions Question How tobuild every cubic graph such that every induced cycle has length divisible by 4 ? Conjecture (Conforti, Cornuéjols and Vušković) In a balanceable bipartite graph either every edge belongs to some R10 or there is an edge that is not the unique chord of a cycle. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 22 / 23
  • 25.
    Thanks for youattention. Théophile Trunck (BGW 2012) Balanceable graphs November 2012 23 / 23